%pdf-1.3 % 1 0 obj << /opm 1 /type/extgstate >> endobj 2 0 obj << /length 5371 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3742 33.8708 tm 0 g (55)tj et 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 13.5 0 0 13.5 73 585.8022 tm 0 g (is nature immaterial? the possibilities for environmental)tj 0 -1.33333 td (education without an environment)tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 9 0 0 9 73 546.8022 tm 0 g (andrew stables, university of bath, england)tj et q q bt /f1 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 522.8022 tm 0 g [(a)19(bstr)19(act)]tj et q q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 510.8022 tm 0 g -0.005 tc [(contempor)19(ary thinking is gener)18(ally based on subst)19(ance)36(, as opposed t)19(o)]tj 0 -1.26316 td [(p)1(r)19(ocess)37(, met)18(aph)19(y)19(sics: in other w)19(o)1(r)19(d)1(s)38(, the belief that the w)18(orld and the)]tj t* [(univ)19(e)1(r)19(se ar)19(e best under)18(s)1(t)20(ood in terms o)18(f material r)19(ather than e)18(v)19(ents)37(. the)]tj t* [(envir)19(onment, f)36(or e)19(x)19(ample)37(, is conceiv)18(ed o)19(f as subst)18(antial; natur)19(e as a w)18(eb o)19(f)]tj 0 -1.26315 td [(inter)19(connected, if o)18(ften fr)19(agile entities)36(. in this tr)19(adition, ther)18(e is also a)]tj 0 -1.26316 td [(s)1(t)1(r)19(ong legacy o)19(f mind-body dualism: the belief that the (immaterial) human)]tj t* [(mind acts on the inert and mechanical \322body\323 o)18(f natur)19(e)37(. pr)19(ocess)]tj t* [(met)19(aph)18(y)19(sics)37(, on the other hand, posits the w)18(orld as e)19(v)19(ents in which human)]tj t* [(beings ar)19(e implicated. this paper adopts a pr)18(ocess per)19(spectiv)18(e in attempting)]tj t* [(t)19(o de)19(v)19(elop a posthumanist appr)18(oach t)19(o education, r)18(ooted in the idea o)19(f living)]tj t* (as )tj et q q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 98.5057 390.8022 tm 0 g -0.006 tc (semiosis)tj 3.69653 0 td 0 tc (.)tj et q q bt /f1 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 367.0022 tm 0 g (r\216sum\216)tj et q q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 355.2022 tm 0 g (l)tj 0.51806 0 td -0.0002 tc (a)tj 0.75864 0 td 0 tc [(pens\216e moderne s\325inspir)19(e g\216n\216r)18(alement de subst)19(ance plut\231t que de)]tj -1.2767 -1.24211 td (ph\216nom\217nes)tj 5.2395 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51755 0 td 0 tc (de m\216t)tj 2.83108 0 td (aph)tj 1.53686 0 td (y)tj 0.5 0 td [(sique : en d\325autr)19(es mots)36(, la cr)19(o)19(y)19(ance v)19(eut que le)]tj -10.625 -1.24212 td [(monde et l\325univ)19(er)18(s soient mieux compris si on parle d\325\216l\216ments palpables de)]tj 0 -1.24211 td [(pr\216f\216r)19(ence \210 des \216v\216nements)36(. l)167(\325envir)19(onnement, par e)18(x)19(emple)37(, est consid\216r\216)]tj 0 -1.2421 td [(comme import)19(ant,)-519(et la natur)18(e)37(, en t)19(ant que r\216seau d\325entit\216s inter)19(connect\216es)]tj t* [(mais souv)19(ent fr)18(agiles)37(. de cette tr)19(adition, nous vient un puissant dualisme)]tj 0 -1.24211 td [(de l\325esprit et du corps)-519(: la cr)19(o)19(y)19(ance que l\325esprit humain (l\325immat\216riel) agit)]tj 0 -1.2421 td [(sur le \307 corps \310 inerte et m\216canique de la natur)19(e)37(. l)18(a m\216t)19(aph)18(y)19(sique des)]tj 0 -1.24211 td [(ph\216nom\217nes)37(, d\325un autr)18(e c\231t\216, dr)19(esse un portr)18(ait du monde o\235 l\325\220tr)19(e humain)]tj 0 -1.2421 td (est en cause dans des \216v\216nements)tj 14.21606 0 td -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.51764 0 td 0 tc (cet article)tj 4.27533 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51762 0 td 0 tc (en tent)tj 2.94307 0 td (ant de d\216v)tj 4.33179 0 td (elopper une)tj -26.80152 -1.24212 td (appr)tj 1.94458 0 td (oche post-humaniste de l\325\216ducation, adopte une optique de f)tj 25.34521 0 td (onction)tj 3.20484 0 td (-)tj -30.49463 -1.24212 td (nement bien arr\220t\216e \210 l\325id\216e de vivr)tj 14.91749 0 td -0.0002 tc (e)tj 0.70259 0 td 0 tc (en )tj et q q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 247.7473 225.4022 tm 0 g <8e74>tj 0.79613 0 td (at s\216miotique)tj et q q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 311.7865 225.4022 tm 0 g (.)tj -23.61963 -2.52632 td [(k)37(e)19(yw)18(or)19(ds: )]tj et q q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 131.7155 201.4022 tm 0 g [(envir)19(onment)18(al education; pr)19(ocess philosoph)19(y; envir)18(onment;)]tj -4.66479 -1.26316 td (ecosoph)tj 3.6665 0 td (y)tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 101.9705 153.8022 tm 0 g (the ontological status of \322the environment\323: assumptions)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91 132.5022 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc (on)tj 1.69726 0 td 0 tc 0.105 tw [(those stepping int)19(o riv)18(er)19(s st)19(a)18(ying the same other and other w)19(ater)19(s flo)19(w)111(.)]tj -1.69726 -1.23529 td 0 tw [(\(her)19(aclitus)36(, cited in gr)19(aham, 2006, \246 9\))]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 73 99.5022 tm 0 g 0.01 tc 0.129 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(al and sust)19(ainable de)19(v)18(elopment education)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 308.9099 102.5022 tm 0 g (1)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 316.8322 99.5022 tm 0 g 0.01 tc 0.129 tw [(ar)19(e both gener)18(ally)]tj -25.66655 -1.26316 td 0.022 tc 0.227 tw [(pr)19(emised on ont)18(ological and epistemological r)19(ealism and on subst)19(ance)]tj t* 0.322 tw [(met)19(aph)18(y)19(sics)37(. that is t)18(o sa)19(y)111(, the non-human w)19(orld is assumed t)18(o be )]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 197.2256 33.8348 tm 0 g (canadian journal of environmental education, 12, 2007)tj /f5 1 tf 1 0 0 1 -1000 1648 tm 1 g -0.25 tc ( )tj et q endstream endobj 3 0 obj << /length 8234 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 37 588.3035 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc tj 0.77784 0 td 0 tc [(independently r)19(eal\321i.e)56(., independent of our per)18(ceptions of it, )]tj -0.77784 -1.26316 td -0.0002 tc tj 0.77769 0 td 0 tc [(in k)19(e)18(y r)19(espects unchanging and pr)19(edict)18(able)56(, and )]tj -0.77769 -1.26316 td -0.0001 tc tj 0.77777 0 td 0 tc (made of \322stuff.\323 )tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 540.3035 tm 0 g -0.005 tw [(without these assumptions)37(, ther)18(e w)19(ould be no \322natur)19(e\323 t)18(o \322sa)19(v)19(e)56(,\323 no plan-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.01 tw [(et t)19(o pr)18(otect, and so on. on initial inspection, it seems that this is the only)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(sensible w)19(a)18(y t)19(o pr)19(oceed, f)18(or ho)19(w could one be committed t)19(o ecological caus-)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(es without belie)19(ving ther)18(e is a w)19(orld t)19(o safeguar)18(d that is subst)19(antial?)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.006 tc 0.024 tw [(one r)19(eason w)18(e hold these assumptions is simply that w)19(e gr)19(e)18(w up with)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.03 tc 0.007 tw [(them; the)19(y ar)18(e themselv)19(es \322natur)19(al.\323 the sour)18(ces of our dominant belief)19(s about)]tj t* -0.031 tc 0.009 tw [(the w)19(orld ar)18(ound us can be tr)19(aced back t)19(o cert)18(ain k)19(e)19(y figur)18(es in ancient gr)19(eece)56(.)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.012 tw [(these include l)19(eucippus and democritus)36(, cr)19(edited with the birth of at)19(omism)]tj t* 0.008 tc 0.131 tw [(\(the belief that all matter is composed of, and potentially r)19(educible t)19(o,)]tj t* -0.006 tc 0.058 tw [(at)19(oms\321at that time assumed t)18(o be the smallest particle\); pythagorus \(and)]tj t* 0.086 tw [(subsequently euclid and plat)19(o\), whose belief in the m)18(y)19(sticality of number)]tj t* 0.144 tw [(underpins modern f)19(aith in mathematics as the k)19(e)18(y t)18(o under)19(st)19(anding the)]tj t* -0.014 tc -0.008 tw [(univ)19(er)18(se; and arist)19(otle)56(, fr)19(om whose sy)18(stematic studies of that which r)19(e)19(v)18(ealed)]tj t* -0.003 tc 0.141 tw [(itself )-1(t)19(o)1( h)1(i)1(s)1( s)1(e)1(n)1(s)1(e)1(s)1( f)19(orms )-1(the )-1(basis )-1(of )-1(modern )-1(science)56(.)1( w)93(e)1( a)1(l)1(s)1(o)1( o)20(w)19(e)1( o)1(u)1(r)]tj t* -0.006 tc 0.063 tw (modern vie)tj 4.9512 0 td -0.0057 tc (w)tj 1.08893 0 td -0.006 tc (of r)tj 1.52186 0 td (eason, as something that contemplates the w)tj 19.71571 0 td (orld fr)tj 2.67197 0 td (om a)tj -29.94967 -1.20001 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(position of det)19(achment, t)18(o plat)19(o, arist)19(otle)56(, and other)18(s)38(. in effect, at)18(omic)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.006 tc -0.016 tw [(science is fundament)19(ally democritean, pythagor)19(ean, and arist)18(otelian, while)]tj t* 0.003 tc 0.135 tw (modern philosoph)tj 8.09994 0 td 0.0035 tc (y)tj 0.93926 0 td (as)tj 1.34971 0 td (a)tj 0.92026 0 td 0.003 tc (whole amounts t)tj 7.54582 0 td 0.0034 tc (o)tj 0.95721 0 td 0.003 tc (no mor)tj 3.32227 0 td 0.0035 tc (e)tj 0.92031 0 td 0.003 tc [(than \322f)19(ootnotes t)18(o)]tj -24.05477 -1.20001 td -0.007 tc -0.016 tw [(plat)19(o,\323 accor)18(ding t)19(o alfr)19(ed north whitehead (1929a, p. 63): particle ph)18(y)19(sics)36(,)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.013 tw [(stephen ha)19(wking\325)36(s cosmology)111(, and the human genome pr)19(oject ar)19(e all based)]tj -0.0046 tc (on)' 1.51851 0 td -0.005 tc 0.143 tw (these ancient assumptions)tj 11.61706 0 td -0.0047 tc (,)tj 0.69011 0 td -0.005 tc (as is the vie)tj 5.42599 0 td -0.0047 tc (w)tj 1.17112 0 td -0.005 tc (of human scientific r)tj 9.25877 0 td 0 tw (eason)tj -29.68156 -1.20001 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(s)1(t)20(anding apart fr)18(om brute)56(, mechanical natur)19(e as de)18(v)20(eloped thr)18(ough the)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.006 tc 0 tw (mor)tj 1.76019 0 td -0.0057 tc (e)tj 0.76658 0 td (r)tj 0.34566 0 td -0.006 tc (ecent, but also seminal per)tj 11.49769 0 td (spectiv)tj 2.96062 0 td (es of descartes and ne)tj 9.76571 0 td (wt)tj 1.04382 0 td (on.)tj -26.34027 -1.20002 td 0.009 tc 0.13 tw (dominant as these per)tj 10.39982 0 td 0 tw (spectiv)tj 3.06518 0 td 0.13 tw [(es ar)19(e)55(, the)19(y ar)18(e neither univ)19(er)19(sal nor)]tj -15.265 -1.20001 td 0 tc -0.013 tw [(ine)19(vit)18(able)56(. not only ar)19(e ther)19(e alternativ)18(e philosophical sour)19(ces in the gr)19(eek)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.009 tw (canon\321and that canon itself only r)tj 15.19498 0 td 0 tw (epr)tj 1.40698 0 td -0.009 tw (esents a surviving written r)tj 11.68205 0 td 0 tw (ecor)tj 1.85083 0 td -0.009 tw (d, so)tj -30.13484 -1.20001 td 0.012 tc 0.126 tw (cannot giv)tj 4.73184 0 td 0.0124 tc (e)tj 0.92918 0 td 0.012 tc [(us ultimate sour)19(ces\321ther)18(e ar)19(e also competing w)19(orldvie)19(w)18(s)]tj -5.66102 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(e)18(xt)19(ant. hindu and buddhist at)19(omic theories)36(, f)19(or e)19(x)18(ample)56(, differ in emphasis)]tj t* -0.01 tc 0 tw (fr)tj 0.64651 0 td -0.004 tw (om those in the w)tj 7.7429 0 td (est, while man)tj 6.18792 0 td -0.0099 tc (y)tj 0.77299 0 td -0.01 tc 0 tw (tr)tj 0.6465 0 td -0.004 tw (aditional w)tj 4.64661 0 td [(a)19(y)18(s of kno)19(wing ar)19(e not fun-)]tj -20.64343 -1.20002 td -0.018 tc 0 tw (dament)tj 3.20653 0 td 0.004 tw [(ally at)19(omic in an)18(y sense)56(. ev)19(en within the dominant w)92(estern tr)19(adition,)]tj -3.20653 -1.2 td 0.002 tc 0.137 tw [(w)19(ork at the leading edges of both sub-at)19(omic and cosmological ph)18(y)19(sics)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (serv)tj 1.77686 0 td 0.044 tw [(es t)19(o pr)18(oblematiz)19(e long-held assumptions: not only ar)19(e at)18(oms not the)]tj -1.77686 -1.2 td 0.005 tc 0.133 tw (smallest particles)tj 7.64042 0.00001 td 0.0054 tc (,)tj 0.7002 0 td 0.005 tc 0 tw (the)tj 1.36855 0.00001 td 0.0054 tc (y)tj 0.94111 0 td 0.005 tc (ar)tj 0.86211 0.00001 td 0.0054 tc (e)tj 0.92221 0 td 0.005 tc 0.133 tw (also not indivisible)tj 8.39431 0.00001 td 0.0054 tc (,)tj 0.70026 0 td 0.005 tc (while the elements that)tj -21.52917 -1.20002 td 0.002 tc 0.136 tw [(compose them ar)19(e so elusiv)18(e and unpr)19(edict)19(able that it r)19(emains unclear)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw (whether the)tj 5.1318 0.00001 td -0.0041 tc (y)tj 0.77882 0 td -0.004 tc 0 tw (ar)tj 0.84311 0 td -0.0041 tc (e)tj 0.75995 0 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw (best under)tj 4.54276 0 td 0 tw (st)tj 0.71401 0.00001 td -0.01 tw [(ood as particles)37(, strings)36(, or e)19(v)19(ents)37(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 311.2383 135.3036 tm 0 g (2)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 317.7413 132.3036 tm 0 g -0.004 tc -0.01 tw (the pr)tj 2.76294 0.00001 td 0 tw (ob)tj 1.08485 0 td 0 tc (-)tj -31.92192 -1.20001 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw (lems of quantum theory ar)tj 11.36265 0.00001 td -0.0075 tc (e)tj 0.75646 0 td -0.008 tc 0 tw (illustr)tj 2.31762 0.00001 td -0.007 tc -0.006 tw (ated b)tj 2.63488 0.00001 td -0.0076 tc (y)tj 0.77539 0 td -0.008 tc (niels bohr\325)tj 4.59656 0.00001 td -0.0077 tc (s)tj 0.6822 0 td (r)tj 0.34379 0.00001 td -0.007 tc (emark: \322whether an)tj -23.46955 -1.20003 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(object beha)19(v)18(es as a particle or as a w)19(a)19(v)19(e depends on y)18(our choice of appar)19(atus)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc (f)tj 0.29614 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (or)tj 1.18466 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (looking at it\323 \(cited in mcev)tj 11.94205 0.00001 td (o)tj 0.51807 0.00001 td -0.0002 tc (y)tj 0.79665 0 td (&)tj 0.99965 0 td (z)tj 0.51914 0.00001 td 0 tc [(ar)19(ate)56(, 1996, p. 160\).)]tj -14.45635 -1.20002 td (a)tj 0.59302 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (t)tj 0.62108 0 td 0 tc 0.028 tw (the le)tj 2.39902 0.00001 td (v)tj 0.4812 0.00001 td (el of thinking about the w)tj 11.23372 0.00001 td (orld ar)tj 2.86075 0.00001 td (ound us)tj 3.43547 0.00001 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.58387 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (ho)tj 1.074 0.00001 td (w)tj 0.73999 0.00001 td 0.028 tw [(e)19(v)19(er)110(, ingr)19(ained)]tj -25.82212 -1.20005 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(assumptions hold f)19(ast: the w)18(orld is material, and the human mind, whether)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (56)tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.3333 33.8708 tm 0 g (andrew stables)tj et q endstream endobj 4 0 obj << /length 7322 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3742 33.8708 tm 0 g (57)tj et 1 g 72 54 324 541.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(immaterially or materially caused, observ)19(es it and is r)19(esponsible f)18(or looking)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(after it. mor)19(ality applies t)18(o people; machine-lik)19(e pr)19(edict)19(ability t)18(o animals and)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(the r)19(est of natur)18(e)56(. this w)19(orldvie)19(w is gr)18(ounded in subst)19(ance met)19(aph)18(y)19(sics and)]tj t* 0 tc 0.033 tw [(is deeply affected b)19(y a f)18(orm of mind-body dualism de)19(v)19(eloped thr)19(ough the)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.01 tw [(judaeo-christian and cartesian r)19(ationalist tr)18(aditions)37(. its conv)19(er)18(se w)19(ould be)]tj 0.0065 tc (a)' 0.92329 0 td 0.007 tc 0.132 tw [(pr)19(ocess met)18(aph)19(y)19(sics that escapes mind-body subst)19(ance dualism, and)]tj -0.92329 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw [(such a met)19(aph)18(y)19(sics is b)19(y no means unthink)19(able)56(.)]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 149.9236 482.3616 tm 0 g (process philosophy and environment)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 459.5616 tm 0 g -0.006 tc 0.004 tw [(the r)19(oots of a pr)18(ocess met)19(aph)19(y)18(sics can be f)19(ound in the fr)18(agment)19(ary surviv-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.012 tc -0.01 tw [(ing writings of her)19(aclitus)36(, who is best kno)19(wn f)19(or asserting that a man cannot)]tj t* -0.006 tc 0.001 tw [(put his hand in the same riv)19(er twice \(though the written r)18(ecor)19(d only r)18(e)19(v)18(eals)]tj t* -0.023 tc [(plat)19(o attributing this t)18(o him; the quot)19(ation at the opening of this paper is\321per-)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.006 tw [(haps confusingly\321what her)19(aclitus is kno)18(wn t)19(o ha)18(v)19(e written on the matter\),)]tj t* -0.032 tc 0.01 tw (and that fir)tj 4.43342 0 td -0.0319 tc (e)tj 0.72373 0 td -0.032 tc (is the primary element. in other w)tj 13.84418 0 td [(or)19(ds)36(, her)19(aclitus puts f)18(orth a vie)19(w)]tj -19.00133 -1.20001 td -0.017 tc -0.006 tw [(of the w)19(orld as united in its endless change and tr)19(ansmut)18(ation int)19(o opposites)37(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(p)56(erhaps the most influential modern w)92(estern philosopher t)19(o ha)18(v)19(e de)19(v)18(el-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(oped pr)19(ocess philosoph)18(y fr)19(om this sour)19(ce is whitehead, whose )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 345.7245 363.5616 tm 0 g -0.002 tc -0.011 tw [(pr)19(ocess and)]tj -27.27245 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(r)19(eality )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 104.4502 351.5616 tm 0 g [((1929a) r)19(emains str)18(ongly influential.)]tj -1.34502 -1.2 td 0.009 tc 0.13 tw (on this vie)tj 5.02791 0 td [(w)111(, change t)18(ak)19(es pr)19(ecedence o)18(v)19(er subst)19(ance; e)18(v)19(ents and)]tj -6.82791 -1.20001 td 0 tc -0.01 tw [(pr)19(ocesses)36(, r)19(ather than subst)19(ances)36(, ar)19(e vie)19(w)19(ed as primal; and what w)18(e tend)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.006 tw [(t)19(o r)18(egar)19(d as material e)19(xistence can be under)19(st)18(ood in terms of the dur)19(ation)]tj t* -0.02 tc (and r)tj 2.16672 0 td [(epetition, or near-r)19(epetition, of e)19(v)18(ents)37(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 253.3282 307.5616 tm 0 g (3)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 259.7221 303.5616 tm 0 g -0.02 tc 0.006 tw (whitehead st)tj 5.45619 0 td [(ates)37(, \322ho)18(w an actu-)]tj -24.1284 -1.2 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw (al entity)tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 109.0876 291.5616 tm 0 g -0.015 tc (becomes )tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 145.8897 291.5616 tm 0 g -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(constitutes what that actual entity is\323 \(1929a: p. 3)56(1: m)18(y it)19(a)-1(l)-1(-)]tj -7.28897 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(ics\). as human beings)37(, w)18(e ar)19(e implicated in pr)18(ocesses)37(, and our e)19(xperiences)]tj t* 0 tc 0.049 tw [(ar)19(e ho)18(w those pr)19(ocesses feel t)19(o us fr)18(om the inside)56(. in whitehead\325)37(s terms)37(,)]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 255.5616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc [(appr)19(ehension\321)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 138.0619 255.5616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(the gr)19(asping of immediate e)18(xperience)]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 300.3182 255.5616 tm 0 g tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 309.9109 255.5616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc [(inv)19(olv)18(es)]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 347.047 255.5616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc [(pr)19(ehe)-1(nsion:)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 243.5616 tm 0 g -0.0034 tc (our)tj 1.69773 0 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(r)19(esidual kno)18(wledge \(f)19(or w)19(ant of a better term\) of what seems t)18(o be \(but)]tj -1.69773 -1.2 td -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(is not\) fix)19(ed and subst)18(antial. in other w)19(or)18(ds)37(, w)19(e under)18(st)19(and \(appr)18(ehend\) ne)19(w)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(e)19(xperiences in the light of pr)18(e)19(vious e)19(xperiences)36(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 276.8846 223.5616 tm 0 g -0.0081 tc (4)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 284.4159 219.5616 tm 0 g -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(thus)37(, what w)18(e e)19(xperience)]tj -21.14159 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(is cert)19(ainly r)18(eal, but the objects of our consciousness that w)19(e ha)19(v)18(e tended t)19(o)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(t)19(ak)18(e as material ar)19(e in f)18(act elements of pr)19(ocesses)37(. this has significant impli-)]tj t* 0 tc -0.013 tw [(cations f)19(or a number of k)18(e)19(y t)19(ak)18(en-f)19(or-gr)19(anted concepts in the envir)18(onmen-)]tj (t)' 0.29614 0 td 0 tw [(al le)19(xicon, t)18(o which i shall r)19(eturn belo)19(w)111(.)]tj 1.50386 -1.2 td (t)tj 0.46802 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.86636 0 td 0 tc 0.052 tw [(risk another simplification, the w)19(a)18(y w)19(e \322pattern\323 the w)19(orld, or ar)18(e)]tj -3.13438 -1.2 td -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(implicated in patterning it, emer)19(ges with e)18(xperience and is not mer)19(ely a mir-)]tj 0 tc (r)' 0.35119 0.00001 td 0.139 tw (oring of a fix)tj 5.93466 0 td (ed, subst)tj 3.99192 0 td (antial template)tj 6.56685 0.00001 td (.)tj 0.69483 0 td [(indeed, ph)19(y)19(sics no)18(w tells us)37(, the)]tj -17.53945 -1.20002 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(smallest subat)19(omic particles ar)18(e not pr)19(edict)19(able in terms of space or time)56(, at)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(sour)19(ce ar)18(e bur)19(sts of ener)19(gy lacking complete pr)18(edict)19(ability)111(, and \(t)18(o mak)19(e the)]tj t* 0 tc 0.015 tw (mathematics w)tj 6.64416 0.00001 td (ork, at an)tj 4.15965 0.00001 td -0.0003 tc (y)tj 0.81175 0 td (r)tj 0.35121 0.00001 td 0 tc (ate\) most of the univ)tj 9.02317 0.00001 td [(er)19(se must comprise \322dark)]tj -20.98994 -1.20002 td 0.122 tw [(matter\323 that w)19(e cannot detect at all. unlik)18(e a pizz)19(a, an at)19(om cannot be)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.022 tw [(chopped int)19(o r)18(ecogniz)19(able \322)56(at)19(om slices)36(,\323 f)19(or \322stuff\323 is not made of \322stuff.\323)]tj t* 0 tw (ev)tj 1.05518 0.00001 td -0.012 tw (en our conceptions of space and time can be under)tj 22.11442 0.00001 td 0 tw (st)tj 0.72193 0.00001 td -0.012 tw [(ood as abstr)19(actions)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 320.6566 33.8348 tm 0 g -0.018 tc (is nature immaterial? )tj et q endstream endobj 5 0 obj << /length 6709 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (58)tj et 1 g 36 59 324 536.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.008 tw [(fr)19(om pr)18(ocess)37(. contr)19(a-k)36(ant, w)19(e can at least conjectur)19(e)56(, space and time ma)18(y)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(not lie behind the (other) human categories of sense-making but ma)19(y them-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.001 tc 0.137 tw [(selv)19(es be part of (our?) pattern-making. thus)37(, not only is ther)18(e no final)]tj t* 0 tc 0.043 tw [(cause that w)19(e can disco)18(v)19(er \(as the positivists ha)19(v)19(e alw)18(a)19(y)19(s ackno)19(wledged\),)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.006 tc 0.132 tw [(ther)19(e ma)18(y be no beginning or end. on this account, as barbar)19(a har)19(dy)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(\(1977\) has claimed \(though pr)19(obably not with this intention\), narr)18(ativ)19(e is \322)56(a)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw (primary act of mind.\323 )tj 1.8 -1.19999 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(it is not, on this account, possible f)19(or us t)18(o cr)19(eate or destr)19(o)19(y natur)18(e as a)]tj -1.8 -1.20001 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(whole)56(, though w)18(e ar)19(e implicated in its f)19(orms)36(, pr)19(ocesses)37(, and e)19(v)19(ents)36(, and thus)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.031 tw [(w)19(e can effect changes in those)56(. whitehead wr)19(ote that, \322)92(a living society \311)]tj t* 0.005 tw [(destr)19(o)19(y)19(s \311 its f)18(ood \311 life is r)19(obbery\323 (1929a, p. 146), b)19(y which is implied)]tj t* 0.02 tw [(not that w)19(e destr)18(o)19(y natur)19(e in an)19(y holistic sense)55(, but that w)19(e appr)19(opriate it)]tj t* -0.011 tw [(while w)19(e ar)18(e part of it, and that the changes that happen t)19(o it and t)19(o us ar)18(e)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(insepar)19(able)56(. life is thus endlessly both pr)18(oductiv)19(e and consumptiv)19(e)55(. as the)]tj t* [(flo)19(w)19(er opens)37(, the bud deca)18(y)20(s)37(. as the seed ripens)37(, the flo)19(w)19(er deca)19(y)19(s)38(, and so)]tj t* [(on. nothing is e)19(v)19(er fix)18(ed in its identity)111(, though both subst)19(ance met)19(aph)18(y)19(sics)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(and our o)19(wn senses ar)18(e inclined t)19(o lead us t)19(o belie)18(v)19(e the r)19(e)19(v)19(er)18(se)56(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(ho)19(w does \322sust)18(ainability\323 r)19(elate t)19(o a w)18(orld of f)19(orms and e)19(v)18(ents)37(, but with-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(out subst)19(ance? what e)18(x)19(actly ar)19(e w)19(e trying t)18(o sust)19(ain?)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.038 tw [(on the pr)19(ocess vie)18(w)111(, the immediate envir)19(onment is not so much that)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw (which is)tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73.2116 347.9616 tm 0 g -0.022 tc (lying )tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 94.9209 347.9616 tm 0 g -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(ar)19(ound us as that which is)]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 204.6695 347.9616 tm 0 g -0.022 tc (happening )tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 248.4578 347.9616 tm 0 g -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(ar)19(ound us)36(, while the global)]tj -21.14578 -1.2 td -0.015 tc 0 tw (envir)tj 2.10919 0 td 0.001 tw (onment is the sum t)tj 8.42362 0 td 0 tw (ot)tj 0.80315 0 td 0.001 tw (al of cotempor)tj 6.08896 0 td [(aneous e)19(v)18(ents)37(. t)88(o t)18(ak)19(e an e)19(x)19(ample)56(,)]tj -17.42492 -1.20001 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(let us consider the case of a r)19(olling log. a)56(ccor)18(ding t)19(o subst)19(ance met)18(aph)19(y)19(sics)37(,)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(this is fir)19(st\321a log; second\321in motion. a)55(ccor)19(ding t)19(o pr)18(ocess met)19(aph)19(y)19(sics)36(, this)]tj t* -0.019 tc 0.005 tw (is fir)tj 1.7784 0 td (st\321an e)tj 3.40882 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.46222 0 td -0.019 tc [(ent, second\321inv)19(olving dur)18(ation of (a) mo)19(v)19(ement and (b) a st)19(ate)]tj -5.64944 -1.20001 td 0 tc -0.003 tw [(of aff)19(air)18(s r)19(ecogniz)19(ed as a log \(until it br)18(eaks up int)19(o splinter)19(s)37(, or whate)18(v)19(er\). )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.005 tw [(on a pr)19(ocess vie)18(w)111(, e)19(v)19(ents ar)19(e not arbitr)18(ary but neither ar)19(e the)19(y entir)18(e-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw (ly pr)tj 1.84712 0 td 0 tw (edict)tj 1.96927 0 td 0.007 tw [(able: e)19(v)18(ents/patterns r)19(ecur)111(, intermingle)56(, and modify; ultimately noth-)]tj -3.81639 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.12 tw [(ing has only one cause)56(. while this ma)18(y ur)19(ge scepticism concerning pr)19(e-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(dict)19(ability)110(, it does)37(, ho)19(w)18(e)18(v)19(er)111(, offer r)18(eal possibilities f)19(or the de)18(v)19(elopment of envi-)]tj 0 tc (r)' 0.33786 0 td -0.013 tc 0 tw (onment)tj 3.29058 0 td -0.001 tw [(al ethics and envir)19(onment)18(al education. the r)19(eason f)19(or this is as sim)-1(-)]tj -3.62844 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.007 tw [(ple as it is surprising \(fr)19(om a subst)18(ance per)19(spectiv)19(e\): w)18(e e)19(xperience r)19(eality)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tw [(dir)19(ectly; our e)18(xperience is (of) r)19(eality and is not a r)19(eflection on or of it.)]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 116.3245 170.3616 tm 0 g (process, posthumanism, and ethics)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 147.5616 tm 0 g 0.019 tc 0.12 tw [(this r)19(ealiz)18(ation immediately opens the w)19(a)19(y f)18(or the de)19(v)19(elopment of a)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.123 tw (posthumanist ethics and education, as suggested in andr)tj 25.49053 0.00001 td (e)tj 0.4812 0.00001 td -0.0002 tc (w)tj 1.15973 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (st)tj 0.81499 0 td 0.123 tw (ables and)tj -27.94645 -1.20002 td 0.082 tw [(william scott \(1999, 200)56(1\). not t)18(o be confused with the c)19(ybor)19(g f)18(orms of)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(posthumanism e)19(vident in the writings of, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, donna har)19(a)18(w)19(a)19(y)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0 tw (\(199)tj 1.83578 0.00001 td 0.004 tw (1\), and in a gr)tj 5.80131 0.00001 td (eat deal of science fiction, this posthumanism is principally)tj -7.63709 -1.20001 td -0.0001 tc (a)tj 0.87642 0 td 0 tc 0.099 tw [(br)19(oadening of the scope of humanist v)18(alues and thinking int)19(o ar)19(eas of)]tj -0.87642 -1.2 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(r)19(elationship betw)19(een the human and non-human w)19(o)1(r)1(l)1(d)1(s)37(.)1( )1(i)1(t)1( )1(t)20(a)1(k)20(e)1(s)1( )1(u)1(s)1( )1(b)1(e)19(y)20(ond)]tj t* 0 tc 0.037 tw (the limited deont)tj 7.48128 0.00001 td (ological envir)tj 5.77579 0.00001 td 0 tw (onment)tj 3.36988 0.00001 td 0.037 tw [(al ethics implied b)19(y immanuel k)36(ant)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.3333 33.8708 tm 0 g (andrew stables)tj et q endstream endobj 6 0 obj << /length 6830 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [((1949), accor)19(ding t)18(o which our tr)19(eatment of animals is ethical or not insof)19(ar)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.019 tc 0.005 tw [(as it r)19(epr)18(oduces our beha)19(viour t)19(o)18(w)19(ar)19(ds other people)56(, and be)18(y)19(ond arist)19(otelian-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.022 tc 0.2 tw [(based virtue ethics)37(, accor)18(ding t)19(o which envir)19(onment)18(ally r)19(esponsible)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(beha)19(viour might arise as a r)18(esult of the tr)19(aining of per)19(sonal char)19(acter)110(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 361.0642 554.9617 tm 0 g (5)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 367.4761 551.9617 tm 0 g -0.017 tc 0.003 tw (it goes)tj -29.44761 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.013 tw [(be)19(y)19(ond tr)18(aditional utilit)19(arian ethics in attempting t)19(o v)18(aloriz)19(e mor)19(e than the)]tj t* 0 tw [(specifically human inter)19(est. insof)18(ar as deep ecological per)19(spectiv)19(es tend t)18(o)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.014 tc [(m)19(y)19(stify natur)18(e)56(, a posthumanism de)19(v)18(eloped fr)19(om a pr)19(ocess account also runs)]tj 0 -1.19999 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(counter t)19(o deep ecological ethics; ho)18(w)19(e)18(v)19(er)110(, this b)19(y no means true of all deep)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.018 tw [(ecology \(e)56(.g., l)18(eopoldian land-ethics\). thus)37(, a pr)19(ocess-based posthumanist)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.015 tc 0.124 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(al ethic ma)19(y)1( )1(o)1(r)1( )1(m)1(a)20(y not be at odds with str)18(ands in deep)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (ecological thought. )tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.0216 tc (the)tj 1.81121 0 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(k)37(antian per)19(spectiv)18(e is that cruelty t)19(o animals belittles the people who)]tj -3.61121 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.027 tw [(do it since it is unr)19(easonable t)18(o be cruel. ther)19(e is no sense in this k)37(antian)]tj t* 0.134 tw [(appr)19(oach of an)18(y r)19(elationship, discour)19(se)55(, or negotiation with the animals)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(inv)19(olv)18(ed. ev)19(ery)19(da)18(y life)56(, ho)19(w)19(e)18(v)19(er)110(, tells a differ)19(ent st)19(ory)110(. t)148(ak)19(en t)18(o e)19(xtr)19(emes)36(, the)]tj t* -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(k)37(antian conception of the categorical imper)19(ativ)19(e might lead one t)18(o conclude)]tj t* 0 tc 0.046 tw [(that kindness is the appr)19(opriate w)18(a)19(y t)19(o tr)18(eat the danger)19(ous animal that is)]tj t* 0.012 tw [(char)19(ging at y)18(ou, because kindness is a virtue)56(, and what is virtuous is virtu-)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(ous in all conte)19(xts)36(, wher)19(eas in r)19(eality y)19(ou will try either t)18(o escape or distr)19(act)]tj t* 0 tc 0.061 tw [(it, if necessary b)19(y hurting it. in other w)18(or)19(ds)36(, y)19(our actions will, indeed, be)]tj t* 0.013 tc 0.126 tw [(affected b)19(y both the animal\325)37(s actions and the lik)18(ely immediate conse-)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw (quences: it will be a tw)tj 9.76725 0 td 0 tw (o-w)tj 1.54366 0 td 0 tc (a)tj 0.47753 0 td -0.0039 tc (y)tj 0.77905 0 td -0.004 tc (pr)tj 0.89965 0 td -0.01 tw [(ocess\321a sort of negotiation. k)37(antian ethics)37(,)]tj -13.46714 -1.20001 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(b)19(y ignoring this ine)19(vit)18(able inter)19(action, t)18(ak)19(es us only so f)19(ar)110(. in such situations)37(,)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(absolute monological r)19(eason cannot be called upon t)18(o dict)19(ate human beha)19(v)-1(-)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.009 tw (iour with r)tj 4.4219 0 td (espect t)tj 3.28237 0 td -0.0054 tc (o)tj 0.79554 0 td -0.005 tc (the r)tj 1.96453 0 td [(est of natur)19(e)56(.)1( )1(h)1(o)20(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)111(,)1( )1(i)1(f)1( )1(w)19(e abandon an absolutist)]tj -10.46434 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.04 tw [(vie)19(w of r)18(eason, as part of abandoning a belief in the independence of the)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(human mind fr)19(om the materiality of the natur)19(al w)18(orld, then r)19(ationality)]tj t* -0.019 tc 0.005 tw (need not be div)tj 6.47158 0 td 0 tw (or)tj 0.84998 0 td 0.005 tw [(ced fr)19(om consequentialism.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 261.3689 266.9616 tm 0 g (6)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 267.7669 263.9616 tm 0 g -0.019 tc (specifically)tj 4.49519 0 td -0.0192 tc (,)tj 0.52273 0 td -0.019 tc 0.005 tw (if w)tj 1.52079 0 td -0.0191 tc (e)tj 0.74491 0 td -0.019 tc 0 tw [(ackno)19(wledge)]tj -26.76031 -1.20001 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(that the animal and oneself ar)19(e engaged in the same comple)18(x pr)19(ocess)37(,)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.002 tc 0.137 tw [(then under)19(st)18(anding and affecting our r)19(elationships with the non-human)]tj t* -0.019 tc 0.005 tw (become of primary and immediate inter)tj 16.76486 0 td (est. thus it is not ultimately irr)tj 12.62339 0 td 0 tw (ational)tj -29.38825 -1.20001 td 0.013 tc 0.126 tw [(t)19(o either st)19(op, or escape fr)18(om, the animal; which is the mor)19(e r)19(ational)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(depends on the situation. in such situations)37(, e)18(v)19(erybody kno)19(wn t)18(o this author)]tj 0 tc (w)' 0.71269 0 td -0.027 tc 0.013 tw [(ould lik)19(ely act out of a sort of enlightened self-inter)18(est, in a)19(v)19(oiding harm fr)18(o)1(m)]tj -0.71269 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.017 tw [(the animal \(fir)19(st priority\) while attempting t)18(o a)19(v)19(oid harm t)18(o it \(second and)]tj t* 0 tw (lo)tj 0.75903 0 td 0.064 tw [(w)19(er priority\). in other w)19(or)18(ds)37(, w)18(e w)19(ould act as though at the centr)19(e of a)]tj -0.75903 -1.2 td 0 tw [(pr)19(ocess inv)18(olving (in this case) non-human other)19(s)37(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(by ackno)19(wledging our activity as part of a )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 268.5613 143.9616 tm 0 g -0.014 tc [(ne)18(xu)1(s )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 294.5793 143.9616 tm 0 g -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [((whitehead, 1929a), w)19(e)]tj -22.15793 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.007 tw [(ar)19(e also parting fr)18(om all ethical sy)19(stems based on the idea of mor)19(al \(in this)]tj t* -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(case)56(, envir)18(onment)19(al\) action as principally e)19(xpr)18(essiv)19(e of desir)19(able tr)19(aits of char)-1(-)]tj t* 0.011 tc 0.127 tw [(acter or per)19(sonality)110(, including both arist)19(otelian virtue ethics and mor)19(e)]tj t* -0.019 tc 0.005 tw [(r)19(ecent conceptions of ecofeminist and car)18(e-based ethics other than those that)]tj t* 0 tc 0.098 tw [(e)19(xplor)18(e the e)19(xperiential human/non-human boundaries \(such as cla)19(yt)18(on,)]tj t* 0 tw [(1998\): these latter conceptions appear much mor)19(e pr)18(ocess-friendly)111(.)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm 0 g (59)tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 319.6128 33.8348 tm 0 g -0.012 tc (is nature immaterial? )tj et q endstream endobj 7 0 obj << /length 6783 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (60)tj et 1 g 36 57.857 324 537.9431 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 55 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.028 tc 0.006 tw [(p)56(artly analogously)111(, a pr)18(ocess-posthumanist vie)19(w is necessarily at odds with)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.022 tc -0.001 tw [(all f)19(orms of utilit)18(arianism, as tr)19(aditionally conceiv)19(ed within a narr)18(o)19(wly human)-1(-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.006 tc 0.015 tw [(ist fr)19(ame)18(w)19(ork. ho)18(w)19(e)18(v)19(er)110(, a f)19(orm of utilit)19(arianism that ackno)18(wledged gr)19(eater)]tj t* 0.002 tc 0.137 tw [(than the human inter)19(est might w)18(ell be mor)19(e appealing fr)19(om a pr)18(ocess-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.017 tc -0.006 tw [(posthumanist per)19(spectiv)18(e)56(, bearing in mind the str)19(ongly pr)18(agmatic orient)19(ation)]tj t* -0.006 tc 0.024 tw [(of an)19(y philosoph)18(y that judges in r)19(elation t)19(o r)18(eal-w)19(orld out)18(comes)37(. \(note that)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.104 tw [(daniel holbr)19(ook [1992] has ar)18(gued that unr)19(econstructed \322qualit)18(ativ)19(e utili-)]tj 0 -1.19999 td -0.03 tc 0.008 tw [(t)19(arianism\323 is alr)19(eady sufficient t)18(o deal with man)19(y)111(, though not all, envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.006 tc 0 tw [(concerns)37(, though man)18(y envir)19(onment)19(alists ar)18(e str)19(ongly anti-utilit)19(arian.\))]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(thus the adoption of a pr)19(ocess per)18(spectiv)19(e does not lead t)19(o an unequiv-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(ocal pr)19(efer)18(ence f)19(or one e)19(xisting body of envir)19(onment)18(al-ethical thought o)19(v)19(er)]tj t* -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(another)111(.)1( )1(r)19(ather)111(,)1( )1(i)1(t)1( )1(p)1(r)20(o)19(vides a lens f)19(or critiquing e)18(xisting ethical models: in par-)]tj t* [(ticular)111(, b)18(y pointing t)19(o the limits of an)19(y scheme that sees either human or non-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.102 tw [(human natur)19(e as fix)18(ed or natur)19(al entities (including people), as mutually)]tj t* 0.04 tw [(isolable)56(. ther)18(e is mor)19(e than one e)19(xisting model that could conceiv)19(ably be)]tj t* 0 tw [(modified t)19(o meet these objections)36(.)]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 102.6873 374.3616 tm 0 g (process, poststructuralism, and )tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 2.33813 11 252.428 374.3616 tm 0 g (semiosis)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 351.5616 tm 0 g -0.0027 tc (a)tj 0.89128 0 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(pr)19(ocess vie)18(w ine)19(vit)19(ably pr)18(oblematiz)19(es concepts critical t)18(o envir)19(onment)19(al-)]tj -0.89128 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.121 tw (ism such as e)tj 6.15715 0 td [(v)19(olution, entr)18(op)19(y)111(, envir)19(onment, and sust)18(ainability \(corbeil,)]tj -6.15715 -1.20001 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(2004\), y)19(et it also allo)18(w)19(s f)19(or bridges t)19(o be built betw)18(een the often mutually sus-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(picious fields of the ecologist and the poststructur)19(alist.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 271.4263 318.5616 tm 0 g (7)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 55 303.5616 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc (i)tj 0.61808 0 td 0 tc (ha)tj 1.03708 0 td 0.044 tw [(v)19(e ar)18(gued else)19(wher)19(e that a theory of living and learning based on)]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 291.5616 tm 0 g -0.02 tc (semiosis)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73.7811 291.5616 tm 0 g -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(\(r)19(esponse t)18(o signs\) has the potential t)19(o r)19(esolv)18(e a number of pr)19(oblems)]tj -3.67811 -1.2 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(arising fr)19(om cartesian mind-body dualism in education, ethics)37(, and r)18(elated)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(fields \(st)19(ables)36(, 2005\). the ar)19(gument at the cor)19(e of the discussion can be sum-)]tj t* 0 tc -0.004 tw [(mariz)19(ed as f)18(ollo)19(w)19(s)37(. it is gener)19(ally assumed that \322intelligent\323 human beings)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(r)19(espond t)19(o signs in their envir)18(onments)37(, while animals and other natur)19(al enti-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.125 tw [(ties r)19(espond \(mer)18(ely\) t)19(o signals)37(. ho)18(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)111(, collapsing mind-body dualism)]tj t* -0.003 tw [(r)19(esults in collapsing the sign/signal differ)19(ence)56(, all)-1(o)19(wing us t)19(o posit all living)]tj t* -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(as r)19(esponse t)18(o \322sign(al)s)37(.\323 \(the theor)19(etical ar)19(gument is made fully in st)18(ables)37(,)]tj t* 0 tc -0.012 tw [(2005, chapter 1.\) the sign-signal, or sign\(al\) might, indeed, be r)19(egar)18(ded as)]tj -0.0001 tc (a)' 0.91347 0 td 0 tc 0.136 tw [(natur)19(al cor)18(ollary of john de)19(w)19(e)19<79d5>36(s \322body-mind\323 \(de)19(w)19(e)19(y)111(, 1925\), though)]tj -0.91347 -1.2 td -0.0001 tc (de)tj 1.18506 0 td 0 tc -0.004 tw [(w)19(e)19(y did not t)18(ak)19(e this step. ho)19(w)19(e)19(v)18(er)111(, while \322body\323 (at least) is a subst)19(an-)]tj -1.18506 -1.2 td -0.009 tc 0 tw (tiv)tj 1.02839 0 td (e)tj 0.75504 0 td -0.005 tw [(term, \322sign\323 and \322signal\323 ar)19(e not. a sign(al) is mor)18(e lik)19(e a punch, a kick,)]tj -1.78343 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.007 tw [(or a char)19(ge than a \322thing\323: lik)18(e a w)19(or)19(d in a te)18(xt, it mo)19(v)19(es us on. \(the w)18(or)19(d)]tj t* -0.015 tc 0.001 tw (as black ink on white paper appear)tj 14.65469 0.00001 td 0 tc (s)tj 0.37361 0.00001 td -0.0155 tc (,)tj 0.5265 0 td -0.015 tc (of cour)tj 2.91153 0 td -0.016 tc 0 tw (se)tj 0.83925 0.00001 td -0.0155 tc (,)tj 0.52645 0 td -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(subst)19(antial, y)18(et this t)19(oo is f)19(ad-)]tj -19.83203 -1.20002 td 0 tc 0 tw [(ing a)19(w)19(a)19(y)111(, but t)18(oo slo)19(wly f)18(or us t)19(o notice)56(.\) )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(this fully semiotic appr)19(oach ine)18(vit)19(ably dr)19(a)18(w)19(s on concepts fr)18(om the)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.018 tc 0 tw (br)tj 0.87098 0.00001 td 0.004 tw (anches of theory deriving fr)tj 11.47387 0.00001 td (om the w)tj 3.95651 0.00001 td (ork of the f)tj 4.57416 0.00001 td [(ounder)19(s of the modern dis-)]tj -20.87552 -1.20002 td 0 tc 0.005 tw [(cipline of semiotics: the american pr)19(agmatist philosopher charles sander)18(s)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.019 tc 0.12 tw [(p)56(e)1(i)1(r)20(ce \(p)56(e)1(i)1(r)19(ce)56(,)1( )1(1)1(9)1(3)57(1-1935; 1938\) and the swiss linguist, f)55(er)19(dinand de)]tj t* 0.001 tc 0 tw (saussur)tj 3.30122 0.00001 td 0.0007 tc (e)tj 0.91751 0 td 0.001 tc 0.138 tw (\(de saussur)tj 5.07248 0.00001 td 0 tc (e)tj 0.44495 0.00001 td 0.0007 tc (,)tj 0.69551 0 td 0.001 tc [(1966\). such de)19(v)19(elopments include the poststruc)-1(-)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.3333 33.8708 tm 0 g (andrew stables)tj et q endstream endobj 8 0 obj << /length 7893 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3742 33.8708 tm 0 g (61)tj et 1 g 72 57.857 324 537.9431 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g 0.002 tw [(tur)19(alist per)18(spectiv)19(es of philosopher)19(s such as jacques derrida \(e)55(.g., derrida,)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.016 tc [(200)56(1\) and emmanuel l\216vinas \(e)56(.g., l\216vinas)36(, 1987\). f)56(or pr)19(esent purposes)37(, the)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(concepts of justice pr)19(omoted b)18(y both of these think)19(er)19(s is of r)18(ele)19(v)19(ance)55(, as ar)19(e)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw (the specifically derridean notions of )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 225.4085 551.9617 tm 0 g -0.017 tc [(diff\216r)19(ance )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 267.452 551.9617 tm 0 g -0.018 tc (and )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 285.8486 551.9617 tm 0 g -0.017 tc [(tr)19(ace)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 305.541 551.9617 tm 0 g -0.0183 tc (.)tj 0.52365 0 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(ho)19(w)19(e)19(v)18(er)111(, such ideas)]tj -23.77775 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(ha)19(v)18(e been little used in the specific field of envir)19(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)17(al education or edu-)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(cation f)19(or sust)18(ainable de)19(v)19(elopment.)]tj 1.8 -1.20001 td -0.003 tw [(t)88(o poststructur)19(alists)36(, as t)19(o pr)19(ocess theorists \(and t)18(o phenomenologists)37(,)]tj -1.8 -1.19999 td 0.035 tw [(such as edmund husserl, martin heidegger)111(, and maurice merleau-p)56(onty)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 385.3713 506.9616 tm 0 g (8)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 389.2627 503.9616 tm 0 g (\),)tj -31.62627 -1.20001 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(e)19(xperiential meaning is all-import)19(ant, since living is something w)19(e ar)18(e intri-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.043 tw [(cately implicated in, in r)19(elationships with other)18(s)37(, human and non-human,)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(r)18(ather than something objectified and abstr)19(acted and of which w)19(e ar)19(e priv-)]tj t* -0.014 tc 0 tw [(ileged a god\325)37(s)1(-)1(e)19(y)20(e vie)18(w)112(. derrida\325)36(s vie)19(w)19(s on meaning can in some r)19(espects be)]tj t* 0 tc -0.009 tw [(easily squar)19(ed with those of whitehead (1929a), while in other)18(s the)19(y seem)]tj t* 0.139 tw [(utterly opposed. lik)19(e whitehead, derrida has a vie)18(w of the e)19(xperiential)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(w)18(orld as in const)19(ant flux; each per)19(ception carries with it echoes of pr)19(e)18(vious)]tj t* 0 tc -0.011 tw [(e)19(xperiences)37(. while whitehead\325)36(s idea of the \322pr)19(ehension\323 is one attempt t)19(o)]tj t* 0.113 tw [(mak)19(e sense of these echoes)36(, another\321less t)19(ot)19(alizing and pr)18(edict)19(able\321is)]tj t* 0.009 tc 0 tw [(derrida\325)37(s )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 117.2417 383.9616 tm 0 g 0.008 tc [(tr)19(ace)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 138.2034 383.9616 tm 0 g 0.009 tc (.)tj 0.70383 0 td 0.13 tw [(derrida (1992) mak)19(es the point that each time w)18(e)56(, f)19(or)]tj -7.22417 -1.2 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(inst)19(a)-1(n)-1(c)-1(e)54(, r)19(ead a te)19(xt, w)18(e effectiv)19(ely \322)56(counter)19(sign\323 it; each act of meaning car)-1(-)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(ries tr)19(aces of the last. )]tj 1.8 -1.19 td 0.127 tw [(while whitehead and derrida ar)19(e both anti-essentialist in subst)18(ance)]tj -1.8 -1.19 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(terms)37(, whitehead does not attempt the r)18(adical, deconstructiv)19(e met)19(aph)19(y)19(s)1(i)1(c)1(s)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw (of absence that char)tj 8.40866 0 td 0 tw (acteriz)tj 2.72328 0 td 0.004 tw (es derrida. that is t)tj 8.11596 0 td -0.0184 tc (o)tj 0.78256 0 td (sa)tj 0.87067 0 td 0 tc (y)tj 0.38977 0 td -0.0183 tc (,)tj 0.52372 0 td -0.018 tc (whitehead belie)tj 6.73135 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.46302 0 td -0.018 tc (es firm)tj 2.91312 0 td 0 tc (-)tj -31.92211 -1.19002 td 0.019 tc 0.12 tw [(ly in the pr)19(esent\321that which is liv)18(ed and e)19(xperienced\321as \322pr)18(esent\323;)]tj 0 -1.19 td 0.014 tc 0.125 tw (derrida, b)tj 4.61633 0 td 0.0139 tc (y)tj 0.94969 0 td 0.014 tc 0 tw (contr)tj 2.30983 0 td 0.125 tw (ast, r)tj 2.35657 0 td [(ejects all f)19(orms of plat)18(onist essentialism and its)]tj -10.23242 -1.19001 td 0.022 tc 0.118 tw [(implied assumptions of pr)19(esence)55(, instead ar)19(guing that all meaning is)]tj 0 -1.19 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(\322deferr)19(ed.\323 derrida\325)37(s idea of )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 191.9417 276.6617 tm 0 g -0.02 tc [(diff\216r)19(a)1(n)1(c)1(e)1( )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 233.6368 276.6617 tm 0 g -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(combines that of \322differ)19(ence\323 with that)]tj -16.06368 -1.19001 td -0.0107 tc (of)tj 1.09466 0 td -0.011 tc 0 tw (\322deferment.\323)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 139.5151 268.7617 tm 0 g (9)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 145.9717 264.7617 tm 0 g -0.011 tc (ho)tj 1.20073 0 td -0.003 tw [(w)19(e)18(v)18(er)111(, while this met)19(aph)19(y)18(sical gulf separ)19(ates whitehead)]tj -8.4979 -1.19 td 0 tc 0.106 tw [(and derrida on one le)19(v)19(el, on another each points in the same )-1(dir)19(ection:)]tj (t)' 0.29614 0 td (o)tj 0.51807 0 td (w)tj 0.73999 0 td 0 tw (ar)tj 0.85107 0 td 0.009 tw (ds a study of e)tj 6.31602 0 td (xperience as r)tj 6.10967 0 td (elational and as it is e)tj 9.39795 0 td (xperienced, r)tj 5.73037 0 td 0 tw (ather)tj -29.95928 -1.19003 td [(than in some idealiz)19(ed and abstr)18(acted f)19(orm.)]tj 1.8 -1.18 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(finally)111(, a r)18(elational vie)19(w of living begs a conception of justice as str)18(ong-)]tj -1.8 -1.18 td 0 tc 0 tw [(ly r)19(esponsiv)18(e t)19(o the not-fully-kno)19(wn\321e)18(v)19(en ultimately unkno)19(w)19(able\321other)111(.)]tj t* 0.032 tw [(alterity mak)19(es r)18(elationships possible)56(. such a vie)19(w of justice is put f)18(orw)19(ar)19(d)]tj t* 0.016 tc 0.123 tw [(\(albeit b)19(y r)18(ather differ)19(ent means\) in v)19(arious w)18(orks b)19(y derrida and b)19(y)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (l\216vinas)tj 3.2237 0 td 0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.69496 0 td 0 tc 0.139 tw (and its implications f)tj 9.45778 0.00001 td 0.0002 tc (or)tj 1.32419 0 td 0 tc (education ha)tj 5.69714 0 td [(v)19(e been discussed b)18(y gert)]tj -20.39777 -1.18001 td -0.009 tc 0 tw (biest)tj 2.02789 0 td -0.0092 tc (a)tj 0.75483 0 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw (and denise egea-k)tj 7.94627 0 td (uehne \(200)tj 4.75633 0 td (1\) and egea-k)tj 5.87215 0 td [(uehne (2006). put simply)111(,)]tj -21.35747 -1.18002 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(l\216vinas\325 particular line is that, on encountering the f)19(ace of the other)111(, w)18(e ha)19(v)18(e)]tj 0 -1.18 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(an initial desir)19(e t)18(o obliter)19(ate its alienness)37(, y)18(et w)19(e must o)18(v)19(er)18(come this desir)19(e)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (and attempt, instead, t)tj 9.83362 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.8146 0 td 0 tc (defer t)tj 2.81439 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.81459 0 td 0 tc [(the otherness)37(. in other w)18(or)19(ds)37(, t)18(o liv)19(e fully)]tj -14.2772 -1.18001 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(w)19(e must mak)19(e the necessary eff)18(orts t)19(o r)19(elate)56(. in effect, derrida\325)36(s musings on)]tj 0 -1.18 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(justice tend in the same dir)19(ection. a univ)18(er)19(se char)19(acteriz)19(ed b)18(y pr)19(ocess does)]tj t* 0 tc -0.003 tw [(not allo)19(w f)18(or fix)19(ed identities and thus guar)19(antees (if nothing else) enduring)]tj t* 0.003 tc 0.135 tw [(alterity)111(. w)92(e ar)19(e ne)19(v)18(er complete \322of our)18(selv)19(es)37(,\323 nor can w)18(e act ethically)]tj t* -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(without defer)19(ence t)18(o the other)111(. within the human r)19(ealm, w)19(e ma)18(y not find this)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 319.6128 33.8348 tm 0 g -0.012 tc (is nature immaterial?)tj et q endstream endobj 9 0 obj << /length 6905 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (62)tj et 1 g 36 59.888 324 535.912 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc (a)tj 0.76697 0 td 0 tc -0.011 tw [(particularly r)19(adical idea, but our surviv)18(al as humans depends on our r)19(ela-)]tj -0.76697 -1.18 td -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(tions with the non-human also, albeit neither derrida nor l\216vinas ha)19(v)18(e an)19(y)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(e)19(vident inter)18(e)1(s)-1(t in this)37(.)]tj 1.8 -1.20001 td 0.0148 tc (a)tj 1.06161 0 td 0.015 tc 0.124 tw [(vie)19(w of justice as attending t)18(o the unkno)19(wn other\321and thus of)]tj -2.86161 -1.20001 td 0.022 tc 0.138 tw [(inviting further ignor)19(ance and e)18(xplor)19(ation, r)19(ather than kno)18(wledge as)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.054 tw [(closur)19(e\321runs counter t)18(o the instincts of most philosopher)19(s)37(, but opens up)]tj 0 -1.19999 td -0.006 tw [(e)19(x)19(citing opportunities f)18(or education that i shall attend t)19(o briefly in the final)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tw [(section of this paper)111(.)]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 134.7903 470.7616 tm 0 g (some practical implications)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 447.9616 tm 0 g -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(in the space a)19(v)18(ailable)56(, it is neither advisable nor feasible t)19(o attempt a set of)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(c)1(o)1(m)1(p)1(r)20(ehensiv)18(e)1( )1(s)1(t)20(atements about the implications of a pr)19(o)1(c)1(e)1(s)1(s)1( )1(v)1(i)1(e)19(w)1( )1(f)20(o)1(r)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(either curriculum or the pr)19(actice of teaching. i shall ther)18(ef)19(o)1(r)19(e limit m)19(y)19(self t)19(o)]tj t* 0 tc -0.012 tw [(some gener)19(al st)18(atements of principle)56(, illustr)19(ated b)19(y a small number of pos)-1(-)]tj t* 0 tw (sible e)tj 2.74048 0 td (x)tj 0.51806 0 td [(amples)37(. )]tj -1.45854 -1.19 td -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(it is a platitude t)19(o claim that life is e)18(xperienced, and ther)19(ef)19(o)1(r)19(e that edu-)]tj -1.8 -1.19001 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(cation should be \322)56(e)19(xperiential.\323 l)19(earning cert)18(ainly should be\321indeed, must)]tj 0 -1.19 td 0 tc 0.046 tw [(be\321e)19(xperiential. ho)18(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)111(, a pr)18(ocess vie)19(w differ)19(s fr)18(om the dominant sub-)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(st)19(ance per)18(spectiv)19(e in claiming that e)18(xperiences and e)19(v)19(ents )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 287.1203 352.3616 tm 0 g -0.01 tc (comprise)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 326.7378 352.3616 tm 0 g -0.011 tc -0.003 tw (life: our)tj -28.97378 -1.19 td 0 tc (e)tj 0.46965 0 td -0.012 tc 0 tw (xperiences )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 90.0214 340.4616 tm 0 g -0.011 tc (ar)tj 0.84734 0 td 0 tc (e)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 105.4648 340.4616 tm 0 g -0.012 tc -0.002 tw (our inv)tj 2.9522 0 td 0 tw (olv)tj 1.22437 0 td -0.002 tw (ements in e)tj 4.94149 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.46964 0 td -0.012 tc [(ents)37(. this f)18(or)19(ces us t)19(o r)18(econsider sub-)]tj -16.43418 -1.19001 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw (jectivity and objectivity)tj 10.27841 0 td 0.0039 tc (.)tj 0.69875 0 td 0.004 tc (most educational pr)tj 8.88272 0 td [(actice\321particularly)111(, i w)18(ould)]tj -19.85987 -1.19 td [(ar)19(gue)55(, in the sciences and social sciences)37(, but sometimes)37(, and perhaps)]tj t* 0 tc 0.136 tw [(incr)19(easingly)110(, in the humanities and language arts\321is undert)19(ak)19(en on the)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(assumption that what is subjectiv)19(e \(\322feelings)37(,\323 \322opinions)36(,\323 and the lik)19(e\) is a)]tj t* 0 tc -0.004 tw [(mer)19(e comment)18(ary on what is objectiv)19(e \(\322the w)19(orld,\323 \322kno)18(wledge)56<2cd320d266>19(acts)37<2cd3>]tj t* -0.014 tw [(et)19(c)19(.\), and, as comment)19(ary)110(, the subjectiv)19(e is of less v)19(alue than the objectiv)19(e)56(.)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0.003 tw (on this account, what it is most import)tj 16.29303 0 td (ant t)tj 1.87999 0 td -0.0174 tc (o)tj 0.78362 0 td -0.017 tc (learn is the w)tj 5.58218 0 td [(a)19(y the w)19(orld \322r)18(eal-)]tj -24.53882 -1.19002 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(ly is)37(,\323 and the student\325)37(s thoughts and feelings do not offer a path t)18(o)19(w)19(ar)19(ds such)]tj 0 -1.19 td -0.01 tc 0 tw (under)tj 2.46693 0 td -0.004 tw [(st)19(anding. ir)18(onically)111(, \322)56(empirical\323 science \(i.e)55(., science a)19(v)19(o)19(w)19(edly gr)19(ound-)]tj -2.46693 -1.19 td -0.016 tc (ed)tj 1.28796 0 td (in)tj 1.06496 0 td 0.002 tw [(e)19(xperience\) has gener)18(ally de)19(v)19(alued \322)56(e)18(xperience\323 t)19(o \322observ)19(ation\323\321and)]tj -2.35292 -1.19 td 0 tc 0.025 tw [(observ)19(ation under highly constr)18(ained cir)19(cumst)19(ances)36(, at that \(r)19(orty)111(, 1980\).)]tj t* 0.005 tc 0.134 tw (again, w)tj 3.93415 0 td 0.0052 tc (e)tj 0.92203 0 td 0.005 tc 0 tw (ha)tj 1.04766 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.48648 0 td 0.0052 tc (e)tj 0.92199 0 td 0.005 tc 0.134 tw (immaterial \322mind\323 observing material \322body\323: a highly)tj -7.31231 -1.19001 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(impo)19(v)18(erished conception of e)19(xperience)56(. in effect, ther)18(ef)19(or)19(e)55(, encour)19(aging chil-)]tj 0 -1.19 td 0 tc 0.017 tw [(dr)19(en t)18(o \322think scientifically\323 about what is going on ent)19(ails asking them t)19(o)]tj t* 0 tw (swit)tj 1.7395 0 td -0.0001 tc (ch)tj 1.30646 0 td 0 tc 0.01 tw [(off, or ignor)19(e)56(, lar)18(ge parts of their per)19(sonalities)37(. t)87(o t)19(ak)19(e a r)18(ather triv-)]tj -3.04596 -1.19 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(ial e)19(x)18(ample)56(, a child\325)37(s r)18(esponse of \322the mixtur)19(e e)19(xploded\323 might be a v)18(alid con-)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw (clusion t)tj 3.588 0.00001 td -0.0012 tc (o)tj 0.79981 0 td (a)tj 0.76281 0 td -0.001 tc [(classr)19(oom e)18(xperiment, but \322this e)19(xperiment scar)19(ed me\323 w)18(ould)]tj -5.15062 -1.19 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw (not, despite the potential educational opportunities (scientific and otherwise))tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(offer)19(ed b)18(y the latter r)19(eaction.)]tj 1.8 -1.19 td -0.007 tw (the r)tj 2.23363 0.00001 td [(esults of this bifur)19(cation ar)18(e man)19(y)111(, but some e)19(x)19(amples ar)18(e partic-)]tj -4.03363 -1.19 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(ularly r)19(e)19(v)19(ealing. f)55(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, ther)19(e r)18(emain fe)19(w e)19(x)19(amples of y)19(oung people\325)36(s)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(cr)19(eativ)18(e writing being gr)19(ounded in their e)19(x)19(citement at what the)19(y ha)18(v)19(e learnt)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw (about science)tj 5.64609 -0.00001 td (,)tj 0.52599 0 td (at)tj 1.04698 0 td [(least in m)19(y and m)18(y colleagues\325 e)19(xperience)56(. the pr)19(oper mat-)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.3333 33.8708 tm 0 g (andrew stables)tj et q endstream endobj 10 0 obj << /length 6722 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g 0.007 tw [(ter of st)19(ory)110(, poetry)111(, and dr)19(ama r)18(emains)37(, in common conception, the w)19(ork-)]tj 0 -1.19 td 0.064 tw [(ing out of r)19(elationships and the w)18(orking thr)19(ough of subjectivity)111(, the latter)]tj t* -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(under)19(st)18(ood in a v)19(ery limited w)18(a)19(y \(actually much mor)19(e limited than in r)18(en\216)]tj t* -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(descartes)37(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample\), with little or no intellectual endea)19(v)18(our and often with)]tj 0 -1.18999 td 0 tc 0 tw [(r)19(espect t)19(o a v)18(ery limited domestic ethical spher)19(e)56(. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.007 tw [(by contr)19(ast, the k)18(e)19(y educational implication of the pr)19(ocess vie)19(w is that)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.028 tc 0.014 tw [(e)18(xperience is life itself; it is not mer)19(ely )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 231.786 516.3617 tm 0 g -0.026 tc (of )tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 241.8812 516.3617 tm 0 g -0.028 tc 0.014 tw [(life; w)19(e ar)18(e not observing r)19(eality fr)19(om)]tj -16.88812 -1.2 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(an insulated space or a safe dist)19(ance)56(. life is r)18(elational and w)19(e ar)19(e part of what)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(goes on.)-264(it f)19(ollo)18(w)19(s that ther)19(e)-265(r)19(eally is a place f)18(or dir)19(ect e)19(xperience in science)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw [(lessons)37(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(ev)19(erything w)18(e e)19(xperience in da)19(y)1(-)1(t)20(o-da)18(y life potentially tells us something)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.072 tw [(of educational v)19(alue)56(, while man)18(y\321though not all\321of the things w)19(e learn)]tj t* -0.012 tw [(about in school can be e)19(xperienced b)18(y us in daily life)56(.)-265(ex)18(amples of the fir)19(st)]tj t* -0.002 tc [(might include a visit t)19(o a sick r)18(elativ)19(e or a w)19(alk in a particular landscape; of)]tj t* 0.012 tc 0.127 tw [(the second, f)19(or)18(ces of acceler)19(ation and deceler)19(ation while tr)18(a)19(v)19(elling, or)]tj t* -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(pr)19(ocesses of deca)18(y and r)19(ec)19(y)18(cling at w)19(ork in composting, or chemical change)]tj t* 0 tc 0.034 tw (in cooking. the critical message f)tj 14.57423 0 td [(or teacher)19(s is that the mor)18(e connections)]tj -14.57423 -1.2 td 0.109 tw [(dr)19(a)18(wn betw)19(een daily living and scientific theory\321not as abstr)19(acted con-)]tj t* 0.129 tw [(nections)37(, but thr)18(ough liv)19(ed e)19(xperience\321the better the consequences f)19(or)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(enrichment of each. in man)19(y inst)18(ances r)19(elating t)19(o education f)19(or sust)18(ainable)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(de)19(v)18(elopment, the potential benefits ar)19(e clearly social as w)18(ell as per)19(sonal. t)88(o)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0 tw (giv)tj 1.19065 0 td -0.0165 tc (e)tj 0.74748 0 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(one e)19(x)18(ample)56(, polluting beha)19(viour that is often char)18(acteriz)19(ed as \322thought-)]tj -1.93813 -1.20001 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(less\323 can be carried out b)19(y educated people not because the)18(y do not under-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(st)19(and the theory)110(, but because the)19(y ar)18(e not in the habit of associating the sci-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.007 tw [(ence with their daily pr)19(actices; such ar)18(e inst)19(ances of an educational legac)19(y)]tj t* -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(of which w)19(e should be less than pr)18(oud. w)93(e ha)19(v)19(e come t)18(o belie)19(v)19(e that our liv)19(es)]tj t* 0 tc 0.071 tw [(and actions ar)19(e someho)18(w unr)19(eal: insubst)19(antial in a subst)18(antial w)19(orld. w)93(e)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(should ha)19(v)18(e learnt that our actions)37(, thoughts)36(, feelings)37(, and so on ar)19(e part of)]tj t* 0 tc -0.007 tw [(the ener)19(gy of the r)18(eal w)19(orld unf)19(olding, and that e)18(v)19(erything w)19(e do is part of)]tj t* 0 tw [(changing that w)19(orld\321a w)18(orld fr)19(om which ther)19(e is no r)18(etr)19(eat.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.0001 tc (i)tj 0.57969 0 td 0 tc 0.006 tw [(ha)19(v)18(e)56(, in the past, ar)19(gued f)19(or a v)18(ery br)19(oad conception of envir)19(onmen-)]tj -2.37969 -1.2 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(t)19(al liter)19(ac)18(y)112(, based on the assumption that w)18(e r)19(espond t)18(o the w)19(orld ar)19(ound us)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(m)1(u)1(c)1(h)1( )1(a)1(s)1( )1(w)20(e)1( )1(r)19(ead a book \(st)19(ables & bishop, 200)56(1\). some ha)18(v)20(e)1( )1(r)19(esponded t)19(o)]tj t* -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(this as a v)19(ery partial and incomplete account of what education f)18(or sust)19(ainable)]tj t* -0.027 tc 0.013 tw [(de)19(v)18(elopment needs t)19(o achie)18(v)19(e)55(. my intention has alw)19(a)18(y)19(s been, ho)19(w)18(e)18(v)19(er)111(, t)18(o con-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.091 tw [(v)19(e)19(y liter)18(ac)19(y in terms of r)19(eading )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 215.4774 168.3617 tm 0 g 0.085 tw (and writing, )tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 270.2887 168.3617 tm 0 g 0.091 tw [(and in m)19(y later w)18(ork i ha)19(v)19(e)]tj -19.72887 -1.2 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(attempted t)19(o a)18(v)19(oid accusations of r)19(eductionism b)18(y making clear that b)19(y \322lit-)]tj t* -0.02 tc 0 tw (er)tj 0.81163 0 td (ac)tj 0.90465 0 td 0.006 tw (y\323 i mean \322semiotic engagement\323 or )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 245.4262 144.3617 tm 0 g -0.019 tc (semiosis )tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 282.1398 144.3617 tm 0 g -0.02 tc 0.006 tw (in the fullest possible sense)tj -20.91398 -1.2 td 0.002 tc 0.137 tw [(\(st)19(ables)36(, 2005\). in this spirit, derrida has ar)19(gued that when w)19(e r)18(ead or)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(r)19(er)19(ead a te)19(x)1(t)1(,)1( )1(w)19(e)1( )157(counter)19(sign\323 it (derrida, 1992). by the same t)19(o)1(k)19(en, when)]tj t* [(w)19(e t)19(ak)18(e part in a natur)19(al e)19(v)18(ent w)19(e ar)19(e r)18(eading and counter)19(signing a little bit)]tj -0.0104 tc (of)' 1.09522 0 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(the book of the w)19(orld, r)18(e)19(writing it as w)19(ell as r)18(eading it, which is wh)19(y envi-)]tj -1.09522 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(r)19(onment)18(al liter)19(ac)19(y)111(, on the br)18(oad vie)19(w)111(, is as activ)19(e as it is passiv)18(e)56(. it is a dual-)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(ist and subst)19(antialist f)18(allac)19(y that thinking does not inv)19(olv)19(e doing: t)18(o hold ont)19(o)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3784 33.8708 tm 0 g (63)tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 319.6128 33.8348 tm 0 g -0.012 tc (is nature immaterial? )tj et q endstream endobj 11 0 obj << /length 6781 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(this belief is t)19(o r)18(eject a gr)19(eat deal of r)19(ecent philosophical thinking and t)19(o r)18(e)19(v)19(ert,)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(r)19(ather)111(, t)18(o the cartesian position that the mind is immaterial while the w)19(orld)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.028 tc 0.014 tw [(is material\321and that, b)19(y implication, the mind can think about the w)18(orld with-)]tj t* 0 tc -0.01 tw [(out affecting it. sur)19(ely education f)18(or sust)19(ainable de)19(v)19(elopment should ne)18(v)19(er)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tw [(pr)19(oceed on such a pr)18(emise)56(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(this is not the place t)19(o de)18(v)19(elop a det)19(ailed curriculum. r)18(ather)111(, let me illus-)]tj -1.8 -1.20001 td 0 tc -0.004 tw [(tr)19(ate this b)18(y r)19(eferring t)19(o one possible teaching-and-learning activity r)18(elated)]tj 0 -1.19999 td 0.003 tc 0.135 tw [(t)18(o each of the f)19(orms of envir)19(onment)18(al liter)19(ac)19(y \(under)18(st)19(ood as )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 320.0569 503.9616 tm 0 g 0.003 tc (semiosis)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 356.0428 503.9616 tm 0 g (\))tj -31.90428 -1.2 td [(delineated in pr)19(e)19(vious w)18(ork: functional, cultur)19(al, and critical. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(functional liter)19(ac)18(y enables an individual t)19(o cope with da)19(y-t)19(o-da)18(y r)19(ealities)37(.)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(functional envir)19(onment)18(al liter)19(ac)19(y)110(, ther)19(ef)19(or)18(e)56(, might include an a)18(w)19(ar)19(eness of)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(ho)19(w household w)18(aste should best be disposed of: what can be r)19(ec)19(y)19(cled, com-)]tj t* -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(posted, buried, or inciner)19(ated. ther)18(e ar)19(e man)19(y w)18(a)19(y)19(s of teaching this that can)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(inv)19(olv)18(e activ)19(e engagement b)19(y 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛 as part of a br)18(oader set of initiativ)19(es)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(connected with the \322)56(eco-school.\323)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(cultur)19(al liter)18(ac)19(y)1( )1(r)20(efer)18(s)1( )1(t)20(o a)19(w)19(ar)19(eness of the cultur)18(al v)19(alues placed on per-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td [(sons)37(, places)36(, and e)19(v)18(ents)37(. a)56(ctiv)19(e inv)18(olv)19(ement in issues r)19(elating t)18(o the upk)19(eep)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(of national parks)37(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, will giv)19(e 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛 insights int)19(o \(and pr)18(actical)]tj t* 0.012 tc 0.127 tw [(e)19(xperience of\) dealing with landscape)56(,)1( )1(c)1(o)1(n)1(s)1(e)1(r)1(v)20(a)1(t)1(i)1(o)1(n)1(,)1( )1(a)1(n)1(d)1( )1(s)1(u)1(s)1(t)19(a)1(i)1(n)1(a)1(b)1(i)1(l)1(i)1(t)1(y)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(issues that ar)19(e richly \322)55(cultur)19(al\323 in their orient)19(ation.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.007 tc -0.015 tw [(critical liter)19(ac)18(y r)19(elates t)19(o the ability t)18(o under)19(st)18(and the ideological under-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.006 tc 0.013 tw (pinnings of a te)tj 6.65222 0 td (xt, including an \322)tj 7.32569 0 td 0 tw (envir)tj 2.15606 0 td (onment)tj 3.33654 0 td 0.013 tw [(al te)19(xt\323 \(an ar)18(ea of landscape)56(,)]tj -19.47051 -1.20001 td -0.032 tc 0.009 tw [(f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)55(, accor)19(ding t)19(o st)18(ables & bishop, 200)56(1\). again, w)19(orking activ)18(ely with-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.007 tc -0.016 tw [(in a f)19(or)18(est, a f)19(arm, or a conserv)18(ation ar)19(ea \(or indeed an urban envir)19(onment\))]tj t* -0.006 tc 0.029 tw (will allo)tj 3.25589 0 td -0.0057 tc (w)tj 1.05417 0 td -0.006 tc (世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛 t)tj 4.19504 0 td -0.0057 tc (o)tj 0.83221 0 td -0.006 tc (begin t)tj 2.95223 0 td -0.0057 tc (o)tj 0.8322 0 td -0.006 tc [(under)19(st)18(and\321and, ther)19(ef)19(or)18(e)56(, subsequently t)18(o)]tj -13.12175 -1.20001 td -0.022 tc -0.001 tw [(counter)19(act\321economic and political f)18(or)19(ces that ha)19(v)18(e helped t)19(o determine pr)19(es-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.009 tw [(ent patterns of land and r)19(esour)18(ce use \(f)19(or e)19(x)18(ample\). in the united st)19(ates con-)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0 tw (te)tj 0.76162 0 td -0.005 tw (xt, at least, wher)tj 6.87775 0 td -0.0174 tc (e)tj 0.73834 0 td -0.017 tc [(activ)19(e political engagement is an e)19(xpected part of a civics)]tj -8.37771 -1.20001 td -0.006 tc -0.016 tw [(curriculum, such activities could r)19(elativ)18(ely easily be e)19(xtended t)19(o incorpor)18(ate)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(al and other sust)19(ainable de)19(v)18(elopment concerns)37(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc (w)tj 0.84639 0 td -0.0048 tc (e)tj 0.75928 0 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw (need t)tj 2.66653 0 td -0.0048 tc (o)tj 0.79621 0 td -0.005 tc [(go further than this)37(, ho)18(w)19(e)19(v)18(er)111(. not only ar)19(e w)18(e implicated in)]tj -6.86841 -1.20001 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(e)18(v)19(ents: as w)18(e ar)19(e defined b)19(y inter)18(actions)37(, w)19(e ar)18(e r)19(elational entities r)19(ather than)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.002 tw [(democrit)19(an at)18(oms or epicur)19(ean monads)37(. put alternativ)19(ely)110(, e)19(v)19(ery sy)18(stem is)]tj t* 0.006 tc 0.133 tw (an open sy)tj 5.04526 0 td [(stem. w)93(e liv)18(e among and betw)19(een our prior conceptions of)]tj -5.04526 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.094 tw [(appar)19(ently discr)18(ete beings)37(. thus ther)19(e is no fix)18(ed boundary betw)19(een the)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw (human and the non-human \(f)tj 12.51817 0 td [(or e)19(x)19(ample\), just as ther)19(e is no fix)18(ed boundary)]tj -12.51817 -1.2 td 0.008 tc 0.131 tw [(betw)19(een \322me as a child\323 and \322me as an adult.\323 as ancient ritual fr)18(om)]tj t* 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(ar)19(ound the w)18(orld r)19(eminds us)37(, w)18(e \322t)19(ak)18(e on\323 v)19(arious attributes gener)19(ally)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(associated with other animals at differ)19(ent times; and as modern science has)]tj t* -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(r)18(e)19(v)18(ealed, humans ar)19(e not the only t)18(ool-user)19(s and do not ha)19(v)18(e sole rights o)19(v)18(er)]tj t* -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(language)56(. r)18(ather)111(, w)19(e ar)18(e alw)19(a)19(y)19(s part of what w)19(e ar)19(e e)18(xperiencing. w)93(e ar)19(e lim-)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(inal cr)19(eatur)18(es)37(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.004 tw [(if human natur)19(e is fluid, then individual human e)18(xperiences can ne)19(v)19(er)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(be entir)19(ely pr)18(edict)19(able)56(. this is not t)19(o den)18(y that the univ)19(er)19(se might be deter-)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (64)tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.3333 33.8708 tm 0 g (andrew stables)tj et q endstream endobj 12 0 obj << /length 6665 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 58.18 324 537.62 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g 0.078 tw [(mined, or at least ha)19(v)19(e a )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 187.1003 587.9617 tm 0 g (telos)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 206.5339 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (:)tj 0.6332 0 td 0 tc 0.078 tw [(r)19(ather that w)18(e shall ne)19(v)19(er be able t)19(o t)18(ak)19(e)]tj -13.98659 -1.2 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(account of the m)19(yriad f)18(act)19(or)19(s or influences that will come t)18(ogether in an)19(y par-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(ticular place at an)19(y particular time)56(. thus)36(, fr)19(om the human point of vie)19(w)111(, out)-1(-)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(comes ar)19(e alw)18(a)19(y)19(s unpr)18(edict)19(able; patterns r)19(ecur)111(, cert)18(ainly)111(, but with v)19(ariation.)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(w)93(e ar)19(e changing with the w)18(orld that is changing as w)19(e ar)19(e going along with)]tj t* -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(it. this r)19(e)19(v)19(eals tw)18(o further senses in which w)19(e need t)19(o mo)18(v)19(e education a)19(w)19(a)19(y)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(fr)19(om a vie)18(w of trivial subjectivities engaged with import)19(ant objectivities)37(. w)93(e)]tj 0 -1.19999 td 0 tc -0.006 tw [(also need t)19(o mo)18(v)19(e it a)19(w)19(a)19(y fr)18(om o)19(v)19(erriding concern with \322deliv)18(ery\323 of st)19(an-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(dar)19(diz)18(ed objectiv)19(es)37(, and w)18(e need t)19(o mo)19(v)19(e it be)18(y)20(ond humanism. nothing e)18(v)19(er)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.139 tw [(achie)19(v)18(ed b)19(y human beings has been either entir)18(ely pr)19(edict)19(able or man-)]tj t* 0.011 tw [(aged b)19(y human agenc)18(y in isolation. indeed, human agenc)19(y is ne)19(v)19(er in iso)-1(-)]tj t* 0 tw [(lation: w)19(e need, at the v)18(ery least, air t)19(o br)19(eathe and f)18(ood t)19(o eat.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.009 tc (a)tj 0.885 0 td -0.005 tw [(consequence of the abo)19(v)18(e is that ther)19(e is absolutely no guar)19(antee that)]tj -2.685 -1.2 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(the w)19(a)19(y an)18(y per)19(son helps t)18(o r)19(ead and write the w)19(orld is the w)18(a)19(y an)19(y educat)18(or)111(,)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(al or otherwise)56(, w)19(ants them t)18(o. it is all t)19(oo easy t)19(o convince our-)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(selv)19(es that the w)18(orld is a cert)19(ain w)19(a)18(y and that pr)19(escribable actions will fix it)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(f)19(or the futur)19(e)56(. t)88(o see the w)18(orld in terms of infinite pr)19(ocesses in which all peo-)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(ple and all other f)19(orms ar)18(e implicated is t)19(o r)18(ecogniz)19(e it as a te)19(xt under con-)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(s)1(t)20(ant r)18(e)19(vision and of be)19(wildering richness and v)19(ariety)110(.)1( )1(t)89(o)1( )1(r)19(er)19(ead and r)19(e)19(w)1(r)1(i)1(t)1(e)]tj -0.0001 tc (a)' 0.77392 0 td 0 tc -0.004 tw [(bit of such a w)19(orld \(w)18(e do not ha)19(v)19(e \322semiotic\323 equiv)19(alent terms f)18(or r)19(ead-)]tj -0.77392 -1.2 td -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(ing and writing\) deserv)19(es not only t)18(alk and action but the full gamut of human)]tj 0 tc (e)' 0.49046 0 td 0.009 tc 0.13 tw (xperience and endea)tj 9.49025 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.49046 0 td 0.009 tc (our: ph)tj 3.28679 0 td [(y)19(sical, affectiv)18(e)56(, cognitiv)19(e)55(, and ethical. it)]tj -13.75796 -1.20001 td -0.014 tc 0 tw [(demands)37(, on all fr)19(onts)36(, r)19(esponse and r)19(esponsibility)110(. it demands an education)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.02 tw [(that w)19(orks fr)18(om and t)19(o human e)19(xperience in all its richness)36(, and does not)]tj t* 0 tw (attempt t)tj 3.96362 0 td -0.0002 tc (o)tj 0.81461 0 td 0 tc (st)tj 0.72201 0 td (abiliz)tj 2.25855 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.77773 0 td 0 tc [(it, or the w)19(orld of which it f)18(orms part. )]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 220.2285 266.3616 tm 0 g (notes)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 73 247.5616 tm 0 g (1)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 87.4 243.5616 tm 0 g 0.002 tc 0.137 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(al education and education f)19(or sust)19(ainable de)19(v)18(elopment)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(ar)19(e clearly not synon)18(ymous)37(. ho)19(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)111(, insof)19(ar as each \(t)18(o a differ)19(ent)]tj t* 0.018 tc 0.121 tw [(degr)19(ee\) is concerned with the concept \322sust)18(ainability)111(,\323 the pr)19(esent)]tj t* 0 tc 0.063 tw [(ar)19(gument applies t)18(o both. it might further be noted that in the united)]tj t* 0.022 tc 0.285 tw [(kingdom, whence this paper comes)37(, neither envir)18(onment)19(al nor)]tj t* 0 tc 0.056 tw [(sust)19(ainable de)18(v)19(elopment education has e)19(v)19(er been a f)18(ormal part of the)]tj t* 0.006 tw (school curriculum; thus a british writer might ha)tj 20.92789 0 td [(v)19(e fe)19(w)19(er qualms about)]tj -20.92789 -1.2 td 0.008 tc 0.131 tw (combining the concepts f)tj 11.53196 0 td [(or cert)19(ain purposes than, sa)18(y)111(, a canadian.)]tj -11.53196 -1.2 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(ar)19(guably)110(, envir)19(onment)19(al education tends further t)19(o)18(w)19(ar)19(ds a pr)19(ocess vie)18(w)]tj t* 0 tc 0.015 tw (than education f)tj 7.06627 0.00001 td (or sust)tj 2.88384 0 td (ainable de)tj 4.45928 0 td (v)tj 0.4812 0.00001 td [(elopment, insof)19(ar as the latter might)]tj -14.89059 -1.20002 td 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(place a gr)19(eater emphasis on the envir)18(onment \(pur)19(ely\) as \322r)19(esour)18(ce)56<2ed3>]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(ho)19(w)19(e)19(v)18(er)111(, most envir)19(onment)19(al education also seems t)18(o mo)19(v)19(e f)18(orw)19(ar)19(d on)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (the assumption that the natur)tj 12.8335 0.00001 td (al w)tj 1.75878 0.00001 td (orld is subst)tj 5.18433 0.00001 td (antial.)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 73 91.5616 tm 0 g (2)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 87.4 87.5616 tm 0 g -0.007 tw [(f)56(or an e)19(x)19(cellent intr)18(oduction t)19(o quantum ph)19(y)19(sics)36(, including the issue of)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(the w)19(a)19(v)19(e pr)19(operties of particl)-1(es)1( )-1(and that of whether particles can ther)19(ef)19(o)1(r)20(e)]tj 0 tc (v)' 0.4812 0.00001 td 0.041 tw (alidly be held t)tj 6.4776 0.00001 td -0.0002 tc (o)tj 0.85598 0 td (e)tj 0.4812 0.00001 td 0 tc [(xist at all, see j.p)148(. mcev)19(o)18(y and oscar z)37(ar)19(ate (1996).)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3784 33.8708 tm 0 g (65)tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 319.6128 33.8348 tm 0 g -0.012 tc (is nature immaterial? )tj et q endstream endobj 13 0 obj << /length 7903 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 51.4 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(whitehead (1929a) w)19(as v)18(ery a)19(w)19(ar)19(e of the early hist)18(ory of this debate when)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.0002 tc (he)tj 1.33355 0 td 0 tc 0 tw [(wr)19(ote )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 92.1324 575.9617 tm 0 g [(pr)19(ocess and r)18(eality)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 173.1798 575.9617 tm 0 g -0.0003 tc (.)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 567.9616 tm 0 g (3)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 51.4 563.9617 tm 0 g [(see also st)19(ables (2005, pp. 48-50).)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 555.9616 tm 0 g (4)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 51.4 551.9617 tm 0 g 0.073 tw [(\322pr)19(ehension is the basic)18(, e)19(xtr)19(asensory a)18(w)19(ar)19(eness)37(, or gr)18(asping, that all)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.019 tc 0.12 tw [(e)18(xperiences ha)19(v)19(e of all earlier e)18(xperiences\323 \(ander)19(son, 2002, \246 2,)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(r)19(eferring t)19(o whitehead\). )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 519.9616 tm 0 g (5)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 51.4 515.9616 tm 0 g 0.085 tw [(note da)19(vid cooper and simon james\325)36(s (2005) r)19(einvigor)19(ation of virtue)]tj 0 -1.19999 td 0 tw [(ethics in r)19(elation t)18(o the envir)19(onment.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 495.9616 tm 0 g (6)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 51.4 491.9616 tm 0 g [(see also st)19(ables (2004).)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 483.9616 tm 0 g (7)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 51.4 479.9616 tm 0 g -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(see)56(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, michael bonnett\325)37(s (2000) dismissal of poststructur)19(alist)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(per)19(spectiv)18(es as \322r)19(etr)19(eat fr)18(om r)19(eality\323 \(pp. 593-6)56(12\).)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 459.9616 tm 0 g (8)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 51.4 455.9616 tm 0 g -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(f)56(or a useful intr)19(oduction t)18(o these phenomenologists)37(, and their particular)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(v)19(alue in envir)19(onment)18(al philosoph)19(y)111(, see da)19(vid abr)18(am (1996).)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 435.9616 tm 0 g (9)tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 51.4 431.9616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc [(diff\216r)19(ance)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 96.5798 431.9616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(is a pun in fr)19(ench, used in the conte)18(xt of deconstruction. the)]tj -4.51798 -1.2 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(pun arises out of tw)19(o meanings of the fr)18(ench w)19(or)19(d )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 269.089 419.9616 tm 0 g -0.011 tc [(diff\216r)19(er)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 298.7779 419.9616 tm 0 g -0.0116 tc (:)tj 0.53028 0 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [19(o defer\323 \(in)]tj -25.26807 -1.2 td 0.014 tc 0.125 tw (the sense of )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 111.8034 407.9616 tm 0 g 0.013 tc 0.116 tw [(t)19(o postpone)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 162.5615 407.9616 tm 0 g 0.0141 tc (\))tj 0.72688 0 td 0.014 tc 0.125 tw [(and \322t)19(o differ)110(.\323 in the thought of jacques)]tj -11.84303 -1.2 td -0.025 tc 0 tw (derrida, )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 87.3995 395.9616 tm 0 g -0.023 tc [(diff\216r)19(a)1(n)1(c)1(e)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 128.974 395.9616 tm 0 g -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(r)19(efer)19(s r)18(oughly t)19(o the f)19(act that w)18(or)19(ds and signs can ne)19(v)19(er)]tj -7.7574 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.081 tw [(summon f)19(orth what the)18(y mean \(the \322)56(absent signified,\323 which derrida)]tj t* 0.084 tw (called the )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 97.3444 371.9616 tm 0 g [(tr)19(ace)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 117.8791 371.9616 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc (\))tj 0.6574 0 td 0 tc 0.084 tw [(but can only be defined or e)19(xplained in other w)18(or)19(ds)37(.)]tj -7.30531 -1.2 td -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(ther)19(ef)18(or)19(e)55(, w)19(or)18(ds and signs ar)19(e alw)19(a)18(y)18(s )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 211.3296 359.9616 tm 0 g -0.018 tc [(differ)19(ent)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 247.5086 359.9616 tm 0 g -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(fr)19(om what the)18(y mean, and)]tj -19.61086 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.005 tw [(the actual things the)19(y r)18(efer t)19(o ar)19(e alw)18(a)19(y)19(s )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 228.5859 347.9616 tm 0 g (postponed)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 273.9061 347.9616 tm 0 g -0.005 tw [(b)19(y human language)]tj -22.25061 -1.2 td 0 tw ((wikipedia, 2006). )tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 149.5769 302.3616 tm 0 g (notes on contributor)tj et q q bt /f13 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 279.5616 tm 0 g -0.006 tw [(andr)19(e)19(w st)18(ables)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 109.2843 279.5616 tm 0 g -0.005 tw [(is pr)19(ofessor of education and philosoph)18(y at the univ)19(er)19(sity)]tj -7.22843 -1.2 td 0.001 tc 0.137 tw [(of bath, england. his chief inter)19(est is in the r)18(elationship of language t)19(o)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(other aspects of human and non-human life)56(, and in the implications of this)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(f)19(or education f)19(or sust)18(ainable de)19(v)19(elopment. he is eur)18(opean edit)19(or of )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 10 0 0 10 329.1864 243.5616 tm 0 g -0.003 tc (journal)tj -29.21864 -1.2 td 0.0078 tc (of)tj 1.21886 0 td 0.008 tc 0.121 tw (curriculum studies)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 130.9091 231.5616 tm 0 g 0.0082 tc (.)tj et q q bt /f13 1 tf 10 0 0 10 137.9401 231.5616 tm 0 g 0.008 tc [(cont)19(act: )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 180.8316 231.5616 tm 0 g 0.008 tc 0.13 tw [(department of education, univ)19(er)18(sity of)]tj -14.38316 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(bath, bath, b)37(a2 7a)129(y)131(, england; edsa)18(wgs@bath.ac)19(.uk)]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 171.7622 185.9616 tm 0 g (references)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37 163.1616 tm 0 g 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(abr)19(am, d. (1996). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 110.1774 163.1616 tm 0 g 0.005 tc 0.124 tw [(the spell of the sensuous: p)37(er)18(ception and language in a mor)19(e-than-)]tj -6.49146 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(human w)19(orld. )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 105.9689 151.1616 tm 0 g [(ne)19(w y)79(ork: vint)19(age)56(.)]tj -8.11399 -1.41176 td 0.007 tc 0.132 tw [(ander)19(son, a. (2002). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 120.3056 139.1616 tm 0 g 0.006 tc [(pr)19(ehension.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 165.9868 139.1616 tm 0 g 0.007 tc 0.132 tw [(r)19(etrie)19(v)19(ed ma)18(y 15, 200)56(7, fr)19(om http://w)18(ebsyte)56(.com/)]tj -13.05727 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(alan/pr)19(ehen.htm )]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(biest)19(a, g. j. j. & egea-k)36(uehne)56(, d. \(eds)37(.\). \(200)56(1\). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 208.2926 115.1616 tm 0 g -0.009 tc -0.004 tw (derrida and education.)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 289.5481 115.1616 tm 0 g -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(l)19(ondon: r)19(outledge)55(.)]tj -29.71154 -1.41176 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(bonnett, m. (2003). r)19(etrie)18(ving natur)19(e: education f)19(or a post-humanist age)56(. )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 323.011 103.1616 tm 0 g 0.004 tc 0.125 tw (journal of)tj -31.5307 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(philosoph)19(y of education )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 142.3387 91.1616 tm 0 g ([special edition], )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 206.3917 91.1616 tm 0 g (37)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 215.2113 91.1616 tm 0 g ((4), 549-730.)tj -20.96604 -1.41176 td 0.065 tw [(cla)19(yt)18(on, p)148(. h. (1998). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 119.3336 79.1616 tm 0 g 0.06 tw [(connection on the ice: envir)19(onment)18(al ethics in theory and pr)19(actice)37(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 55 67.1616 tm 0 g [(philadelphia: t)88(emple univ)19(er)18(sity pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (66)tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.3333 33.8708 tm 0 g (andrew stables)tj et q endstream endobj 14 0 obj << /length 11669 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3784 33.8708 tm 0 g (67)tj et 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 73 588.9874 tm 0 g -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(cooper)111(, d. e. & james)37(, s. p)147(. (2005). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 201.8065 588.9874 tm 0 g -0.008 tc -0.005 tw [(buddhism, virtue and envir)19(onment.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 325.6111 588.9874 tm 0 g -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(alder)19(shot: ashgate)56(.)]tj -29.71896 -1.41176 td 0.006 tc 0.133 tw [(corbeil, m. (2004). pr)19(ocess inf)18(ormation met)19(aph)19(y)18(sics and envir)19(onment)19(al philosoph)19(y)110(.)]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91 564.9874 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc (c)tj 0.55587 -0.00001 td 0 tc 0.019 tw [(oncr)19(escence 5)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 144.8104 564.9874 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.57553 -0.00001 td 0 tc 0.02 tw [(r)19(etrie)18(v)19(ed ma)19(y 15, 200)56(7, fr)18(om http://concr)19(escence)56(.or)18(g/ajpt_paper)19(s/)]tj -6.90617 -1.41176 td 0 tw [(v)19(ol05/ajpt_v05-12_corbeil.htm)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td (derrida, j. (1992). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 141.3113 540.9874 tm 0 g [(a)56(cts of liter)19(atur)18(e)37(. )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 203.9199 540.9874 tm 0 g [(l)19(ondon: r)18(outledge)56(.)]tj -15.40234 -1.41176 td [(derrida, j. \(200)56(1\). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 140.8361 528.9874 tm 0 g [(writing and differ)19(ence)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 219.9674 528.9874 tm 0 g [(.)-259(l)19(ondon: r)19(outledge)56(.)]tj -17.29028 -1.41176 td [(de)19(w)19(e)18(y)112(, j. (1925). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 137.5365 516.9874 tm 0 g [(experience and natur)19(e)37(. )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 220.5962 516.9874 tm 0 g [(l)19(a salle)56(, il.: open court.)]tj -17.36426 -1.41176 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(egea-k)37(uehne)56(, d. (ed.). (2006). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 182.9715 504.9874 tm 0 g -0.011 tc -0.002 tw [(l\216vinas and education: a)37(t the inter)19(section of f)18(aith and r)19(eason.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91 492.9874 tm 0 g [(l)19(ondon: r)18(outledge)56(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(gr)19(aham, d. (2006). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 145.7179 480.9874 tm 0 g -0.001 tc -0.012 tw [(the internet ency)19(clopedia of philosoph)18(y: her)19(aclitus)37(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 328.7688 480.9874 tm 0 g -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(r)19(etrie)19(v)18(ed ma)19(y 15,)]tj -27.9728 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(200)56(7, fr)18(om www)111(.utm.edu/r)19(esear)18(ch/iep/h/her)19(aclit.htm )]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td 0.004 tw [(har)19(a)18(w)19(a)19(y)111(, d. j. \(199)56(1\). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 155.1466 456.9874 tm 0 g 0.004 tw [(simians)37(, cybor)18(gs)37(, and w)19(omen: the r)18(einv)19(ention of natur)18(e)37(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 357.2491 456.9874 tm 0 g 0.004 tw [(ne)19(w y)79(ork:)]tj -31.32343 -1.41176 td 0 tw [(r)19(outledge)56(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.012 tw [(har)19(dy)110(, b)37(. (1977). narr)18(ativ)19(e as a primary act of mind. in m. meek, a w)93(arlo)19(w)111(, & g. bart)18(on)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.021 tc 0 tw [(\(eds)37(.\), )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 114.6752 420.9874 tm 0 g -0.019 tc 0.006 tw [(the cool w)19(eb: the pattern of childr)18(e)1(n)138(s)1( )1(r)19(eading )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 273.9802 420.9874 tm 0 g -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [((pp. 12-23). l)19(ondon: bodle)18(y head.)]tj -23.64473 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0.091 tw [(holbr)19(ook, d. (1992). utilit)18(arianism on envir)19(onment)19(al issues r)18(ee)19(x)19(amined. )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 349.0724 408.9874 tm 0 g (international)tj -30.36146 -1.41177 td -0.019 tc 0.006 tw [(journal of applied philosoph)19(y)111(, 7)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 198.3631 396.9874 tm 0 g -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [((1). r)19(etrie)18(v)19(ed ma)18(y 15, 200)56(7, fr)19(om http://libarts)36(.w)19(su.edu/)]tj -12.63095 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(philo/f)19(aculty-st)18(aff/holbr)19(ook%20ne)19(w/utilit)18(arianism% 20on%20env)111(.html)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td (k)tj 0.61108 0 td 0.049 tw (ant, i. (1949). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 131.864 372.9874 tm 0 g (k)tj 0.59301 0 td 0.046 tw [(ant\325)37(s critique of pr)18(actical r)19(eason and other writings in mor)19(al philosoph)18(y)111(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91 360.9874 tm 0 g [(chicago: univ)19(er)18(sity of chicago pr)19(ess)37(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td (l\216vinas)tj 3.22168 0 td -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.55573 0 td 0 tc (e. (1987). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 143.3636 348.9874 tm 0 g (time and the other)tj 7.71875 0 td -0.0004 tc (.)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 213.3724 348.9874 tm 0 g (pittsbur)tj 3.33228 0 td (gh: duquesne)tj 5.88892 0 td (.)tj -25.7356 -1.41177 td [(mcev)19(o)19(y)111(, j. p)148(. & z)36(ar)19(ate)56(, o)92(. (1996). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 195.4635 336.9874 tm 0 g [(intr)19(oducing quantum theory)110(. )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 297.4199 336.9874 tm 0 g [(l)19(ondon: t)88(otem.)]tj -26.40234 -1.41176 td (p)tj 0.53891 0 td 0.021 tc (eir)tj 1.17239 0 td (ce)tj 0.94867 0.00001 td 0.0207 tc (,)tj 0.71545 0 td 0.021 tc 0.118 tw (c. s. \(193)tj 4.59322 0 td 0 tw (1-1935\). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 176.5573 324.9874 tm 0 g 0.019 tc 0.11 tw (collected paper)tj 6.71274 0 td 0.0193 tc (s)tj 0.83352 0 td 0.019 tc (of charles sander)tj 7.84219 0 td 0.0192 tc (s)tj 0.83338 0 td (p)tj 0.5566 0 td 0.019 tc 0 tw (eir)tj 1.15015 0 td (ce )tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 339.9722 324.9874 tm 0 g 0.021 tc (\(v)tj 0.81879 0 td (ols)tj 1.22927 0 td 0.0207 tc (.)tj 0.71545 0 td 0.021 tc 0.118 tw (1-6\). \(c.)tj -32.05436 -1.41177 td 0 tc 0 tw (hartshorne & p)tj 6.55468 0 td -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55551 0 td (w)tj 0.85123 0 td 0 tc [(eiss)37(, eds)36(.\). cambridge)56(, ma: harv)19(ar)18(d univ)19(er)19(sity pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj -10.07907 -1.41177 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(p)56(eir)19(ce)56(, c. s. (1958). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 144.7804 300.9874 tm 0 g -0.011 tc -0.002 tw [(collected paper)19(s of charles sander)18(s p)37(eir)18(ce )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 291.5203 300.9874 tm 0 g -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(\(v)19(ols)36(. 7-8\). \(a. w)130(. burks)37(, ed.\).)]tj -23.59062 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw (cambridge)tj 4.68433 0 td -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.55575 0 td 0 tc (ma: harv)tj 4.05533 0 td (ar)tj 0.85107 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (d)tj 0.8338 0 td 0 tc (univ)tj 1.9809 0 td (er)tj 0.85108 0 td (sity pr)tj 2.72119 0 td [(ess)37(.)]tj -18.65109 -1.41179 td (r)tj 0.61108 0 td [(orty)111(, r. (1980). )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 135.5007 276.9874 tm 0 g (philosoph)tj 4.07398 0 td -0.0001 tc (y)tj 0.73971 0 td 0 tc [(and the mirr)19(or of natur)18(e)37(. )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 266.0845 276.9874 tm 0 g (oxf)tj 1.57397 0 td [(or)19(d: blackw)18(ell.)]tj -24.2898 -1.41177 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw (de saussur)tj 4.49783 0 td 0 tc (e)tj 0.43107 0 td -0.0133 tc (,)tj 0.52861 0 td (f)tj 0.37603 0 td -0.0132 tc (.)tj 0.5288 0 td -0.013 tc 0 tw ((1966). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 154.8411 264.9874 tm 0 g -0.012 tc (cour)tj 1.89621 0 td -0.001 tw (se in gener)tj 4.3423 0.00001 td (al linguistics)tj 5.02978 0 td 0 tc (.)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 254.9615 264.9874 tm 0 g -0.013 tc -0.001 tw (\(c. bally)tj 3.32701 0 td -0.0131 tc (,)tj 0.52885 0 td -0.013 tc (a. secheha)tj 4.62909 0.00001 td 0 tc (y)tj 0.48698 0 td (e)tj 0.43107 0 td -0.0131 tc (,)tj 0.52885 0 td (&)tj 0.97285 0 td -0.013 tc (a. riedlinger)tj 5.29265 0 td 0 tc (,)tj -35.48693 -1.41178 td 0 tw (eds)tj 1.5188 0 td (.\) \(w)tj 1.96142 0 td -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55567 0 td 0 tc (baskin, t)tj 3.90185 0 td (r)tj 0.35108 0 td (ans)tj 1.46288 0.00001 td [(.\). ne)19(w y)79(ork: mcgr)19(a)19(w-hill.)]tj -11.86935 -1.41178 td 0.006 tc (st)tj 0.82781 0 td 0.132 tw [(ables)37(, a. (2004). r)18(esponsibility be)19(y)19(ond r)18(ationality: the case f)19(or rhiz)19(omatic conse)-1(-)]tj 1.28984 -1.41177 td 0 tc 0 tw (quentialism. )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 138.6901 228.9874 tm 0 g (international journal of childr)tj 12.47412 0 td (en\325)tj 1.20264 0.00001 td -0.0002 tc (s)tj 0.68466 0 td 0 tc (spirituality)tj 4.53629 0 td -0.0003 tc (,)tj 0.51738 0 td (9)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 308.1298 228.9874 tm 0 g ((2), 2)tj 2.20337 0 td (19-226.)tj -29.86569 -1.41177 td (st)tj 0.81494 0 td (ables)tj 2.18579 0 td -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.55522 0 td 0 tc (a. (2005). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 141.9483 216.9874 tm 0 g (living and learning as semiotic engagement: a ne)tj 20.53586 0 td -0.0001 tc (w)tj 0.98029 0 td 0 tc (theory of education.)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91 204.9874 tm 0 g [(l)19(e)19(wist)18(on, ny/l)19(ampeter: mellen pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.019 tc (st)tj 0.77749 0 td (ables)tj 2.09219 0 td -0.0189 tc (,)tj 0.65367 0 td (a.)tj 1.2648 0 td (&)tj 1.09767 0 td -0.019 tc 0.135 tw (bishop, k. \(200)tj 6.58299 0 td (1\). w)tj 2.30034 0 td (eak and str)tj 4.86101 0 td (ong conceptions of envir)tj 10.63977 0 td 0 tw (onment)tj 3.25754 0.00001 td 0.135 tw (al liter)tj 2.6702 0 td 0 tw [(ac)19(y:)]tj -34.08002 -1.41179 td -0.031 tc -0.005 tw (implications f)tj 5.45094 0 td (or envir)tj 3.11657 0 td 0 tw (onment)tj 3.18496 0 td -0.005 tw (al education. )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 236.5634 180.9874 tm 0 g -0.029 tc (envir)tj 2.05981 0 td (onment)tj 2.93706 0 td -0.005 tw (al education r)tj 5.60264 0 td [(esear)19(ch, 7)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 359.5611 180.9874 tm 0 g -0.031 tc -0.005 tw ((1), 89-97.)tj -33.71307 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0.003 tw [(st)19(ables)36(, a. & scott, w)130(. (1999). envir)19(onment)19(al educa)-1(tion and the discour)19(ses of humanist)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td 0.139 tw (modernity: r)tj 5.82757 0 td [(edefining critical envir)19(onment)19(al liter)18(ac)19(y)111(. )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 295.0339 156.9874 tm 0 g 0.129 tw (educational philosoph)tj 9.35513 0 td 0.0002 tc (y)tj 0.86942 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (and)tj -34.22854 -1.41177 td (theory)tj 2.77759 0.00001 td -0.0003 tc (,)tj 0.51738 0 td -0.056 tc (31)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 127.3533 144.9874 tm 0 g ((2), 145-155.)tj -6.39451 -1.41176 td 0.007 tw [(st)19(ables)36(, a. & scott, w)130(. \(200)56(1\). p)56(ost-humanist liber)18(al pr)19(agmatism? envir)19(onment)18(al educa-)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td 0 tw [(tion out of modernity)111(. )]tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 173.6322 120.9874 tm 0 g [(journal of philosoph)19(y of education, 35)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 308.8 120.9874 tm 0 g ((2), 269-280.)tj -27.74118 -1.41176 td (whitehead, a. n. (1929a). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 171.0737 108.9874 tm 0 g [(pr)19(ocess and r)18(eality)111(. )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 241.373 108.9874 tm 0 g [(l)19(ondon: macmillan.)]tj -19.80859 -1.41176 td (whitehead, a. n. (1929b). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 171.5489 96.9874 tm 0 g [(the aims of education, and other essay)19(s)37(. )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 316.2627 96.9874 tm 0 g [(l)19(ondon: macmillan.)]tj -28.61914 -1.41176 td 0.01 tc 0.128 tw (wikipedia (2006). )tj et q q bt /f12 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 144.7806 84.9874 tm 0 g 0.01 tc [(diff\216r)19(ance)36(.)1( )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 187.377 84.9874 tm 0 g 0.01 tc 0.128 tw [(r)18(etrie)19(v)19(ed ma)18(y 15, 200)56(7, fr)19(om http://en.wikipedia.or)18(g/)]tj -11.33847 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(wiki/differ)19(ance)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 319.6128 33.8348 tm 0 g -0.012 tc (is nature immaterial? )tj et q endstream endobj 15 0 obj << /nums[0<>] >> endobj 16 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 44/comma 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon 63/question 65/a/b/c 69/e 73/i/j 78/n/o/p 82/r/s/t/u 87/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 108/l/m/n/o/p 114/r/s/t/u/v/w 121/y 210/quotedblleft/quotedblright] /type/encoding >> endobj 17 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 5597 /length1 5597 >> stream gltbga+eurostileregular7 ? ? ea2*t/buvsfnjm 5i1pcg&owed8"x4 6z#h0iwq$+34y\k2f28mm " v ~ 3 {  ] h:yzie20{....2uhd)xee4>x#geef&x82)eex%w -\[t^_˫f?j iihn e@v2+}u.u.y,2!ygvvgqd agg yix'ex]guug?-lkk{%w%feex1,ij@4a#-\˙͔Ѓ{{ai vu%wxkjj.??-5u.`@zkkdi'<"*u_uu_p;v *7$ oss3'(weyyer@uqx@ (oy)jkk{՛ї~qpz zi1=mfpv\/^^10^p v;b__b@v7ron} st3 p : t0z)zrs͋i3d0^1t pizaiwwib ?kk{+djo utd6jjtsiprbkkkd+dz#mۭԞ{llh$^ cs m_  ڳ֠|mmr7 zu4u oh)6.#u u$ pu1 1 -p p u u 2ll.l.4ڸߩd%ots"0n qyqqxo 6^% ֫ڛ|nnda;7k8k3iriqgqgk0m+(##q:.m'u ߳ڡ 'c$p i 6(^2h nj4é06oss".w.2Ɗyhh8uc`lk`)|,cvmqabnmmddȦbapwvddlnw6c">>|!mccm>w>mm}>>ؠvc! 2_*'Ѩirpvu+ f#\/k  [$2*z'j[[jgs%>ii{a 豺գr[ /🬈diou+-o"&& lgiieg* ny|oot9g r[[.>!z)apb7p6x6s9s:qrv7=$p]p0ui$b +heuuepgwdch'4 u p[/=yiyyh@r!eii{4%뭻ϣs[u$ong}!:iiz36Σ~srzar nsr!/2igssgoq^kjk@a !|hoosxugbwhwhxydkxjdxixhx΁ci27ziɜmivk~bu55ul7g)gpa:w8v8xxc9`c9w8x8wwa:'ph6ܞ::6dp*am`^qwhgwj#/t |{,4{oot8vuhr q!fgah'>)pwp-fsn@}{xͦ")!Ũ%gb$,(qww;1s}ppp/!xffmlf8|)j!6}ooa)xjgmmg>| p[$0(&geuuepsmeei"@t.xlgkkfc{!$hmm| 8__u#4ǿ r>]-$8y hwwgbrckj{20ӣt^?9ici+Ϊw@?7f7ת\jpkj5t,ii90b+*2x9g[[fsllgfy99lp vcljŏy~0^m[.ljŪʋv|0^m[. ulhsnnr>[.lhpknm>[.ll.l.l.l.. 6a2Ѧhupvu*"5"]/[  [!6(z)i\[ift"agfy(3Ԥs[ tc^on^}iskj{t:p{lkea-.loo b;os>i[ct}n}n)êt99%cy3˹ʹ n-:|u>{5kgfkay amm|+]um0yys85ũ5w.u./.ur#⭪by©8>klkldofufui7d+϶8yhh? y8hkhk&q*j5w;dlkc(|49%ccw4̹*8zk.lnmlxt^nm^m,$?ccmx)xklmam`|: 7"[[$tr^ʿɿ;|mmm+ũ43sm%ydimli<|nbawЭ08tok%!etgsg[tau/noo}Ӳ25}p :aaw^aìc!li hgd_nrlkrl j4 tspbpa-x.eiie"{@+,ccw%oxg-,udaoo`~d5ggyݰ)=yg  {mmi' x?ekke0|"ldcx*:0&[[!sl[Ϳ3ziig$ȧ܋ jkk\xro[n[m%0u&Ю)5}qpb #vkbtsblwru<i.``,,e;3.9b$ɫ#moo#&.xfe;(uhagg`;z q endstream endobj 18 0 obj << /fontfile3 17 0 r /stemh 0 /capheight 1775 /type/fontdescriptor /descent -512 /flags 32 /fontname/gltbga+eurostileregular /xheight 0 /ascent 1775 /fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867] /italicangle 0 /stemv 0 >> endobj 19 0 obj << /widths[250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 198 0 0 0 613 614 613 613 613 613 613 613 614 614 195 0 0 0 0 520 0 608 617 597 0 498 0 0 0 204 502 0 0 0 696 613 590 0 623 560 515 655 0 999 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 510 511 485 510 502 265 510 514 188 0 0 188 826 516 506 510 0 398 474 326 507 402 670 0 389 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 319 319] /lastchar 211 /fontdescriptor 18 0 r /basefont/gltbga+eurostileregular /name/f0 /firstchar 32 /encoding 16 0 r /subtype/type1 /type/font >> endobj 20 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[65/a 82/r 97/a/b/c 109/m 114/r/s/t/u 142/eacute] /type/encoding >> endobj 21 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 1943 /length1 1943 >> stream vflydb+usherwood-bolditalic@^   /+fvcopyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bold italicitc usherwood "ctusbd3vn  q05ӆrcqtyo ypa[k $fx$yxx\\\ $k{yy\hz[gvnoy $rk-yw+erle{)kǨk}tuacgftaf;<\@?tj[coz쬜dif:(bmoy"od:en4"a)bbl[pdgwcskrgxwȋ%av狱pj~yǘw xuggjk}Ǩ|ȅtxe?&e^:_y2hxcski|opǷov )yn~𑜒}hicenp>4}fccdtpfqsmu\mj $yb]_ɶty|sszu}eegt] $=!v3f?ܽӾy+oy,>nu𚚇oys4pxzj c=y\'(cπ!((ekbs=lgǒp t>a67o{sb\ayƜ ry*w h ztxzuysr}>yw{tx inv<q1u|ب𕯐wqmrob:rrwwzv}n'ljmigȻyrvpi^vv > p zxʘbzopdly} $Ƌtt~v}gnrsviwyqmp|z"gikpn8hab;9sc~f`rng_kssyk> endobj 23 0 obj << /widths[722 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 685 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 556 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 852 0 0 0 0 463 463 389 593 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 481] /lastchar 142 /fontdescriptor 22 0 r /basefont/vflydb+usherwood-bolditalic /name/f1 /firstchar 65 /encoding 20 0 r /subtype/type1 /type/font >> endobj 24 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period 58/colon/semicolon 67/c/d 73/i 75/k/l 80/p 84/t 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 107/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 136/agrave 142/eacute/egrave/ecircumflex 153/ocircumflex 157/ugrave 199/guillemotleft/guillemotright 210/quotedblleft/quotedblright 213/quoteright] /type/encoding >> endobj 25 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 6333 /length1 6333 >> stream trzbzr+usherwood-mediumitalic@ww   3/copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood medium italicitc usherwood1$poufnqsbzijlhtmcevd xgw5y* iw1-r%jx,3lu <k5 2 $ q s b  gv;2'yht p`?yȪl,gygs'  \kq+jao؃tsstssn3ur&*!2 òy0ty$ #/<$ %-?$h-تla<-'>q-ykv/-|t?:xlpqqnjcijdĹ~zzzwv~tiy8n:>h{jz{}3k{mt8xnr2 $ywwsoneryЀvyqzjcq*}v7%})؝כٚr{qod|w}yfkg",+huܻզe3sv:f`//sgr>woby%ww0$q}{|{ $}wx  "flwf? `uo5/: p侴#vn0v\_|**y%ww0f$q}{|{ $}wt |y{~{|wthvzlmk $,(q74pݸݻkimra2~kq\hddykϵnwdq ehhdob+5~//1qqrqrqwwxwwwtsawtx=x9w@vvw[i[]12g/!g]12g/!gvvw[i[/!)g12/!)g1-ymwwyޢ0mҀq}{|{ $ }w drvywz@[{wyw||ss~y.'koœěƳzkv{z3k{w}io'hbfɽvssgaby%3(2ai; "flwf? `uo5/: p侴#vn0v\_|*wܣs+s $tb/ǧ?;eilx $sxw{q_d=~zxmkv "sop\omw5-Քٔeeecdc $sawtx=x9w@yf`  endstream endobj 26 0 obj << /fontfile3 25 0 r /stemh 0 /capheight 622 /type/fontdescriptor /descent -254 /flags 98 /fontname/trzbzr+usherwood-mediumitalic /xheight 694 /ascent 684 /fontbbox[-195 -282 995 857] /italicangle -12 /stemv 75 >> endobj 27 0 obj << /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 278 278 0 0 259 333 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 574 648 0 0 0 0 296 0 630 537 0 0 0 574 0 0 0 574 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 519 426 519 444 333 500 537 278 0 519 259 833 556 519 519 500 426 426 352 556 500 759 537 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 444 444 444 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 389 389 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 426 426 0 259] /lastchar 213 /fontdescriptor 26 0 r /basefont/trzbzr+usherwood-mediumitalic /name/f2 /firstchar 32 /encoding 24 0 r /subtype/type1 /type/font >> endobj 28 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 46/period 59/semicolon 97/a 99/c/d/e 104/h/i 108/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v 121/y 142/eacute] /type/encoding >> endobj 29 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 2700 /length1 2700 >> stream upbtuy+usherwood-medium?9   %!r ocopyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood mediumitc usherwoodtfnjpubrvowsmedqizp4r($7tzty*py{ $ekoiolml $,=\-bӋx\hxʻyfyyy*yv?htgm62f؜o0e3%$鱢n(h rr $zyߋ>dfa{} $`|՘z/m[x $t f]5>[zawys8hxzawrfczkry3%*n~ w4asr $zrfczkry3uqpuuqpu-y*y!&&/!!0$&&$!'/]/%%^yyvpquuqqu*yv<c ~{vyyu| $/?htgm62fԜo0e3%$鱢n(hywwwrrotcejrxnh:prohҶã*y{vfb~\m[azw $s~a|a{b~įwrs>xi]ctf3ev@wb͙-}v!Ÿ nzÕvxqy~ft`/+ */ðyca8rax8/:aرv.?yw}_yuqrfczkrj2[?/.‹ȏrfcziry3"fе_cpr z $zxۑi65bzo $puo?> endobj 31 0 obj << /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 481 556 500 0 0 593 278 0 0 278 889 593 556 574 556 389 426 315 574 500 0 0 537 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500] /lastchar 142 /fontdescriptor 30 0 r /basefont/upbtuy+usherwood-medium /name/f3 /firstchar 32 /encoding 28 0 r /subtype/type1 /type/font >> endobj 32 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 37/percent/ampersand 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 63/question/at/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p 82/r/s/t/u/v/w 89/y/z/bracketleft 93/bracketright 95/underscore 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 142/eacute 165/bullet/paragraph 201/ellipsis 209/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright 213/quoteright] /type/encoding >> endobj 33 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 10499 /length1 10499 >> stream oxcfbt+usherwood-book?&x   !(copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bookitc usherwoods0ouiptfqjhswbznexgm )dv (s &c5tliw8 "-%1r*/4ky#[.;+$6,y<>3':!7@u[8 (n~n - % h  f j|/qu"l-h@j + y !!!!"#+#$a%0%%&nyҵxyf%ns ce-bp2/=bk! \?*j}`{ $_~:kn,n $dt{*w=xh{tnu~x{1y wtsuylqЅtx`zqv~bm{{-:!wj}`{ $_~:kn,n $dt{9@gupdʏ{tnu~x{1y<y4d ';)'.0 s/)8d!tyvlvwfw^vӻ\jeganv{{|vr#rr@fi|zz̀arzhl&rϬss^g_*yv"dnta?3 róɊܕ\)18?b洝r 'dc]ce:q-}vs"(sv)i6y1'~pkl{Ŏr1bp""g+_q]t{tnu~x{*wej}_{ $`iċ{tnu~x{ wuuxyttx*usk_ntme}]tɡǚgxo{~w{xu~yy@ywy--n.b{t_el)ӈĊupa7fa 4>ǭ{mvl~}{|lnf"@hۻ_22[r=ng*~Džw@~c{ $p<®vp}}}j^qsyƏ{tnu~]{*:lr $qryyyvwv ${~uz!qnÆppoooo ${g*yvam|q~{p~8kmv{{xd}c{fsodo{pqks\y[adjp拵]n`waat2obɸt29}& µwywywy ${fnjdr$Ƅqpqnon ${x2zb+w`jv^o|wwjejю)*i~_{ $`|z,o:u $oy|r7r1r $px~a.7=>urg3:ecpl{tnu~x{1-y7!w){ w3*7p.`?uyw (d)a̯@j[ɋ{tnu~x{:b9ne $ #  $%ь|{|toy ${dmr1ox^ powc#~ty{z ${ea=hb*soqnht ${{@㆛2wyؿ $@—؅|ofqÂ̌ȝdo}ud $vda6nuzgvqw"z-wts`{ $_dʏ{tnu~x{1yywuuwwuuwvwz;ngeav$b if9rm{ $nq6ܥomonnm ${:>>ܥooonlm ${:69rm{ $nqoy7t4jugq9$psj~y؄~~{u-',56ݰy&wiyu#Ћ{w}u{x{.v@(3s"b-{ms{]{of->ؠijlwov,Ŵrhsszq`ry[ctsxwyfxpturx ${97maj"&; =3-xby}|xuj $u#&jr/Ү-ytvƬ\ygsyo0vjk\kkvoy ͋" '>otxx}yyfki>[5=-=r[yyd-yܰy.90u3'@+nm'+> ,(@v)0os-ywzn 06 74rwhzh:l "jm8"]*vݰȰŰ 3ib6t߁-vdy >zb-/-< 껺takfcڽi#nq24nvw.%´vem]!gn;+z[?vv˱r zyˆ}v[rz[%5*rv %t\}u3r(=e-wk $vÎ{j_f7{熋.*uv-ѱww^^ww $d}eaw|}j~wk~x=`vfjwtw3p*v]vwh:'':9'';͠vfkowt{vfpl.w;j}`{ $_л2fwqqt $y|lvdvgȳ{zzwww ${vod\oaj`ʏ{tnu~x{8bvpxgtqbjenuuqgtqbjenuubvpxpŴrhsszqry[ctsxqzŴrhsszqry[ctsx>d $ʯt+p0 $Υٶdbyyysss ${xbjautd9pyyyyzz ${dnriq8"]lllmml ${u yks!h«p?wz|ԇ|}}{zcbx^Ō¹fp_u_oi^vrggxxx'yssyxstxwov/nŴrhsszqhry[ctsx0wuuwwuuwwɛ $fru+vwuknk{ $\\9[xxwrsr ${oysoz^ejgdfqjz*ћx}}s3wp2sߥomonnm ${73so\~vȱw%3džva`qpppqp{z{{{{g{zl4oty @"dh'$)$?w i]5:nk  $tk#;0wppֈppw}|{|||{959rm-}vr7wőnaǔrh{bsb4 $?)Ʈʵ3{ixwsi&$u,$-_Ȇ $nq6ܥooonlm ${:69rmvvuv5ˌlhffrrrqߋ2&Ɍyyystt ${րw(ttuvvv ${z'ls $-y6yw"[ums5kźyzuyxtyݷ^k}rl`~}xhfg"‹{tnu~x{#wuuxyttxl-jl蟆 $}vwlr{y~o{ $[`hu袠s{ln ${yizygdljvh}{uqocy ${bo3"c^]zrnԱtw|ˉcr]7if,dew) a*r < b֡ cuorrt~}|||}|j{739rmovffw2jȅxedh*]!4rsbe(pf{bf~eltsp}9ކ $ie,d ؿ(kzzzjp`{ $p$täuvvqrr $y^vwvrrr ${/3yc@|ww4qh(ik֥̋鋝}}|vvw ${anqs|ac/ (q{|}|zjutwwy}xwgv`lt e %⯨qbyx $ů(c skhi @֋ -vhwwn2r*wcusoeo_k2sij|]y&xfitqı; shey}vsޥooonlm ${8*_m]v}t^bk=dyww"wdl\j"$zmm^|w~y]d1sc5쭡-:`v $a}|li{~sz{zx} $#0 %93l0hr\muwtonoyߛrrrqqq ${gt;c0$jΙomnnkq ${Ãabk.q6_Ɇ $fzhӑ&>cy $qt|uxe1Ƿ櫦wzxrpu ${sqbmj\`'sϘpopmmm ${{f6?^-vÐwjzyޱ#ȉ0fz~^vpw^ӱ#3l}7͋ p5yuuyxvuyxvwwxvuyxvvxxvuyvrwyiru-y9ÖwvЫy{ $,27_p|uݜˑ*Ƥuyps(popopo&`$h7~k$"mb eͷ{udyv-yܰcey+mؾb<5>1gour6b-b 0cۨpi*l`i6d؞]f5gltx;f3g  3sgs3g1l3sngnwαzwxov{ $rsȁx5~| $,͚r' %tuuΈuut{z{֌{{{{zm1mi:fx]~Ɇ $fvfw %t[}u!~2sk,q_ʋllkhhg ${| =poq\#] kz}*0jj8yryv:%&@߀>)btc5uur9j%-z״߀r]" hs3_cewb>驥bx봠jlop r/q{mplcmdj[򒮭ppp|{| ${vgy^e) xlllmnm ${ie/jg $բש*yvy<<yj&kzh[@gijijh>pk''kvt.˥ťlkkqlqqqp>>pk''k78˥ťlkkqlqqqyf`  endstream endobj 34 0 obj << /fontfile3 33 0 r /stemh 0 /capheight 622 /type/fontdescriptor /descent -254 /flags 34 /fontname/oxcfbt+usherwood-book /xheight 694 /ascent 684 /fontbbox[-101 -307 964 856] /italicangle 0 /stemv 59 >> endobj 35 0 obj << /widths[278 0 0 0 0 963 722 0 296 296 0 0 278 278 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 0 0 0 407 1000 630 593 611 704 574 537 630 704 296 296 648 500 815 685 741 574 0 630 519 556 667 611 944 0 611 556 333 0 333 0 500 0 500 556 463 556 500 315 500 556 259 241 519 241 889 574 537 556 556 370 426 315 537 500 759 537 519 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 963 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 963 444 444 0 278] /lastchar 213 /fontdescriptor 34 0 r /basefont/oxcfbt+usherwood-book /name/f4 /firstchar 32 /encoding 32 0 r /subtype/type1 /type/font >> endobj 36 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space] /type/encoding >> endobj 37 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 147 /length1 147 >> stream shfxps+eurostileregular7 ? ? dag!{.... endstream endobj 38 0 obj << /fontfile3 37 0 r /stemh 0 /capheight 1775 /type/fontdescriptor /descent -512 /flags 34 /fontname/shfxps+eurostileregular /xheight 0 /ascent 1775 /fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867] /italicangle 0 /stemv 0 >> endobj 39 0 obj << /widths[250] /lastchar 32 /fontdescriptor 38 0 r /basefont/shfxps+eurostileregular /name/f5 /firstchar 32 /encoding 36 0 r /subtype/type1 /type/font >> endobj 40 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 44/comma/hyphen/period 49/one 51/three 53/five 55/seven 57/nine/colon 65/a/b/c/d/e 72/h/i/j/k/l 80/p 82/r/s/t 87/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 108/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 142/eacute 209/emdash 213/quoteright] /type/encoding >> endobj 41 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 6850 /length1 6850 >> stream vhfirm+usherwood-bookitalic@o`   .*copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporationitc usherwood book italicitc usherwood21spdftboe3mjuzcnqihyvgx %+$45&w#"8-*),r4lhk)8#$ a r o 9 5n&cjdltl?x`:o 2] $thk $,ktok؉jf_{{{{_ubm>z?l]v.o9ؿ=۰ҳoy|yxpb=gh{koyv`fxmdu;y>*ybly0=(1# 0d.ъp73*61mty:is[=hmg<Үvduvwģ[s0huҽby:nwm:?bi՗Ęv94-c l 3uj(\pvÓ8tyb˖$py@ rjd a tb\albĞwyj~wrmhddºǨkh|+yagvl\w}{xxsb}}{|z|ab%3pū}{{`x_~toiztyv8t=Őzu`mahklxqwxz|oz%bw9<-udh{koyvj`fsios"u7*ya2`w|z}y{fӟݚ0Қϡ{cnl}l{dpxhtvhn 7tv}}}gl-%tbr8gqwĭx脆 $dzije;ă9 $fl}q8$Ր?oop؉opouuu{_}~~.6z?wsdc@zn7?y֛wqz|oeoyqr{f8$gumwxyŔpz|oؤžЋk}z}9o~urgmi_newx$wswroz{y(wxsrxkoxҌІyx[meaoklnxi…slxwy=awfvvwu|huzh:*b^xwgzy|}ku}țeeh{ig7i3szvɼ*y:w lx]gon{{p{lyҋvcpf4n*tws.k@bpdd&yv8tl.ŏ]xsvs*wbi-¸uxnjmndpkwxz|o]򔫔qidtqs@fxmg=cpf{koyvm`fzbcrv7}vj:fƝ̖k:sm΋'okm9\dkyh{koyv`ftmbzy޵dgwz[yltsttttf3\ s4pm@+@*ii^|ontۋ: c dc~}fԷԢ䆱wʛ~nf̨pooqdf{ $zz!kkjnnm ${pvrl{tv@"hcuy~ $g_c7!{nwwwvwv ${ly5kjjo@xxxvvu ${$m% ) $#,+- $wˋ싞q{ryz}| $՛p}—~Ûueacm1f{6Τfgflgl ${_}~(6xxr{ ${_6ӓhihiii ${dx}e>>Хfgflkl ${_}~~.6z?wsvj>jzqqtvnzzeitr{w $uhpȱq2yq $tzzug69r;۽~}}}~xyx ${pjk/)?]iХfgflkl ${_}~~.6z?ws=}ve:<ɝɖxӓ;қ{fhvud<qnַЦaow)g\w=@\wibuvyic%'h񸴛7 c>"g$п[$>=:6awç $ir3wdl`l&{Ԫcy}{eq rxyf`  endstream endobj 42 0 obj << /fontfile3 41 0 r /stemh 0 /capheight 622 /type/fontdescriptor /descent -254 /flags 98 /fontname/vhfirm+usherwood-bookitalic /xheight 694 /ascent 684 /fontbbox[-187 -307 972 849] /italicangle -12 /stemv 58 >> endobj 43 0 obj << /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 315 259 0 0 519 0 519 0 519 0 519 0 519 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 630 574 556 667 556 0 0 667 296 296 630 519 0 0 0 574 0 630 519 556 0 0 907 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 499 500 426 500 444 315 481 519 278 0 0 259 796 537 500 519 481 389 426 315 519 463 722 519 481 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 444 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 963 0 0 0 259] /lastchar 213 /fontdescriptor 42 0 r /basefont/vhfirm+usherwood-bookitalic /name/f12 /firstchar 32 /encoding 40 0 r /subtype/type1 /type/font >> endobj 44 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 58/colon 65/a 67/c 83/s 97/a/b/c/d/e 108/l 110/n/o 114/r/s/t 119/w] /type/encoding >> endobj 45 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 2231 /length1 2231 >> stream dpwyas+usherwood-bold@/   "ecopyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bolditc usherwood"oesfx4ubcmt$pdd ~b>)nau``tezxxsqgk $tufiiihhh $kt{zr$sluh $:dzz $vfĘ]rmv~ $c|\f,5gfsomkliookt3 @av?ywbykʒmeogreku5bpmq)(+ ܸyyqb/nb2@_˼ck,w $@ȼᶛdȎ=`dex&vxylxzz\kx{buzzħp^tg8vey,w:zģtq[*orucalʣ?y|v$w|ptʒmeogreku5~}ze|r*4=@b_kd Ҵp+ [33>x̫wbq˒meogrekt3@avk $vty`]NJwfm~~zl"ej3@Ƌ%ahow%z˱~gv]uvjaإnvwyeɃw)stpf&<%3b\oȁzt_lt$uqb -yy//""-//-ܵ@a@::a=yat{au|dnc0tبhil̄{{vp,$(+y(ynggnnggn`nggnnggnyf`  endstream endobj 46 0 obj << /fontfile3 45 0 r /stemh 0 /capheight 622 /type/fontdescriptor /descent -254 /flags 262178 /fontname/dpwyas+usherwood-bold /xheight 694 /ascent 684 /fontbbox[-155 -300 1092 866] /italicangle 0 /stemv 108 >> endobj 47 0 obj << /widths[296 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 296 0 0 0 0 0 0 667 0 630 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 574 481 574 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 296 0 611 556 0 0 389 426 352 0 0 778] /lastchar 119 /fontdescriptor 46 0 r /basefont/dpwyas+usherwood-bold /name/f13 /firstchar 32 /encoding 44 0 r /subtype/type1 /type/font >> endobj 48 0 obj << /kids[49 0 r 50 0 r 51 0 r 52 0 r 53 0 r 54 0 r] /type/pages /count 6 /parent 55 0 r >> endobj 49 0 obj << /parent 48 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 2 0 r /type/page >> endobj 50 0 obj << /parent 48 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 3 0 r /type/page >> endobj 51 0 obj << /parent 48 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 4 0 r /type/page >> endobj 52 0 obj << /parent 48 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 5 0 r /type/page >> endobj 53 0 obj << /parent 48 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 6 0 r /type/page >> endobj 54 0 obj << /parent 48 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 7 0 r /type/page >> endobj 56 0 obj << /kids[57 0 r 58 0 r 59 0 r 60 0 r 61 0 r 62 0 r] /type/pages /count 6 /parent 55 0 r >> endobj 57 0 obj << /parent 56 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 8 0 r /type/page >> endobj 58 0 obj << /parent 56 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 9 0 r /type/page >> endobj 59 0 obj << /parent 56 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 10 0 r /type/page >> endobj 60 0 obj << /parent 56 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 11 0 r /type/page >> endobj 61 0 obj << /parent 56 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 12 0 r /type/page >> endobj 62 0 obj << /parent 56 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 13 0 r /type/page >> endobj 63 0 obj << /kids[64 0 r] /type/pages /count 1 /parent 55 0 r >> endobj 64 0 obj << /parent 63 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 14 0 r /type/page >> endobj 55 0 obj << /type/pages /kids[48 0 r 56 0 r 63 0 r] /count 13 >> endobj 65 0 obj << /pagelabels 15 0 r /type/catalog /pages 55 0 r >> endobj 66 0 obj << /creationdate(20091021134748) /producer(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5) /xpressprivate(%%documentprocesscolors:\n%%endcomments) /title /creator(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5) >> endobj xref 0 67 0000000000 65535 f 0000000015 00000 n 0000000059 00000 n 0000005482 00000 n 0000013768 00000 n 0000021142 00000 n 0000027903 00000 n 0000034785 00000 n 0000041620 00000 n 0000049565 00000 n 0000056522 00000 n 0000063297 00000 n 0000070131 00000 n 0000076849 00000 n 0000084805 00000 n 0000096528 00000 n 0000096573 00000 n 0000096878 00000 n 0000102558 00000 n 0000102780 00000 n 0000103410 00000 n 0000103540 00000 n 0000105566 00000 n 0000105800 00000 n 0000106150 00000 n 0000106538 00000 n 0000112954 00000 n 0000113184 00000 n 0000113822 00000 n 0000114001 00000 n 0000116784 00000 n 0000117006 00000 n 0000117440 00000 n 0000117935 00000 n 0000128519 00000 n 0000128739 00000 n 0000129438 00000 n 0000129529 00000 n 0000129757 00000 n 0000129979 00000 n 0000130150 00000 n 0000130446 00000 n 0000137379 00000 n 0000137607 00000 n 0000138246 00000 n 0000138404 00000 n 0000140718 00000 n 0000140944 00000 n 0000141321 00000 n 0000141428 00000 n 0000141642 00000 n 0000141816 00000 n 0000142001 00000 n 0000142186 00000 n 0000142371 00000 n 0000144046 00000 n 0000142556 00000 n 0000142663 00000 n 0000142848 00000 n 0000143033 00000 n 0000143219 00000 n 0000143405 00000 n 0000143591 00000 n 0000143788 00000 n 0000143860 00000 n 0000144118 00000 n 0000144187 00000 n trailer << /size 67 /root 65 0 r /info 66 0 r /id[<156d6b8514a6117154da62c4ead67280><156d6b8514a6117154da62c4ead67280>] >> startxref 144477 %%eof