%pdf-1.3 % 1 0 obj << /opm 1 /type/extgstate >> endobj 2 0 obj << /length 5474 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 13.5 0 0 13.5 37 585.8022 tm 0 g (finding the right kind of awe and wonder: the)tj 0 -1.33333 td (metaphysical potential of religion to ground an)tj t* (environmental ethic)tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 9 0 0 9 37 528.8022 tm 0 g (martin ashley, university of the west of england, united kingdom)tj et q q bt /f1 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 504.8022 tm 0 g [(a)19(bstr)19(act)]tj et q q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 492.8022 tm 0 g [(this paper ar)19(gues that an anthr)18(opocentric f)37(allacy permeates thinking with-)]tj 0 -1.26316 td [(in both technological and ecological appr)19(oaches t)18(o envir)19(onment)18(alism. in)]tj t* [(consequence)37(, sust)18(ainable de)19(v)19(elopment is an incoher)18(ent concept thr)19(ough the)]tj t* [(w)19(eakness o)19(f its anthr)18(opocentric ethical gr)19(ounding. using the judaeo-)]tj t* [(christian tr)19(adition as an e)18(x)19(ample)37(, this paper e)18(x)19(amines the degr)19(ee t)19(o which)]tj t* [(r)19(eligion can be an alternativ)19(e means o)18(f gr)19(ounding an envir)19(onment)18(al ethic)]tj t* [(outside anthr)19(opocentrism. it concludes that, though r)18(eligion can also be)]tj t* [(corrupted b)19(y anthr)18(opocentrism, insights gained thr)19(ough theology ought not)]tj t* [(t)19(o be wholly dismissed. )]tj et q q bt /f1 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 372.8022 tm 0 g (r\216sum\216)tj et q q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 360.8022 tm 0 g [(cet article soutient qu\325un sophisme anthr)19(opocentrique p\216n\217tr)18(e la pens\216e)]tj 0 -1.26316 td (des deux appr)tj 5.906 0 td (oches technologique et \216cologique \210 l\325envir)tj 17.97461 0 td (onnement)tj 4.23999 0 td (alisme)tj 2.70216 0 td (.)tj -30.82276 -1.26317 td (en cons\216quence)tj 6.64721 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51762 0 td 0 tc (le d\216v)tj 2.40524 0 td [(eloppement dur)19(able est un concept incoh\216r)18(ent d\236 \210 la)]tj -9.57006 -1.26316 td [(f)37(aiblesse de son f)37(ondement \216thique anthr)18(opocentrique)37(. p)37(ar l\325e)18(x)19(emple du)]tj t* (jud\216o-christianisme)tj 8.36889 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51755 0 td 0 tc (ce te)tj 1.9053 0 td (xte \216tudie \210 quel degr\216 la r)tj 11.23388 0 td (eligion peut \220tr)tj 6.42359 0 td -0.0002 tc (e)tj 0.70265 0 td 0 tc (une)tj -29.15187 -1.26317 td (solution de r)tj 5.35083 0 td [(echange pour \216t)19(ablir une \216thique de l\325envir)18(onnement en dehor)19(s)]tj -5.35083 -1.26316 td [(de l\325anthr)19(opocentrisme)36(. il conclut que m\220me si la r)19(eligion peut aussi \220tr)19(e)]tj 0 -1.26315 td (corr)tj 1.77735 0 td (ompue par l\325anthr)tj 7.70141 0 td (opocentrisme)tj 5.70288 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51764 0 td 0 tc (la lar)tj 2.18329 0 td (geur de vue ainsi atteinte par la)tj -17.88257 -1.26317 td (th\216ologie ne peut \220tr)tj 8.6997 0 td -0.0002 tc (e)tj 0.70263 0 td 0 tc [(compl\217tement \216cart\216e)37(.)]tj -9.40233 -2.52632 td (k)tj 0.59302 0 td (e)tj 0.42504 0 td (yw)tj 1.25879 0 td -0.0004 tc (or)tj 0.92578 0 td 0 tc (ds:)tj et q q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 95.7155 240.8022 tm 0 g (r)tj 0.37013 0 td (eligion; anthr)tj 5.87036 0 td (opocentrism; theology; envir)tj 12.66601 0 td (onment)tj 3.42651 0 td (alism;)tj -26.9978 -1.26317 td [(sust)19(ainability; envir)18(onment)19(al education )]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 170.5725 195.2022 tm 0 g (introduction)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 55 172.4022 tm 0 g -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(p)56(erhaps most not)18(ably since the seminal publication of aldo l)19(eopold\325)37(s land)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(ethic \(l)19(eopold, 1949\), envir)18(onment)19(alism has struggled t)19(o est)18(ablish some f)19(orm)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw (of eco or biocentric ethical gr)tj 12.44898 0 td (ounding which will r)tj 8.70012 0 td [(egulate human beha)19(viour)110(.)]tj -21.1491 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.028 tw [(this per)19(ceiv)18(ed need t)19(o r)19(egulate human beha)18(viour giv)19(es envir)19(onment)18(alism)]tj 0 -1.19999 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(common cause with the w)19(orld\325)36(s major r)19(eligious f)19(aiths)37(. envir)18(onment)19(alism and)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (orthodo)tj 3.3884 0 td -0.0002 tc (x)tj 0.8186 0 td (r)tj 0.3512 0 td 0 tc 0.004 tw (eligion ma)tj 4.52137 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (y)tj 0.80081 0 td 0 tc (not necessarily agr)tj 8.11729 0.00001 td [(ee on the priorities r)19(egar)18(ding the)]tj -17.9977 -1.2 td (r)tj 0.3255 0 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw (egulation of human beha)tj 10.24287 0.00001 td 0 tw (viour)tj 1.96359 0.00001 td -0.0257 tc (,)tj 0.51628 0 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw (but the)tj 2.87005 0.00001 td (y)tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 203.7542 100.4023 tm 0 g -0.024 tc (do)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 215.9159 100.4023 tm 0 g -0.026 tc (agr)tj 1.2743 0.00001 td 0.012 tw (ee that human beha)tj 8.24241 0.00001 td (viour needs)tj -27.4083 -1.2 td 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(t)19(o be r)18(egulated. in e)19(x)19(amining the potential f)18(or a r)19(eligious gr)19(ounding of)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (envir)tj 2.1838 0 td (onment)tj 3.3699 0 td 0.012 tw (al ethics)tj 3.51177 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.56729 0 td 0 tc (the question that is addr)tj 10.56453 0.00001 td (essed is that of whether the)tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm 0 g (canadian journal of environmental education, 11, 2006)tj et 1 g 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (88)tj /f6 1 tf 1 0 0 1 -1000 1648 tm 1 g -0.25 tc ( )tj et q endstream endobj 3 0 obj << /length 5765 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(enlightenment pr)19(oject of human perfectibility is att)18(ainable)56(. the r)19(eligious vie)19(w-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(point, at least of the semitic or abr)19(ahamic f)18(a)1(i)1(t)1(h)1(s)1( )1(\()1(j)1(u)1(d)1(a)1(i)1(s)1(m)1(,)1( )1(c)1(h)1(r)1(i)1(s)1(t)1(i)1(a)1(n)1(i)1(t)1(y)112(,)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw (and islam\), is that it is not. )tj 1.8 -1.20001 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(the discussion in this paper centr)19(es ar)18(ound what i shall call the )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 364.5981 551.9617 tm 0 g -0.003 tc [(anthr)19(o)-1(-)]tj -29.15981 -1.2 td -0.015 tc 0.002 tw [(pocentric f)19(allacy)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 138.5825 539.9617 tm 0 g -0.0161 tc (.)tj 0.5259 0 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(anthr)19(opocentrism means t)18(o place human inter)19(ests and con-)]tj -7.08415 -1.2 td -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(cerns at the centr)19(e of the r)18(elationship betw)19(een people and their envir)19(onment.)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc -0.014 tw [(mor)19(e simply and str)18(ongly)111(, w)18(e might e)19(xpr)19(ess anthr)18(opocentrism as meaning)]tj 0 -1.19999 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(human inter)19(ests ar)18(e the ultimate concern of human beings)37(. the meaning of)]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 491.9616 tm 0 g -0.023 tc 0.01 tw [(anthr)19(opocentric f)18(allacy)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 165.9572 491.9616 tm 0 g -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(is that human beings imagine themselv)19(es not t)19(o be part)]tj -9.29572 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(of natur)19(e\321t)18(o the e)19(xtent that some writer)19(s ha)18(v)19(e e)19(v)18(en suggested that natur)19(e)56(,)]tj t* 0 tc 0.07 tw [(along with nietzsche\325)37(s god, has been ended thr)18(ough human thought and)]tj t* 0.003 tw [(action (mckibben, 1989). the discussion of r)19(eligion in this paper is limited)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(t)19(o the w)18(estern judaeo-christian tr)19(adition, which is one of a number of f)19(aith)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(sy)18(stems that challenge anthr)19(opocentrism. )]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 105.8618 398.3616 tm 0 g (science and religion as the friends of environmentalism)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 91 375.5616 tm 0 g -0.014 tw [(in an earlier paper)111(, i ar)18(gued that science is an unr)19(eliable friend t)19(o envi-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0.007 tc 0.131 tw [(r)18(onment)19(alism \(ashle)19(y)110(, 2000\). the essence of this ar)19(gument is f)19(amiliar:)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(though science is a \322friend\323 in that it has alerted us t)19(o most of the thr)19(eats t)18(o)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.003 tw (the w)tj 2.33036 0 td [(orld\325)37(s envir)18(onment, it is not a r)19(eliable friend because its allegiance is t)19(o)]tj -2.33036 -1.20001 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(the dispassionate pur)19(suit of the corr)18(espondence betw)19(een observ)19(ation and a)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.002 tw [(postulated e)19(xternal r)18(eality)111(. the epistemic v)19(alues of ph)19(y)19(sical science \(k)36(uhn,)]tj t* -0.011 tw (1996\) ar)tj 3.63721 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.76656 0 td 0 tc [(indiffer)19(ent t)18(o human v)19(alues and conceptualiz)19(ations of the w)18(orld.)]tj -4.40377 -1.2 td -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(thoughtful scholar)19(s such as bonnett (2004) ha)19(v)18(e pr)19(oduced w)18(ell-r)19(easoned ar)19(gu-)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(ments that attempt t)19(o sho)18(w that the deficit model of public under)19(st)18(anding of)]tj t* -0.014 tc 0 tw [(science is f)19(at)18(ally fla)19(w)19(ed. p)55(ost-enlightenment r)19(eason and r)19(ationality alone will)]tj t* 0 tc -0.004 tw [(ne)19(v)19(er change human beha)18(viour t)19(o)19(w)19(ar)19(ds the envir)18(onment. a possible hope)]tj t* -0.028 tc 0.014 tw [(f)19(or r)18(eligion is that if only the \322bad\323 elements of e)19(xtr)19(eme fundament)18(alism could)]tj t* 0 tc -0.013 tw [(be r)19(egulated, w)18(e might ha)19(v)19(e \322good\323 r)19(eligion that commits us all t)18(o an ethic)]tj t* 0.006 tw [(of caring f)19(or natur)18(e)56(. the ar)19(guments t)19(o be de)18(v)19(eloped do not support such a)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(na\225v)19(e hope)56(, but do indicate possible w)18(a)19(y)20(s in which r)18(eligious insights can add)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(t)19(o our r)19(epert)18(oir)19(e of possible r)19(esponses t)18(o the challenge of educating ne)19(w gen-)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(er)19(ations about their r)18(elationship with the earth.)]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 122.0879 149.9616 tm 0 g (the anthropocentric fallacy as ultimate concern)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 91 127.1616 tm 0 g -0.009 tw (the term )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 133.2368 127.1616 tm 0 g -0.008 tw (ultimate concern)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 205.2525 127.1616 tm 0 g -0.009 tw [(w)19(as de)19(vised b)18(y the theologian p)56(aul tillich in)]tj -13.2253 -1.2 td -0.013 tw [(his seminal discussions of f)19(aith (scott-smith, 2003). ultimate concern is an)]tj t* -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(intense desir)19(e f)18(or the success of the cause that claims ultimate allegiance)56(, t)18(ot)19(al)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(surr)19(ender t)18(o that cause)56(, \322ultimate fulfillment\323 f)19(or the f)19(aithful, and e)18(x)19(clusion)]tj t* -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(of the unf)19(aithful \(connelly)111(, 200)55(1\). the significance of anthr)19(opocentrism is that)]tj t* 0.019 tc 0.12 tw [(f)19(or the man)18(y people who ha)19(v)18(e lost t)19(ouch with a r)19(eligious dimension, )]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 246.2002 33.8348 tm 0 g (finding the right kind of awe and wonder)tj et 1 g 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3659 33.8708 tm 0 g (89)tj et q endstream endobj 4 0 obj << /length 6345 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 g 0.13 tw [(self-inter)19(est and the flourishing of the society in which the)18(y liv)19(e ar)19(e the)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(ultimate concern. it has t)19(o be said, t)18(oo, that r)19(eligious people ar)19(e not immune)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.123 tw [(t)19(o such a char)19(ge)55(. the anthr)19(opocentric f)19(allac)19(y is the hegemonic mode of)]tj t* 0.011 tw [(thinking. its significance is that the imagined det)19(achment of humans fr)18(om)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.134 tw [(natur)19(e allo)18(w)19(s thinking that puts human self-inter)19(est abo)19(v)19(e all else t)18(o be)]tj t* 0.022 tc 0.24 tw [(pr)19(ofligate)55(, unquestioned, and disguised b)19(y a comf)19(orting rhet)18(oric of)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw [(sust)19(ainable de)18(v)19(elopment.)]tj 1.8 -1.19999 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(some envir)19(onment)18(al educat)19(or)19(s ha)18(v)19(e embr)19(aced sust)18(ainable de)19(v)19(elop-)]tj -1.8 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.004 tw [(ment as r)19(ele)18(v)19(ant t)19(o their aims and v)19(alues)36(, and a means of maint)19(aining the)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.06 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(alist agenda within the political mainstr)19(eam. other)19(s feel that)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(unqualified capitulation t)19(o the kind of sust)18(ainable de)19(v)19(elopment that appear)19(s)]tj t* 0 tc 0.029 tw [(incr)19(easingly t)18(o be on offer fr)19(om u.s.-influenced w)19(estern go)18(v)19(ernments can)]tj t* 0.011 tc 0.128 tw [(amount t)19(o a betr)18(a)19(y)19(al of principles)37(. cert)18(ainly)111(, apologists such as p)56(orritt)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [((2005) hold out f)19(or optimistic notions such as de)19(v)18(elopment as gr)19(o)18(wth in fr)19(ee-)]tj t* 0.022 tc 0.117 tw [(dom or human happiness r)19(ather than economic e)18(xploit)19(ation of finite)]tj t* 0 tc 0.139 tw [(r)19(esour)19(ces or the o)18(v)19(er)19(str)18(essing of natur)19(al r)19(egener)18(ation sy)19(stems)37(. this is a)]tj t* 0.008 tw [(vie)19(w with which the pr)18(esent author has some sympath)19(y)111(. ho)19(w)19(e)18(v)19(er)111(, it is dif-)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(ficult t)19(o be optimistic about such aspir)18(ations)37(, giv)18(e)1(n the d)-1(egr)19(ee t)19(o which con-)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(sumerism as the r)19(oute t)18(o happiness has embr)19(aced the souls of w)18(estern y)19(outh)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(\(mer)19(cer)110(, 2006\). hence)56(, ther)19(e ma)19(y be a case f)18(or at least considering whether)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(r)19(eligion can offer a serious and viable challenge t)19(o destructiv)18(e consumerism)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (within envir)tj 5.18286 0 td (onment)tj 3.36987 0 td (al education. )tj -6.75273 -1.20001 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(bonnett (2002) ar)19(gues with some eloquence that the massiv)18(e consensus)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(ar)19(ound sust)18(ainable de)19(v)19(elopment is r)18(e)19(v)18(ealed as so much empty uplift once it)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw (is r)tj 1.28737 0 td 0 tw (ealiz)tj 1.92349 0 td -0.01 tw (ed that a semantic trick is emplo)tj 13.95443 0 td [(y)19(ed t)19(o hide the impossibility of r)18(ec-)]tj -17.16529 -1.20001 td 0.01 tc 0.129 tw [(onciling sust)19(ainability with anthr)19(op)-1(ocentrism. sust)19(ainable de)19(v)19(elopment)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.007 tw [(might be possible w)19(er)18(e a significantly mor)19(e natur)19(e-centr)18(ed ethic t)19(o r)19(eplace)]tj -0.0101 tc (an)' 1.31794 0 td -0.01 tc 0 tw (anthr)tj 2.24598 0 td -0.004 tw (opocentric one)tj 6.26208 0 td -0.0101 tc (,)tj 0.53183 0 td -0.01 tc [(but this is unlik)19(ely t)18(o occur pr)19(esently because of the)]tj -10.35783 -1.20001 td 0 tc [(denial engender)19(ed b)18(y the anthr)19(opocentric f)19(allac)19(y)111(. )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 252.8972 251.9616 tm 0 g [(r)19(eally)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 281.1623 251.9616 tm 0 g -0.004 tw [(t)19(o put natur)19(e fir)18(st,)]tj -24.41623 -1.2 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(t)19(o f)18(or)19(go )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 76.0989 239.9616 tm 0 g 0.003 tc (all)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 90.5197 239.9616 tm 0 g 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(the pleasur)19(es of high-ener)19(gy w)18(estern materialism \(including)]tj -5.35197 -1.2 td 0.007 tc 0.132 tw (flights t)tj 3.37871 0 td 0.0067 tc (o)tj 0.96046 0 td 0.007 tc 0 tw (eco-t)tj 2.10775 0 td 0.132 tw [(ourist destinations\), r)19(equir)18(es an ascetic of which fe)19(w ar)19(e)]tj -6.44692 -1.20001 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(capable)56(. the enlightenment belief that it is possible t)19(o achie)18(v)19(e a perfect bal-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(ance betw)19(een ecology and consumption thr)18(ough human intelligence means)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (that the high-risk str)tj 8.70361 0 td [(ategy of a technological fix is all but ine)19(vit)18(able)56(. )]tj -6.90361 -1.2 td 0.008 tc 0.131 tw [(quite often, the liter)19(atur)18(e on envir)19(onment)19(alism and envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.008 tw (education t)tj 4.80578 0 td [(alks of anthr)19(opocentrism as though it w)18(er)19(e some kind of polari-)]tj -4.80578 -1.2 td -0.004 tw [(ty)111(, at the other end of which is t)18(o be f)19(ound eco or biocentrism \(i.e)56(., placing)]tj t* 0.002 tw [(\322natur)19(e\323 at the centr)18(e of concern\). the suggestion, long cherished b)19(y envi-)]tj t* 0.028 tw [(r)19(onment)19(alists)36(, is that some kind of ethical education will per)19(suade gr)19(eater)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(number)19(s t)18(o)19(w)19(ar)19(ds the ecocentric end of the spectrum (kirkman, 2002). this)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(i)1(s)1( )1(e)20(x)1(t)1(r)19(emely misleading as it suggests an appr)19(o)19(ximately equal distribution of)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(ethical attitudes t)19(o the envir)18(onment that is r)19(eadily amenable t)19(o change)56(. the)]tj t* -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(r)18(eality is that anthr)19(opocentricism is lik)19(ely t)19(o be encounter)18(ed a gr)19(eat deal mor)19(e)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(fr)19(equently than ecocentrism, and is e)18(xtr)19(emely r)19(esist)18(ant t)19(o change)56(. )]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm 0 g (martin ashley)tj et 1 g 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (90)tj et q endstream endobj 5 0 obj << /length 6958 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 91 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(the anthr)19(opocentric f)18(allac)19(y has an intricate r)19(elationship with postmod-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td [(ern philosoph)19(y)110(, which at least partly accounts f)19(or the fr)19(equenc)18(y with which)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(e)19(xternalities ar)19(e conceiv)18(ed as r)19(elativ)19(e t)18(o, or e)19(v)19(en solely the pr)19(oduct of,)]tj t* -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(human thought. it is indeed a consequence of anthr)19(opocentric thinking t)18(o sug-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(gest that natur)19(e is not r)18(eal, but a social construction. as bonnett e)19(xplains)37(, this)]tj t* 0 tc 0.069 tw [(is partly true (bonnett, 2004). the human conception of natur)19(e is indeed)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.002 tc 0.136 tw [(socially constructed, and such social constructions ar)19(e)-1( )-1(l)-1(e)-1(g)-1(i)-1(t)-1(i)-1(m)-1(a)-1(t)-1(e)-1(l)-1(y)-1( )-1(b)-1(o)-1(t)-1(h)]tj 0 -1.19999 td 0 tc 0.08 tw [(the t)19(ar)18(get and means of critiquing the w)19(a)19(y human beings act within and)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(t)19(o)18(w)19(ar)19(ds their envir)19(onments)36(. man)19(y marxist, postmodernist, poststructur)19(alist,)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(and ecofeminist philosopher)19(s ha)18(v)19(e been able t)19(o demonstr)19(ate this)37(. such a pr)18(e)1(-)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(occupation with human aff)19(air)18(s)38(,)1( )1(h)1(o)19(w)20(e)19(v)19(er)111(,)1( )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 247.835 467.9616 tm 0 g -0.006 tc (is)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 257.3925 467.9616 tm 0 g -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(b)19(y definition an anthr)19(opocentric)]tj -18.43925 -1.2 td -0.027 tc 0.013 tw [(activity)111(. the only serious challenges t)18(o such thinking come fr)19(om either a r)19(ecog-)]tj t* 0 tc -0.014 tw [(nition that ther)19(e is a primor)18(dial and )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 229.0024 443.9616 tm 0 g [(r)19(eal)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 247.3523 443.9616 tm 0 g -0.014 tw [(natur)19(e that is described b)18(y a ph)19(y)19(s-)]tj -17.43523 -1.2 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(ical science mor)19(e fundament)18(al than an)19(y social science)56(, or the possibility that)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(cr)19(eation is the w)18(ork of a divine being. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(t)80(r)18(apped in cultur)19(al r)18(elativism, an ecofeminist vie)19(w of natur)19(e)55(, f)19(or e)18(x)19(am-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(ple)56(, cannot rise abo)18(v)19(e anthr)19(opocentric concerns)36(. ther)19(e is a str)19(ong ar)18(gument)]tj t* 0 tc 0.138 tw [(within ecofeminism that the baconian pr)19(oject t)19(o subdue na)-1(tur)19(e thr)19(ough)]tj t* 0.015 tc 0.124 tw [(science has objectified natur)19(e and led t)18(o)1( )1(e)20(x)1(p)1(l)1(o)1(i)1(t)20(ation and degr)18(adation)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(\(griffin, 1978; mer)19(chant, 1996; mies & shiv)19(a, 1993; r)18(adf)19(or)18(d-r)19(euther)111(, 1992\).)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(i)1(t)1( )1(i)1(s)1( )1(d)1(i)1(f)1(f)1(i)1(c)1(u)1(l)1(t)1( )1(t)20(o)1( )1(s)1(e)1(e)56(,)1( )1(h)1(o)20(w)19(e)20(v)19(er)111(, the means thr)18(ough which feminist thought can)]tj t* -0.022 tc 0.008 tw (rise t)tj 2.00302 0 td -0.0224 tc (o)tj 0.77861 0 td -0.022 tc (command a vie)tj 6.42993 0 td (wpoint equiv)tj 5.35066 0 td (alent t)tj 2.55616 0 td -0.0224 tc (o)tj 0.77862 0 td -0.022 tc [(that claimed b)19(y adher)18(ents t)19(o belief)]tj -17.897 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.002 tw [(in a superhuman deity)111(. p)55(ostmodernism w)19(ould sur)19(ely see feminism as only)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.0001 tc (a)tj 0.76635 0 td 0 tc -0.011 tw [(cultur)19(ally r)18(elativist vie)19(w which men, if the)19(y feel so inclined, ar)18(e fully enti-)]tj -0.76635 -1.2 td -0.013 tw (tled t)tj 2.17271 0 td -0.0002 tc (o)tj 0.80149 0 td (r)tj 0.3512 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (efute)tj 2.11084 0 td -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.54269 0 td 0 tc -0.013 tw [(the cultur)19(al r)18(elativism of postmodern and associated anthr)19(o-)]tj -5.97893 -1.20001 td -0.014 tc 0 tw [(pocentric f)19(orms of philosoph)18(y)112(, then, ma)18(y need t)19(o t)19(ak)18(e its place alongside sci-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc [(ence as unr)19(eliable friends t)18(o envir)19(onment)19(alism. )]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 116.9692 242.3616 tm 0 g (judaeo-christianity and the anthropocentric fallacy)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 91 219.5616 tm 0 g 0.018 tw [(r)19(easoning under the anthr)19(opocentric f)18(allac)19(y often has a pr)19(oblem with)]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 207.5616 tm 0 g -0.008 tc (human)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 103.9239 207.5616 tm 0 g -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(natur)19(e)55(. as ste)19(v)19(en pink)18(er has ar)19(gued with gr)19(o)18(wing influence)56(, much of)]tj -3.09239 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.014 tw [(the cultur)19(ally r)18(elativist philosoph)19(y of the 20)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 5 0 0 5 259.1604 198.9679 tm 0 g (th)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 266.1527 195.5616 tm 0 g -0.014 tw [(century has been gr)19(ounded in)]tj -19.31527 -1.2 td 0.037 tw [(an ideology of denial with r)19(egar)18(d t)19(o human natur)19(e \(pink)18(er)111(, 2002\). on this)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw (point, the tr)tj 5.07204 0 td [(aditions of the har)19(d sciences and judaeo-christianity find some)]tj -5.07204 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw (common gr)tj 4.92914 0 td [(ound: both r)19(ecogniz)18(e that ther)19(e )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 257.7852 159.5616 tm 0 g -0.0091 tc (is)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 267.2874 159.5616 tm 0 g -0.009 tc -0.005 tw (such a thing as human natur)tj 12.05872 0 td -0.065 tc 0 tw (e.)tj -31.48746 -1.2 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(f)56(or science)56(, human natur)18(e is the pr)19(oduct of millions of y)19(ear)19(s of e)18(v)19(olution and)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (ma)tj 1.37012 0.00001 td -0.0003 tc (y)tj 0.80726 0 td (y)tj 0.5002 0.00001 td 0 tc 0.011 tw (et turn out t)tj 5.16138 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.8256 0 td 0 tc (be a deterministic pr)tj 9.01239 0.00001 td [(ocess r)19(educible t)18(o molecular le)19(v)19(el)]tj -17.67695 -1.20002 td 0 tw [(e)19(xplanations)37(. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.012 tw [(christianity posits human natur)19(e as f)18(allen, that is t)19(o sa)19(y fundament)18(ally)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.009 tw (disposed t)tj 4.3796 0 td -0.0002 tc (o)tj 0.8053 0 td 0 tc (sin thr)tj 2.74894 0.00001 td (ough the primor)tj 6.99887 0.00001 td (dial disobedience of a)tj 9.47168 0.00001 td [(dam and ev)19(e)56(. in a)]tj -24.4044 -1.2 td 0.009 tw [(contempor)19(ary e)18(xposition, hought)19(on (1994) describes car)19(eless e)18(xploit)19(ation)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(of the envir)19(onment as a sin. thus the deterministic e)19(v)18(olution of science and)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 246.2002 33.8348 tm 0 g (finding the right kind of awe and wonder)tj et 1 g 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3659 33.8708 tm 0 g (91)tj et q endstream endobj 6 0 obj << /length 6649 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 g 0.034 tw [(the christian doctrine of original sin can both account f)19(or the tendenc)18(y of)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(human beings t)19(o destr)18(o)19(y the envir)19(onments that sust)19(ain them. the question)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(that must concern us her)19(e is not the na\225v)18(e one of which is the truer account,)]tj t* 0 tc 0.055 tw [(but the mor)19(e pr)18(essing one of the degr)19(ee t)19(o which each can support alter-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tw [(nativ)19(es t)18(o anthr)19(opocentrism. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.023 tw [(the curious per)19(sistence and r)18(esur)19(gence of r)19(eligion in a w)18(orld that had)]tj -1.8 -1.20001 td 0.113 tw [(imagined enlightenment thinking w)19(ould dispel super)18(stition offer)19(s a clue)56(.)]tj 0 -1.19999 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(human beings\321finding themselv)19(es thr)18(eatened b)19(y a )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 256.3569 503.9616 tm 0 g -0.016 tc [(r)19(eal)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 274.0704 503.9616 tm 0 g -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(natur)19(e that commits)]tj -23.70704 -1.20001 td 0 tc -0.012 tw [(atr)19(ocities \(an anthr)18(opocentric concept\) such as tsunamis)37(, earthquak)19(es)36(, and)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(category 5 hurricanes\321r)19(equir)18(e a surviv)19(al mechanism in which concepts such)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(as hope and meaning need t)19(o be e)18(xplor)19(ed and under)19(s)1(t)19(ood. ph)19(y)19(sical science)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(does not do w)19(ell her)18(e)56(. it offer)18(s an e)19(xplanation based on r)19(andom indiffer)19(ence;)]tj t* 0 tc -0.014 tw (it tells us that )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 97.0063 443.9616 tm 0 g [(r)19(eal )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 115.1803 443.9616 tm 0 g -0.014 tw [(natur)19(e does not car)18(e about us)37(, and that our liv)19(es ha)19(v)18(e no)]tj -7.81803 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(meaning. f)56(or those able t)18(o accept this as an authentic positi)1(on, the situation)]tj t* -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(ma)19(y be in some w)18(a)19(y)20(s str)18(aightf)19(orw)18(ar)19(d. f)56(e)19(w)111(, it seems)37(, ar)18(e able t)19(o r)19(each such)]tj -0.0148 tc (a)' 0.7492 0 td -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(position of accept)19(ance and the consequences of its adv)19(ocac)18(y ar)19(e uncert)19(ain. )]tj 1.0508 -1.2 td [(r)19(eligion offer)19(s the hope of meaning and the accommodation of m)19(y)19(stery)110(.)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(t)80(r)19(aditions such as the judaeo-christian, mor)19(eo)18(v)19(er)111(, ar)19(e r)18(ooted in an ethic that)]tj t* 0 tc -0.007 tw [(denies anthr)19(opocentrism. if god is at the centr)18(e of things)37(, humankind can-)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(not be)56(. ther)18(e is a teleology of cr)19(eation and god is the author of it. this theo-)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(centric position pr)19(o)19(vides an alternativ)18(e account of the w)19(orth of natur)19(e)56(. it has)]tj 0 tc (v)' 0.47565 0 td -0.006 tc 0 tw (alue)tj 1.69973 0 td -0.0057 tc (,)tj 0.53631 0 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw (not as a commodity t)tj 9.0775 0 td -0.0057 tc (o)tj 0.79534 0 td -0.006 tc (be e)tj 1.78432 0 td [(xploited, as in anthr)19(opocentrism, nor as a)]tj -14.36885 -1.20001 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(self-r)19(egar)18(ding or)19(ganism, as in gaian ecocentrism \(de)19(v)18(all & sessions)37(, 1985\).)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(in theocentrism, natur)19(e has v)18(alue because god made it and \322sa)19(w that it w)19(as)]tj t* 0 tc 0.057 tw (good\323 \(genesis 1:3)tj 8.18694 0 td (1\). the judaic tr)tj 7.02222 0 td (adition has been built on the notion of)tj -15.20916 -1.20001 td 0.066 tw [(co)19(v)18(enant, a tw)19(o-w)19(a)18(y r)19(elationship betw)19(een god and humans)36(. the book of)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(g)1(e)1(n)1(e)1(s)1(i)1(s)1( )1(d)1(e)1(s)1(c)1(r)1(i)1(b)1(e)1(s)1( )1(h)1(o)20(w)1( )1(h)1(u)1(m)1(a)1(n)1(s)1( )1(w)19(e)1(r)20(e set abo)19(v)19(e all other animals thr)19(ough being)]tj t* -0.023 tc 0 tw (cr)tj 0.76812 0 td 0.009 tw (eated \322in the image of god,\323 with authority o)tj 18.5391 0 td [(v)19(er the r)18(est of cr)19(eation but ne)19(v-)]tj -19.30722 -1.20001 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(ertheless account)19(able t)18(o god. the pr)19(ecise natur)19(e of this \322dominion\323 has been)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.002 tw [(hotly contested. white\325)37(s ar)18(gument, that christianity has thr)19(ough the a)56(dam)]tj t* -0.02 tc 0.006 tw (and ev)tj 2.85081 0 td -0.0198 tc (e)tj 0.74416 0 td (st)tj 0.6828 0 td -0.02 tc [(ory e)19(v)18(olv)19(ed int)18(o the most anthr)19(opocentric r)19(eligion in the w)18(orld, has)]tj -4.27777 -1.20001 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(been particularly influential \(white)56(, 1994\). significantly)111(,)1( )1(t)1(h)1(o)1(u)1(g)1(h)1(,)1( )1(i)1(t)1( )1(i)1(s)1( )1(a)1(n)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(hist)19(orical r)18(ather than theological ar)19(gument. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw (apologists such as hodson (2000) suggest that such a vie)tj 23.35147 0 td -0.0239 tc (w)tj 0.99912 0 td -0.024 tc (does not seem)tj -26.15059 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.115 tw [(t)19(o fit with the notion of co)19(v)18(enant. the oper)19(ation of the co)19(v)18(enant that)1( is)]tj t* -0.023 tc 0.009 tw (described in old t)tj 7.4787 0 td [(est)19(ament scriptur)18(e)56(, which of cour)18(se long pr)19(edates an)19(y lar)19(ge-)]tj -7.4787 -1.2 td 0.022 tc 0.117 tw [(scale industrializ)19(ation, is hea)18(vily infused with land- and natur)19(e-based)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(met)19(aphor)18(s)37(. god\325)37(s displeasur)19(e with human unf)18(aithfulness w)19(as almost inv)19(ari)-1(-)]tj t* -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(ably e)19(xpr)18(essed thr)19(ough natur)19(al phenomena such as \322hailst)18(ones and st)19(orms)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(of fir)19(e\323 and pr)18(ophetic admonition that \322the land mourns and all who liv)19(e in)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(it w)19(aste a)18(w)19(a)18(y\323 (hosea 4:3). the st)19(ory that is t)19(old is pr)19(ecisely that of humans)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(bringing suffering on themselv)19(es thr)18(ough neglect of the co)19(v)19(enant: ecological)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(and natur)19(al disaster clearly being god\325)36(s agents of the suffering. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(it is not alw)19(a)18(y)19(s easy t)18(o separ)19(ate judaic and christian doctrine)55(, as the latter)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm 0 g (martin ashley)tj et 1 g 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (92)tj et q endstream endobj 7 0 obj << /length 7096 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g 0.059 tw [(has an intimate r)19(elationship with the f)18(ormer)111(. cert)19(ainly)111(, the point must be)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(conceded t)19(o white that man)18(y imperialistic)19(, w)19(estern christians ha)18(v)19(e beha)19(v)18(ed)]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 563.9617 tm 0 g -0.01 tc -0.003 tw (as though)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 115.0944 563.9617 tm 0 g -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(god had giv)19(en them divine license t)18(o e)19(x)19(er)19(cise a t)19(o)1(t)19(ally e)19(xploit)19(ativ)18(e)]tj -4.20944 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.033 tw [(dominion. the possibility)111(, ho)18(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)111(, is that such christians ma)18(y ha)19(v)19(e been)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(acting on the basis of the anthr)19(opocentric f)18(a)-1(l)-1(l)-1(a)-1(c)18(y)111(. it is necessary t)18(o e)19(x)18(a)-1(m)-1(i)-1(n)-1(e)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(ho)19(w this ma)18(y ha)19(v)19(e come about. )]tj 1.8 -1.20001 td 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(although the judaic scriptur)19(es ar)18(e based on co)19(v)19(enant, the)19(y ar)18(e also)]tj -1.8 -1.19999 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(based on a vie)19(w of god as a)18(w)19(esome)56(. it is quite clear that a)19(w)19(e)55(, her)19(e)55(, does not)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.002 tw [(r)19(efer t)19(o the sanitiz)18(ed \322)56(a)19(w)19(e and w)19(onder\323 in the accounts of \322spiritual de)18(v)19(el-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.014 tw [(opment\323 f)19(o)1(r)1( )156(childr)19(en of an)19(y)1( )1(f)19(aith or none\323 that emanate fr)19(om the human-)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(istic-phenomenology of the uk national curriculum \(ashle)18(y)111(, 2000\). it r)19(efer)19(s)]tj t* 0 tc 0.054 tw [(t)19(o the holiness of god that is intimately r)19(elated t)18(o the fear of god. this is)]tj t* -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(e)18(xpr)19(essed in psalm 96: \322bo)19(w y)18(our)19(selv)18(es t)19(o jeho)19(v)18(ah, in the honour of holiness:)]tj t* -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(be afr)19(aid of his pr)18(esence)56(, all the earth\323 (psalms 96:9). ther)19(e is little doubt that)]tj t* [(the fear r)19(eferr)18(ed t)19(o her)19(e is not simply a synon)18(ym f)19(or a muted ritual r)19(e)18(v)19(er)18(ence)56(.)]tj t* 0 tc -0.006 tw [(the hebr)19(e)18(w )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 128.0635 407.9616 tm 0 g [(yir)19(ah)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 149.5283 407.9616 tm 0 g -0.0003 tc (,)tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 155.0251 407.9616 tm 0 g [(y)19(ar)18(e)37(, )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 177.5256 407.9616 tm 0 g (and )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 196.5429 407.9616 tm 0 g (pachad)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 228.8708 407.9616 tm 0 g -0.006 tw [(mean v)19(ariously r)18(e)19(v)19(er)19(ent fear)110(, terr)19(or)111(, or)]tj -15.58708 -1.2 td 0 tw [(dr)19(ead \(k)36(oberle)56(, 2004\). )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(thus f)19(or je)18(w)19(s)36(, ther)19(e ar)19(e clear r)18(easons t)19(o r)19(emain f)18(aithful t)19(o the co)19(v)18(enant,)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(and the old t)88(est)19(ament is abundant in e)18(x)19(amples of pr)19(ophetic admonition with)]tj t* 0 tc 0.132 tw [(r)19(egar)19(d t)18(o this)37(. in christianity the r)19(elationship is mor)18(e ambiguous)37(, partly)]tj t* -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(because of the emphasis on lo)19(v)18(e and r)19(edemption. some envir)18(onment)19(ally con-)]tj t* 0 tc -0.014 tw (cerned christians ha)tj 8.8188 0 td (v)tj 0.481 0 td -0.0003 tc (e)tj 0.76378 0 td 0 tc (attempted t)tj 5.00365 0 td -0.0004 tc (o)tj 0.80049 0 td (r)tj 0.351 0 td 0 tc [(eturn t)19(o the judaic notion of ste)19(w)19(ar)18(d)1(-)]tj -16.21872 -1.20001 td 0.002 tc 0.137 tw [(ship thr)19(ough a r)18(ene)19(w)19(ed emphasis on genesis)37(, eden, and the gar)18(dening)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(met)19(aphor \(hought)18(on, 1994\), a)1(nd this is )-1(often appealed t)19(o in contempor)19(ary)]tj t* -0.002 tc 0 tw (christianity)tj 4.82962 0 td -0.0019 tc (.)tj 0.54 0 td -0.002 tc -0.012 tw (this is pr)tj 3.90186 0 td (oblematic f)tj 4.80189 0 td [(or tw)19(o r)18(easons)37(. fir)18(st, the ste)19(w)19(ar)19(dship con)-1(-)]tj -14.07337 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.016 tw [(cept, depriv)19(ed of a)18(w)19(e and holiness)37(, is w)19(eak. in a w)18(estern w)19(orld which has)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tw [(seen a dilution of the christian gospel thr)19(ough affluence and concession t)18(o)]tj t* 0.012 tc 0.127 tw (scientific w)tj 5.11943 0 td 0 tw (orldvie)tj 3.0269 0 td 0.127 tw [(w)19(s)37(, holiness)37(, a)19(w)19(e)56(, and the thr)18(eat of damnation ha)19(v)19(e)]tj -8.14633 -1.20001 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(r)18(etr)19(eated significantly)111(. second, ther)19(e ar)18(e)-1( )-1(a)-1(l)-1(t)-1(e)-1(r)-1(n)-1(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(v)18(e vie)19(wpoints in christianity)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(in which ste)19(w)19(ar)18(dship of cr)19(eation is not a centr)19(al concern. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.017 tc (ar)tj 0.94725 0 td (guably)tj 2.64057 0 td (,)tj 0.51667 0 td -0.005 tw [(the r)19(oot of this is t)18(o be f)19(ound in the ambiguity o)19(v)19(er christ\325)36(s sec-)]tj -5.90449 -1.20001 td -0.03 tc 0.007 tw [(ond coming. in a series of gospel accounts kno)19(wn as the oliv)18(et discour)19(se)56(, jesus)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.018 tc -0.004 tw [(speaks as though his second coming w)19(er)18(e imminent \(matthe)19(w 16:28; 24:34\).)]tj t* -0.006 tc 0 tw (ther)tj 1.94067 0 td -0.0058 tc (e)tj 0.76517 0 td -0.006 tc -0.001 tw [(w)19(as clear e)18(xpect)19(ation amongst man)19(y of jesus\325)36(s contempor)19(ary f)19(ollo)18(w-)]tj -2.70584 -1.2 td -0.022 tc 0 tw [(er)19(s that the)18(y w)19(ould liv)19(e t)18(o see the second coming. it is r)19(ecor)19(ded in mark 13:32)]tj t* -0.006 tc (that jesus himself did not kno)tj 12.83205 0 td -0.0057 tc (w)tj 1.02541 0 td -0.006 tc [(the answ)19(er t)18(o this contr)19(o)18(v)19(er)18(sy)111(. christianity)110(,)]tj -13.85746 -1.2 td -0.014 tc -0.009 tw [(ther)19(ef)18(or)19(e)55(, e)19(xists in a st)19(ate of permanent w)18(at)19(chfulness f)19(or the second coming.)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.007 tw [(t)88(w)18(o millennia ha)19(v)18(e no)19(w passed, and although some of the \322signs\323 \(e)55(.g., the)]tj t* 0.003 tw [(f)18(all of the temple)56(, nation shall mak)19(e w)18(ar against nation\) ha)19(v)18(e come t)19(o pass)37(,)]tj t* 0.114 tw [(other)19(s)36(, such as the so-called \322gr)19(eat commission\323 \(t)19(o mak)18(e disciples of all)]tj t* 0 tw [(nations\) ha)19(v)18(e not. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(the global ascendanc)19(y of a thir)18(d abr)19(ahamic r)19(eligion, islam, indeed)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.019 tc 0.005 tw [(conf)19(ounds the sign of the gr)18(eat commission f)19(or the pr)18(esent at least. northcott)]tj t* -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [((2004), in a v)19(ery po)18(w)19(erful critique of the curr)18(ent w)19(a)18(v)19(e of u.s. imperialism and)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 246.2002 33.8348 tm 0 g (finding the right kind of awe and wonder)tj et 1 g 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm 0 g (93)tj et q endstream endobj 8 0 obj << /length 6321 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.002 tw [(hostility t)19(o islam, sees right-wing e)18(v)19(angelical christianity as the inspir)19(ation)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(and guiding f)19(or)18(ce of the policies)37(. he ar)19(gues that ther)18(e is an alternativ)19(e)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(christianity that w)19(ould dir)18(ect the soul of america in an entir)19(ely differ)19(ent w)19(a)18(y)111(.)]tj t* -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(this is undoubtedly the case)56(, but the difficult question r)18(emains of e)19(xplaining)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(wh)19(y)110(, if ther)19(e is one true)56(, omnipotent god, ther)18(e ar)19(e so man)19(y differ)19(ent v)18(er)19(sions)]tj t* 0.015 tc 0.124 tw [(of christianity that appar)19(ently serv)19(e the political aspir)18(ations of mort)19(al)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(human beings)37(. anthr)19(opocentrism at the heart of r)18(eligion is one possible e)19(xpla-)]tj 0 -1.19999 td 0 tc 0 tw [(nation f)19(or this)36(.)]tj 1.8 -1.20001 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(american polic)19(y w)18(ould seem t)19(o be influenced, not only b)18(y liter)19(al belief)19(s)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0.009 tc 0.13 tw [(in cr)19(eationism as suggested b)18(y the book of genesis)37(, but also b)19(y liter)19(al)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(belief)19(s in the apocalypse suggested b)18(y the book of r)19(e)19(v)18(elation. in the est)19(ab-)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(lished doctrines of the major christian denominations)37(, ther)19(e is a permanent)]tj t* 0 tc -0.013 tw [(w)19(at)19(chfulness r)18(elated t)19(o eschat)19(ology)111(, the doctrine of death, judgment, hea)18(v-)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(en, and hell. unlik)19(e the pagan emphasis on c)19(y)19(clic r)18(ebirth or eastern tr)19(aditions)]tj t* -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(of r)19(eincarnation, christian eschat)18(ology is essentially linear and teleological.)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(it str)19(esses a moment of cr)18(eation (genesis), mo)19(ving ine)19(x)19(or)18(ably t)19(o a moment)]tj t* -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(of apocalypse \(r)19(e)19(v)18(elation\). it is dir)19(ected t)19(o)19(w)19(ar)18(ds a \322ne)19(w jerusalem\323 that will)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(be est)19(ablished at christ\325)36(s second coming\321pictur)19(ed in the book of r)19(e)18(v)19(elation)]tj t* 0 tc 0.078 tw [(as a series of a)19(w)19(esome e)18(v)19(ents)37(. orthodo)19(x doctrine does not interpr)18(et this)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [56(apocalypse\323 in the ph)18(y)19(sical scientific sense of a mass e)18(xtinction e)19(v)18(ent. the)]tj t* 0 tc 0.126 tw [(\322ne)19(w jerusalem\323 is not an immaterial spiritual city)110(, but the full ph)19(y)19(sical)]tj (r)' 0.35107 0 td 0 tw (est)tj 1.22193 0 td (or)tj 0.88794 0 td -0.009 tw (ation of the e)tj 5.69441 0 td [(xisting material cr)19(eation. it is thr)18(ough this hope that the)]tj -8.15535 -1.20001 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(meaning of a \322ne)19(w)1( )1(c)1(o)19(v)19(enant\323 becomes appar)19(ent. christians assent in their)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(cr)19(eeds t)18(o the \322r)19(esurr)19(ection of the )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 182.1514 311.9616 tm 0 g [(body)111(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 203.4404 311.9616 tm 0 g -0.0003 tc tj -14.84404 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.009 tw (during this period of e)tj 9.68279 0 td (xtended w)tj 4.54601 0 td (aiting, ho)tj 4.02671 0 td [(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)110(, it is almost ine)19(vit)19(able)]tj -20.05551 -1.20001 td -0.015 tc 0.001 tw [(that ne)19(w thinking will challenge orthodo)19(x positions)36(. the gnostic her)19(esy)111(, a set)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(of pr)19(e-christian belief)18(s particularly influential in second-century christianity)111(,)]tj t* 0.001 tc 0.138 tw (has had an enduring effect. gnostics t)tj 17.18486 0 td (aught that the ultimate end of all)tj -17.18486 -1.20001 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(being w)19(as t)18(o o)19(v)18(er)19(come matter)111(. thus)36(, f)19(or gnostic christians)37(, the material cr)18(e-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.007 tw [(ation w)19(as of no consequence)55(. only the immaterial spirit matter)19(ed, and the)]tj (e)' 0.4635 0 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw (xistence of the whole univ)tj 10.90554 0 td [(er)19(se w)18(as seen as a corruption and a calamity)111(. this)]tj -11.36904 -1.20001 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(vie)19(w is officially her)18(etical, but its influence can be felt wher)19(e)19(v)19(er the materi-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(al cr)19(eation\325)36(s import)19(ance is do)19(wnpla)19(y)18(ed in r)19(elation t)19(o a better spiritual w)19(orld)]tj t* -0.028 tc 0.014 tw (that is t)tj 3.00027 0 td -0.0279 tc (o)tj 0.77313 0 td -0.028 tc [(come)56(. it seems e)18(v)19(en, in a confused w)19(a)18(y)111(, t)19(o ha)18(v)19(e penetr)19(ated the think)-1(-)]tj -3.7734 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.003 tw [(ing of american polic)19(y)111(. matter/spirit dualism continues t)18(o be the subject of)]tj t* -0.025 tc 0.011 tw (much obfuscation in popular under)tj 14.44486 0 td [(st)18(anding of chr)1(i)-1(s)1(ti)-1(anity)111(. mor)19(eo)18(v)19(er)111(, the obvi-)]tj -14.44486 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.007 tw [(ous futility of the position that all christians need t)19(o do is t)18(o w)19(ait w)19(at)18(chful-)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(ly thr)19(ough a primary concern with their o)18(wn salv)19(ation is pointed out b)19(y v)18(an)]tj t* -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(hoogstr)19(aten \(200)56(1\), who ar)18(gues that an)19(y insights fr)19(om pr)18(e-enlightenment r)19(eli-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.037 tw [(gion must at least be integr)19(ated with the economic-style thinking that has)]tj t* 0 tw [(de)19(v)19(eloped since the enlightenment. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.0248 tc (a)tj 0.8608 0 td -0.025 tc 0.002 tw [(mor)19(e contempor)18(ary \322her)19(esy\323 is that of cr)19(eation spirtuality)111(, a mo)18(v)19(ement)]tj -2.6608 -1.2 td -0.01 tc -0.013 tw [(str)19(ongly associated with an american dominican called matthe)18(w f)56(o)18(x, which)]tj t* 0.007 tc 0.132 tw [(denies most of a)56(ugustine\325)37(s teaching on original sin and do)18(wnpla)19(y)19(s the)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm 0 g (martin ashley)tj et 1 g 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (94)tj et q endstream endobj 9 0 obj << /length 6373 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.006 tc 0.004 tw [(holiness and a)19(w)18(esomeness of god. the cr)19(eation spirituality mo)18(v)19(ement has)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.01 tc 0.129 tw [(pr)19(o)19(v)19(ed attr)18(activ)19(e t)19(o man)19(y who look t)18(o christianity f)19(or a mor)18(e positiv)19(e)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.012 tc -0.01 tw [(appr)19(oach t)18(o the ecological crisis)37(. f)56(o)19<78d5>36(s centr)19(al tenet is the r)18(eplacement of the)]tj t* -0.006 tc 0.139 tw [(notion of original sin b)19(y original blessing \(f)55(o)19(x, 1983\). inspir)18(ed b)19(y a \322via)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.003 tc 0.135 tw [(positiv)19(a\323 f)18(ounded upon r)19(ejoicing in the unlimited goodness of cr)19(eation,)]tj t* -0.026 tc 0.003 tw [(christians will w)19(ork f)18(or sust)19(ainability out of jo)18(y r)19(ather than duty \(ashle)19(y)110(, 1999\).)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.023 tc 0.001 tw [(though f)56(o)19(x also offer)19(s)1( )1(t)1(h)1(r)19(ee other paths \()]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 243.4442 515.9616 tm 0 g -0.022 tc [(negativ)19(a)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 276.6616 515.9616 tm 0 g -0.0237 tc (,)tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 281.7624 515.9616 tm 0 g -0.022 tc [(cr)19(eativ)18(a)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 315.3167 515.9616 tm 0 g -0.023 tc (and )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 333.471 515.9616 tm 0 g -0.022 tc [(tr)19(ansf)18(ormativ)19(a)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 392.0384 515.9616 tm 0 g (\))tj -31.90384 -1.19999 td -0.016 tc -0.007 tw [(which ha)19(v)18(e biblical gr)19(ounding as w)18(ell as some undeniable wisdom, his denial)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.006 tc 0 tw [(of original sin is r)19(egar)18(ded as a her)19(esy b)19(y orthodo)18(x christianity)111(. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.029 tw [(dr)19(a)18(wing on campolo (1992), basden ar)19(gues that denial of original sin)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.008 tw [(r)19(educes r)19(edemption t)18(o mer)19(e gr)19(o)19(wth or education. a f)18(ailur)19(e t)19(o diagnose the)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(r)19(eal pr)18(oblem f)19(aced b)19(y humanity\321its inher)19(ent inability t)18(o o)19(v)18(er)19(come a sinful)]tj t* 0 tc 0.052 tw [(natur)19(e without divine gr)18(ace\321 mak)19(es christian appr)19(oaches no differ)18(ent t)19(o)]tj t* -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(enlightenment appr)19(oaches)36(. the)19(y ar)19(e simply \322teeth gritting e)18(xhort)19(ations t)19(o f)18(ol-)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(lo)19(w jesus\325)36(s good e)19(x)19(ample\323 (basden, 2005). fundament)19(ally)111(, such e)18(xhort)19(ations)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(ar)19(e no differ)18(ent t)19(o e)19(xhort)18(ations t)19(o f)19(ollo)18(w the advice of climate scientists and)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(place human will once again at the centr)19(e)56(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.013 tc 0.126 tw [(basden is equally critical of contempor)19(ary charismatic christianity)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(wher)19(e appeal is made t)18(o a \322per)19(sonal jesus\323 who r)19(e)19(w)19(ar)18(ds the f)19(aithful with what)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(the)19(y w)18(ant. this jesus of the affluent ignor)19(es the judaic notion of god\325)37(s holi)-1(-)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(ness)37(, which is r)18(ooted in a mor)19(e dist)19(ant god whose name y)79(ahw)19(eh \(i am who)]tj -0.0049 tc (i)' 0.55505 0 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw (am\) w)tj 2.66961 0 td (as unspeak)tj 4.7392 0 td (able and who w)tj 6.75751 0 td (as uniquely separ)tj 7.43683 0 td [(ate fr)19(om the r)18(est of cr)19(e-)]tj -22.1582 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.006 tw [(ation \(jones)37(, 196)56(1\). although god is often portr)18(a)19(y)19(ed in the ne)19(w t)87(est)19(ament)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.019 tc 0.005 tw [(as mor)19(e lo)18(ving than a)19(w)19(esome)56(, he is still capable not simply of ph)18(y)19(sical harm,)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw (but the utter annihilation of the soul \(matthe)tj 18.75892 0 td -0.0077 tc (w)tj 1.01516 0 td (1)tj 0.49261 0 td -0.008 tc (0.28\). a theology that posits)tj -20.26669 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.03 tw [(god as a doting par)19(ent attentiv)18(e t)19(o human w)19(ants is sur)18(ely one that rightly)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.009 tw [(attr)19(acts white\325)36(s censur)19(e \(white)56(, 1994\), but quite possibly also one that has)]tj t* 0 tw (lost t)tj 2.09253 0 td (ouch with meaningful doctrine)tj 13.22021 0 td -0.0003 tc (.)tj -13.51274 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.139 tw (this section began with the optimistic suggestion that a theocentric)tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(ethic)19(, in which god and his will came fir)18(st, might offer an alternativ)19(e t)18(o the)]tj t* 0.013 tc 0.126 tw (ecocentric ethics of deep ecology in underpinning thought outside the)tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(anthr)19(opocentric f)18(allac)19(y)111(. it concludes less optimistically that anthr)18(opocentric)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(thinking has indeed inv)19(aded contempor)18(ary christianity)111(. the splits betw)19(een)]tj t* -0.009 tc 0 tw (conserv)tj 3.2883 0 td -0.005 tw [(ativ)19(e vie)18(w)19(s)37(, r)19(esting on the absolute authority of those sections of the)]tj -3.2883 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.044 tw [(bible that support conserv)19(ativ)18(e mor)19(als)37(, pr)18(ogr)19(essiv)19(e liber)18(al vie)19(w)19(s that r)19(ein-)]tj t* 0 tw (terpr)tj 2.0918 0 td -0.004 tw [(et scriptur)19(e in the light of philosophical and scientific r)18(easoning, liber-)]tj -2.0918 -1.2 td -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(ation theologies that align with the poor and charismatic e)19(v)19(angelical theologies)]tj t* 0 tc 0.005 tw [(that align with the affluent do seem pr)19(ogr)18(essiv)19(ely t)19(o undermine the funda-)]tj t* 0 tw [(ment)19(al principle of theocentrism.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.009 tw [(br)18(oadly)111(, thr)19(ee possible cour)19(ses of action ha)18(v)19(e been seen t)19(o be open t)18(o)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(al christianity:)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 73 83.9616 tm 0 g -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [-1042(r)19(elativ)19(e neglect, since god himself will mak)18(e all things ne)19(w at the second com-)]tj 1.5158 -1.2632 td 0 tc 0 tw [(ing, which r)19(ather do)18(wnpla)19(y)19(s the r)19(ole of human r)18(esponsibility; )]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 246.2002 33.8348 tm 0 g (finding the right kind of awe and wonder)tj et 1 g 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm 0 g (95)tj et q endstream endobj 10 0 obj << /length 5732 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 37 588.3035 tm 0 g -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [-1023(a r)19(eturn t)19(o old t)87(est)19(ament notions of co)19(v)19(enant and ste)19(w)19(ar)19(dship, which lacks)]tj 1.51579 -1.26316 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(unambiguous backing fr)19(om the ne)18(w t)88(est)19(ament and is w)19(eak when the fear of)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(god is r)19(emo)18(v)19(ed fr)19(om the equation; and)]tj -1.51579 -1.26316 td -0.002 tw [-1016(ne)19(w interpr)18(et)19(ations of the f)19(aith, which run the risk of her)19(esy and err)18(or and)]tj 1.51579 -1.26316 td 0 tw [(lack the accumulated wisdom of orthodo)19(x doctrine)55(. )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 55 516.3035 tm 0 g -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(none of these offer)19(s a complete blueprint f)19(or the human actions that will)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(guar)19(antee envir)19(onment)18(al sust)19(ainability)111(. the need f)19(or an ethical sy)18(stem that)]tj t* 0 tc 0.139 tw [(o)19(v)18(er)19(comes the anthr)19(opocentric f)18(allac)19(y is ne)19(v)18(ertheless so pr)19(essing that a)]tj t* 0.085 tw [(degr)19(ee of r)18(eluct)19(ance might be att)19(ached t)19(o the complete abandonment of)]tj t* -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(something that might equate t)19(o a theocentric alternativ)19(e t)18(o ecocentrism. in)]tj t* -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(the final section, i try t)19(o mak)18(e some possible sense of this in the conte)19(xt of)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(the w)19(ork of envir)18(onment)19(al educat)19(or)18(s)37(.)]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 94.1204 410.7035 tm 0 g (conclusion: towards a new awe and wonder)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 55 387.9035 tm 0 g -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(the k)19(e)18(y ar)19(gument in this paper has been against anthr)19(opocentrism. the)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.007 tw (dominant mode of opposition t)tj 13.47231 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.80812 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (anthr)tj 2.2958 0 td -0.007 tw [(opocentrism in envir)19(onment)18(alism is)]tj -16.57623 -1.20001 td -0.014 tc 0 tw [(ecocentrism. the ecocentric position, ho)19(w)19(e)18(v)19(er)111(, often appeals t)18(o a natur)19(alistic)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.093 tw [(f)19(allac)19(y that natur)18(e has a mor)19(al quality: that which is \322natur)19(al\323 is \322good.\323)]tj t* -0.025 tc 0 tw (ph)tj 1.06209 0 td 0.011 tw [(y)18(sica)1(l scien)-1(ce)1( )-1(points t)19(o)19(w)18(ar)19(ds a natur)18(e that is amor)19(al, oper)19(ating thr)18(ough geo-)]tj -1.06209 -1.2 td -0.014 tc 0 tw [(logical and e)19(v)19(olutionary time scales)36(. when it is imagined that ther)19(e is a \322)56(con-)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(nectedness\323 betw)19(een humans and natur)19(e as though)-1( the latter w)19(er)19(e sentient)]tj t* 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(and amenable t)19(o contr)18(actual obligation, the natur)19(alistic f)19(allac)19(y becomes)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(the anthr)19(opocentric f)18(allac)19(y at the heart of ecocentrism.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.004 tc 0.134 tw [(the paper has sho)19(wn t)18(oo that theocentrism is f)19(ar fr)18(om immune t)19(o)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0.007 tc 0.132 tw [(anthr)19(opocentrism. indeed, it has pr)19(esented e)18(vidence that suggests that)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(christianity and god ar)19(e all t)18(oo easily commandeer)19(ed b)19(y ambitious humans)]tj t* 0 tc 0.033 tw (and the agents of global domination. envir)tj 18.63992 0 td 0 tw (onment)tj 3.36987 0 td 0.033 tw (al educat)tj 3.90333 0 td [(or)19(s might look)]tj -25.91312 -1.20001 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(afr)19(esh at what is common t)18(o both ecocentrism and theocentrism: their)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(cor)19(e opposition t)18(o anthr)19(opocentrism. the t)19(ask is sur)18(ely t)19(o find a w)19(a)19(y of edu)-1(-)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw (cating childr)tj 5.10668 0 td (en against the belief that the)tj 11.84354 0 td -0.0163 tc (y)tj 0.76665 0 td -0.016 tc [(ar)19(e the centr)18(e of concern, and that)]tj -17.71687 -1.20001 td -0.014 tc 0 tw [(their material w)19(ants ar)18(e the fir)19(st priority)111(. the difficulty lies with the ease with)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.002 tw [(which such principles ar)19(e corrupted. i ha)18(v)19(e ar)19(gued else)19(wher)18(e that envir)19(on-)]tj t* 0 tw (ment)tj 2.25903 0 td 0.043 tw [(al education has itself become corrupted b)19(y consumerism and hege-)]tj -2.25903 -1.2 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw (monic notions of economic gr)tj 12.50204 0 td [(o)18(wth, as e)19(x)19(emplified b)18(y the w)19(a)18(y that economic)]tj -12.50204 -1.2 td -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [19(alue\323 no)18(w needs t)19(o be added t)19(o natur)19(e b)18(y envir)19(onment)19(al centr)18(es and y)19(outh)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(mo)19(v)18(ements such as scouting \(ashle)19(y)111(, 2005b\). )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw (the suggestion that is no)tj 10.43435 0.00001 td -0.0129 tc (w)tj 1.01015 0 td -0.013 tc [(made tent)19(ativ)18(ely is f)19(or a r)19(ehabilit)18(ation of a)19(w)19(e)]tj -13.2445 -1.2 td -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(a)1(n)1(d)1( )1(w)20(onder)110(.)1( )1(a)75(w)20(e and w)18(onder (popular notions in the definition of spirituality))]tj t* 0 tc -0.009 tw [(ar)19(e as capable of infiltr)18(ation b)19(y anthr)19(opocentric consumerism as an)18(y other)]tj t* 0.049 tw (concept. the)tj 5.6055 0 td -0.0001 tc (y)tj 0.8461 0 td 0 tc [(become easily corrupted when, f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, vicarious por-)]tj -6.4515 -1.2 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(tr)19(a)19(y)19(als of natur)19(e thr)18(ough media images r)19(ather than potentially uncomf)19(ort)18(able)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm 0 g (martin ashley)tj et 1 g 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (96)tj et q endstream endobj 11 0 obj << /length 6571 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 g 0.015 tc 0.123 tw [(or danger)19(ous hands-on e)18(xperience in the wild fuel childr)19(en\325)37(s inher)18(ent)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(anthr)19(opocentricity)110(. thus the notion of the \322megast)19(ar f)19(auna\323\321that wild ani)-1(-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(mals ha)19(v)19(e v)18(alue \322because y)19(ou might see them\323 \(ashle)19(y)111(, 2005b\) obscur)19(es other)]tj t* 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(possibilities that wild animals might ha)19(v)19(e their o)18(wn intrinsic v)19(alue)56(, per-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(haps deriv)19(ed fr)18(om their \322right\323 as sentient beings t)19(o inflict harm on humans)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(per)19(ceiv)18(ed as thr)19(eats)37(. envir)19(onment)18(al educat)19(o)1(r)19(s need t)19(o)1( )1(w)20(ork har)18(d at placing)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(v)19(alue outside childr)19(en\325)37(s)1( )1(i)1(m)1(m)1(e)1(d)1(i)1(a)1(t)1(e)1( )1(d)1(e)1(s)1(i)1(r)19(e)1(s)1( )1(f)20(o)1(r)1( )1(s)1(a)1(t)1(i)1(s)1(f)19(action. the)19(y need t)19(o)1( )1(s)1(t)19(and)]tj 0 -1.19999 td 0 tc 0.069 tw [(firm against the continuous assault of the t)19(ourist industry posing as envi-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(r)19(onment)19(al education. p)56(ar)18(ado)19(xically)111(, this ma)18(y w)19(ell mean mor)19(e e)18(xplicit teach-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.071 tw [(ing that natur)19(e might at times be something t)18(o be fear)19(ed. this is what is)]tj t* 0 tw [(meant, fundament)19(ally)110(, b)19(y the r)19(ehabilit)18(ation of a)19(w)19(e and w)19(onder)111(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(t)88(eaching a)19(w)19(e as r)19(e)19(v)19(er)19(ential fear)110(,)1( )1(r)20(ather than the object of sanitiz)19(ed)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(w)19(onder at safe media images)37(, is a difficult challenge)55(. r)19(eligious education, o)19(v)18(er)]tj t* -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(the last 50 y)19(ear)18(s)38(, has r)18(etr)19(eated a long w)19(a)18(y fr)19(om the notion of teaching the fear)]tj t* 0 tc 0.002 tw [(of god, often f)19(or good r)18(easons)37(. envir)19(onment)18(al education has cert)19(ainly had)]tj t* 0.059 tw [(plenty of encounter)19(s with the fear-driv)18(en e)19(v)19(angelical appr)19(oach of sin \(t)18(oo)]tj t* -0.014 tw [(much consumerism\), r)19(epent)19(ance \(a pr)18(omise t)19(o)1( )1(r)20(ec)18(y)20(cle\), and salv)18(ation \(sus-)]tj t* -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(t)19(ainable de)19(v)18(elopment\). a lesson learned fr)19(om this is that fear induced b)18(y e)19(x)19(ag-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.003 tw [(ger)19(ated scenarios of climate change and r)18(esour)19(ce scar)19(city is seldom a pos-)]tj t* -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(itiv)19(e emotional t)18(ool f)19(or w)19(ork with childr)18(en. ho)19(w)19(e)18(v)19(er)111(, the possibility that cli-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.139 tw [(mate change might not be as e)19(x)18(agger)19(ated a thr)19(eat as some of envir)18(on-)]tj t* 0 tw (ment)tj 2.2589 0 td -0.014 tw (al education\325)tj 5.4857 0 td -0.0002 tc (s)tj 0.68982 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (detr)tj 1.72167 0 td (act)tj 1.25893 0 td -0.014 tw [(or)19(s ha)18(v)19(e portr)19(a)19(y)19(ed it, no)18(w seems incr)19(easingly t)19(o)]tj -11.41501 -1.20001 td 0.057 tw [(loom. p)56(erhaps it is time f)18(or the r)19(ehabilit)19(ation of fear as a positiv)18(e t)19(ool f)19(or)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tw [(human de)19(v)19(elopment. )]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.02 tc (eschat)tj 2.69418 0 td 0.006 tw (alogical a)tj 3.80484 0 td 0 tc (w)tj 0.7199 0 td -0.0202 tc (e)tj 0.74384 0 td -0.02 tc [(holds in balance fear and hope)56(, and e)18(v)19(ents within and)]tj -9.76276 -1.20001 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw [(be)19(y)18(ond human contr)19(ol. it is thus fundament)19(ally differ)18(ent t)19(o sensationalist ten-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.018 tc 0.121 tw [(dencies inher)19(ent in popular interpr)18(et)19(ations of mass e)19(xtinction e)18(v)19(ents)37(.)]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 263.9616 tm 0 g (armageddon-)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 128.9009 263.9616 tm 0 g 0.002 tw (style films ma)tj 6.0594 0 td -0.0001 tc (y)tj 0.79859 0 td 0 tc (be less lik)tj 4.20751 0 td [(ely t)19(o induce a)18(w)19(e as r)19(e)19(v)19(er)18(ential fear)]tj -16.65559 -1.20001 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(than t)19(o pr)18(omote trivializ)19(ation and empty f)19(at)18(alism. f)56(at)19(alism ma)18(y simply)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.048 tw [(inv)19(olv)18(e the r)19(esigned accept)19(ance that human actions ha)19(v)18(e no influence on)]tj t* -0.011 tc 0 tw (futur)tj 2.00269 0 td -0.0105 tc (e)tj 0.75354 0 td (e)tj 0.47081 0 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(v)18(ents)37(, ther)19(e)-1(b)17(y offering r)19(e)-1(l)-1(i)-1(e)-1(f)-1( )-1(f)-1(r)18(om an)18(y obligation t)19(o r)19(espond either t)18(o)]tj -3.22704 -1.20001 td -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(ethical principles or t)19(o measur)18(ed scientific pr)19(ojections)37(. this is a vie)18(w that cr)19(aig)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [((2000) r)19(egar)18(ds as \322bar)19(ely coher)19(ent.\323 the alternativ)19(e of matur)18(e theology)]tj t* 0 tc 0.013 tw (merits mor)tj 4.82558 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.79032 0 td 0 tc [(serious consider)19(ation than humanists such as gr)18(a)19(yling \(200)56(1\))]tj -5.6159 -1.2 td 0.007 tw [(ar)19(e pr)18(epar)19(ed t)19(o giv)18(e it, and does not r)19(equir)19(e blind, unr)18(eas)1(oning adh)-1(er)19(ence)]tj (t)' 0.29614 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.81478 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (dogma.)tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 185.5769 134.3616 tm 0 g (notes on contributor)tj et q q bt /f13 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 111.5616 tm 0 g -0.009 tc -0.006 tw [(dr)111(. martin ashle)18(y)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 152.3353 111.5616 tm 0 g -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(is a principal lectur)19(er in education at the univ)18(er)19(sity of the)]tj -7.9335 -1.2 td 0 tc (w)tj 0.867 0 td 0.016 tc 0.123 tw (est of england, brist)tj 9.36874 0.00001 td (ol uk, wher)tj 5.51286 0.00001 td 0.0158 tc (e)tj 0.93261 0 td 0.016 tc (he is a member of the centr)tj 13.35173 0.00001 td 0.0158 tc (e)tj 0.93258 0 td -0.003 tc 0 tw [(fo)-19(r)]tj -30.9655 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.008 tw [(r)19(esear)19(ch in education and democr)18(ac)19(y (cred) and the unity f)19(or the study)]tj -0.0002 tc (of)' 1.1263 0 td 0 tc -0.003 tw [(r)19(eligion and spirituality)110(. his r)19(esear)19(ch inter)18(ests include v)19(alue as a r)19(eason)]tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 246.2002 33.8348 tm 0 g (finding the right kind of awe and wonder)tj et 1 g 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm 0 g (97)tj et q endstream endobj 12 0 obj << /length 9640 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 36 55.9031 324 539.897 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 g -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(f)19(or action, childr)18(en\325)37(s spirituality)111(, and masculinity and the social attitudes of)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.009 tw [(bo)19(y)19(s)37(. he is leader of the pr)18(ofessional doct)19(or)19(ate in education and education)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.009 tc 0.13 tw [(studies a)19(w)18(ar)19(ds)37(. )]tj et q q bt /f13 1 tf 10 0 0 10 109.7818 563.9617 tm 0 g 0.009 tc [(cont)19(act:)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 10 0 0 10 152.4729 563.9617 tm 0 g 0.009 tc 0.13 tw [(uwe f)56(aculty of education, s block, fr)19(encha)18(y)]tj -11.54729 -1.20001 td -0.017 tc 0 tw [(campus)37(, coldharbour l)18(ane)56(, brist)19(ol, bs16 1q)74(y)129(, uk; martin.ashle)19(y@uw)19(e)55(.ac)19(.uk)]tj et q q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 171.7622 518.3616 tm 0 g (references)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37 495.5616 tm 0 g -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(ashle)19(y)111(, m. (2005a). t)88(ensions betw)18(een indoctrination and the de)19(v)19(elopment of judgement:)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(the case against early closur)19(e)56(. )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 168.6377 483.5616 tm 0 g [(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch, 1)110(1)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 303.7848 483.5616 tm 0 g ((2), 187-197.)tj -31.38645 -1.41176 td 0.001 tw [(ashle)19(y)111(, m. (2005b). natur)18(e and nurtur)19(e in the right r)19(elationships with natur)18(e: some par-)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td 0.011 tc 0.128 tw [(allels with r)19(eligious indoctrination. american educational r)18(esear)19(ch association)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(annual confer)19(ence)56(, montr)18(eal, 1)161(1\32015 april 2005.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(ashle)19(y)111(, m. (2000). secular spirituality and implicit r)18(eligion: the r)19(ealisation of human)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw (potential. )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91.9924 423.5616 tm 0 g [(implicit r)19(eligion, 3)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 158.7017 423.5616 tm 0 g [((1), 3)56(1-49.)]tj -14.31785 -1.41176 td 0.057 tw [(ashle)19(y)111(, m. (1999). citiz)18(enship, our duty or our jo)19(y? in k. maccarth)19(y (ed.), )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 314.9717 411.5616 tm 0 g 0.053 tw (making con-)tj -30.58491 -1.41176 td 0.096 tw (nections: an emer)tj 7.65061 0 td (ging r)tj 2.50146 0 td [(ationale f)19(or the futur)18(e)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 223.9035 399.5616 tm 0 g 0.103 tw ((pp. 49-52))tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 265.2452 399.5616 tm 0 g -0.0004 tc (.)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 270.4601 399.5616 tm 0 g (bright)tj 2.57348 0 td 0.103 tw (on: r)tj 2.38059 0 td 0 tw (emembering)tj -30.30232 -1.41177 td (education.)tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw (basden, a. (n.d.). )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 101.7322 375.5616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc -0.009 tw [(t)80(rue \324cr)18(eation spirituality\325: original blessing and original sin~a critique of)]tj -5.49791 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0.049 tw [(matthe)19(w f)36(o)19(x [homepage of john r)19(ay initiativ)18(e])]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 223.9644 363.5616 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.60866 0 td 0 tc 0.053 tw [(r)19(etrie)18(v)19(ed oct)19(ober 12)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 4.25 0 0 4.25 308.2687 366.4679 tm 0 g (th)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 311.9698 363.5616 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.60885 0 td 0 tc 0.053 tw [(2005, fr)19(om)]tj -30.84059 -1.41176 td 0 tw [(www)111(.jri.or)18(g.uk/brief/originalblessing.htm)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.014 tc (bonnett, m. (2004). )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 108.6965 339.5616 tm 0 g (r)tj 0.59855 0 td -0.013 tc [(etrie)19(ving natur)18(e: education f)19(or a post-humanist age)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 289.402 339.5616 tm 0 g -0.0136 tc (.)tj 0.52841 0 td -0.014 tc (oxf)tj 1.53362 0 td [(or)19(d: blackw)18(ell.)]tj -31.75639 -1.41177 td 0.011 tc 0.128 tw [(bonnett, m. (2002). education f)19(or sust)18(ainability as a fr)19(ame of mind. )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 306.3171 327.5616 tm 0 g 0.01 tc [(envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj -29.56672 -1.41176 td 0 tc [(education r)19(esear)18(ch, 8)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 132.8779 315.5616 tm 0 g ((1), 9-20.)tj -11.27975 -1.41176 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw (campolo, t)tj 4.62355 0 td (.)tj 0.51798 0 td 0 tw ((1992). )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 107.82 303.5616 tm 0 g -0.022 tc (ho)tj 1.10369 0 td -0.0224 tc (w)tj 0.94548 0 td -0.022 tc 0.009 tw [(t)19(o r)18(escue the earth without w)19(or)19(shipping natur)19(e)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 281.9075 303.5616 tm 0 g -0.024 tc (.)tj 0.51798 0 td (milt)tj 1.51539 0 td 0.01 tw [(on k)37(e)18(ynes: w)93(or)19(d)]tj -28.72838 -1.41177 td 0 tc 0 tw [(books)37(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(connelly)111(, m. \(200)56(1\). f)55(aith as ultimate concern. l)19(ongvie)19(w community college)56(, philosoph)18(y)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.037 tc 0.006 tw [(of r)19(eligion cour)18(se notes)37(. r)19(etrie)18(v)19(ed oct)18(ober 27, 2005, fr)19(om connelly@longvie)19(w)110(.cc)19(.mo.us)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td 0.012 tc 0.127 tw [(cr)19(aig, e. (2000). f)55(at)19(alism. )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 141.2421 255.5616 tm 0 g 0.011 tc 0.118 tw [(the concise r)19(outledge ency)18(clopedia of philosoph)19(y )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 328.5607 255.5616 tm 0 g 0.012 tc 0.127 tw ((p 274).)tj -32.18361 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(l)19(ondon: r)18(outledge)56(. )]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(de)19(v)18(all, w)130(. & sessions)37(, g. (1985). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 157.0338 231.5616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc -0.009 tw [(deep ecology: living as if natur)19(e matter)18(ed)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 303.2725 231.5616 tm 0 g -0.004 tc (.)tj 0.53798 0 td -0.01 tw [(salt l)19(ak)18(e city:)]tj -29.74652 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw (gibbs smith.)tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(f)55(o)19(x, m. (1983). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 92.91 207.5616 tm 0 g -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(original blessing: a primer in cr)19(eation spirituality)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 262.5974 207.5616 tm 0 g -0.0166 tc (.)tj 0.52536 0 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(san fr)19(ancisco: bear & co.)]tj -27.06624 -1.41176 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(gr)19(a)19(yling, a. \(200)55(1\). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 108.5889 195.5616 tm 0 g -0.008 tc -0.005 tw [(the meaning of things: applying philosoph)18(y)1( t)18(o life)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 282.0356 195.5616 tm 0 g -0.0083 tc (.)tj 0.53358 0 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(l)19(ondon: w)92(eidenfeld)]tj -27.24366 -1.41176 td -0.0001 tc (&)tj 0.99972 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (nicholson.)tj -3.11736 -1.41176 td (griffin, s. (1978). )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 102.6405 171.5616 tm 0 g (w)tj 0.86914 0 td [(omen and natur)19(e: the r)18(oaring inside her)111(.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 255.5367 171.5616 tm 0 g (ne)tj 1.16603 0 td -0.0003 tc (w)tj 1.03646 0 td 0 tc [(y)80(ork: harper & r)18(o)19(w)111(.)]tj -27.91269 -1.41177 td (hodson, m. (2000). )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 110.3602 159.5616 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (a)tj 0.88868 0 td 0 tc (feast of seasons)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 173.9089 159.5616 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55566 0 td (l)tj 0.48121 0 td 0 tc [(ondon: monar)19(ch.)]tj -17.1438 -1.41176 td 0.015 tc 0.124 tw [(hought)19(on, j. (1994). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 119.4914 147.5616 tm 0 g 0.014 tc 0.115 tw [(global w)19(arming: the complete briefing)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 264.1918 147.5616 tm 0 g 0.0149 tc (.)tj 0.70967 0 td 0.015 tc 0.124 tw (cambridge: cambridge)tj -25.32047 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw (univ)tj 1.98095 0.00001 td (er)tj 0.85108 0.00001 td (sity pr)tj 2.72119 0.00001 td (ess)tj 1.31469 0.00001 td (.)tj -8.98557 -1.41179 td [(jones)37(, o)92(. \(196)56(1\). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 99.6481 123.5616 tm 0 g (the concept of holiness)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 181.7884 123.5616 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55551 0 td 0 tc [(sy)19(dne)18(y: allen & un)19(win.)]tj -17.5894 -1.4118 td 0.006 tc 0.132 tw (kirkman, r. (2002). )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 116.8961 111.5616 tm 0 g 0.006 tc 0.123 tw [(sk)19(eptical envir)18(onment)19(alism: the limits of philosoph)18(y and science)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6371 111.5616 tm 0 g (.)tj -35.4867 -1.4118 td (bloomingt)tj 4.4253 0 td (on, in: indiana univ)tj 8.72021 0.00001 td (er)tj 0.85107 0.00001 td (sity pr)tj 2.7212 0.00001 td [(ess)37(.)]tj -18.8354 -1.4118 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(k)37(oberle)56(, a. (2004). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 106.9544 87.5616 tm 0 g -0.006 tc -0.007 tw [(the quest f)19(or holiness: a biblical, hist)18(orical and sy)19(stematic inv)19(estigation.)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 55 75.5616 tm 0 g [(eugene)56(, or: wipf & st)19(ock.)]tj -2.1176 -1.4118 td (k)tj 0.5854 0 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw (uhn, t)tj 2.506 0 td -0.0259 tc (.)tj 0.5161 0 td -0.026 tc 0 tw ((1996). )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 94.6685 63.5616 tm 0 g -0.024 tc 0.011 tw (the structur)tj 4.77847 0.00001 td -0.0242 tc (e)tj 0.66575 0 td -0.024 tc (of scientific r)tj 5.08612 0.00001 td 0 tc (e)tj 0.40104 0.00001 td -0.024 tc 0 tw [(v)19(olutions)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 217.8546 63.5616 tm 0 g -0.0258 tc (.)tj 0.51616 0 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw (chicago il: univ)tj 6.64769 0.00001 td 0 tw (er)tj 0.79963 0.00001 td 0.012 tw (sity of chicago pr)tj 7.12648 0.00001 td 0 tw [(ess)37(.)]tj et 1 g 36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm 0 g (martin ashley)tj et 1 g 14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm 0 g (98)tj et q endstream endobj 13 0 obj << /length 4793 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q 1 g 72 63 324 532.8 re f q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 73 588.9874 tm 0 g [(l)19(eopold, a. (1949). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 145.4202 588.9874 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (a)tj 0.88868 0 td 0 tc (sand country almanac)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 230.8248 588.9874 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.55572 0 td 0 tc [(oxf)19(or)18(d: oxf)19(or)18(d univ)19(er)19(sity pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj -19.12334 -1.41176 td [(mckibben, w)130(. (1989). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 155.1674 576.9874 tm 0 g [(the end of natur)19(e)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 216.9957 576.9874 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55565 0 td 0 tc [(ne)19(w y)79(ork: r)19(andom house)56(.)]tj -17.49633 -1.41176 td -0.001 tc (m)tj 0.81405 -0.00001 td -0.013 tw [(er)19(cer)110(, j. (2006). capit)19(alising on childr)19(en\325)36(s spirituality: p)56(ar)19(ent)19(al anxiety)110(, childr)19(en as con-)]tj 1.3036 -1.41176 td -0.014 tc 0 tw [(sumer)19(s and the mark)18(eting of spirituality)111(. )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 237.2852 552.9874 tm 0 g -0.013 tc [(international journal of childr)19(en\325)36(s spirituality)111(,)]tj -17.21002 -1.41176 td -0.111 tc (11)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 98.8774 540.9874 tm 0 g ((1), 23-33.)tj -3.0444 -1.41176 td [(mer)19(chant, c. (1996). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 150.9194 528.9874 tm 0 g [(earthcar)19(e: w)37(omen and the envir)19(onment)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 291.074 528.9874 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55566 0 td 0 tc [(l)19(ondon: r)18(outledge)56(.)]tj -26.21143 -1.41176 td [(mies)37(, m. & shiv)18(a, v)111(. (1993). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 176.5792 516.9874 tm 0 g (ecofeminism)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 222.0592 516.9874 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55565 0 td 0 tc [(ne)19(w jer)18(se)19(y: z)36(ed )1(books)36(.)]tj -18.09203 -1.41176 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw (northcott, m. (2004). )tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 151.5323 504.9874 tm 0 g -0.005 tc -0.008 tw [(an angel dir)19(e)1(c)1(t)1(s)1( )1(t)1(h)1(e)1( )1(s)1(t)19(orm: apocalyptic r)19(eligion and american empir)19(e)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 392.6403 504.9874 tm 0 g (.)tj -35.48709 -1.41176 td [(ne)19(w y)79(ork: t)148(aurus)37(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td 0.004 tw [(pink)19(er)110(, s. (2002). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 138.2785 480.9874 tm 0 g 0.004 tw [(the blank slate: the modern denial of human natur)19(e)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 322.4284 480.9874 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55994 0 td 0 tc 0.004 tw [(ne)19(w y)79(ork/l)19(ondon:)]tj -27.78681 -1.41176 td 0 tw [(bc)36(a.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td [(p)56(orritt, j. (2005). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 136.4242 456.9874 tm 0 g [(capit)19(alism as if the w)18(orld matter)19(s)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 255.4968 456.9874 tm 0 g -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55566 0 td 0 tc [(l)19(ondon: earthscan.)]tj -22.02588 -1.41176 td 0.077 tw [(r)19(adf)19(or)18(d-r)19(euther)111(, r. (1992). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 177.5932 444.9874 tm 0 g 0.071 tw (gaia and god: an ecofeminist theology of earth healing)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 376.0865 444.9874 tm 0 g -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.63242 0 td 0 tc (san)tj -34.17201 -1.41176 td [(fr)19(ancisco: harper collins)36(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(scott-smith, l. (2003). what is f)19(aith?: an analy)18(sis of tillich\325)37(s \324ultimate concern.)148]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 359.4307 420.9874 tm 0 g -0.008 tc (quodlibet,)tj -31.58008 -1.41176 td 0 tc (5)tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 95.4098 408.9874 tm 0 g ((4), 1-12.)tj -2.63645 -1.41177 td 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(v)19(an hoogstr)19(aten, h. \(200)55(1\). )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 182.5731 396.9874 tm 0 g 0.004 tc 0.125 tw [(deep econom)19(y: caring f)18(or ecology)111(, humanity and r)18(eligion)]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 392.6381 396.9874 tm 0 g (.)tj -35.48684 -1.41176 td [(cambridge: james clark)19(e)56(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.007 tc (white)tj 2.482 0 td -0.0072 tc (,)tj 0.53474 0 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(l. (1994). the hist)19(orical r)18(oots of our ecological crisis)37(. in d. v)19(an de v)92(eer & c. pier)19(ce)]tj -0.89909 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(\(eds)37(.\), )]tj et q q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 117.0415 360.9874 tm 0 g 0.111 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(al ethics and policy: philosoph)19(y)111(, ecology)111(, economics )]tj et q q bt /f4 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 351.631 360.9874 tm 0 g 0.12 tw [(\(pp. 45-5)56(1\).)]tj -30.66247 -1.41176 td 0 tw (belmont, c)tj 4.77807 0 td (a: w)tj 2.03662 0 td (adsw)tj 2.22168 0 td (orth.)tj et 1 g 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 246.2002 33.8348 tm 0 g (finding the right kind of awe and wonder)tj et 1 g 396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3659 33.8708 tm 0 g (99)tj et q endstream endobj 14 0 obj << /nums[0<>] >> endobj 15 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 44/comma/hyphen 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon 65/a 67/c 69/e/f/g 73/i/j/k 77/m/n 80/p 82/r/s/t/u 87/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 108/l/m/n/o/p 114/r/s/t/u/v/w 121/y] /type/encoding >> endobj 16 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 5398 /length1 5398 >> stream vutqjs+eurostileregular7 ? ? ea2'joehuif3,pg"xb8s5.qztdm1(v&wn 6*$+4/c4=[%%ll#z$b  * r 8 ` b m uf1d6{....[.--q?u1 1 -p p * ny|oot9g r[[.>!z)apui$b +heuuepgwdch'4 u p[/=yiyyh@r!eii{4%뭻ϣs[p[$0(&geuuepsmeei"@t.xlgkkfc{!$hmm| 8__u#4ǿ r>]-$8y hwwgbrckj{20ӣt^pz zi1=mfpv\/^^10^'u ߳ڡ 'c$p i 6(^2h izaiwwib ?kk{+djo utd6jjtsiprbkkkd+dz#mۭԞ{llh$^e;3.9b$ɫ#moo#&.xfe;(uhagg`;z qu.gpw&[.cvmqabnmmddȦbapwvddlnw6c">>|!mccm>w>mm}>>ؠvc /🬈diou+-o"&& 5ul7g)gpa:w8v8xxc9`c9w8x8wwa:'ph6ܞ::6dp*`@zkkdi'<"*u_uu_p;v *7$ oss3'(weyyer@uqx@ (oy)jkk{՛ї~qsxugbwhwhxydkxjdxixhx΁ci27ziɜmivk~bu5: t0z)zrs͋i3d0^1t pll.l.l.l.(##q:.mmup"}t}iodonq#.}klf.eˍbb9.u. 6a2Ѧhupvu*"5"]/[  [!6(z)i\[ift"agfy(3Ԥs[&!p>uhr q!fgah'>)pwp-fsn@}{xͦ")y,2!ygvvgqd agg yix'ex]guug?-lkk{%w%feex1,ij@4a#-\˙͔Ѓ{{ai u$ong}!:iiz36Σ~srzar nsr!/2igssgoq^kjk@a !|hoou u nj4é06oss".w.2Ɗyhh8uc`lk`)|,f_o2w)dfed%y8lyys@wi=ft }qqfi++ihg)||.ii??he^ ]/ff/i2Ū-ˉp v;b__b@v7ron} st3 p lgiiegb7p6x6s9s:qrv7=$p]p0 cs m_  ڳ֠|mmr7 zu4u oh)6.#u u$ pllhtnnr?z.g-u9_kk_{f9$aavp.p]''ww"qer&bp.p}u.u. tc^on^}iskj{t:p{lkea-.loo b;os>i[ct}n}n)êt99%cy3˹ʹ n-:|u>{5kgfkay amm|+]um0yys85ũ5w.u./.ur#⭪by©8>klkldofufui7d+϶8yhh? y8hkhk&q*j5w;dlkc(|49%ccw4̹*8zk.lnmlxt^nm^m,$?ccmx)xklmam`|: 7"[[$tr^ʿɿ;|mmm+ũ43sm%ydimli<|nbawЭ08tok%!etgsg[tau/noo}Ӳ25}pam`^qwhgwj#/t |{,4{oot8vx#geef&x82)eex%w -\[t^_˫f?j iihn e@v2+vu%wxkjj.??-5u.! 2_*'Ѩirpvu+ f#\/k  [$2*z'j[[jgs%>ii{a 豺գr[u`-k)xw endstream endobj 17 0 obj << /descent -512 /flags 32 /type/fontdescriptor /ascent 1775 /stemh 0 /stemv 0 /fontname/vutqjs+eurostileregular /xheight 0 /fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867] /capheight 1775 /italicangle 0 /fontfile3 16 0 r >> endobj 18 0 obj << /basefont/vutqjs+eurostileregular /encoding 15 0 r /subtype/type1 /name/f0 /widths[250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 198 208 0 0 613 614 613 613 613 613 613 613 614 614 195 0 0 0 0 0 0 608 0 597 0 498 489 619 0 204 502 603 0 858 696 0 590 0 623 560 515 655 0 999 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 510 511 485 510 502 265 510 514 188 0 0 188 826 516 506 510 0 398 474 326 507 402 670 0 389] /lastchar 121 /type/font /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 17 0 r >> endobj 19 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[65/a 82/r 97/a/b/c 109/m 114/r/s/t/u 142/eacute] /type/encoding >> endobj 20 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 1943 /length1 1943 >> stream tucccz+usherwood-bolditalic@^   /+fvcopyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bold italicitc usherwood "ctusbd3vn  q05ӆrcqtyo ypa[k $fx$yxx\\\ $k{yy\hz[gvnoy $rk-yw+erle{)kǨk}tuacgftaf;<\@?tj[coz쬜dif:(bmoy"od:en4"a)bbl[pdgwcskrgxwȋ%av狱pj~yǘw xuggjk}Ǩ|ȅtxe?&e^:_y2hxcski|opǷov )yn~𑜒}hicenp>4}fccdtpfqsmu\mj $yb]_ɶty|sszu}eegt] $=!v3f?ܽӾy+oy,>nu𚚇oys4pxzj c=y\'(cπ!((ekbs=lgǒp t>a67o{sb\ayƜ ry*w h ztxzuysr}>yw{tx inv<q1u|ب𕯐wqmrob:rrwwzv}n'ljmigȻyrvpi^vv > p zxʘbzopdly} $Ƌtt~v}gnrsviwyqmp|z"gikpn8hab;9sc~f`rng_kssyk> endobj 22 0 obj << /basefont/tucccz+usherwood-bolditalic /encoding 19 0 r /subtype/type1 /name/f1 /widths[722 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 685 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 556 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 852 0 0 0 0 463 463 389 593 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 481] /lastchar 142 /type/font /firstchar 65 /fontdescriptor 21 0 r >> endobj 23 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 44/comma/hyphen/period 58/colon 67/c 69/e 73/i/j/k 80/p 84/t/u 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 136/agrave 142/eacute/egrave/ecircumflex 158/ucircumflex 213/quoteright] /type/encoding >> endobj 24 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 5984 /length1 5984 >> stream fhdvrh+usherwood-mediumitalic@ww   3/ccopyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood medium italicitc usherwood+5ijtqbfshvuopdgmznlxcew*r 6+$y&1k,-)"aaha > f a ^ = j w`?]zy?ŵwխ $tbu%}?qЄyb2agv}~qЁ]|uvyߏ&ux9w@ykv/w{z3nktttn jjjgdrvywzzhx9:'xd<ɚȜwtls}=sgrrswy5u5v7 $ydw {arvy{~ȫzmwtz3k{vxwzwd.mllda$wsoknarsty0r_0%cr7 d"`h^eu[rwjwlulgg ͋!d{ċrb}vvp$vq֝֜י}~}uwkv8v&xa-f`p{kz{}3k{tsxtzrqeuq_w_nf@ey*y%[|y{~{|wthvzlmk $,(q74pݸݻkimra2~kq\hddyby% "flwf? `uo5/: p侴#vn0v\_|*tva3<#|{֐yuajbmo7.yfz{}3k{mt;zhq) $*z #itkll $jp-,rڴɵotn(vdoxduesfn\q' l %bv{ _p-ymy)Ҁtrvywz[{wyw||ss~y.'koœěƳzkv{z3k{w}io'hbfɽvssgaywwsoneryЀvyqzjch{jz{}3k{mt8xnr2 $y0ty$ #/<$ %-?$h-تla<-'>qty% o^qo\mse-몦wevvw~_e#4b"p͵ѻ wkscu8ǔwԀsnpb-yx~~~̛pqq!q,e|rljmcni35wxtjtz~ywf?ptyw|rvywzɣ䒮wtls}=sgrrs:jjjgdcvfosxq6.`?-ux{~zwoyumkolmxyweroziyңݕۚkklfgg $szuuv{du5ed߮䙔Йdddbcb $sr{y{zwcdc[s=pՔٔeeecdc $sawtxnixqkni~^}^{_xmӋ8 ?yȪl,gygs'  \kq+jao؃tsstssn3ur&*!2 òyqv2iaqhiŋü}x}wtsdy}t˧ź{zoyvqgoyi`k}}bpsyzvmyvmu+cenxhrystyw{cvxŭv> endobj 26 0 obj << /basefont/fhdvrh+usherwood-mediumitalic /encoding 23 0 r /subtype/type1 /name/f2 /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 333 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 574 0 574 0 0 0 296 296 630 0 0 0 0 574 0 0 0 574 648 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 519 426 519 444 333 500 537 278 278 519 259 833 556 519 519 500 426 426 352 556 500 759 537 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 444 444 444 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259] /lastchar 213 /type/font /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 25 0 r >> endobj 27 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 59/semicolon 97/a/b/c/d/e 103/g/h/i 108/l/m/n/o/p 114/r/s/t/u/v 121/y] /type/encoding >> endobj 28 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 2762 /length1 2762 >> stream mimfhw+usherwood-medium?9   %!p copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood mediumitc usherwoodsfmjhpobuiqdtnzwvcekrb)y|jp ]@ - { $z Ϊװl~xmgt_crfczkry3%*n~*yv?htgm62f؜o0e3%$鱢n(hפw $zqrfczkry3 as w4asr $zrfczkry3uqpuuqpu*cӹgrkg`d wvtwvu@trv ;=#'^xnvntqom{w鋭ыщdldd6 edĜ{qzp|p}?d"; }|}uf `tƖz{q}qm@з\2:atce`޳-y*y!&&/!!0$&&$!'/]/%%^r z $zxۑi65bzo $puo?xi]ctf3ev@wb͙ywwwrrotcejrxnh:prohҶãr) wznۑi65bzo $puo?dfa{} $`|՘z/m[x $t f]5>[zawys8hxzawrfczkry3%*n~nv^_1xЫĺuuuutu $rkuvxhghjkk $ryx.ux]_ f\|nbba5*zup $uvvtut $rgprr&$ghhllm $r{|0?yw}_yuqrfczkrj2[?/.‹ȏrfcziry3"fе_cp-y! w3 g o-)7s9*n' +7@][pkmrfczkry3c}h-y! w!nvhk/ )/ѱaoewkrfczkrkj($:z۪y?yf`  endstream endobj 29 0 obj << /descent -254 /flags 34 /type/fontdescriptor /ascent 684 /stemh 0 /stemv 80 /fontname/mimfhw+usherwood-medium /xheight 694 /fontbbox[-82 -282 1027 872] /capheight 622 /italicangle 0 /fontfile3 28 0 r >> endobj 30 0 obj << /basefont/mimfhw+usherwood-medium /encoding 27 0 r /subtype/type1 /name/f3 /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 556 481 556 500 0 500 593 278 0 0 278 889 593 556 574 0 389 426 315 574 500 0 0 537] /lastchar 121 /type/font /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 29 0 r >> endobj 31 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 38/ampersand 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 63/question/at/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w 89/y/z 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 149/idieresis 165/bullet 208/endash/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright] /type/encoding >> endobj 32 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 10294 /length1 10294 >> stream mpnzme+usherwood-book?&x   !(copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bookitc usherwoodp1fsibqtnpuocmzjdvg"e-  whx5k&y*r4+$./[(,iw#6l0)23'%8:t!o 7;ar  a?9}c { ^ ? 0 b ekg}7mqg8@aw : !["("a""##$s$%z%?w i]5:nk  $tk#;0wppֈppw}|{|||{959rm*yv"dnta?3 róɊܕ\)18?b洝r 'dc]ce:q*~Džw@~c{ $p<®vp}}}j^qsyƏ{tnu~]{-:!wj}`{ $_~:kn,n $dt{9@gupdʏ{tnu~x{1*yvam|q~{p~8kmv{{xd}c{fsodo{pqks\y[adjp拵]n`waat2obɸ-}vs"(sv)i6y1'~pkl{Ŏr1bp""g+_q]t{tnu~x{tyvlvwfw^vӻ\jeganv{{|vr#rr@fi|zz̀arzhl&rϬss^g_*i~_{ $`|z,o:u $oy|r7r1r $px~a.7=>urg3:ecpl{tnu~x{1y<y4d ';)'.0 s/)8d!y wtsuylqЅtx`zqv~bm{{?*j}`{ $_~:kn,n $dt{*w=xh{tnu~x{1-y7!wґn$-1/#izh\yq{tnu~x{nm~y#e(9>(=e-wts`{ $_dʏ{tnu~x{1t29}& µwywywy ${fnjdr$Ƅqpqnon ${x2zb+w`jv^o|wwjejю)*wej}_{ $`iċ{tnu~x{ wuuxyttxoy7t4jugq9$psj~y؄~~{u-',56ݰy&wiyu#Ћ{w}u{x{.v@(3s"b-{ms{]{of->ؠijl㆛2wyؿ $@—؅|ofqÂ̌ȝdo}ud $vda6nuzgvqw"zwɛ $fru+vwuknk{ $\\9[xxwrsr ${oysoz^ejgdfqjz-y7!w){ w3*7p.`?uyw (d)a̯@j[ɋ{tnu~x{:*ћx}}s3wp2sߥomonnm ${73so\vpxpŴrhsszqry[ctsxvwz;ngeav$bwov,Ŵrhsszq`ry[ctsx-wk $vÎ{j_f7{熋.*uv-vdy >zb-/-< 껺takfcڽi#nq24n-:`v $a}|li{~sz{zx} $#0 %93l0hr\muwtonovw.%´vem]!gn;+z[*:lr $qryyyvwv ${~uz!qnÆppoooo ${g*usk_ntme}]tɡǚgxo{~w{xu~yy@ywy--n.b{t_el)ӈĊupa7fa 4>ǭ{mvl~}{|lnf"@hۻ_22[r=ngb9ne $ #  $%ь|{|toy ${dmr1ox^ powc#~ty{z ${ea=hb*soqnht ${{@yywuuwwuuw-ѱww^^ww $d}eaw|}j~wk~x=`-}v3we>k}rl`~}xhfg"‹{tnu~x{#wuuxyttx?vv˱r zyˆ}v[rz[%5*rv %t\}u3rcy $qt|uxe1Ƿ櫦wzxrpu ${sqbmj\`'sϘpopmmm ${{f6?^-yܰcey+mؾb<5>1gour6b-b 0cۨpi*l`i6d؞]f5gltx;f-ytvƬ\ygsyo0vjk\kkvoy ͋" '>otxx}yyfki>[5=-=r[yyd-yܰy.90u3'@+nm'+> ,(@v)0osyywuuwwuuw`2wuuwwuuwbvpxgtqbjenuuqgtqbjenuubvpxpŴrhsszqry[ctsxqzŴrhsszqry[ctsx-ywzn 06 74rwhzh:l "jm8"]rnԱtw|ˉcr]7if,dew) a*r < b֡ cuorrt~}|||}|j{739rmiwߕƐc0yttwxttx$1xttxxttxe† $`m#doou[{.\j}_-y6yw"[ums5kźyzuyxtyݷ^>ܥooonlm ${:69rm{ $nql}}ҵxeinbprfgsdn 7ɏf%ns ce-bp2/=bk! \-vÐwjzyޱ#ȉ0fz~^vpw^ӱ#3l}7wov/nŴrhsszqhry[ctsx0wuuwwuuwyc@|ww4qh(ik֥̋鋝}}|vvw ${anqs|ac/ (q{|}|zjutwwy}xwgv`lt e %⯨qbyx $ů(c skhi @֋ wαzwxov{ $rsȁx5~| $,͚r' %tuuΈuut{z{֌{{{{zm1mi:fx]~Ɇ $fvfw %t[}u!~d $ʯt+p0 $Υٶdbyyysss ${xbjautd9pyyyyzz ${dnriq8"]lllmml ${u vrwyirud( )} $\nϋvvvyxy ${lohm>2sk,q_ʋllkhhg ${| =poq\*v]vwh:'':9'';#] kz}*0jj8yryv:%&@߀>)btc5uur9j%-z״߀r]" hs3_cewb>驥bx봠jlop r/q{mplcm-vf^iwts*yks!h«p?wz|ԇ|}}{zcbx^Ō¹fp_u_oi^vrggxxx'yssyxstxdj[򒮭ppp|{| ${vgy^e) xlllmnm ${ie/jg $բש-vhwwn2r*wcusoeo_k2sij|]y&xfitqı; sheyvpxjgtqbjenuuyf`  endstream endobj 33 0 obj << /descent -254 /flags 34 /type/fontdescriptor /ascent 684 /stemh 0 /stemv 59 /fontname/mpnzme+usherwood-book /xheight 694 /fontbbox[-101 -307 964 856] /capheight 622 /italicangle 0 /fontfile3 32 0 r >> endobj 34 0 obj << /basefont/mpnzme+usherwood-book /encoding 31 0 r /subtype/type1 /name/f4 /widths[278 0 0 0 0 0 722 0 296 296 0 0 278 278 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 0 0 0 407 1000 630 593 611 704 574 537 630 704 296 296 648 500 815 685 741 574 741 630 519 556 667 611 944 0 611 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 556 463 556 500 315 500 556 259 241 519 241 889 574 537 556 556 370 426 315 537 500 759 537 519 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 963 444 444 278 278] /lastchar 213 /type/font /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 33 0 r >> endobj 35 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 44/comma/hyphen/period 49/one 51/three 53/five 56/eight 58/colon 65/a 67/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j 76/l/m 79/o/p/q/r/s/t 87/w 91/bracketleft 93/bracketright 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 107/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 126/asciitilde 212/quoteleft/quoteright] /type/encoding >> endobj 36 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 7355 /length1 7355 >> stream jwmxcd+usherwood-bookitalic@o`   .*copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporationitc usherwood book italicitc usherwood7epbouisqdfjgmzvn3th cw"&*.l5a$4_rx'y<)+>%-08(219j tv!| z o  % @  \ ;yo1dfyry|*ya2`w|z}y{fӟݚ0Қϡ{cnl}l{dpxhtvhn 7tv}}}gl-%tbr8gq*ybly0=(1# 0d.ъp73*61m+yagvl\w}{xxsb}}{|z|ab%3pū}{{`x_~toiztyv8t=Őzu`mahklxqwxz|oz%bw9<-udh{koyvj`fsios"u7y(wxsrxkoxҌІyx[meaoklnxi…slxwyyv=wŎzkыrvzyzbbpytwxz|oz*du=c1fgmeo_qr{f|l&pliv.o9ؿ=۰ҳoy|yxpb=gh{koyv`fxmdu;y>vŐq{zr qdzu}vj:fƝ̖k:sm΋'okm9\dkyh{koyv`ftmbzs?s> $=yvbw|ydjbebbrun nqr<rqgxx|{uv|mqpvnqn2zjrw~z-yڱ6<_os# "jq t. jh|yjqa $g1n)#&îy[w' v̀qhgt )ri87ig'xϡwwfxnrlz6;+rnλit~~vj>jzqqtvnzzeitr{-v ͋y`# ;mjd.^&~(.=}ve:<ɝɖxӓ;қ{fhvud<qnַЦaow)g\w=@\wibuӠv8a~w$\porpb%smǰwv~r~=p{sv.)qd|u{sz ${{p7"=-Ňi{sx}zs^~i\tvͭ= $ctz~jşȜunz[%+[_Ǒ{}wwig_`{b}~~.9y?xry{vatbsws}o_|!n}zuzuhd%xi tysrzzxx`~Ĉ=l^xr{ ${_6ӓhihiii ${dx}e>>Хfgflkl ${_}~~.6z?wsϛϦfgfljl ${_}~~{@r6^vu`qycxlы p=gj j=xeyi 7gyˡzxy<\ȕj =684tj]\/e 8ii:?ki7:t;]i3-b\giqݭxh37=jmlxmljtvu{a}~~.8z?ws=q{bo՛p}—~Ûueacm1f{6Τfgflgl ${_}~(6xz?l]yf`  endstream endobj 37 0 obj << /descent -254 /flags 98 /type/fontdescriptor /ascent 684 /stemh 0 /stemv 58 /fontname/jwmxcd+usherwood-bookitalic /xheight 694 /fontbbox[-187 -307 972 849] /capheight 622 /italicangle -12 /fontfile3 36 0 r >> endobj 38 0 obj << /basefont/jwmxcd+usherwood-bookitalic /encoding 35 0 r /subtype/type1 /name/f5 /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 315 259 0 0 519 0 519 0 519 0 0 519 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 630 0 556 667 556 537 611 667 296 296 0 519 815 0 685 574 685 630 519 556 0 0 907 0 0 0 315 0 315 0 0 0 499 500 426 500 444 315 481 519 278 0 481 259 796 537 500 519 481 389 426 315 519 463 722 519 481 0 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 259] /lastchar 213 /type/font /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 37 0 r >> endobj 39 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space] /type/encoding >> endobj 40 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 147 /length1 147 >> stream storfk+eurostileregular7 ? ? dag!{.... endstream endobj 41 0 obj << /descent -512 /flags 34 /type/fontdescriptor /ascent 1775 /stemh 0 /stemv 0 /fontname/storfk+eurostileregular /xheight 0 /fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867] /capheight 1775 /italicangle 0 /fontfile3 40 0 r >> endobj 42 0 obj << /basefont/storfk+eurostileregular /encoding 39 0 r /subtype/type1 /name/f6 /widths[250] /lastchar 32 /type/font /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 41 0 r >> endobj 43 0 obj << /baseencoding/macromanencoding /differences[32/space 46/period 58/colon 65/a 67/c/d 77/m 97/a 99/c 101/e 104/h/i 108/l 110/n/o 114/r/s/t 121/y] /type/encoding >> endobj 44 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 2416 /length1 2416 >> stream osgctt+usherwood-bold@/   "i ocopyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bolditc usherwood%s.bujo"timfz$pd"%g#1j6wfwfr ac itpopopywxwwwvk„h::htb",77a*&7,w $@ȼᶛdȎ=`}}}wi_k $gzthihhhh $m#mjjkeee $kg jt襍 $ye^>dex&vxylxzz\kx{buzzħp^tg8vey,w:zģtq[*orucalʣywttlsk]sŚЈv{p7czewc4rk9qҮw  $v ͒melgoekt3 @avnggnnggndzz $vfĘ]rmv~ $c|\f,5gfsomkliookt3 @avnau``tezxxsqgk $tufiiihhh $kt{zr$sluh $:ty`]NJwfm~~zl"ej3@Ƌ%ahow%z˱~gv]uvjaإnvr wz $vfĘ]rmv~ $c|\f,9jfspގ˒meogreku5@av̫wbq˒meogrekt3@avk $vyowgtu\sblȌƊd ,,!&+殡qӝfuevyu&gp|vq&+gggddd $k]xhdmh6i\|h\f\,\@0tttrqq $wyeɃw)stpf&<%3b\oȁzt_lt$uqb -yy//""-//-ܵ@a@::a=yat{au|dnc0tبhil̄{{vp,$(+y(ynggnnggn`nggnnggnyf`  endstream endobj 45 0 obj << /descent -254 /flags 262178 /type/fontdescriptor /ascent 684 /stemh 0 /stemv 108 /fontname/osgctt+usherwood-bold /xheight 694 /fontbbox[-155 -300 1092 866] /capheight 622 /italicangle 0 /fontfile3 44 0 r >> endobj 46 0 obj << /basefont/osgctt+usherwood-bold /encoding 43 0 r /subtype/type1 /name/f13 /widths[296 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 296 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 296 0 0 0 0 0 0 667 0 630 685 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 815 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 0 481 0 519 0 0 593 296 0 0 296 0 611 556 0 0 389 426 352 0 0 0 0 519] /lastchar 121 /type/font /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 45 0 r >> endobj 47 0 obj << /kids[48 0 r 49 0 r 50 0 r 51 0 r 52 0 r 53 0 r] /type/pages /count 6 /parent 54 0 r >> endobj 48 0 obj << /resources<> /extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 2 0 r /parent 47 0 r /type/page >> endobj 49 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 3 0 r /parent 47 0 r /type/page >> endobj 50 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 4 0 r /parent 47 0 r /type/page >> endobj 51 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 5 0 r /parent 47 0 r /type/page >> endobj 52 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 6 0 r /parent 47 0 r /type/page >> endobj 53 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 7 0 r /parent 47 0 r /type/page >> endobj 55 0 obj << /kids[56 0 r 57 0 r 58 0 r 59 0 r 60 0 r 61 0 r] /type/pages /count 6 /parent 54 0 r >> endobj 56 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 8 0 r /parent 55 0 r /type/page >> endobj 57 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 9 0 r /parent 55 0 r /type/page >> endobj 58 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 10 0 r /parent 55 0 r /type/page >> endobj 59 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 11 0 r /parent 55 0 r /type/page >> endobj 60 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 12 0 r /parent 55 0 r /type/page >> endobj 61 0 obj << /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /contents 13 0 r /parent 55 0 r /type/page >> endobj 54 0 obj << /type/pages /kids[47 0 r 55 0 r] /count 12 >> endobj 62 0 obj << /type/catalog /pages 54 0 r /pagelabels 14 0 r >> endobj 63 0 obj << /title /producer(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5) /creationdate(20061025170852) /xpressprivate(%%documentprocesscolors:\n%%endcomments) /creator(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5) >> endobj xref 0 64 0000000000 65535 f 0000000015 00000 n 0000000059 00000 n 0000005585 00000 n 0000011402 00000 n 0000017799 00000 n 0000024809 00000 n 0000031510 00000 n 0000038658 00000 n 0000045031 00000 n 0000051456 00000 n 0000057241 00000 n 0000063865 00000 n 0000073558 00000 n 0000078404 00000 n 0000078449 00000 n 0000078728 00000 n 0000084209 00000 n 0000084431 00000 n 0000084881 00000 n 0000085011 00000 n 0000087037 00000 n 0000087271 00000 n 0000087621 00000 n 0000087900 00000 n 0000093967 00000 n 0000094197 00000 n 0000094823 00000 n 0000094984 00000 n 0000097829 00000 n 0000098051 00000 n 0000098441 00000 n 0000098878 00000 n 0000109257 00000 n 0000109477 00000 n 0000110170 00000 n 0000110503 00000 n 0000117941 00000 n 0000118169 00000 n 0000118817 00000 n 0000118908 00000 n 0000119136 00000 n 0000119358 00000 n 0000119529 00000 n 0000119710 00000 n 0000122209 00000 n 0000122435 00000 n 0000122820 00000 n 0000122927 00000 n 0000123160 00000 n 0000123344 00000 n 0000123528 00000 n 0000123712 00000 n 0000123896 00000 n 0000125307 00000 n 0000124080 00000 n 0000124187 00000 n 0000124371 00000 n 0000124555 00000 n 0000124730 00000 n 0000124926 00000 n 0000125122 00000 n 0000125372 00000 n 0000125441 00000 n trailer << /size 64 /root 62 0 r /info 63 0 r /id[<5536e2b64f21fba41c03f4bc6ce68b0e><5536e2b64f21fba41c03f4bc6ce68b0e>] >> startxref 125695 %%eof