%pdf-1.3
%����
1 0 obj
<<
/opm 1
/type/extgstate
>>
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/op true
/type/extgstate
>>
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/op false
/type/extgstate
>>
endobj
4 0 obj
<<
/length 4672
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
13.5 0 0 13.5 37 585.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
0.001 tw
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in)tj
0 -1.33333 td
(environmental education research: issues of quality)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
9 0 0 9 37 546.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart, university of regina, canada)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f1 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 510.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(a)19(bstr)19(act)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f2 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 498.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(within the conte)19(xt o)18(f an educational r)19(esear)18(ch community that no)19(w seems)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
[(pr)18(epar)19(ed t)19(o t)18(ak)19(e narr)18(ativ)19(e f)36(orms o)19(f r)19(epr)18(esenting human e)19(xperience serious-)]tj
t*
[(ly)110(, this paper addr)19(esses issues o)19(f quality within such inquiries)36(, as applied t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.26315 td
[(r)19(esear)19(ch in envir)18(onment)19(al education. a)37(t issue her)18(e is not whether w)19(e shall)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
[(hav)19(e criteria but what might be the basis f)36(or criteria within a tr)19(ansf)37(ormed)]tj
t*
[(social inquiry)111(. gr)18(ounded in studies o)19(f teacher thinking and pr)18(actice in)]tj
t*
[(canadian element)19(ary schools)36(, the paper tr)19(aces the debates about issues o)19(f)]tj
t*
[(quality in qualit)19(ativ)18(e inquiry thr)19(ough the language o)19(f positivist, interpr)18(e-)]tj
t*
[(tivist, criticalist and postmodernist notions o)19(f r)18(epr)19(esent)18(ation and legitima-)]tj
t*
(tion. ultimately)tj
6.55346 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.51762 0 td
0 tc
(narr)tj
1.88863 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.61084 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.70264 0 td
0 tc
[(methodologies pull us aw)19(ay fr)18(om f)37(oundational)]tj
-11.2732 -1.26317 td
[(criteria t)19(o)19(w)19(ar)18(d mor)19(e situated local community per)18(spectiv)19(es; conv)19(er)18(sations)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
(about mor)tj
4.46264 0 td
(al, ethical, and critical consciousness and social critique that con)tj
27.38184 0 td
(-)tj
-31.84449 -1.26316 td
(nect per)tj
3.40576 0 td
(sonal t)tj
2.85107 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(o)tj
0.77759 0 td
0 tc
[(social t)19(o envir)18(onment)19(al dimensions o)18(f discour)19(se pr)19(actices)36(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f1 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 332.0022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r\216sum\216)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f2 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 320.0022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(dans le conte)tj
5.6272 0 td
[(xte d\325une communaut\216 de r)19(echer)18(che p\216dagogique qui semble)]tj
-5.6272 -1.26316 td
[(maintenant pr\220te \210 adopter des f)37(ormes narr)18(ativ)19(es pour r)19(epr\216senter)]tj
t*
[(s\216rieusement l\325e)19(xp\216rience humaine)36(, ce document abor)19(de les enjeux de la)]tj
t*
[(qualit\216 de semblables enqu\220tes applicables \210 la r)19(echer)18(che en \216ducation envi-)]tj
t*
[(r)19(onnement)19(ale)36(. il ne s\325agit pas de sav)19(oir si nous aur)19(ons ou non des crit\217r)18(es)37(,)]tj
0 -1.26315 td
[(mais plut\231t de d\216terminer ce qui peut constituer le f)37(ondement des crit\217r)18(es)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
[(d\325une enqu\220te sociale tr)19(ansf)36(orm\216e)37(. appuy\216 sur des \216tudes au sujet du)]tj
t*
[(r)19(aisonnement et de la pr)19(atique des enseignants dans les \216coles \216l\216ment)18(air)19(es)]tj
t*
[(canadiennes)37(, ce document r)18(etr)19(ace les d\216bats sur les enjeux de la qualit\216 des)]tj
t*
[(enqu\220tes qualit)19(ativ)18(es au mo)19(y)19(en du langage de notions positivistes)37(, interpr\216)-1(-)]tj
t*
[(t)19(ativ)19(es)36(, critiques et postmodernes de la r)19(epr\216sent)18(ation et de la l\216gitimation.)]tj
t*
(en d\216finitiv)tj
4.90649 0 td
(e)tj
0.40698 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.51763 0 td
0 tc
[(les m\216thodologies narr)19(ativ)18(es nous \216loigner)19(ons des crit\217r)19(es)]tj
-5.83111 -1.26316 td
<678e6e8e72>tj
2.35059 0 td
[(aux pour nous amener \210 des per)19(spectiv)18(es communaut)19(air)18(es locales)]tj
-2.35059 -1.26315 td
[(dav)19(ant)18(age situationnelles)37(, ainsi qu\325\210 des conv)19(er)18(sations sur la conscience)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
(mor)tj
1.75855 0.00001 td
[(ale)37(, \216thique et critique et sur la critique sociale qui r)18(elient les dimen-)]tj
-1.75855 -1.26316 td
[(sions per)19(sonnelles)36(, sociales et envir)19(onnement)19(ales des pr)18(atiques du discour)19(s)37(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(140)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36 17.496 324 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(canadian journal of environmental education, 7(2), spring 2002)tj
/f3 1 tf
1 0 0 1 -1000 1648 tm
1 g
-0.25 tc
( )tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
<<
/length 7431
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(p)56(eople outside natur)19(al hist)18(ory find it quaint that natur)19(alists study chimpanz)18(ees)37(,)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(f)19(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, case b)18(y case)56(, constructing elabor)19(ate accounts of a single individual.)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.016 tw
[(it is f)19(ar fr)18(om quaint, \(ste)19(v)19(en ja)18(y\) gould ar)19(gues)37(, because ther)19(e is no essence of)]tj
t*
0.088 tw
[(chimpness; ther)19(e ar)18(e)56(, instead, infinite det)19(ails and possibilities each of which)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(e)19(xpands our under)19(s)1(t)19(anding, enriches our kno)19(wledge)56(, and can be a means f)19(or sup)-1(-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.005 tw
[(porting quality and accomplishment or insight f)19(or change and tr)18(ansf)19(ormation.)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(\(a)74(y)19(er)18(s)37(, 1992, p. 157-158\))]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 503.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
(in their book, )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 131.1448 503.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.021 tc
0.008 tw
[(narr)19(ativ)18(e in t)88(eaching, l)19(earning, and r)18(esear)19(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 312.8256 503.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0229 tc
(,)tj
0.51907 0 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(mcew)19(an and egan)]tj
-24.50163 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[((1995) describe the \322turn t)19(o narr)18(ativ)19(e\323 within educational r)19(esear)18(ch as one of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.134 tw
[(the most impr)19(essiv)18(e shifts in the hist)19(ory of the field. this shift fr)19(om an)]tj
t*
0.066 tw
[(assumption that the teacher is simply an instrument in the pr)19(oduction of)]tj
t*
0.014 tw
[(school achie)19(v)18(ement t)19(o a vie)19(w of the teacher as an intelligent agent in edu-)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(cating childr)19(en r)18(epr)19(esents a ne)19(w r)18(esear)19(ch per)19(spectiv)19(e of per)18(sonal agenc)19(y and)]tj
t*
0.008 tc
0.13 tw
[(empo)19(w)18(erment \(carter & do)19(yle)56(, 1996\). giv)18(en the r)19(apid emer)19(g)-1(e)-1(n)-1(c)-1(e)-1( )-1(a)-1(n)-1(d)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.043 tw
[(gr)19(o)19(wing perv)18(asiv)19(eness of qualit)19(ativ)18(e f)19(orms of inquiry that use narr)19(ativ)18(e)56(, it)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(seems useful t)19(o consider the potential of its application t)18(o envir)19(onment)19(al edu-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.011 tw
[(cation r)19(esear)18(ch, particularly in light of issues of quality that ma)19(y arise)56(. this)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(paper f)19(ocuses on methodological issues that char)18(acteriz)19(e the qualit)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch liter)19(atur)18(e and whether normativ)19(e criteria ar)19(e lik)18(ely t)19(o impr)19(o)19(v)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch. the paper dr)19(a)18(w)18(s on e)19(xperiences of edu-)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
(cational r)tj
4.18525 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.29297 0 td
(cher)tj
1.88277 0 td
0.0031 tc
(s)tj
0.84582 0 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
(who ha)tj
3.32146 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.48442 0 td
0.0031 tc
(e)tj
0.91992 0 td
0.003 tc
(used narr)tj
4.25606 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.56782 0 td
0.0031 tc
(e)tj
0.91991 0 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(methods in ar)19(eas such as)]tj
-20.6764 -1.20002 td
0 tc
0 tw
(teacher thinking and pr)tj
10.12915 0 td
(actice in envir)tj
6.07178 0 td
(onment)tj
3.36987 0 td
(al education.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 158.6704 301.8874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative in qualitative research )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 279.0874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(the study of narr)tj
7.32795 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.53359 0 td
-0.0055 tc
(e)tj
0.7585 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(is the study of the w)tj
8.60478 0 td
[(a)19(y)19(s in which humans e)19(xperience)]tj
-18.22482 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(the w)19(orld. it is as \322old as the hills)36(.\323 as a mode of thinking and feeling, nar-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.55494 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.85516 0 td
0 tc
0.077 tw
(uses st)tj
2.96577 0 td
(oried kno)tj
4.18756 0 td
(wing t)tj
2.74299 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.89228 0 td
0 tc
(attempt t)tj
4.04096 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.8922 0 td
0 tc
[(giv)19(e meaning t)18(o w)19(a)19(y)19(s in which)]tj
-18.48294 -1.20002 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(humans under)tj
6.20768 0 td
0 tw
(st)tj
0.71183 0 td
-0.009 tw
[(and the w)19(orld and communicate that under)18(st)19(anding t)18(o oth-)]tj
-6.91951 -1.20001 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(e)1(r)20(s)37(. as both a phenomenon \(i.e)56(.)1(,)1( )1(s)1(t)20(ory\) and a method \(i.e)55(.)1(,)1( )1(n)1(a)1(r)1(r)20(ativ)19(e)1( )1(i)1(n)1(q)1(u)1(i)1(r)1(y)1(\))]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
((see connelly & clandinin, 1990), r)tj
15.9397 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.28393 0 td
(cher)tj
1.87554 0 td
0.0013 tc
(s)tj
0.84407 0 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
(who use narr)tj
5.95666 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.5606 0 td
0.0013 tc
(e)tj
0.91816 0 td
0.001 tc
(under)tj
2.5437 0 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92236 -1.20002 td
-0.003 tc
(st)tj
0.71617 0 td
-0.011 tw
[(and it as a legitimate f)19(orm of kno)18(wledge)56(, an epistemological claim, which)]tj
-0.71617 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(is fundament)19(al t)18(o ar)19(guments about what counts as r)19(esear)18(ch (elbaz, 1983).)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
(if y)tj
1.34383 0 td
(ou belie)tj
3.30233 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.47089 0 td
-0.0104 tc
(e)tj
0.75364 0 td
-0.01 tc
(that narr)tj
3.66212 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.51367 0 td
-0.0104 tc
(e)tj
0.75354 0 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(is a linguistic f)19(orm uniquely suited f)19(or displa)18(ying)]tj
-11.80002 -1.20001 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(h)-1(u)-1(m)-1(a)-1(n)-1( )-1(e)18(xistence in situated action, then under)19(st)18(a)-1(n)-1(d)-1(i)-1(n)-1(g)-1( )-1(p)-1(e)-1(o)-1(p)-1(l)-1(e)-1<d5>36(s st)19(ories is a)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.058 tw
[(legitimate r)19(esear)18(ch t)19(ask \(p)56(olkinghorne)56(, 1995\). a)55(ccor)19(ding t)19(o bruner \(1986,)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
(1990\), narr)tj
5.01854 0.00001 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.55873 0 td
0.0008 tc
(e)tj
0.91764 0 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(inquiry can help us under)19(st)18(and r)19(easons f)19(or our actions)]tj
-7.49491 -1.20001 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
(which ar)tj
3.656 0.00001 td
-0.0074 tc
(e)tj
0.75656 0 td
-0.007 tc
0 tw
(motiv)tj
2.44412 0.00001 td
-0.007 tw
(ated b)tj
2.63525 0.00001 td
-0.0074 tc
(y)tj
0.77556 0 td
-0.007 tc
[(belief)19(s)37(, desir)19(e)1(s)37(, theories)37(, and v)19(alues)37(.)1( )1(t)1(h)1(u)1(s)37(, narr)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
-10.26749 -1.20002 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s describe liv)19(es using narr)19(ativ)18(es or st)19(ories of v)19(arious kinds and nar)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(r)19(ativ)18(e-r)19(elated methods such as case hist)19(ory)110(, biogr)19(aph)19(y/aut)18(obiogr)19(aph)19(y)110(, and life)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0 tw
(hist)tj
1.5503 0 td
0.135 tw
(ory which f)tj
5.1783 0.00001 td
(ocus on an individual within a social conte)tj
19.44418 0.00001 td
[(xt consider)19(ed)]tj
-26.1728 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(o)19(v)19(er time (see goodson, 1994).)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1383 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(141)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/length 6847
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 55 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
-0.007 tw
[(interpr)19(et)18(ation is inv)19(olv)19(ed, of cour)18(se)56(, in pr)19(o)19(viding convincing accounts of)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.019 tc
0.002 tw
[(what a st)19(ory means)36(, or so that it mak)19(es sense not only t)19(o the teller but the lis-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
-0.005 tw
[(tener)111(, particularly if the st)19(ory is t)18(old b)19(y a r)19(esear)18(cher/narr)19(at)19(or other than the)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.007 tw
[(author)111(.)1( )1(t)1(h)1(i)1(s)1( )1(i)1(n)1(t)1(e)1(r)1(p)1(r)19(etiv)19(e turn becomes a sort of double hermeneutic wher)19(e the)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.009 tc
-0.008 tw
[(ine)19(vit)18(able critics of qualit)19(ativ)19(e f)18(orms of inquiry begin asking questions about)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.006 tw
[(wh)18(y th)1(is )-1(pa)1(r)-1(ticular st)19(ory is being t)19(old, wh)18(y it w)19(as selected f)19(or r)18(etelling b)19(y the)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
[(narr)19(at)18(or)111(, what ar)19(e the motiv)18(es)37(, inter)19(ests)36(, and whose v)19(oice is silenced or priv-)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.008 tc
-0.009 tw
[(ileged, as w)19(ell as other questions that r)19(eflect on issues of r)18(epr)19(esent)19(ation and)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
(legitimation. )tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(answ)19(er)18(s t)19(o such questions ar)19(e not alw)18(a)19(y)18(s as definitiv)19(e as positivist crit-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(ics demand. st)19(ories)36(, f)19(or all that the)19(y)1( )1(r)19(equir)19(e v)19(erisimilitude \(p)56(olkinghorne)55(, 1988,)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0.008 tw
[(1)-2(9)-2(8)-2(9)-2(\))-2(,)-2( )-2(c)-2(a)-2(nnot pr)19(oduce the t)79(ruth. although narr)19(ativ)19(e is one of the fundament)18(al)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
-0.002 tw
[(sense-making oper)19(ations of the mind and perhaps the best windo)19(w int)18(o ho)19(w)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.007 tw
[(w)19(e think, and is f)18(oundational t)19(o learning \(see har)19(dy)110(, 1977; mcew)19(an & egan,)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(1)2(9)2(9)2(5)2(\))2(,)2( )2(i)2(t)2(s methods ar)19(e alw)18(a)19(y)18(s e)19(xplor)18(at)19(ory)111(, conv)19(er)18(sational, tent)19(ativ)19(e)55(, and inde-)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.001 tw
[(terminate\321all these in the modernist age of science that de)19(v)19(a)1(l)1(u)1(e)1(s)1( )1(s)1(t)20(o)1(r)1(y)1( )1(a)1(n)1(d)1(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(in f)19(act, v)18(alues nonnarr)19(ativ)19(e as a measur)18(e of sophistication in r)19(ationality)111(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.005 tw
[(the politics of r)19(epr)18(esent)19(ation and legitimation within qualit)19(ativ)18(e f)19(orms)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(of inquiry w)19(as br)18(ought int)19(o sharp r)19(elief in rishma dunlop\325)37(s \(200)55(1\) justification)]tj
t*
0.02 tc
0.118 tw
[(of the no)19(v)18(el f)19(orm of her doct)18(or)19(al thesis within the conserv)18(atism of a)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(canadian post-secondary institution. dunlop\325)37(s st)19(ory of e)18(xploring the landscape)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
(of alternativ)tj
5.15822 0 td
-0.0011 tc
(e)tj
0.76286 0 td
(f)tj
0.29519 0 td
-0.001 tc
(orms of r)tj
3.94507 0 td
0 tw
(epr)tj
1.40392 0 td
-0.013 tw
[(esent)19(ation and the v)18(alue of fictional narr)19(ativ)19(e as)]tj
-11.56526 -1.20001 td
-0.0001 tc
(a)tj
0.78232 0 td
0 tc
0.005 tw
[(legitimate contribution t)19(o \322kno)18(wledge\323 is r)19(eminiscent of m)19(y e)18(xperiences)]tj
-0.78232 -1.2 td
-0.007 tw
[(with gr)19(aduate 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛
 in r)18(epr)19(esenting aut)19(oethnogr)18(aph)19(y and other alterna-)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0 tw
(tiv)tj
1.06012 0 td
0.0016 tc
(e)tj
0.91842 0 td
(f)tj
0.29793 0 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
(orms of writing as legitimate f)tj
13.7364 0 td
[(orms of scholar)19(ship t)18(o the academ)19(y)]tj
-16.01287 -1.20001 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(\(see eisner)111(, 1997\). the pr)18(oblem of the narr)19(ativ)19(e pr)19(oject is that it runs the risk)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(of becoming an arbitr)19(ary set of pr)18(ocedur)19(es motiv)19(ated b)18(y political or economic)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(criteria \(conle)tj
6.01585 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.556 0 td
0 tc
(2000\). while ther)tj
7.57482 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77803 0 td
0 tc
[(is the need t)19(o gr)18(ound our r)19(esear)19(ch w)18(ork)]tj
-14.9247 -1.20001 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(in e)19(xperience)55(, as r)19(esear)19(cher)19(s)37(, w)18(e also need t)19(o demonstr)18(ate our a)19(w)19(ar)19(eness of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.044 tw
[(the limit)19(ations of our qualit)18(ativ)19(e methodologies)37(, particularly because each)]tj
t*
0 tw
(genr)tj
1.92505 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77774 0 td
0 tc
(or tr)tj
1.85068 0 td
[(adition has its o)19(wn inher)18(ent w)19(eaknesses (see hart, 2000).)]tj
-2.75347 -1.20001 td
0.041 tw
[(in our o)19(wn w)18(ork within canadian element)19(ary schools w)19(e struggled t)18(o)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(adapt our methods within an emer)19(ging and e)18(v)19(olving r)18(esear)19(ch design \(see hart,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.008 tw
(1996\). our f)tj
5.31251 0 td
[(ocus on narr)19(ativ)18(e inquiry as a w)19(a)19(y int)19(o teacher thin)-1(king about)]tj
-5.31251 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(envir)19(onment-r)18(elated element)19(ary school pr)19(actice became e)19(v)18(en mor)19(e comple)19(x)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
(when w)tj
3.37258 0 td
-0.0042 tc
(e)tj
0.75981 0 td
-0.004 tc
[(r)19(ealiz)18(ed that teacher actions w)19(er)19(e being driv)19(en b)18(y v)19(alues as much)]tj
-4.13239 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(as b)19(y subject matter kno)18(wledge)56(. in the end, w)19(e r)18(econceptualiz)19(ed our pr)19(ocess)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(of r)19(epr)18(esent)19(ation so that our interpr)19(et)18(ation of envir)19(onment)19(al education)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.058 tw
[(within canadian element)19(ary schools w)18(as e)19(xpr)19(essed in teacher)18(s\325 v)19(oices as)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(much as in our o)19(wn. ho)18(w)19(e)18(v)19(er)110(, our under)19(st)18(anding of the benefits of narr)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(w)18(as temper)19(ed b)19(y se)19(v)18(er)18(al limit)19(ations)37(. f)56(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, although narr)18(ativ)19(e allo)19(w)18(ed)]tj
0.0116 tc
(us)'
1.403 0 td
0.012 tc
0.127 tw
[(t)19(o delv)18(e beneath the outw)19(ar)19(d sho)18(w of human beha)19(viour t)19(o e)18(xplor)19(e)]tj
-1.403 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(thoughts)37(, feelings)36(, and intentions of teacher)19(s who appear)19(ed t)18(o us as agents)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(activ)19(e in constructing their o)19(wn curriculum, it w)18(as quite easy t)19(o succumb t)19(o)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(142)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/length 6344
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tw
[(the seductiv)19(e po)18(w)19(er of m)19(yth and fiction which ma)19(y ha)18(v)19(e been dist)19(orted or)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.007 tc
0.131 tw
[(concealed in the telling or the writing. our participant teacher)19(s simply)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(r)18(esponded t)19(o our intervie)19(w questions until w)19(e learned ho)18(w t)19(o engage them)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(\(sanger)111(, 1996\) in mor)18(e authentic tw)19(o-w)18(a)19(y )1(c)-1(onv)19(er)19(sations \(josselson, lieblich,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(shar)19(aban)18(y)111(, & wiseman, 1997; k)37(v)19(ale)56(, 1996; r)19(ubin & r)18(ubin, 1995\). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.009 tw
[(intervie)19(wing as a method \(see k)36(v)19(ale)56(, 1996\), along with other methods)]tj
-1.8 -1.20001 td
-0.014 tw
[(such as participant observ)19(ation and cooper)18(ativ)19(e inquiry \(her)18(on, 1996\), has)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[(e)18(v)19(olv)19(ed in f)18(orm and pr)19(ocess in the past fe)18(w y)19(ear)19(s \(bryman & bur)18(gess)37(,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.075 tw
[(1994; coffe)19(y & a)36(tkinson, 1996; cort)19(azzi, 1993; ten ha)19(v)19(e)55(, 1999; w)93(olcott,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(1994\). ho)19(w)18(e)19(v)18(er)111(, our o)18(wn appr)19(ach t)19(o method e)18(v)19(olv)19(ed as much fr)18(om our field)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(e)19(xperience as fr)19(om our r)18(eadings about method. w)93(e learned ho)19(w t)18(o listen bet-)]tj
t*
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(ter)111(. w)92(e learned t)19(o r)19(ecogniz)18(e st)19(ories f)19(or what the)18(y ar)19(e\321v)19(er)18(sions of r)19(eality that)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(r)19(esonate with the community (or do not). in seeking t)19(o unco)18(v)19(er and surf)19(ace)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(unconscious)37(, incomplete)56(, partially coher)18(ent, or implicit thoughts as narr)19(ativ)19(e)1(s)38(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.007 tw
[(w)19(e also learned ho)19(w t)18(o help teacher)19(s do that f)19(or themselv)18(es)37(, t)19(o accept crit-)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(ical appr)19(aisal, t)18(o r)19(ely on inter)19(subjectiv)18(e and negotiated under)19(st)19(andings that)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.035 tw
[(help us adher)19(e t)18(o r)19(easonable le)19(v)18(els of trustw)19(orthiness)37(. that is)37(, w)18(e learned)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(about methods and methodology r)19(ecur)18(siv)19(ely)111(, on the gr)18(ound, fr)19(om those ele-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.013 tw
[(m)-3(e)-3(n)-3(t)-3(s)-3( )-3(o)-3(f)-3( )-3(o)-3(u)-3(r)-3( )-3(n)-3(a)-3(r)-3(r)16(a)-3(t)-3(iv)18(e-oriented fieldw)19(ork that helped us mak)19(e sense of our)]tj
t*
-0.028 tc
0.011 tw
[(o)19(wn st)18(ories)37(, our belief)19(s)37(, and not only in terms of our o)19(wn thinking but in terms)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
[(of teacher)19(s\325 thinking about what w)19(as going on in those cl)-1(assr)19(ooms)37(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
(w)tj
0.85107 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.88501 0 td
0 tc
0.107 tw
(also learned about the import)tj
13.20636 0 td
(ance of conte)tj
6.02858 0 td
(xt and of the cultur)tj
8.68803 0 td
0 tw
(al)tj
-31.45905 -1.20001 td
0.056 tw
[(embeddedness of not only teacher)19(s\325 w)18(ork but also our o)19(wn. a)56(ccor)18(ding t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(bruner (1990) narr)19(ativ)18(e sensibility inv)19(olv)19(es kno)18(wing and r)19(ecognizing our o)19(wn)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(st)tj
0.71585 0 td
-0.011 tw
(ories within the m)tj
7.79974 0 td
0 tw
(yths)tj
1.76641 0 td
-0.0032 tc
(,)tj
0.53867 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(f)19(olklor)18(e)56(, and hist)19(ories of our cultur)18(e)56(. as fr)19(ames f)19(or)]tj
-10.82067 -1.20001 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(our identity)111(, narr)18(ativ)19(e inquiry ent)19(ails finding a place within one\325)37(s cultur)18(e)56(. the)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.03 tw
[(challenge is one of becoming conscious and critically r)19(eflectiv)18(e \(about, f)19(or)]tj
(e)'
0.47453 0 td
(x)tj
0.5114 0 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(ample)56(, ho)18(w envir)19(onment)19(al education fits or differ)18(s fr)19(om other curriculum)]tj
-0.98593 -1.20001 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(goals and pruposes\). the challenge is t)19(o r)18(ecogniz)19(e the beguiling natur)18(e of nar-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(r)18(ativ)19(e inquiry as a windo)19(w int)19(o consciousness because it ma)18(y mer)19(ely be a mir-)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.34224 0 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
(or t)tj
1.44033 0 td
(o)tj
0.79195 0 td
[(our o)19(wn. narr)18(ativ)19(e is as much a w)19(a)18(y of kno)19(wing our)19(selv)18(es as a w)19(a)19(y of)]tj
-2.57452 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.066 tw
[(or)19(ganizing and communicating the e)18(xperiences of other)19(s)37(. in our envir)19(on-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tw
[(ment)19(al education inquiries w)18(e came t)19(o see v)19(alue in some f)19(orm of inter)18(sub-)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0 tw
(jectiv)tj
2.09781 0 td
-0.0269 tc
(e)tj
0.7371 0 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(debate as essential t)19(o communication of other people\325)36(s narr)19(ativ)19(es about)]tj
-2.83491 -1.2 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(who w)19(e ar)18(e)56(, what w)19(e belie)19(v)18(e and wh)19(y w)19(e f)18(ollo)19(w one cour)19(se of inquiry)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.34352 0 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(ather than another)111(. ho)18(w else)56(, sa)19(y mcew)18(an and egan (1995), can w)19(e under-)]tj
-0.34352 -1.2 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(st)19(and the comple)18(x ment)19(al life of a teacher outside the narr)18(o)19(w instrument)19(alist)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(conceptions of thought and action?)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 149.279 110.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(finding our way in research method)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 87.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0155 tc
(as)tj
1.2889 0 td
(i)tj
0.5444 0 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(r)20(ead gr)18(aduate student theses or articles submitted t)19(o envir)19(onment)18(al edu-)]tj
-1.8334 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.014 tw
[(cation journals f)19(or publication, i am disappointed most often b)19(y the lack of)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1425 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(143)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/length 6658
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.011 tc
0.128 tw
[(attention t)19(o gr)18(ounding in methodology)111(. qualit)19(ativ)19(e methods r)18(equir)19(e as)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(much attention t)19(o det)18(ail as quantit)19(ativ)19(e inquiry)111(, although the pr)18(ocess is)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(quite differ)19(ent. unlik)18(e the r)19(ather unif)19(orm methodological assumptions of quan-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(tit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch, qualit)18(ativ)19(e inquiry consists of se)19(v)19(er)18(al distinct tr)19(aditions such)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.012 tc
0.127 tw
[(as ethnogr)19(aph)18(y)112(, phenomenology)111(, narr)18(ativ)19(e inquiry)111(, participat)18(ory action)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.001 tw
[(r)16(e)-3(s)-3(e)-3(a)-3(r)16(c)-3(h)-3( )-3(a)-3(s)-3( )-3(w)15(ell as critical, feminist, cultur)19(al, and postmodern per)19(spectiv)19(es)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.023 tc
0.007 tw
[(\(see)56(,)1( )1(f)19(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, denzin & lincoln, 1994, 2000; lincoln & guba, 2000\). each)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(o)3(f these genr)18(es has its o)19(wn par)19(adigmatic tr)18(adition of scholar)19(ship which)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.046 tw
[(tr)19(anslates thr)18(ough its ont)19(ology and epistemology int)19(o methodological ten-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.006 tw
[(dencies that, in turn, go)19(v)18(ern the choice and use of particular methods \(s)1(ee)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(schw)19(andt, 2000; vidich & l)36(yman, 2000\). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(it is the r)19(esponsibility of the r)18(esear)19(cher t)19(o gr)18(ound his or her methods in)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
[(methodologies)37(, each of which implicates a particular vie)19(w of kno)18(wledge as)]tj
t*
-0.001 tw
[(w)19(ell as of r)19(eality)110(. while it is not necessary or e)19(v)19(en desir)19(able t)18(o lock oneself)]tj
t*
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
[(int)19(o one narr)18(o)19(w str)18(and of methodology)111(, it is necessary t)19(o demonstr)18(ate)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(under)19(st)18(anding of the methodological basis f)19(or each method. some methods)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(ar)19(e mor)18(e compatible within cert)19(ain methodological fr)19(a)-1(m)-1(e)18(w)18(orks)37(. f)55(or e)19(x)18(am-)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(ple)56(, conv)19(er)18(sation as method is most lik)19(ely t)19(o r)18(esult in st)19(ories as dat)18(a \(florio-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.01 tw
[(r)19(uane)56(, 199)56(1\). this seems so obvious)36(, but w)19(e do indeed need t)19(o \322sw)18(eat the)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(det)19(ails\323 because the entir)18(e enterprise of qualit)19(ativ)19(e inquiry is pr)19(edicated on)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.005 tw
[(methodological critique and debate\321on critical r)19(efle)18(xivity and inter)19(subjec-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(tiv)tj
1.0474 0 td
-0.0026 tc
(e)tj
0.76134 0 td
-0.003 tc
(scrutin)tj
2.90684 0 td
0 tc
(y)tj
0.40544 0 td
-0.0027 tc
(.)tj
0.53926 0 td
(l)tj
0.4787 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(otz-sisitk)19(a \(200)55(1\), f)19(or e)19(x)18(ample)56(, r)19(ecounts the critical natur)18(e of)]tj
-6.13898 -1.20001 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(h)-1(e)-1(r)-1( )-1(e)18(v)18(o)-1(l)-1(v)-1(i)-1(n)-1(g)-1( )-1(q)-1(u)-1(a)-1(l)-1(i)-1(t)18(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(v)17(e inquiry pr)19(ocesses: \322i tell ho)19(w m)18(y r)19(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)18(ch design deci-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(sions w)19(er)18(e confr)19(onted and r)19(e-adjusted in pr)18(ocesses of r)19(eflectiv)19(e)-1( )-1(e)-1(n)-1(g)-1(a)-1(g)-1(e)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)]tj
-0.0002 tc
(.)'
0.55569 0 td
(.)tj
0.55569 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(.\323 (p. 13).)tj
0.68861 -1.2 td
0.039 tw
[(the import)19(ance of methodological gr)18(ounding is illustr)19(ated in p)56(almer\325)37(s)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(emer)19(gent envir)18(onment)19(alism pr)19(oject, particularly as it r)18(elates t)19(o adult  aut)19(o)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0 tw
(biogr)tj
2.08371 0 td
0.01 tw
(aphical r)tj
3.49919 0 td
[(ecall about cert)19(ain \322significant\323 life e)19(xperiences)36(. cert)19(ain per)19(sonal)]tj
-5.5829 -1.20001 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(life hist)19(ory e)18(xperiences w)19(er)19(e r)18(eported t)19(o ha)19(v)18(e been import)19(ant in construct-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.005 tc
0.133 tw
[(ing a sense of ecologcial identity \(thomasho)19(w)110(, 1995\) or envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
0 tw
(ethics)tj
2.4508 0 td
-0.0053 tc
(.)tj
0.53663 0 td
(se)tj
0.98982 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(v)19(er)19(al r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s)37(, w)18(orking within their o)19(wn countries)37(, participated)]tj
-3.97725 -1.20001 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(in pr)19(o)18(viding aut)19(obiogr)18(aphical narr)19(ativ)19(es which p)56(almer and suggate (1996) coa-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(lesced int)19(o mor)18(e gener)19(al r)19(eports about the import)19(ance of significant life e)18(xpe-)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
(riences in the emer)tj
8.88572 0 td
[(gence of \322)56(envir)18(onment)19(alism\323 among envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
-8.88572 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(pr)19(ofessionals)36(. my inv)19(olv)19(ement, w)18(orking with canadian participants)37(, serv)19(ed)]tj
t*
(as an intr)tj
4.00809 0 td
[(oduction t)19(o the politics of per)18(sonal kno)19(wledge \(see grumet, 199)56(1\))]tj
-4.00809 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(or the self narr)19(ativ)18(e \(see wither)19(ell, 199)56(1\). as carter and do)19(yle (1996) put it,)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.014 tw
[(one must learn ho)19(w t)18(o ferr)19(et out ho)19(w multiple interpr)18(et)19(ations of the mean-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(ings of social e)19(xperience come t)18(o position one\325)37(s identity as a teacher)111(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.005 tw
[(this line of r)19(esear)18(ch on significant life e)19(xperiences w)19(as part of a lar)18(ger)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.017 tw
[(set of ideas originating in the united st)19(ates in the early 197)36(0s \(see t)148(anner)111(,)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(1980 and spa)19(wning a series of r)18(eports fr)19(om widely separ)18(ated r)19(esear)19(cher)19(s)1( )1(o)19(v)19(er)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.008 tw
[(se)19(v)19(er)18(al y)19(ear)19(s \(see)55(, f)19(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, cha)18(wla, 1998a, 1998b; sw)19(ar)19(d & mar)19(cink)18(o)19(w)19(ski,)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
0.138 tw
[(1997\). ho)19(w)18(e)18(v)19(er)110(, it seemed that a r)19(esur)19(gence in the mid-1)-6(9)-6(9)-6(0)-6(s)-6( )-6(s)-6(p)-6(a)12(w)-6(n)-6(e)-6(d)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(144)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/length 7775
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tc
-0.003 tw
[(s)-3(e)16(v)15(e)-3(r)16(a)-3(l)-3( )-3(n)-3(o)-3(r)-3(th american associatio)-1(n)1( )-1(f)19(or envir)19(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)18(al education confer)18(e)-1(n)-1(c)-1(e)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0.058 tw
[(seminar)19(s and w)18(orkshops as w)19(ell as publications such as a special issue of)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 563.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.013 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 216.3738 563.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0034 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 221.7327 563.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(4)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 226.8917 563.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.014 tw
[((4), 1998. this r)19(esear)18(ch f)19(ocus on signif-)]tj
-15.38917 -1.20001 td
0.078 tw
[(icant life e)19(xperience gener)19(ated enough inter)18(est t)19(o support a set of critical)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.009 tc
0.127 tw
[(r)18(e)-1(s)-1(p)-1(o)-1(n)-1(s)-1(e)-1( )-1(p)-1(a)-1(p)-1(e)-1(r)18(s which w)19(er)18(e also published in )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 287.2653 539.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.009 tc
0.118 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
-21.42653 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(e)-1(s)1(ear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 110.1733 527.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0031 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 115.7399 527.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(5)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 120.902 527.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
0.007 tw
[((2), 1999. critiques came fr)19(om a r)18(ange of per)19(spectiv)19(es but each)]tj
-4.7902 -1.20001 td
-0.021 tc
0.004 tw
[(in its o)19(wn w)18(a)19(y challenged either the methodology \(as opposed t)19(o the method\))]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.02 tc
0.003 tw
[(or the epistemological or ont)19(ological st)19(ance implicit or e)18(xplicit in the r)19(esear)19(ch.)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.016 tc
-0.001 tw
[(whether w)19(e agr)18(ee or not with an)19(y or all of these critiques)37(, and )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 336.0657 491.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
[(envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
-26.30657 -1.2 td
-0.009 tc
-0.006 tw
[(education r)19(esear)18(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 155.1407 479.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
-0.007 tw
[(edit)19(or william scott invited wide participation in this dis)-1(-)]tj
-8.21407 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.005 tw
[(cussion, the point is that writer)19(s in the v)19(arious genr)18(es of qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch,)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.003 tw
[(in particular narr)19(ativ)18(e inquiry)111(, should be pr)19(epar)18(ed t)19(o e)19(xtend their discussions)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
[(about methodology and its r)19(elationships be)19(y)18(ond initial publication. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.022 tc
0.002 tw
[(critique is essential t)19(o pr)18(ogr)19(ess in the qualit)19(ativ)18(e inquiries of the social sci-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.068 tw
[(ences)37(. thus)36(, it is essential that r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s be pr)19(ecise about their method-)]tj
t*
0.127 tw
[(ological pr)19(actices and that the)18(y kno)19(w enough t)19(o anticipate or t)18(o mar)19(shal)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.001 tw
[(r)19(esponses in or)19(der t)19(o adv)18(ance the discour)19(s)1(e)57(, and hopefully the pr)19(actice of that)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.008 tw
[(f)19(orm of r)19(esear)18(ch. deeper qualit)19(ativ)19(e and narr)18(ativ)19(e inquiries int)19(o per)18(sonal think-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(ing and r)19(easons f)18(or pr)19(actice ma)19(y serv)18(e t)19(o pr)19(oblematiz)19(e curr)18(ent thought,)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.008 tw
[(risking that \322special r)19(esentment\323 that r)18(orty (1979) r)19(ecogniz)19(es ma)18(y occur when)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.01 tw
[(belief)19(s so centr)18(al t)19(o our desir)19(es ar)18(e challenged. this line of r)19(easoning applies)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.002 tw
(as much t)tj
4.03495 0 td
-0.0214 tc
(o)tj
0.77393 0 td
(r)tj
0.33002 0 td
-0.021 tc
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.17091 0 td
0.002 tw
(ch pr)tj
2.09941 0 td
[(actice as it does t)19(o pedagogy)110(. thus)37(, r)19(esponse t)18(o critique)]tj
-9.40922 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.004 tw
[(is essential. the r)19(esponse)55(, ho)19(w)19(e)18(v)18(er)111(, is mor)18(e plausible if the author)1( i)-1(s )1(ab)-1(le t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.029 tc
0.01 tw
[(demonstr)19(ate thor)18(ough under)19(s)1(t)20(anding of the methodological gr)18(ounding, t)19(o)1( )1(c)1(o)1(m)1(-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
-0.005 tw
(municate this under)tj
8.38457 0 td
0 tw
(st)tj
0.69348 0 td
-0.005 tw
(anding within the thesis or article)tj
13.89937 0 td
-0.0143 tc
(,)tj
0.52215 0 td
-0.014 tc
[(then e)19(xtend that line)]tj
-23.49957 -1.20001 td
0.009 tc
0.124 tw
[(of r)19(easoning about method be)18(y)19(ond the critique int)19(o a mor)18(e thoughtful)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.029 tc
0.009 tw
[(description or justification of pr)19(ocess\321a kind of self-critical anticipation of r)18(eac-)]tj
t*
-0.016 tc
-0.004 tw
(tion f)tj
2.16131 0 td
0 tw
(ollo)tj
1.47464 0 td
-0.004 tw
[(w)19(ed b)18(y a thor)19(ough engagement in the ine)19(vit)18(able methodological dis-)]tj
-3.63595 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
0 tw
[(cussion that should f)19(ollo)18(w)111(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(connelly and clandinin \(1990; clandinin & connelly)111(, 1994, 1995, 2000\))]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(intr)tj
1.48622 0 td
-0.011 tw
(oduce man)tj
4.77545 0 td
-0.0033 tc
(y)tj
0.77974 0 td
-0.003 tc
[(ideas within the genr)19(e of narr)18(ativ)19(e inquiry that appear use-)]tj
-7.04141 -1.20001 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(ful in pr)19(omoting r)18(eflection and intr)19(ospection. p)56(art of the difficulty)110(, the)19(y sa)19(y)110(,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(in writing narr)19(ativ)18(e is in finding w)19(a)18(y)19(s t)18(o e)19(xpr)18(ess comple)19(xity as w)19(e under)18(st)19(a)-1(n)-1(d)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
(it. r)tj
1.64624 0 td
[(esear)19(cher)18(s r)19(est)19(ory e)18(v)19(ents)37(, select cert)18(ain st)19(ories o)19(v)19(er other)18(s and do so with)]tj
-1.64624 -1.2 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(v)18(arying degr)19(ees of intent or ignor)19(ance of the pr)18(ocess)37(. the)19(y describe the dilem-)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
(mas as partly a pr)tj
7.59136 0 td
[(oblem of multiple i\325)37(s)37(, in other w)19(or)18(ds)37(, ho)18(w w)19(e can become)]tj
-7.59136 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(pluriv)19(ocal thr)18(ough as much disclosur)19(e as w)18(e can muster)111(, r)19(ecognizing whose)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(v)19(oice is dominant and eliciting our o)18(wn per)19(sonal qualities such as a concern)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(f)19(or ethical questions of trust and r)18(elationship. the risk, of cour)19(se)56(, is self-dil)-1(-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.005 tw
[(lusion and f)19(alsehood, those dirty little lies or genuine f)18(ailur)19(es of per)19(ception)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(that illustr)19(ate the import)18(ance of the inter)19(subjectiv)19(e quality of such inquiry as)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.01 tw
[(w)19(ell as turning a sharp ear t)19(o our critics b)18(y r)19(esponding t)19(o legitimate issues)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.137 tw
[(of narr)19(ativ)18(e smoothing and narr)19(ativ)19(e secr)19(ec)18(y)111(, absent pr)18(esences)37(, pr)19(esent)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(absences)37(, and blind spots b)19(y conscientiously discussing issues of selection,)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1425 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(145)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/length 6694
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
0.136 tw
[(silence)56(, fictions)37(, and other limit)18(ations of the indeterminate condition of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e inquiry and with some humility)111(, please \(jickling, 199)56(1\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 107.6152 544.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(issues of quality in qualitative research)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 521.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(giv)19(en the necessity f)18(or critique)56(, it seems appr)19(opriate t)19(o f)18(ocus on cert)19(ain issues)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(of quality that ma)19(y be useful in qualit)18(ativ)19(e f)19(orms of educational inquiry)111(, based)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(on our r)19(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)17(ch e)19(xperiences in studies of teacher thinking and childr)19(e)-1(n)-1<d5>36(s ideas)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.024 tw
[(in envir)19(onment)18(al education. although w)19(e ha)19(v)19(e tended t)18(o r)19(ely on narr)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.133 tw
[(inquiry because w)19(e belie)18(v)19(e that teacher)18(s w)19(ant t)18(o hear teacher)19(s\325 st)19(ories)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(ather than r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s\325 theories)37(, w)18(e anticipate that mor)19(e activ)19(e appr)18(oach-)]tj
t*
0.01 tw
[(es)37(, inter)18(activ)19(e and participat)19(ory)110(, ar)19(e mor)19(e lik)18(ely t)19(o addr)19(ess political as w)18(ell)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(as intellectual gr)19(o)19(wth and change)55(. w)93(e ha)19(v)18(e begun t)19(o e)19(xplor)18(e this idea in a ne)19(w)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.03 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch pr)18(ogr)19(am f)19(ocused on ment)18(or-pr)19(ot\216g\216 r)19(elationships and our r)18(ecent)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(e)19(xperiences and r)18(eadings will inf)19(orm this ne)19(w pr)18(ocess \(see hart, 200)56(1\). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.013 tw
[(a)74(w)19(ar)19(e of the danger)18(s of an o)19(v)19(er-r)19(eliance on narr)18(ativ)19(e)56(, w)18(e feel the need)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
(as r)tj
1.70315 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.29276 0 td
(cher)tj
1.8826 0 td
(s)tj
0.84564 0 td
(t)tj
0.29939 0 td
0.0031 tc
(o)tj
0.95693 0 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
(engage in conv)tj
6.83321 0 td
[(er)19(sations about our conceptions of the)]tj
-14.81368 -1.20001 td
0 tc
(w)tj
0.73348 0 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(a)18(y things ar)19(e)55(, our vie)19(w)19(s of kno)18(wing and our belief)19(s)37(, and about what f)18(orms)]tj
-0.73348 -1.2 td
-0.0186 tc
(of)tj
1.07884 0 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(consciousness w)19(e think adv)18(ance our under)19(st)18(anding and our pr)19(actice)56(. it has)]tj
-1.07884 -1.2 td
0.016 tc
0.123 tw
(been our e)tj
5.01352 0 td
(xperience that that which succeeds in deepening meaning,)tj
-5.01352 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.025 tw
[(e)19(xpanding a)19(w)19(ar)18(eness)37(, enlar)19(ging under)18(st)19(anding is in the end a community)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.138 tw
[(decision. so, conv)19(er)18(sations \(e)56(.g., confer)19(e)-1(n)-1(c)-1(e)-1(s)-1(\))-1( )-1(a)-1(n)-1(d)-1( )-1(w)-1(r)-1(i)-1(t)-1(i)-1(n)-1(g)-1( )-1(\()-1(e)55(.g., publica-)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
(tion\) can be an activ)tj
8.5078 0 td
-0.0126 tc
(e)tj
0.75137 0 td
-0.013 tc
(means of testing these ideas in the community)tj
19.61126 0 td
-0.0127 tc
(,)tj
0.52929 0 td
-0.013 tc
(that is)tj
2.52221 0 td
0 tc
(,)tj
-31.92193 -1.20001 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(if the climate e)19(xists that both supports the gr)18(o)19(wth of ideas in a v)19(ariety of w)18(a)19(y)19(s)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(and encour)19(ages critically r)18(eflectiv)19(e engagement about what w)19(e ar)19(e doing and)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0 tw
(ho)tj
1.02795 0 td
-0.0233 tc
(w)tj
0.99951 0 td
(w)tj
0.71718 0 td
-0.0231 tc
(e)tj
0.74093 0 td
-0.023 tc
(ha)tj
0.99108 0 td
0.009 tw
[(v)19(e chosen t)19(o r)18(epr)19(esent our w)19(ork. giv)18(en ne)19(w ar)19(guments about alter-)]tj
-4.47665 -1.20001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(nativ)19(e f)18(orms of writing \(see)56(, f)19(or e)19(x)19(ample)55(, dunlop, 200)56(1; richar)19(dson, 2000\),)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.005 tw
[(no)19(v)18(el seems a mor)19(e meaningful f)19(orm of r)19(epr)18(esent)19(ation, in terms of pr)19(acti-)]tj
t*
0 tw
(tioner)tj
2.53564 0 td
0.046 tw
(s\325 under)tj
3.54501 0 td
[(st)19(anding, than descriptiv)18(e narr)19(ativ)19(e or other f)18(orms of r)19(epr)19(e-)]tj
-6.08065 -1.20001 td
0 tw
[(sent)19(ation.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.001 tw
[(whate)19(v)19(er the f)18(orm, quality is par)19(amount; so ho)19(w do w)18(e judge quality?)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
(w)tj
0.8572 0 td
0.006 tc
(e)tj
0.92286 0 td
0.133 tw
[(need a pr)19(ocess thr)18(ough which r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s ar)19(e able t)19(o deepen )-1(their)]tj
-1.78006 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.017 tw
[(insight int)19(o their o)18(wn r)19(esear)19(ch v)18(alues as w)19(ell as de)19(v)18(elop their)1( capability t)18(o)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
0 tw
(tr)tj
0.64578 0 td
-0.004 tw
(anslate these v)tj
6.22981 0 td
(alues int)tj
3.51551 0 td
-0.0103 tc
(o)tj
0.79056 0 td
(r)tj
0.34108 0 td
-0.01 tc
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.22625 0 td
-0.004 tw
[(ch pr)19(actice)55(. this inv)19(olv)19(es under)19(st)18(anding the)]tj
-13.74899 -1.20001 td
0.011 tc
0.128 tw
[(epistemological assumptions underpinning v)19(arious notions of narr)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(inquiry)111(. can w)18(e accept f)19(orms of kno)19(wledge)56(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, that come fr)18(om an)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.033 tw
[(epistemology of pr)19(actice in which kno)18(wing comes fr)19(om within the action,)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(itself, wher)19(e kno)18(wing is pr)19(actitioner-deriv)19(ed r)18(ather than e)19(xpert-deriv)19(ed,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.02 tw
(and wher)tj
4.0936 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.79791 0 td
0 tc
[(gr)19(o)19(wth and change come fr)18(om pr)19(oblems of pr)19(actice that cause)]tj
-4.8915 -1.2 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(those inv)19(olv)18(ed t)19(o activ)19(ely r)18(eflect conflicts in v)19(alues? in teacher)19(s\325 minds)36(,)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(pr)19(ofessional kno)18(wledge is not a sy)19(stematically or)19(ganiz)18(ed body of theor)19(etical)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
0 tw
(kno)tj
1.6067 0 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(wledge)56(,)1( )1(r)19(ather a shar)19(ed body of inherited pr)19(actical kno)19(wledge\321a set of)]tj
-1.6067 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(v)19(alues)37(, pr)18(efer)19(ences and norms that mak)19(e sense in pr)18(actical situations)37(. )]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(146)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/length 7069
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 91 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(t)88(o act is t)18(o theoriz)19(e)55(, sa)19(y)19(s p)55(agano \(199)56(1\). i cannot describe m)19(y da)18(y or a)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(moment in m)19(y classr)18(oom without r)19(ecour)19(se t)18(o intentions or assumptions)37(. w)93(e)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(act in w)19(a)19(y)19(s that r)18(eflect our belief)19(s about the w)19(a)19(y the w)18(orld w)19(orks)37(. t)87(eacher)19(s)1<d5>]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(theories ar)19(e st)18(ories about the kind of w)19(orld w)19(e w)18(ant t)19(o liv)18(e in and about what)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(w)19(e need t)18(o do \(with childr)19(en\) t)19(o mak)18(e that w)19(orld. if r)19(esear)18(ch can be vie)19(w)19(ed)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(similarly)111(, as a social pr)18(actice)56(, then quality cannot be impr)19(o)19(v)19(ed other than b)19(y)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(impr)19(o)18(ving the r)19(esear)19(cher\325)37(s capability t)18(o r)19(ealiz)18(e their o)19(wn v)19(alues thr)18(ough their)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch pr)18(actice)56(. change in both cases comes fr)19(om critically r)18(eflecting on)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.012 tw
[(pr)19(actice in terms of the tr)18(aditions of thought that shape those pr)19(actices)37(. in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(this w)19(a)18(y r)18(e)19(vision of kno)18(wledge and belief)19(s occur)19(s inter)18(activ)19(ely r)19(ather than b)18(y)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(applying a univ)19(er)18(sal t)19(ool kit of theor)19(etical rules)36(.)1( )1(m)1(y)1( )1(s)1(t)20(o)1(r)1(i)1(e)1(s)1( )1(r)20(e)19(v)19(eal m)19(y)1( )1(v)19(alues)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.056 tw
[(and attitudes)37(, m)18(y sense of m)19(y o)19(wn car)18(es and r)19(esponsibilities)37(, whether as)]tj
t*
0.015 tw
[(teacher or as r)19(esear)18(cher)111(. t)88(o kno)18(w our)19(selv)19(es then becomes a teacher\325)37(s or a)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(cher\325)36(s primary obligation. education is meant t)19(o change people)56(, as is)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch; not thr)18(ough colonizing their consciousness but b)19(y bringing them t)18(o)]tj
-0.0001 tc
(a)'
0.77118 0 td
0 tc
-0.007 tw
[(place wher)19(e the)18(y can go on t)19(o mak)19(e up their o)18(wn st)19(ories \(p)56(agano, 199)56(1\). )]tj
1.02882 -1.2 td
0.024 tw
[(implied in telling a st)19(ory \(whether fr)18(om life or the imagination\) is that)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(meaning is deriv)19(ed fr)18(om our interpr)19(et)19(ation r)19(ather than fr)18(om rules \(of analy-)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(sis\). a)56(ccor)18(ding t)19(o p)56(olkinghorne (1988, 1989) and bruner (1990) w)18(e interpr)19(e)-1(t)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(s)1(t)20(ories fr)18(om their v)19(erisimilitude)56(, their lifelik)18(eness)37(.)1( )1(r)20(orty\325)36(s (1979) distinction)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(betw)19(een kno)18(wing truth v)19(er)19(sus endo)18(wing e)19(xperience with meaning is impor-)]tj
0 tc
(t)'
0.2703 0 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
(ant her)tj
2.90482 0 td
-0.0259 tc
(e)tj
0.73807 0 td
-0.026 tc
(because humans)tj
6.8541 0 td
(,)tj
0.516 0 td
(he asserts)tj
4.01253 0 td
(,)tj
0.51597 0 td
[(ha)19(v)18(e the ability t)19(o see connections with-)]tj
-15.81179 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.005 tw
[(out being able t)19(o pr)18(o)19(v)19(e them. in other w)19(or)18(ds)37(, st)18(ories of human e)19(xperience)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(\(i.e)56(., intention and action\) ar)18(e written with a differ)19(ent inter)19(est than whether)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.012 tw
(something is test)tj
7.35719 0 td
(ably right. the narr)tj
8.37062 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.55493 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.79026 0 td
0 tc
0.012 tw
[(inter)19(est is in whether it is belie)18(v-)]tj
-18.073 -1.20001 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(able)56(. bruner\325)37(s (1990) distinction betw)18(een tw)19(o fictions \(i.e)56(., tw)18(o f)19(orms of illu-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.139 tw
[(sion t)19(o r)18(eality\) is useful in thinking about our goal in narr)19(ativ)18(e or other)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0 tw
(interpr)tj
2.79613 0 td
(etiv)tj
1.48154 0 td
-0.0185 tc
(e)tj
0.74552 0 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(f)19(o)1(r)1(m)1(s)1( )1(o)1(f)1( )1(i)1(n)1(q)1(u)1(i)1(r)1(y)111(.)1( )1(r)20(ather than seeking univ)18(er)19(sal rules thr)19(ough con-)]tj
-5.02319 -1.20001 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(te)19(xt independence and objectiv)18(e v)19(erification, the purpose of most qualit)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.002 tw
[(inquiry is t)19(o under)18(st)19(and human e)19(v)18(ents)37(, within conte)19(xt, in such a w)18(a)19(y as t)19(o)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0 tw
(lea)tj
1.23156 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.48433 0 td
0.003 tc
(e)tj
0.91975 0 td
0.136 tw
[(r)19(oom f)18(or r)19(eflection \(perhaps critical r)19(eflection\) and inter)18(subjectiv)19(e)]tj
-2.63564 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(scrutin)19(y)110(. this lea)19(v)18(e)-1(s)-1( )-1(a)-1( )-1(p)-1(l)-1(a)-1(c)-1(e)-1( )-1(f)18(or multiple per)18(spectiv)19(es without succumbing t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(r)19(elativism. the plur)19(alism implied, sa)18(y)19(s bruner (1987, 1990), about what is)]tj
t*
0.015 tc
0.123 tw
(the right interpr)tj
7.36062 0 td
[(et)19(ation, is not settled b)18(y dogged insistence on cert)19(ain)]tj
-7.36062 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(absolute v)19(alues r)18(ather b)19(y a willingness t)19(o negotiate differ)18(ences in w)19(orldvie)19(w)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
0 tw
(\(i.e)tj
1.23447 0 td
-0.003 tw
[(., open-mindedness\) without loss of commitment t)19(o one\325)37(s o)18(wn v)19(alues \(or)111(,)]tj
-1.23447 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(indeed, their negotiation\). thus)37(, narr)18(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(v)18(e)-1( )-1(c)-1(a)-1(n)-1( )-1(b)-1(e)-1( )-1(v)-1(i)-1(e)18(w)18(ed both as a mode of)]tj
t*
[(thought \(a w)19(a)19(y of kno)18(wing\) and an e)19(xpr)19(ession of w)18(orldvie)19(w \(i.e)56(., ont)19(ology\). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.117 tw
[(the rightness of interpr)19(et)18(ation, while dependent on per)19(spectiv)19(e also)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.009 tc
0.13 tw
[(r)19(eflects cert)19(ain conv)18(entions of method \(which v)19(ary acr)19(oss genr)18(es fr)19(om)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.06 tw
[(ethnogr)19(aph)18(y t)19(o action r)19(esear)18(ch\), of what counts as e)19(vidence)56(, consistenc)19(y)111(,)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(coher)19(ence)56(. not e)18(v)19(erything goes: ther)19(e ar)18(e inher)19(ent criteria, not technical cri-)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(teria but ethical criteria, of rightness)37(, ethics)36(, mor)19(al v)19(alues which should)]tj
t*
0.008 tc
0.131 tw
[(come thr)19(ough clearly in the r)18(esear)19(ch pr)19(ocess as w)19(ell as r)18(etr)19(ospectiv)19(ely)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1425 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(147)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
12 0 obj
<<
/length 6708
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.008 tc
0.131 tw
[(thr)19(ough conscious)36(, critically r)19(eflectiv)19(e dialogue and debate)55(. y)80(ou cannot)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.047 tw
[(ar)19(gue f)18(or a particular interpr)19(et)19(ation, accor)18(ding t)19(o bruner)111(, without t)19(aking a)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.056 tw
[(mor)19(al st)18(ance and a rhet)19(orical postur)19(e \(bruner)110(, 1990\). qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(e)-1(n)-1(t)18(ails a disposition t)18(o e)19(x)18(amine assumptions underlying r)19(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)18(ch pr)18(actice in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(terms of the e)19(xtent t)18(o which the v)19(alues ostensibly guiding r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s w)19(ork)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(ar)19(e actually serv)18(ed b)19(y their pr)19(actices \(grundy)110(, 1989\).)]tj
1.8 -1.20001 td
-0.004 tw
[(in our w)19(ork with canadian element)18(ary teacher)19(s who engage their chil-)]tj
-1.8 -1.19999 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(dr)19(en in some f)18(orm of envir)19(onment-r)19(elated school activity)111(, the best w)18(e could)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[(do t)19(o under)18(st)19(and their thinking w)19(as t)18(o find w)19(a)18(y)19(s t)19(o enlist their help in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(interpr)19(eting their meanings)37(. making sense of teacher)18(s\325 and childr)19(en\325)37(s think-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.002 tw
[(ing about/f)19(or envir)18(onment w)19(as challenging because of the sheer intellectu-)]tj
t*
0.022 tc
0.136 tw
[(al t)19(ask of bringing t)18(acit pr)19(esuppositions and unr)19(eflectiv)18(e actions and)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(inter)19(actions)36(, those deep v)19(alue positions \(acquir)19(ed early in life\), t)19(o mor)18(e)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(conscious le)19(v)18(els of r)19(eflection and discussion. on r)19(eflection, w)18(e belie)19(v)19(e that,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.139 tw
[(as r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s)37(, w)18(e f)19(ocused on teacher)19(s\325 narr)18(ativ)19(e constructions \(i.e)56(., fic-)]tj
t*
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(tions\) because the)19(y constituted f)18(orms of e)19(xplanation that mak)19(e sense t)18(o their)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.133 tw
[(peer)19(s)36(. these st)19(ories-in-action communicated teacher)19(s\325 thought-pr)19(actices)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(amidst the messiness of daily life)56(. their colleagues described them as plau-)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(s)1(i)1(b)1(l)1(e)57(,)1( )1(c)1(r)19(edible)56(, belie)19(v)19(able; the)19(y appear)19(ed t)18(o be authentic)19(,)1( )1(w)19(e think, and)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.013 tw
[(trustw)19(orth)18(y)111(. but w)19(er)19(e the)18(y? ho)19(w could w)19(e as r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s discuss or debate)]tj
t*
-0.01 tw
[(the w)19(arr)18(ant of these st)19(ories? w)93(e must begin b)18(y trying t)19(o articulate our o)19(wn)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
(methodological r)tj
7.22441 0 td
(easoning, r)tj
4.74857 0 td
0 tw
(eflectiv)tj
3.06281 0 td
(ely)tj
1.14483 0 td
-0.0015 tc
(,)tj
0.54042 0 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(j)1(u)1(s)1(t)1( )1(a)1(s)1( )1(w)20(e e)18(xpect our teacher-partic-)]tj
-16.72104 -1.20001 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(ipants t)19(o engage their thinking/pr)19(actice)55(. ev)19(en that is not enough; w)19(e need t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(listen t)19(o our critics)36(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.023 tc
0.006 tw
(critique that t)tj
5.6176 0 td
0 tw
(ak)tj
0.95498 0 td
0.006 tw
(es r)tj
1.47048 0 td
[(eflection int)19(o the inter)18(subjectiv)19(e needs a language that)]tj
-9.84306 -1.20001 td
0.004 tc
0.132 tw
[(not only ackno)19(wledges the indeterminac)18(y and openendedness of social)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.005 tc
0.131 tw
[(phenomena but finds w)19(a)19(y)19(s t)18(o deal with their associated pr)19(oblems)37(. the)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.01 tw
(debate within the liter)tj
9.33183 0 td
0 tw
(atur)tj
1.67564 0 td
-0.0069 tc
(e)tj
0.75431 0 td
-0.007 tc
-0.01 tw
[(of qualit)19(ativ)18(e inquiry no)19(w questions whether w)19(e)]tj
-11.76178 -1.20001 td
-0.022 tc
0.005 tw
[(should be seeking criteria of adequac)19(y f)18(or \322good\323 e)19(xplanation within ackno)18(wl-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(e)3(d)3(g)3(e)3(d)3( )3(i)3(n)3(d)3(e)3(t)3(e)3(r)3(m)3(i)3(n)3(ac)19(y (see denzin, 2000; lincoln & guba, 2000). while this)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.007 tw
(debate is w)tj
4.89258 0 td
(orth f)tj
2.34437 0 td
[(ollo)19(wing, criteria of quality alr)18(eady e)19(xist within qualit)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
-7.23695 -1.20001 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(inquiry)111(, although differ)18(ences occur betw)19(een genr)19(es such as ethnogr)18(aph)19(y or)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(phenomenology)111(, and participat)18(ory (action) f)19(orms of inquiry)111(. genr)19(es themselv)18(es)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
0 tw
(ar)tj
0.8317 0 td
-0.0098 tc
(e)tj
0.75422 0 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(dynamic and e)19(v)18(olving so that the criteria of adequac)19(y f)18(or critical ethnog-)]tj
-1.58592 -1.2 td
[(r)18(aph)19(y or v)19(arious feminist or postmodern turns within ethnogr)19(aphic r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0 tw
(ma)tj
1.32083 0 td
-0.0248 tc
(y)tj
0.75823 0 td
-0.028 tc
0.011 tw
[(b)-3(e)-3( )-3(d)-3(i)-3(f)-3(f)-3(e)-3(r)16(e)-3(n)-3(t)-3(.)-3( )-3(t)-3(h)-3(e)-3( )-3(i)-3(m)-3(p)-3(o)-3(rt)18(ant point is that each of these r)19(esear)18(ch par)19(adigms)]tj
-2.07906 -1.2 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(a)3(r)22(e)3( )3(b)3(e)3(c)3(o)3(m)3(i)3(n)3(g)3( )3(m)3(o)1(r)19(e self-r)19(eflectiv)19(e in char)18(acter)111(,)1( )1(m)1(o)1(r)20(e critical some might sa)18(y)112(.)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(multiple v)19(alid e)18(xplanations of phenomena ar)19(e r)19(ecogniz)18(ed and e)19(xpected as ar)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(differ)19(ent types of e)18(xplanation, r)19(aising the possibility of alternativ)19(e)56(, perhaps)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.022 tw
[(competing claims \(bohman, 199)56(1\). but the question r)18(emains)37(, ho)19(w can w)18(e)]tj
t*
0.065 tw
[(gener)19(ate high quality)111(, meaningful qualit)18(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch without r)19(ecour)19(se t)18(o)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(objectivist or essentialist st)19(andar)19(ds? se)18(v)19(er)19(al appr)19(oaches ar)19(e possible)55(. in this)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(paper a narr)19(ativ)18(e interpr)19(etiv)19(e fr)19(ame)18(w)19(ork serv)19(es as a f)18(ocus)37(, giv)19(en the \322r)19(equisite)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(v)19(ariety\323 within qualit)18(ativ)19(e f)19(orms of inquiry (hart, 2000).)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(148)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
13 0 obj
<<
/length 5909
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 192.0195 587.4685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(whether criteria?)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 564.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tc
[(one appr)19(oach t)18(o issues of quality is t)19(o engage in r)19(econstruction of tr)18(aditional)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.014 tc
0.125 tw
[(objectiv)19(e criteria such as v)18(alidity)111(, gener)19(aliz)19(ability and r)18(eliability)111(, terms)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(alr)19(eady r)18(etheoriz)19(ed within se)19(v)18(er)19(al interpr)19(etiv)19(e par)18(adigms \(see denzin &)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(lincoln, 1994, 2000\). guba uses the term par)19(adigm or interpr)18(etiv)19(e fr)19(ame)18(w)20(ork)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(t)19(o describe a basic set of belief)19(s and principles that guide r)18(esear)19(ch methods)37(,)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(belief)19(s and feelings about the natur)18(e of r)19(eality \(i.e)56(., ont)18(ology\), what counts as)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.01 tc
0.129 tw
[(legitimate kno)19(wledge \(i.e)55(., epistemology\) and ho)19(w)1( )1(w)19(e should go about)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(studying and collecting kno)19(wledge \(i.e)56(., methodology\). a)56(ccor)18(ding t)19(o denzin)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.031 tw
[(and lincoln (1994), each of these interpr)19(etiv)18(e par)19(adigms w)19(ork against y)18(et)]tj
t*
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(alongside positivist and postpositivist models)37(. these models tend t)18(o w)19(ork with-)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(in a r)19(ealist ont)18(ology and objectivist epistemology)111(, hence quantit)19(ativ)19(e)55(, applied)]tj
t*
0.01 tc
0.129 tw
[(science methodologies \(which ma)19(y include rigor)18(ous defined qualit)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(methods\), wher)19(eas each of the interpr)18(etiv)19(e par)19(adigms tend t)18(o)19(w)19(ar)19(d r)18(elativist)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.003 tw
[(ont)19(ologies \(multiple constructed r)18(ealities\), interpr)19(etiv)19(e epistemologies)37(, and)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(natur)19(alistic methodologies \(e)55(.g., ethnogr)19(aph)19(y)111(, phenomenology)111(, narr)18(ativ)19(e)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.008 tw
[(inquiry\). whether critical theorists)37(, feminists)36(, or a v)19(ariety of poststructur)19(al-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(ists w)19(ould agr)18(ee with their inclusion within this fr)19(ame)19(w)19(ork, ther)19(e ar)19(e definite)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(par)19(adigmatic differ)18(ences among these genr)19(es of inquiry which ha)18(v)19(e become)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.041 tw
[(mor)19(e distinct and contentious in mor)18(e r)19(ecent iter)19(ations \(see)55(, f)19(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(,)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(kinchloe & mcl)19(ar)18(en, 2000; lincoln & guba, 2000; schw)19(andt, 2000\).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.034 tw
[(a)56(ccor)18(ding t)19(o lincoln and guba (2000), issues most often in contention)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.032 tw
(among both est)tj
6.72696 0 td
(ablished and emer)tj
7.98812 0 td
[(gent par)19(adigms include claims about the)]tj
-14.71508 -1.20001 td
-0.013 tc
-0.009 tw
[(n)-3(a)-3(t)-3(u)-3(r)16(e)-3( )-3(o)-3(f)-259(kno)19(wledge \(i.e)55(., epistemology\) ho)19(w kno)19(wledge is accumulated \(i.e)56(.,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
-0.004 tw
[(methodology\) and ho)19(w quality is e)18(v)19(aluated \(i.e)56(., quality criteria, v)19(alues)36(, ethics)37(,)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0 tw
(hegemo)tj
3.36666 0 td
-0.016 tc
-0.003 tw
[(n)19(y)1(\))1(.)1( )1(t)1(h)1(e)1(r)20(e is a need t)19(o)1( )1(e)19(xtend this analy)19(s)1(i)1(s)37(.)1( )1(h)1(o)20(w)19(e)20(v)19(e)1(r)111(,)1( )1(a)1(t)1( )1(p)1(r)20(esent, find-)]tj
-3.36666 -1.2 td
-0.032 tc
0.012 tw
[(ings ar)19(e typically pr)18(esented in terms of criteria such as cr)19(edibility)111(, tr)19(ansfer)18(ability)111(,)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.007 tw
[(dependability)111(, and confirmability)111(, although feminist, critical, poststructur)18(al, and)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.008 tw
[(cultur)19(al studies par)18(adigms add criteria r)19(elating t)19(o r)18(ace)56(, gender)111(, and class)36(, or)]tj
t*
0.058 tw
[(mor)19(e br)18(oadly)111(, oppr)19(ession, injustice)55(, and mar)19(ginaliz)19(ation. t)87(o f)19(ollo)19(w the dis)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.012 tw
[(cussions and debates thr)19(ough the r)18(esear)19(ch liter)19(atur)18(e is comple)19(x and be)19(y)18(ond)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
-0.001 tw
[(the scope or intent of this paper)111(. ho)18(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)110(, r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s in education \(and envi-)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.001 tw
[(r)19(onment)18(al education\) should be a)19(w)19(ar)18(e of the kinds of criticism that their w)19(ork)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
-0.003 tw
[(ma)19(y gener)18(ate fr)19(om the per)19(spectiv)19(e of these criteir)18(a and their association with)]tj
0 tc
(v)'
0.45659 0 td
-0.025 tc
0.005 tw
[(alidity)111(, r)18(eliability)111(, and gener)19(aliz)18(ability in the minds of some critics)37(. in f)18(act, se)19(v-)]tj
-0.45659 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0 tw
[(er)19(al per)18(spectiv)19(es on the issue of quality should be consider)18(ed.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 124.5532 123.0685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(new criteria for new perspectives on research)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 100.2685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tw
[(f)56(oundationalist-oriented r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s ar)19(gue that t)18(o assur)19(e confidence in the)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(findings of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch, st)18(andar)19(ds)37(, original)-1(ly par)19(allel t)19(o those of tr)18(a-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.078 tw
[(ditional r)19(esear)18(ch (see lincoln & guba, 1985, 2000) ar)19(e emer)19(ging, amidst)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1383 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(149)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/length 7005
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.139 tw
[(debates about appr)19(opriate w)18(arr)19(ants of quality \(see guba, 1990; phillips)37(,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(1987; smith, 1984\). a)37(t least within interpr)18(etiv)19(e \(including narr)19(ativ)19(e\) inquiry)110(,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(methodological rigor seems t)19(o be est)18(ablished in tw)19(o w)19(a)18(y)19(s)37(, trustw)19(orthiness)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(and authenticity)111(. although it is r)19(ecogniz)18(ed that interpr)19(etiv)19(e f)18(orms of inquiry)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.126 tw
[(ar)19(e based on axioms mark)18(edly differ)19(ent fr)19(om tr)18(aditional r)19(esear)19(ch, trust-)]tj
t*
0.004 tw
[(w)19(orthiness is defined in terms of elements that corr)19(espond, albeit r)18(oughly)111(,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(t)19(o internal and e)19(xternal v)19(a)1(l)1(i)1(d)1(i)1(t)1(y)111(,)1( )1(r)20(eliability)111(, and objectivity)111(. these elements\321)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(cr)19(edibility)110(, tr)19(a)-1(n)-1(s)-1(f)-1(e)-1(r)18(ability)110(, dependability)111(, and confirmability)111(, ha)19(v)18(e been used)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(t)19(o assess the quality of the findings of qualit)19(ativ)19(e inquiries)36(, in terms of their)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(truth v)19(alue)56(, applicability)110(, consistenc)19(y)111(, and neutr)18(ality (lincoln & guba, 1985).)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.08 tw
[(each of these criteria, f)19(amiliar t)18(o most qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s)37(, ha)18(v)19(e been)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(applied t)19(o justify narr)18(ativ)19(e inquiry)111(, although some e)18(v)19(olution fr)19(om ideas)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(such as triangulation (denzin, 1978) t)19(o mor)18(e comple)19(x r)19(enderings such as cry)18(s)1(-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(t)19(alliz)19(ation \(richar)18(dson, 1994\) has occurr)19(ed. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(wher)19(eas trustw)18(orthiness criteria ar)19(e applied t)19(o assess the quality of the)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(esults)36(, authenticit)1(y)-1( criteria such as f)19(airness)37(, and ont)19(ological educativ)18(e)56(, cat-)]tj
t*
0.016 tc
0.122 tw
[(alytic)19(, and t)18(actical authenticity f)19(ocus on the natur)19(e and quality of the)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch pr)18(ocess)37(. l)19(ess f)18(amiliar perhaps than the elements of trustw)19(orthiness)37(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.006 tw
[(these criteria addr)19(ess some of the limits of trustw)18(orthiness)37(, that is)37(, when it)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(is consider)19(ed in par)18(allel t)19(o tr)19(aditional aspects of rigor \(r)19(odw)18(ell & by)19(er)19(s)36(, 1997\).)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.013 tw
[(the)19(y also addr)18(ess issues of r)19(epr)19(esent)18(ation such as inquir)19(er bias)37(, multiv)19(ocal)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0 tw
(balance)tj
3.11941 0 td
-0.0229 tc
(,)tj
0.51902 0 td
(r)tj
0.32856 0 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
(espect, comple)tj
6.17383 0 td
0 tw
(xity)tj
1.42802 0 td
-0.0227 tc
(,)tj
0.5193 0 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(and potential f)19(or change and empo)18(w)19(erment that)]tj
-12.08814 -1.20001 td
0.022 tc
0.117 tw
[(ha)19(v)19(e been applied as social scientists ha)18(v)19(e e)19(xpanded what counts as)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(social/educational dat)19(a (lincoln & guba, 2000). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
(se)tj
0.95857 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.46049 0 td
-0.021 tc
(er)tj
0.80965 0 td
0.007 tw
[(al ne)19(w genr)18(es of qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch such as cultur)19(al studies)37(, life his-)]tj
-4.02871 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.01 tw
[(t)19(ory)110(, and postmodern f)19(orms ha)19(v)19(e engaged the f)18(oundational contr)19(o)19(v)19(er)18(sy in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(quite differ)19(ent w)18(a)19(y)19(s)36(. these \322ne)19(w par)19(adigm\323 inquir)18(er)19(s r)19(ely incr)18(easingly on the)]tj
0 tc
(e)'
0.48316 0 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
(xperiential, the embodied, and the emotiv)tj
19.02463 0 td
0.0019 tc
(e)tj
0.91867 0 td
0.002 tc
[(qualities of human e)19(xperi-)]tj
-20.42647 -1.20001 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(ence that contribute t)19(o the narr)18(ativ)19(e quality of life \(see ellis & bochner)111(, 2000;)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(fine)56(, w)92(eis)37(, w)92(eseen, & w)93(ong, 2000; richar)19(dson, 2000\). mor)19(e tr)18(ansgr)19(essiv)19(e)]tj
(f)'
0.2917 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(orms of v)tj
4.0512 0 td
[(alidity criteria such as l)19(ather\325)37(s (1993) notions of simulacr)18(a/ir)19(onic)19(,)]tj
-4.3429 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.004 tw
[(rhiz)19(omatic)18(, and situated v)19(alidity f)19(oster thinking about ideas of heter)18(ogene-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.004 tw
[(ity)111(, multiple path opening, and tent)18(ativ)19(eness in w)19(a)18(y)19(s that bring ethical and)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
(epistemological criteria t)tj
10.36201 0 td
[(ogether via pr)19(actices of engagement and self-r)18(efle)19(x-)]tj
-10.36201 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(ivity)111(. t)147(ak)19(en t)19(ogether)111(, accor)18(ding t)19(o lincoln and guba (2000), these criteria can)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
(act as w)tj
3.44837 0 td
[(a)19(y)19(s )-1(of)1( )-1(i)1(nterr)-1(u)1(pting)-1(, disru)1(pting, and tr)18(ansf)19(orming \322pur)19(e\323 truth int)18(o a)]tj
-3.44837 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(disturbing, fluid, partial, and pr)19(oblematic truth\321a poststructur)18(al and decid-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(edly postmodern f)19(orm of discour)18(se theory (p. 182).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.004 tw
[(these qualit)19(ativ)18(e e)19(xtensions of ideas about v)19(alidity ar)18(e link)19(ed t)19(o issues)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.01 tc
[(of v)19(oice)55(, r)19(efle)19(xivity)110(, and postmodern te)19(xtual r)19(epr)19(esent)18(ation \(lincoln & guba,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.003 tw
(2000\). the )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 86.6998 107.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
[(wa)-19(y)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 106.3325 107.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.003 tw
[(in which w)19(e kno)18(w)111(, the)19(y sa)19(y)111(, is most assur)18(edly tied up with)]tj
-6.9333 -1.2 td
0 tw
(both )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 59.3321 95.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(what)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 82.5725 95.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.008 tw
[(w)19(e kno)19(w as w)18(ell as in our r)19(elationships with our r)19(esear)18(ch partic-)]tj
-4.5573 -1.2 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(ipants)37(. in our narr)18(ativ)19(e w)19(ork with teacher)19(s and 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛
 in envir)18(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)18(al edu-)]tj
t*
-0.016 tc
-0.001 tw
[(c)-3(a)-3(t)-3(i)-3(o)-3(n)-3( )-3(w)16(e)-3( )-3(e)-3(ncounter)18(ed these issues of v)19(alidity as an inter)19(action of kno)19(wledge)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(150)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<<
/length 6180
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.03 tc
0.013 tw
[(\(i.e)56(., under)18(st)19(andings\) with mor)19(al v)18(alues \(i.e)56(., belief)19(s; hart, 1996\). w)92(e had a vie)19(w)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(t)18(o)19(w)19(ar)18(d e)19(xtending criterial st)19(andar)18(ds t)19(o)19(w)18(ar)19(d the postmodern as l)19(ather (1993))]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.001 tc
0.137 tw
[(and other)19(s seem inclined t)18(o do. but w)19(e tended t)19(o)18(w)19(ar)18(d lincoln\325)37(s (1995))]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(se)19(v)18(en \322ne)19(w st)18(andar)19(ds\323 pr)19(offer)18(ed as pr)19(ogr)19(essiv)18(e criteria. these \322ne)19(w\323 emer)19(g)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(ing criteria, which begin t)19(o addr)18(ess the epistemology/ethics ne)19(xus)36(, dir)19(ect qual-)]tj
t*
0.015 tc
0.124 tw
[(i)1(t)20(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s)1( )1(t)20(o)19(w)19(ar)19(d a)19(w)19(ar)19(eness of the positionality of st)18(andpoint)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(judgments)37(, specific discour)18(se communities \(e)56(.g., narr)19(ativ)19(e inquiry within envi-)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(r)19(onment)18(al education\) as arbiter)19(s of quality; v)19(oice)55(, or the e)19(xtent t)19(o which a te)18(xt)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.004 tw
[(has the quality of polyv)19(ocality; critical subjectivity \(or intense self-r)18(efle)19(xivi-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.139 tw
[(ty\); r)19(ecipr)18(ocity \(v)19(s)37(. hier)19(ar)18(ch)19(y\); sacr)19(edness; and privilege (lincoln, 1995).)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(that these criteria, and issues surr)19(ounding them, deserv)18(e mor)19(e debate is obvi-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.003 tw
[(ous as w)19(e enter an age wher)18(e w)19(e will see gr)19(eater emphasis on inquiry that)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(r)19(espects ecological v)19(alues)36(, community v)19(alues)37(, r)18(efle)19(xivity shaped b)19(y per-)]tj
t*
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[(sonal hist)19(ories)36(, and gender locations)37(, and democr)19(atic v)18(alues \(lincoln &)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(guba, 2000\).)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 113.1316 386.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(criteria without the labels: the quasifoundationalists)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 363.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.006 tc
(a)tj
1.05277 0 td
0.133 tw
[(second appr)19(oach t)18(o quality issues in interpr)19(etiv)19(e f)18(orms of qualit)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
-1.05277 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(inquiry seems t)19(o be t)18(o ackno)19(wledge the need f)19(or methodological scrutin)19(y but)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(without pr)tj
4.40107 0 td
[(escription of specific criteria. a)56(dmittedly a blurry ar)18(ea, occup)19(ying)]tj
-4.40107 -1.20001 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(gr)19(ound betw)18(een f)19(oundationalist criteria and antif)19(oundationalist esche)19(wing of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.003 tw
[(criteria, lincoln and guba (2000) couch the ar)19(guments in terms of the v)18(ar-)]tj
t*
0.057 tw
(ious debates about v)tj
9.04195 0 td
[(alidity as w)19(ell as postmodern ar)18(guments about inter-)]tj
-9.04195 -1.2 td
0.01 tc
0.129 tw
[(p)1(r)20(et)18(ation/r)19(epr)19(esent)18(ation. on the one hand schw)19(andt (1996), scheurich)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[((1997), smith (1993), and smith and deemer (2000) suggest that if v)18(alidity)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.133 tw
[(is t)19(o surviv)18(e it must be r)19(adically r)19(e)-1(f)17(ormulated. a)37(t issue is not so much)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(\322whether criteria\323 but what the natur)19(e of social inquiry ought t)19(o be)56(, whether)]tj
t*
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(it ought t)19(o under)18(go a tr)19(ansf)19(ormation, and what might be the basis f)18(or criteria)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(within a pr)19(ojected tr)18(ansf)19(ormation. w)93(e suggest fr)19(om our field e)18(xperience that)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.093 tw
[(elements of critical, participat)19(ory)110(, and postmodern per)19(spectiv)19(es on inter-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
-0.001 tw
[(pr)19(etivism, that intr)18(oduce dimensions of thinking fr)19(om dialogic)19(, pr)18(a)-1(c)-1(t)-1(i)-1(c)-1(a)-1(l)-1(,)-1( )-1(a)-1(n)-1(d)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(mor)19(al discour)18(ses as w)19(ell as notions of critical r)19(efle)19(xivity)110(, ar)19(e w)19(orth pur)18(suing. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.003 tw
[(these connections)37(, it seems t)18(o me)56(, ar)19(e particularly import)19(ant f)18(or envi-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
0.082 tw
[(onment)19(al education, because the epistemological and ont)18(ological under-)]tj
-0.35107 -1.2 td
0.018 tc
0.121 tw
(pinnings of cert)tj
7.29309 0 td
[(ain genr)19(es of qualit)18(ativ)19(e inquiry seem consistent with)]tj
-7.29309 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education\325)37(s socially critical and action competence aspir)19(ations)37(.)]tj
0 tc
(t)'
0.46226 0.00001 td
(r)tj
0.33727 0.00001 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(ansf)tj
1.74066 0 td
(ormativ)tj
3.25392 0.00001 td
-0.0139 tc
(e)tj
0.75009 0 td
-0.014 tc
[(methodological goals of inquiry)111(, such as participation, appear)]tj
-6.5442 -1.20002 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(t)18(o be implicit in dimensions of a ne)19(w ecophilosophical w)19(orldvie)19(w \(e)55(.g.,)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(holism\) underpinning much of envir)19(onment)18(al education. p)56(articipation, sa)19(y)19(s)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.5888 0 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
(eason (1988) is an implicit aspect of wholeness)tj
19.39933 0.00001 td
-0.0225 tc
(.)tj
0.51947 0 td
(p)tj
0.4958 0.00001 td
-0.022 tc
0 tw
(er)tj
0.80651 0.00001 td
0.008 tw
[(sonal gr)19(o)19(wth ma)19(y be f)18(o)1(s)1(-)]tj
-21.8099 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(ter)19(ed thr)18(ough social critique \(see fien, 1993; r)19(obott)19(om & hart, 1993\). \322my)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.002 tw
[(per)19(sonal belief is that our basic philosophical st)18(ance f)19(or a ne)19(w appr)18(oach t)19(o)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1383 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(151)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/length 6865
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(human inquiry . . . (is) part of a ne)19(w w)18(orldvie)19(w that is emer)18(ging thr)19(ough sy)19(s)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
0.095 tw
[(t)-8(e)-8(m)-8(s)-8( )-8(t)-8(h)-8(i)-8(n)-8(king, ecologcial concerns)37(,)1( )1(a)19(w)20(ar)18(eness)37(, feminism (and) education\323)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.028 tc
0.005 tw
[(\(r)19(eason, 1988, p. 3\). gr)18(eat potential deriv)19(es)37(, sa)18(y da)19(y)111(, calderhead and denicolo)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.011 tw
[((1993), when r)19(esear)18(ch par)19(adigm is complement)19(ary t)18(o the )1(vie)18(w of education,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.025 tc
0.003 tw
[(when methodology and w)19(orldvie)18(w align. it w)19(ould seem contr)19(adict)18(ory in a field)]tj
t*
0.002 tw
[(such as envir)19(onment)18(al education, which encour)19(ages the nurt)-8(u)-8(r)-8(i)-8(n)-8(g)-8( )-8(o)-8(f)-8( )-8(p)-8(r)10(o)-9(b)-9(l)-9(e)-9(m)-9(-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(solving, social activism and participation in social/envir)19(onment pr)18(oblems)37(, if)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(cher)19(s)1( )1(i)1(n)1( )1(t)1(h)1(i)1(s)1( )1(a)1(r)19(ea did not nurtur)19(e both human consciousness and)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(socio-political action in r)19(espect of educational r)18(esear)19(ch. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.032 tw
[(issues of discour)19(se-pr)18(actices)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
7 0 0 7 177.4545 482.2716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 184.4433 479.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.032 tw
[(in methodology par)19(allel and mer)18(ge with)]tj
-14.74433 -1.2 td
0.018 tw
[(issues of discour)19(se-pr)18(actice in ne)19(w par)19(adigm philosoph)18(y)111(. schw)19(andt \(1996,)]tj
t*
-0.013 tw
[(2000\), f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, pr)19(oposes a pr)18(actical philosophical  fr)19(ame)19(w)19(ork that can)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(act t)19(o tr)18(ansf)19(orm social inquiry just as aesthetic)19(, prudential, and mor)18(al r)19(e)-1(f)-1(l)-1(e)18(x)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(ivity can act t)19(o tr)18(ansf)19(orm society)111(. deep questioning \(i.e)56(., social critique\) about)]tj
t*
[(ho)19(w w)18(e shall get on in the w)19(orld leads)37(, in this quasif)18(oundationalist ar)19(gument,)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.009 tw
[(t)19(o criteria that guide social inquiry in seeking kno)19(wledge that compliments)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(and supplements r)19(ather than displacing la)18(y pr)19(obing of social pr)18(oblems)37(.)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(social inquiry as critique itself par)19(allels social critique as a mor)18(e pr)19(actical philo-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(sophical endea)19(v)18(or gr)19(ounded in a mor)19(al base of pr)19(actical wisdom. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.05 tw
[(ar)19(guing that absolutist criteria will ne)18(v)19(er e)19(xist f)18(or qualit)19(ativ)19(e f)18(orms of)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.01 tc
0.129 tw
[(human inquiry)111(, manning (1997) ar)18(gues that interpr)19(etiv)19(e inquiry is w)19(ell)]tj
t*
0.019 tc
0 tw
(serv)tj
1.85239 0 td
0.12 tw
(ed with \322)tj
4.29795 0 td
0.0187 tc
(a)tj
0.93549 0 td
(r)tj
0.37009 0 td
0.019 tc
(ange of questions and consider)tj
14.5078 0 td
[(ations fr)19(om which the)]tj
-21.96372 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.011 tw
[(r)16(e)-3(s)-3(e)-3(a)-3(r)16(c)-3(h)-3(e)-3(r)-3( )-3(c)-3(an est)18(ablish purposeful, conte)19(xtual and plausible studies \(k)37(v)18(ale)56(,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.007 tc
0.129 tw
[(1995; l)19(ather)110(, 1993, 1995; lincoln, 1995\). ho)19(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)110(, she sa)19(y)19(s)37(, f)19(ollo)18(wing)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.59486 0 td
-0.016 tc
0 tw
(eason (1996), these consider)tj
11.96959 0 td
(ations must st)tj
5.82638 0 td
[(art fr)19(om questions of e)18(xperience)56(,)]tj
-18.39083 -1.20001 td
-0.015 tc
-0.001 tw
[(need, and pr)19(actice as defined b)18(y the people with and f)19(or whom w)19(e ar)18(e w)19(ork-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
-0.002 tw
[(ing. this idea is congruent with schw)19(andt\325)37(s (1996) idea of \322guiding ideals\323 or)]tj
0 tc
<d2>'
0.37873 0 td
-0.009 tc
-0.007 tw
(enabling condi)tj
6.23356 0 td
-0.007 tc
[(tions\323 t)19(o be applied conte)18(xtually r)19(ather than as objectiv)19(e cri-)]tj
-6.61229 -1.20001 td
0 tc
-0.002 tw
[(teria. the pr)19(oblem with this notion is that it ignor)18(es the f)19(act that the meth-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.005 tw
[(ods)37(, as w)18(ell as criteria f)19(or judging them, emanate fr)19(om the assumptions of)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(the emer)tj
3.85483 0 td
(gent par)tj
3.53988 0 td
[(adigm. criteria can oper)19(ate within the conte)18(xt of a v)19(ariety)]tj
-7.39471 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(of methodological assumptions and in turn within epistemological and ont)19(o-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.028 tc
0.011 tw
[(l)-3(o)-3(g)-3(i)-3(c)-3(a)-3(l)-3( )-3(p)-3(e)-3(r)16(s)-3(p)-3(e)-3(ctiv)18(es)37(. thus)37(, just as w)18(e ha)19(v)19(e conflicting per)19(spectiv)19(es in ar)18(eas such)]tj
t*
-0.015 tc
-0.002 tw
(as envir)tj
3.26901 0 td
[(onment)19(al education, w)18(e ha)19(v)18(e r)19(equisite v)19(ariety in methodological per-)]tj
-3.26901 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.005 tw
[(spectiv)19(es among adv)18(ocates of similar r)19(esear)19(ch par)19(adigms \(e)55(.g., ethnogr)19(aph)19(y)110(,)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(critical ethnogr)tj
6.43535 0 td
[(aph)19(y)111(, aut)18(oethnogr)19(aph)19(y)111(, and so on . . .; hart, 2000\).)]tj
-4.63535 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(questions about qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch which appear on the surf)19(ace t)18(o be)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(methodological ar)19(e often gr)18(ounded in deeper differ)19(ences in the v)19(aluing of cer)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(t)19(ain f)18(orms of kno)19(wledge or vie)19(w)18(s of r)19(eality)111(. this leads us t)18(o question what con-)]tj
t*
0.01 tc
0.128 tw
[(stitutes the necessary conditions f)19(o)-1(r)-1( )-1(a)-1(d)-1(e)-1(q)-1(u)-1(a)-1(t)-1(e)-1( )-1(e)17(x)-1(p)-1(l)-1(a)-1(n)-1(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(o)-1(n)-1( )-1(w)-1(i)-1(t)-1(h)-1(i)-1(n)-1( )-1(e)-1(a)-1(c)-1(h)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(r)19(esear)18(ch par)19(adigm. p)56(atterns of e)19(xplanation ha)18(v)19(e e)19(v)18(olv)19(ed fr)19(om those cases that)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(e)19(xhibit featur)19(es of e)18(xplanation of that type \(e)56(.g., narr)19(ativ)18(e inquiry\). this dis-)]tj
t*
[(tillation of cases \(e)56(.g., significant life e)19(xperience w)18(ork within envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.042 tw
[(education r)19(esear)18(ch\) ma)19(y begin t)19(o f)18(orm a methodological cor)19(e that is then)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(152)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/length 6865
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(open t)19(o debate e)18(v)19(en as these methodologies e)19(v)18(olv)19(e and matur)18(e)56(. whether w)19(e)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(accept the conv)19(entions of these genr)18(es of inquiry)111(, depends on our per)19(spec-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.008 tc
0.131 tw
[(tiv)19(es on the r)18(esear)19(ch pr)19(oject. w)92(e can\325t o)19(v)18(er)19(come the indeterminac)19(y of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.072 tw
[(human intentions and belief)19(s thr)18(ough r)19(ecour)19(se t)18(o causality)111(, sa)19(y)19(s bohman)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(\(199)56(1\), so w)18(e turn t)19(o f)19(orms of e)18(xplanation which t)19(ak)18(e the indeterminac)19(y of)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.001 tw
[(social action \(or educational pr)19(actice\) as our st)18(arting point. our actions ar)19(e)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(open t)19(o multiple interpr)19(et)18(ations)37(, and conte)19(xtual v)19(ariations)36(, so each r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0 tc
0.006 tw
[(pr)19(ogr)18(am tries t)19(o build interpr)19(etiv)18(e and conte)19(xtual components int)19(o a theo-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(r)19(etical fr)19(ame)18(w)20(ork that mak)18(es sense and can be defended within the conte)19(xt)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(of that r)19(esear)18(ch par)19(adigm.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(it seems useful her)19(e t)18(o distinguish betw)19(een ar)19(guments about quality in)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.031 tw
[(the application of method \(within the methodological fr)19(ame)18(w)19(ork of a par-)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(ticipat)19(ory qualit)18(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch par)19(adigm\) and in ascribing salience t)19(o one inter-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(p)1(r)20(et)18(ation o)19(v)19(er another)111(. criteria ha)18(v)20(e e)18(v)19(olv)19(ed in r)19(elation t)18(o methods)37(, wher)19(eas)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(ne)19(w)19(er critiques question whether the act of interpr)18(et)19(ation itself can be)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(trusted. in our study of element)19(ary teacher)19(s\325 r)18(ationale f)19(or envir)19(onment)18(al edu-)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(cation, f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, ho)19(w successful w)18(er)19(e w)18(e in interpr)19(eting our thick descrip-)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(tions of envir)19(onment-r)18(elated activity in terms of teacher)19(s\325 t)19(acit mor)19(al v)18(alues)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.021 tw
[(and e)19(xplicit curriculum goals? w)92(er)19(e teacher)19(s consciously or unconsciously)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(e)19(xtending their per)18(sonal and social v)19(alues t)19(o include envir)18(onment)19(al v)19(alues? )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0.022 tw
[(although our appar)19(ent under)19(st)18(andings w)19(er)18(e gr)19(ounded within so called)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.019 tw
(thick description and rich te)tj
12.10589 0 td
(xt deriv)tj
3.29234 0 td
(ed fr)tj
2.005 0 td
(om the e)tj
3.84955 0 td
[(xisting fr)19(ame of narr)18(ativ)19(e)]tj
-21.25278 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
0.03 tw
[(i)-3(n)-3(q)-3(u)-3(i)-3(r)-3(y)-3( )-3(\()-3(s)-3(e)-3(e hart, 1996\), w)18(e ar)19(e cautious about our interpr)19(et)18(ations)37(. w)93(e use)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
0.002 tw
[(methods which w)19(e think can help us t)18(o specify)111(, f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, ho)19(w per)18(sonal life)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0 tw
(hist)tj
1.5144 0 td
0.025 tw
(ory or significant life e)tj
9.64174 0 td
0 tw
(xperiences)tj
4.59166 0 td
-0.0057 tc
(,)tj
0.56918 0 td
-0.006 tc
0.025 tw
[(within cultur)19(al boundaries)36(, ma)19(y ha)19(v)18(e)]tj
-16.31698 -1.20001 td
-0.032 tc
0.013 tw
[(influenced belief f)19(o)1(r)1(m)1(a)1(t)1(i)1(o)1(n)1(.)1( )1(w)94(e)1( )1(p)1(r)19(esent findings which appear t)19(o)1( )1(p)1(o)1(i)1(n)1(t)1( )1(a)1(s)1( )1(m)1(u)1(c)1(h)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.052 tw
[(t)18(o aesthetic as cognitiv)19(e r)19(easons/intentions f)18(or envir)19(onment)19(al education in)]tj
t*
0.048 tw
(canadian schools in the absence of a specific curriculum mandate)tj
28.59303 0 td
-0.0058 tc
(.)tj
0.5925 0 td
(w)tj
0.84568 0 td
-0.0057 tc
(e)tj
0.81471 0 td
-0.006 tc
0 tw
[(try)111(,)]tj
-30.84593 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
-0.014 tw
[(r)21(e)3(f)3(l)4(e)21(x)3(i)3(v)22(e)3(l)3(y)114(,)3( )3(t)21(o)3( )3(r)22(ecogniz)19(e limits t)18(o our interpr)19(et)19(ation within our o)18(wn per)19(sonal)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.013 tw
[(biases and conte)19(xt but r)18(ecogniz)19(e that such interpr)19(et)19(ations can only be e)18(v)19(al-)]tj
t*
-0.004 tw
(uated inter)tj
4.65011 0 td
0 tw
(subjectiv)tj
3.75238 0 td
-0.004 tw
[(ely\321in light of other interpr)19(et)19(ations \(whether b)18(y partic-)]tj
-8.40249 -1.20001 td
-0.021 tc
0.005 tw
[(ipants or critics\). as r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s)37(,)1( )1(w)20(e must ackno)19(wledge the possibility of other)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0 tw
[((multiple) interpr)19(et)19(ations)36(, based on other \(cultur)19(al, par)19(adigmatic\) r)19(ealities)36(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.48433 0 td
0.0162 tc
(o)tj
0.97276 0 td
0.016 tc
0.125 tw
[(question whether w)19(e can r)18(ecogniz)19(e better interpr)19(et)18(ations fr)19(om)]tj
-3.25709 -1.2 td
0.008 tc
0.134 tw
[(w)19(o)1(r)20(se interpr)19(et)18(ations seems the r)19(esponsible cour)18(s)1(e)57(. giv)19(en the assump-)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.016 tw
(tions of r)tj
3.92942 0 td
[(esponsible methodological and ethical applications and ackno)18(wl-)]tj
-3.92942 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.005 tw
[(edging our under)19(st)18(anding \(or lack ther)19(eof\) of the social theories that w)19(e think)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.008 tw
[(ha)19(v)19(e inf)18(ormed our interpr)19(et)19(ation within these lar)18(ger conte)19(xts of e)19(vidence and)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.009 tw
[(r)18(esponsibility)111(, w)19(e pr)18(oceed in the best w)19(a)18(y)19(s w)18(e kno)19(w)111(. in)-1(s)1(tead )-1(of)1( a)-1( nihilist post-)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.009 tw
[(modern a)19(v)19(oidance of interpr)18(etiv)19(e indeterminac)19(y w)18(e attempt t)19(o e)19(xtend and)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0.007 tw
[(integr)19(ate our macr)18(o and micr)19(o le)19(v)18(els of e)19(xplanation\321not only intr)19(ospectiv)19(ely)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.085 tw
[(but b)19(y encour)18(aging social critique ar)19(ound our e)19(xplicit \(t)18(o the best of our)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(k)-2(n)-2(o)17(w)-2(l)-3(edge\) pr)19(actical criteria \(r)19(ather than technical, objectiv)18(e criteria\). and then)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(w)19(e w)19(ait, hoping that our w)18(ork at least w)19(arr)19(ants comment)18(ary)111(. )]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1425 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(153)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/length 6359
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 55 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(c)1(r)1(i)1(t)1(i)1(c)1(i)1(s)1(m)1( )1(m)1(a)20(y)1( )1(f)19(o)1(l)1(l)1(o)20(w and, if not center)19(ed on adher)18(e)1(n)1(c)1(e)1( )1(i)1(s)1(s)1(u)1(e)1(s)1( )1(r)20(elating t)19(o)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.108 tw
[(criteria, ma)19(y t)18(ak)19(e the f)19(orm of r)18(easoned questioning. the best criticisms)37(,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.002 tw
[(accor)19(ding t)18(o bohman, \(199)56(1\), ar)19(e the most complete)56(, being w)18(ell fr)19(amed in)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(terms of ont)19(ology \(e)56(.g., r)18(elativism v)19(s)37(. r)18(ealism\); epistemology \(e)56(.g., subjectivism)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.088 tw
[(v)19(s)37(. objectivism\); methodology \(e)56(.g., positivism-interpr)18(etivism-critical-post-)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(modernism\). the)19(y should be gener)18(ativ)19(e)56(, pointing t)18(o)19(w)19(ar)19(ds emancipat)18(ory)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
[(dir)19(ections b)18(y pr)19(o)18(viding insights int)19(o coer)19(cion, po)18(w)19(er r)18(elations)37(, and con-)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
[(tr)19(ol. the)18(y should suggest pr)19(actical alternativ)19(es f)18(or per)19(sonal gr)19(o)19(wth and)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.138 tw
[(social change)56(, perhaps tr)19(ansf)18(orming e)19(xisting thought and pr)19(actice)56(. the)18(y)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(should r)19(espect the r)18(ole of agents in altering their o)19(wn cir)19(cumst)18(ances and con-)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(ditions of social life)56(. just because social agenc)18(y e)19(v)19(ades all attempts t)18(o disco)19(v)19(er)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(determinate la)19(w)18(s or theories doesn\325t pr)19(eclude the possibility of constructing)]tj
t*
0.008 tc
0.131 tw
[(adequate and fruitful e)19(xplanations that can fulfill a v)18(ariety of purposes)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(\(bohman, 199)56(1\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 110.2148 398.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(what would we do without criteria?)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 377.0616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(methodology is t)19(oo import)19(a)-1(n)-1(t)-1( )-1(t)17(o be left t)19(o methodologists)37(. \(beck)19(er in a)55(d)-1(e)-1(l)-1(m)-1(a)-1(n)-1(,)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
0 tc
0 tw
(1989, p. 173\))tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 344.0616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.008 tc
-0.009 tw
[(w)-3(ithin a br)19(oad fr)18(ame)19(w)19(ork of inter)18(activ)19(e critique)56(, bochner\325)37(s \(200)55(1\) r)19(esponse)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.002 tc
0.134 tw
[(t)19(o critics of per)18(sonal narr)19(ativ)19(e illustr)18(ate ho)19(w r)19(esear)18(ch ma)19(y be defended)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.002 tw
[(without dir)19(ect r)18(ecour)19(se t)19(o criteria. he contends that conflicts o)18(v)19(er criteria usu-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.008 tw
(ally boil do)tj
4.7052 0 td
[(wn t)19(o differ)18(ences in v)19(alues that ar)19(e contingent on human choic-)]tj
-4.7052 -1.2 td
0.089 tw
[(es)37(. conv)18(er)19(sations f)19(ocusing on criteria, sa)18(y)19(s bochner (2000), ha)19(v)19(e as their)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.007 tw
[(subte)19(xt a t)18(acit desir)19(e t)19(o authoriz)18(e or legislate a pr)19(e-e)19(xisting or st)18(atic set of st)19(an-)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.004 tw
[(dar)19(ds that will thw)18(art subjectivity and ensur)19(e r)19(ationality)110(. such criteria, he sa)19(y)19(s)37(,)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.007 tw
[(distr)19(act us fr)18(om figuring out ho)19(w t)18(o k)19(eep the conv)19(er)18(sation going \(with teach-)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.004 tw
[(er)19(s\) without inv)18(alidating the import)19(ant differ)19(ences that separ)19(ate us)37(, so that w)18(e)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.002 tw
[(can imagine and cr)19(eate better w)19(a)18(y)19(s of teaching \(about/f)19(or/thr)18(ough envir)19(on-)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.003 tw
[(ment)19(al education\) and of living in this w)18(orld. the w)19(or)19(d criteria itself separ)18(ates)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.009 tw
[(f)19(oundationalists fr)18(om anti-f)19(oundationalists \(and modernists fr)19(om postmod-)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
0.137 tw
[(ernists\) in terms of ho)19(w w)18(e mak)19(e choices about quality)111(, that is thr)18(ough)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.013 tw
[(objectiv)19(e methods or mor)18(e subjectiv)19(ely thr)19(ough our v)19(alues)36(. until w)19(e r)19(ecog-)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0 tw
(niz)tj
1.20871 0 td
-0.0228 tc
(e)tj
0.73842 0 td
-0.023 tc
0.006 tw
[(these differ)19(ences as a r)18(eflection of incommensur)19(able w)19(a)18(y)19(s of seeing, sa)18(y)19(s)]tj
-1.94713 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(bochner (2000), w)tj
7.93404 0 td
-0.0029 tc
(e)tj
0.7723 0 td
-0.003 tc
[(cannot begin t)19(o engage in meaningful conv)19(er)18(sation.)]tj
-6.90634 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(f)56(or anti- or non-f)18(oundationalists)37(, v)19(alidity depends on belief)18(s and v)19(alues)37(.)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
(bochner \(200)tj
5.75311 0 td
[(1\) ar)19(gues that, in the f)18(ace of plur)19(ality of the r)19(esear)19(ch field and)]tj
-5.75311 -1.20001 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(the messiness and comple)19(xity of human thought and social inter)18(actions)37(, w)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(should not be surprised at the impossibility of a single st)19(andar)19(d set of criteria.)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.051 tw
(it is mor)tj
3.729 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.8283 0 td
(pr)tj
0.9071 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(oductiv)tj
3.14746 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.8283 0 td
(t)tj
0.29621 0.00001 td
-0.0029 tc
(o)tj
0.85975 0 td
-0.003 tc
0.051 tw
[(appr)19(oach quality issues in r)18(esear)19(ch, fr)19(om the per-)]tj
-10.596 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.011 tw
[(spectiv)19(e that a multiplicity of goals imply multiple w)19(a)18(y)19(s of assessing qualit)-3(y)108(.)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(ther)19(e is no one right w)18(a)19(y t)19(o do r)18(esear)19(ch. ther)19(e is no one right w)18(a)19(y t)19(o)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
(assess it. y)tj
4.4975 0 td
(ou cannot emplo)tj
7.11716 0.00001 td
-0.0118 tc
(y)tj
0.77113 0 td
-0.012 tc
0 tw
(tr)tj
0.64279 0.00001 td
-0.002 tw
[(aditional empiricist st)19(andar)18(ds t)19(o point out the)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(154)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
19 0 obj
<<
/length 6750
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(f)19(ailur)18(es of interpr)19(etiv)19(e)56(, critical, or postmodern appr)18(oaches)37(. questions about)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.037 tw
[(h)19(ypotheses)37(, r)18(andom samples)37(, dat)19(a analy)18(ses)37(, and conclusions ar)19(e inappr)18(o)1(-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tw
[(priate)56(, naiv)18(e)56(, and perhaps e)19(v)19(en ignor)19(ant (see also, hart, 2000). )]tj
1.8 -1.20001 td
-0.014 tc
[(fr)19(om our o)18(wn r)19(esear)19(ch per)18(spectiv)19(e within envir)19(onment)18(al education, our)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.002 tw
[(under)19(st)18(anding teacher thinking could not be depicted within a language of)]tj
t*
-0.013 tw
[(objectivity because it e)19(xisted as a mor)18(al discour)19(se of community)111(. narr)18(ativ)19(e)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(inquiry)111(, that is)36(, the st)19(oried natur)19(e of such inquiry)110(, has a pr)19(actical, ethical f)19(ocus)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(on mor)19(al r)18(esponsibility)111(. this places narr)19(ativ)19(e in the service of a purpose that)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(is differ)19(ent fr)18(om the analy)19(sis of social f)19(acts)37(. p)55(olkinghorne (1995) mak)19(es a sim-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(ilar distinction betw)19(een narr)19(ativ)18(e analy)19(sis and analy)19(sis of narr)18(ativ)19(e)56(. our inter-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.007 tw
[(est w)19(as not in turning st)18(ories of teacher discour)19(ses-pr)19(actices int)18(o concepts)37(,)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(or theories)37(, or the gr)18(ounds f)19(or e)19(xplicating f)18(orms of social action. r)19(ather)111(, w)18(e)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(r)19(egar)19(ded teacher thinking as a means of dialogue f)19(or the benefit of educat)19(o)1(r)19(s)38(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.007 tw
[(and in e)19(xploring the possibilities of theorizing with st)18(ories instead of about)]tj
t*
0 tw
(them. )tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.002 tw
[(similarly)111(, in m)18(y aut)19(obiogr)19(aphical w)18(ork with envir)19(onment)19(al pr)18(ofession-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.092 tw
[(als that led t)19(o ideas about the import)18(ance of early life e)19(xperiences)37(, \(e)56(.g.,)]tj
t*
0.009 tc
0.13 tw
[(p)56(almer)110(, suggate)56(, r)19(obott)18(om, & hart, 1999\) m)19(y inter)19(est w)18(as in the con-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.006 tw
[(structed, e)19(v)18(olving, contested natur)19(e of per)19(sonal narr)19(ativ)18(es)37(. this type of life)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(hist)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch should not be construed as an attempt at unif)18(ormity about)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.03 tw
[(ho)19(w w)18(e come t)19(o be envir)18(onment)19(ally sensitiv)19(e or ecologically conscious)37(. if)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
0 tw
(ther)tj
1.70584 0 td
-0.0041 tc
(e)tj
0.75985 0 td
(is)tj
0.9407 0 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
(no agr)tj
2.70559 0 td
(eement on goals)tj
7.03102 0 td
-0.0041 tc
(,)tj
0.53786 0 td
-0.004 tc
(that is whether t)tj
6.95736 0 td
-0.0042 tc
(o)tj
0.79676 0 td
-0.004 tc
[(tr)19(eat st)18(ory as e)19(vidence or)]tj
-21.43497 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.001 tw
[(as a means of being with other)19(s \(what jackson [1995] calls an under)18(st)19(and-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(ing\) it mak)19(es no sense t)18(o ar)19(gue o)19(v)19(er who is right or what is the best method.)]tj
0 tc
(w)'
0.85107 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77134 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(ar)tj
0.85111 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77132 0 td
0 tc
-0.006 tw
(not scientists seeking la)tj
10.20115 0 td
[(w)19(s that go)19(v)18(ern our beha)19(viour)111(, sa)18(y)19(s bochner)]tj
-13.44599 -1.20001 td
-0.012 tw
[(\(200)56(1\); w)18(e ar)19(e st)19(oryteller)18(s seeking meanings that ma)19(y help us t)19(o cope with)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tw
[(our cir)19(cumst)18(ances)37(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
(de)tj
1.17951 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.47843 0 td
-0.003 tc
0.03 tw
[(eloping ne)19(w images of v)18(alidity ma)19(y simply perpetuate an inappr)19(o-)]tj
-3.45794 -1.20001 td
-0.022 tc
0.005 tw
[(priate quest f)19(or quality)110(. should w)19(e r)19(ather f)18(ocus on ethical/mor)19(al concerns such)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0.003 tw
[(as dialogue betw)19(een r)19(esear)18(cher and participants \(about, f)19(or e)19(x)19(ample)55(, whether)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.026 tw
(the inquiry pr)tj
5.92 0 td
(ocess and/or the findings w)tj
11.8799 0 td
[(er)19(e r)18(espectful and appr)19(eciativ)19(e of)]tj
-17.7999 -1.20001 td
-0.004 tc
-0.013 tw
[(teacher)19(s\). ellsw)18(orth (1989) ar)19(gues f)19(or local kno)18(wing, local v)19(alidity)111(, and local)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.011 tw
[(choices)37(. it is in the peculiarities \(the differ)18(e)-1(n)-1(c)-1(e)-1(s)-1(\))-1( )-1(o)-1(f)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1( )-1(l)-1(o)-1(c)-1(a)-1(l)-1( )-1(m)-1(o)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)-1( )-1(w)-1(h)-1(e)-1(r)18(e)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
0 tw
(import)tj
2.86053 0 td
-0.009 tw
[(ant choices ar)19(e made (see scheurich, 1997). other)18(s \(noddings)37(, 1992;)]tj
-2.86053 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
0.002 tw
[(white)56(, 199)56(1\) ar)18(gue f)19(or an attitude of attentiv)19(e car)19(e)56(, a willingness t)18(o hold open)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.006 tw
(an inter)tj
3.2626 0 td
[(subjectiv)19(e space t)18(o allo)19(w f)19(or differ)18(ence)56(. and a thir)19(d alternativ)18(e)57(, intr)18(o)1(-)]tj
-3.2626 -1.2 td
-0.022 tc
0.005 tw
[(duces a critical, postmodernist, and ethical political f)19(ocus in or)18(der t)19(o f)18(oster dif-)]tj
t*
0.015 tc
0.121 tw
[(fer)19(ence o)18(v)19(er st)19(ability)111(,)1( )1(y)19(et cr)19(eate a space f)19(or tr)18(ansf)19(ormativ)19(e possibility)110(.)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0.134 tw
[(scheurich (1997) in assessing each of these appr)19(oaches w)18(ould be mor)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.03 tc
0.013 tw
[(comf)19(ort)18(able if man)19(y kinds of v)19(oices could appear in the findings)36(. what is called)]tj
t*
-0.016 tc
-0.001 tw
[(f)19(or)110(, he sa)19(y)19(s)37(, is a bakhtinian dialogic carniv)18(al, an open, polyphonic)19(, subv)19(er)18(siv)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.003 tw
[(conv)19(er)18(sation on v)19(alidity \322)56(as the wild uncontr)18(ollable pla)19(y of differ)19(ence\323 \()-3(p)-3(.)-3( )-3(9)-3(0)-3(\))-3(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.004 tw
[(antif)19(oundationalist appr)18(oaches t)19(o issues of quality in qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.002 tc
-0.013 tw
[(ar)19(e intended t)18(o r)19(aise questions about the belief)19(s and v)18(alues of the inquir)19(er)111(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1425 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(155)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/length 6783
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.003 tc
0.025 tw
[(f)56(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, questions about narr)18(ativ)19(e w)19(a)19(y)19(s of kno)19(wing \(as an epistemo)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.007 tc
-0.004 tw
[(logical position\) ma)19(y interr)18(ogate the thoughtfulness in the application of the)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tc
-0.001 tw
[(assumptions of narr)19(ativ)18(e inquiry t)19(o the particular r)19(esear)18(ch pr)19(oject in conte)19(xt)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.004 tw
[(\321as it w)19(as conceiv)18(ed, and adjusted on the gr)19(ound. confidence is deriv)19(ed if,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.004 tc
0.137 tw
[(f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, the r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s ha)18(v)19(e consider)19(ed, e)18(xplicitly)111(, wh)18(y the)19(y ha)19(v)18(e)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.01 tw
[(decided t)19(o liv)18(e with an emer)19(gent \(v)19(s)37(. pr)19(eor)18(dinate\) design, wh)19(y the)19(y belie)18(v)19(e)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.003 tc
0.004 tw
[(in co-constructed interpr)19(et)18(ation or r)19(esear)19(ch-as-instrument. these method)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.001 tc
-0.01 tw
[(ological choices ar)19(e not pr)18(esented as descriptiv)19(e hollo)19(w slogans but as sub-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.025 tc
0.133 tw
[(st)19(antial decision points t)18(ak)19(en f)19(or good r)18(eason. f)56(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, ho)18(w do)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
0.006 tw
[(r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s addr)19(ess issues of r)18(epr)19(esent)19(ation, pr)18(esent)19(ation of findings)37(, or their)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.01 tw
[(writing style in terms of their commitment t)19(o, f)18(or e)19(x)18(a)-1(m)-1(p)-1(l)-1(e)55(, notions of mul-)]tj
t*
0.004 tc
0.137 tw
[(tiple r)19(ealities \(i.e)56(., r)18(elativist ont)19(ology\) as socially constructed, uncert)19(ain,)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.003 tw
[(and tent)19(ativ)18(e? ho)19(w do the)19(y discuss their r)18(ationale f)19(or est)19(ablishing a r)18(espect-)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.139 tw
[(ful, inter)19(activ)18(e r)19(esear)19(cher-participant r)18(elationships \(i.e)56(., their subjectivist)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(epistemology\) based on notions of trust, collabor)18(ation, r)19(espect, and mutu-)]tj
t*
0.013 tw
[(ality of purpose\)? ho)19(w do the)18(y describe their negotiation of mutually con-)]tj
t*
0.025 tc
0.224 tw
[(structed findings)37(, as e)18(xpr)19(essed in narr)19(ativ)19(e f)18(orm \(i.e)56(., hermeneutic)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0 tw
(methodology\)? )tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.052 tw
[(choosing among the possibilities)37(, e)18(v)19(en within narr)19(ativ)19(e methodology)110(,)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(seems endless\321wh)19(y pr)18(olonged engagement, wh)19(y per)19(sistent observ)19(ation, wh)18(y)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(efle)19(xiv)18(e engagement, without a clear pictur)19(e of the goals)37(. within narr)18(ativ)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
0 tw
(inquiry)tj
2.87227 0 td
(,)tj
0.52888 0 td
(f)tj
0.28335 0 td
-0.001 tw
(or e)tj
1.61335 0 td
0 tc
(x)tj
0.50522 0 td
-0.013 tc
[(ample)56(, methods ar)19(e justified b)18(y a depiction that interpr)19(ets ho)19(w)]tj
-5.80307 -1.20001 td
0 tc
-0.014 tw
[(individuals mak)19(e sense of their pr)18(actices within a particular conte)19(xt. in our)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(o)19(w)1(n)1( )1(w)20(ork in teacher thinking in envir)19(onment)18(al education, the choice of meth-)]tj
t*
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
(ods w)tj
2.46481 0 td
(as intended t)tj
5.42468 0 td
-0.0145 tc
(o)tj
0.7865 0 td
-0.015 tc
(lead t)tj
2.28473 0 td
[(o)18(w)19(ar)18(d de)19(v)18(eloping meaning which w)19(as gr)19(asped not)]tj
-10.96073 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.012 tw
[(b)19(y simply e)19(xplaining beha)18(viour observ)19(ed but b)19(y sear)18(ching f)19(or under)19(st)18(and-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(ing thr)19(ough a r)18(ecur)19(siv)19(e pr)18(ocess of unco)19(v)19(ering \(f)19(or r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
10 0 0 10 290.8341 275.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.024 tc
(and)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 308.1289 275.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.025 tc
(participants\))tj
-27.11289 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(underlying v)tj
5.34191 0 td
0 tw
(alues)tj
2.15203 0 td
(,)tj
0.53896 0 td
-0.011 tw
[(belief)19(s)37(, and assumptions)37(. these methods e)18(v)19(olv)19(ed during)]tj
-8.0329 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(the early st)19(ages of the pr)18(ocess as participants themselv)19(es sho)18(w)19(ed us ho)19(w t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(corr)19(ect our naiv)18(et\216 in intervie)19(wing and participant observ)19(ation. t)88(e)19(xtbook the)-1(-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.006 tw
(ory only goes so f)tj
7.6539 0 td
(ar without common sense and sa)tj
14.4182 0 td
[(vvy that allo)19(w inquir)18(er)19(s)]tj
-22.0721 -1.20001 td
0 tw
[(t)19(o adapt their methods t)19(o the per)18(sonalities in conte)19(xt.  )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.015 tw
[(critics of narr)19(ativ)18(e \(see)56(, f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, a)36(tkinson, 1997; silv)19(erman, 1997\))]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.024 tc
0.005 tw
(seem t)tj
2.74839 0 td
-0.0243 tc
(o)tj
0.77111 0 td
-0.024 tc
[(ignor)19(e the f)18(act that st)19(ories)37(, particularly those fr)18(om per)19(sonal narr)19(ativ)18(es)37(,)]tj
-3.5195 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.003 tw
[(can giv)19(e a measur)18(e of coher)19(ence and continuity t)19(o e)18(xperience not a)19(v)18(ailable)]tj
t*
-0.031 tc
0.012 tw
(in its original moment. char)tj
11.35964 0 td
[(ges of dist)19(ortion, sa)18(y)19(s fr)19(eeman (1998), ar)19(e not only)]tj
-11.35964 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.009 tw
[(par)19(asitic on empiricist accounts of r)18(eality)111(, the)19(y f)18(or)19(get the possibility of undis-)]tj
t*
-0.03 tc
0.01 tw
[(t)19(ortion. what if w)18(e)56(, as teams of r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s and participants)37(, could co-construct)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.008 tw
[(accounts that could actually get t)19(o the bott)19(om of things and serv)18(e t)19(o impr)19(o)18(v)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.069 tw
[(our discour)19(ses-pr)18(actices? what if the r)19(esear)18(ch is vi)1(e)18(w)19(ed b)18(y participants as)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.131 tw
[(empo)19(w)19(ering, as opportunity f)19(or deep engagement in critically r)18(eflectiv)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.012 tw
[(t)18(asks which v)19(alues e)19(xperiential kno)18(wledge as a t)19(ouchst)19(oned method? what)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.011 tw
[(if participants actually thank)19(ed r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s f)18(or the opportunity t)19(o t)19(alk and t)18(o)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0 tw
[(write about the meaning of their liv)19(es in their r)18(easons f)19(or teachi)-3(n)-3(g)-3(?)-3( )]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(156)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/length 6386
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 91 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.057 tw
[(the idea of ne)19(w par)18(adigm inquiry)111(, sa)19(y)19(s r)18(eason (1988), is t)19(o consider)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[(kinds of inquiry based on self-kno)19(wing, self-r)18(eflection, and self-critique)56(.)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(the purpose of per)19(sonal or aut)18(obiogr)19(aphical narr)19(ativ)18(e is t)19(o e)19(xtr)18(act meaning)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(fr)19(om e)18(xperience r)19(ather than t)19(o depict e)19(xperience e)18(x)19(actly as liv)19(ed. this)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(r)19(equir)19(es a tr)18(ansition in thinking about what counts as kno)19(wledge\321fr)19(om objec)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(tiv)19(e consciousness t)18(o critical subjectivity)111(. this kind of kno)19(wing, while pr)18(one)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(t)19(o dist)19(ortion, f)18(alse consciousness and so f)19(orth, also has man)18(y good qualities)37(.)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[<d2>1(w)93(e do not try t)19(o)1( )1(s)1(u)1(p)1(p)1(r)20(ess our primary subjectiv)19(e e)18(xperience but nor do w)19(e)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
-0.013 tw
[(allo)19(w our)18(selv)19(es t)19(o be o)18(v)19(erwhelmed and sw)19(ept a)19(w)19(a)18(y b)19(y it; r)19(ather w)18(e r)19(aise it)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tw
[(t)19(o consciousness and use it as part of the inquiry pr)19(ocess\323 (p. 12).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(the pr)19(oblem is ho)18(w t)19(o engage the r)19(eader)111(, t)18(o write per)19(suasiv)19(ely)110(, cr)19(edibly)111(,)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(pr)19(o)19(v)19(ocativ)18(ely so that w)19(e ar)19(e dr)18(a)19(wn t)19(o the st)19(ories)36(, tr)19(ansfix)19(ed b)18(y the ideas and)]tj
t*
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
[(caught in our o)19(wn thoughts t)18(o question both what w)19(e ar)18(e r)19(eading and)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(thinking. sur)19(ely)110(, sa)19(y)19(s clough (2000), e)19(xperiment)19(al ethnogr)19(aphic writing)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(has meant t)19(o allo)18(w f)19(or a rigor)19(ous self-consciousness about the situated-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.006 tw
[(ness of a subject in her observ)19(ation . . . sur)18(ely)111(, the st)19(ory mak)18(es us think of)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(our o)19(wn e)18(xperience)56(, our memories or feelings)37(. . . sur)18(ely it allo)19(w)19(s us t)19(o e)18(xpe-)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(rience vicariously r)19(elationships)36(, thoughts)37(, acts)37(, about per)18(sonality and cultur)19(e)56(.)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.01 tw
[(in e)19(v)18(aluating a narr)19(ativ)19(e-type manuscript f)19(or publication, ellis (2000) ques)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(tions the st)19(ory line itself \(about balance)55(, flo)19(w)111(, coher)19(ence)56(, clarity\), the writing)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(\(liter)19(ac)18(y)111(, elegance)56(, vividness)37(, comple)19(xity)110(, e)19(v)19(ocation\), the goals \(w)18(orthwhile-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(ness)tj
1.88867 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.54805 0 td
0 tc
(legitimac)tj
3.90637 0 td
(y)tj
0.40796 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
0.54771 0 td
(w)tj
0.74021 0 td
0 tc
-0.008 tw
[(orldvie)19(w)19(s)37(, potential t)18(o stimulate per)19(sona/social activity\),)]tj
-8.03897 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tw
[(about ethics and so f)19(orth. the point is that just as w)18(e try t)19(o judge people in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(conte)19(xt so w)18(e should do no less f)19(or st)19(ories)36(, honestly and f)19(airly t)19(o the best of)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
(our ability)tj
3.98016 0 td
-0.0267 tc
(.)tj
0.51528 0 td
-0.027 tc
(it is)tj
1.4166 0 td
-0.0266 tc
(,)tj
0.51545 0 td
-0.027 tc
(after all, a subjectiv)tj
7.82552 0 td
[(e)55(, unsy)19(stematic)19(, and continually interrupted)]tj
-14.25301 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(pr)19(ocess)36(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.002 tw
[(good narr)19(ativ)18(es)37(, accor)19(ding t)18(o bochner (2000), help the r)19(eader or listen-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
-0.001 tw
(er t)tj
1.36936 0 td
-0.0185 tc
(o)tj
0.77697 0 td
-0.018 tc
0 tw
(under)tj
2.42601 0 td
-0.001 tw
[(s)1(t)20(and and feel the e)18(xperiences within rich descriptions of the com-)]tj
-4.57234 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
0.015 tw
[(ple)19(xity of per)18(sonality)111(, conte)19(xt, and time)55(. r)19(ather than inv)19(oking fix)18(ed criteria)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
0.134 tw
[(when ask)19(ed t)18(o mak)19(e a judgment, bochner looks f)19(or abundant, concr)19(ete)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0 tw
(det)tj
1.27968 0 td
0.005 tw
(ail; structur)tj
4.55971 0 td
[(al comple)19(xity; a tempor)18(al fr)19(ame)19(w)19(ork that r)19(eflects the curvilinear)]tj
-5.83939 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.005 tw
[(pr)19(ocess of memory w)18(ork; the author\325)37(s emotional st)18(ability)111(, vulner)19(ability)110(, eth-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.022 tc
0.003 tw
[(ical self-consciousness)37(, honesty)111(, and r)18(efle)19(xivity; per)19(sistence in digging beneath)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.34552 0 td
-0.006 tc
-0.003 tw
[(esear)19(ch decisions and actions)36(, la)19(ying oneself out on the page; ackno)18(wledg-)]tj
-0.34552 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
-0.004 tw
[(ing limit)19(ations)36(, contr)19(adictions)37(, feelings)37(, and la)18(y)19(er)19(s of subjectivity)111(. he w)18(ants t)19(o)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.043 tw
(see the pr)tj
4.28948 0 td
[(ocess of the r)19(esear)18(cher\325)37(s and participant\325)37(s journe)18(y)111(, a \322t)19(ale of tw)18(o)]tj
-4.28948 -1.2 td
-0.026 tc
0.007 tw
[(selv)19(es)36(,\323 a life cour)19(se r)19(eimagined or tr)19(ansf)18(ormed and, finally)111(, a st)19(ory that mo)19(v)18(es)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
0.138 tw
[(the r)19(eader/listener in heart and mind, an e)18(xistential struggle f)19(or honesty)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.076 tw
[(and e)19(xpr)18(ession in an uncert)19(ain w)19(orld \(see also l)18(opate)56(, 1994\). ho)19(w do w)18(e)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.002 tw
[(encompass in our minds the comple)19(xities of some liv)18(ed moments of life? not,)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0 tw
[(sa)19(y)18(s coles (1989), with theories or sy)19(stems\321y)18(ou do it with st)19(ories)37(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1425 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(157)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
22 0 obj
<<
/length 6305
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 174.9929 587.4685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(so what?)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 564.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(curr)19(ent discour)18(ses of qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch r)19(eflect se)18(v)19(er)19(al positions on the issues)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(of e)19(v)18(aluativ)19(e criteria. the contr)19(o)19(v)18(er)19(sies surr)19(ounding these positions ar)18(e not)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(lik)19(ely t)18(o be r)19(esolv)19(ed. as r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s w)18(e ar)19(e obliged t)19(o find a place that)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.124 tw
[(mak)19(es sense)55(. in our w)19(ork within envir)19(onment)18(al education, f)19(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.042 tw
[(r)19(orty\325)37(s (1979) idea of a communicativ)18(e and pr)19(agmatic v)19(alidity cr)18(eated b)19(y)]tj
t*
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(means of a community narr)19(ativ)18(e)56(, and bounded b)18(y mo)1(r)18(al consider)19(ations)36(, made)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(sense t)19(o)1( )1(u)1(s)1( )1(b)1(e)1(c)1(a)1(u)1(s)1(e)1( )1(w)19(e had an e)19(y)19(e t)19(o the emancipat)19(o)1(r)1(y)1( )1(n)1(a)1(r)1(r)19(ativ)19(e)1(s)1( )1(o)1(f)1( )1(t)1(h)1(e)1( )1(c)1(r)1(i)1(t)1(-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.019 tw
[(ical theorists and the goal of a mor)19(e participat)18(ory and cooper)19(ativ)19(e f)18(orm of)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(inquiry)111(.  )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.07 tw
[(as smith and deemer (2000) observ)19(e)56(, no method is a neutr)18(al t)19(ool of)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(inquiry\321each is methodologically)111(, hence epistemologically and ont)18(ologically)111(,)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(gr)19(ounded. without the security of pr)18(ocedur)19(al objectivity)111(, the question of qual-)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(ity becomes one of the kinds of justification that w)19(e feel w)18(e need within our)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch communities)36(. f)56(or nonf)19(oundationalist \(or antif)18(oundationalists\), the)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.02 tw
[(issue of criteria f)19(or judging inquiry is a political, pr)18(actical, and mor)19(al aff)19(air)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(r)19(equiring activ)19(e discussion and debate ar)18(ound actual cases)37(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(in postmodern times w)19(e learn t)18(o liv)19(e with uncert)19(ainty)111(. contingenc)18(y)112(, dia)-1(-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.009 tc
0.13 tw
[(logue)56(,)1( )1(f)19(allibilism, and deliber)19(a)1(t)1(i)1(o)1(n)1( )1(m)1(a)1(r)1(k)1( )1(o)1(u)1(r)1( )1(w)20(a)19(y of being in the w)18(orld)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(\(schw)19(andt, 1996\). these ont)18(ological consider)19(ations ar)19(e not equiv)19(alent t)18(o et)1(er)-1(-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(nal ambiguity)111(, lack of commitment, or an inability t)18(o act in the f)19(ace of our)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(uncert)19(ainty)110(, sa)19(y)19(s schw)18(andt (1996). the pr)19(oblem of ho)19(w t)18(o mak)19(e judgments)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
(without being able t)tj
8.21606 0 td
-0.0198 tc
(o)tj
0.78126 0 td
-0.02 tc
(appeal t)tj
3.27497 0 td
-0.0199 tc
(o)tj
0.78107 0 td
-0.02 tc
[(f)19(oundations or t)18(o something outside the social)]tj
-13.05336 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.124 tw
[(pr)19(ocesses of kno)18(wledge construction does not deter r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s such as)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.011 tw
(bochner (2000), ellis (2000), denzin (2000), smith and deemer (2000), or)tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
(lincoln and guba (2000) fr)tj
10.95796 0 td
[(om gener)19(ating questions that fit with the pr)18(agmatic)19(,)]tj
-10.95796 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(ethical, and political contingencies of concr)19(ete situations)36(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.008 tc
0.13 tw
[(criteria, or sets of questions)37(, continue t)18(o flo)19(w fr)19(om feminist, com)-1(-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(munt)19(arian, mor)18(al and ethical debate)56(, r)19(ooted as the)18(y ma)19(y be in concepts such)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(as caring, sharing, neighbourliness)37(, lo)18(v)19(e)57(, and kindness that pr)18(o)19(vide the sub-)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(st)19(ance f)18(or social criticism as w)19(ell as social action \(angr)19(osino & p\216r)19(ez, 2000;)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.009 tw
[(christians)37(, 2000; fine)56(, w)92(eis)37(, w)92(eseem, & w)93(ong, 2000; gr)19(een)18(w)19(ood & l)19(e)19(vin,)]tj
t*
0.086 tw
[(2000; k)37(emmis & mct)148(aggart, 2000; lincoln & guba, 2000; madriz, 2000;)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(schw)19(andt, 2000\). the essential pr)18(oblem, sa)19(y smith and deemer (2000) is t)18(o)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.01 tw
(honour the need f)tj
7.70943 0 td
[(or)111(, and the v)18(alue of, plur)19(ality)111(, multiplicity)110(, differ)19(ence)56(, and)]tj
-7.70943 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(so on, without giving o)19(v)19(er t)18(o e)19(x)19(cesses)37(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, t)18(o inquiry so fr)19(agment-)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(ed that lines of connection ha)tj
12.62433 0 td
[(v)19(e been lost and with them the possibilities of)]tj
-12.62433 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(per)19(sonal, social, and envir)18(onment)19(al impr)19(o)19(v)19(ement. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(pr)19(oblems of r)18(epr)19(esent)19(ation and legitimation in narr)19(ativ)18(e \(and qualit)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
(inquiry\) t)tj
4.0939 0 td
0 tw
(ak)tj
1.0027 0 td
0.0012 tc
(e)tj
0.918 0 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
(us be)tj
2.42199 0.00001 td
[(y)19(ond issues of criteria. if w)18(e continue t)19(o mo)19(v)18(e a)19(w)19(a)18(y)]tj
-8.4366 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.005 tw
[(fr)19(om f)18(oundational and quasif)19(oundational appr)19(oaches and t)18(o)19(w)19(ar)19(d mor)19(e sit)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.002 tw
[(uated, local per)19(spectiv)18(es; if w)19(e continue the turn t)19(o perf)18(ormance te)19(xts that)]tj
t*
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
(ask audiences t)tj
6.3885 0 td
-0.0151 tc
(o)tj
0.7858 0 td
(t)tj
0.2813 0 td
-0.015 tc
0 tw
(ak)tj
0.9701 0.00001 td
-0.0151 tc
(e)tj
0.74891 0 td
(a)tj
0.74891 0 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(st)19(and \(perhaps mor)18(al\) on the meaning of e)19(xperience;)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(158)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/length 6523
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.01 tw
[(then, issues of quality within the div)19(er)18(se genr)19(es of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch will)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(r)19(est on critical discour)19(ses and critical conv)18(er)19(sations about, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.012 tw
[(issues of te)19(xt and v)18(oice)56(, the e)19(xistential, narr)18(ativ)19(e as political te)19(xt, r)19(efle)18(xivi-)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(ty)111(, and vulner)18(ability in te)19(xt. the v)19(alue of inquiry is f)18(ound in its potential f)19(or)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.013 tc
0.125 tw
[(mor)19(al, ethical, and critical consciousness)36(. these discussions about t)1(he)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(potential of qualit)19(ativ)19(e inquiry being assessed in terms of its ability t)18(o stim-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(ulate social critique ar)19(e r)18(eminiscent of our o)19(wn debates about this issue with-)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(in envir)19(onment)18(al education \(see oult)19(on & scott, 2000\). )]tj
1.8 -1.20001 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(as lincoln and denzin (2000) ar)19(gue)56(, it is time t)18(o get on with the r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(p)1(r)20(oject: t)18(oo much critique can stifle our w)19(ork. endless self-r)18(efer)19(ential criticisms)]tj
0.0044 tc
(of)'
1.27753 0 td
0.004 tc
0.134 tw
[(postmodernists can pr)19(oduce mount)18(ains of te)19(xt with fe)18(w r)19(efer)19(ents t)18(o)]tj
-1.27753 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(concr)19(ete human e)18(xperience)56(. the)19(y oper)19(ate in the abstr)18(act with opposing sides)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(often pr)19(eaching t)18(o the conv)19(erted. gr)19(anted, w)19(e need critical dialogue but w)18(e)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(also need dialogue with those who w)19(e seek t)18(o w)19(ork with t)18(o change the w)19(orld,)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(those who ar)19(e willing t)18(o get int)19(o the field r)19(ather than those who r)18(emain con-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(fined t)19(o armchair)18(s and other points of str)19(ategic v)19(ant)19(age)55(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0.002 tw
[(those who do qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch t)19(o a)18(v)19(oid st)18(atistics ma)19(y need t)19(o think)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.001 tc
0.135 tw
[(again. qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch is fr)19(aught with difficulties)36(, which seem t)19(o be)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(compounding as r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s struggle t)19(o find their w)19(a)18(y within ne)19(w territ)19(ory)110(.)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.004 tw
[(the domain is comple)19(x, multipar)18(adigmatic)19(, and demands high quality think-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.02 tw
[(ing and writing that f)19(ar and a)19(w)18(a)19(y e)19(x)18(ceeds the demands of the quantit)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.34776 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.013 tw
(eporting of analy)tj
7.24967 0 td
(sis of dat)tj
3.81 0 td
(a. f)tj
1.51 0 td
[(or those willing t)19(o do the r)18(eading and engage)]tj
-12.91743 -1.20001 td
-0.028 tc
0.011 tw
[(the field, and the critical discour)19(se that will f)18(ollo)19(w)111(, ther)18(e is r)19(eason f)19(or optimism.)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.007 tw
[(whether the academics cr)19(edit or discr)18(edit ou)1(r attempts at narr)18(ativ)19(e inquiry)]tj
t*
-0.015 tc
-0.002 tw
(within envir)tj
5.003 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.28085 0 td
-0.002 tw
(al education, our r)tj
7.59983 0 td
[(esponse fr)19(om pr)18(actitioner)19(s is gr)19(atifying)]tj
-15.88368 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
0.092 tw
[(in the sense that the)19(y find support f)19(or their sometimes lonely struggle t)18(o)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.012 tw
[(engage in envir)19(onment)18(al education in the shar)19(ed st)19(ories of their colleagues)36(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.029 tw
(difficulties inv)tj
6.21275 0 td
0 tw
(olv)tj
1.25904 0 td
0.029 tw
[(ed in r)19(epr)18(esenting other)19(s turn on the amount of per-)]tj
-9.27179 -1.20001 td
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
[(sonal, subjectiv)19(e)56(, poetic self that is openly giv)19(en in the te)18(xt \(lincoln &)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.014 tw
[(denzin, 2000\). richar)19(dson (2000) and ellis and bochner (2000) ar)18(e among)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
(those who discuss w)tj
8.74296 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
0.4771 0 td
-0.004 tc
[(y)19(s of r)19(eturning the author t)18(o the te)19(xt \(e)56(.g., thr)18(ough fic-)]tj
-9.22006 -1.20001 td
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(tional narr)19(ativ)18(es)37(, dr)19(ama, poetic te)18(xt and st)19(ories\). rishma dunlop\325)37(s \(200)56(1\) no)18(v)19(el)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.011 tw
[(as dissert)19(ation, a struggle within the e)18(xisting academ)19(y)111(, ma)19(y signal changes)]tj
(t)'
0.29519 0 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(o)19(w)19(ar)19(d te)18(xts which, lincoln and denzin (2000) suggest, ar)19(e simult)19(aneously)]tj
-0.29519 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(minimal, e)19(xistential, aut)18(oethnogr)19(aphic)19(, vulner)18(able)56(, perf)19(ormativ)19(e)56(, and criti)-1(-)]tj
t*
0 tw
(cal; ackno)tj
4.33325 0 td
[(wledging the v)19(alue-laden natur)18(e of inquiry)111(. )]tj
-2.53325 -1.2 td
0.009 tc
0.127 tw
[(in man)19(y w)18(a)19(y)18(s)37(, the philosoph)18(y underlying envir)19(onment)19(al education)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.007 tc
0.129 tw
[(anticipates the r)19(esear)18(ch that lincoln and)1( denzin (2000) envision as an)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.009 tw
[(e)19(xtension of curr)18(ent tr)19(ends in qualit)19(ativ)19(e inquiry)110(, a type of scholar)19(ship and par-)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.004 tw
[(ticipat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch that sho)19(w)19(s us ho)18(w t)19(o act mor)19(ally with passion, r)18(espect and)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.004 tw
[(r)19(esponsibility)110(, t)19(o engage the futur)19(e in complement)19(ary)110(, r)19(ather than competi-)]tj
t*
-0.03 tc
0.013 tw
[(tiv)19(e)55(, destructiv)19(e w)19(a)18(y)19(s)37(. this kind of inquiry r)19(epr)18(esents a call t)19(o action and mor)19(al-)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.004 tw
[(ly inf)19(ormed social criticism, the)18(y sa)19(y)111(, that connects per)18(sonal t)19(o hist)19(orical and)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.005 tw
[(social \(and w)19(e w)18(ould add envir)19(onment)19(al\) dimensions of discour)19(se-pr)18(actice)56(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1383 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(159)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/length 8574
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[(only thr)19(ough meaningful w)18(o)1(r)1(k)1( )1(r)20(efle)19(x)1(i)1(v)19(e)1(l)1(y)1( )1(r)20(econstituted can w)19(e inv)18(ent our-)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(selv)19(e)1(s)1( )1(i)1(n)1( )1(s)1(t)19(o)1(r)1(i)1(e)1(s)1( )1(p)1(o)20(w)19(e)1(r)20(ed with an intellectual and mor)19(a)1(l)1( )1(p)1(a)1(s)1(s)1(i)1(o)1(n)1( )1(s)1(t)1(r)19(ong enough)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(t)18(o empo)19(w)18(er us t)19(o appr)19(opriate our o)18(wn liv)19(es and t)19(o authoriz)18(e our entry int)19(o those)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(of other)19(s . . . these ar)18(e mor)19(al fictions . . . wher)18(e)1( )1(w)20(e encounter the otherness of)]tj
t*
0.012 tw
[(o)-3(u)-3(r)-3( )-3(s)-3(t)-3(u)-3(d)-3(e)-3(n)-3(t)-3(s)-3( )-3(in or)18(der that the)19(y ma)19(y appr)18(opriate their o)19(wn st)19(ories . . . in mor)18(al)]tj
t*
0.028 tw
[(fictions w)19(e ne)18(v)19(er come t)19(o the end of questions)36(, the liv)19(es ar)19(e uncompleted . . .)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.009 tw
[(mor)19(al fictions teach us our o)18(wn ignor)19(ance and help our 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛
 t)19(o come t)19(o their)19(s)36(.)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
[(\(p)56(agano, 199)56(1, p. 205\))]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 184.2285 481.8875 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(notes)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
7 0 0 7 37 461.3974 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 459.0874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(cherryholmes (1988, p. 9) uses discour)19(ses-pr)18(actices t)19(o indicate and empha-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0.139 tw
[(siz)19(e the r)18(elationship (dialectic) betw)19(een discour)19(se/thought \(as it is st)19(ated)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(or)19(ally or as written\) and pr)18(actice \(what is done)56(, or sometimes)37(, what is done)]tj
0 -1.26315 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(with what is said\). the idea being that meanings flo)19(w back and f)18(orth fr)19(om the-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(ory t)19(o pr)18(actice)56(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 149.5769 377.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(notes on contributor)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 354.6874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(p)tj
0.50223 0 td
0.002 tc
0.146 tw
(aul hart)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
10 0 0 10 84.4929 354.6874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
(is a pr)tj
2.9362 0 td
(ofessor of science and envir)tj
12.6805 0 td
[(onment)19(al education at the)]tj
-20.36599 -1.20001 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(univ)19(er)18(sity of r)19(egina, and he has been a r)19(egular contribut)19(or t)18(o journals in these)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(fields)37(. his curr)18(ent r)19(esear)19(ch inter)19(ests ar)18(e in the ar)19(eas of teacher thinking and)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(pr)tj
0.90759 0 td
0.139 tw
[(actice in envir)19(onment)18(al education, childr)19(en\325)37(s ideas about the envir)18(on-)]tj
-0.90759 -1.2 td
0.015 tw
[(ment, and in the r)19(elationship betw)18(een theory and pr)19(actice within envir)19(on-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(ment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 171.7622 261.0874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(references)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37 238.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(a)56(delman, c. (1989). the pr)19(actical ethic t)18(ak)19(es priority o)19(v)18(er methodology)111(. in w)130(. carr (ed.),)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 226.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.007 tc
0.122 tw
(quality in teaching: ar)tj
9.91897 0 td
[(guments f)19(or a r)18(eflectiv)19(e pr)19(ofession)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 270.6543 226.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.008 tc
0.131 tw
((pp. 173-182). l)tj
7.29841 0 td
0 tw
(ondon:)tj
-32.66951 -1.41177 td
0 tc
[(f)56(almer)111(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(angr)19(osino, m. & p\216r)18(ez, k. (2000). r)19(ethinking observ)19(ation: fr)19(om method t)18(o conte)19(xt. in n.)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)36(.\),)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 149.9223 190.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
0.007 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(a)1(t)1(i)1(v)19(e)1( )1(r)20(e)1(s)1(e)1(a)1(r)19(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 262.2665 190.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(\(2nd edition\) \(pp. 673-7)37(02\).)]tj
-24.3843 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(thousand oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(a)37(tkinson, p)147(. (1997). narr)19(ativ)19(e turn or blind alle)18(y? )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 216.0265 166.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e health r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 312.6087 166.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0039 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 317.1832 166.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(7)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 321.5645 166.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0037 tc
(,)tj
0.53823 0 td
-0.004 tc
(325-344.)tj
-34.01641 -1.41176 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(a)74(y)19(er)19(s)36(, w)130(. (1992). in the country of the blind. in w)130(. schubert & w)129(. a)74(y)19(er)19(s \(eds)36(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 315.6316 154.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
0.002 tw
[(t)88(eacher lor)18(e:)]tj
-30.66254 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(l)tj
0.5 0.00001 td
0 tw
(earning fr)tj
4.10791 0.00001 td
(om our o)tj
3.7024 0.00001 td
(wn e)tj
1.94262 0.00001 td
(xperience)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 178.499 142.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((pp. 157-158). ne)tj
7.59424 0.00001 td
-0.0003 tc
(w)tj
1.03646 0 td
(y)tj
0.53118 0.00001 td
0 tc
(ork: l)tj
2.4624 0.00001 td
(ongman.)tj
-28.27121 -1.41178 td
[(bochner)111(, a. (2000). criteria against our)18(selv)19(es)37(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 206.3484 130.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e inquiry)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 272.2545 130.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 276.9777 130.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 281.3874 130.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((2), 266-272.)tj
-28.7515 -1.4118 td
[(bochner)111(, a. \(200)55(1\). narr)19(ativ)19<65d5>37(s virtues)36(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 180.3794 118.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e inquiry)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 246.2855 118.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 251.0087 118.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(7)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 255.4185 118.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((2), 13)56(1-157.)]tj
-25.6963 -1.4118 td
[(bohman, j. \(199)56(1\). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 108.1522 106.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(ne)19(w philosoph)18(y of social science)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 222.8462 106.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55578 0 td
0 tc
[(cambridge)56(, ma: mit pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-22.42 -1.4118 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(bruner)111(, j. (1986). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 100.4231 94.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
-0.007 tw
[(a)56(ctual minds)37(, possible w)19(orlds)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 202.8577 94.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0068 tc
(.)tj
0.53515 0 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(cambridge)56(, ma: harv)18(ar)19(d univ)19(er)18(sity pr)19(ess)37(.)]tj
-20.0478 -1.4118 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(bruner)111(, j. (1987). life as narr)18(ativ)19(e)56(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 164.6328 82.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(social r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 219.6857 82.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 224.4088 82.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(54)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 233.2284 82.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55557 0 td
0 tc
[(1)161(1-32.)]tj
-23.6413 -1.4118 td
[(bruner)111(, j. (1990). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 101.6921 70.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(a)56(cts of meaning)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 158.1665 70.2874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55578 0 td
0 tc
[(cambridge)56(, ma: harv)18(ar)19(d univ)19(er)19(sity)-1( )1(pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(160)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
25 0 obj
<<
/length 13027
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 73 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(bruner)111(, j. (1996). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 137.6921 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(the cultur)19(e of education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 222.5033 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55578 0 td
0 tc
[(cambridge)56(, ma: harv)18(ar)19(d univ)19(er)18(sity pr)19(ess)37(.)]tj
-18.1444 -1.41176 td
[(bryman, a., & bur)19(gess)36(, r. (1994). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 199.4022 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(analyzing qualit)19(ativ)18(e dat)19(a)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 290.7668 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
0 tc
[(l)19(ondon: r)18(outledge)56(.)]tj
-26.17529 -1.41176 td
-0.0047 tc
(c)tj
0.60634 -0.00001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(arter)111(, k. & do)18(yle)56(, w)130(. (1996). p)56(er)18(sonal narr)19(ativ)19(e and life hist)18(ory in learning t)19(o teach. in j.)]tj
1.51131 -1.41176 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(sik)18(ula (ed.), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 134.0322 552.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.023 tc
0.01 tw
[(handbook of r)19(esear)18(ch on teacher education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 280.5975 552.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[((2nd edition) (pp. 120-142). ne)19(w)]tj
-22.30559 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(y)80(ork: simon & schuster macmillan.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.013 tw
[(cha)19(wla, l. (1998a). r)18(esear)19(ch methods t)19(o inv)18(estigate significant life e)19(xperiences: r)19(e)19(vie)18(w)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(and r)19(ecommendations)36(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 178.511 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 301.3812 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 306.1044 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(4)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 310.5142 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((4), 383-398.)tj
-27.94285 -1.41176 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(cha)19(wla, l. (1998b) significant life e)19(xperiences r)18(e)19(visited: a r)18(e)18(vie)19(w of r)19(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)18(ch on sour)18(ces)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(of envir)19(onment)18(al sensitivity)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 197.2292 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 320.0995 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 324.8226 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(4)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 329.2324 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((4), 369-382.)tj
-30.14499 -1.41176 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(christians)37(, c. (2000). ethics and politics in qualit)19(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(v)17(e r)19(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)18(ch. in n. denzin & y)130(.)-1( )-1(l)-1(i)-1(n)-1(c)-1(o)-1(l)-1(n)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.002 tc
0 tw
[(\(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 115.8143 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.011 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 232.8242 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[((2nd edition) (pp. 133-155). thousand oaks)37(,)]tj
-16.6852 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(c)37(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(clandinin, j. & connelly)111(, m. (1994). p)55(er)19(sonal e)19(xperience methods)36(. in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(\(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 116.0248 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(handbook of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 233.8398 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(\(pp. 4)56(13-427\). thousand oaks)36(, c)37(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-18.92233 -1.41176 td
-0.014 tc
[(clandinin, j. & connelly)111(, m. (1995). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 200.6266 420.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
[(t)88(eacher)19(s\325 pr)18(ofessional kno)19(wledge landscapes)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 353.7621 420.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0143 tc
(.)tj
0.52761 0 td
-0.014 tc
[(ne)19(w y)79(ork:)]tj
-31.44079 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(t)88(eacher)19(s college pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41177 td
0.034 tw
[(clandinin, j. & connelly)111(, m. (2000). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 206.8126 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.032 tw
[(narr)19(ativ)18(e inquiry: experience and st)19(ory in qualit)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
-13.62501 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 120.7251 384.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55572 0 td
0 tc
[(san fr)19(ancisco: josse)18(y-bass)37(.)]tj
-6.17043 -1.41176 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
(clough, p)tj
4.11848 0 td
0.0019 tc
(.)tj
0.69675 0 td
0.002 tc
[((2000). comments on setting criteria f)19(or e)19(xperiment)18(al writing. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.462 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
(qualit)tj
2.54665 0 td
[(ativ)19(e)]tj
-33.77747 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(inquiry)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 116.3319 360.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 121.055 360.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 125.4648 360.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((2), 278-29)56(1.)]tj
-6.17233 -1.41176 td
-0.016 tc
(coffe)tj
2.17922 0 td
0 tc
(y)tj
0.39204 0 td
-0.0161 tc
(,)tj
0.52586 0 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
(a., & a)tj
2.9488 0 td
[(tkinson, p)148(. (1996). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 190.6848 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
0.002 tw
(making sense of qualit)tj
8.96807 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.47625 0 td
(e)tj
0.67489 0 td
(dat)tj
1.25032 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 299.9392 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
(.)tj
0.52594 0 td
0.002 tw
(thousand oaks)tj
6.46277 0 td
-0.0162 tc
(,)tj
0.52569 0 td
(c)tj
0.55823 0 td
-0.016 tc
(a: sage)tj
-34.77137 -1.41177 td
-0.006 tc
-0.009 tw
[(coles)37(, r. (1989). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 134.7764 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.008 tw
[(the call of st)19(ories: t)87(eaching and the mor)19(al imagination)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 325.2499 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0056 tc
(.)tj
0.53635 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(b)1(o)1(s)1(t)20(on: hought)18(o)1(n)]tj
-28.09516 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(mifflin.)tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
(conle)tj
2.40674 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55734 0 td
0 tc
0.002 tw
(c. (2000). narr)tj
6.4465 0 td
[(ativ)19(e inquiry: r)18(esear)19(ch t)19(ool and medium f)18(or pr)19(ofessional de)19(v)19(elop-)]tj
-7.29293 -1.41177 td
0 tw
(ment. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 115.0847 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(eur)19(opean journal of t)87(eacher education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 252.004 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 256.7272 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(23)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 265.5467 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 49-63.)tj
-22.65255 -1.41176 td
-0.011 tc
(connelly)tj
3.6016 0 td
-0.0107 tc
(,)tj
0.53114 0 td
(f)tj
0.37856 0 td
-0.0106 tc
(.)tj
0.53137 0 td
(&)tj
0.97537 0 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
(clandinin, j. (1990). st)tj
9.47837 0.00001 td
(ories of e)tj
3.86826 0 td
(xperience and narr)tj
8.04309 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.51297 0 td
-0.0106 tc
(e)tj
0.75332 0 td
-0.011 tc
[(inquiry)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 354.3004 288.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
(educational)tj
-30.97652 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.61108 0 td
[(esear)19(cher)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 129.8518 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 134.5749 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(19)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 143.3945 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((4), 2-13.)tj
-8.28171 -1.41176 td
(cort)tj
1.81372 0 td
(azzi, m. (1993). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 147.7631 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narr)tj
1.88769 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.53564 0.00001 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.7026 0 td
0 tc
(analy)tj
2.25541 0 td
(sis)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 211.6044 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
(l)tj
0.4812 0 td
0 tc
(ondon: f)tj
3.81421 0.00001 td
(almer)tj
2.38892 0 td
(.)tj
-23.54639 -1.41178 td
0.016 tc
(da)tj
1.21829 0 td
0 tc
(y)tj
0.42458 0 td
0.0165 tc
(,)tj
0.71129 0 td
0.016 tc
0.122 tw
(c., calderhead, j., & denicolo, p)tj
14.97424 0 td
0.0165 tc
(.)tj
0.71121 0 td
0.016 tc
0 tw
(\(eds)tj
1.88116 0 td
0.122 tw
(.\). \(1993\).)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 284.1119 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r)tj
0.6266 0 td
0.015 tc
(esear)tj
2.25991 0 td
0.114 tw
(ch on teacher thinking:)tj
-25.60555 -1.41177 td
0 tc
0 tw
(under)tj
2.49878 0 td
[(st)19(anding pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)19(elopment)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 233.9976 240.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
(l)tj
0.4812 0 td
0 tc
[(ondon: f)56(almer)111(.)]tj
-19.97775 -1.41177 td
(denzin, n. (1978). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 143.0461 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sociological methods)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 216.838 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55565 0 td
0 tc
(ne)tj
1.16603 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(w)tj
1.03646 0 td
(y)tj
0.53117 0 td
0 tc
(ork: mcgr)tj
4.23999 0 td
(a)tj
0.4812 0 td
(w-hill.)tj
-24.93261 -1.41178 td
-0.003 tw
(denzin, n. (2000). a)tj
8.8048 0 td
(esthetics and the pr)tj
8.49035 0 td
(actices of qualit)tj
6.71485 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.55493 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77441 0 td
0 tc
[(inquiry)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 326.7589 216.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(qualit)tj
2.53516 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.53564 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.69964 0 td
0 tc
(inquiry)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 392.6389 216.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 204.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 95.4098 204.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((2), 256-265.)tj
-2.63645 -1.41176 td
-0.011 tw
(denzin, n. & lincoln, y)tj
10.01077 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.54502 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(\(eds)tj
1.81467 0 td
-0.011 tw
(.\). \(1994\). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 216.2216 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tw
(handbook of qualit)tj
7.82752 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.53565 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.69261 0 td
(r)tj
0.3702 0 td
0 tc
(esear)tj
2.18238 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 331.4215 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.54508 0 td
0 tc
-0.011 tw
(thousand oaks)tj
6.65696 0 td
(,)tj
-35.48693 -1.41177 td
(c)tj
0.57398 0 td
0 tw
(a: sage)tj
3.14844 0 td
(.)tj
-5.84006 -1.41177 td
0.107 tw
[(denzin, n. & lincoln, y)130(. \(eds)36(.\). \(2000\). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 223.2381 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.1 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 344.5123 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.107 tw
((2nd edition).)tj
-29.82498 -1.41176 td
0 tw
(thousand oaks)tj
6.66773 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55551 0 td
0 tc
[(c)37(a: sage)55(.)]tj
-9.34088 -1.41177 td
0.026 tw
(dunlop, r. \(200)tj
6.84982 0.00001 td
0 tw
(1\). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 143.41 144.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(p)tj
0.5371 0.00001 td
0.024 tw
[(oetics)37(, landscape and embodied w)18(ay)19(s of kno)19(wing)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 320.8258 144.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.58187 0 td
(p)tj
0.51809 0.00001 td
0 tc
0.026 tw
[(aper pr)19(esented at)]tj
-28.1383 -1.41177 td
0 tw
[(eecom confer)19(ence)56(, whitehor)18(se)56(, y)74(uk)18(on, july 17-19.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
0.123 tw
[(eisner)111(, e. (1997). the pr)18(omise and perils of alternativ)19(e f)19(orms of dat)18(a r)19(epr)19(esent)18(ation.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 108.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(educational r)19(esear)18(cher)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 173.5865 108.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55554 0 td
0 tc
[(a)56(ugust-september)110(, 4-1)56(0.)]tj
-12.3892 -1.4118 td
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(elbaz, f)148(. (1983). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 138.4626 96.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.005 tc
0.124 tw
[(t)88(eaching thinking: a study of pr)19(actical kno)18(wledge)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 321.2145 96.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.0051 tc
(.)tj
0.69986 0 td
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(ne)19(w y)79(ork: cr)19(oom)]tj
-27.7839 -1.4118 td
0 tc
0 tw
(helm.)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1425 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(161)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
26 0 obj
<<
/length 12200
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(ellis)37(, c. (2000). cr)18(eating criteria: an ethnogr)19(aphic short st)18(ory)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 256.4713 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tc
0.001 tw
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e inquiry)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 320.1902 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0149 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 324.6716 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 328.966 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
((2), 273-)tj
-32.2313 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(277.)tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.0094 tc
(e)tj
0.56459 -0.00001 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(llis)37(, c. & bochner)110(, a. (2000). a)56(ut)19(oethnogr)18(aph)19(y)111(, per)19(sonal narr)19(ativ)18(e)57(,)1( )1(r)19(efle)19(xivity: r)19(esear)18(cher)]tj
1.55306 -1.41176 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(as subject. in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)36(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 211.854 552.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
-0.004 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 326.9611 552.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
(\(2nd edi-)tj
-31.99542 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(tion\) \(pp. 1)56(0)56(7-13)56(1\). thousand oaks)36(, c)37(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.007 tw
[(ellsw)19(orth, e. (1989). wh)18(y doesn\325t this feel empo)19(w)19(ering? w)19(orking thr)18(ough the r)19(epr)19(essiv)19(e)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(m)19(yths of critical pedagogy)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 155.7445 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(harv)19(ar)18(d educational r)19(e)19(vie)18(w)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 255.1567 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 259.8799 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(59)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 268.6995 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((3), 297-325.)tj
-27.25877 -1.41176 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
(fien. j. (1993). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 90.2461 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.023 tc
0.01 tw
[(education f)19(or the envir)18(onment: critical curriculum theorising and envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
-4.1466 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 89.1432 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.5558 0 td
0 tc
[(geelong, a)56(ustr)18(alia: deakin univ)19(er)19(sity pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-6.69029 -1.41176 td
0.028 tw
[(fine)56(, m., w)92(eis)37(, l., w)93(eseen, s., & w)92(ong, l. (2000). f)56(or whom? qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch, r)18(ep-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0.008 tw
[(r)19(esent)19(ations)36(, and social r)19(esponsibilities)37(. in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)36(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 323.4398 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(handbook)tj
-31.58115 -1.41176 td
[(of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 135.0548 456.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((2nd edition). thousand oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-11.53586 -1.41176 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(florio-r)19(uane)55(, s. \(199)56(1\). conv)19(er)19(sation and narr)18(ativ)19(e in collabor)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch: an ethnog)-1(-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.008 tc
-0.007 tw
[(r)18(a)-1(p)-1(h)18(y)-1( )-1(o)-1(f)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1( )-1(w)-1(r)-1(i)-1(t)-1(t)-1(e)-1(n)-1( )-1(l)-1(i)-1(t)-1(e)-1(r)18(a)-1(c)17(y f)19(orum. in c. wither)19(all & n. noddings \(eds)36(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 317.5907 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.006 tw
[(st)19(ories liv)18(es)]tj
-30.89303 -1.41176 td
-0.025 tc
0.012 tw
[(tell: narr)19(ativ)18(e and dialogue in education )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 189.5516 420.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[((pp. 234-256). ne)18(w y)80(ork: t)88(eacher)18(s college pr)19(ess)37(.)]tj
-17.94725 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(fr)19(eeman, m. (1993). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 114.7596 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(r)19(e)19(writing the self: hist)19(ory)110(, memory)111(, narr)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 274.7406 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
0 tc
[(l)19(ondon: r)18(outledge)56(.)]tj
-28.52514 -1.41177 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(fr)19(eeman, m. (1998). experience)55(, narr)19(ativ)19(e and the r)19(elation betw)18(een them. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 326.0124 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
[(narr)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
-31.88381 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(inquiry)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 80.3319 384.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 85.055 384.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(8)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 89.4648 384.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55573 0 td
0 tc
(455-466.)tj
-6.72806 -1.41176 td
-0.004 tc
(gr)tj
0.97342 0 td
-0.01 tw
[(een)19(w)19(ood, d. & l)18(e)19(vin, m. (2000). r)18(econstructing the r)19(elationships betw)19(een univ)19(er)18(sities)]tj
1.14422 -1.41176 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(and society thr)19(ough action r)18(esear)19(ch. in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 297.3984 360.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.023 tc
0.01 tw
(handbook of qual-)tj
-28.51746 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(it)tj
0.57398 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.53565 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.70255 0 td
(r)tj
0.3702 0 td
0 tc
[(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 110.9908 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(\(2nd edition\) \(pp. 85-1)tj
9.68555 0 td
(06\). thousand oaks)tj
8.63111 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.5555 0 td
(c)tj
0.57413 0 td
0 tc
[(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-28.1511 -1.41178 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(goodson, i. (1994). studying the teacher\325)37(s life and w)18(ork. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 244.5538 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.011 tw
[(t)88(eaching and t)88(eacher education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6406 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 324.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
0.46289 0 td
(0)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 63.3444 324.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 29-37.)tj
-3.09934 -1.41176 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
(grumet, m. \(199)tj
6.76635 0 td
(1\). the politics of per)tj
8.70123 0 td
[(sonal kno)19(wledge)55(. in c. wither)19(ell & n. noddings \(eds)37(.\),)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tw
[(st)19(ories liv)18(es tell: narr)19(ativ)18(e and dialogue in education )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.894 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tw
[((pp. 67-77). ne)18(w y)80(ork: t)88(eacher)19(s)]tj
-21.98753 -1.41176 td
0 tw
(college pr)tj
4.33252 0 td
(ess)tj
1.31469 0 td
(.)tj
-7.76486 -1.41177 td
-0.013 tc
(grundy)tj
2.99588 0 td
-0.0132 tc
(,)tj
0.52872 0 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(s. (1989). be)19(y)19(ond pr)18(ofessionalism. in w)130(. carr (ed.), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 252.3829 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
-0.001 tw
(quality in teaching: ar)tj
9.09929 0 td
0 tw
(guments)tj
-32.3208 -1.41177 td
0 tc
(f)tj
0.29614 0 td
(or a r)tj
2.27539 0.00001 td
(eflectiv)tj
2.92407 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.70257 0 td
0 tc
(pr)tj
0.88898 0 td
(ofession )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 146.5535 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((pp. 79-99))tj
4.76074 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
(l)tj
0.4812 0 td
0 tc
(ondon: f)tj
3.81421 0 td
(almer)tj
2.38892 0 td
(.)tj
-24.88938 -1.41178 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
(guba, e. (ed.). (1990). the alternativ)tj
15.68085 0 td
(e)tj
0.76305 0 td
0 tw
(par)tj
1.40444 0 td
-0.013 tw
(adigm dialogue)tj
6.5299 0 td
(.)tj
0.541 0 td
(in e. guba (ed.), )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 310.5692 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.012 tw
(the par)tj
3.1473 0 td
0 tw
(adigm)tj
-33.21427 -1.41177 td
0 tc
(dialogue )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 86.7712 240.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((pp. 17-27))tj
4.76074 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55565 0 td
0 tc
[(ne)19(wbury p)55(ark, c)37(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-11.17183 -1.41177 td
-0.017 tc
(har)tj
1.50432 0 td
(dy)tj
0.93013 0.00001 td
-0.0172 tc
(,)tj
0.52467 0 td
(b)tj
0.53926 0 td
-0.017 tc
(.)tj
0.52497 0 td
0.003 tw
((1977). t)tj
3.69018 0 td
0 tc
(o)tj
0.5012 0 td
(w)tj
0.72312 0 td
-0.017 tc
0 tw
(ar)tj
0.81733 0.00001 td
0.003 tw
(ds a poetics of fiction. in m. meek (ed.), )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 262.4069 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
0.003 tw
(the cool w)tj
4.27197 0 td
0 tw
(eb )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 308.5635 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
((pp. 175-183))tj
5.65621 0 td
0 tc
(.)tj
-35.48721 -1.41177 td
0 tw
(ne)tj
1.16601 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(w)tj
1.03646 0 td
(y)tj
0.53118 0 td
0 tc
(ork: a)tj
2.57421 0 td
(theneum.)tj
-7.42551 -1.41178 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(hart, p)148(. (1996). pr)19(oblematizing enquiry in envir)18(onment)19(al education: issues of method in)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.0139 tc
(a)tj
0.75014 0 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(study of teacher thinking and pr)tj
13.44822 0 td
(actice)tj
2.3611 0 td
-0.0141 tc
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 200.2436 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
(canadian journal of envir)tj
10.37566 0 td
(onment)tj
3.03264 0 td
(al education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6391 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 59.4098 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.5557 0 td
0 tc
(56-88.)tj
-3.19215 -1.41176 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(hart, p)148(. (2000).  r)18(equisite v)19(ariety: the pr)19(oblem with generic guidelines f)18(or div)19(er)19(se genr)18(es)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(of qualit)tj
3.51831 0 td
[(ativ)19(e inquiry)110(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 134.6356 156.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(envir)tj
2.20361 0 td
[(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 257.5059 156.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 262.229 156.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 266.6388 156.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 37-46.)tj
-27.01633 -1.41176 td
0.002 tw
(hart, p)tj
2.87265 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55799 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(\(200)56(1\). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 94.3586 144.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sear)tj
1.83154 0.00001 td
0.002 tw
[(ching f)19(or meaning: the r)18(oots of teacher)19(s\325 implicit theories of education)]tj
-6.46196 -1.41177 td
0 tw
[(and the envir)19(onment)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 127.6816 132.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.5558 0 td
0 tc
[(unpublished paper)111(.)]tj
-11.22422 -1.41176 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(her)19(on, j. (1996). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 99.5085 120.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.01 tw
[(co-oper)19(ativ)18(e inquiry: r)19(esear)19(ch int)18(o the human condition)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 295.8338 120.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0034 tc
(.)tj
0.53862 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(thousand oaks)37(,)]tj
-28.872 -1.4118 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(c)37(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.1176 -1.4118 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(huberman, m. (1995). w)93(orking with life-hist)18(ory narr)19(ativ)19(es)36(. in h. mcew)19(an & k. egan \(eds)37(.\),)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 84.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.012 tc
0.118 tw
[(narr)19(ativ)18(e in teaching, learning, and r)19(esear)19(c)1(h)1( )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 224.5796 84.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.012 tc
0.126 tw
[((pp. 127-165). ne)18(w y)80(ork: t)88(eacher)18(s)]tj
-19.9505 -1.4118 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(college pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(162)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/length 12488
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 73 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(jackson, m. (1995). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 146.1984 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(a)37(t home in the w)19(orld)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 219.679 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.5557 0 td
0 tc
[(durham, nc: duk)19(e univ)18(er)19(sity pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj
-17.81205 -1.41176 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(jickling, b)37(. \(199)55(1\). envir)19(onment)19(al education, pr)19(oblem solving, and some humility please)55(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 564.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(t)tj
0.47607 -0.00001 td
(rumpeter)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 127.4653 564.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 132.1885 564.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(8)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 136.5983 564.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(\()tj
0.29587 -0.00001 td
0 tc
(3\), 153-155.)tj
-7.77803 -1.41176 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(josselson, r., lieblich, a., shar)19(aban)18(y)111(, r., & wiseman, h. (1997). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 309.1361 552.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.01 tw
[(conv)19(er)18(sation as method:)]tj
-25.66307 -1.41176 td
-0.006 tc
-0.007 tw
[(analyzing the r)19(elational w)18(orld of people who w)19(er)18(e r)19(aised communally)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 332.1707 540.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0064 tc
(.)tj
0.53555 0 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(thousand oaks)37(,)]tj
-28.90858 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(c)37(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(k)37(emmis)37(, s. & mct)147(aggart, r. \()1(20)-1(0)1(0)-1(\))1(. p)55(articipat)19(ory action r)19(esear)18(ch. in n. denzin & y)130(.)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(lincoln \(eds)37(.)1(\))1(,)1( )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 143.5499 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
-0.002 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 258.2999 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
((2nd edition) (pp. 567-605). thousand)tj
-19.68234 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(kinchloe)56(, j. & mcl)19(ar)18(en, p)148(. (2000). r)19(ethinking critical theory and qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch. in n.)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 186.0796 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
0.007 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(a)1(t)1(i)1(v)19(e)1( )1(r)20(e)1(s)1(e)1(a)1(r)19(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 298.4277 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(\(2nd edition\) \(pp. 279-3)56(13\).)]tj
-24.40326 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(thousand oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
[(k)37(v)19(ale)56(, s. (1995). the social construction of v)18(alidity)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 261.8843 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 334.2318 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 338.955 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 343.3647 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 19-40.)tj
-31.80761 -1.41176 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(k)36(v)19(a)-1(l)-1(e)55(, s. (1996). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 134.0722 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.01 tw
[(intervie)19(w)19(s: an intr)18(oduction t)19(o qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch intervie)18(wing)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 354.58 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0036 tc
(.)tj
0.53839 0 td
-0.004 tc
(thousand)tj
-31.5478 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(l)19(ather)111(, p)147(. (1993). f)56(ertile obsession: v)93(alidity after poststructur)19(alism. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 315.7363 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.008 tw
(sociological quarterly)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 392.639 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(34)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 99.8196 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55573 0 td
0 tc
(673-693.)tj
-3.71098 -1.41176 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(l)19(ather)110(, p)148(. (1995). the v)19(alidity of angels: interpr)18(etiv)19(e and te)19(xtual str)19(ategies in r)18(esear)19(ching)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(the liv)tj
2.62964 0 td
[(es of w)19(omen with hiv/aids. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 220.5337 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(qualit)tj
2.53515 0 td
[(ativ)19(e inquiry)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 286.4398 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 291.163 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 295.5727 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55558 0 td
(4)tj
0.50009 0 td
0 tc
(1-68.)tj
-27.24069 -1.41176 td
0.039 tw
[(lincoln, y)130(. (1995). emer)18(ging criteria f)19(or quality in qualit)19(ativ)19(e and interpr)18(etiv)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(qualit)tj
2.53515 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.53565 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.70271 0 td
0 tc
(inquiry)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 156.9061 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 161.6293 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 166.0391 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55573 0 td
0 tc
(275-289.)tj
-11.5015 -1.41176 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(lincoln, y)130(. & denzin, n. (2000). the se)19(v)18(enth moment: out of the past. in n. denzin & y)130(.)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0.02 tc
0.119 tw
(lincoln \(eds)tj
5.59707 0 td
0 tw
(.\), )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 149.8614 324.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.018 tc
0.111 tw
(handbook of qualit)tj
8.40233 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.60968 0 td
0.0183 tc
(e)tj
0.85045 0 td
(r)tj
0.38872 0 td
0.018 tc
(esear)tj
2.27492 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 276.7191 324.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.02 tc
0.119 tw
(\(2nd edition\) \(pp. 1)tj
9.0498 0 td
0 tw
(047-1)tj
2.54472 0 td
(065\).)tj
-33.44382 -1.41177 td
0 tc
(thousand oaks)tj
6.66773 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55551 0 td
(c)tj
0.57413 0 td
0 tc
[(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-9.91501 -1.41177 td
[(lincoln, y)130(. & guba, e. (1985). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 183.6577 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(natur)19(alistic inquiry)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 251.9399 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55562 0 td
0 tc
[(be)19(v)18(erly hills)37(, c)37(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-21.60737 -1.41176 td
0.013 tw
(lincoln, y)tj
4.19713 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.5688 0 td
(&)tj
1.0128 0 td
0 tc
(guba, e. (2000). p)tj
7.83616 0 td
0 tw
(ar)tj
0.85107 0.00001 td
0.013 tw
(adigmatic contr)tj
6.77086 0 td
(o)tj
0.51807 0 td
(v)tj
0.4812 0 td
[(er)19(sies)36(, contr)19(adictions)37(, and emer)18(ging)]tj
-20.11845 -1.41179 td
0 tw
(confluences)tj
5.09228 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.5667 0 td
0 tc
0.011 tw
[(in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 259.9875 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.01 tw
(handbook of qualit)tj
7.86784 0 td
[(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 378.156 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(\(2nd)tj
-33.78306 -1.41176 td
(edition\) \(pp. 163-188\). thousand oaks)tj
16.66894 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55551 0 td
(c)tj
0.57414 0 td
0 tc
(a: sage)tj
3.14844 0 td
(.)tj
-23.06467 -1.41178 td
(l)tj
0.47651 0 td
-0.005 tc
(opate)tj
2.32831 0 td
-0.0049 tc
(,)tj
0.53706 0 td
(p)tj
0.42134 0 td
-0.0048 tc
(.)tj
0.53716 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
((ed.). (1994). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 159.1702 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(the art of the per)tj
7.06848 0 td
(sonal essay: an anthology fr)tj
11.57419 0 td
(om the classical ear t)tj
8.60173 0 td
0 tc
(o)tj
-35.26442 -1.41178 td
0 tw
(the pr)tj
2.42529 0 td
(esent)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 130.0199 240.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
0 tc
(ne)tj
1.16603 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(w)tj
1.03646 0 td
0 tc
[(y)80(ork: anchor)110(.)]tj
-9.46636 -1.41177 td
(l)tj
0.48812 0 td
0.007 tc
(otz-sisitk)tj
3.93886 0.00001 td
0.132 tw
(a, h. \(200)tj
4.55611 0 td
0 tw
(1\). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 162.677 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(w)tj
0.83947 0 td
0.006 tc
0.123 tw
(eaving cloths: r)tj
6.88193 0.00001 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.21466 0 td
0.123 tw
(ch design in conte)tj
7.88863 0 td
(xts of tr)tj
3.58111 0 td
0 tw
(ansf)tj
1.7834 0 td
(ormation)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 392.6369 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.4867 -1.41176 td
(p)tj
0.51807 0 td
(aper pr)tj
3.11059 0 td
(esented at the eecom confer)tj
12.87012 0 td
(ence)tj
1.98097 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55574 0 td
0 tc
[(july 18-20, 200)56(1, whitehor)18(se)56(, canada.)]tj
-21.15313 -1.41178 td
0.069 tw
[(madriz, e. (2000). f)56(ocus gr)18(oups in feminist r)19(esear)19(ch. in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)36(.\),)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.006 tw
(handbook of qualit)tj
7.52514 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.46155 0 td
-0.0188 tc
(e)tj
0.67108 0 td
(r)tj
0.35168 0 td
-0.019 tc
(esear)tj
2.08975 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 203.8008 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
((2nd edition) (pp. 835-850). thousand oaks)tj
18.12459 0 td
-0.0201 tc
(,)tj
0.52176 0 td
(c)tj
0.55428 0 td
-0.02 tc
(a: sage)tj
3.01546 0 td
0 tc
(.)tj
-37.60443 -1.41178 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
(manning, k. (1997). a)tj
9.39557 0 td
(uthenticity in constructivist inquiry: methodological consider)tj
25.89394 0 td
0 tw
(ations)tj
-33.17186 -1.41177 td
0 tc
[(without pr)19(escription. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 169.8408 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e inquiry)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 235.7469 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 240.4701 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(3)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 244.8799 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((1), 93-1)161(15.)]tj
-20.22117 -1.41176 td
-0.027 tc
(mcew)tj
2.48329 0 td
0.013 tw
[(an, h. & egan, k. \(eds)37(.\). \(1995\). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 207.0021 156.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.025 tc
(narr)tj
1.78642 0 td
0.012 tw
[(a)1(t)1(i)1(v)20(e in teaching, learning, and r)18(e)1(s)1(e)1(a)1(r)20(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 354.642 156.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0273 tc
(.)tj
0.51463 0 td
-0.027 tc
(ne)tj
1.11178 0 td
-0.0274 tc
(w)tj
0.99544 0 td
-0.027 tc
[(y)80(ork:)]tj
-33.63856 -1.41177 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.46801 0.00001 td
[(eacher)19(s college pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-2.58566 -1.41177 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(noddings)37(, n. (1992). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 150.3457 132.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tc
-0.009 tw
[(the challenge t)19(o car)18(e in schools: an alternativ)19(e appr)18(oach t)19(o education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 392.6393 132.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.48698 -1.41176 td
[(ne)19(w y)79(ork: t)88(eacher)19(s college pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-2.1176 -1.4118 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(oult)19(on, c. & scott, w)129(. (2000). envir)19(onment)19(al education: a time f)18(or r)19(e)19(visioning. in b)36(. moon,)]tj
2.1176 -1.4118 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(m. ben-p)56(er)18(etz, & s. br)19(o)19(wn \(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 212.5833 96.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(r)18(outledge international companion t)19(o education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 380.873 96.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.008 tc
(\(pp.)tj
-34.1027 -1.4118 td
0 tc
[(489-50)56(1\). l)18(ondon: r)19(outledge)56(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1466 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(163)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
28 0 obj
<<
/length 13398
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(p)56(agano, j. \(199)56(1\). mor)19(al fictions: the dilemma of theory and pr)18(actice)56(. in c wither)19(ell & n.)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(noddings \(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 113.9259 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.022 tc
0.009 tw
[(st)19(ories liv)18(es tell: narr)19(ativ)18(e and dialogue in education )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 291.2416 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[((pp. 234-256). ne)19(w)]tj
-27.79313 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(y)tj
0.531 -0.00001 td
0 tw
[(ork: t)88(eacher)18(s college pr)19(ess)37(.)]tj
-2.64865 -1.41176 td
-0.014 tc
[(p)56(almer)111(, j. & suggate)56(, j. (1996). influences and e)18(xperiences affecting the pr)19(o-envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(beha)19(viour of educat)18(or)19(s)37(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 143.2913 540.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 266.1615 540.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 270.8846 540.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 275.2944 540.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((1), 1)56(09-12)56(1.)]tj
-28.03464 -1.41176 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(p)56(almer)111(, j., suggate)56(, j., r)18(obott)19(om, i., & hart, p)148(. (1999). significant life e)19(xperiences and f)18(orm-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
-0.013 tw
[(ativ)19(e influences on the de)18(v)19(elopment of adults\325 envir)19(onment)19(al a)18(w)19(ar)19(eness in the uk,)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(a)56(ustr)19(alia, and canada. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 139.6783 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 262.5486 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 267.2717 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(5)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 271.6815 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((2), 18)56(1-200.)]tj
-27.60959 -1.41176 td
-0.011 tw
[(phillips)37(, d. (1987). v)92(alidity in qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch: wh)19(y the w)18(orry about w)19(arr)19(ant will not)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(w)19(ane)56(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 78.9166 480.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(education and urban society)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 180.7091 480.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 185.4322 480.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(20)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 194.2518 480.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 9-24.)tj
-18.50021 -1.41176 td
0.131 tw
[(p)56(olkinghorne)56(, d. (1988). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 132.258 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.122 tw
[(narr)19(ativ)18(e kno)19(wing and the human sciences)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 288.4433 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.68659 0 td
0 tc
0.131 tw
[(alban)19(y)111(, ny)73(: st)19(ate)]tj
-28.15051 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(univ)19(er)18(sity of ne)19(w y)80(ork pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(p)56(olkinghorne)55(, d. (1989). changing conv)19(er)19(sations about human science)55(. in s. k)37(v)19(ale (ed.),)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(issues of v)19(alidity in qualit)18(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 195.9244 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((pp. 13-45). l)18(und, sw)19(eden: studentlitter)19(atur)111(.)]tj
-18.69699 -1.41176 td
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
[(p)56(olkinghorne)56(, d. (1995). narr)19(ativ)18(e configur)19(ation in qualit)19(ativ)19(e anal)-1(y)19(sis)37(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 312.4056 420.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.006 tc
(international)tj
-30.28301 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(journal of qualit)19(ativ)18(e studies in education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 204.3041 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 209.0272 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(8)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 213.437 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 5-23.)tj
-20.7573 -1.41177 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(r)19(eason, p)148(. (ed.). (1988). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 126.1116 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.01 tw
[(human inquiry in action: de)19(v)19(elopments in ne)18(w par)19(adigm r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6372 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.48673 -1.41176 td
[(ne)19(wbury p)55(ark: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
(r)tj
0.5982 0 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(eason, p)148(. (1996). r)19(eflections on the purposes of human inquiry)110(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 270.1525 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
(qualit)tj
2.46301 0 td
-0.001 tw
[(ativ)19(e inquiry)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 334.109 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0132 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 338.6045 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 342.9121 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0131 tc
(,)tj
0.52888 0 td
-0.013 tc
(58-)tj
-34.40089 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(72.)tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
(richar)tj
2.75854 0 td
0.091 tw
(dson, l. (1994). w)tj
8.23632 0 td
(riting: a method of inquiry)tj
11.82648 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.64688 0 td
0 tc
[(in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)36(.\),)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(handbook of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)18(ch )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 172.6532 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(\(pp. 5)56(16-529\). thousand oaks)36(, c)37(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-15.9592 -1.41176 td
(richar)tj
2.75854 0 td
0.091 tw
(dson, l. (2000). w)tj
8.23632 0 td
(riting: a method of inquiry)tj
11.82648 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.64688 0 td
0 tc
(in n. denzin & y)tj
7.58471 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.64691 0 td
0 tc
(lincoln \(eds)tj
5.33103 0 td
0 tw
(.\),)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 312.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.006 tw
(handbook of qualit)tj
7.52514 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.46155 0 td
-0.0188 tc
(e)tj
0.67108 0 td
-0.019 tc
[(r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 167.8008 312.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
((2nd edition) (pp. 923-948). thousand oaks)tj
18.12459 0 td
-0.0201 tc
(,)tj
0.52176 0 td
(c)tj
0.55428 0 td
-0.02 tc
[(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-34.58897 -1.41177 td
0 tc
-0.005 tw
[(r)19(obott)19(om, i. & hart, p)147(. (1993). t)88(o)19(w)19(ar)19(ds a met)18(a-r)19(esear)19(ch agenda in science and envir)19(on)-1(-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tw
(ment)tj
2.25903 0 td
(al education. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 123.6267 288.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(international journal of science education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 271.9783 288.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 276.7014 288.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(15)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 285.521 288.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((5), 59)tj
2.75927 0 td
(1-605.)tj
-31.99704 -1.41177 td
(r)tj
0.60656 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(odw)19(ell, m. & by)18(er)19(s)36(, k. (1997). a)56(uditing constructivist inquiry: p)56(er)18(spectiv)19(es of tw)19(o st)18(ak)19(e)-1(-)]tj
1.51108 -1.41177 td
0 tc
0 tw
(holder)tj
2.74072 0 td
(s)tj
0.38892 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 86.3251 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(qualit)tj
2.53515 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.53565 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.70271 0 td
0 tc
(inquiry)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 152.2312 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 156.9543 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(3)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 161.3641 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 1)tj
2.09839 0 td
(16-134.)tj
-16.72946 -1.41176 td
(r)tj
0.61108 0 td
(orty)tj
1.62964 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.56245 0 td
0 tc
0.007 tw
(r. (1979). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 99.6723 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(philosoph)tj
4.07398 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(y)tj
0.74598 0 td
0 tc
0.006 tw
(and the mirr)tj
5.17614 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(or)tj
1.15389 0 td
(of)tj
1.07989 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(natur)tj
2.23969 0 td
(e)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 226.4363 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.5625 0 td
0 tc
(princet)tj
3.03553 0 td
0.007 tw
(on, nj: princet)tj
6.25199 0 td
(on univ)tj
3.37635 0 td
0 tw
(er)tj
0.85107 0 td
(sity)tj
-34.24643 -1.41178 td
(pr)tj
0.92505 0 td
[(ess)37(.)]tj
-3.04269 -1.41177 td
(r)tj
0.58458 0 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
(ubin, h. & r)tj
5.07132 0.00001 td
(ubin, i. (1995). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 138.5493 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.025 tc
(qualit)tj
2.38672 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.43669 0.00001 td
-0.0249 tc
(e)tj
0.66501 0 td
-0.025 tc
(intervie)tj
2.93021 0 td
0.012 tw
(wing: the art of hearing dat)tj
10.91367 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 298.4032 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0266 tc
(.)tj
0.51535 0 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
(thousand oaks)tj
6.33567 0 td
0 tc
(,)tj
-35.48669 -1.41177 td
(c)tj
0.57398 0 td
0 tw
(a: sage)tj
3.14844 0 td
(.)tj
-5.84006 -1.41177 td
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(s)-1(a)-1(n)-1(g)-1(e)-1(r)110(, j. (1996). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 97.7757 204.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.026 tc
0.013 tw
[(the compleat observ)19(er? a field r)18(esear)19(ch guide t)19(o observ)19(ation)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 298.596 204.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0276 tc
(.)tj
0.51436 0 td
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(l)19(ondon: f)55(a)-1(l)-1(m)-1(e)-1(r)110(.)]tj
-31.29037 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(scheurich, j. (1997). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 113.5021 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r)tj
0.61108 0 td
(esear)tj
2.18238 0 td
(ch method in the postmodern)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 239.8462 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
(l)tj
0.4812 0 td
0 tc
(ondon: f)tj
3.81421 0 td
(almer)tj
2.38892 0 td
(.)tj
-31.10425 -1.41178 td
(schw)tj
2.27759 0 td
(andt, t)tj
2.92652 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55573 0 td
0 tc
((1996). f)tj
3.85198 0 td
[(ar)19(e)18(w)19(ell t)19(o criteriology)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 201.6294 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(qualit)tj
2.53516 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.53565 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.70271 0 td
0 tc
(inquiry)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 267.5355 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 272.2587 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 276.6685 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.5557 0 td
0 tc
(58-72.)tj
-28.752 -1.41176 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(schw)19(andt, t)129(. (2000). thr)19(ee epistemological st)19(ances f)19(or qualit)18(ativ)19(e inquiry: interpr)19(etivism,)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.013 tc
0 tw
(hermeneutics)tj
5.69565 0 td
-0.0131 tc
(,)tj
0.5289 0 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(and social constructionism. in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)36(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 324.1605 156.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
(handbook)tj
-31.66594 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(of qualit)tj
3.40502 0.00001 td
[(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 135.0548 144.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(\(2nd edition\) \(pp. 189-2)tj
10.24146 0.00001 td
[(13\). thousand oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-21.77732 -1.41177 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(silv)19(erman, d. (1997). t)87(o)19(w)19(ar)19(ds an aesthetics of r)18(esear)19(ch. in d. silv)19(erman (ed.), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 321.2543 132.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.008 tc
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
-31.32404 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(r)19(esear)18(ch: theory)111(, method and pr)19(actice)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 190.917 120.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((pp. 239-253). l)18(ond)1(o)-1(n: )1(sage)55(.)]tj
-18.1079 -1.4118 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(smith, j. (1984). the pr)19(oblem of criteria f)18(or judging interpr)19(etiv)19(e inquiry)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 317.2404 108.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.003 tc
(educational)tj
-30.8518 -1.4118 td
0 tc
[(ev)19(aluation and p)36(olicy analy)19(sis)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 163.0616 96.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 167.7848 96.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 172.1946 96.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((4), 379-39)56(1.)]tj
-15.9052 -1.4118 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
(smith, j. (1993). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 96.255 84.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.006 tw
[(after the demise of empiricism: the pr)19(oblem of judging social and educational)]tj
-4.8535 -1.4118 td
0 tc
0 tw
(inquiry)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 80.1783 72.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.5556 0 td
0 tc
[(norw)19(ood, nj: able)18(x.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.998 17.496 322.999 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.998 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(paul hart)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 21.198 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(164)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
29 0 obj
<<
/length 5139
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 73 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(smith, j. & deemer)111(, d. (2000). the pr)19(oblem of criteria in the age of r)19(elativism. in n. denzin)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(&)tj
1.13875 0 td
0.139 tw
[(y)130(. lincoln \(eds)36(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 167.2064 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.129 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 289.5562 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.139 tw
((2nd edition) (pp. 877-896).)tj
-23.35955 -1.41176 td
-0.0001 tc
(t)tj
0.55588 -0.00001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(housand oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.67353 -1.41176 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(sw)18(ar)19(d, l. & mar)19(cink)18(o)19(w)18(ski, t)130(. (1997). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 202.4808 552.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.024 tc
0.011 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al sensitivity: a r)19(e)19(vie)18(w of the r)19(esear)18(ch, 1980-)]tj
-13.11539 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(1995)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 108.6392 540.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55127 0 td
0 tc
-0.004 tw
[(p)56(aper pr)18(esented at the annual confer)19(ence of the north american association)]tj
-2.62647 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(f)19(or envir)19(onment)18(al education.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.014 tc
[(t)148(anner)111(, t)130(. (1980). significant life e)18(xperiences)37(.)1( )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 235.524 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
[(journal of envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 357.4135 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0145 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 361.898 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.124 tc
(11)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 369.5504 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tc
((4), 20-)tj
-32.77064 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(24.)tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(ten ha)19(v)18(e)56(, p)148(. (1999). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 143.4695 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.006 tw
[(doing conv)19(er)18(sation analy)19(sis: a pr)18(actical guide)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 298.9108 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0201 tc
(.)tj
0.52189 0 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(thousand oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-27.09963 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(thomasho)19(w)111(, m. (1995). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 162.1027 480.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ecological identity)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 226.606 480.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55578 0 td
0 tc
[(cambridge)56(, ma: mit pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-18.62708 -1.41176 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(vidich, a. & l)37(yman, s. (2000). qualit)18(ativ)19(e methods: their hist)19(ory in sociology and anthr)19(o-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(pology)111(. in n. denzin & y)130(. lincoln \(eds)36(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 234.8116 456.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
-0.001 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(a)1(t)1(i)1(v)19(e)1( )1(r)20(e)1(s)1(e)1(a)1(r)20(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 349.1386 456.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
((2nd edition))tj
-30.36925 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[((pp. 37-84). thousand oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(white)56(, s. \(199)55(1\). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 134.0437 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
0.002 tw
[(p)37(olitical theory and postmodernism)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 255.0238 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0161 tc
(.)tj
0.52591 0 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(cambridge)56(, uk: cambridge univ)18(er)19(sity)]tj
-19.82283 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(wither)19(ell, c. \(199)55(1)1(\). the self in narr)18(ativ)19(e)55(. in c. wither)19(ell & n. noddings (ed.), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 353.6024 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.006 tw
[(st)19(ories liv)18(es)]tj
-30.8944 -1.41177 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(tell: narr)19(ativ)18(e and dialogue in education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 231.6111 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55565 0 td
0 tc
[(ne)19(w y)79(ork: t)88(eacher)19(s college pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-19.21578 -1.41176 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(w)92(olcott, h. (1994). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f10 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 144.2073 384.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(t)79(r)19(ansf)18(orming qualit)19(ativ)19(e dat)18(a: description, analy)19(sis)37(, and interpr)18(et)19(ation)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f9 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 392.6416 384.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.48725 -1.41176 td
(thousand oaks)tj
6.66773 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55551 0 td
0 tc
[(c)37(a: sage)55(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 87.8172 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(narrative, knowing, and emerging methodologies in environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
395.985 17.496 25.325 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1466 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(165)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/nums[0<</s/d/st 140>>]
>>
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/differences[32/space 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon 63/question 67/c/d/e/f 72/h/i/j/k/l/m/n 80/p/q/r/s/t/u 87/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 108/l/m/n/o/p 114/r/s/t/u/v/w 121/y]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
/type/encoding
>>
endobj
32 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 5789
/length1 5789
>>
stream




ajnmwl+eurostileregular

7�����
�?��
�?��ea���


6/bsujwf

,opxhe&n.imtvd3*g2z1)6$+	
4q'8 -c5%8
h


k
�
�
�s�����hk�k��e�	x���	�	�
b
f
�ts�3��

�
��0o�� ��s@x��o��{���.��.����.��.��vu��%�w�x�k�j���j���������.���������?�?��-���5��u�.����`���@��zk��k�d�
���i�'��<��"*u_uu_p;��v�*���7�������$� ��o�s��s���3�'(weyyer@��������u���q�x@�(o�y)j��kk�{��՛�����ї���~q��:�� ���t���0��z)��z�r�s��͋�i3��d��0^1t����� �p����p�z� �z�����i�1�=�m�f���p����v�\�/^^1�0^����������u�1� �1� �-�p� �p� �b�7�p�6��x�6s9s:�q�r�v�7�=���$���p�]���p�0�����izaiwwib���?��kk�{��+�d��jo�u��t���d�6�jjtsip��r�b���kk��k�d�+����dz������#m������ۭ���Ԟ���{l��l�h$�^������l�l��h�tnnr�?���������z�.����u���.�����g�p�w��&�[��������.�*�� ���n���y��|o��o�t9g��� ��r�[��[.���>!z)a������p��c�vmq��a�b���nm��m�d�d�����Ȧ��b�ap�w��v���d�d�lnw��6�c�"�>�>|!mccm>w��>��mm�}��>�>������ؠ���vc��g��p���a�:w8v8�x�x�c�9����`���c�9w8x8�w�w�a�:����'���p�h�����6�ܞ���:�:��6����d���p�*����p����[�$��0��(&geuuep��s�m���ee��i�"�@�����t.xlgkkfc{!$h��mm�|�����8�__��u�#�4����ǿ������ r�>�]�-�$�8y hwwgbr��c��kj�{��2�0����ӣ���t^����u����i�$��b�� +heuuep��g�w���dc��h�'�4������� u� p���[�/��=y�iyyh@r�!e��ii�{��4�%�뭻��ϣ���s[���l���
���
��g���i��i�e�g���� ���c���s� �m��_�� ���	�ڳ���֠���|m��m�r7�� ��z���u�4�
u o��h)��6�.#u u����$� �p��mu���p�"�}�t}iod�o�n�q�#�������.���������}�����k�l�f���.�e���ˍ���������b�b9���.u���'�u��� ����߳���ڡ��'�c�$p��� ����i�����6(^2h����� ���u��� u� �����y�,�����2!ygvvgqd ��a�gg�� y�i�x'ex]guug?��-l��kk�{�����%�w�%�f�ee��x�1�,����ij����@4��a��#���-�\���˙�����͔��Ѓ{��{�ai� �����p���	v;b__b@v�7r��on�}���� ��s���t�3������� �p� ���u�$ong}!�:��ii�z��3�6������Σ��
�~s��r�zar� �n�s��r!��/�2�igssgo��q�^���kj��k�@�����a��� !|hoo������e���;�3���.���9b��$���ɫ���������#m�o�o�#��&�����.�����xf��e�;�(uhagg`;z�	�q������l�l�.�l�.���l�.�l�.�}�u���.u�. ����������/�🬈����di�o�u+-�o�"�&��&��� �h����є�(�v��j�pk��j�5������4eahgaj�e�����i�??��9e�����=����<�����?ge]�h�i�k���gf�y�9������9�������l�r�ry��y��r����5�[�	��d"�-���&�!�p��>u�hr q!�f�g�a�h�'�>�)���p��w��p-f�sn@�}�{�x��������ͦ��������"�����)�������nj�4������é��0�6o�s��s"��.w�����.��2Ɗ���y�h�h�8��uc`lk`)|�,�
���_��u�������.���.�
���
�.u�.�g���-�u9_kk_�{�f�9$��aa�v���p�.�p]�'�'�ww��"q�e�r�&��������b�p�.�p������tc^on^�}�i�s���kj�{�t��:�������p��{l��k�e��a�-����.l�o��o�	��b���;os>i[ct}n}n��)�����ê�t�9�9�%c�y�����3�˹ʹ��	��n��-�:����u��.�/�����.u�r���ru�<���i�����.���`��`�,�����,����������ctip�k�����c�i6��.a�����-����ͤ�r����q�zw��w�-������+jiu��"�y��8����z�8izyi�s�s�t���ii�{�8������8�������t�s�rz���|u�>�{5kgfkay��
a��mm�|�����+�]�um��0�yy��s�8�5�����ũ��5�w�.���u����`�-�k�)��x�w9���ix���)������������)����Ť��e��0�.am8m7|���b�b����78��a�0���*q��x�������#�⭪����b��y������©�
��8��>k�l�k����l��d��ofufui�
��7�d�+����϶�����8��yh��h�?�	�y8hkhk&q�<y�fs�hs_s^o-��$���k���9����z��)�����������)xz[xqr+����/�赩��ߛ���b�b{��m��m.��/e����r[����a�m���`�^�qwhgwj#�/�t���|{�,��4���{�o�o�t8�v<cmmb�
}�d�.+��fe�y����-�n��+�'�yy��s�y�v�'���ͼ��
�<�/n�q�q����h��j��
�g�f�y΋����ʺ�����6����|�m�m�f���-�3l�m����.� ���6��a�2�����Ѧ��h�up�v��u*��"�5"]/[����
� �����[�!�6�(z)i\[ift"�a��gf�y��(�3����Ԥ���s[����[�������.��-��-�q�?sxu���gb�whwh�x�y�d����k�x���jd�xixh�x΁�����c����i�2�7���z���i���ɜ���m�i�v�������k�~�bu�5�����
���{m��m�i'�x?ekke0|�"�l���dc�x����*:�0�&�[[��!s�l�[����Ϳ���3�z�i�i�g�$���ȧ�����܋��� j�k�k����\��x��ro[n[m%��0�u�&���Ю�����)�5�}q��p�b�#vkbtsb���lw������2u�h�����d�)�xe��e�4��>x#geef&x�8�2)��ee�x���%w� �-�\[��t�^�_�����˫��f�?j�	i��i���h�n�e@v���2����+�������
h�e��e���w�v�mqmlql��h��p�����y���mm��m�f�b�����ì�
�h�9l�m��m���k�`�b:q��������
��@��s��s�[c��z�s�*���>�*�j�5��w;dlkc(|�4�9%��cc�w��4��̹�����*�8�zk�������������.l�n��m���l�x�t^nm^m,�$��?�c�c�m�x�)xklmam`|:����7�"�[�[�$t�r��^���ʿɿ��
��;��|�m�m�m�+���ũ���4�3�s�m%�ydimli<|��n���ba�w����Э�����0�8�t�����o�k%!etgsg[ta����u�/�n�o�o�}��
��Ӳ�����2�5�}p��2��l�l�.�l�.�4��ڸ��ߩ������d�%o�t��s"��0�n�
qyqqxo �6�^�%�����֫���ڛ���|n��n�d��a;7k8k3iriqgqgk0�m�+���������:�aa��w�^�a�����ì��c��!����li�
h��g���d�_�nrlkrl��j�4� �ts��p�b�p������a�-x.eiie"{�@�+,��cc�w�����%�o�x�����g�-�,�udaoo`�~�d�5��gg�y����ݰ�����)�=�yg����u�����#�r��.�!����
���2�_�*��'����Ѩ��i�rp�v��u+�� �f#\/k����� ��� ����[�$�2�*z'j[[jgs%�>��ii�{��a� �豺��գ���r[��(����#���#�q�:�.��m�d���l�������z����h�9f��e���w����3����p�/�ji��i��1���vs�&\ji["k�7�q�����
endstream
endobj
33 0 obj
<<
/stemv 0
/capheight 1775
/stemh 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/flags 32
/descent -512
/fontname/ajnmwl+eurostileregular
/xheight 0
/ascent 1775
/fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867]
/italicangle 0
/fontfile3 32 0 r
>>
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1
/basefont/ajnmwl+eurostileregular
/widths[250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 277 277 0 0 198 0 0 0 613 614 613 613 613 613 613 613 614 614 195 0 0 0 0 520 0 0 0 597 653 498 489 0 667 204 502 603 485 858 696 0 590 655 623 560 515 655 0 999 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 510 511 485 510 502 265 510 514 188 0 0 188 826 516 506 510 0 398 474 326 507 402 670 0 389]
/lastchar 121
/name/f0
/firstchar 32
/fontdescriptor 33 0 r
/encoding 31 0 r
/type/font
>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<<
/differences[65/a 82/r 97/a/b/c 109/m 114/r/s/t/u 142/eacute]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
/type/encoding
>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 1943
/length1 1943
>>
stream




vjjeuc+usherwood-bolditalic

@��
����^������
��
��
/
+
f�v

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bold italicitc usherwood



"ctusbd3�vn
�
 
�
�q�0�5�ӆ��r���������cq���t�y�o��������� �y��������pa�[��k���������$��f������x�$�������������y�x�x\\�\$�k�����{yy\h�z��[gvn�oy������������$������r�k-y�������w
�+�����������erle{)��kǨ�k}�t�ua��c�g�ft��a��f��;�<�\�@?tj[c��o�����z쬜di�f�:(bm���oy���
�����"��������o�d�:���en�4��"�a��)�bbl[�p�d���������g�wcskrg�x�w�����ȋ��%�av�狱�������p�j����~��y���ǘw��������xuggjk}�����������Ǩ����|�ȅtx�e?��&e^:_y2hxc�s���k�i�|o�p���Ƿ��o�v�
�
���)��y�������n~������𑜒����}�hicenp>4���������}�fccdtpfq�s��������mu\m���j���������$�y���
���b����]�_���ɶ�t�y|ssz�u}�����e��e���gt�]$�=�!�v�3f�?�ܽӾ����y+oy�,>n������u𚚇���oy���
���s���4pxz<jtl�����۫�vjw�x�y�w�ɖ������o�f�6��3�7��i����ñ�������m�f�p��
����d���������o����������$��a�n����������a΋���1�1�������������$��p�u�x�i���l����Ώ����?��rk��k҉ji�lyy��y�y�y�y�҄k�����a|�x�};��|kzk@�����������ּnk0>j�
c�=y����������\'��(�c����π�!���(���(ekbs=lg�ǒ�������p��
�t�>�a��6�7��o���������{sb�\ayƜ���ry��*w��h���z�����t�xzuys�r}���������>�������y�w{t��x i�n��������v<�
�q1u|�������ب𕯐������wqmrob:r�r��������wwz�v�}�n'�l�j�mi�g����Ȼ���y�r�vp�i�������^�v�v�����>���p�z�x�ʘ��b���zop�d�ly�}���������$������Ƌ��tt~�v�}�g��n�r�sv�i��������w�yqmp�|�������z��"�������g�ikpn8h���������a�b;9�sc���������~�f`rng_ks�s��������yk<m�e�f���������$y����f��`��������
�����
endstream
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/stemv 112
/capheight 622
/stemh 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/flags 262242
/descent -254
/fontname/vjjeuc+usherwood-bolditalic
/xheight 694
/ascent 684
/fontbbox[-202 -308 1068 850]
/italicangle -12
/fontfile3 36 0 r
>>
endobj
38 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1
/basefont/vjjeuc+usherwood-bolditalic
/widths[722 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 685 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 556 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 852 0 0 0 0 463 463 389 593 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 481]
/lastchar 142
/name/f1
/firstchar 65
/fontdescriptor 37 0 r
/encoding 35 0 r
/type/font
>>
endobj
39 0 obj
<<
/differences[32/space 44/comma/hyphen/period 59/semicolon 65/a 67/c/d/e 71/g 73/i 85/u 87/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 136/agrave 142/eacute/egrave/ecircumflex 153/ocircumflex 213/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
/type/encoding
>>
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 5974
/length1 5974
>>
stream




lyttrm+usherwood-mediumitalic

@��
����w���w��
��
��
3
/
��9

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood medium italicitc usherwood


+8juio
fdpygbevmstnzxqlwh
r"c($6%���k*��&-
�
7
�c��>��z���
�	f
-
�n�o��
o
l��w� ��g�%�o��������
�����a�����'��a���������$�����
��z�x�l�st��$�s�����za��i�
�]�n��t�u�tpj�x$�s�����hj�&e�!e�"�c��t�u�tpj�x$�s�����h��)��u��n���������$�è§��y��dw����{�a���������rvy�{~�������ȫ��������z�mwt��z3k�{��������vxw�z�w�d�.�m�l�ld�a������$��������w�soknar�s���y����w������wsonery������������������Ѐvy�qz������jc<uk*a�s�n���m�l�kv�{�������y�kv�/����w���{�z���3������nkt�t�t�n��j�j�jg�d������������rvy�wz�������z���������h�x9:'xd����<�ɚȜ�wtls}=��s���gr�r�sw��y5u5v7���������$-y�kv�/����-�|�t�?�:�������xlp�q�q�n��j�c�ij�d������Ĺ~�z�zzw�v~�������t���������i�y8n:>h���������{�jz{��}3k�{��������mt8x�nr2���������$��by��%�
������
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*��ty��%�
������
�
o�^qo\m�se�����-몦wev�v�w�~���������_�e��#�4�b"�p�͵�ѻ�y��0�
������ty�$�
�#�/�<���$�	�%�-��?�$�h���-�تla�<�-'>q���y��qv�2�i��������a�q�h�iŋ�����ü}�x}wts�dy��}t�˧��ź���{z���o���y�v�qgoyi`k�}�}�b�psyzv�my�v��������mu��+cenxhry�st��yw{�c�v�x�����ŭ��������w�k�s��c���u�8�ǔ����w�Ԁsn�pb����-���yx~�~�~��̛�������������pq��q�!q�,e|r�lj�m��c�ni�35�wx�������t�jt�z~y�wf���?��p�t��*y��%�
���[��|�y�{~{|w�t�����h��v���zlm�k$�,�(�q�74�p�ݸݻ�������k�i������������m�������ra�2~kq�\hd�d�y����y��%����w
���s��������rvy�w{�����ɷ�kwtls}=��s���gz�}�z}np�n�n��3��a�1 �n��ｧ���x�v�vb�]����������#��,ﴳne_7���_k��-y�m������y��)Ҁ�t�������rvy�wz������[���{�wyw||s�s��������~y.'���ko����œ���ěƳ�z�kv{��z3k�{��������w}�io�'�hb�f����ɽ���v�s�sg�a�������y�����w
���|�����rvy�wz����������ɣ䒮wtls}=��s���gr�r�s:��j�j�jg�d�������t�v��a����3���<�#�������|{�������֐������y�uajbmo7.���������y�fz{��}�3k�{��������mt;z�hq)���������$�ty��0�
�������������r�_�0�%�cr�7�� �d��"�`h^e�u�[���������r�wjwlul�g�g���	��͋���!�d{������ċ���r�b����ky�kv�/����d��$�|�z�e�h������toy�e�of�����������$��b����݋��xlp�q�q�n��j�c�ij�d������Ĺ~�z�zzw�v~�������z���������i�y@f<nw���������r�p<)�en���������{�jz{��}3k�{��������kw;m�y}y���������$�������
c��v��f����o�s��������xq6��.`?�����-ux{~z<l�v������ђ��6'.�ds����o�r�t�t�u�ww%���������b���]����~�o}w��s�
�����f��3��j��d�����o�s��������zx,��0`x���������x�}�{�z�{xy�x$�s�����e*��
bl��������1s�zrvz{wku�w����������\�$b�a�b���������$�����Ǝp�p�p�n�p�o���������$���y�`����p}w��s��}v�v�p��$����v��q��֝֜י���}~�}uw����������k�v���8��v�&�x�a-f�`p���������{�kz{��}3k�{��������tsx�t�zr���q��euq�_�����w���_n�f�@�
ey���y�kv�7����w������2��wr8�5am}ϗ����g�p�������p������ĸ}�y~y|u�@��4� �������o�p<<4nq�����ɚȜ�wtls}=��s���gw�m�s|nm��d�+���������$�*�v�/�
�*��l����o�s��������xw5�&�<`y������1s�zrvz{wku�w����������\�$b�a�b���������$���^�p����o}w��s�*����z�� �
�����#���i�t�����kl�l$�j��p�-,�r�ڴɵ���o�t�n�(�vd�������o�xduesfn��\��q���'�������
������l�
������%bv�{�_p���Ѡv�h�
�����f������ˆ�׵lot��zhb�z?a�y�
����������u�mkolmx�y������werozi�*�}v���7��%�}�����)��؝כٚ��r{��������������qod|w�}y��fk��g�"�,�+�h��u�ܻզ���e�3s�v�:f`���/��/���sgr>���wo���y�
���y�����{�tossku�w����������
������3�q�`�������������!����~hd�c��s���������$��`�x�~�\��������������b�c�bef�e$�s�����yvriyr�s����6y��fx������������$��������`�y��%����w
�!����������hj�=�;�
fc�����tls}=��s���gr�r�s{0c��zt�z�e��c���g��4��_�;�=�q;f[��������dy����r�������������v�w�����9�����v�v�wop�o$�k�����n{�{�|�\�=}k](�z���>��a�j��jf�������s���~__�_$����z�q�/�7� ��
����?y��Ȫl����,�����gygs'�
�
\���k��q�+��ja�������o؃����ts��s��ts�s�n�3�u�r�&�*�!�2��ò�y��ң
������ݕ�ۚ��k�k�lfg�g$�s�����z�u�uv��{du��5�ed�߮��������䙔Й��d�d�dbc�b$�s�����r{�y�{z�w�cd�c��[��s��=��y�����������������u�mkolmx�y������werozip�m�������{�tossku�w����k��ϵn��w���������������d��q�� �ehh�������d�o������������������b�+�5�~�//��1qq��r��qr�qww��x��ww�wt�s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@���v�<�l
��-�
�<������u�mkolmx�y������werozi�by��%��aw���&�g<��(�o����҅�x�y�y{x�$���!��
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*��by��%��������3��(�2�����a�i�;�����
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*��*y��%���ww����0f��$�����q��}�{|��{$}w�t�
��|�y�{~{|w�t�����h��v���zlm�k$�,�(�q�74�p�ݸݻ�������k�i������������m�������ra�2~kq�\hd�d�y��������gw���'�b���j�����Σ�|�lvu��z3k�{��������uzr�m�sn��i�(h=k�vy�������m�ygwiuhq��i��8��(��(��������w�soknar�s������ܣ
w�	w����������$��t�b������������Ք�ٔ��e�e�ecd�c$�s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@��by��%���ww����0���$�����q��}�{|��{$}w�x�
��
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*��y��0��������p��(�2�����a�i�;�����ty�$�
�#�/�<���$�	�%�-��?�$�h���-�تla�<�-'>q��?�v���ov͵�|�x��w�w�-��x�x��������⃋q���Ɯƞ�iece�2ok���������;�ېu��ɛɝ�ntn�u/&��|���jk��q������sx�yx��;�kww��xr��ww�w���s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@�y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
41 0 obj
<<
/stemv 75
/capheight 622
/stemh 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/flags 98
/descent -254
/fontname/lyttrm+usherwood-mediumitalic
/xheight 694
/ascent 684
/fontbbox[-195 -282 995 857]
/italicangle -12
/fontfile3 40 0 r
>>
endobj
42 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1
/basefont/lyttrm+usherwood-mediumitalic
/widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 333 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 667 0 574 648 574 0 611 0 296 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 648 0 944 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 519 426 519 444 333 500 537 278 278 519 259 833 556 519 519 500 426 426 352 556 500 759 537 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 444 444 444 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259]
/lastchar 213
/name/f2
/firstchar 32
/fontdescriptor 41 0 r
/encoding 39 0 r
/type/font
>>
endobj
43 0 obj
<<
/differences[32/space]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
/type/encoding
>>
endobj
44 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 147
/length1 147
>>
stream




xztfzh+eurostileregular

7�����
�?��
�?��dag��




!��{���.��.����.��.����
endstream
endobj
45 0 obj
<<
/stemv 0
/capheight 1775
/stemh 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/flags 34
/descent -512
/fontname/xztfzh+eurostileregular
/xheight 0
/ascent 1775
/fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867]
/italicangle 0
/fontfile3 44 0 r
>>
endobj
46 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1
/basefont/xztfzh+eurostileregular
/widths[250]
/lastchar 32
/name/f3
/firstchar 32
/fontdescriptor 45 0 r
/encoding 43 0 r
/type/font
>>
endobj
47 0 obj
<<
/differences[32/space 38/ampersand 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 63/question 65/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w 89/y 91/bracketleft 93/bracketright 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 142/eacute 209/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright 213/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
/type/encoding
>>
endobj
48 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 9908
/length1 9908
>>
stream




jaifyo+usherwood-book

?��
���&���x��
��
��
!

��&�

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bookitc usherwood


m1fpqm
vutjeobsizgrdn[
ychw*	4+
(xl".&iw5$%#)�3k80'-,/ 267�:<>o
�


u
�.1����0�l�p�	p	�
+
�y9��

9
�:����=�����t�/����+����q��*�n�d� �!!�""�"�#o#�$$7�?��������w����	������i���������]5�
:n�k������������$�t�����k���#��;�0��wp��pֈpp�w}|��{�|�|�|��{����9�59r�m��*y���v���"��������d�nta?3 r��������ó���Ɋ��ܕ���������\���)1�8�?�b���洝����r�������'d��c]�ce:��q�y��<�
�������y����4�d�
�'�;���)�'��.��������0�
�s/)8d��!-�}v���s��"����������(�s���v�)��i�6�y1'�~��p�����kl{��Ŏ�r�����1�b��p��"���"�g��+_q]t��������{�tnu~x�{������-������w�����t�s`{���������$�_�����d�ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����1��y��&��w�������iy�������u�����#Ћ���{�w}u{x�{����.�v@(3s���"��b��-{�ms{�]�{����o�f-�>���ؠ��i�j�l��y�� ��w������tsuylq���������������Ѕtx�`z�����q�v~bm{{����
���������ty��v�lv���w��fw���^����������v��ӻ��\�j���e�g�a��������nv�����������{����������{��|v�r#rr@f�i�|�z�z̀�arzhl�&rϬ�s�s�^�g�_����*��w����e����j�}_{���������$�`������i�ċ�{�tnu~x�{���� ��������w�uuxytt�x�-y��7��!��w�������)�{�w3*7p���.�����`?��uy�w��(�d�)�a���̯���@���j��������[��������ɋ�{�tnu~x�{����:?���*�����������j�}`{���������$�_������~������:k�n,���n���������$�d�����t�{��*w=xh���{�tnu~x�{����1�*y���v�a�m����|���q���~�{p�~���8������k��mv��{�{���������x��d}c{f����������sodo{p�q�k�s�\y[a�d�j�p�拵����]�n���������`�w������a�at2�ob��ɸ��������*�~Džw�����@�~c�{���������$�p�����<���®�vp������������}}�}j�^qsy�Ə���{�tnu~]�{�����-���:��!��w��������j�}`{���������$�_������~������:k�n,���n���������$�d�����t�{��9@gup�d�ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����1�����t��2�
��9�}��&�����µw�y�wyw�y${����fnjd�r$����Ƅ����������q�p�qno�n${���x�2�
��z����b+w`jv^�o|��ww��j�e�j������ю�)��㆛�2��w�y���ؿ����������$�@�������—�����؅|o�fqÂ���̌���ȝdo��������}�����u��d$vda6�n�u�zgv�q�w���"��z�-�}v���r��7��w��������������ő�n�����aǔ�����rh��{b�sb�4��	$�?��)��Ʈʵ��3��{ix�w�s������i�&�$u,$-_���oy��7�t��������4�jugq9$�p�������sj���~�����y؄��������~��~{�u�-'�,�5�6���ݰ������*��������������i�~_{���������$�`������|�������z,�o:���u���������$�o�y���|�������r7�r1���r���������$�p�x���~�a�.7=>ur��g�3:ecpl�����{�tnu~x�{����1�o�v��f���f��w��2�������j��ȅ������������x�edh��*]��!�4�����rs�b�e��(p���������f{��b�f~e��������lt�s��p}�w�ov�,������Ŵ��r�hsszq`r�y�������[ctsx����l���-��j��l蟆���������$�}�v���������w�l�r�{y~�o�{���������$�[�`�h�u����袠����s�{ln��${����yizygdlj�v�h�}��������{�u�qoc�y${���b�o�3���"c^��]z-y��7��!��w������ґ�������n��$���-�1/�#�izh\y��q�����{�tnu~x�{��������n�m~y���#����e��(9>(=e���*����u�����s�����k�_���n�t������m�e�������}���������]�t���ɡǚ���gx��o��{���~w{xu~y��y�@�yw�y--n�.�b�{�t_��el���)�ӈĊ�u�p�a7fa�� 4>�ǭ����{�mv��l~�}�{|l�n������f�"�@�h��ۻ����_22[r=ng���*����
��:�l��r����������$��q��r�y�y�yvw�v${��~uz!��qn������������p�p�ooo�o${�����g�y�
���y�����w�uuwwuu�w�������
��Ȇ���������$�n�q���6ܥ����o�o�onl�m${����:�69r�m����v�w
�����z�;��n�g�����ea���v���$�b�y���v���w��w������y�������u��+�����x��+��gɸ����hj����������ʆ�����cy��=��?d �m����uiqo$��$p޻�s��v�@�a���}v���
���s��ޥ����o�o�onl�m${����8��*_m]v}���t��^�b�k����=���v�w
�.���%´�����v��e�m�]�!�g�n;+z[wy������������������f����������x�p�tur�x${����97maj"�&;��=�3���-���xb���y�}���|����xu�j$�u#�&�j�r���/��Ү��������w�ov�/���n������Ŵ��r�hsszqhr�y�������[ctsx0��������w�uuwwuu�w��
��b�����9�n���e����������$����	��
���#�����������$��������%�ь�|�{�|to�y${����dmr�1ox^��p�ow�c�#~�t�y{z�${��e�a=�hb��*�������������s�o�qnh�t${���{�@����l��.��w���;����j�}`{���������$�_������л��������2f��w�q�q�t���������$�y�|�l�v�d�v�g���ȳ����{�z�zww�w${����vod\oaj`���ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����8��v�f�
�����j���������wtw��3pw������ɛ
����������������$�f�r����������u��+�v�w�ukn�k�{���������$�\���\��9�[x�x�wrs�r${����oysoz^e�jg�dfq�j���������z-������w
����k����������$�v������Î���{j_f7{熋�.��*�uv�-�v�����
������dy�
��>��z�b-���/-���<�
껺����t�a��kf�cڽ����i�
#nq24n��-y�t���v��Ƭ���\����������������������������y�gsyo0vj��k\�kk�vo���y���������������
͋�"��'�>�o�t�x��x�}���y������y�fki>���������[5��=-=r[yyd�����-y�����9Öw�vЫ�����y�������{�$�,����2��7_p|u���ݜˑ�������*�Ƥ�uyps�(po��p�o�p�o��&`�$h7�~�������k$"mb�
�eͷ{u��d�y�v-�v��Ðw���j���zy�������ޱ�#������������ȉ�0��fz����~^vpw^��ӱ�����#��3�l}�7-y��ܰ��c����e����y�����+�m��ؾ����b���<5>1�g�o�ur6b��-�b�
�0�c�ۨ���p�i*l`i�6d��؞��������]f5gltx;�f���9����
����
���ކ���������$�i�e���������,���d��
������ؿ�(��������k�z�z�zjp�`�{���������$�p�����$t�������ä����u�v�vqr�r$�y���^��v�w�vrr�r${���/3����?�v����v˱�r������
��z�y�ˆ����������}������������v[rz[%5*����r����v�������������%t\}�u�3�r��<�ur���΋���}}rp�p���~��~s�~�~����{���d^�6k�xy��b�v�p�x��������gtqbje�n������u�u�������������q�gtqbje�n������u�u������������b�v�p�x�������p��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsx��qz��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsx-���ѱ�w�w�^��^w��w����������$�d�}��������ea��������w�|�}�j���~����������w�k�~x������������=��`�dy���w���w���"w����dl\j"�$��z�m����
��m�^�����|���w����~�y]��d�1���s�c���5��쭡�y�c����@�|��w�w���4�q��h�(�i�k֥��̋鋝����}�}�|vv�w${����anqs�|a���c/� ��(��q�����{�|�}�|��z�j��ut�w��w�y�}���xw�g�v�`lt e����
�%��⯨q��b�y�x���������$�������ů��(�c� skhi � �@֋����~v���ȱ�w�����%�3dž��������������������v��a���`qp��p��pq�p{z��{��{{�{g{��zl�4o�ty�����������@�"�d�h'$�)�$���-y�����w
��������z�n����0�6�����
�7��4rwhz�������h����:������l "jm8"]��-y��ܰ
�������y�.��9�0�u3���'@�+�n�m���'�+���>����
��,�(�@v�)0o��s-y�����6�y��w�"���[�u�m�s��5kz���́�����y�zuyxty��ݷ����^<ol6p�u�������u.�
)3�xi��d|s�w�sڋ�:����8�+Ծ�������v�p�x
����p��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsxr��n��Ա�t�w������|ˉ����c����������r]7if,de�����w)� �a*���r���������������������<���
���b�����֡����cuo��r���rt�~}|��|���|}�|j�{����7�39r�m���v�rw
���y��i�ru-���:�`��v������������������$��a�}��������������|�li{~s��������z�{zx�}$�#�0��%93�l����������0hr�\���m�uw�ton��o����������������
�	�����i�����f9r�m�{���������$�n�q���6ܥ����o�m�onn�m${����:�>���>ܥ����o�o�onl�m${����:�69r�m�{���������$�n�q���͠v�f�
�����k�������o��wt{v�f�pw���α�z��w����������x�ov{���������$�r�����s��ȁ�x��5�~�|�����������$������,͚�r�'�������%��tu��uΈuu�t{z��{֌{{�{�{��zm���1�m�������i:fx]��-�}v�3��w����e���>k}rl`~��}x��h�f�g�����"�‹�{�tnu~x�{����#��������w�uuxytt�x�����>��������d��������������$�ʯ�����t���+��p��0���������$�Υٶ�d��b�����y�y�yss�s${����xbjaut����d�9��p�y�y�yyz�z${����dnriq8�"�����]�����������l�l�lmm�l${���u��	�y��ҵ
���x��y�f��%�n�s� ��c�e��-�b�p�2��/�����=�������b�k�!��
���\�������~�����������Ɇ���������$�f�v���f����w�������������%t[}�u�!�~��<�ur���ϊ���||so�q���~��~�~�~���{���d^�6k�xy��*�����ћ�
����x��������}���}��������s�3wp2��sߥ����o�m�onn�m${����7��3s�o\������
�����Ɇ���������$�f�z���h�ӑ�������&�>��c�y�����������$�q�t�|�u�x�e�1�Ƿ�櫦�w�z�xrp�u${����sqbmj\�`�'�sϘ����p�o�pmm�m${���{f�6?��^����������v���v�u�v��5��ˌ���l��h�f�f��r�r�r�q���ߋ�2����&�Ɍ�y�y�yst�t${ր�w�(�������t�t�uvv�v${�z�������'�l�s���������$��y����k���s�������!h����������«������p�?wz��|ԇ|}�}{�����z��c�bx^������Ō¹fp_u_oi^vrg�g�x�����x�x�'�����y�ssyxst�x���l��}�}��ҵ���x���einbprf���g����sd�n��	�7������ɏ��������f��%�n�s� ��c�e��-�b�p�2��/�����=�������b�k�!��
���\�y��ߛ
�������������r�r�rqq�q${��gt��;c0�$�j�����Ι����o�m�nnk�q${Ã�ab��k��.�q��6��_d�����
��j������[�򒮭p�p�p|{�|${����vgy^e)�
��� �x���������l�l�lmn�m${��i�e���/��j�g���������$�բש��y��������y�����w�uuwwuu�w�`�2�����w�uuwwuu�w��*y���v���"��0w������-����'���	��������-��� ���d�nta?3 r��������ó���Ɋ��Ҁ����������\���)1�8�?�b���洝�����r�������'d��c]�ce:��qd����
��(���)��}����������$�\�����n���������ϋ�v�v�vyx�y${����lohm>2sk,�q�_ʋ�������l�l�khh�g${�|������=�po�q\����3��g�
�	��	�3�s���g���s���3��g�
�1��l�3���sn��g�ny����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
49 0 obj
<<
/stemv 59
/capheight 622
/stemh 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/flags 34
/descent -254
/fontname/jaifyo+usherwood-book
/xheight 694
/ascent 684
/fontbbox[-101 -307 964 856]
/italicangle 0
/fontfile3 48 0 r
>>
endobj
50 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1
/basefont/jaifyo+usherwood-book
/widths[278 0 0 0 0 0 722 0 296 296 0 0 278 278 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 0 0 0 407 0 630 593 611 704 574 537 630 704 296 296 648 500 815 685 741 574 741 630 519 556 667 611 944 0 611 0 333 0 333 0 0 0 500 556 463 556 500 315 500 556 259 241 519 241 889 574 537 556 556 370 426 315 537 500 759 537 519 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 963 444 444 0 278]
/lastchar 213
/name/f9
/firstchar 32
/fontdescriptor 49 0 r
/encoding 47 0 r
/type/font
>>
endobj
51 0 obj
<<
/differences[32/space 44/comma/hyphen 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon 63/question 65/a 67/c/d/e 72/h/i/j 76/l/m/n 80/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 213/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
/type/encoding
>>
endobj
52 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 8257
/length1 8257
>>
stream




qgylbb+usherwood-bookitalic

@��
����o���`��
��
��
.
*
�� $

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporationitc usherwood book italicitc usherwood


;/bsujwf
o5dih
-e3t&pnmvxz2"gq)clry*4[.+61$78% k=
�
!
�
�}�hk�w�g	4�<�c	'	r
m
�d�
u
�k�p��e�e�s�a������$|�y�@��;�o�~��w����
����@�u�f���������<���h��d��m������a�ƛŚ�x�v�xvv�u$�{�����v|�}�}5��;�;>�:<�=x�x�xuv�v$�{�����\m�m�me��u�byh���������$�+y�a��gv�����l�\�w�}{xxs������b��}�����}��{��|z�|�a��b�%3�p����ū���}�{�{`�x�������
����_����~�toi���zt�����v�.�o����9�ؿ���=������۰ҳ���o��y�������������|�yxpb=g�����������h{koyv�`f����������xmdu;y>��y��(��w������xsrxkox�����������Ҍ������І�y�x[������meaokln�x�i�…s�l�xw�y�������y������Ŕ�p������z��|���o��������ؤ�žЋ��k��}z��}9o�~���������ur�g�m�i��_�n�ew�x������$����������wswroz�{��o�v�8�a��$��o���u���?�s����m�~���fr�z��������k}1��<pm���������Ň�i{sx}zs^�~����������i�[�u�by��:�
�������nwm:?bi�՗����Ę�����v�9�4��-�c �l����3����uj(�\pv�Ó��8���y��v�8�t����=Ő�z����������������u`m�a�h�k��l�x�qw�x����������z��|���o��������z��%�������b�w9<-ud�����������h{koyvj`f����������sios"u7-���խ�w� ��4���������������$��u�h����������z��ex�����������}�s�}�������������}؁]bty���������zy?x�r��ty��:�
��������is[=hmg���<��Ү�vdu�v�w���ģ����[�s���0�h��u���ҽ�y��v�=����w��Ŏ�z���k����ы��rvz�y�z�b�b�p�y�tw�x����������z��|���o��������z��*�������d�u=c1fg����m������eo_qr��{���f��|��l�&p�l�i��=����n��*�~w�����6��)����y������������|�|x�w�d��e�0,�u��ߨ���o�!t�p�3�em�������|�u\xujp��[��-�������=���q������qm�dz[d�v8e�x�f������
���)�����z�qqtvnz�������zeitr{������՛���p��������}—�~���Û���ueacm�1f{���������6�Τ�����f�g�flg�l$�{�����_}�~���(�6x<s�y��*y�a��2��`w�����|�z����}y{�f���ӟݚ���0�Қϡ�{cnl}l��{����dpxh�t�vh�n�
�7��t���v����}�}�}g�l����������-��%���tbr8���gq��w���ĭ���x����脆���������$��d�z����������i��je��;ă9����������$��f�l�}�q���8$��Ր����?��oo��p؉op�ouu��u�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s�������������dc@zn�7?�ty��b��˖��$������������p�y�@� �rj�d�� �a�� �tb\a��lb�Ğ����w�yj~wrmh��d��������d��º��Ǩkh|����-����i��|vͭ��������(��<����������Š����������u_v_q)\���_�r����������z��~j�������şȜ�un�z[$ ����+�z_����Ǒ�{~x��w�sno��q9�q�s�u����{�����a}�~�~.�8z?w�s��*y��b�
������ly����0�=�(���1�# �0���d���.�ъ�p7�3*�61m���&y��v�8�t����l��.ŏ�]����������������xsvs*wbi����-���������¸��uxn�j�m�n�
�d�p�kw�x����������z��|���o��������]�򔫔����q�id�tqs@�������f�xmg=cp�����������f{koyvm`f����������zbcr�v7�y��֛�w
���q���z��|���o����������������eoyqr��{���f�����8�$�g�umw�x�������x�a���a��Ȍ��9���j�����|x~{�l�����������Nj����y�m���s}{���{zz�`�od�i���\y���������薬�������k{|��~h\�~��������xxj�i�k�n��o�k�vd�d����Ǭ���{�p�pd�c����������;�a�����|��m����������$��o�p���ؘ�����İ������������{ciuy��h��&������z�z�z{y�{$1��$�'�-��{�o�������֋҃���`t�m�i���mqh��h|u��z�����+�'�����y��޵�d�g��w������z[y�lts��t�t�t�t�f3\�
s4�p�������m@+@*�ii��^|o�n�tۋ�:��
�
�c��
dc~}fԷ�Ԣ�䆱����
����Ӡv�8�a�~w���$��\��p���o������������r�p�b�%�s�m�ǰ��w�v��~�r�~����=p��{��������sv.��)qd����������|�u���{�sz��${���{p7"�=-���������Ň�i{sx}zs^�~����������i�\�t�=������a��wfv����v�����������w�u�|���hu��z���������h:�*�b^x�������w��gzy|�}ku�}������ț��ee�h{ig7i3s�z�����v������ɼ�����d��t��ڱ���d��Èo�b��������������u�ji]_g(���%���a�d�=�o�b�i�<�@�a�&�d�x�#���!�l��� ��s�g��p�3�h��l�,�
8��(�y���������y�����x�ynvsnu�|�p��,�����x�ynvsnu�|�w������ʛ~��������n�f����̨���������p�o�oqd�f��{���������$��z������z�!�������������k�k�jnn�m$�{�����pvrl{t�v��@"hc�uy�~����������$��������g��������w�x�x��a���l�@�������{�Ԃvw�sxԛ�����}t}�}�}��̠��������ou��n}c�tefz}8�nd�rp�2�'a�d;nn�p{�������|�ad������w�o��"��0�d���}v���j��:�������f��Ɲ��̖�������k����������:�s�m΋���'�o�k�m9\dky�����������h{koyv`f����������tmbz<d�e�u��~uu�|��=���������x1!o�c�\_������ŭ���
��f�����������$��u�h����������j��\�jx>x�r��{���������$��{�_����������6����ӓ��h�i�hii�i$�{�����d��x�}e�>����>�Х�����f�g�flk�l$�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s��*y��:����w
� ��l��������x]go�n��{���{p��{�����l�yҋ�v��c��p�f4n*tw��s�������.��k@�b�p�dd���=y��v�b����w��|���������ydjbe�bbr�u�n�n����q����������r<���r�q�g�����������xx|{u�v|���m�q�p�v��������n�q<�nff]����e������eo_qr��{���f��{���=�}v���e��:�����<��ɝ��ɖ���x����ӓ���;�қ���{��fhvu�d��<��q��n�ַЦ���a�o�w)g�\w=����@����\wi���bu����v��{��w��n�� y��������@������̪���Ȏ�c�h�c��/^u����������z�yzy^oz��ӿ���%�8#�h��e�r�y��{v�a�t������b���sws}o�_|��!n�������}z���u���z�u�hd�%xi�t��ysrzzx�x`�~������Ĉ=���l^<xo}��~~��a�{�{��˺����"��p������������
��������������$��u�h����������6������f�g�flk�l$�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s��y�����w
������h��h���p���
�c������
4�.cdywj�����������r������w6�e..cx��
�y��[w�'��
��v̀���q�h������g�t� ���)r����i�����87ig�'x�ϡ����w�wfxnrlz��6�;�+����r��n���λ����it~�~��ty�s��(�i�y�|�^d�z����������������Ʉ��l|�kyncj�kj��\���%���	�t��d�ed�ens��wt�w{�|rh�\sd`c���æ�����x�ot�d0h��v�j�>
����j�����z�qqtvnz�������zeitr{�9��~��������2�q�k��������	�*�p��9��k��:�����i�k�����=�iw0c�h��{���������$��f�x����������1�ߞ����s�t�svv�v$��h��g��7o�bp�ap�cw�v�vsr�r$�{�����aw�o�t?��u>s?s>���������$������ϛ
�������Ϧ�����f�g�flj�l$�{�����_}�~�~���{@r�6�^v�������u�`�qyc�x�lы���	���p��v��w����t��w�.�*�y����������j������y���x�phfi:�vu��t*�us�q������]�1�;�
��7�r�.qu��yr�x|�{�����f������yww~lgm��������Ϲ]c��������y����b��w���$�䆬o��t��k��!��@�op������
ʦԎ��fj�f�8n����w~f}gif���̧���=-fh<p�r�����ڳ]l�!��8\��w�������w
����������ç��$��i�r����������3������wdl`l&��{Ԫ�cy�}�{e��q�	r�x���v�����
������y�����i���c���%'���h񸴛����7�
c>�"g��$����п[$�>=:6a���y���
�����~�生є��k�h�kon�o$�{�����cx�a�lq��s(k1�)�@i�ݡ���������͘��c�b�dmn�m$�{�����_x�r�ur���n�l�m!�w���$��h�?��������x���������������
�`:��
o�2�]�����������$��t�h����������k�	�$���,�k��to��k؉jf�_{{��{�{�����_u�b�m>�z?l�]�-y��ڱ
���6����<_os#�
"j���q��t�.��	�jh�������|����yjq�a$�g�1�n���)�#�&��î�y����ˡ��z�x���y�����<�\���ȕ����j� �
=684�t�j�]�\��/�e���8�����i�i:?ki7:t����������;]i3-b\�g�i����v���
���������������q{z��r q�dzu�y���
������vy�a����j�o�%�h&���r!�(�
$�i�����&̪;j�;<���;t��r�v���
�1�����|������`/����k*�j��������Ә�ŗ��d�d�dlk�l$�{�|����������
�����������$���������{v�r�z|z��$�������
�����������_c��7�!�{�n��w�w�wvw�v$�{���l�y5�kjj��o�@��x�x�xvv�u$�{����$��m�%� �)���������$���#�������,��+��-���������$���������w�ˋ싞��q�{�r�yz}�|$���q��ݭx����h�������������������������37��=jm��lx�ml�jtv��u�{�����a}�~�~.�8z?w�s�������������=��q�{��bo���������y���w���w���1���]�%}�|����l��@�d�bnw��|̆|��~������������{�{^|gs`��������lsbpohhhfh~sw�u�t�l�c�+�����x�ynvsnu�|����������+�p���h���žϹ�k��}z��}9o�~���������ur�h�mb��h`�c�pv�������y�~r}mpjr��q������(����������wswroz�{�y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
53 0 obj
<<
/stemv 58
/capheight 622
/stemh 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/flags 98
/descent -254
/fontname/qgylbb+usherwood-bookitalic
/xheight 694
/ascent 684
/fontbbox[-187 -307 972 849]
/italicangle -12
/fontfile3 52 0 r
>>
endobj
54 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1
/basefont/qgylbb+usherwood-bookitalic
/widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 315 0 0 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 259 0 0 0 0 407 0 630 0 556 667 556 0 0 667 296 296 0 519 815 630 0 574 685 630 519 556 648 593 907 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 499 500 426 500 444 315 481 519 278 259 481 259 796 537 500 519 481 389 426 315 519 463 722 519 481 426 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259]
/lastchar 213
/name/f10
/firstchar 32
/fontdescriptor 53 0 r
/encoding 51 0 r
/type/font
>>
endobj
55 0 obj
<<
/differences[32/space 72/h 80/p 97/a 108/l 114/r 116/t/u]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
/type/encoding
>>
endobj
56 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 1186
/length1 1186
>>
stream




hqgkah+usherwood-bold

@��
����/������
��
��
"

3��

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bolditc usherwood


1bvm
)su	
�

�
�
�t�8��-��������f��w���t�
洆���������$�?�������
�.��e�0��&vq��p։qp�t|{��{�{�z�z��k„�h:��:�ht���b���������s++hw0i�y�e����^����>����������d����e�x�&vx��yl�xz�z�����\k��x{buz�z�����ħp^tg�8vey,w�:�z��ģ�t��q�������[�*orucal�����ʣry��׫�w
���y��ny�������k������̒�melgoe�k���u5dbfk>kx����͒�melgoe�k���t3�(�m�
��Ԧ��e�c�u�����̫�w
���b�q�˒�meogre�k���t3��@�av�k���������$�v�������������{�
����������������$�t�����,���,:�ht�k���������$�t������ܐ�’�c�c�ffc�c$k„�h:����ܐ�’�c�c�ffc�c$k„�h:��:�ht��������,��w��������������$�@�����ȼ��ᶛd�����������Ȏ����=`<z|��m�klioo�k���t3�	@�av���y�����w������
ttlsk]s�����Ś�����Јv{�p7�czewc4rk���9�q��Ү�y����f��`��������
�����
endstream
endobj
57 0 obj
<<
/stemv 108
/capheight 622
/stemh 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/flags 262178
/descent -254
/fontname/hqgkah+usherwood-bold
/xheight 694
/ascent 684
/fontbbox[-155 -300 1092 866]
/italicangle 0
/fontfile3 56 0 r
>>
endobj
58 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1
/basefont/hqgkah+usherwood-bold
/widths[296 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 704 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 296 0 0 0 0 0 389 0 352 593]
/lastchar 117
/name/f11
/firstchar 32
/fontdescriptor 57 0 r
/encoding 55 0 r
/type/font
>>
endobj
59 0 obj
<<
/kids[60 0 r 61 0 r 62 0 r 63 0 r 64 0 r 65 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 66 0 r
>>
endobj
60 0 obj
<<
/contents 4 0 r
/parent 59 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 34 0 r/f1 38 0 r/f2 42 0 r/f3 46 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
61 0 obj
<<
/contents 5 0 r
/parent 59 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
62 0 obj
<<
/contents 6 0 r
/parent 59 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
63 0 obj
<<
/contents 7 0 r
/parent 59 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
64 0 obj
<<
/contents 8 0 r
/parent 59 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
65 0 obj
<<
/contents 9 0 r
/parent 59 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
67 0 obj
<<
/kids[68 0 r 69 0 r 70 0 r 71 0 r 72 0 r 73 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 66 0 r
>>
endobj
68 0 obj
<<
/contents 10 0 r
/parent 67 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
69 0 obj
<<
/contents 11 0 r
/parent 67 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
70 0 obj
<<
/contents 12 0 r
/parent 67 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
71 0 obj
<<
/contents 13 0 r
/parent 67 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
72 0 obj
<<
/contents 14 0 r
/parent 67 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
73 0 obj
<<
/contents 15 0 r
/parent 67 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
74 0 obj
<<
/kids[75 0 r 76 0 r 77 0 r 78 0 r 79 0 r 80 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 66 0 r
>>
endobj
75 0 obj
<<
/contents 16 0 r
/parent 74 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
76 0 obj
<<
/contents 17 0 r
/parent 74 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
77 0 obj
<<
/contents 18 0 r
/parent 74 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
78 0 obj
<<
/contents 19 0 r
/parent 74 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
79 0 obj
<<
/contents 20 0 r
/parent 74 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
80 0 obj
<<
/contents 21 0 r
/parent 74 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
81 0 obj
<<
/kids[82 0 r 83 0 r 84 0 r 85 0 r 86 0 r 87 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 66 0 r
>>
endobj
82 0 obj
<<
/contents 22 0 r
/parent 81 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
83 0 obj
<<
/contents 23 0 r
/parent 81 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
84 0 obj
<<
/contents 24 0 r
/parent 81 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r/f11 58 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
85 0 obj
<<
/contents 25 0 r
/parent 81 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
86 0 obj
<<
/contents 26 0 r
/parent 81 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
87 0 obj
<<
/contents 27 0 r
/parent 81 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
88 0 obj
<<
/kids[89 0 r 90 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 2
/parent 66 0 r
>>
endobj
89 0 obj
<<
/contents 28 0 r
/parent 88 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
90 0 obj
<<
/contents 29 0 r
/parent 88 0 r
/resources<</procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f9 50 0 r/f0 34 0 r/f10 54 0 r>>/extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>>>
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
>>
endobj
66 0 obj
<<
/type/pages
/kids[59 0 r 67 0 r 74 0 r 81 0 r 88 0 r]
/count 26
>>
endobj
91 0 obj
<<
/pagelabels 30 0 r
/type/catalog
/pages 66 0 r
>>
endobj
92 0 obj
<<
/producer(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5)
/creationdate(20070407163137)
/creator(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5)
/xpressprivate(%%documentprocesscolors: black\n%%endcomments)
>>
endobj
xref
0 93
0000000000 65535 f 
0000000015 00000 n 
0000000059 00000 n 
0000000105 00000 n 
0000000152 00000 n 
0000004876 00000 n 
0000012359 00000 n 
0000019258 00000 n 
0000025654 00000 n 
0000032364 00000 n 
0000040191 00000 n 
0000046938 00000 n 
0000054060 00000 n 
0000060821 00000 n 
0000066783 00000 n 
0000073841 00000 n 
0000080074 00000 n 
0000086992 00000 n 
0000093910 00000 n 
0000100322 00000 n 
0000107125 00000 n 
0000113961 00000 n 
0000120400 00000 n 
0000126758 00000 n 
0000133334 00000 n 
0000141961 00000 n 
0000155042 00000 n 
0000167296 00000 n 
0000179838 00000 n 
0000193290 00000 n 
0000198482 00000 n 
0000198528 00000 n 
0000198828 00000 n 
0000204700 00000 n 
0000204922 00000 n 
0000205380 00000 n 
0000205510 00000 n 
0000207536 00000 n 
0000207770 00000 n 
0000208120 00000 n 
0000208406 00000 n 
0000214463 00000 n 
0000214693 00000 n 
0000215319 00000 n 
0000215410 00000 n 
0000215638 00000 n 
0000215860 00000 n 
0000216031 00000 n 
0000216470 00000 n 
0000226461 00000 n 
0000226681 00000 n 
0000227367 00000 n 
0000227666 00000 n 
0000236006 00000 n 
0000236234 00000 n 
0000236891 00000 n 
0000237017 00000 n 
0000238286 00000 n 
0000238512 00000 n 
0000238867 00000 n 
0000238974 00000 n 
0000239188 00000 n 
0000239393 00000 n 
0000239587 00000 n 
0000239781 00000 n 
0000239975 00000 n 
0000244579 00000 n 
0000240180 00000 n 
0000240287 00000 n 
0000240482 00000 n 
0000240677 00000 n 
0000240872 00000 n 
0000241067 00000 n 
0000241273 00000 n 
0000241468 00000 n 
0000241575 00000 n 
0000241770 00000 n 
0000241965 00000 n 
0000242160 00000 n 
0000242355 00000 n 
0000242561 00000 n 
0000242756 00000 n 
0000242863 00000 n 
0000243058 00000 n 
0000243253 00000 n 
0000243470 00000 n 
0000243676 00000 n 
0000243882 00000 n 
0000244088 00000 n 
0000244167 00000 n 
0000244373 00000 n 
0000244665 00000 n 
0000244734 00000 n 
trailer
<<
/size 93
/root 91 0 r
/info 92 0 r
/id[<a6679bd57406cf59a6481c07f7572389><a6679bd57406cf59a6481c07f7572389>]
>>
startxref
244909
%%eof