%pdf-1.3 % 1 0 obj << /opm 1 /type/extgstate >> endobj 2 0 obj << /op true /type/extgstate >> endobj 3 0 obj << /op false /type/extgstate >> endobj 4 0 obj << /length 8083 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 36 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 13.5 0 0 13.5 37 585.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the moral epistemology of first nations stories)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 9 0 0 9 37 564.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (jim cheney, university of wisconsin\321waukesha, united states)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f1 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 528.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(a)19(bstr)19(act)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 516.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(one w)19(ay t)18(o vie)19(w the import)18(ance o)19(f st)19(orytelling in fir)18(st nations cultur)19(es is)]tj 0 -1.26316 td [(t)19(o look at the epistemology that inf)37(orms st)18(orytelling and, mor)19(e gener)18(ally)111(,)]tj t* [(pr)18(actice in those cultur)19(es)36(. listen)1(ing t)18(o the fir)19(st nations v)18(oices o)19(f car)19(ol)]tj t* (geddes on )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 94.6649 480.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(r)19(espect)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 124.2155 480.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0003 tc (,)tj 0.51744 0 td 0 tc [(l)19(ouise pr)18(o)19(feit-l)19(eblanc on )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 233.941 480.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(r)19(esponsible truth)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 303.2474 480.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51767 0 td 0 tc (vine deloria)tj -27.02792 -1.26316 td (on )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 64.0682 468.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (principles of epistemological method)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 215.711 468.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51769 0 td 0 tc [(and deloria and l)19(ee hester on the)]tj -17.81359 -1.26316 td [(centr)19(ality o)18(f )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 103.098 456.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (belief)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 128.0772 456.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(in the w)74(est in contr)18(ast t)19(o the centr)19(ality o)18(f )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 299.7035 456.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(pr)19(actice)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 332.0652 456.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (,)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 444.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(e)19(xperience)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 96.4253 444.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51763 0 td 0 tc (and )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 118.7605 444.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(st)19(ory)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 141.6198 444.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(in indigenous w)19(orlds suggests that st)18(orytelling)]tj -9.49682 -1.26316 td [(should be centr)19(al t)18(o envir)19(onment)18(al education, ethics)37(, and pr)19(actice)36(.)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f1 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 408.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (r\216sum\216)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 396.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(une f)37(a\215on de consid\216r)18(er l\325import)19(ance de l\325art de r)19(aconter dans les cultur)18(es)]tj 0 -1.26316 td (des pr)tj 2.62817 0 td (emi\217r)tj 2.40527 0 td (es nations consiste \210 e)tj 9.53345 0 td (x)tj 0.51806 0 td (aminer l\325\216pist\216mologie qui inf)tj 12.6062 0 td (orme cet)tj -27.69116 -1.26317 td (art et, plus g\216n\216r)tj 7.21826 0 td (alement, la pr)tj 5.84789 0 td (atique dans ces cultur)tj 9.25684 0 td [(es)37(. l)166(\325\216coute des v)19(oix)]tj -22.323 -1.26317 td [(des pr)19(emi\217r)18(es nations)37(, comme celle de car)18(ol geddes sur )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 278.9152 360.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(le r)19(espect)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 318.838 360.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0003 tc (,)tj 0.51748 0 td 0 tc (de)tj -28.66885 -1.26316 td (l)tj 0.51806 0 td (ouise pr)tj 3.46192 0 td (o)tj 0.5 0 td (feit-l)tj 2.25708 0 td (eblanc sur )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 159.3697 348.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (la v\216rit\216 r)tj 4.14722 0 td (esponsable)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 245.3939 348.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51765 0 td 0 tc (de vine deloria sur )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 329.9754 348.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (les)tj -29.32373 -1.26316 td (principes de la m\216thode \216pist\216mologique)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 226.2663 336.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (et de deloria et l)tj 7.18018 0 td (ee hester sur la)tj -25.58716 -1.26316 td [(centr)19(alit\216 de )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f4 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 103.6198 324.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(la cr)19(o)19(y)18(ance)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f2 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 153.736 324.8022 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(dans l\325occident par contr)19(aste av)18(ec la centr)19(alit\216 de)]tj -10.77221 -1.26316 td (la pr)tj 1.94336 0 td (atique)tj 2.59253 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.51756 0 td 0 tc (de l\325e)tj 2.16409 0 td (xp\216rience et du r\216cit dans les mondes aut)tj 17.49317 0 td (ocht)tj 1.81445 0 td [(ones)37(, sugg\217r)18(e)]tj -26.52515 -1.26317 td (que l\325art de r)tj 5.44092 0 td [(aconter de)19(vr)18(ait se situer au centr)19(e de l\325\216ducation envir)18(on-)]tj -5.44092 -1.26316 td [(nement)19(ale)36(, de l\325\216thique et de la pr)19(atique)37(. )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 196.8801 243.2022 tm 0 0 0 1 k (i)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 220.4022 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (i)tj 0.6007 0 td 0 tc 0.027 tw [(teach envir)19(onment)18(al ethics and fir)19(st nations philosoph)19(y)111(. i came t)19(o think)]tj -0.6007 -1.2 td 0.002 tw (about and teach fir)tj 8.39336 0 td [(st nations philosoph)19(y in part because i w)18(as dissatisfied)]tj -8.39336 -1.2 td 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(with envir)19(onment)18(al ethics as it had unf)19(olded within the eur)19(o-american)]tj t* -0.024 tc 0.01 tw (analytic tr)tj 4.05738 0 td (adition. i came t)tj 6.67265 0 td -0.0245 tc (o)tj 0.77646 0 td (t)tj 0.2719 0 td -0.024 tc 0 tw (ak)tj 0.95142 0 td -0.0244 tc (e)tj 0.73962 0 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw (it as axiomatic \(in the logical or mathematical)tj -13.46943 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw (sense)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 7 0 0 7 61.2554 174.7122 tm 0 0 0 1 k (1)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 65.1467 172.4022 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (\))tj 0.56758 0 td 0 tc -0.006 tw [(that a cultur)19(e that has not been envir)18(onment)19(ally ruinous in its long)]tj -3.38225 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(member)19(ship in the earth community must \(whether e)18(xplicitly or implicitly\))]tj t* -0.011 tc 0 tw (ha)tj 1.0155 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.47039 0.00001 td -0.0109 tc (e)tj 0.7531 0 td (a)tj 0.7531 0 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(sophisticated and effectiv)19(e ethic concerning its pr)18(esence and pr)19(actice)]tj -2.99209 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw [(as member of the earth community)111(. and so, i ha)18(v)19(e drifted further and fur-)]tj 0 -1.19999 td -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(ther fr)19(om mainstr)18(eam envir)19(onment)19(al ethics and deeper and deeper int)19(o fir)18(st)]tj t* 0 tc 0.035 tw (nations philosoph)tj 7.8122 0 td (y)tj 0.408 0 td -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.5908 0 td 0 tc (sticking with m)tj 6.79138 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (y)tj 0.83183 0 td 0 tc (axiom has pr)tj 5.7359 0.00001 td [(o)19(v)19(en t)18(o be enormously)]tj -22.1701 -1.2 td 0 tw (fruitful.)tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.121 tw [(a)37(t the heart of m)19(y st)18(ory is )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 178.8281 88.4023 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(st)19(ory)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 200.6763 88.4023 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.67653 0 td 0 tc 0.121 tw [(in corr)19(espondence concerning the)]tj -17.0442 -1.2 td -0.014 tw (canadian netw)tj 6.5746 0 td (ork f)tj 1.98477 0.00001 td (or envir)tj 3.427 0.00001 td 0 tw (onment)tj 3.3686 0.00001 td -0.014 tw [(al education and communication 200)56(1)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 14.134 17.496 21.866 23.0401 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.1344 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (88)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 36 17.496 324.817 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (canadian journal of environmental education, 7(2), spring 2002)tj /f6 1 tf 1 0 0 1 -1000 1648 tm 1 g -0.25 tc ( )tj et q endstream endobj 5 0 obj << /length 7804 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 72 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.115 tw [(confer)19(ence)56(, bob jickling ask)18(ed ho)19(w i lik)18(e t)19(o teach envir)19(onment)19(al ethics)36(.)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.099 tw [(although i hadn\325t e)19(xpr)18(essed it this w)19(a)19(y until bob ask)18(ed, m)19(y answ)19(er w)18(as)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(immediate: i teach with st)19(ories)36(. my o)19(wn st)19(ories enter in her)18(e and ther)19(e)56(, but)]tj t* -0.014 tc 0 tw [(mostly i use the st)19(ories of other)18(s)37(, most of whom i r)19(egar)19(d as elder)18(s within m)19(y)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.027 tc 0.013 tw [(o)19(wn eur)19(o-american cultur)18(e)56(. a)37(t the moment i use aldo l)19(eopold\325)37(s \(197)36(0\) )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 366.708 539.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0254 tc (a)tj 0.85049 0 td -0.025 tc (sand)tj -30.22129 -1.2 td 0.003 tc 0.126 tw (county almanac)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 142.8704 527.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.0037 tc (,)tj 0.69846 0 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(gary sn)19(y)19(der\325)36(s (1990) )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 248.0536 527.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.003 tc 0.126 tw [(the pr)19(actice of the wild)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 353.1555 527.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.0036 tc (,)tj 0.69826 0 td 0.004 tc [(w)93(endell)]tj -28.71381 -1.20001 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(berry\325)37(s (1977) )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 135.0887 515.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.011 tc -0.002 tw (the unsettling of america)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 240.3876 515.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0119 tc (,)tj 0.53013 0 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(and fr)19(eeman house\325)36(s (1999) )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 370.21 515.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.011 tc [(t)88(otem)]tj -29.721 -1.19999 td 0 tc (salmon)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 104.0913 503.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.56806 0 td 0 tc 0.012 tw [(t)88(o intr)18(oduce the notion that a cultur)19(e is best under)19(st)18(ood as a peo-)]tj -3.67719 -1.20001 td -0.002 tw [(ple enacting a st)19(ory r)18(elating humans)37(, natur)19(e)56(, and the sacr)18(ed, as w)19(ell as the)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.012 tc [(basic contr)19(ast betw)18(een st)19(ories r)19(ooted in fear and st)18(ories r)19(ooted in trust, i use)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(daniel quinn\325)37(s (1992) no)18(v)19(el )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 192.3586 467.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.015 tc (ishmael)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 223.7064 467.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0159 tc (.)tj 0.526 0 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(thr)19(ough all of this i thr)18(ead lessons fr)19(om)]tj -15.59665 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(indian country\321lessons about the epistemology of st)19(ories)36(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.0001 tc (i)tj 0.71285 0 td 0 tc 0.139 tw [(ask m)19(y 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛 t)18(o try on these st)19(ories b)19(y l)18(eopold et al., t)19(o w)19(ear)]tj -2.51285 -1.2 td 0.008 tw [(them f)19(or a while)55(, see ho)19(w the)19(y fit, see what differ)19(ences the)18(y mak)19(e t)19(o their)]tj t* 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(per)19(ception and sense of being-in-the-w)18(orld. the fir)19(st st)19(ory i use is gary)]tj t* 0 tc -0.012 tw [(sn)19(y)19(der\325)36(s (1990) \322the w)93(oman who married a bear)111(,\323 in which sn)18(y)19(der tells a)]tj t* 0.001 tw [(v)19(er)18(sion of the st)19(ory based on a telling b)19(y maria johns t)19(o the anthr)18(opologist)]tj t* 0.015 tw [(catherine mcclellan. sn)19(y)19(der then r)18(etells the st)19(ory)111(, the same st)18(ory in man)19(y)]tj t* -0.014 tw [(w)19(a)19(y)19(s)37(, but with additions of his o)19(wn: f)18(olding in some bear f)19(acts dr)19(a)19(wn fr)18(om)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(contempor)19(ary biology and adding \322)56(and neither should men\323 t)18(o maria john\325)37(s)]tj t* -0.002 tc -0.012 tw [(comment that \322girls had t)19(o be car)18(eful about bear dr)19(o)1(p)1(p)1(i)1(n)1(g)1(s)38(,)1( )1(t)1(h)1(e)20(y)1( )1(s)1(h)1(o)1(u)1(l)1(d)1(n)11(t)]tj 0 tc (w)' 0.72235 0 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw (alk o)tj 1.97119 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.46356 0 td -0.018 tc (er them,\323 t)tj 4.51654 0 td -0.0178 tc (o)tj 0.7832 0 td -0.018 tc [(cite just tw)19(o e)18(x)19(amples (p. 155 & p. 163). he tells his o)19(wn)]tj -8.45684 -1.20001 td 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(v)19(er)19(sion of the st)18(ory as one who has led his o)19(wn particular life)55(, and he)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(ther)19(ef)18(or)19(e w)19(ear)18(s the st)19(ory in his o)19(wn particular w)18(a)19(y)111(. he does not tell the st)19(ory)]tj t* 0 tc -0.009 tw (as an artef)tj 4.51815 0 td (act t)tj 1.8427 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.8056 0 td 0 tc (be \322)tj 1.71256 0 td [(appr)19(eciated\323 and \322under)18(st)19(ood\323 fr)19(om the point of vie)18(w)]tj -8.87901 -1.20001 td 0.002 tc 0.136 tw [(of privileged eur)19(o-american discour)18(se)56(. the differ)19(ence betw)18(een sn)19(y)18(der\325)37(s)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(telling and maria john\325)37(s is the differ)18(ence betw)19(een tw)19(o distinct tr)19(ails thr)18(ough)]tj t* (the w)tj 2.35354 0 td (orld, not the differ)tj 7.77527 0 td [(ence betw)19(een the telling of the st)18(ory b)19(y a \322belie)19(v)19(er\323)]tj -10.12881 -1.20001 td 0 tc -0.014 tw [(and a social scientist\325)37(s r)18(eport of the \322belief)19(s\323 or \322w)19(orld vie)18(w)19(s\323 of an indige-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tw [(nous cultur)19(e)56(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw (most 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛 )tj 5.95161 0 td -0.0015 tc (,)tj 0.54056 0 td -0.001 tc (once the)tj 3.68014 0 td -0.0015 tc (y)tj 0.78151 0 td -0.001 tc [(under)19(s)1(t)19(and what is being ask)19(ed of them, find)]tj -12.75382 -1.20001 td -0.014 tc 0 tw [(it easy t)19(o liv)18(e within the ambience of this st)19(ory \(at least f)19(or a time)56(, until other)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(st)19(ories r)18(eclaim them\). the)19(y ar)19(e not being ask)18(ed t)19(o subscribe t)19(o the belief that)]tj t* 0.004 tc 0.135 tw (humans and bear)tj 7.90485 0 td (s)tj 0.84682 0 td [(can mate)56(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample; nor ar)19(e the)18(y being ask)19(ed t)19(o)]tj -8.75166 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(tr)19(anslate the st)18(ory int)19(o terms consistent with contempor)19(ary eur)18(o-american)]tj t* -0.015 tc 0.001 tw (belief. the)tj 4.36068 0 td -0.0146 tc (y)tj 0.76831 0 td -0.015 tc [(ar)19(e simply ask)18(ed t)19(o liv)19(e within the \322w)18(orld\323 of the st)19(ory)111(, t)18(o liv)19(e on)]tj -5.12899 -1.2 td 0.007 tc 0.132 tw [(its terms)37(. this e)18(x)19(er)19(cise mak)19(es it possible f)18(or 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛 t)19(o r)19(ead l)19(eopold,)]tj t* -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(sn)19(y)19(der)110(, berry)111(, and house as st)19(ories of liv)18(es liv)19(ed\321liv)19(es liv)18(ed within lar)19(ger liv)19(es)36(,)]tj t* 0 tc -0.006 tw [(st)19(ories within lar)18(ger st)19(ories\321r)19(ather than as ar)18(guments in competition with)]tj t* 0 tw [(one another)111(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(but some st)19(ories ar)18(e destructiv)19(e)55(, not conduciv)19(e t)19(o ecosy)18(stemic health. the)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.065 tw [(st)19(ory that w)92(estern cultur)19(e whisper)19(s in our ear)18(s\321so sa)19(y)19(s ishmael \(quinn,)]tj t* 0.001 tw [(1992\)\321is that the w)19(orld w)18(as made f)19(or man and man w)19(as destined t)18(o con-)]tj t* -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(quer and rule\321a tr)19(agic scenario that e)18(x)19(cludes other st)19(ories and r)18(educes a rich)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 226.6436 33.8348 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the moral epistemology of first nations stories)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 395.982 17.496 23.013 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3482 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (89)tj et q endstream endobj 6 0 obj << /length 6941 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 36 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.013 tw [(and v)19(aried ecosy)18(stem in the dir)19(ection of monocultur)19(e)56(. ho)18(w do w)19(e e)19(v)18(aluate)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.006 tw [(st)19(ories? ho)18(w do w)19(e tell good st)19(ories with (and about) our liv)18(es? ho)19(w do w)18(e)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(learn t)19(o tell comedic st)18(ories \(see p)56(art iii\) of the earth and its human and other-)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(than-human citiz)19(ens?)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(ho)19(w should w)18(e under)19(st)18(and st)19(ories? the)19(y seem, man)18(y of them, t)19(o be at)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(once descriptiv)19(e and e)18(v)19(aluativ)19(e)56(. the)19(y orient us)37(, it seems)36(, b)19(y telling us what)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(our w)19(orld is lik)18(e and ho)19(w w)18(e might be good citiz)19(ens within it. the)19(y ma)18(y seem)]tj 0 -1.19999 td 0 tc 0.024 tw [(t)19(o point t)19(o mor)18(al norms suggested b)19(y \(or deriv)18(able fr)19(om\) pr)19(esumably true)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.007 tc 0.132 tw [(\(though st)19(oried\) accounts of the w)18(orld. other st)19(ories\321some w)19(ould cite)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(\322the w)93(oman who married a bear\323 \(sn)18(y)19(der)111(, 1990\)\321seem t)18(o be mer)19(ely)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(pr)19(escriptiv)18(e: the)19(y ar)19(e simply st)18(oried f)19(orms of telling us what w)19(e ought t)19(o do.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.006 tc 0.133 tw [(some answ)19(er)18(s)1( )1(t)20(o these tw)18(o sets of questions ar)19(e suggested b)19(y ele-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(ments of fir)19(st nations epistemology)110(.)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 195.7602 410.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (ii)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 387.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(anthon)19(y w)92(est)19(on and i ha)19(v)18(e r)19(ecently ar)19(gued that the st)19(andar)18(d under)19(st)19(anding)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc -0.008 tw [(of the r)19(elationship betw)18(een ethics and epistemology is mist)19(ak)19(en. the st)18(an-)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(dar)19(d vie)18(w)111(, in part, is that ethical action is a r)19(esponse t)18(o our kno)19(wledge of the)]tj t* -0.027 tc 0.013 tw [(w)19(orld. kno)18(wledge comes fir)19(st; then, and only then, pr)19(actice)55(. ethical ar)19(guments)]tj 0.001 tc (pr)' 0.90943 0 td 0.138 tw [(esuppose or articulate some f)19(actual situation t)18(o which the question is)]tj -0.90943 -1.20001 td 0 tc -0.012 tw [(what our appr)19(opriate r)18(esponse is t)19(o be)56(. that natur)19(al ecosy)18(stems)37(, f)19(or e)18(x)19(am-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.014 tw [(ple)56(, ma)18(y sho)19(w integrity)111(, st)18(ability)111(, or beauty)111(, as a matter of f)19(act, is supposed)]tj (t)' 0.29614 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.81609 0 td 0 tc 0.001 tw [(be the basis upon which w)19(e can \322)55(consider\323 them ethically)111(. that animals)]tj -1.11223 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(feel pain, or ar)19(e self-conscious)36(, or ha)19(v)18(e e)19(xpect)19(ations that can be violated, is)]tj t* -0.014 tc 0 tw [(supposed t)19(o be the basis upon which the)19(y mig)-1(ht be attributed rights)37(. indeed,)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(t)19(o speak of a \322basis\323 in this w)19(a)19(y is only a w)18(a)19(y of underlining the necessity of)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(some f)19(actual appeal, some empirical st)18(arting-)1(point. often an object\325)36(s or sy)19(s-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.014 tw [(tem\325)37(s alleged possession of \322intrinsic v)18(alue\323 is itself supposed t)19(o be a kind)]tj t* 0.006 tc 0.133 tw [(of f)19(act t)18(o which ethical action r)19(esponds)37(. that e)18(v)19(en the \322possession\323 of)]tj t* 0 tc -0.003 tw [(v)19(alue itself is ther)19(eb)18(y tr)19(eated as a kind of )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 216.7412 219.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(f)19(act)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 234.848 219.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.003 tw [(illustr)19(ates just ho)18(w t)19(ak)19(en-f)18(or-)]tj -19.7848 -1.2 td 0.01 tc 0.128 tw [(gr)19(anted the f)18(act-based model of ethics curr)19(ently is \(chene)19(y & w)92(est)19(on,)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (1999\).)tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.006 tc 0.045 tw [(w)92(e ar)19(gued, on the contr)19(ary)110(, that ethical action is fir)19(st and f)19(or)18(emost an)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0.024 tw (attempt t)tj 3.93743 0 td -0.0057 tc (o)tj 0.82742 0 td -0.006 tc [(open up possibilities)37(, t)18(o enrich the w)19(orld. it is not an attempt t)18(o)]tj -4.76484 -1.2 td 0 tc (r)tj 0.34552 0 td -0.006 tc 0.015 tw [(espond t)19(o the w)18(orld as )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 141.0482 159.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.005 tc (alr)tj 1.11214 0 td (eady)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 174.0733 159.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.006 tc (kno)tj 1.59417 0 td 0.015 tw [(wn. on the usual vie)19(w)110(, f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, w)18(e)]tj -15.3015 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.133 tw [(must fir)19(st kno)18(w what animals ar)19(e capable of, then decide on that basis)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.012 tw (whether and ho)tj 6.6883 0.00001 td -0.0076 tc (w)tj 1.00965 0 td (w)tj 0.73289 0.00001 td -0.0074 tc (e)tj 0.75104 0 td -0.007 tc 0 tw (ar)tj 0.83648 0 td -0.0074 tc (e)tj 0.75101 0 td (t)tj 0.28889 0.00001 td (o)tj 0.78803 0 td -0.007 tc -0.012 tw [(consider them ethically)111(. on the alternativ)19(e vie)18(w)112(,)]tj -11.84629 -1.20002 td -0.01 tc -0.01 tw [(w)19(e will ha)19(v)18(e no idea of what other animals ar)19(e actually capable\321w)18(e)1( will)-1( not)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.011 tw [(r)18(eadily under)19(st)19(and them\321until w)18(e )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 187.6681 111.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.005 tc [(alr)19(eady)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 220.4293 111.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.006 tc -0.011 tw [(ha)19(v)18(e appr)19(oached them ethically:)]tj -18.3429 -1.2 td -0.01 tc -0.01 tw (that is)tj 2.5354 0 td -0.0096 tc (,)tj 0.5268 0 td -0.01 tc (until w)tj 2.8674 0 td -0.0095 tc (e)tj 0.749 0 td -0.009 tc 0 tw (ha)tj 1.0183 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.4718 0 td -0.0095 tc (e)tj 0.749 0 td -0.01 tc -0.009 tw [(offer)19(e)-1(d)-1( t)-1(h)-1(e)-1(m)-1( t)-1(h)-1(e)-1( s)-1(p)-1(a)-1(c)-1(e)-1( a)-1(n)-1(d)-1( t)-1(i)-1(m)-1(e)54(, )1(the )1(occasion, )1(and )1(the)]tj -8.9177 -1.2 td -0.001 tc 0.134 tw [(ackno)19(wledgment necessary t)18(o enter int)19(o r)19(elationship. ethics must come)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 75.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.005 tc [(fir)19(st)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 56.4996 75.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.006 tc [(\(chene)19(y & w)92(est)19(on, 1999\).)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 37 17.496 323 23.0401 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 38 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (jim cheney)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 14.134 17.496 21.866 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.1344 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (90)tj et q endstream endobj 7 0 obj << /length 7983 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 72 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 91 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.015 tc -0.003 tw [(e)-4(p)-4(istemologies ha)19(v)18(e ethical dimensions)37(, so ther)18(e is an ethical dimension)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0.002 tc 0.132 tw [(t)18(o kno)19(wledge itself. within a particular epistemology kno)19(wledge is con-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(s)4(t)4(r)4(u)4(c)4(t)4(ed in accor)19(dance with particular ethical v)18(alues)37(, principles)37(, vie)18(w)19(s)37(, or pr)19(ac)-1(-)]tj t* -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(tices; t)19(o articulate an epistemology is t)18(o articulate an ethical pr)19(actice)56(. as e)19(x)18(em-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(plified in the methodology of the contr)19(olled e)19(xperiment, much of the kno)18(wl-)]tj t* -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(edge gather)19(ed in the name of modern science is shaped b)19(y the v)18(alues of dom-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.096 tw [(ination and contr)19(ol \(chene)18(y)111(, 1998\). the kno)19(wledge of patterns in natur)19(e)]tj 0 -1.19999 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(arriv)19(ed at b)18(y patient observ)19(ations in the field (as in phenology) and r)19(ecipr)19(ocal)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.072 tw [(dialogue within the mor)19(e-than-human w)18(orld \(abr)19(am, 1996\), on the other)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.139 tw [(hand, giv)19(es v)18(oice t)19(o other v)19(alues)37(. the \322w)18(orlds\323 constructed b)19(y differing)]tj t* 0 tw [(epistemologies can be r)19(adically dissimilar \(hester & chene)18(y)111(, 2000\).)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.014 tw [(the ethical dimensions of epistemology itself ha)19(v)19(e r)18(ar)19(ely been attend-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0.087 tw [(ed t)19(o, or e)18(v)19(en noticed, b)19(y eur)18(o-american philosopher)19(s)37(. one e)19(x)19(ception is)]tj t* 0.065 tw [(nietzsche)56(, who, in \2441)161(1)-1(4 of )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 192.8013 431.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.061 tw (the gay science)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 261.0118 431.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.621 0 td 0 tc 0.065 tw [(said that \322)93(all e)18(xperiences ar)19(e)]tj -19.42218 -1.2 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(mor)19(al e)18(xperiences)37(, e)19(v)18(en in)1( the r)18(ealm of sense per)19(ception.\323 another impor-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.111 tw [(t)19(ant e)19(x)19(ception is t)87(om bir)19(ch\325)37(s (1993) notion of \322univ)18(er)19(sal consider)19(ation.\323)]tj t* 0.01 tw [(because the self-pr)19(oclaimed concern of ethics is t)18(o disco)19(v)19(er what things in)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(the w)19(orld demand pr)18(actical r)19(espect, w)19(e must )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 263.0433 383.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.017 tc 0.004 tw [(f)19(or that r)19(eason alone)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 345.8172 383.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0185 tc (,)tj 0.52341 0 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(bir)19(ch sa)18(y)19(s)38(,)]tj -27.80513 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [56(consider\323 them in the most fundament)19(al w)18(a)19(y: b)19(y pa)18(ying close)56(, car)19(eful, and)]tj t* 0 tc 0.015 tw [(per)19(sistent attention. thus all things must be consider)18(able in this basic and)]tj t* -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(una)19(v)19(oidable sense)55(. indeed, r)19(ather than an)19(y ne)19(w potential consider)18(andum ha)19(v-)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw (ing t)tj 1.86662 0 td -0.0067 tc (o)tj 0.79433 0 td -0.007 tc (meet a bur)tj 4.62304 0 td (den of pr)tj 3.87066 0 td (oof, univ)tj 3.72882 0 td [(er)19(sal consider)18(ation r)19(equir)19(es us t)18(o r)19(e)18(v)18(er)19(se)]tj -14.88347 -1.20001 td -0.027 tc 0.013 tw [(the usual bur)19(den of pr)18(oof as w)19(e appr)19(oach other)19(s in the w)18(orld. \322other)19(s ar)19(e no)18(w)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(t)19(ak)19(en as v)18(aluable)56(, e)19(v)19(en though w)19(e ma)18(y not y)19(et kno)19(w ho)18(w or wh)19(y)111(, until the)19(y)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (ar)tj 0.85107 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.79658 0 td (pr)tj 0.90707 0 td 0 tc (o)tj 0.51807 0 td 0.019 tw [(v)19(ed otherwise)56(.\323 a)55(ctually)111(, e)19(v)18(en mor)19(e deeply)111(, univ)19(er)18(sal consider)19(ation)]tj -3.07279 -1.20001 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(r)19(equir)18(es us not mer)19(ely t)19(o e)18(xtend this kind of benefit of the doubt but activ)19(e-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.031 tw [(ly t)19(o t)18(ak)19(e up the case)56(, so t)18(o speak, f)19(or beings so f)19(ar e)18(x)19(cluded or de)19(v)19(alued,)]tj (r)' 0.33961 0 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw (ocks included. once again ethics is primary: ethics opens the w)tj 26.71417 0 td [(a)18(y t)19(o kno)18(wl-)]tj -27.05378 -1.20001 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(edge)56(, epistemology is v)18(alue-driv)19(en, not vice v)18(er)19(sa \(bir)19(ch; chene)18(y & w)93(est)19(on,)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.053 tw [(1999\). t)88(o put nietzsche t)18(ogether with bir)19(ch, univ)19(er)18(sal consider)19(ation must)]tj t* -0.003 tc 0 tw (inf)tj 1.11947 0 td -0.011 tw (orm our v)tj 4.22631 0 td 0 tw (ery )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 142.8895 227.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.003 tc (per)tj 1.32395 0 td (ception)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 188.7435 227.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.003 tc -0.011 tw (of the w)tj 3.47164 0 td (orld, it must shape our w)tj 10.69964 0 td [(a)19(y)19(s of kno)19(wing)]tj -25.74563 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw [(the w)19(orld, our epistemologies)36(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.088 tw [(while eur)19(o-american philosopher)18(s ha)19(v)19(e f)18(or the most part paid scant)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw (attention t)tj 4.34164 0 td -0.0108 tc (o)tj 0.79017 0 td -0.011 tc [(the mor)19(al dimensions of epistemology)110(, fir)19(st nations peoples)37(, on)]tj -5.13181 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.069 tw [(the other hand, can r)19(eadily be under)18(st)19(ood as ha)19(ving paid )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 329.3286 179.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (close)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 353.3374 179.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (attention.)tj -28.03374 -1.2 td 0.035 tw (imagine a deep pr)tj 7.97635 0 td [(actice of univ)19(er)18(sal consider)19(ation f)19(or all things)36(, a consid-)]tj -7.97635 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(er)19(ation that is not instituted as a mor)18(al principle or rule go)19(v)19(erning beha)19(viour)111(,)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(but is)37(, r)18(ather)111(, a dimension of one\325)37(s v)18(ery )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 243.6845 143.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.006 tc [(per)19(ception)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 289.2631 143.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(of the w)19(orld. such a con-)]tj -21.62631 -1.2 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(ception is pr)19(esent in the notion of \322r)19(espect\323 f)18(or all beings that is perv)19(asiv)19(e in)]tj t* -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(f)1(i)1(r)20(st nations cultur)18(e)1(s)38(.)1( )1(t)89(o)1( )1(w)93(estern ear)19(s)37(, the term \322r)19(espect\323 ma)19(y ha)19(v)19(e o)18(v)20(ert)18(ones)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(of hier)19(ar)18(chically-structur)19(ed r)19(elationships)36(, or it might ha)19(v)19(e a k)37(antian fla)19(v)19(or of)]tj t* -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(obedience t)19(o mor)18(a)-1(l)-1( )-1(l)-1(a)18(w)111(. but t)18(o indigenous ear)19(s it signifies a mode of pr)19(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(n)-1(c)-1(e)]tj t* 0 tc -0.007 tw [(in the w)19(orld the centr)18(al featur)19(e of which is )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 258.4856 83.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(aw)18(ar)19(eness)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 301.9548 83.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.54909 0 td 0 tc -0.007 tw [(an a)19(w)19(ar)18(eness that is)]tj -23.4446 -1.2 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(simult)19(aneously a mode of kno)18(wing\321an epistemology\321and what might be)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 226.6436 33.8348 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the moral epistemology of first nations stories)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 395.982 17.496 23.013 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3482 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (91)tj et q endstream endobj 8 0 obj << /length 7730 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 36 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(called a \322pr)19(ot)18(ocol\323 or mode of \322)56(comportment,\323 as car)19(ol geddes (1996))]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.027 tw [(e)19(xplained in r)18(esponse t)19(o a question concerning the meaning of the tlingit)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.001 tc 0.137 tw [(notion of r)19(espect: \322it does not ha)18(v)19(e a v)18(ery pr)19(ecise definition in tr)18(ansla-)]tj t* 0 tc -0.008 tw [(tion\321the w)19(a)18(y it is used in english. it is mor)19(e lik)19(e a)19(w)19(ar)18(eness)37(. it is mor)19(e lik)18(e)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.021 tw [(kno)19(wledge and that is a v)18(ery import)19(ant distinction, because it is not lik)19(e a)]tj t* -0.006 tw [(mor)19(al la)18(w)111(, it is mor)19(e lik)19(e something that is just a part of y)18(our whole a)19(w)19(ar)19(e-)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tw [(ness)37(. it is not something that is abstr)18(act at all\323 (p. 46).)]tj 1.8 -1.19999 td -0.024 tc 0.007 tw [(giv)19(en the v)18(a)-1(l)-1(u)-1(e)-1(-)-1(l)-1(a)-1(d)-1(e)-1(n)-1( )-1(n)-1(a)-1(t)-1(u)-1(r)18(e of epistemologies and their multiplicity)111(, what)]tj -1.8 -1.20001 td -0.019 tc 0.002 tw [(shall w)19(e sa)18(y about the kno)19(wledge that emer)19(ges fr)18(om )1(their use? do these epis)-1(-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.007 tc -0.01 tw [(temologies deliv)19(er truths about the w)18(orld? l)19(ouise pr)19(ofeit-l)18(eblanc\325)37(s r)19(esponse)]tj t* -0.029 tc 0.012 tw [(t)18(o a question posed t)19(o her concerning whether the st)19(ories she used in her w)19(ork)]tj t* -0.003 tc 0.017 tw [(with at risk childr)19(en w)18(er)19(e \322true\323 is r)19(e)18(v)19(ealing. in her r)19(esponse)56(, she used the)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0 tw [(northern t)88(ut)18(chone term )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 140.5161 443.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.016 tc (tli an oh)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 175.9343 443.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.017 tc [(\(usually glossed as \322what the)19(y sa)18(y)111(, it\325)37(s true\323\))]tj -13.89343 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.004 tw [(and defined it as meaning \322)56(corr)18(ectly true)56<2cd320d272>19(esponsibly true\323 \(a \322r)18(esponsible)]tj t* -0.003 tc 0.057 tw [(truth\323\), \322true t)19(o what y)18(ou belie)19(v)19(e in,\323 \322what is good f)18(or y)19(ou and the com-)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.006 tw [(munity)111(,\323 and \322rings true f)18(or e)19(v)19(erybody\325)36(s w)19(ell-being\323 \(in conv)19(er)18(sation\). in the)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.013 tw [(notion of a \322r)19(esponsible truth\323 w)18(e ha)19(v)18(e a str)19(aight-f)19(orw)18(ar)19(d ackno)19(wledgment)]tj t* -0.001 tc 0.137 tw [(of the ethical dimension of kno)19(wledge itself, one that ties the notion of)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.014 tw [(truth t)19(o individual and community w)18(ell-being and what a per)19(son st)18(ands f)19(or)111(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.119 tw [(putting car)19(ol geddes\325 r)18(emarks t)19(ogether with those of l)19(ouise pr)18(ofeit-)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(l)19(eblanc)18(, w)19(e can perhaps sa)18(y that what w)19(e in the w)93(est might think of as the)]tj t* -0.009 tc 0 tw (\322sear)tj 2.17799 0 td -0.005 tw (ch f)tj 1.55326 0 td (or truth\323 is)tj 4.53328 0 td -0.0087 tc (,)tj 0.53323 0 td -0.009 tc (in fir)tj 2.20073 0 td [(st nations cultur)19(es)-1(,)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 7 0 0 7 227.5571 338.2716 tm 0 0 0 1 k (2)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 234.028 335.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.009 tc -0.005 tw (better under)tj 5.24347 0 td 0 tw (st)tj 0.70484 0 td -0.005 tw (ood as a sear)tj 5.53867 0 td 0 tw (ch)tj -31.18978 -1.20001 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(f)19(or man)19(y-la)18(y)20(er)18(ed r)19(esponsible truths arriv)19(ed at b)18(y means of an epistemology)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(of r)19(espect f)18(or all beings)37(.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.048 tw (in a series of r)tj 6.35466 0 td 0 tw (emark)tj 2.75879 0 td 0.048 tw (able articles r)tj 5.87203 0 td (ecently collected in )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 292.215 299.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.044 tw (spirit & r)tj 4.27322 0 td 0 tw (eason)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 287.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.005 tw [(\(deloria, f)56(oehner)111(, & scint)18(a, 1999\), vine deloria char)19(acteriz)19(es the natur)18(e of)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(r)19(esponsible truths and de)19(v)19(elops the epistemology of r)19(espect r)18(equir)19(ed t)19(o)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (arriv)tj 1.97974 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.7778 0 td 0 tc (at them. \322the r)tj 6.5928 0 td [(eal inter)19(est of the old indians)36(,\323 deloria sa)19(y)19(s:)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 55 242.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.014 tc [(w)19(as not t)19(o disco)18(v)19(er the abstr)19(act structur)19(e of ph)18(y)20(sical r)18(eality but r)19(ather t)19(o find the)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.015 tc (pr)tj 0.87831 0.00001 td -0.014 tc (oper r)tj 2.50599 0 td [(oad along which, f)19(or the dur)18(ation of a per)19(s)1(o)1(n)138(s life)55(, individuals w)19(er)18(e)1( sup)-1(-)]tj -3.38429 -1.2353 td -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(posed t)19(o w)18(alk. this colorful image of the r)19(oad suggests that the univ)18(er)19(se is a mor)19(al)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(univ)19(er)18(s)1(e)57(. that is t)19(o sa)18(y)112(, ther)18(e is a pr)19(oper w)19(a)19(y [or \322ther)18(e ar)19(e pr)19(oper w)19(a)19(y)19(s)11(])1( )1(t)20(o liv)18(e)]tj t* -0.012 tc -0.002 tw (in the univ)tj 4.47834 0 td [(er)19(se: ther)18(e is a content t)19(o e)19(v)18(ery action, beha)19(vior)110(, and belief. the sum)]tj -4.47834 -1.2353 td 0 tc 0.061 tw [(t)19(ot)18(al of our life e)19(xperiences has a r)19(eality)111(. ther)18(e is a dir)19(ection t)19(o the univ)18(er)19(se)56(,)]tj 0 -1.23529 td 0.008 tw [(empirically e)19(x)19(emplified in the ph)18(y)19(sical gr)19(o)19(wth c)19(y)19(cles of childhood, y)18(outh, and)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(old age)56(, with the corr)18(esponding r)19(esponsibility of e)19(v)19(ery entity t)18(o enjo)19(y life)56(, fulfill)]tj t* 0.001 tc 0 tw (itsel)tj 1.74638 0 td -0.002 tc 0.138 tw [(f, and incr)19(ease in wisdom and the spiritual de)19(v)18(elopment of per)19(sonality)111(.)]tj -1.74638 -1.2353 td -0.009 tc -0.008 tw [(nothing has incident)19(al meaning and ther)18(e ar)19(e no coincidences)37(. . . . in the mor)18(al)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.003 tc [(univ)19(er)18(se all activities)37(, e)19(v)18(ents)37(, and entities ar)19(e r)18(elated, and consequently it does)]tj t* -0.001 tc 0.137 tw [(not matter what kind of e)19(xistence an entity enjo)18(y)20(s)37(,)1( )1(f)20(or the r)18(esponsibility is)]tj t* -0.003 tc 0 tw [(alw)19(a)18(y)19(s ther)19(e f)18(or it t)19(o participate in the continuing cr)19(eation of r)18(eality)111(. (p. 46-47))]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 94.4616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.006 tc 0.018 tw [92(all kno)19(wledge)56(, if it is t)19(o be useful,\323 deloria sa)18(y)19(s)36(, \322w)19(as dir)18(ected t)19(o)19(w)18(ar)19(d that)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.035 tc 0.012 tw [([)-3(mor)18(a)-1(l)-1(])-1( )-1(g)-1(o)-1(a)-1(l)-1-1( )-1(\()-1(d)-1(e)-1(l)-1(o)-1(r)-1(i)-1(a)-1(,)-1( )-1(f)55(o)-1(e)-1(h)-1(n)-1(e)-1(r)110(, & scint)19(a, 1999, p. 43-44\). in the block quot)9(a)-9(t)-9(i)-9(o)-9(n)]tj t* 0 tc 0.011 tw [(abo)19(v)18(e)56(, deloria builds a pictur)19(e of the w)19(orld ar)18(ound this centr)19(al mor)19(al goal.)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 37 17.496 323 23.0401 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 38 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (jim cheney)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 14.134 17.496 21.866 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.1344 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (92)tj et 0.125 w 0 0 0 1 k 143.4399 446.8528 m 146.1065 447.7457 l s q endstream endobj 9 0 obj << /length 9394 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 72 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(most eur)19(o-americans w)18(ould call this pictur)19(e deloria\325)37(s \(or the dak)19(ot)18(a\) \322w)19(orld)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(vie)19(w)110(.\323 i w)19(a)-1(n)-1(t)-1( )-1(t)17(o)-1( )-1(o)-1(f)-1(f)-1(e)-1(r)-1( )-1(a)-1(n)-1( )-1(a)-1(l)-1(t)-1(e)-1(r)-1(n)-1(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(v)18(e t)19(o this idea, one that is mor)18(e consistent)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.139 tw [(with fir)19(st nations epistemology)110(. ther)19(e ar)19(e tw)18(o elements t)19(o this alterna-)]tj t* 0.022 tw [(tiv)19(e: (a) the notion of \322)55(cer)19(emonial w)19(orlds\323 \(m)18(y term\) and \(b\) the notion of)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tw [(\322principles of epistemological method\323 \(deloria\325)37(s term\).)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 10 0 2.12557 10 73 512.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (ceremonial worlds )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 493.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(the concept of a \322)56(cer)19(emonial w)18(orld\323 is built ar)19(ound tw)19(o further notions \(as)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.007 tw [(l)19(ee hester puts it in hester & chene)18(y)112(, 200)55(1\): \322[1] the import)19(ance of dir)19(ect)]tj t* 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(e)18(xperience and [2] agnosticism concerning belief\323 among fir)19(st nations)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(peoples)37(. \322within the life hist)18(ory of maturity)111(,\323 deloria sa)19(y)19(s)37(, e)19(xplicitly critiquing)]tj t* -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(w)93(estern science as articulated b)19(y thomas k)36(uhn \(197)37(0\), \322one can be said t)19(o)]tj t* 0 tc 0.042 tw [(tr)19(a)18(v)19(el fr)19(om inf)19(ormation t)18(o kno)19(wledge t)19(o wisdom. or)18(ganisms gather inf)19(or-)]tj t* -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(mation, and as the cumulativ)19(e amount begins t)18(o achie)19(v)19(e a critical mass)37(, pat-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.033 tw [(terns of interpr)19(et)18(ation and e)19(xplanation begin t)19(o appear)111(. . . . her)18(e it is that)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(w)92(estern science pr)19(ematur)19(ely deriv)19(es its scientific \324la)18(w)19(s\325 and assumes that the)]tj t* 0 tc 0.027 tw [(pr)19(oducts of its o)18(wn mind ar)19(e inher)19(ent in the structur)18(e of the univ)19(er)19(se)55(. but)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.009 tw [(american )-1(indians )-1(allo)19(w)1( t)1(h)1(e)1( p)1(r)19(o)1(c)1(e)1(s)1(s)1( t)20(o)1( c)1(o)1(n)1(t)1(i)1(n)1(u)1(e)57(,)1( r)19(ecognizing )-1(that )-1(pr)19(ematur)19(e)]tj t* -0.019 tc 0.005 tw [(analy)19(sis will pr)18(oduce anomalies and giv)19(e incomplete under)19(s)1(t)20(anding\323 \(deloria,)]tj t* 0 tc 0.001 tw [(f)56(oehner)111(, & scint)18(a, 1999, p. 14\). a)37(t the point wher)19(e \322patterns of interpr)19(et)18(a-)]tj t* 0.003 tc 0.135 tw [(tion and e)19(xplanation\323 begin t)18(o emer)19(g)-1(e)55(, the epistemological methods of)]tj t* 0 tc 0.074 tw [(w)93(estern science and fir)19(st nations epistemological methods part w)18(a)19(y)19(s)37(. in)]tj t* -0.011 tw [(w)93(estern science \(and philosoph)19(y\) )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 220.3176 313.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (belief)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 245.3782 313.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.011 tw [(enter)19(s the pictur)18(e and the theor)19(eti-)]tj -17.23782 -1.2 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(cal map is t)19(ak)18(en as a )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 164.5482 301.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.004 tc (true)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 183.7175 301.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(account of the territ)19(ory)110(. f)56(or fir)19(st nations peoples)36(,)]tj -11.07175 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw (the map is not under)tj 9.05518 0 td (st)tj 0.72192 0 td (ood as a true pictur)tj 8.3689 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.7778 0 td 0 tc (of the territ)tj 4.88797 0 td [(ory)111(.)]tj -22.01177 -1.20001 td [(as l)19(ee hester \(hester & chene)18(y)111(, in pr)19(ess\) puts it:)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91 256.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0125 tc (i)tj 0.54741 0 td (w)tj 0.728 0 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw (ould char)tj 3.90676 0.00001 td 0 tw (acteriz)tj 2.76514 0 td -0.0123 tc (e)tj 0.75171 0 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw (the attitude of nativ)tj 8.33091 0 td -0.0123 tc (e)tj 0.75167 0 td -0.012 tc (americans as one of agnosticism con)tj 15.67254 0 td 0 tc (-)tj -33.45414 -1.23531 td [(cerning the r)19(elationship betw)18(een their map and the territ)19(ory)111(. though this ma)18(y)]tj 0 -1.23529 td 0 tw (seem str)tj 3.68433 0 td (ange fr)tj 3.01782 0 td (om a w)tj 3.22143 0.00001 td [(estern st)19(ance)56(, it is actually v)18(ery pr)19(actical. . . .)]tj -7.80594 -1.2353 td -0.0136 tc (the)tj 1.83522 0 td -0.014 tc (import)tj 2.82579 0 td (ance of dir)tj 4.46108 0 td (ect e)tj 1.96909 0.00001 td (xperience and agnosticism concerning belief can)tj -13.20884 -1.2353 td -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(be seen in v)19(arious linguistic elements of the choct)18(a)19(w language and other nativ)19(e)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.02 tc 0.006 tw (american languages)tj 8.3576 0 td -0.0196 tc (.)tj 0.52235 0 td -0.02 tc (in choct)tj 3.45994 0 td [(a)18(w ther)19(e is a mark)19(er t)18(o indicate when y)19(ou ar)19(e pass)-1(-)]tj -12.33988 -1.2353 td 0 tc -0.008 tw (ing on second-hand e)tj 9.25484 0 td (xperiences . . . a hear)tj 9.2762 0 td 0 tw (sa)tj 0.90698 0 td -0.0002 tc (y)tj 0.78918 0 td 0 tc (mark)tj 2.25873 0 td (er)tj 0.75904 0 td -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.5482 0 td 0 tc -0.008 tw (such mark)tj 4.60354 0 td [(er)19(s ar)18(e com-)]tj -28.39671 -1.23531 td -0.027 tc 0.013 tw (mon among nativ)tj 7.41151 0 td -0.0274 tc (e)tj 0.7366 0 td -0.027 tc (american languages)tj 8.22392 0 td -0.0275 tc (.)tj 0.51449 0 td -0.027 tc (in choct)tj 3.40489 0 td 0 tc (a)tj 0.45385 0 td (w)tj 0.62059 0 td -0.0276 tc (,)tj 0.51435 0 td (f)tj 0.26885 0 td -0.027 tc (or e)tj 1.56981 0 td 0 tc (x)tj 0.49071 0 td -0.027 tc 0 tw (ample)tj 2.49311 0 td -0.0275 tc (,)tj 0.51451 0 td -0.027 tc 0.013 tw (the phr)tj 2.93344 0.00001 td (ase \322the)tj -30.15062 -1.23533 td 0 tc 0.02 tw (cat is on the mat\323 might be tr)tj 12.91633 0 td 0 tw (anslated, )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 236.3794 172.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (k)tj 0.59301 0 td (at)tj 0.79493 0 td 0.019 tw (osat shukbo binili)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 310.8017 172.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.57555 0 td 0 tc 0.02 tw (if w)tj 1.64856 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.79763 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (sa)tj 0.90707 0 td -0.0004 tc (y)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 351.137 172.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (k)tj 0.59301 0 td (at)tj 0.79493 0 td (osat)tj -31.9923 -1.2353 td -0.021 tc 0.008 tw (shukbo binili-miha)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 153.5868 161.8616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.023 tc (,)tj 0.519 0 td 0.009 tw [(then w)19(e ha)18(v)19(e disclaimed dir)19(ect observ)18(ation, w)19(e ar)19(e sa)18(ying that)]tj -7.88216 -1.2353 td 0 tc 0.001 tw [(someone t)19(old us)36(. without the hear)19(sa)19(y mark)18(er)111(, the assumption is that what w)19(e)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.007 tc 0 tw (ar)tj 0.83689 0.00001 td -0.0072 tc (e)tj 0.75675 0 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(sa)19(ying is a part of our e)18(xperience)56(. but the hear)19(sa)18(y mark)19(er \322miha\323 is just the)]tj -1.59365 -1.2353 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(beginning. ther)19(e ar)18(e a v)19(ariety of mark)19(er)18(s that describe our attitude t)19(o)18(w)19(ar)19(d the)]tj t* 0 tc -0.014 tw [(sour)19(ce of the e)18(xperience)56(, its r)19(eliability)111(, or whether that particular e)18(xperience is)]tj t* -0.003 tc 0 tw (shar)tj 1.8203 0 td -0.011 tw (ed. f)tj 2.06618 0.00001 td (or e)tj 1.64254 0.00001 td 0 tc (x)tj 0.51495 0.00001 td -0.003 tc 0 tw (ample )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 167.3143 109.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (k)tj 0.59012 0.00001 td -0.003 tc (at)tj 0.78912 0.00001 td -0.01 tw (osat shukbo binili-hah)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 258.6135 109.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.003 tc -0.011 tw (means something lik)tj 8.91857 0.00001 td -0.0033 tc (e)tj 0.76072 0 td -0.003 tc (\322don\325t w)tj 3.83357 0.00001 td 0 tc (e)tj -33.2321 -1.2353 td -0.028 tc 0.014 tw [(agr)19(ee that the cat is on the mat?\323 some of the mark)18(er)19(s can be giv)19(en r)18(ather humor-)]tj t* -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(ous tr)19(anslations)36(. )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 151.5835 88.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.009 tc -0.004 tw [(k)37(at)19(osat shukbo binili-cho)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 240.8688 88.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(has been tr)19(anslated b)18(y one linguist as)37(,)]tj -17.6316 -1.2353 td (\322the cat is on the mat, y)tj 10.38247 0.00001 td (ou idiot.\323 the )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 230.3275 77.8616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.009 tc (cho)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 244.6212 77.8616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.01 tc (mark)tj 2.22034 0.00001 td -0.004 tw (er implies that the cat is right in)tj -20.2934 -1.2353 td 0 tc 0 tw [(fr)19(ont of y)18(ou . . . that y)19(ou should open up y)19(our e)18(y)19(es)37(.)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 226.6436 33.8348 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the moral epistemology of first nations stories)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 395.982 17.496 23.013 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3524 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (93)tj et q endstream endobj 10 0 obj << /length 10517 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 36 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 73 588.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.018 tc 0.129 tw [(these mark)19(er)18(s gener)19(ally pick out a r)19(elationship betw)19(een the per)18(son)]tj -2.11765 -1.23529 td 0.02 tc 0.127 tw [(speaking and the st)19(atement, r)19(ather t)-1(han betw)19(een the st)19(atement and the)]tj t* 0.008 tc 0.136 tw [(w)19(orld. in english, a st)18(atement asserts a particular pictur)19(e of the w)19(orld, in)]tj t* 0.013 tw [(choct)19(a)18(w y)19(ou ar)18(e mor)19(e nearly r)19(elating an e)18(xp)1(erience)55(. it is difficult t)19(o assert a)]tj t* -0.005 tc -0.001 tw [(\322truth\323 in choct)19(a)18(w)111(. the closest y)19(ou can come t)19(o an english affirmation of truth)]tj t* 0.006 tc -0.011 tw [(in choct)19(a)19(w is t)18(o end y)19(our sentence with the w)19(or)18(d \322)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 244.7333 536.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.005 tc [(hok)19(e)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 261.2797 536.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.0057 tc tj 0.72196 0 td 0.006 tc -0.011 tw [(\(it is pr)19(onounced ho)]tj -24.99016 -1.23529 td 0.008 tc 0.139 tw [(k)19(a)18(y\). this w)19(or)18(d is so po)19(w)18(erful that it is often f)19(ollo)19(w)18(ed b)19(y an e)19(x)18(clamation)]tj t* 0.004 tc -0.009 tw [(p)1(o)1(i)1(n)1(t)1( )1(i)1(n)1( )1(w)1(r)1(i)1(t)1(i)1(n)1(g)1( )1(o)1(r)1( )1(i)1(s)1( )1(s)1(t)1(r)20(essed when speaking. though it is an affirmation, y)19(o)1(u)]tj t* -0.013 tc 0.007 tw [(w)19(ould ne)18(v)19(er sa)18(y )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 115.3228 504.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.012 tc 0.007 tw [(k)37(at)18(osat shukbo binili hok)19(e)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 205.5765 504.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0127 tc (!)tj 0.53748 0 td -0.013 tc 0.007 tw [(r)19(egar)18(dless of ho)19(w \322)56(cert)18(ain\323 y)19(ou w)19(er)18(e)]tj -18.25237 -1.23529 td 0.008 tc 0.003 tw [(that the cat w)19(as on the mat. \322)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 166.5244 494.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.008 tc [(hok)19(e)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 184.4095 494.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.0082 tc tj 0.74098 0 td 0.008 tc 0.003 tw [(is mainly used in cases lik)19(e )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 294.8821 494.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.008 tc 0.002 tw [(l)19(ashpa hok)19(e)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 339.3587 494.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k (!)tj -33.45396 -1.23529 td -0.008 tc 0.003 tw (since \322)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 80.3421 483.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.008 tc (lashpa)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 103.0697 483.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0083 tc tj 0.70804 0 td -0.008 tc 0.003 tw [(means hot, idiomatically the phr)19(ase might be tr)19(anslated, \322it sur)18(e)]tj -6.3633 -1.23529 td 0.003 tc -0.008 tw (is hot!\323 \322)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 87.5024 473.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.002 tc [(hok)19(e)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 105.2079 473.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.0026 tc tj 0.7189 0 td 0.003 tc -0.008 tw [(under)19(s)1(c)1(o)1(r)19(e)1(s)1( )1(y)20(our e)19(xperience of the w)18(orld, it doesn\325t assert the)]tj -6.62571 -1.23529 td -0.004 tc -0.002 tw [(\322truth\323 of some pictur)19(e of that w)18(orld. the closest the mark)19(er comes t)19(o such an)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0.011 tw [(assertion is pr)19(obably its use in the phr)18(ase )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 204.1069 452.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.016 tc 0.01 tw [(chat)19(ah sia hok)18(e)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 257.8317 452.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0167 tc (!)tj 0.5336 0 td -0.017 tc 0.011 tw [(this is gener)19(ally tr)18(ans-)]tj -24.39616 -1.23529 td -0.009 tc 0.004 tw [(lated, \322i am choct)19(a)19(w\323 though this w)18(ould be the meaning e)19(v)19(en without the affir-)]tj t* 0.008 tc 0 tw (mation )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 84.7644 431.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.008 tc [(hok)19(e)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 101.3898 431.4874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.0082 tc (.)tj 0.66449 0 td 0.008 tc 0.092 tw [(with the affirmation in place)56(, y)18(ou might tr)19(anslate it as \322i am)]tj -6.12211 -1.23529 td 0 tc -0.005 tw [(choct)19(a)19(w and y)18(ou can\325t sa)19(y otherwise)56(.\323 it is not only an affirmation, but a defi-)]tj t* 0.01 tc 0.137 tw [(ant one)56(. the question r)19(emains)36(, is it asserting a truth about the w)19(orld, an)]tj 0 -1.2353 td 0.008 tc -0.012 tw [(e)18(xperience of that w)19(orld or ma)19(ybe an attitude t)19(o)18(w)19(ar)19(d one or both? whate)18(v)19(er)]tj 0 -1.23529 td 0.062 tw [(the answ)19(er)110(, the most po)19(w)19(erful affirmation in the choct)19(a)18(w language doesn\325t)]tj t* 0 tw [(assert truth in the w)19(a)18(y e)19(v)18(en a r)19(elativ)19(ely ambiguous english sentence does)37(.)]tj 2.11765 -1.23529 td 0 tc (p)tj 0.51807 0 td 0.011 tw [(ossibly the most telling e)19(x)19(ample is the kind of r)18(esponse that a tr)19(adition-)]tj -2.63572 -1.23528 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw (al nativ)tj 3.12145 0 td -0.0177 tc (e)tj 0.74631 0 td -0.018 tc 0 tw (per)tj 1.35419 0 td 0.004 tw (son will giv)tj 4.62799 0 td -0.0177 tc (e)tj 0.74625 0 td -0.018 tc [(in answ)19(er t)18(o a question. i don\325t kno)19(w ho)19(w man)18(y indian)]tj -10.59619 -1.2353 td 0 tc (r)tj 0.34806 0 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw (elated confer)tj 5.57938 0 td (ences i ha)tj 4.29946 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.47819 0 td -0.0031 tc (e)tj 0.76095 0 td -0.003 tc (been t)tj 2.67489 0 td -0.0032 tc (o)tj 0.7978 0 td -0.003 tc 0 tw (wher)tj 2.15373 0 td -0.0031 tc (e)tj 0.76088 0 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw (some non-indian academic will ask a)tj -17.85333 -1.23531 td 0 tc -0.002 tw [(medicine-per)19(son or elder a question. the r)18(esponse the)19(y seek is a st)19(atement of)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw (the w)tj 2.34652 0 td 0 tc (a)tj 0.47413 0 td -0.0072 tc (y)tj 0.77578 0 td -0.007 tc [(things ar)19(e)56(, a truth, a det)18(ailed map of the territ)19(ory)110(. the answ)19(er that the)19(y)]tj -3.59643 -1.2353 td -0.008 tw (get is a r)tj 3.59775 0 td -0.006 tc (ambling narr)tj 5.50726 0 td 0 tw (ativ)tj 1.52942 0 td 0 tc (e)tj 0.43771 0 td -0.0065 tc (.)tj 0.53547 0 td (.)tj 0.53547 0 td (.)tj 0.53547 0 td (.)tj 0.53547 0 td -0.007 tc -0.008 tw (the narr)tj 3.62575 0 td -0.006 tc 0 tw (ativ)tj 1.52941 0 td -0.0065 tc (e)tj 0.75752 0 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(is gener)19(ally a st)18(o)1(r)1(y)1( )1(f)1(r)20(o)1(m)1( )1(t)1(h)1(e)1(i)1(r)1( )1(o)20(w)1(n)]tj -19.12669 -1.23531 td 0 tc 0 tw [(life)56(, ma)18(ybe with a fe)19(w tr)19(aditional side st)18(ories)37(. . . .)]tj 2.11765 -1.23529 td (kno)tj 1.73999 0.00001 td -0.009 tw (wledge is a narr)tj 6.84068 0 td [(ativ)19(e of a life liv)18(ed in the w)19(orld. the individual st)19(ories)]tj -10.69832 -1.2353 td -0.004 tc 0 tw (ar)tj 0.84378 0.00001 td -0.0038 tc (e)tj 0.7602 0 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw (what y)tj 2.87543 0.00001 td (ou kno)tj 2.93027 0 td 0 tc (w)tj 0.6443 0 td -0.0038 tc (.)tj 0.5382 0 td -0.004 tc 0 tw (the)tj 1.582 0 td -0.0038 tc (y)tj 0.77915 0 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(ma)19(y or ma)18(y not pr)19(o)19(vide a map of the w)18(orld, but the)19(y)]tj -10.95333 -1.23531 td -0.005 tc -0.009 tw (do tell y)tj 3.38552 0 td (ou about the consequences of y)tj 13.50129 0.00001 td (our actions)tj 4.6982 0 td -0.0048 tc (.)tj 0.53703 0 td (y)tj 0.52659 0 td -0.005 tc (ou can learn much e)tj 8.70836 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.47664 0 td -0.005 tc (en if)tj -31.83364 -1.23531 td 0 tc (y)tj 0.5 0 td -0.0001 tc (ou)tj 1.35167 0 td 0 tc 0 tw [(belie)19(v)18(e little)56(. y)80(ou can e)19(v)18(en be t)19(aught. \(hester & chene)19(y)111(, in pr)18(ess\))]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 55 243.5166 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.007 tc 0.132 tw [(what i ha)19(v)19(e called a \322)56(cer)18(emonial w)19(orld\323 \(chene)19(y)111(, 1999; chene)19(y)1( )1(&)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc (w)tj 0.85107 0 td 0 tw (est)tj 1.22193 0 td 0.002 tw (on, 1999\) is a compr)tj 9.00769 0 td 0 tw (ehensiv)tj 3.29565 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.77976 0 td 0 tc 0.002 tw (map. cer)tj 3.96444 0 td [(emonial w)19(orlds ar)18(e the w)19(orlds)]tj -19.12054 -1.20001 td -0.014 tc 0 tw (\(compr)tj 3.0088 0 td [(ehensiv)19(e maps)36(, st)19(ories\) within which w)19(e liv)19(e)55(, the w)19(orlds that ha)19(v)18(e the)]tj -3.0088 -1.2 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(po)19(w)19(er t)18(o orient us in life)56(. the)19(y define f)19(or us the natur)18(e of the sacr)19(ed \(that in)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.005 tw (which meaning is located, the mor)tj 14.66805 0 td (e-than-human dimensions of our w)tj 14.88483 0 td 0 tw (orlds\),)tj -29.55288 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.064 tw [(the natur)19(al, and the human, and the r)18(elationships betw)19(een them. a cer)19(e-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.002 tc -0.012 tw (monial w)tj 3.99317 0 td [(orld is an activ)19(ely constructed portr)18(ait of the w)19(orld intended t)19(o be)]tj -3.99317 -1.2 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(r)19(esponsibly true)56(, one which rings true f)18(or e)19(v)19(erybody\325)37(s w)18(ell-being. it is a w)19(orld)]tj t* 0 tc 0.014 tw [(built on the basis of an ethical-epistemological orient)19(ation of attentiv)18(eness)]tj (\()' et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 39.7389 135.5166 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.021 tc [(r)18(espect)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 67.7326 135.5166 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0222 tc (\))tj 0.53771 0 td -0.025 tc 0.008 tw [(r)16(a)-3(ther than an epistemology of contr)18(ol. such cer)19(emonial w)19(orlds)36(, built,)]tj -3.61097 -1.2 td -0.003 tc 0.016 tw [(as the)19(y ar)18(e)56(, ar)19(ound the notion of r)18(esponsible truth, ar)19(e synthetic cr)19(eations)37(,)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.004 tw [(adjusted holistically t)19(o all the concerns that arise fr)18(om a f)19(ocus on r)18(esponsib)-3(l)-3(e)]tj t* 0 tc -0.014 tw [(truth: the)19(y must tie do)18(wn t)19(o the w)19(orld of e)19(v)19(ery)18(da)19(y pr)19(actice and e)18(xperience)]tj t* -0.006 tc 0.011 tw [(i)-6(n)-6( )-6(a)-6( )-6(w)13(a)12(y)-6( )-6(t)-6(h)-6(a)-6(t)-6( )-6(m)-6(ak)19(es it possible t)19(o surviv)18(e; the)19(y must orient the community)]tj t* -0.021 tc 0.002 tw [(and its individuals on r)19(oads of life that allo)18(w f)19(or the flourishing of all memb)-5(e)-5(r)14(s)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 37 17.496 323 23.0401 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 38 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (jim cheney)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 14.134 17.496 21.866 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.1344 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (94)tj et q endstream endobj 11 0 obj << /length 7734 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 72 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(of the community)111(, as f)18(ar as that is possible)56(. the met)19(aph)18(y)19(sics or ont)19(ology of)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.014 tc 0 tw [(such a w)19(orld will not be under)18(st)19(ood as true in the modern sense of the term.)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(the issue is alw)19(a)19(y)19(s (if implicitly) whether it is r)18(esponsibly)111(, or corr)19(ectly)111(, true;)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (whether it is action guiding in the full sense just delineated.)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 10 0 2.12557 10 73 527.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (principles of epistemological method )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 508.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(the block quote fr)19(om deloria \(abo)18(v)19(e\) depicts a cer)18(emonial w)19(orld. within this)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(cer)19(emonial w)18(orld some elements ha)19(v)19(e an epistemological function. deloria)]tj t* 0 tc 0.029 tw [(is e)19(xplicit about this and coins the w)18(onderful term \322principle of epistemo-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.025 tc 0.011 tw [(logical method\323 (deloria, p. 44) t)19(o)1( )1(r)19(efer t)19(o them. deloria pr)19(o)19(vides a nice e)19(x)19(am-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.013 tw [(ple of such a principle in his discussion of the w)19(ell-kno)18(wn phr)19(ase \322\324)93(all m)18(y)]tj t* -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(r)19(elativ)19(es\325 [)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 116.1461 448.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.012 tc -0.001 tw [(m)-1(i)-1(t)18(ak)18(uy)19(e)-1( o)17(y)18(asin)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 181.411 448.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(], which is used as an opening inv)19(ocation and clos-)]tj -10.8411 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(ing benediction f)19(or cer)18(emonies)37(. \324)93(all m)18(y r)19(elativ)18(es\325 . . . also has a secular pur-)]tj t* 0 tc -0.005 tw [(pose)56(, which is t)18(o r)19(emind us of our r)19(esponsibility t)18(o r)19(espect life and t)19(o fulfill)]tj t* 0.012 tc 0.127 tw [(our co)19(v)18(enant)19(al duties)37(. but fe)19(w people under)18(st)19(and that the phr)19(ase also)]tj t* 0 tc 0.046 tw (describes the )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 133.7249 400.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (epistemology)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 191.375 400.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.046 tw (of the indian w)tj 6.69125 0 td 0 tw (orldvie)tj 2.94361 0 td 0.046 tw [(w)111(, pr)19(o)19(viding the )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 361.1156 400.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (method)tj 3.07349 0 td (-)tj -31.88505 -1.2 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw (ological basis)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 129.3884 388.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(f)18(or the gathering of inf)19(ormation about the w)19(orld\323 \(deloria et al.,)]tj -5.63884 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(1999, p. 52; emphasis added\). deloria is clear that this \322gathering of inf)19(or)-1(-)]tj t* -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(mation\323 does not cast humans in the r)19(ole of sole kno)18(w)19(er)19(s and all else in the)]tj t* 0 tc 0.139 tw [(r)19(ole of objects kno)18(wn: inf)19(ormation \322gather)19(ed\323 is the r)18(esult of r)19(ecipr)19(ocal)]tj t* 0 tw [(communication within a mor)19(e-than-human w)18(orld.)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(man)19(y st)18(atements coming fr)19(om fir)19(st nations w)18(orlds that eur)19(o-americans)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.006 tw [(w)19(ould under)19(st)18(and t)19(o be st)19(atements of )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 239.6359 316.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (belief)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 264.8654 316.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.006 tw [((truth claims) concerning fir)19(st)]tj -19.18654 -1.2 td 0.139 tw [(nations w)19(orldvie)18(w)19(s ar)19(e best under)19(st)18(ood as principles of epistemological)]tj t* 0.057 tw (method. fir)tj 5.11208 0 td (st nations thought on the notion that the univ)tj 20.21576 0 td 0 tw (er)tj 0.85108 0 td 0.057 tw (se is aliv)tj 3.76127 0 td (e)tj 0.44409 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.61276 0 td (f)tj 0.2962 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (or)tj -31.29324 -1.20002 td (e)tj 0.4812 0 td (x)tj 0.51807 0 td (ample)tj 2.62988 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.55739 0 td 0 tc 0.002 tw (is truly r)tj 3.57616 0 td [(emark)19(able)56(. \322it cannot be ar)18(gued,\323 deloria sa)19(y)19(s)37(, \322that the)]tj -7.7627 -1.20001 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(univ)19(er)18(se is mor)19(al or has a mor)19(al purpose without simult)18(aneously maint)19(ain-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw (ing that the univ)tj 6.99204 0 td 0 tw (er)tj 0.84536 0 td -0.011 tw (se is aliv)tj 3.59632 0 td 0 tc (e)tj 0.44123 0 td -0.003 tc (.)tj 0.53903 0 td (the)tj 1.86709 0 td (old indians had no pr)tj 9.15485 0 td (oblem with this con)tj 8.48633 0 td 0 tc (-)tj -31.92225 -1.20002 td -0.012 tc -0.002 tw (cept because the)tj 7.02221 0 td -0.0125 tc (y)tj 0.77039 0 td (e)tj 0.46885 0 td -0.012 tc (xperienced life in e)tj 8.02473 0 td [(v)19(erything, and ther)19(e)1( )1(w)19(as no r)19(eason t)19(o)]tj -16.28618 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw [(suppose that the continuum of life w)19(as not univ)18(er)19(sal\323 \(deloria et al., 1999,)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.021 tc 0.007 tw (p. 49\). is this a scientific claim with supporting e)tj 19.97576 0 td (xperiential e)tj 5.11023 0 td (vidence? a met)tj 6.35635 0 td 0 tc (a)tj 0.47958 0 td (-)tj -31.92192 -1.20001 td -0.018 tc 0 tw (ph)tj 1.05763 0 td 0 tc (y)tj 0.4823 0 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw (sical w)tj 2.7862 0 td [(orldvie)19(w? not lik)18(ely in vie)19(w of our discussion t)19(o this point. but fir)19(st)]tj -4.32613 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0 tw [(nations thought concerning the notion of a living planet is mor)19(e r)18(e)19(v)19(ealing: )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91 175.8616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.003 tc -0.005 tw [(the pr)19(actical criterion that is alw)18(a)19(y)19(s cited t)19(o demonstr)18(ate its v)19(alidity is the eas-)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.006 tw [(ily observ)19(able f)18(act that the earth nurtur)19(es smaller f)19(orms of life\321people)56(, plants)36(,)]tj t* -0.006 tc -0.002 tw [(bir)19(d)1(s)37(, animals)37(, riv)19(er)18(s)37(, v)19(alle)19(y)19(s)37(, and continents)37(. f)56(or indians)37(, both speculation and)]tj t* 0.005 tc 0.062 tw (analogy end at this point. t)tj 12.20964 0.00001 td 0.0055 tc (o)tj 0.88746 0 td 0.005 tc (go further and attribute a plenitude of f)tj 17.58406 0.00001 td 0 tw (amiliar)tj -30.68115 -1.23531 td 0.003 tw [(human char)19(acteristics t)18(o the earth is un)19(w)18(arr)19(anted. it w)19(ould cast the planet in)]tj 0 -1.23529 td 0.01 tc 0.135 tw [(the r)19(estricted clothing of lesser beings)36(,)1( )1(a)1(n)1(d)1( )1(w)20(e)1( )1(w)20(ould not be able t)18(o gain)]tj t* 0.005 tc 0 tw [(insights and kno)19(wledge about the r)18(eal essence of the earth. (p. 49-50))]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 90.8616 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.003 tw (the humour \(as w)tj 7.84242 0.00001 td (ell as the seriousness\) in deloria\325)tj 14.14412 0.00001 td -0.0002 tc (s)tj 0.70706 0 td 0 tc [(twist on w)93(estern criti)-1(-)]tj -22.6936 -1.2 td 0.077 tw (cisms of anthr)tj 6.31976 0.00001 td (opomorphizing nonhuman natur)tj 14.31879 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.85486 0 td (b)tj 0.5372 0.00001 td (y)tj 0.87387 0 td 0 tc (attributing \322superior\323)tj -22.9045 -1.2 td 0 tw [(human char)19(acteristics t)18(o it ar)19(e)56(, i hope)56(, obvious)36(.)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 226.6436 33.8348 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the moral epistemology of first nations stories)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 395.982 17.496 23.013 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3524 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (95)tj et q endstream endobj 12 0 obj << /length 7387 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 36 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 55 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(if speculation and analogy end wher)19(e fir)18(st nations peoples end it, then)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(the idea of the living earth isn\325t e)19(v)18(en speculativ)19(e: it is obvious on the f)18(ace of)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0 tc 0.119 tw (it. not that it can\325t be denied, but at that point speculation, theory con-)tj t* -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(struction, or met)19(aph)18(y)19(sics )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 143.0406 551.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.021 tc (is)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 152.2953 551.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(necessary)111(. casting humans as \322lesser\323 beings puts)]tj -11.52953 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.004 tw [(another twist on the matter: it f)19(olds the idea of the living earth int)18(o a cer)19(e-)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(monial w)19(orld orienting fir)18(st nations peoples on the mor)19(al r)19(oad. the notion)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.006 tc -0.008 tw [(of a living w)19(orld is not part of a fir)18(st nations )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 228.8824 515.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.006 tc [(w)18(orldvie)19(w)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 270.7626 515.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.006 tc -0.008 tw (\321a truth claim\321it is)tj -23.37626 -1.19999 td 0.021 tc 0.118 tw [(an e)19(v)19(ery)18(da)19(y observ)19(ation fitted int)19(o a cer)18(emonial w)19(orld in a w)19(a)19(y that)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.003 tc 0.136 tw [(enhances its epistemological effectiv)19(eness)37(. \322coming last, human beings)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(w)19(e)1(r)20(e)1( )1(t)1(h)1(e)1( )11(y)20(ounger br)19(other)18(s\325 of the other life-f)19(orms and ther)19(ef)19(o)1(r)19(e had t)19(o learn)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(e)19(v)19(erything fr)18(om these cr)19(eatur)19(es\323 (deloria et al., 1999, p. 50).)]tj 1.8 -1.2 td 0.005 tw [(the notion of a living univ)19(er)18(se)56(, ther)19(ef)18(or)19(e)56(, is not mer)19(ely obvious on the)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(f)19(ace of it, but it also pr)19(o)19(vides )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 158.3676 443.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.019 tc (epistemological)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 222.4057 443.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(dir)19(ection in the sear)18(ch f)19(or kno)18(wl-)]tj -18.54057 -1.2 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(edge as w)19(ell as po)18(w)19(erful )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 139.8564 431.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.021 tc [(mor)19(al)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 165.7048 431.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(dir)19(ection. the epistemological dir)18(ection is itself)]tj -12.87048 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(ethically inf)19(ormed, as w)18(e ha)19(v)19(e seen. ther)19(e is mor)18(e:)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 55 398.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0224 tc (the)tj 1.80876 0 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(living univ)19(er)18(se r)19(equir)19(es mutual r)18(espect among its member)19(s)37(, and this suggests)]tj -1.80876 -1.23529 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(that a str)19(ong sense of individual identity and self is a dominant char)18(acteristic of)]tj t* -0.016 tc 0.002 tw (the w)tj 2.31144 0 td [(orld as w)19(e kno)18(w it. the willingness of entities t)19(o allo)19(w other)18(s t)19(o fulfill them-)]tj -2.31144 -1.2353 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(selv)19(es)36(, and the r)19(efusal of an)19(y entity t)18(o intrude thoughtlessly on another)111(, must be)]tj 0 -1.23529 td 0 tc -0.005 tw [(the oper)19(ativ)18(e principle of this univ)19(er)19(se)55(. consequently)111(, self-kno)19(wledge and self-)]tj t* -0.017 tc 0.003 tw [(discipline ar)19(e high v)18(alues of beha)19(vior)111(. . . . r)18(espect . . . inv)19(olv)19(es tw)18(o attitudes)37(. one)]tj t* -0.01 tc -0.004 tw (attitude is the accept)tj 8.72937 0 td (ance of self-discipline b)tj 9.84648 0 td -0.0102 tc (y)tj 0.77278 0 td -0.01 tc (humans and their communities t)tj 13.84645 0 td 0 tc (o)tj -33.19508 -1.2353 td -0.006 tc -0.009 tw [(act r)19(esponsibly t)18(o)19(w)18(ar)19(d)-1( )-1(o)-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1(r)-1( )-1(f)17(orms of life)56(. the other attitude is t)19(o seek t)18(o est)19(a)-1(b)-1(-)]tj 0 -1.23529 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(lish communications and co)19(v)19(enants with other f)18(orms of life on a mutually)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (agr)tj 1.35107 0 td (eeable basis)tj 5.20411 0 td -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.55577 0 td 0 tc (\(deloria et al., 1999, p. 50-5)tj 12.13172 0 td (1\))tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 281.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.012 tw (these conclusions ar)tj 9.00493 0 td (en\325t f)tj 2.2532 0 td 0 tw (or)tj 0.88794 0 td 0.012 tw [(ced upon us b)19(y the notion of a living univ)18(er)19(se)56(,)]tj -12.14607 -1.20001 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(of cour)19(se)55(, but the)19(y ar)19(e the sorts of conclusions one might e)18(xpect within a cer-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(emonial w)19(orld built ar)18(ound the mor)19(al purpose of \322finding the pr)19(oper mor)18(al)]tj t* -0.027 tc 0.013 tw (and ethical r)tj 5.04281 0 td (oad upon which human beings should w)tj 16.61783 0 td [(alk.\323 the)19(y e)18(xtend in quite)]tj -21.66064 -1.20001 td -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(natur)19(al w)18(a)19(y)18(s the gener)19(al attitude of univ)19(er)18(sal consider)19(ation discussed earli-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [(er as a featur)19(e of fir)18(st nations w)19(orlds)37(. when deloria sa)18(y)19(s that b)19(y emplo)19(ying)]tj 0 tc (v)' 0.4812 0 td 0.012 tw [(arious principles of epistemological method w)19(e \322gain insights and kno)18(wl-)]tj -0.4812 -1.2 td -0.019 tc 0.005 tw [(edge about the r)19(eal essence of the earth\323 (deloria et al., 1999, p. 50) he is not)]tj t* 0 tc 0.017 tw (speaking of deep )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 113.803 185.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (truths)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 141.5696 185.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.017 tw [(about the w)19(orld; r)18(ather)111(, he is speaking of a deeply)]tj -10.45696 -1.2 td 0 tw [(pr)19(actical map of the w)18(orld, a cer)19(emonial w)19(orld.)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 194.6404 140.3616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (iii)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 117.5616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0065 tc (i)tj 0.5535 0 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw (conclude with a fe)tj 7.75024 0.00001 td -0.0065 tc (w)tj 1.01648 0 td -0.007 tc (thoughts concerning envir)tj 11.11809 0.00001 td -0.006 tc 0 tw (onment)tj 3.33129 0.00001 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw (al education, ethics)tj 8.15262 0.00001 td 0 tc (,)tj -31.9222 -1.2 td -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(and pr)19(actice suggested b)19(y the \322mor)18(al epistemology\323 sk)19(et)19(ched abo)18(v)19(e)56(. these)]tj t* -0.012 tc -0.002 tw [(thoughts constitute an endor)19(sement of car)18(ol geddes\325 (1996) r)19(emark that the)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.011 tw (tlingit \322w)tj 4.1287 0 td (ould ne)tj 3.1748 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.4787 0 td -0.003 tc [(er ha)19(v)18(e a subject called envir)19(onment)19(al ethics; it is simply)]tj -7.7822 -1.2 td 0 tc 0 tw [(part of the st)19(ory\323 (p. 32).)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 37 17.496 323 23.0401 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 38 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (jim cheney)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 14.134 17.496 21.866 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.1344 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (96)tj et q endstream endobj 13 0 obj << /length 9076 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 72 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 73 588.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(1)-9(.)-9( )-418(w)93(estern envir)18(onment)19(al education, ethics)37(, and pr)19(actice is)36(, b)19(y and lar)19(ge)56(, mod-)]tj 1.51579 -1.26316 td 0 tc 0.045 tw [(eled on the notion of an epistemology- or kno)19(wledge-based ethic: w)92(e fir)19(st)]tj t* 0.007 tw [(come t)19(o under)18(st)19(and the w)19(a)18(y the w)19(orld )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 249.0187 564.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k (is)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 256.0548 564.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (;)tj 0.56305 0 td 0 tc 0.007 tw [(only then do w)19(e deduce our eth-)]tj -18.31619 -1.26316 td 0 tw [(ical r)19(esponsibilities t)18(o that w)19(orld. )]tj -1.51579 -2.52632 td 0.028 tw [(2. )-376(fir)18(st nations pr)19(actice begins with an epistemology that is )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 327.4445 528.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(alr)19(eady)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 360.8638 528.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k (ethically)tj -28.78566 -1.26316 td 0.038 tw [(inf)19(ormed, an epistemology emplo)18(y)19(ed in a sear)19(ch f)19(or )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 308.0345 516.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(r)19(esponsible)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 358.0478 516.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.038 tw [(truths b)19(y)]tj -28.48924 -1.26316 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(which individuals and communities might surviv)19(e)55(, \322seek life\323 \(beck, w)93(alter)19(s)36(,)]tj -0.0212 tc (&)' 0.96495 0 td -0.024 tc 0.007 tw [(fr)19(ancisco, 1990, p. 47\), and find the pr)18(oper r)19(oad upon which t)18(o w)19(alk so that)]tj -0.96495 -1.26316 td -0.003 tc 0.011 tw [(the)19(y ma)18(y \322)56(act r)19(esponsibly t)19(o)18(w)19(ar)19(d other f)18(orms of life [and] seek t)19(o est)19(ablish)]tj t* -0.009 tc -0.008 tw [(communications and co)19(v)19(enants with other f)18(orms of life on a mutually agr)19(ee-)]tj t* -0.019 tc -0.001 tw [(a)-3(b)-3(l)-3(e)-3( )-3(b)-3(a)-3(s)-3(i)-3(s)34(.\323 this epistemology is one of r)19(espect or univ)18(er)19(sal consider)19(ation that)]tj t* -0.006 tc 0.027 tw [(is made e)19(xplicit in principles of epistemological method embedded in cer)18(e-)]tj t* 0 tw [(monial w)19(orlds)36(.)]tj -1.51579 -2.52632 td 0.002 tc 0.137 tw [(1)2(a)2(.)-180(the type of kno)19(wledge appr)18(opriate t)19(o w)93(estern envir)18(onment)19(al education)]tj 1.51579 -1.26316 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [([(1), abo)19(v)19(e] is an under)19(s)1(t)19(anding of \322the abstr)19(act structur)19(e of ph)18(y)20(sical r)18(eality\323)]tj t* -0.008 tc -0.006 tw [((deloria et al., 1999, p. 46). the r)19(ole of e)18(xperience of the natur)19(al w)19(orld with-)]tj t* -0.019 tc 0.005 tw (in the dominant w)tj 7.79159 0 td (estern envir)tj 4.92942 0.00001 td 0 tw (onment)tj 3.25918 0 td 0.005 tw (al education par)tj 6.65778 0 td [(adigm is t)19(o connect the)]tj -22.63797 -1.26317 td 0 tc 0.02 tw [(abstr)19(act kno)18(wledge fr)19(om which an envir)19(onment)19(al)-1( ethic i)1(s d)-1(eriv)19(ed with the)]tj 0 -1.26316 td -0.004 tc -0.01 tw [(liv)19(ed e)18(xperience of the child and t)19(o gener)19(ate a liv)18(ed sense of the \322land-com-)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw (munity\323 \(l)tj 4.59106 0 td (eopold, 197)tj 5.11304 0 td (0\) and of the student as part of that community)tj 20.50146 0.00001 td -0.0003 tc (.)tj -31.72136 -2.52633 td -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(2)-20(a)-20(.)-202(the kno)18(wledge appr)19(opriate t)19(o fir)18(st nations pr)19(actice [(2), abo)19(v)19(e] is alr)18(eady eth-)]tj 1.51579 -1.26316 td -0.002 tc -0.012 tw (ically inf)tj 3.60083 0 td (ormed and is kno)tj 7.54783 0 td (wledge that is not abstr)tj 10.02322 0 td [(acted fr)19(om the liv)18(ed e)19(xpe-)]tj -21.17188 -1.26317 td 0 tc 0.02 tw [(rience of the whole per)19(son. borr)18(o)19(wing holmes r)19(olst)19(on\325)36(s (1988) w)19(or)19(ds and)]tj 0 -1.26316 td (f)tj 0.29614 0 td 0.012 tw (olding them in with hester\325)tj 11.86395 0 td (s)tj 0.38891 0 td -0.0003 tc (,)tj 0.56788 0 td (w)tj 0.7402 0 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.79023 0 td 0 tc (can sa)tj 2.73414 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (y)tj 0.80918 0 td 0 tc (that \322)tj 2.36389 0 td (an [indigenous] ethic is not)tj -20.55453 -1.26318 td -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.56339 0 td (.)tj 0.56339 0 td (.)tj 0.56339 0 td (a)tj 0.78539 0 td 0 tc 0.008 tw (theory but a tr)tj 6.22638 0.00001 td (ack thr)tj 2.98908 0 td [(ough the w)19(orld\323 (p. 349). \322[l]ogic will be mix)18(ed)]tj -11.69103 -1.26316 td -0.022 tc [(with st)19(ory)110(. the [w)93(estern natur)19(alistic] mo)18(v)19(e fr)18(om )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 279.127 252.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.02 tc (is)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 288.2703 252.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.04 tc [(to)-18( )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 298.2839 252.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.02 tc (ought)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 323.1257 252.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0216 tc (.)tj 0.52031 0 td (.)tj 0.52031 0 td (.)tj 0.52031 0 td -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(is tr)19(ansf)18(ormed)]tj -26.37415 -1.26316 td 0.009 tc 0.13 tw ([in indigenous philosoph)tj 11.12899 0 td (y] int)tj 2.44379 0 td 0.0091 tc (o)tj 0.96288 0 td 0.009 tc 0 tw (mo)tj 1.42566 0 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.49052 0 td 0.009 tc 0.13 tw (ement along a st)tj 7.72289 0 td (ory line\323 (p. 342).)tj -24.17472 -1.26317 td -0.019 tc 0 tw (\322kno)tj 2.11011 0 td 0.005 tw [(wledge is a narr)19(ativ)18(e of a life liv)19(ed in the w)19(orld. the individual st)18(ories ar)19(e)]tj -2.11011 -1.26316 td 0 tc -0.01 tw [(what y)19(ou kno)18(w\323 \(hester & chene)19(y)111(, in pr)19(ess\). individuals ma)18(y tell their o)19(wn)]tj t* -0.008 tc 0 tw (st)tj 0.70634 0 td -0.006 tw (ories or pass do)tj 6.66998 0 td (wn the st)tj 3.89885 0 td (ories of other)tj 5.63624 0 td 0 tc (s)tj 0.38112 0 td -0.008 tc (.)tj 0.53384 0 td [(w)93(e gr)18(o)19(w and learn b)19(y sharing and)]tj -17.82638 -1.26317 td 0 tc (r)tj 0.35107 0 td 0 tw [(eflecting on st)19(ories: )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 173.4033 192.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k (st)tj 0.81494 0 td [(ories ar)19(e what w)18(e kno)19(w)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 279.6191 192.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k (.)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 91 168.3035 tm 0 0 0 1 k (st)tj 0.81494 0 td 0.039 tw [(ories within the dominant w)93(estern par)18(adigm of envir)19(onment)19(al edu-)]tj -2.61494 -1.2 td -0.003 tw (cation ar)tj 3.7735 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (e)tj 0.77494 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (mer)tj 1.74001 0.00001 td -0.003 tw (ely t)tj 1.83087 0.00001 td (ools f)tj 2.31158 0.00001 td (or educating 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛 up t)tj 11.24707 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.81189 0 td 0 tc (\(what is thought t)tj 7.5465 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.81188 0 td 0 tc 0 tw (be\))tj -30.84824 -1.20004 td 0.004 tc 0.135 tw [(the r)19(eal thing: a pr)18(oper scientific under)19(st)19(anding of the land-community)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.01 tc 0.129 tw (and the ethic that f)tj 8.90273 0.00001 td 0 tw (ollo)tj 1.57701 0 td 0 tc (w)tj 0.75002 0.00001 td 0.0098 tc (s)tj 0.85256 0 td 0.01 tc (fr)tj 0.68609 0.00001 td 0.129 tw [(om this under)19(st)18(anding. st)19(ories within fir)18(st)]tj -12.76841 -1.20002 td 0 tc 0 tw (nations cultur)tj 6.0166 0.00001 td (es)tj 0.88892 0.00001 td -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.55579 0 td 0 tc (on the other hand, )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 230.9541 120.3036 tm 0 0 0 1 k (ar)tj 0.8689 0.00001 td (e)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 246.8599 120.3036 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the r)tj 1.99975 0.00001 td (eal thing.)tj -17.5857 -1.2 td -0.011 tw [(a)37(t this point i w)19(ant t)18(o add a final, and vit)19(al, element t)19(o the st)19(ory i ha)18(v)19(e)]tj -1.8 -1.2 td -0.001 tc -0.01 tw (been telling. as i mentioned in p)tj 14.02621 0.00001 td (art i of this paper)tj 7.3161 0.00001 td -0.0008 tc (,)tj 0.54396 0 td (i)tj 0.56196 0 td -0.001 tc 0 tw (ha)tj 1.0358 0.00001 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.48056 0.00001 td -0.0008 tc (e)tj 0.76599 0 td -0.001 tc -0.01 tw [(m)19(y 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛 r)18(ead)]tj -24.7306 -1.2 td 0 tc (l)tj 0.4805 0 td -0.001 tc (eopold, sn)tj 4.53886 0.00001 td 0 tc (y)tj 0.49931 0.00001 td -0.001 tc 0 tw (der)tj 1.31288 0.00001 td -0.0009 tc (,)tj 0.54385 0 td -0.001 tc (berry)tj 2.23706 0.00001 td -0.0008 tc (,)tj 0.54393 0 td -0.001 tc -0.01 tw (and house as st)tj 6.77278 0.00001 td (ories of liv)tj 4.45063 0.00001 td (es liv)tj 2.17002 0.00001 td [(ed\321liv)19(es liv)18(ed with-)]tj -23.5498 -1.2 td 0.006 tc 0.136 tw [(in lar)19(ger liv)18(es)37(, st)19(ories within lar)18(ger st)19(ories\321)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 272.8172 72.3036 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.005 tc 0.126 tw [(r)18(ather than as ar)19(g)-1(u)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)-1(s)-1( )-1(i)-1(n)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 226.6436 33.8348 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the moral epistemology of first nations stories)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 395.982 17.496 23.013 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3524 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (97)tj et q endstream endobj 14 0 obj << /length 5995 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 36 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.008 tw [(c)-2(o)-2(m)-2(petition with one another)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 159.3247 587.9617 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.56463 0 td 0 tc 0.009 tw [(st)19(ories in r)18(elationship t)19(o one another beha)19(v)18(e)]tj -12.7971 -1.2 td -0.013 tw [(mor)19(e lik)18(e elements of ecosy)19(stems than lik)19(e ar)18(guments squaring off against)]tj 0 -1.20001 td -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(one another)111(. joseph meek)19(er suggests that biological life is essentially comedic)]tj t* -0.026 tc 0.012 tw [(and that surviv)19(al ma)18(y depend upon human conf)19(ormity t)19(o this biological norm.)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc 0.083 tw [(f)56(or e)19(x)19(ample)55(, basing his analy)19(sis on a classical under)19(st)18(anding of comedy)111(,)]tj t* 0 tw [(meek)19(er (1997) sa)18(y)19(s that:)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 55 506.9616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.023 tc 0.009 tw [(ev)19(olution pr)18(oceeds as an unscrupulous)37(, opportunistic comedy)111(, the object of which)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(appear)19(s t)18(o be the pr)19(olifer)19(ation and pr)18(eserv)19(ation of as man)19(y life f)19(orms as possible)55(.)]tj t* -0.003 tc -0.011 tw [(successful participants in it ar)19(e those who liv)18(e and r)19(epr)19(oduce e)18(v)19(en when times)]tj t* [(ar)19(e har)18(d or danger)19(ous)37(, not those who ar)18(e best able t)19(o destr)19(o)19(y enemies or com-)]tj t* -0.01 tc -0.004 tw [(petit)19(o)1(r)19(s)38(. its gr)18(ound rules f)19(or participants)37(, including people)56(, ar)18(e those that go)19(v)19(ern)]tj t* 0 tc 0.059 tw [(liter)19(ary comedy: or)18(ganisms must adapt themselv)19(es t)19(o their cir)18(cumst)19(ances in)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.009 tw [(e)19(v)19(ery possible w)19(a)19(y)111(, must studiously a)18(v)19(oid all-or-nothing choices)37(, must seek alter-)]tj t* -0.027 tc 0.005 tw [(nativ)19(es t)18(o death, must accept and r)19(e)19(v)19(el in maximum div)19(er)18(sity)111(, must accommodate)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.012 tw [(t)-2(h)-2(e)-2(m)-2(s)-2(e)-2(l)-2(v)17(e)-2(s)-2( )-2(t)16(o)-2( )-2(t)-2(h)-2(e accident)19(al limit)19(ations of birth and envir)19(onment, and must pr)18(e)1(-)]tj t* -0.02 tc -0.005 tw [(fer cooper)19(ation t)18(o competition, y)19(et compete successfully when necessary)111(. . . . the)]tj 0 -1.2353 td -0.012 tc -0.013 tw [(c)5(o)5(m)5(i)5(c)5( w)24(a)23(y)5( i)5(s)5( t)24(o)5( b)5(e)5( f)24(o)5(u)5(n)5(d)5( i)5(n)5( e)23(v)24(o)5(l)5(u)5(tionary )-5(hist)19(ory)110(, )-5(in )-5(the )-5(pr)19(ocesses )-5(of )-5(ecology)111(, )-5(and)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.01 tc -0.009 tw (in comic liter)tj 5.50269 0 td [(atur)19(e)56(, which ma)19(y r)18(epr)19(esent the closest w)18(e ha)19(v)19(e come t)19(o describing)]tj -5.50269 -1.2353 td -0.004 tc 0.138 tw [(humans as adaptiv)19(e animals)37(. comedy illustr)18(ates that surviv)19(al depends upon)]tj 0 -1.23529 td -0.03 tc 0.01 tw [(our ability t)19(o change our)18(selv)19(es r)19(ather than our envir)19(onment . . . . comedy is a str)18(at-)]tj t* -0.003 tc 0.065 tw [(e)3(g)3(y)3( )3(f)22(o)3(r)3( )3(l)3(i)3(v)3(i)3(n)3(g)3( )3(t)3(h)3(a)3(t)3( )3(c)3(ont)18(ains ecological wisdom, and it ma)19(y be o)-3(n)-3(e)-3( )-3(o)-3(f)-3( )-3(o)-3(u)-3(r)-3( )-3(b)-3(e)-3(s)-3(t)]tj t* -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(guides as w)19(e try t)18(o r)19(et)19(ain a place f)18(or our)19(selv)19(es among the other animals that liv)18(e)]tj t* 0 tc 0 tw [(accor)19(ding t)18(o the comic w)19(a)19(y)111(. \(p. 20-2)56(1\))]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 37 316.4616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.019 tc 0.005 tw [(so with st)19(ories: the)18(y ar)19(e (or can be) comedic instruments of surviv)19(al. it seems)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0 tc (t)tj 0.29614 0 td -0.0001 tc (o)tj 0.87171 0 td 0 tc 0.057 tw (me that an account of kno)tj 11.67336 0 td (wledge and ethics that r)tj 10.57969 0 td [(e)19(visions these along)]tj -23.4209 -1.20001 td -0.008 tc -0.007 tw [(comedic or ecosy)19(stemic)18(, e)19(v)18(o)-1(l)-1(u)-1(t)-1(i)-1(o)-1(n)-1(a)-1(r)-1(y)-1( )-1(l)-1(i)-1(n)-1(e)-1(s)36(, since it mirr)19(or)18(s)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1( )-1(v)18(ery ecosy)19(s)-1(-)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.001 tc 0.138 tw [(tems that ar)19(e the concern of envir)18(onment)19(al ethics)37(, is f)18(ar mor)19(e lik)19(ely t)18(o)]tj t* 0 tc -0.01 tw (succeed than an account of kno)tj 13.65091 0 td (wledge and ethics that is conceptually \(and)tj -13.65091 -1.2 td 0 tw [(tr)19(agically\) at odds with that which it w)18(ould \322sa)19(v)19(e)56<2ed3>]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 184.2285 222.8616 tm 0 0 0 1 k (notes)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 202.3716 tm 0 0 0 1 k (1)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 200.0616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.001 tc -0.013 tw [(that is)37(, f)18(ollo)19(wing w)93(ebster)110(, under)19(st)18(anding an axi)1(om as \322)55(a pr)19(oposition that is)]tj 0 -1.26316 td -0.011 tc -0.003 tw [(assumed without pr)19(oof f)18(or the sak)19(e of studying the consequences that f)18(ollo)19(w)]tj t* -0.022 tc 0 tw (fr)tj 0.62243 0 td 0.008 tw [(om it\323 r)19(ather than as \322)55(a self-e)19(vident truth that r)19(equir)19(es no pr)18(oof\323 or as \322)56(a uni-)]tj -0.62243 -1.26316 td 0 tc (v)tj 0.4812 0 td 0 tw [(er)19(sally accepted principle or rule)55<2ed3>]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 7 0 0 7 37 154.3716 tm 0 0 0 1 k (2)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 152.0616 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.013 tc -0.001 tw [(such gener)19(aliz)18(ations ar)19(e the author\325)37(s)36(. see the \322)56(ackno)19(wledgments\323 section f)19(or)]tj 0 -1.26316 td 0 tc 0 tw (other disclaimer)tj 6.99854 0.00001 td -0.037 tc (s.)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 37 17.496 323 23.0401 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 38 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (jim cheney)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 14.134 17.496 21.866 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.1344 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (98)tj et q endstream endobj 15 0 obj << /length 8206 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 72 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 192.366 587.4685 tm 0 0 0 1 k (acknowledgments)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 564.6685 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.004 tw [(the author ackno)19(wledges the pen of anthon)18(y w)93(est)19(on. much of the materi)-1(-)]tj 0 -1.2 td -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(al in the pr)19(esent paper that is dr)18(a)19(wn fr)19(om our co-author)18(ed article \(chene)19(y &)]tj t* 0 tc 0.054 tw [(w)93(est)19(on, 1999\) w)18(as written b)19(y him. mostly)111(, ho)18(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)111(, the author wishes t)18(o)]tj t* 0.111 tw [(ackno)19(wledge the inspir)18(ation and ideas of fir)19(st nations philosopher)19(s that)]tj 0 -1.20001 td 0.007 tw [(inf)19(orm this paper)110(. i do not kno)19(w whether i ha)19(v)18(e serv)19(ed those ideas w)19(ell or)]tj t* -0.022 tc 0.008 tw [(ill, but either w)19(a)19(y it is most cert)18(ainly true that i ha)19(v)19(e not gr)19(asped them in their)]tj 0 -1.2 td 0.015 tc 0.124 tw [(fullness)37(. i ha)18(v)19(e)56(, mor)19(eo)19(v)18(er)111(, used these ideas t)19(o addr)19(ess issues in eur)18(o-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.004 tw [(american envir)19(onment)18(al education and philosoph)19(y)111(, not as the)19(y liv)18(e within)]tj t* 0.039 tw [(fir)19(st nations cultur)18(es)37(. this application of fir)19(st nations ideas has no doubt)]tj t* 0 tw [(tr)19(ansf)18(ormed the ideas themselv)19(es in some measur)19(e)56(. the only true authori)-1(-)]tj t* [(ties on fir)19(st nations thought ar)18(e fir)19(st nations peoples themselv)19(es)36(.)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 185.5769 411.0685 tm 0 0 0 1 k (notes on contributor)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f13 1 tf 10 0 0 10 73 388.2685 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.005 tc -0.01 tw [(jim chene)19(y)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 10 0 0 10 126.8762 388.2685 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.005 tc -0.009 tw [(teaches envir)19(onment)18(al ethics and fir)19(st nations philosoph)19(y and)]tj -5.38762 -1.2 td 0.022 tc 0.182 tw [(liter)19(atur)18(e at the univ)19(er)19(sity of wisconsin\321w)92(auk)19(esha. he has been a)]tj t* -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(r)19(ock)18(efeller f)56(oundation visiting humanities f)56(ello)19(w with the nativ)18(e philosoph)19(y)]tj t* -0.02 tc 0.006 tw [(pr)19(oject at l)18(ak)19(ehead univ)19(er)18(sity in thunder ba)19(y)111(, ont)19(ario (1996-1997) and inau)-1(-)]tj t* 0 tc 0.127 tw [(gur)19(al visiting scholar of ecophilosoph)18(y and earth education at mur)19(doch)]tj t* 0 tw [(univ)19(er)18(sity in w)93(estern a)56(ustr)18(alia (2000). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 11 0 0 11 207.7622 294.6684 tm 0 0 0 1 k (references)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 73 271.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.005 tc 0.134 tw [(abr)19(am, d. (1996). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 146.1774 271.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.005 tc 0.124 tw [(the spell of the sensuous: p)37(er)18(ception and language in a mor)19(e-than-)]tj -6.49146 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw (human w)tj 3.83106 0 td (orld)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 137.5695 259.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55565 0 td 0 tc (ne)tj 1.16602 0 td -0.0003 tc (w)tj 1.03646 0 td (y)tj 0.53118 0 td 0 tc (ork: p)tj 2.49926 0.00001 td [(antheon books)37(.)]tj -13.38498 -1.41178 td 0.115 tw (beck, p)tj 3.17103 0.00001 td 0 tw (.v)tj 0.77784 0 td 0.115 tw (., w)tj 1.79946 0 td 0 tw (alter)tj 1.90699 0 td (s)tj 0.38891 0 td -0.0001 tc (,)tj 0.67058 0 td 0 tc 0.115 tw (a.l., & fr)tj 4.35865 0.00001 td (ancisco, n. \(eds)tj 7.06181 0 td (.\). \(1990\). )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 284.357 247.8685 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.107 tw (the sacr)tj 3.60482 0.00001 td 0 tw (ed)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 323.0207 247.8685 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.67046 0 td (t)tj 0.47616 0 td 0 tc (saile)tj 1.86963 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.67058 0 td 0 tc 0.115 tw (az: na)tj 3.02234 0 td (v)tj 0.4812 0 td 0 tw (ajo)tj -34.48692 -1.41178 td (community college pr)tj 9.73926 0 td (ess)tj 1.31469 0 td (.)tj -13.1716 -1.41177 td (berry)tj 2.24048 0 td -0.0002 tc (,)tj 0.55551 0 td (w)tj 0.81412 0 td -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.55572 0 td 0 tc ((1977). )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 137.0634 223.8685 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the unsettling of america)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 227.8469 223.8685 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.55572 0 td 0 tc (san fr)tj 2.7585 0 td (ancisco: sierr)tj 5.77539 0 td -0.0002 tc (a)tj 0.7777 0 td 0 tc [(club books)37(.)]tj -28.08458 -1.41177 td 0.005 tc (bir)tj 1.21878 0.00001 td 0.134 tw (ch, t)tj 2.16092 0 td 0.0052 tc (.)tj 0.70002 0 td (h.)tj 1.40926 0 td 0.005 tc ((1993). mor)tj 5.26654 0 td (al consider)tj 4.87678 0 td (ability and univ)tj 7.03769 0 td 0 tw (er)tj 0.86184 0.00001 td 0.134 tw (sal consider)tj 5.30794 0 td 0 tw (ation. )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 342.8851 211.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.005 tc (envir)tj 2.22871 0.00001 td (onment)tj 3.13973 0 td (al)tj -35.00198 -1.41177 td 0 tc (ethics)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 112.4119 199.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0003 tc (,)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 117.135 199.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k (15)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 125.9546 199.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k ((4), 3)tj 2.20336 0 td (13-332.)tj -8.43332 -1.41177 td 0.018 tc (chene)tj 2.81167 0 td 0.121 tw [(y)111(, j. (1998). univ)19(er)18(sal consider)19(ation: an epistemological map of the terr)19(ain.)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 91 175.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(envir)19(onment)18(al ethics)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 166.2134 175.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0003 tc (,)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 170.9365 175.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k (20)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 179.7561 175.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k ((3), 265-277.)tj -12.55954 -1.41176 td -0.016 tc (chene)tj 2.64461 0 td 0 tc (y)tj 0.39249 0.00001 td -0.0156 tc (,)tj 0.52642 0 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw (j. (1999). the journe)tj 8.53191 0.00001 td -0.0156 tc (y)tj 0.76737 0 td -0.016 tc 0 tw (home)tj 2.36384 0 td -0.0156 tc (.)tj 0.52634 0 td -0.016 tc 0.002 tw [(in a. w)93(est)18(on (ed.), )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 275.3005 163.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.015 tc 0.001 tw (an invit)tj 3.16314 0 td (ation t)tj 2.58382 0.00001 td -0.0146 tc (o)tj 0.73134 0 td -0.015 tc 0 tw (envir)tj 2.01949 0.00001 td (onment)tj 3.02302 0 td 0.001 tw (al phi-)tj -33.20322 -1.41179 td 0 tc 0 tw [(losoph)19(y)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 120.4283 151.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(\(pp. 14)56(1-167\). oxf)18(or)19(d: oxf)19(or)18(d univ)19(er)19(sity pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj -5.5798 -1.41176 td -0.007 tc -0.007 tw [(chene)19(y)110(, j. & w)93(est)19(on, a. (1999). envir)18(onment)19(al ethics as envir)19(onment)19(al etiquette: t)87(o)19(w)19(ar)18(d)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.024 tc 0.01 tw [(an ethics-based epistemology in envir)19(onment)18(al philosoph)19(y)111(. )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 299.6237 127.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.022 tc 0.009 tw [(envir)19(onment)18(al ethics)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 371.1257 127.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0242 tc (,)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 375.5277 127.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.078 tc (21)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 383.4929 127.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.024 tc ((2),)tj -34.4109 -1.4118 td 0 tc (1)tj 0.395 0 td (15-134. )tj -2.5127 -1.4118 td -0.019 tc 0.005 tw [(deloria, b)37(., f)55(oehner)111(, k., & scint)19(a, s. \(eds)37(.\). \(1999\). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 252.1205 103.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.018 tc 0.004 tw [(spirit & r)19(eason: the vine deloria, jr)110(. r)19(ead)-1(-)]tj -18.9554 -1.4118 td 0 tc 0 tw (er)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 98.0785 91.8684 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.5558 0 td 0 tc (golden, co: fulcrum publishing.)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 226.6436 33.8348 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the moral epistemology of first nations stories)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 395.982 17.496 23.013 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3482 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (99)tj et q endstream endobj 16 0 obj << /length 5345 >> stream /gs0 gs 1 g 0 648 0 0 re f q /gs1 gs 0 0 0 0 k 36 63 324 532.8 re f q /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 37 588.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.009 tc -0.005 tw [(geddes)37(, c. (1996). in a panel discussion b)19(y y)73(uk)19(on fir)19(st nations people on the t)19(opic: what)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.027 tc 0.013 tw [(is a good w)19(a)19(y t)18(o teach childr)19(en and y)18(oung adults t)19(o r)19(espect the land? in b)36(. jickling (ed.),)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 55 564.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (a)tj 0.94426 -0.00001 td 0 tc 0.056 tw [(colloquium on envir)19(onment, ethics)36(, and education)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 242.7315 564.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (\()tj 0.29588 -0.00001 td 0 tc 0.06 tw [(pp. 32-48\). whitehor)19(se: y)73(uk)19(on)]tj -22.38194 -1.41176 td 0 tw [(college)56(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td -0.027 tc 0.013 tw [(hester)111(, l. & chene)18(y)112(, j. (2000). cer)19(emon)-1(ial w)19(orlds and envir)19(onment)19(al sanity)110(.)1( )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 302.2153 540.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.026 tc [(str)19(ategies)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 334.8163 540.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0276 tc (,)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 339.1896 540.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.026 tc (13)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 347.5767 540.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.027 tc ((1),)tj -34.42079 -1.41176 td 0 tc (77-87.)tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td 0.018 tc 0.121 tw [(hester)111(, l. & chene)18(y)112(, j. \(in pr)18(ess\). t)80(ruth and nativ)19(e american epistemology)110(. )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 337.2135 516.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.016 tc (social)tj -33.20159 -1.41176 td 0 tc (epistemology)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 102.2065 504.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k (.)tj -7.67135 -1.41176 td -0.015 tc [(h)-1(e)-1(s)-1(t)-1(e)-1(r)110(,)-1( )-1(l)-1(.)-1(,)-1( )-1(m)-1(c)-1(p)-1(h)-1(e)-1(r)17(son, d., booth, a., & chene)19(y)111(, j. (2000). indigenous w)18(o)-1(r)-1(l)-1(d)-1(s)-1( )-1(a)-1(n)-1(d)-1( )-1(c)-1(a)-1(l)-1(l)-1(i)-1(c)-1(o)-1(t)-1(t)-136(s)]tj 2.11765 -1.41176 td 0 tc [(land ethic)19(. )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 95.6136 480.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(envir)19(onment)18(al ethics)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 170.827 480.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0003 tc (,)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 175.5502 480.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k (22)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 184.3697 480.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k ((3), 273-290.)tj -17.33761 -1.41176 td [(house)56(, f)147(. (1999). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 100.9098 468.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(t)88(otem salmon)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 150.1894 468.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55561 0 td 0 tc [(bost)19(on: beacon pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj -13.87201 -1.41176 td 0.015 tc 0.124 tw [(k)37(uhn, t)130(.s. \(197)36(0\). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 110.1348 456.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.014 tc 0.115 tw [(the structur)19(e of scientific r)18(e)19(v)19(olutions)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 253.0304 456.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k 0.015 tc 0.124 tw ((2nd edition). chicago: the)tj -23.2977 -1.41176 td 0 tc 0 tw [(univ)19(er)18(sity of chicago pr)19(ess)37(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41176 td [(l)19(eopold, a. \(197)37(0\). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 109.1068 432.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (a)tj 0.88868 0 td 0 tc (sand county almanac)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 193.1024 432.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55566 0 td 0 tc [(ne)19(w y)79(ork: ballantine books)37(.)]tj -18.92065 -1.41176 td -0.014 tw [(meek)19(er)110(, j. (1997). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 103.3707 420.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.013 tw [(the comedy of surviv)19(a)1(l)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 186.2864 420.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.014 tw [(\(3r)19(d edition\). t)87(ucson: the univ)19(er)19(sity of ariz)18(ona)]tj -15.44546 -1.41176 td 0 tw [(pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj -2.11765 -1.41177 td (quinn, d. (1992). )tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 103.9022 396.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k (ishmael)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 131.4235 396.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0002 tc (.)tj 0.55566 0 td 0 tc [(ne)19(w y)79(ork: bant)19(am.)]tj -11.6643 -1.41176 td [(r)19(olst)19(on, iii, h. (1988). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 120.7362 384.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k [(envir)19(onment)18(al ethics)]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 194.9971 384.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.55579 0 td 0 tc [(philadelphia: t)88(emple univ)19(er)18(sity pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj -19.14369 -1.41176 td -0.0002 tc (sn)tj 1.07398 0 td 0 tc [(y)19(der)111(, g. (1990). )]tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f5 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 105.0104 372.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k (the pr)tj 2.66626 0 td (actice of the wild)tj et q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f3 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 187.296 372.9874 tm 0 0 0 1 k -0.0001 tc (.)tj 0.55572 0 td 0 tc (san fr)tj 2.7585 0 td [(ancisco: north p)56(oint pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj et 0 0 0 0 k 37 17.496 323 23.0401 re f q /gs2 gs /gs1 gs q bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 38 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (jim cheney)tj et 0 0 0 0 k 14.134 17.496 21.866 23.0401 re f bt /f0 1 tf 8.5 0 0 8.5 15.1344 33.8708 tm 0 0 0 1 k (100)tj et q endstream endobj 17 0 obj << /nums[0<>] >> endobj 18 0 obj << /differences[32/space 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine 65/a 67/c 69/e/f 73/i/j 77/m/n 80/p 82/r/s/t/u 87/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 107/k/l/m/n/o/p 114/r/s/t/u/v/w 121/y 209/emdash] /baseencoding/macromanencoding /type/encoding >> endobj 19 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 5369 /length1 5369 >> stream gurgoi+eurostileregular7 ? ? ea25if.psbm&qjtunhzg'/o4+$ 6w8dvle*  1"xc34: i%e1h3 i ~ x  po:mv$[l{....(##q:.m'u ߳ڡ 'c$p i 6(^2h izaiwwib ?kk{+djo utd6jjtsiprbkkkd+dz#mۭԞ{llh$^mup"}t}iodonq#.}klf.eˍbb9.ucvmqabnmmddȦbapwvddlnw6c">>|!mccm>w>mm}>>ؠvc: t0z)zrs͋i3d0^1t p`@zkkdi'<"*u_uu_p;v *7$ oss3'(weyyer@uqx@ (oy)jkk{՛ї~qu u lgiieg. 6a2Ѧhupvu*"5"]/[  [!6(z)i\[ift"agfy(3Ԥs[u1 1 -p p y,2!ygvvgqd agg yix'ex]guug?-lkk{%w%feex1,ij@4a#-\˙͔Ѓ{{ai pz zi1=mfpv\/^^10^ cs m_  ڳ֠|mmr7 zu4u oh)6.#u u$ pp[$0(&geuuepsmeei"@t.xlgkkfc{!$hmm| 8__u#4ǿ r>]-$8y hwwgbrckj{20ӣt^&!p>uhr q!fgah'>)pwp-fsn@}{xͦ") /🬈diou+-o"&& [.--q?vu%wxkjj.??-5u.* ny|oot9g r[[.>!z)apam`^qwhgwj#/t |{,4{oot8v{5kgfkay amm|+]um0yys85ũ5w. tc^on^}iskj{t:p{lkea-.loo b;os>i[ct}n}n)êt99%cy3˹ʹ n-:llhtnnr?z.g-u9_kk_{f9$aavp.p]''ww"qer&bp.pb7p6x6s9s:qrv7=$p]p0sxugbwhwhxydkxjdxixhx΁ci27ziɜmivk~bu5u$ong}!:iiz36Σ~srzar nsr!/2igssgoq^kjk@a !|hoodp v;b__b@v7ron} st3 p {u c*cqw-kdk ui$b +heuuepgwdch'4 u p[/=yiyyh@r!eii{4%뭻ϣs[}u.u..lnmlxt^nm^m,$?ccmx)xklmam`|: 7"[[$tr^ʿɿ;|mmm+ũ43sm%ydimli<|nbawЭ08tok%!etgsg[tau/noo}Ӳ25}pu`-k)xw9ix))Ťe0.am8m7|bb78a0*qx#⭪by©8>klkldofufui7d+϶8yhh? y8hkhk&qx#geef&x82)eex%w -\[t^_˫f?j iihn e@v2+ heewvmqmlql hpymmmfbì h9lmmk`b:qй@ss[czs*>*j5w;dlkc(|49%ccw4̹*8zk5ul7g)gpa:w8v8xxc9`c9w8x8wwa:'ph6ܞ::6dp*! 2_*'Ѩirpvu+ f#\/k  [$2*z'j[[jgs%>ii{a 豺գr[e;3.9b$ɫ#moo#&.xfe;(uhagg`;z q endstream endobj 20 0 obj << /stemh 0 /capheight 1775 /type/fontdescriptor /flags 32 /descent -512 /ascent 1775 /fontname/gurgoi+eurostileregular /xheight 0 /stemv 0 /fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867] /italicangle 0 /fontfile3 19 0 r >> endobj 21 0 obj << /subtype/type1 /basefont/gurgoi+eurostileregular /lastchar 209 /widths[250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 277 277 0 0 198 0 0 0 613 614 613 613 613 613 613 613 614 614 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 608 0 597 0 498 489 0 0 204 502 0 0 858 696 0 590 0 623 560 515 655 0 999 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 510 511 485 510 502 265 510 514 188 0 430 188 826 516 506 510 0 398 474 326 507 402 670 0 389 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 692] /name/f0 /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 20 0 r /encoding 18 0 r /type/font >> endobj 22 0 obj << /differences[65/a 82/r 97/a/b/c 109/m 114/r/s/t/u 142/eacute] /baseencoding/macromanencoding /type/encoding >> endobj 23 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 1943 /length1 1943 >> stream euuvkn+usherwood-bolditalic@^   /+fvcopyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bold italicitc usherwood "ctusbd3vn  q05ӆrcqtyo ypa[k $fx$yxx\\\ $k{yy\hz[gvnoy $rk-yw+erle{)kǨk}tuacgftaf;<\@?tj[coz쬜dif:(bmoy"od:en4"a)bbl[pdgwcskrgxwȋ%av狱pj~yǘw xuggjk}Ǩ|ȅtxe?&e^:_y2hxcski|opǷov )yn~𑜒}hicenp>4}fccdtpfqsmu\mj $yb]_ɶty|sszu}eegt] $=!v3f?ܽӾy+oy,>nu𚚇oys4pxzj c=y\'(cπ!((ekbs=lgǒp t>a67o{sb\ayƜ ry*w h ztxzuysr}>yw{tx inv<q1u|ب𕯐wqmrob:rrwwzv}n'ljmigȻyrvpi^vv > p zxʘbzopdly} $Ƌtt~v}gnrsviwyqmp|z"gikpn8hab;9sc~f`rng_kssyk> endobj 25 0 obj << /subtype/type1 /basefont/euuvkn+usherwood-bolditalic /lastchar 142 /widths[722 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 685 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 556 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 852 0 0 0 0 463 463 389 593 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 481] /name/f1 /firstchar 65 /fontdescriptor 24 0 r /encoding 22 0 r /type/font >> endobj 26 0 obj << /differences[32/space 44/comma/hyphen/period 67/c/d 70/f/g/h 76/l 78/n/o/p 85/u/v/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 107/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 136/agrave 141/ccedilla/eacute/egrave 213/quoteright] /baseencoding/macromanencoding /type/encoding >> endobj 27 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 6213 /length1 6213 >> stream pdbswq+usherwood-mediumitalic@ww   3/(copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood medium italicitc usherwood,0ofxbzupwjinqsdgtmh'/vle -$(1c7%)86yr.vnq>gd^n  t {  b _(k6l:yȺnyr7rq8 /z.vv* >ch i# -f h's-ykv/-|t?:xlpqqnjcijdĹ~zzzwv~tiy8n:>h{jz{}3k{mt8xnr2 $by% "flwf? `uo5/: p侴#vn0v\_|*f3jdoszx,0`xx}{z{xyx $se* bl1szrvz{wkuw\$bab $Ǝpppnpo $y`p}ws*y%[|y{~{|wthvzlmk $,(q74pݸݻkimra2~kq\hddycvfosxq6.`?-ux{~zq*v/*losxw5&<`y1szrvz{wkuw\$bab $^po}wsydw {arvy{~ȫzmwtz3k{vxwzwd.mllda$wsoknarsykv/w{z3nktttn jjjgdrvywzzhx9:'xd<ɚȜwtls}=sgrrswy5u5v7 $kykv/d$|zehtoyeof $b݋xlpqqnjcijdĹ~zzzwv~ziy@fajjfs~___ $zq/7  ?nwk4yry $eq1i .8{rqԉqpvwwxwwwԄsawtx=x9w@Ѡvhfˆ׵lotzhbz?ay%w!hj=; fctls}=sgrrs{0cztzecg4_;=q;f[wv9c_0z0腷m̆ߋƮbbbeee $scةrc $#}{}mpx{~ $kϵnwdq ehhdob+5~//1qqrqrqwwxwwwtsawtx=x9w@ww $tbeee|an=s $waݓ֕aaaggg $s]vwwl!!Քٔeeecdc $sawtx=x9w@a'a $zxlst $sza i ]ntutpjx $shj&e!e"ctutpjx $sh)un $è§yңݕۚkklfgg $szuuv{du5ed߮䙔Йdddbcb $sr{y{zwcdc[s=tb̵%!q^o\mse-몦wevvw~_e#4b*q܄{p~wtkz|y|uh}}}rn~ʺlkȦby%aw&g<(o҅xyy{x $! "flwf? `uo5/: p侴#vn0v\_|*vwoyf`  endstream endobj 28 0 obj << /stemh 0 /capheight 622 /type/fontdescriptor /flags 98 /descent -254 /ascent 684 /fontname/pdbswq+usherwood-mediumitalic /xheight 694 /stemv 75 /fontbbox[-195 -282 995 857] /italicangle -12 /fontfile3 27 0 r >> endobj 29 0 obj << /subtype/type1 /basefont/pdbswq+usherwood-mediumitalic /lastchar 213 /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 333 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 574 648 0 537 611 667 0 0 0 537 0 648 685 574 0 0 0 0 648 630 944 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 519 426 519 444 333 500 537 278 0 519 259 833 556 519 519 500 426 426 352 556 500 759 537 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 426 444 444 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259] /name/f2 /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 28 0 r /encoding 26 0 r /type/font >> endobj 30 0 obj << /differences[32/space/exclam 38/ampersand 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 63/question 65/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w 89/y/z/bracketleft 93/bracketright 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 164/section 209/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright] /baseencoding/macromanencoding /type/encoding >> endobj 31 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 10196 /length1 10196 >> stream orrjjk+usherwood-book?&x   !'copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bookitc usherwoodosftqdupojcmvignhbeyz*w'/lx&"  4$#+.-(8)5%2iwkr 1[0,f7<>a:36;qw"% wg$ / w ' w u & p1"tiive!b\qn |!;!"j"j""##$w$%o*~Džw@~c{ $p<®vp}}}j^qsyƏ{tnu~]{*yv"dnta?3 róɊܕ\)18?b洝r 'dc]ce:qtyvlvwfw^vӻ\jeganv{{|vr#rr@fi|zz̀arzhl&rϬss^g_-}vs"(sv)i6y1'~pkl{Ŏr1bp""g+_q]t{tnu~x{oy7t4jugq9$psj~y؄~~{u-',56ݰy wtsuylqЅtx`zqv~bm{{y<y4d ';)'.0 s/)8d!?*j}`{ $_~:kn,n $dt{*w=xh{tnu~x{1*wej}_{ $`iċ{tnu~x{ wuuxyttx-y7!wґn$-1/#izh\yq{tnu~x{nm~y#e(9>(=e-wts`{ $_dʏ{tnu~x{1y&wiyu#Ћ{w}u{x{.v@(3s"b-{ms{]{of->ؠijl-:!wj}`{ $_~:kn,n $dt{9@gupdʏ{tnu~x{1㆛2wyؿ $@—؅|ofqÂ̌ȝdo}ud $vda6nuzgvqw"z*i~_{ $`|z,o:u $oy|r7r1r $px~a.7=>urg3:ecpl{tnu~x{1*usk_ntme}]tɡǚgxo{~w{xu~yy@ywy--n.b{t_el)ӈĊupa7fa 4>ǭ{mvl~}{|lnf"@hۻ_22[r=ng*yvam|q~{p~8kmv{{xd}c{fsodo{pqks\y[adjp拵]n`waat2obɸ-y7!w){ w3*7p.`?uyw (d)a̯@j[ɋ{tnu~x{:l-jl蟆 $}vwlr{y~o{ $[`hu袠s{ln ${yizygdljvh}{uqocy ${bo3"c^]zt29}& µwywywy ${fnjdr$Ƅqpqnon ${x2zb+w`jv^o|wwjejю)Ȇ $nq6ܥooonlm ${:69rm*:lr $qryyyvwv ${~uz!qnÆppoooo ${g~Ɇ $fvfw %t[}u!~otxx}yyfki>[5=-=r[yyd-yܰy.90u3'@+nm'+> ,(@v)0osrnԱtw|ˉcr]7if,dew) a*r < b֡ cuorrt~}|||}|j{739rm}vsޥooonlm ${8*_m]v}t^bk=vpxpŴrhsszqry[ctsxyywuuwwuuw`2wuuwwuuw9ކ $ie,d ؿ(kzzzjp`{ $p$täuvvqrr $y^vwvrrr ${/3*ћx}}s3wp2sߥomonnm ${73so\-vdy >zb-/-< 껺takfcڽi#nq24n-vÐwjzyޱ#ȉ0fz~^vpw^ӱ#3l}7wyfxpturx ${97maj"&; =3-xby}|xuj $u#&jr/Ү>d $ʯt+p0 $Υٶdbyyysss ${xbjautd9pyyyyzz ${dnriq8"]lllmml ${u  if9rm{ $nq6ܥomonnm ${:>>ܥooonlm ${:69rm{ $nq-ѱww^^ww $d}eaw|}j~wk~x=`~vȱw%3džva`qpppqp{z{{{{g{zl4oty @"dh'$)$l}}ҵxeinbprfgsdn 7ɏf%ns ce-bp2/=bk! \͠vfkowt{vfpbvpxgtqbjenuuqgtqbjenuubvpxpŴrhsszqry[ctsxqzŴrhsszqry[ctsx-}v3we>k}rl`~}xhfg"‹{tnu~x{#wuuxyttx-y9ÖwvЫy{ $,27_p|uݜˑ*Ƥuyps(popopo&`$h7~k$"mb eͷ{udyvyc@|ww4qh(ik֥̋鋝}}|vvw ${anqs|ac/ (q{|}|zjutwwy}xwgv`lt e %⯨qbyx $ů(c skhi @֋ -ywzn 06 74rwhzh:l "jm8"]-y6yw"[ums5kźyzuyxtyݷ^cy $qt|uxe1Ƿ櫦wzxrpu ${sqbmj\`'sϘpopmmm ${{f6?^-yܰcey+mؾb<5>1gour6b-b 0cۨpi*l`i6d؞]f5gltx;f-!vrhz1{۴swתax ԟ^n{酆~Վ~{t"[jmpkxcxrc;i!w]ai(uѨsaba٩2ğxu?alvab=-:`v $a}|li{~sz{zx} $#0 %93l0hr\muwtonodj[򒮭ppp|{| ${vgy^e) xlllmnm ${ie/jg $բש3g  3sgs3g1l3sngnvpxjgtqbjenuuyvw2  ywutxxstxpw,  ۋpqqpqq ${{l;i [d( )} $\nϋvvvyxy ${lohm>2sk,q_ʋllkhhg ${| =poq\wαzwxov{ $rsȁx5~| $,͚r' %tuuΈuut{z{֌{{{{zm1mi:fx]yߛrrrqqq ${gt;c0$jΙomnnkq ${Ãabk.q6_-vhwwn2r*wcusoeo_k2sij|]y&xfitqı; sheyyf`  endstream endobj 32 0 obj << /stemh 0 /capheight 622 /type/fontdescriptor /flags 34 /descent -254 /ascent 684 /fontname/orrjjk+usherwood-book /xheight 694 /stemv 59 /fontbbox[-101 -307 964 856] /italicangle 0 /fontfile3 31 0 r >> endobj 33 0 obj << /subtype/type1 /basefont/orrjjk+usherwood-book /lastchar 213 /widths[278 278 0 0 0 0 722 0 296 296 0 0 278 278 278 0 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 0 0 0 407 0 630 593 611 704 574 537 630 704 296 296 648 500 815 685 741 574 741 630 519 556 667 611 944 0 611 556 333 0 333 0 0 0 500 556 463 556 500 315 500 556 259 241 519 241 889 574 537 556 556 370 426 315 537 500 759 537 519 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 963 444 444 278 278] /name/f3 /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 32 0 r /encoding 30 0 r /type/font >> endobj 34 0 obj << /differences[32/space 97/a/b/c/d/e 103/g/h/i 108/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v 121/y 142/eacute] /baseencoding/macromanencoding /type/encoding >> endobj 35 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 2943 /length1 2943 >> stream abikde+usherwood-medium?9   %!r bcopyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood mediumitc usherwoodmfstqdubwjpocenihrvzk}pr9&iy m פw $zqrfczkry3 as*yv?htgm62f؜o0e3%$鱢n(h { $z Ϊװl~xmgt_crfczkry3%*n~ty*py{ $ekoiolml $,=\-bӋx\hxʻyfyyy?}v=!͞ϙΔlx+x]7j/vfktriavqrƃx&ceu h׾q e&'y=y!8itio36nۥbqqjlj $5))没ywwwrrotcejrxnh:prohҶã*y{vfb~\m[azw $s~a|a{b~įwrs>xi]ctf3ev@wb͙*zup $uvvtut $rgprr&$ghhllm $r{|0*yv<c ~{vyyu| $/?htgm62fԜo0e3%$鱢n(h w4asr $zrfczkry3uqpuuqpu-y*y!&&/!!0$&&$!'/]/%%^r z $zxۑi65bzo $puo?dfa{} $`|՘z/m[x $t f]5>[zawys8hxzawrfczkry3%*n~r) wznۑi65bzo $puo?> endobj 37 0 obj << /subtype/type1 /basefont/abikde+usherwood-medium /lastchar 142 /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 556 481 556 500 0 500 593 278 0 0 278 889 593 556 574 556 389 426 315 574 500 0 0 537 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500] /name/f4 /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 36 0 r /encoding 34 0 r /type/font >> endobj 38 0 obj << /differences[32/space 38/ampersand 44/comma/hyphen/period 48/zero/one/two/three 53/five 58/colon 65/a 67/c/d/e 71/g/h/i/j/k/l 80/p 82/r/s/t/u/v/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 107/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w 121/y] /baseencoding/macromanencoding /type/encoding >> endobj 39 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 7137 /length1 7137 >> stream fagvnp+usherwood-bookitalic@o`   .*copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporationitc usherwood book italicitc usherwood24upsz"boe$vmnd5if1jg86th*(qx3c,l)-w&7% +r415g <f l k !   wjml%??y[w' v̀qhgt )ri87ig'xϡwwfxnrlz6;+rnλit~~y(wxsrxkoxҌІyx[meaoklnxi…slxwy*ybly0=(1# 0d.ъp73*61mv.o9ؿ=۰ҳoy|yxpb=gh{koyv`fxmdu;y>=awfvvwu|huzh:*b^xwgzy|}ku}țeeh{ig7i3szvɼwʛ~nf̨pooqdf{ $zz!kkjnnm ${pvrl{tv@"hcuy~ $g+yagvl\w}{xxsb}}{|z|ab%3pū}{{`x_~toiztyv8t=Őzu`mahklxqwxz|oz%bw9<-udh{koyvj`fsios"u7*ya2`w|z}y{fӟݚ0Қϡ{cnl}l{dpxhtvhn 7tv}}}gl-%tbr8gq-yڱ6<_os# "jq t. jh|yjqa $g1n)#&îxaaȌ9j|x~{lNjyms}{{zz`odi\y薬k{|~h\~xxjiknokvddǬ{ppdcy֛wqz|oeoyqr{f8$gumwx&yv8tl.ŏ]xsvs*wbi-¸uxnjmndpkwxz|o]򔫔qidtqs@fxmg=cpf{koyvm`fzbcrv7ty:is[=hmg<Үvduvwģ[s0huҽ-խw 4  $uhzex}s} }؁]btyzy?xryv=wŎzkыrvzyzbbpytwxz|oz*du=c1fgmeo_qr{f|l&pliby:nwm:?bi՗Ęv94-c l 3uj(\pvÓ8?x`:o 2] $thk $,ktok؉jf_{{{{_ubm>z?l]yŔpz|oؤžЋk}z}9o~urgmi_newx$wswroz{wxxal@{Ԃvwsxԛ}t}}}̠oun}ctefz}8ndrp2'ad;nnp{|adwo"0d_c7!{nwwwvwv ${ly5kjjo@xxxvvu ${$m% ) $#,+- $wˋ싞q{ryz}| $y~生єkhkono ${cxalqs(k1)@iݡ͘cbdmnm ${_xrurnlm!w$htyb˖$py@ rjd a tb\albĞwyj~wrmhddºǨkh|=n*~w6)y||xwde0,uߨo!tp3em|u\xujp[-=qqmdz[dv8exf $uh6Хfgflkl ${_}~~.6z?wsdyhߘrr|hz|z "{z~uqbb&i[e3kfywmq= #uls 4‹ }vj:fƝ̖k:sm΋'okm9\dkyh{koyv`ftmbzxr{ ${_6ӓhihiii ${dx}e>>Хfgflkl ${_}~~.6z?ws՛p}—~Ûueacm1f{6Τfgflgl ${_}~(6x> endobj 41 0 obj << /subtype/type1 /basefont/fagvnp+usherwood-bookitalic /lastchar 121 /widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 759 0 0 0 0 0 259 315 259 0 519 519 519 519 0 519 0 0 0 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 630 0 556 667 556 0 611 667 296 296 630 519 0 0 0 574 0 630 519 556 648 593 907 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 499 500 426 500 444 315 481 519 278 0 481 259 796 537 500 519 481 389 426 315 519 463 722 0 481] /name/f5 /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 40 0 r /encoding 38 0 r /type/font >> endobj 42 0 obj << /differences[32/space] /baseencoding/macromanencoding /type/encoding >> endobj 43 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 147 /length1 147 >> stream sxmwop+eurostileregular7 ? ? dag!{.... endstream endobj 44 0 obj << /stemh 0 /capheight 1775 /type/fontdescriptor /flags 34 /descent -512 /ascent 1775 /fontname/sxmwop+eurostileregular /xheight 0 /stemv 0 /fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867] /italicangle 0 /fontfile3 43 0 r >> endobj 45 0 obj << /subtype/type1 /basefont/sxmwop+eurostileregular /lastchar 32 /widths[250] /name/f6 /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 44 0 r /encoding 42 0 r /type/font >> endobj 46 0 obj << /differences[32/space 67/c 74/j 101/e 104/h/i 109/m/n 121/y] /baseencoding/macromanencoding /type/encoding >> endobj 47 0 obj << /subtype/type1c /length 1347 /length1 1347 >> stream vbenzn+usherwood-bold@/   "5"copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated. all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bolditc usherwood+jn$ifoz ptwbf}vllܐ’ccffcc $k„h:lm%k^{h|pn[n4w  $v ͒melgoekt3 @avnggnnggnzrr $vfĘ]rmv~ $c|nõĘ]rmv~ $c|\i3> endobj 49 0 obj << /subtype/type1 /basefont/vbenzn+usherwood-bold /lastchar 121 /widths[296 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 630 0 0 0 0 0 0 315 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 0 0 593 296 0 0 0 907 611 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519] /name/f13 /firstchar 32 /fontdescriptor 48 0 r /encoding 46 0 r /type/font >> endobj 50 0 obj << /kids[51 0 r 52 0 r 53 0 r 54 0 r 55 0 r 56 0 r] /type/pages /count 6 /parent 57 0 r >> endobj 51 0 obj << /contents 4 0 r /parent 50 0 r /resources<> /extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 52 0 obj << /contents 5 0 r /parent 50 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 53 0 obj << /contents 6 0 r /parent 50 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 54 0 obj << /contents 7 0 r /parent 50 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 55 0 obj << /contents 8 0 r /parent 50 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 56 0 obj << /contents 9 0 r /parent 50 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 58 0 obj << /kids[59 0 r 60 0 r 61 0 r 62 0 r 63 0 r 64 0 r] /type/pages /count 6 /parent 57 0 r >> endobj 59 0 obj << /contents 10 0 r /parent 58 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 60 0 obj << /contents 11 0 r /parent 58 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 61 0 obj << /contents 12 0 r /parent 58 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 62 0 obj << /contents 13 0 r /parent 58 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 63 0 obj << /contents 14 0 r /parent 58 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 64 0 obj << /contents 15 0 r /parent 58 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 65 0 obj << /kids[66 0 r] /type/pages /count 1 /parent 57 0 r >> endobj 66 0 obj << /contents 16 0 r /parent 65 0 r /resources<>/extgstate<>>> /mediabox[0 0 432 648] /type/page >> endobj 57 0 obj << /type/pages /kids[50 0 r 58 0 r 65 0 r] /count 13 >> endobj 67 0 obj << /type/catalog /pages 57 0 r /pagelabels 17 0 r >> endobj 68 0 obj << /xpressprivate(%%documentprocesscolors: black\n%%endcomments) /producer(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5) /creationdate(20070407161931) /creator(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5) >> endobj xref 0 69 0000000000 65535 f 0000000015 00000 n 0000000059 00000 n 0000000105 00000 n 0000000152 00000 n 0000008287 00000 n 0000016143 00000 n 0000023136 00000 n 0000031171 00000 n 0000038953 00000 n 0000048399 00000 n 0000058970 00000 n 0000066757 00000 n 0000074197 00000 n 0000083326 00000 n 0000089374 00000 n 0000097633 00000 n 0000103031 00000 n 0000103076 00000 n 0000103375 00000 n 0000108827 00000 n 0000109049 00000 n 0000109675 00000 n 0000109805 00000 n 0000111831 00000 n 0000112065 00000 n 0000112415 00000 n 0000112676 00000 n 0000118972 00000 n 0000119202 00000 n 0000119830 00000 n 0000120279 00000 n 0000130560 00000 n 0000130780 00000 n 0000131470 00000 n 0000131627 00000 n 0000134653 00000 n 0000134875 00000 n 0000135309 00000 n 0000135581 00000 n 0000142801 00000 n 0000143029 00000 n 0000143483 00000 n 0000143574 00000 n 0000143802 00000 n 0000144024 00000 n 0000144195 00000 n 0000144324 00000 n 0000145754 00000 n 0000145980 00000 n 0000146345 00000 n 0000146452 00000 n 0000146705 00000 n 0000146909 00000 n 0000147113 00000 n 0000147317 00000 n 0000147521 00000 n 0000149350 00000 n 0000147725 00000 n 0000147832 00000 n 0000148037 00000 n 0000148242 00000 n 0000148447 00000 n 0000148652 00000 n 0000148857 00000 n 0000149073 00000 n 0000149145 00000 n 0000149422 00000 n 0000149491 00000 n trailer << /size 69 /root 67 0 r /info 68 0 r /id[] >> startxref 149666 %%eof