%pdf-1.3
%����
1 0 obj
<<
/type/extgstate
/opm 1
>>
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/type/extgstate
/op true
>>
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/type/extgstate
/op false
>>
endobj
4 0 obj
<<
/length 5135
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
13.5 0 0 13.5 73 585.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental)tj
0 -1.33333 td
(education: some issues for methodology)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
9 0 0 9 73 546.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom, deakin university, australia & )tj
0 -1.33333 td
(lucie sauv\216, universit\216 du qu\216bec \210 montr\216al, canada)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f1 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 505.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(a)19(bstr)19(act)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f2 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 493.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(w)74(e r)19(eflect on methodological issues arising in tw)18(o o)19(f our o)18(wn r)19(esear)18(ch pr)19(oj-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
[(ects as a f)37(orm o)18(f pr)19(actice)36(, as a w)19(ay o)19(f engaging in a pr)18(axis o)19(f pr)18(oject)]tj
t*
[(r)19(esear)19(ch. the pr)18(ojects chosen f)37(or this purpose ar)18(e )1(t)-1(h)1(emselv)18(es concerned)]tj
0 -1.26315 td
[(with teacher education and curriculum de)19(v)18(elopment in envir)19(onment)19(al edu-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
[(cation: the)19(y include participat)18(ory \322r)19(eflectiv)18(e pr)19(actice\323 pr)19(ocesses in e)18(xploring)]tj
t*
[(issues r)19(elating t)18(o f)37(ormal education in schools and inf)36(ormal education in)]tj
t*
[(communities and ar)19(e gr)18(ounded in the specific conte)19(xts o)18(f de)19(v)19(eloping coun-)]tj
t*
[(tries)37(. w)73(e discuss issues in participat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch such as:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 392.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f2 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 99.6667 392.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(whose r)19(esear)18(ch agenda gets t)19(o be e)18(xplor)19(ed?)]tj
-1.29123 -1.26316 td
[<a5>-791(the import)18(ance o)19(f pr)19(oject partner)18(ships)]tj
t*
[<a5>-791(p)37(articipants\325 pr)18(econceptions about the natur)19(e o)18(f r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
t*
[<a5>-791(what is \322rigor\323 in participat)18(ory r)19(esear)19(ch in envir)18(onment)19(al education?)]tj
t*
[<a5>-791(the colonialist dilemma: a)74(v)18(oiding the \322pack)19(age or perish\323 ment)19(ality)]tj
t*
[<a5>-791(the bigger pictur)18(e: t)148(echnocr)19(atic r)36(ationality and p)37(articipat)19(ory r)36(esear)19(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f1 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 311.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r\216sum\216)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f2 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 299.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(nous pr\216sent)19(ons dans cet article un ensemble de r\216fle)18(xions d\325or)19(dr)18(e)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
[(m\216thodologique qui ont \216mer)19(g\216 de notr)18(e pr)19(opr)18(e pr)19(axis de r)18(echer)19(che)37(, en)]tj
t*
[(nous penchant dav)19(ant)18(age sur deux pr)19(ojets que nous av)19(ons men\216s dans un)]tj
t*
[(conte)19(xte de coop\216r)18(ation internationale)37(. ces pr)18(ojets concernent le d\216v)19(eloppe-)]tj
t*
[(ment curriculair)19(e et la f)36(ormation des enseignants et animateur)19(s en \216duca-)]tj
t*
[(tion r)19(elativ)18(e \210 l\325envir)19(onnement ; ils se car)18(act\216risent par un souci de conte)19(x-)]tj
t*
[(tualisation et par l\325adoption d\325un pr)19(ocessus participatif de pr)18(atique r\216fle)19(xiv)19(e)]tj
t*
[(associ\216 \210 l\325e)19(xplor)18(ation de pr)19(obl\216matiques r)18(elativ)19(es \210 l\325\216ducation f)37(ormelle en)]tj
t*
[(milieu scolair)19(e et \210 l\325\216ducation non f)36(ormelle en milieu communaut)19(air)19(e)37(. a la)]tj
0 -1.26315 td
(lumi\217r)tj
2.77613 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.70257 0 td
0 tc
(de ces pr)tj
3.70148 0 td
(ojets)tj
1.9812 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.51763 0 td
0 tc
(nous abor)tj
4.25971 0 td
(dons les questions suiv)tj
9.72046 0 td
(antes qui ont tr)tj
6.57276 0 td
(ait \210)tj
-30.23194 -1.26318 td
(la r)tj
1.42456 0 td
(echer)tj
2.25733 0 td
[(che participativ)19(e en \216ducation r)18(elativ)19(e \210 l\325envir)19(onnement:)]tj
-3.68188 -1.78948 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.29123 0 td
0 tc
0.018 tw
[(le part)19(age des pouv)18(oir)19(s dans le pr)18(ocessus de r)19(echer)19(che : qui d\216cide quo et)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tw
[(pour)19(quoi?;)]tj
-1.29123 -1.26316 td
[<a5>-791(le r\231le et la signification du partenariat de r)18(echer)19(che;)]tj
t*
0.087 tw
[<a5>-791(les conceptions initiales de la r)18(echeche chez les participants : un d\216fi de )]tj
1.2912 -1.2632 td
0 tw
(changement;)tj
-1.2912 -1.2632 td
[<a5>-791(la notion de \307 rigueur \310 : \210 la r)18(echer)19(che de crit\217r)19(es;  )]tj
t*
[<a5>-791(l\325enjeu colonialiste du \307 dumping \310 de mat\216riel de f)36(ormation;)]tj
<a5>'
1.2912 0 td
0.077 tw
(une pr)tj
2.81736 0.00001 td
(obl\216matique globale : la r)tj
10.96964 0.00001 td
[(ationalit\216 technocr)19(atique et la r)18(echer)19(che )]tj
-13.787 -1.2632 td
0 tw
[(participativ)19(e)37(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.496 324 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 176.8514 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(canadian journal of environmental education, 8, spring 2003)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396.994 17.4601 22.992 23.0399 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 402.1426 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(111)tj
/f4 1 tf
1 0 0 1 -1000 1648 tm
1 g
-0.25 tc
( )tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
<<
/length 5864
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 66.9534 587.4685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(towards a praxis of research in environmental education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 564.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(a)37(t v)19(arious times w)18(e ha)19(v)19(e adv)19(ocated the adoption of r)18(eflectiv)19(e pr)19(actice in pr)19(o-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(fessional de)19(v)19(elopment in envir)19(onment)19(al education \(r)18(o)1(b)1(o)1(t)1(t)20(o)1(m)1(,)1( )1(1)1(9)1(9)1(3)1(,)1( )1(2)1(0)1(0)1(0)1(;)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.001 tw
[(r)19(obott)19(om & k)36(yburz-gr)19(aber)111(, 2000; sauv\216 & or)18(ellana, 2002\). w)93(e ha)19(v)19(e been)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(inv)19(olv)18(ed in pr)19(ojects that seek t)19(o pr)18(omulgate such an appr)19(oach. w)93(e belie)18(v)19(e that)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(eflectiv)18(e pr)19(actice is especially import)19(ant in the field of envir)18(onment)19(al edu-)]tj
t*
[(cation, which is \322doubly idiosyncr)19(atic\323: the subject matter)18(s of envir)19(onmen-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
[(t)18(al education ar)19(e socially constructed and tend t)19(o be highly political in)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(natur)19(e; and this in turn poses pedagogical and curricular difficulties in a field)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(whose early hist)19(ory tended t)18(o f)19(a)18(v)19(our the mor)19(e \322objectiv)18(e\323 subject matter)19(s of)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(\(envir)19(onment)18(al\) science content. in envir)19(onment)19(al education, the subject w)18(e)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(ar)19(e engaging educationally is not the envir)18(onment )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 248.837 444.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
0.003 tw
(per se)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 272.7301 444.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0168 tc
(,)tj
0.52518 0 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(but the w)19(eb of r)18(ela-)]tj
-24.0982 -1.2 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(tionships among people and the envir)19(onment \(betw)18(een per)19(sons)37(, their social)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(gr)19(oup, and the envir)18(onment\) \(sauv\216, 200)56(1\). the comple)19(xity of the t)19(ask)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.005 tw
[(calls f)19(or a deep psy)18(cho-social tr)19(ansf)19(ormation, f)18(or the de)19(v)19(elopment of com-)]tj
t*
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(ple)19(x r)18(efle)19(xiv)19(e and action competencies)37(, while most often addr)18(essing v)19(ery com-)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(ple)19(x socio-envir)18(onment)19(al issues which ar)19(e ine)18(vit)19(ably shaped b)19(y human)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.069 tw
[(belief)19(s)37(, v)18(alues)37(, and inter)19(ests)37(. it is the ine)18(vit)19(able pr)19(esence of these human)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(belief)19(s)37(, v)19(alues)36(, and inter)19(ests in the subject matter)19(s of envir)19(onment)19(al education)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(that imposes a special need f)19(or a r)18(eflectiv)19(e f)19(orm of pr)18(ofessional pr)19(actice)56(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(in this article w)19(e wish t)18(o r)19(eflect on tw)19(o of our o)18(wn r)19(ecent r)19(esear)18(ch pr)19(oj-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(ects as a f)19(orm of pr)18(actice\321t)19(o engage in a pr)19(axis of pr)19(oject r)18(esear)19(ch. the pr)19(oj)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(ects that w)tj
4.63093 0 td
(e)tj
0.761 0 td
(ha)tj
1.03127 0 td
[(v)19(e chosen f)18(or this purpose ar)19(e themselv)19(es concerned e)18(xplic-)]tj
-6.4232 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.032 tw
[(itly with teacher education and curriculum de)19(v)18(elopment in envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(education. w)93(e will then consider a number of issues w)18(e ha)19(v)18(e e)19(xperienced t)19(o)]tj
-0.0001 tc
(a)'
0.7778 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(gr)tj
0.85111 0 td
[(eater or lesser e)19(xtent in these pr)18(ojects)37(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 60.7312 243.0685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(australia/south africa institutional links (auslinks) project)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
7 0 0 7 330.9724 245.3785 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 219.2685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(background)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 200.0685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.106 tw
(the pr)tj
2.90235 0 td
(oject, \322educating f)tj
8.11793 0 td
(or socio-ecological change: capacity-building in)tj
-11.02028 -1.20001 td
-0.02 tc
0 tw
(envir)tj
2.16001 0 td
(onment)tj
3.25251 0 td
0.006 tw
(al education, f)tj
5.90275 0 td
(ocussing on south africa\325)tj
10.434 0 td
-0.0197 tc
(s)tj
0.67034 0 td
-0.02 tc
[(tertiary educat)19(or)18(s)37(,\323 w)18(as)]tj
-22.41961 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
(funded b)tj
3.77261 0 td
-0.0097 tc
(y)tj
0.77319 0 td
-0.01 tc
[(a)56(usaid and administer)18(ed b)19(y idp education a)56(ustr)19(alia as one of its)]tj
-4.5458 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.008 tw
[(a)56(ustr)19(alia/south africa institutional links pr)18(ojects)37(. this pr)19(oject t)18(ook place in)]tj
t*
0.059 tw
[(1998 and 1999 within the social/cultur)19(al r)18(econstruction conte)19(xt of imme-)]tj
t*
0.012 tw
[(diately post-apartheid south africa, and inv)19(olv)18(ed six south african tertiary)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.012 tc
0.127 tw
[(institutions \(shingw)19(edzi college)55(, tlhabane college)56(, t)80(shisimane college)56(,)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(univ)19(er)18(sity of v)93(enda, univ)19(er)18(sity of stellenbosch, and rhodes univ)19(er)18(sity\) and)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(tw)19(o a)55(ustr)19(alian univ)19(er)18(sities \(deakin univ)19(er)19(sity and griffith univ)18(er)19(sity\).)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(112)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/length 7353
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 588.135 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(geographical and socio-political context)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 568.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(the significance of the pr)19(oject needs t)18(o be vie)19(w)19(ed against the immediate his-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(t)19(ory of south african social life that e)18(xisted f)19(or se)18(v)19(er)19(al decades thr)18(ough t)19(o the)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(early 90s)37(, just bef)18(or)19(e the beginning of this pr)19(oject. this period of south african)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(hist)19(ory sa)18(w a minority white go)19(v)19(ernment, thr)18(ough the policies of apartheid,)]tj
t*
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(sy)18(stematically oppr)19(ess and den)19(y educational opportunities f)19(or people of colour)111(.)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(education itself w)19(as used as an instrument in de)18(v)19(eloping and maint)19(aining a)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.096 tw
[(set of po)19(w)19(er structur)18(es and r)19(elationships in which people of colour w)19(er)18(e)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(se)19(v)18(er)19(ely disadv)18(ant)19(aged. the a)56(uslinks pr)19(oject w)18(as constructed with a vie)19(w t)18(o)]tj
t*
[(addr)19(essing and perhaps in part r)18(edr)19(essing some of these hist)19(orical inequities)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.008 tw
[(in a small w)19(a)18(y in the particular field of envir)19(onment)19(al education. it w)19(as f)18(or)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(this r)19(eason that participat)18(ory)111(, critical appr)18(oaches t)19(o educational r)19(esear)18(ch w)19(er)19(e)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.068 tw
[(adopted as the theor)19(etical underpinning of the pr)18(oject. it w)19(as felt that an)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(appr)19(oach t)18(o r)19(esear)19(ch that w)18(as char)19(acteriz)19(ed b)19(y the principles of conte)18(xtuality)111(,)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(r)18(esponsiv)19(eness)37(, and critical pr)18(axis w)19(as r)19(equir)18(ed in or)19(der t)19(o cr)18(eate the oppor-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.012 tw
[(tunities f)19(or pr)18(e)19(viously disadv)18(a)-1(n)-1(t)18(a)-1(g)-1(e)-1(d)-1( )-1(p)-1(e)-1(o)-1(p)-1(l)-1(e)-1( )-1(t)18(o)-1( )-1(g)-1(e)-1(n)-1(e)-1(r)18(a)-1(t)-1(e)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1(i)-1(r)-1( )-1(o)17(wn vision of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.021 tw
[(education and t)19(o construct their o)18(wn curriculum in accor)19(d with this vision)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(\(l)19(egr)18(ange)56(, mak)19(ou, neluv)19(alani, r)18(eddy)111(, & r)19(obott)18(om, 1999\). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 349.535 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(guiding principles)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 330.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.062 tw
[(the pr)19(oject w)18(as e)19(xplicitly gr)19(ounded in ideas emer)18(ging fr)19(om the period of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.005 tc
0.133 tw
(methodological debates r)tj
11.28643 0 td
0 tw
(eferr)tj
2.06304 0 td
0.133 tw
(ed t)tj
1.78508 0 td
0.0053 tc
(o)tj
0.95915 0 td
0.005 tc
0 tw
(earlier)tj
2.66656 0 td
0.0053 tc
(.)tj
0.70013 0 td
0.005 tc
0.133 tw
(instead of f)tj
5.20212 0 td
0 tw
(ollo)tj
1.55858 0 td
0.133 tw
(wing a single)tj
-26.22109 -1.20002 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
(defined pr)tj
4.31952 0 td
[(ocess of pr)19(ofessional de)18(v)20(elopment or adopting and adapting a sin-)]tj
-4.31952 -1.20001 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(gle set of e)19(xisting envir)18(onment)19(al educational materials)37(, the appr)18(oach w)19(as t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
(simply w)tj
3.81679 0 td
(ork fle)tj
2.66119 0 td
(xibly within a set of principles concerning pr)tj
18.77064 0 td
(ofessional de)tj
5.48423 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.4703 0 td
-0.011 tc
0 tw
(el-)tj
-31.20315 -1.20002 td
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
(opment that w)tj
6.66954 0 td
[(e)1(r)20(e de)18(v)20(eloped in r)18(e)1(s)1(p)1(o)1(n)1(s)1(e)1( )1(t)20(o the methodological debate)56(.)]tj
-6.66954 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(these principles w)19(er)18(e that pr)19(ofessional de)19(v)19(elopment should be:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 234.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 234.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
[(conte)19(xtual)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 128.5944 234.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.0024 tc
(:)tj
0.6972 0 td
0.002 tc
0.136 tw
[(that pr)19(ofessional de)18(v)19(elopment r)18(espects and r)19(elates closely t)19(o)]tj
-5.03345 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(the particular w)19(orkplaces and w)18(orkplace issues of participants;)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 210.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r)tj
0.3611 0 td
-0.009 tc
(esponsiv)tj
3.50093 0 td
0 tc
(e)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 128.2203 210.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0098 tc
(:)tj
0.53221 0 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
(that the issues e)tj
6.76742 0 td
0 tw
(xplor)tj
2.17341 0 td
-0.004 tw
(ed in the pr)tj
4.87145 0 td
[(ofessional de)19(v)18(elopment pr)19(ocess-)]tj
-18.64137 -1.26317 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(es ar)19(e those of inter)18(est and concern t)19(o participants themselv)19(es;)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 186.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(emer)19(gent)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 123.7881 186.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(:)tj
0.6146 0 td
0 tc
0.059 tw
[(that the pr)19(ofessional kno)18(wledge that carries most w)19(eight in dis-)]tj
-4.44493 -1.26316 td
0.003 tw
[(cussions about ho)19(w t)18(o impr)19(o)19(v)19(e pr)18(ofessional pr)19(actice is that which emer)19(ges)]tj
t*
0.038 tw
[(fr)19(om the case study w)18(ork lying at the centr)19(e of the pr)19(ofessional self-de)18(v)19(el-)]tj
0 -1.26315 td
0 tw
[(opment pr)19(ocess;)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 138.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
(participat)tj
3.99895 0.00001 td
(ory)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 138.3535 138.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
(:)tj
0.54 0 td
-0.012 tw
(that participants ar)tj
8.12237 0.00001 td
(e)tj
0.76201 0 td
[(inv)19(olv)18(ed dir)19(ectly and as equit)19(ably as pos-)]tj
-14.7879 -1.26316 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
(sible in all dimensions of the pr)tj
13.161 0.00001 td
[(ofessional de)19(v)18(elopment pr)19(ocess \(f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample:)]tj
-13.161 -1.2632 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(identifying issues t)19(o be addr)18(essed; collection and analy)19(sis of case study)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(dat)19(a; de)18(v)19(elopment and dissemination of materials and r)19(eports\);)]tj
-1.5158 -1.2632 td
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 90.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
(critical)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 114.8026 90.335 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
(:)tj
0.6968 0 td
0.137 tw
(that the pr)tj
4.81607 0.00001 td
[(ocesses of pr)19(ofessional de)18(v)19(elopment look be)19(y)18(ond the)]tj
-8.3974 -1.2632 td
0 tc
-0.013 tw
[(surf)19(ace la)18(y)19(er)19(s of activity at the le)19(v)18(els of polic)19(y)111(, or)19(ganiz)19(ation, and p)-1(r)19(actice t)19(o)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
395.987 17.496 23.492 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1405 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(113)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 120.2524 33.8347 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental education: some issues)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/length 6232
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 588.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(identify and appr)19(aise the v)18(alues)37(, assumptions)37(, and inter)19(ests that inf)18(orm)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
(and justify this activity; and)tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 564.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
[(pr)19(axiological)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 100.1353 564.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0211 tc
(:)tj
0.52085 0 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(that pr)19(ocesses of pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)19(elopment pr)19(oceed thr)19(ough and)]tj
-5.65088 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0.094 tw
[(ar)19(e mediated b)18(y )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 123.568 552.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(pr)19(axis)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 148.364 552.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.094 tw
[(\321defined in this pr)19(oject as a r)18(eflectiv)19(e inter)19(action)]tj
-10.20674 -1.26316 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(betw)19(een per)18(sonal pr)19(ofessional theory)111(, per)18(sonal pr)19(ofessional pr)19(actice)55(, and the)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(pr)19(ofessional settings within which these ar)18(e intelligible \(r)19(obott)19(om & k)36(yburz-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(gr)19(aber)110(, 2000\). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 488.9036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(main processes and representative activities)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 469.7036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(the o)19(v)18(er)19(all f)18(ocus of the a)56(uslinks pr)19(oject w)18(as on the pr)19(ofessional de)19(v)18(elopment)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.029 tw
[(of ne)19(w and e)18(xisting envir)19(onment)19(al education st)18(aff in participating tert)1(iary)]tj
t*
0.02 tw
[(institutions)37(. the part of the pr)18(oject being r)19(eported her)19(e sought t)18(o enhance)]tj
t*
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch and pr)18(ofessional capacity b)19(y w)19(orking with colleagues in a pr)18(ocess)]tj
t*
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[(of w)19(orkplace-based participat)18(ory r)19(esear)18(ch ai)1(med at the de)18(v)19(elopment of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(original case studies of changing envir)19(onment)18(al education pr)19(actice)56(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(the pr)19(ocess b)18(y which the pr)19(oject w)19(as enacted is e)19(xplained in a paper pr)18(e-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(sented b)19(y pr)18(oject participants at the 1999 annual confer)19(ence of their nation-)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(al pr)19(ofessional association \(the envir)18(onment)19(al education association of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.004 tw
[(southern africa\): essentially)111(, it inv)18(olv)19(ed participants in the de)19(v)19(elopment of)]tj
t*
0.013 tc
0.125 tw
[(illustr)19(ated case studies of envir)18(onment)19(al and envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.122 tw
[(issues of inter)19(est and concern t)18(o them as pr)19(ofessionals in the field. the)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(pr)19(ocess of de)18(v)19(elopment of these case studies comprised a series of w)19(orkshops)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(in which participants pr)19(ogr)18(essiv)19(ely constructed, critiqued, and r)19(e)18(vised their)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(illustr)19(ated case studies)36(. a featur)19(e of these case studies is their div)19(er)18(sity and)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(conte)19(xtuality \(l)18(egr)19(ange et al., 1999\). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.012 tc
0.127 tw
[(this participat)19(o)1(r)1(y)1( )1(r)19(esear)19(ch pr)19(oject r)18(esulted in se)19(v)19(er)19(al v)18(aluable out-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(comes)37(, including:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 241.7037 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
(gr)tj
0.85107 0 td
(eater capacity and confidence on the part of man)tj
21.37012 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(y)tj
0.79661 0 td
0 tc
(pr)tj
0.907 0 td
(oject participants; )tj
-25.44059 -1.26317 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
0.04 tw
(the gr)tj
2.53968 0 td
[(eater a)19(v)19(ailability in south africa of materials and r)18(esour)19(ces fr)18(o)1(m the)]tj
-2.53968 -1.26316 td
(a)tj
0.57397 0 td
0 tw
(ustr)tj
1.62866 0 td
(alian conte)tj
4.72144 0 td
(xt; )tj
-8.43986 -1.26317 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
(the de)tj
2.61926 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.47067 0 td
-0.011 tc
(elopment b)tj
4.81788 0 td
-0.0106 tc
(y)tj
0.77233 0 td
-0.011 tc
(south africans of ne)tj
8.51924 0 td
0 tc
(w)tj
0.63742 0 td
-0.0106 tc
(,)tj
0.53136 0 td
-0.011 tc
[(conte)19(xtually r)18(ele)19(v)18(ant materials in)]tj
-18.36817 -1.26318 td
0 tc
0 tw
(south africa f)tj
5.85156 0 td
(or south africans; )tj
-7.36735 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
(the est)tj
3.0172 0 td
(ablishment, e)tj
6.00633 0 td
(xtension, and deepening of collegial and intellectual)tj
-9.02353 -1.26317 td
0 tc
0 tw
(netw)tj
2.1289 0 td
(orks; and )tj
-3.64469 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
0.006 tw
[(o)19(v)19(er)18(all a gr)19(eater sense of what can be achie)19(v)19(ed thr)18(ough collabor)19(ativ)19(e colle-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0.011 tc
0.128 tw
[(gial w)19(ork inv)18(olving r)19(epr)19(esent)18(ativ)19(es fr)19(om a r)18(ange of tertiary institutions)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(acr)tj
1.31397 -0.00001 td
(oss south africa. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 109.7036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.027 tc
0.004 tw
[(link)19(ages ha)18(v)19(e been est)19(ablished among a wide r)18(ange of south africans)37(, and the)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
0.009 tw
(participating a)tj
6.1603 0 td
[(u)1(s)1(t)1(r)20(alian partner)18(s)38(, in a field wher)18(e such link)19(ages did not e)19(x)1(i)1(s)1(t)]tj
-6.1603 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
0.132 tw
[(bef)19(or)18(e the pr)19(oject, enabling all the out)19(comes mentioned abo)18(v)19(e)56(, but also)]tj
t*
-0.035 tc
0.012 tw
[(enabling the less t)19(angible benefits of enhanced f)18(ormal and inf)19(ormal pr)19(of)-9(e)-9(s)-9(s)-9(i)-9(o)-9(n)-9(a)-9(l)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(114)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/length 6807
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tw
[(and academic conv)19(er)18(sations among colleagues)37(. import)19(antly)110(, since the con-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.003 tw
[(clusion of this pr)19(oject, a number of south african pr)18(oject participants ha)19(v)19(e)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(adv)19(anced t)19(o positions of r)18(esponsibility in the fields of curriculum de)19(v)19(elopment)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(and pr)19(ofessional de)18(v)19(elopment in south african envir)19(onment)19(al education.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 181.9829 519.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(the edamaz project )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
7 0 0 7 281.7241 521.6716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 495.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(a)tj
0.858 0 td
(university partnership for community-based environmental education )tj
-0.58168 -1.30001 td
(and research)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 463.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tc
0.138 tw
[(ed)56(amaz \(envir)18(onment)19(al education in amaz)19(onia\) is a univ)18(er)19(sity partner-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.137 tw
[(ship pr)19(oject, which associates the univ)18(er)19(sit\216 du qu\216bec \210 montr\216al with)]tj
t*
0.01 tc
0.123 tw
[(thr)19(ee l)18(atin-american institutions: the univ)19(er)19(sidad gabriel-r)18(en\216-mor)19(eno)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.007 tw
[((bolivia), univ)19(er)18(sidade f)56(eder)19(al de mat)18(o gr)19(osso \(br)19(azil\), and univ)18(er)19(sidad de la)]tj
t*
-0.031 tc
0.012 tw
[(amaz)19(on\222a \(colombia\). the main phase \(1996-200)56(1\) has been financed b)18(y cid)56(a)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.017 tw
[(\(the canadian international de)19(v)18(elopment agenc)19(y\), in the fr)18(ame)19(w)19(ork of the)]tj
t*
0.012 tc
0.121 tw
[(a)55(ucc\325)37(s \(association of colleges and univ)19(er)19(sities of canada\) univ)18(er)19(sity)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.012 tw
[(p)55(artner)19(ship in cooper)19(ation and de)18(v)19(elopment pr)19(ogr)18(am. with the purpose of)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.007 tw
[(assisting amaz)19(onian populations de)18(v)19(elop competencies that pr)19(omote critical)]tj
t*
-0.015 tc
-0.005 tw
[(inv)19(olv)18(ement in the r)19(esolution of socio-envir)19(onment)19(al pr)18(oblems and in )1(ecode-)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.012 tw
[(v)19(elopment initiativ)19(es)36(, the pr)19(oject consisted of cr)19(eating pr)18(ogr)19(ams f)19(or the pr)19(o-)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0 tw
[(fessional de)19(v)19(elopment of pr)18(ofessor)19(s)37(, teacher)19(s)37(, and other educat)19(or)19(s in the field)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.001 tw
[(of envir)19(onment)18(al education, pa)19(ying particular attention t)19(o the gender issue)55(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(thr)19(ee types of pr)18(ogr)19(ams w)19(er)18(e de)19(v)19(eloped: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 283.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
-0.014 tw
(an international pr)tj
8.02601 0 td
0 tw
(ogr)tj
1.38794 0 td
-0.014 tw
(am f)tj
1.94904 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(or)tj
1.17086 0 td
0 tc
(the member)tj
5.3195 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(s)tj
0.6899 0 td
0 tc
(of the f)tj
3.04663 0 td
(our univ)tj
3.55841 0.00001 td
0 tw
(er)tj
0.85107 0 td
-0.014 tw
(sity teams par-)tj
-25.99937 -1.26318 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(ticipating in the pr)tj
7.85472 0 td
(oject, t)tj
2.87435 0 td
-0.0029 tc
(o)tj
0.79809 0 td
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(de)tj
1.03157 0.00001 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.47845 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(elop competencies in curriculum design, pr)19(o-)]tj
-13.03718 -1.26317 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(gr)19(am management, and r)18(esear)19(ch in the field of envir)19(onment)19(al education; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.027 tc
(univ)tj
1.74497 0 td
(er)tj
0.79815 0 td
0.013 tw
(sity on-campus pr)tj
7.31522 0 td
0 tw
(ogr)tj
1.30855 0 td
0.013 tw
(ams f)tj
2.26891 0 td
(or educat)tj
3.81077 0 td
[(or)19(s who wish t)18(o become pedagogical)]tj
-17.24657 -1.26318 td
0 tc
0.018 tw
(or socio-cultur)tj
6.1453 0 td
(al leader)tj
3.68484 0 td
(s\321or f)tj
2.88748 0 td
[(acilit)19(at)18(or)19(s\321in the field of envir)19(onment)18(al edu-)]tj
-12.71762 -1.26317 td
0 tw
(cation; and )tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
(dist)tj
1.53662 0 td
0.072 tw
(ance education pr)tj
7.88368 0 td
0 tw
(ogr)tj
1.38795 0 td
0.072 tw
(ams \(in differ)tj
5.93862 0 td
(ent rur)tj
2.99653 0 td
[(al and poor urban z)19(ones\) f)18(or)]tj
-19.7434 -1.26318 td
0.004 tc
0 tw
(teacher)tj
3.21296 0 td
0.0038 tc
(s)tj
0.84658 0 td
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
(who wish t)tj
5.0126 0 td
0.0039 tc
(o)tj
0.95773 0 td
0.004 tc
[(integr)19(ate envir)18(onment)19(al education int)19(o their daily)]tj
-10.02986 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(pr)19(actice)55(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 163.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tw
(these thr)tj
4.03402 0 td
(ee types of pr)tj
5.89772 0 td
[(ogr)19(ams ar)18(e closely r)19(elated: the member)19(s of the uni-)]tj
-9.93174 -1.20001 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(v)19(er)18(sity teams set up the conditions f)19(or the pedagogical or socio-cultur)19(al)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(l)-1(e)-1(a)-1(d)-1(e)-1(r)18(s \(or f)18(acilit)19(a)-1(t)18(or)18(s\) t)19(o engage in pr)19(ofessional de)19(v)18(elopment; the f)19(aci)2(l)2(i)2(t)20(a)2(t)21(o)2(r)20(s)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.021 tw
(in their turn accompan)tj
9.92458 0.00001 td
-0.0029 tc
(y)tj
0.81179 0 td
-0.003 tc
(the teacher)tj
4.82329 0.00001 td
-0.0029 tc
(s)tj
0.7187 0 td
-0.003 tc
(in the pr)tj
3.68219 0.00001 td
(ocess of integr)tj
6.25698 0.00001 td
[(ating envir)19(on-)]tj
-26.2175 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.005 tw
[(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)18(al education in their o)18(wn \322school-community\323 conte)19(xt. what is learned)]tj
t*
[(at an)19(y le)18(v)19(el of this integr)18(ated pr)19(ocess is thus r)19(einv)19(ested in the other le)18(v)19(els)36(. in)]tj
t*
-0.004 tw
(terms of quantit)tj
6.73689 0.00001 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.5054 0.00001 td
-0.0125 tc
(e)tj
0.74866 0 td
(r)tj
0.33881 0.00001 td
-0.013 tc
(esults)tj
2.33317 0.00001 td
-0.0125 tc
(,)tj
0.52673 0 td
-0.012 tc
-0.004 tw
[(the ed)56(a)1(m)1(a)1(z)1( )1(p)1(r)20(oject de)18(v)19(eloped 7 pr)19(o)1(g)1(r)20(ams and)]tj
-12.1897 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0.041 tw
[(r)19(eached mor)18(e than 900 pr)19(ofessor)19(s and 1)161(1,450 c)-3(h)-3(i)-3(l)-3(d)-3(r)15(e)-3(n)-3(,)-3( )-3(t)-3(h)-3(e)-3(i)-3(r)-3( )-3(p)-3(a)-3(r)16(e)-3(n)-3(t)-3(s)34(,)-3( )-3(a)-3(n)-3(d)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(other member)19(s of their community)110(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 119.5884 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental education: some issues)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.153 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(115)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/length 6977
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 588.135 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(guiding principles)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 568.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(the main guiding principles f)19(or this pr)18(oject ar)19(e pr)19(esented, r)18(ecognizing the dif-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(fer)19(ent dimensions of the pr)18(oject: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 533.9351 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(ed)56(amaz as an internal cooper)18(ation initiativ)19(e; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(as)tj
1.20361 0 td
(a)tj
0.77774 0 td
0 tc
[(pr)19(ofessional de)18(v)19(elopment pr)19(ocess; and )]tj
-3.49714 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(as)tj
1.20359 0 td
(a)tj
0.77773 0 td
0 tc
[(r)19(esear)18(ch pr)19(oject.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 486.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
(ed)tj
1.19732 0 td
-0.002 tw
[(amaz as an international cooper)19(ation initiativ)18(e adopts the main f)19(ollo)19(wing)]tj
-1.19732 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
(principles:)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 451.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(the endogenous char)19(acter of the pr)18(oject: the desir)19(e t)19(o pr)18(omote envir)19(on-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
-0.005 tw
[(ment)19(al education came fr)18(om the l)19(atin-american partner)19(s\321the pr)19(oject w)18(as)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(collectiv)19(ely designed; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.037 tc
-0.005 tw
[(the pr)19(ocess of learning partner)19(ships r)18(ather than one of e)19(xperts deliv)19(ering tr)18(aining;)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26315 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
(the import)tj
4.36684 0 td
[(ance of v)19(aluing the multicultur)19(al, multidisciplinary)110(, multilingual con-)]tj
-4.36684 -1.26316 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(te)19(xt of the pr)18(oject, as a rich div)19(er)19(sity and as a crucible f)19(or the emer)19(gence of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(kno)19(wledge)55(, under)19(st)19(anding, and kno)18(w-ho)19(w; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(the import)19(ance of pr)18(omoting solidarity in sharing r)19(esponsibilities; and)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(the long lasting effects and impacts of the pr)19(oject out)18(comes)37(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 332.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
(ed)tj
1.20937 0 td
-0.008 tw
(amaz as a pr)tj
5.6987 0 td
[(ofessional de)19(v)19(elopment pr)18(ocess implies the adoption of the)]tj
-6.90807 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(f)19(ollo)19(wing integr)18(ated main appr)19(oaches: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 297.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.024 tc
(an )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 64.8862 297.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.023 tc
0.01 tw
[(e)18(xperiential learning)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 144.564 297.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(appr)19(oach, which implies learning about curricular)111(, ped-)]tj
-9.80674 -1.26316 td
0.008 tc
0.131 tw
(agogical, or str)tj
6.72064 0 td
(ategic aspects and issues of envir)tj
15.27466 0 td
[(onment)19(al education b)18(y)]tj
-21.99531 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0.012 tw
[(assuming the r)19(efle)18(xiv)19(e t)19(ask of conceiving and e)18(xperimenting with envir)19(on-)]tj
t*
-0.006 tw
[(ment)19(al education pr)18(ojects)37(. the assumption is that an endogenous and con-)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
0 tw
(te)tj
0.78875 0 td
-0.01 tw
(xtually appr)tj
5.07554 0 td
[(opriate theory of envir)19(onment)19(al education can emer)18(ge fr)19(om a)]tj
-5.86428 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(efle)19(xiv)18(e st)19(ance in and on action, as a f)19(orm of pr)18(axis)37(.)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(a)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 60.7018 225.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(collabor)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 114.2914 225.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.071 tw
[(appr)19(oach: because of the comple)18(xity of the envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
-6.62015 -1.26316 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
(issues and because of the need f)tj
13.65242 0 td
[(or inter)19(disciplinary w)18(ork, pr)19(ofessional de)19(v)19(el-)]tj
-13.65242 -1.26316 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(opment in envir)19(onment)18(al education calls f)19(or a collegial pr)19(ocess)37(, in which par)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(ticipants combine their t)19(alents)37(, e)18(xperience)56(, and kno)19(wledge)56(, so as t)18(o help each)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(other t)19(o de)18(v)19(elop competencies in the field of envir)19(onment)19(al education. )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0099 tc
(a)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 59.8 165.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
(community)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 105.6868 165.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(appr)19(oach: envir)18(onment)19(al education implies opening the school)]tj
-5.7144 -1.26315 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(t)18(o)19(w)18(ar)19(ds the community and inviting community member)19(s t)18(o w)19(ork t)19(ogether)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(t)19(o solv)19(e envir)18(onment)19(al pr)19(oblems or t)18(o conduct eco-de)19(v)19(elopment pr)19(ojects)36(. it)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.029 tw
(is a matter of str)tj
7.24293 0.00001 td
(engthening the cultur)tj
9.27905 0.00001 td
(al identity and sense of belonging t)tj
15.32008 0.00001 td
(o)tj
-31.8421 -1.2632 td
0.053 tw
[(community and place)56(, and of enhancing the ecological as w)19(ell as)-1( the eco-)]tj
t*
0.01 tw
(nomical conditions of the shar)tj
13.1662 0.00001 td
(ed \322home of life)tj
6.95424 0.00001 td
[(.\323 in this per)19(spectiv)18(e)56(, educa-)]tj
-20.1204 -1.2632 td
(t)tj
0.2961 0 td
0 tw
(or)tj
0.8879 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(s)tj
0.7038 0 td
0 tc
(become community leader)tj
11.62896 0.00001 td
-0.0002 tc
(s)tj
0.70356 0 td
(f)tj
0.2962 0.00001 td
0 tc
(or envir)tj
3.36841 0.00001 td
(onment)tj
3.36987 0.00001 td
[(al r)19(eflection and action.)]tj
-22.7707 -1.2632 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.5158 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(a)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 60.038 81.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(critical)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 89.9443 81.935 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tw
[(appr)19(oach t)18(o)19(w)19(ar)19(d the social, envir)19(onment)18(al, and educational r)19(eali-)]tj
-4.0573 -1.2632 td
0.014 tw
(ties of the pr)tj
5.5039 0 td
0 tw
(oject\325)tj
2.29663 0.00001 td
-0.0003 tc
(s)tj
0.71724 0 td
0 tc
0.014 tw
[(o)19(wn milieu, so as t)18(o identify the possibilities and limits)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(116)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/length 6390
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 588.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(encounter)19(ed in tr)18(ansf)19(orming pr)19(oblematic situations)37(. p)55(articularly)111(, ther)19(e is a need)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0.01 tc
0.129 tw
[(t)19(o identify and appr)18(aise the deep r)19(oots and concr)19(ete manifest)19(ations of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(oppr)19(ession and inequity)110(, so as t)19(o adequately addr)19(ess these issues)36(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 540.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.046 tc
0.01 tw
[(ed)56(amaz, as a r)18(esear)19(ch pr)19(oject, aimed at enhancing participant univ)19(er)18(sities\325 capac-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.031 tc
-0.005 tw
[(ities in educational r)19(esear)18(ch, adopts the f)19(ollo)19(wing interr)19(elated guiding principles:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 504.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(r)18(esear)19(ch t)19(o be integr)19(ated with pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)18(elopment and teacher)19(s\325 edu-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(cation activities)37(, and with field educational interv)19(ention. f)56(our main types of)]tj
t*
[(r)18(esear)19(ch w)19(er)18(e conducted: diagnosis r)19(esear)19(ch, action-r)19(esear)18(ch, de)19(v)18(e)-1(l)-1(o)-1(p)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch, and e)18(v)19(aluativ)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch;)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch t)18(o be participat)19(ory)111(, conducted collabor)19(ativ)18(ely b)19(y the main act)19(or)18(s of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.032 tw
[(the situation \(in this case)56(, pr)18(ofessor)19(s)37(, teacher)19(s)37(, and other educat)19(or)18(s\) as co-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s \(her)19(on, 1998; l)19(ammerink & w)92(olffer)19(s)37(, 1998\);)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(r)19(esear)18(ch t)19(o be community-based, addr)18(essing community issue)1(s and inviting)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(community member)19(s)1( )1(t)19(o participate in the r)19(esear)19(ch activities)37(,)1( )1(s)1(o)1( )1(a)1(s)1( )1(t)19(o)1( )1(e)1(n)1(s)1(u)1(r)20(e)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(their r)19(ele)18(v)19(ance)56(, enrich the r)19(esults)37(, and optimiz)18(e the out)19(comes; and)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(r)18(esear)19(ch t)19(o be critical, essentially inter)18(subjectivist, dialectical, and dialogical,)]tj
t*
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
(oriented t)tj
4.35836 0 td
0 tc
(o)tj
0.52197 0 td
(w)tj
0.74388 0 td
0.004 tc
0 tw
(ar)tj
0.85888 0 td
0.135 tw
[(ds the tr)19(ansf)18(ormation \(impr)19(o)19(v)19(ement\) of the conditions of)]tj
-6.48309 -1.26317 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(per)19(sons)36(, social gr)19(oups)37(, and situations \(r)18(obott)19(om & hart, 1993\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 333.9036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(main strategy and activities)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 314.7036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.005 tw
(in its cor)tj
3.78569 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.78273 0 td
0 tc
(international cooper)tj
8.74344 0 td
[(ation pr)19(ocess as w)18(ell as in the differ)19(ent pr)19(o-)]tj
-13.31186 -1.20001 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(fessional de)19(v)19(elopment pr)18(ogr)19(ams)37(, ed)56(amaz adopted the main macr)18(o-str)19(ate-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.0001 tc
(gy)tj
1.28637 0 td
0 tc
-0.01 tw
(of the learning community)tj
11.41278 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.54533 0 td
0 tc
(this str)tj
3.15569 0 td
(ategy essentially inv)tj
8.6827 0 td
0 tw
(olv)tj
1.25904 0 td
-0.01 tw
(es structuring)tj
-26.34191 -1.20001 td
0.0017 tc
(a)tj
0.91846 0 td
(w)tj
0.74214 0 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(orking gr)19(oup and cr)18(eating conditions f)19(or learning t)19(ogether ar)18(ound a)]tj
-1.6606 -1.20001 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(common pr)19(oject that has significance f)19(or the participants)-1( and r)19(ele)19(v)19(ance f)19(or)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.005 tw
(the conte)tj
4.01321 0 td
(xt and is aimed at change: changes among the participants\325 pr)tj
26.94606 0 td
0 tw
(ac)tj
0.96289 0 td
(-)tj
-31.92216 -1.20001 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(tices and/or in their pr)19(ofessional or institutional conditions \(or)18(ellana, 2002;)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(sauv\216 & or)19(ellana, 2002\).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.037 tc
0.012 tw
(the main activities of the numer)tj
12.96133 0 td
(ous and div)tj
4.59604 0 td
0 tw
(er)tj
0.77665 0 td
0.012 tw
(se learning communities \(con)tj
11.78791 0 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92193 -1.20001 td
-0.029 tc
0.004 tw
[(sider)19(ed also as r)18(esear)19(ch communities\) de)19(v)18(eloped in the conte)19(xt of ed)55(amaz ar)19(e)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.023 tc
-0.002 tw
[(w)19(orkshops and gr)18(oup discussions concerning f)19(or e)19(x)18(ample the eco-diagnosis of)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.012 tw
(the milieu, the critical analy)tj
11.5731 0 td
(sis of social, envir)tj
7.39435 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.29461 0 td
-0.012 tw
[(al or educational issues)37(,)]tj
-22.26206 -1.20001 td
-0.011 tc
-0.002 tw
(the conception, implement)tj
11.40268 0 td
[(ation and e)19(v)19(aluation of pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)19(elopment)]tj
-11.40268 -1.2 td
-0.028 tc
0.003 tw
[(or envir)19(onment)18(al education pr)19(ojects and pr)19(ogr)18(ams)37(, and finally)111(, communication)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
0 tw
(so as t)tj
2.66245 0.00001 td
-0.0112 tc
(o)tj
0.79251 0 td
-0.011 tc
[(diffuse)56(, shar)18(e)56(, and discuss the r)19(esults of their r)19(eflection and w)19(ork. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 125.4878 114.1036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(issues in the conduct of participatory research)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 91.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
-0.01 tw
[(nothing is easy in participat)19(ory pr)18(oject r)19(esear)19(ch; in part, it is a matter of bal)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0 tw
[(ancing opportunities and constr)19(aints while oper)18(ating fle)19(xibly within a set of)]tj
t*
-0.029 tc
0.009 tw
[(guiding principles based on cert)19(ain epistemological, ont)18(ological, and ideological)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 119.5884 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental education: some issues)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.153 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(117)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/length 7141
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(assumptions which themselv)19(es need t)19(o be subject t)18(o continuing appr)19(aisal. in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(this section w)19(e intend t)18(o r)19(eflect on the e)19(xperiences of these pr)18(ojects and t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(pr)19(esent some of the issues w)18(e ha)19(v)19(e f)18(ound t)19(o be associated with participat)19(ory)111(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(collabor)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 524.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(whose research agenda?)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 505.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(one of the distinctiv)19(e featur)18(es of participat)19(ory r)19(esear)19(ch is its f)18(ocus on issues)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(of inter)19(est and concern t)18(o participants themselv)19(es)37(. p)56(erhaps unlik)18(e some other)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(f)18(orms of educational r)19(esear)19(ch whose claims f)19(or rigor depend in part on con-)]tj
t*
[(scious attempts t)19(o r)18(et)19(ain a de-politiciz)19(ed per)18(spectiv)19(e in the oper)19(ations of the)]tj
t*
0.008 tc
0.131 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch, participat)18(ory r)19(esear)19(ch is una)18(v)19(oidably political and necessarily)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(politiciz)19(ed. p)55(articipat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch pr)19(offer)19(s itself as an agenc)18(y f)19(or \322inside\323 pr)18(oj-)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(ect participants t)19(o addr)18(ess e)19(xisting po)19(w)19(er r)18(elationships that ma)19(y be per)19(ceiv)18(ed)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(as inequit)19(able in one sense or another)111(. p)55(articipat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch has an inter)19(est)]tj
-0.0114 tc
(in)'
1.07422 0 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(internalizing the locus of contr)19(ol o)18(v)19(er the r)19(esear)19(ch agenda b)19(y encour)18(aging)]tj
-1.07422 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(participants t)19(o dir)18(ect the r)19(esear)19(ch t)18(o)20(w)19(ar)19(ds issues of inter)18(est and concern t)19(o)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(themselv)19(es \(hart, r)18(obott)19(om, & t)148(a)18(ylor)111(, 1994\). a r)19(ele)18(v)19(ant methodological)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(question concerns ho)19(w t)18(o ensur)19(e a f)18(ocusing of the r)19(esear)19(ch on issues of inter-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(est and concern t)19(o participants)36(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.009 tc
0.128 tw
[(in the a)56(uslinks pr)18(oject, a link betw)19(een south african r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s and)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
-0.006 tw
[(a)55(ustr)19(alian r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s w)19(as actually initiated b)18(y the south african envir)19(onmen-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tw
[(t)18(al educat)19(or)19(s with a vie)18(w)111(, in part, t)18(o str)19(ategically base the pr)19(oject on the princi)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.013 tw
[(ples of participat)19(ory)110(, community-based r)19(esear)19(ch. fir)19(stly and most import)18(antly)111(,)]tj
t*
-0.043 tc
0.01 tw
[(t)1(h)1(i)1(s)1( )1(w)20(as an opportunity f)18(or envir)19(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch t)19(o attempt \(in some)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
-0.011 tw
(small w)tj
3.14649 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
0.45876 0 td
-0.023 tc
(y\) t)tj
1.28802 0 td
-0.0226 tc
(o)tj
0.75898 0 td
-0.023 tc
0 tw
(activ)tj
1.90558 0 td
-0.011 tw
[(ely engage and perhaps partly r)19(edr)18(ess some of the effects of)]tj
-7.55783 -1.20001 td
-0.0303 tc
(a)tj
0.71418 0 td
-0.03 tc
-0.003 tw
[(r)19(ecent and v)18(ery obvious hist)19(ory of oppr)19(ession\321namely the hist)18(orical denial of)]tj
-0.71418 -1.2 td
-0.046 tc
0.012 tw
(opportunity f)tj
5.06693 0 td
(or people of colour t)tj
7.83109 0 td
-0.0458 tc
(o)tj
0.73578 0 td
-0.046 tc
0 tw
(de)tj
0.94583 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.43558 0 td
-0.046 tc
0.012 tw
(elop and shape their o)tj
8.67561 0 td
(wn educational mate)tj
8.23127 0 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92209 -1.20002 td
-0.016 tc
0.135 tw
(rials and e)tj
4.56085 0 td
0 tw
(xperiences)tj
4.49139 0 td
-0.0157 tc
(.)tj
0.65966 0 td
-0.016 tc
0.135 tw
(in a v)tj
2.58323 0 td
[(ery secondary sense)56(, it w)18(as an opportunity t)19(o)]tj
-12.29513 -1.20001 td
-0.035 tc
0.001 tw
[(\322test\323 the appr)19(opriateness and adequac)19(y of socially-critical r)18(esear)19(ch within a self-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
(e)tj
0.44545 0 td
-0.036 tc
0.002 tw
(vidently socially and politically char)tj
14.04038 0 td
(ged conte)tj
3.88423 0 td
(xt of post-apartheid south africa\321)tj
-18.37006 -1.20001 td
-0.02 tc
-0.011 tw
(this amounted t)tj
6.50025 0 td
-0.0196 tc
(o)tj
0.76455 0 td
(a)tj
0.72755 0 td
-0.02 tc
(test of the idea of coher)tj
9.69768 0 td
(ence betw)tj
4.23914 0 td
[(een r)19(esear)18(ch methodolo-)]tj
-21.92917 -1.20001 td
0 tw
[(gy and the subst)19(antiv)18(e issues being e)19(xplor)19(ed in the r)18(esear)19(ch. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
(the use of camer)tj
7.07603 0 td
(as as a de)tj
3.99476 0 td
(vice f)tj
2.14909 0 td
(or participants t)tj
6.42455 0 td
-0.0266 tc
(o)tj
0.77435 0 td
-0.027 tc
0 tw
(captur)tj
2.5624 0 td
-0.0267 tc
(e)tj
0.73732 0 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
(images of issues)tj
-25.5185 -1.20001 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
(of r)tj
1.62785 0 td
0 tw
(ele)tj
1.23039 0 td
0.136 tw
[(v)19(ance t)19(o them w)18(as consistent with the principles of participation)]tj
-2.85824 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(and r)tj
2.23343 0 td
[(esponsiv)19(eness; in the e)18(v)19(ent, the issues that w)19(er)18(e e)19(xplor)19(ed thr)18(ough the)]tj
-2.23343 -1.2 td
[(participant-de)19(v)18(eloped case studies w)19(er)18(e selected t)19(ot)19(ally b)18(y participants and)]tj
0 tc
(e)'
0.47646 0.00001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(xplor)19(ed b)18(y them in r)19(esponse t)19(o per)18(ceptions about local community needs)37(.)]tj
-0.47646 -1.20001 td
-0.0193 tc
(a)tj
0.87195 0 td
-0.019 tc
0.003 tw
[(clear e)19(x)19(ample of this w)19(as the choice in the north-w)92(est pr)19(o)19(vince of the issue)]tj
-0.87195 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.014 tw
[(of aids/hiv in the mining community at r)19(ustenbur)19(g. this issue w)18(as of cru-)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.007 tw
(cial import)tj
4.5295 0 td
(ance t)tj
2.5438 0 td
-0.0102 tc
(o)tj
0.7881 0 td
-0.01 tc
0 tw
(member)tj
3.62426 0.00001 td
-0.0102 tc
(s)tj
0.67702 0 td
-0.01 tc
-0.007 tw
(of that community \(ther)tj
10.11818 0.00001 td
-0.0103 tc
(e)tj
0.75087 0 td
-0.01 tc
[(w)19(as a v)18(ery high infec-)]tj
-23.0317 -1.2 td
-0.024 tc
0.007 tw
[(tion r)19(ate\) and the political char)18(acter of the issue is equally clear when it is seen)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.02 tw
[(that the pr)19(oject succeeded in de)19(v)18(eloping an educational curriculum on this)]tj
0 tc
(t)'
0.2934 0 td
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(opic wher)tj
4.2331 0 td
-0.0028 tc
(e)tj
0.7723 0 td
-0.003 tc
(none had e)tj
4.80574 0.00001 td
[(xisted under the pr)19(e)18(vious educational pr)19(o)19(vision.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(118)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
12 0 obj
<<
/length 7046
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 91 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.029 tw
[(in the ed)56(amaz pr)18(oject, as st)19(ated abo)19(v)19(e)56(, the initial idea of an envir)18(on-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.025 tw
[(ment)19(al education pr)18(oject ar)19(ose fr)19(om a meeting of unamaz \(a w)18(eb of uni-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(v)18(er)19(sities in the amaz)19(onian r)18(egion\) who invited our team fr)19(om uq)56(am t)18(o shar)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(e)18(xperience and r)19(esour)19(ces with thr)18(ee institutions of the amaz)19(onian r)19(egion in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(the pr)19(ocess of conceiving and implementing pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)18(elopment pr)19(o-)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(gr)19(ams in this particular field. since the v)18(ery fir)19(st discussions with the partner)18(s)38(,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[(it became clear that t)19(o be r)18(ele)19(v)19(ant, envir)19(onment)18(al ed)1(ucation should be)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(community-based and that ed)56(amaz w)18(ould be conducted in a participat)19(o)1(r)1(y)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch pr)18(ocess)37(, gr)19(ounded in the pr)18(oject activities)37(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(the fir)19(st step w)18(as t)19(o w)18(ork on a partici)1(pat)18(ory diagnosis \(l)19(e boterf, 198)56(1\))]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.0001 tc
(of)tj
1.11851 0 td
0 tc
-0.011 tw
[(each of the specific r)19(egional envir)18(onment)19(al, social, and educational con-)]tj
-1.11851 -1.2 td
-0.014 tw
[(te)19(xts of the participant univ)18(er)19(sities so as t)19(o conceiv)18(e conte)19(xtually appr)19(opri-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(ate pr)19(ofessional de)18(v)20(elopment pr)18(ogr)19(ams and t)19(o orient our r)18(esear)19(ch questions)37(.)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.002 tw
[(the pr)19(ocess of this diagnosis w)18(as collectiv)19(ely constructed and w)19(as the fir)18(st)]tj
t*
-0.004 tw
[(opportunity t)19(o discuss and learn t)18(ogether)111(. the idea of pr)19(omoting the learn-)]tj
t*
-0.006 tw
[(ing community as the basic dynamic of our pr)19(oject emer)18(ged fr)19(om this fir)19(st)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(step. thus)37(, w)18(e e)19(xperimented at our inter-univ)19(er)18(sity team le)19(v)18(el the same e)19(xpe-)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(riential, collabor)19(ativ)18(e)56(, r)19(efle)19(xiv)18(e)56(, critical, and community-based pr)19(ocess w)19(e pr)18(o)1(-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.007 tw
[(pose in the differ)19(ent pr)18(ogr)19(ams w)19(e de)18(v)19(eloped f)19(or teacher)19(s and other educa-)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.006 tw
[(t)16(o)-3(r)15(s)34(.)-3( )-3(o)-3(n)-3(e)-3( )-3(o)-3(f the main char)19(acteristics of this pr)19(ocess is t)19(o associate pr)18(ofessional)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.012 tw
[(de)19(v)18(elopment with r)19(esear)19(ch activities about, in, and f)19(or envir)18(onment)19(al edu-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
-0.003 tw
(cation interv)tj
5.23812 0 td
(entions so as t)tj
5.98311 0 td
-0.0142 tc
(o)tj
0.78396 0 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(de)tj
1.00886 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.4671 0 td
-0.014 tc
-0.003 tw
[(elop pr)19(ogr)18(essiv)19(ely a conte)19(xtually appr)18(opriate)]tj
-13.48115 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
0 tw
[(and coher)19(ent envir)18(onment)19(al education theory and pr)19(actice)56(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(the \322)56(acid test\323 f)19(or participat)18(ory r)19(esear)19(ch is that the issues that come t)19(o)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
(be the f)tj
3.19479 0 td
(ocus of the r)tj
5.23465 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.2302 0 td
-0.005 tw
[(ch ar)19(e those of inter)18(est and concern t)19(o participants)]tj
-10.65964 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.053 tw
[(themselv)19(es\321issues which ha)18(v)19(e meaning within particular social, envir)19(on-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.138 tw
[(ment)19(al, cultur)18(al, and educational conte)19(xts)37(. the methodological issue f)18(or)]tj
t*
0 tw
(participat)tj
4.07324 0 td
(ory r)tj
2.05445 0 td
[(esear)19(ch is t)18(o find w)19(a)19(y)19(s t)18(o ensur)19(e that this happens)37(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 236.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(the importance of project partnerships)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 217.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tc
-0.001 tw
(most of the e)tj
5.44683 0 td
0 tc
(x)tj
0.50418 0 td
-0.014 tc
(amples of participat)tj
8.31278 0 td
[(ory r)19(esear)18(ch w)19(e ha)19(v)18(e been associated with)]tj
-14.26379 -1.20001 td
-0.023 tc
-0.005 tw
[(ha)19(v)18(e been collabor)19(ativ)18(e in natur)19(e)56(. the)18(y ha)19(v)18(e been collabor)19(ativ)19(e in the sense of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0 tw
(inv)tj
1.26386 0 td
-0.011 tw
(olving a collectiv)tj
6.84296 0 td
-0.0168 tc
(e)tj
0.73331 0 td
-0.017 tc
(of people in as man)tj
8.19376 0 td
-0.0168 tc
(y)tj
0.75225 0 td
-0.017 tc
0 tw
(differ)tj
2.19534 0 td
-0.011 tw
(ent aspects of the r)tj
7.88089 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.19334 0 td
-0.011 tw
(ch as)tj
-30.05571 -1.20002 td
-0.013 tc
0 tw
(possible)tj
3.34515 0 td
-0.0125 tc
(,)tj
0.66848 0 td
-0.012 tc
0.137 tw
(partly as an alternativ)tj
9.516 0 td
-0.0125 tc
(e)tj
0.89042 0 td
-0.012 tc
[(t)19(o the mor)18(e usual division of labour that)]tj
-14.42004 -1.20001 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(occur)tj
2.28111 0 td
-0.0141 tc
(s)tj
0.74293 0 td
-0.014 tc
0.067 tw
[(in r)19(esear)18(ch \(wher)19(e \322r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s\323 ar)19(e disjoined fr)19(om the \322subjects-as-)]tj
-3.02404 -1.2 td
0.035 tw
[(objects\323 of r)19(esear)18(ch\), and partly because gr)19(oup r)19(eflection on pr)19(actice can be)]tj
t*
0 tw
(mor)tj
1.73517 0.00001 td
(e)tj
0.76384 0 td
0.014 tw
[(po)19(w)19(erful than individual r)18(eflection \(r)19(obott)19(om, 1987\) and has a gr)19(eater)]tj
-2.49901 -1.20001 td
-0.018 tc
-0.01 tw
[(potential f)19(or pr)18(oduction of conte)19(xtually r)19(ele)18(v)19(ant kno)19(wledge)56(. but in each of the)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
-0.008 tw
[(pr)19(ojects described earlier)110(, the collabor)19(ativ)19(e w)18(ork engaged in during the pr)19(oject)]tj
t*
-0.035 tc
0.007 tw
(continued be)tj
5.21787 0.00001 td
0 tc
(y)tj
0.46513 0.00001 td
-0.035 tc
(ond the life of the pr)tj
8.13948 0.00001 td
(oject itself. netw)tj
6.57094 0.00001 td
[(orks of colleagues est)19(ablished)]tj
-20.3934 -1.2 td
-0.032 tc
0.001 tw
[(d)-3(u)-3(r)-3(i)-3(n)-3(g)-3( )-3(t)-3(h)-3(e)-3( )-3(pr)19(oject ha)18(v)19(e)56(, t)18(o some e)19(xtent, att)19(ained a life of their o)18(wn that has con-)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
-0.011 tw
[(tinued t)19(o serv)18(e pr)19(oject participants w)19(ell in both intellectual and political terms)37(.)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
0.132 tw
(in the case of the ed)tj
9.41745 0.00001 td
(amaz pr)tj
3.87884 0.00001 td
(oject, these netw)tj
7.41209 0.00001 td
[(orks ar)19(e being maint)18(ained)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 119.5884 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental education: some issues)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1489 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(119)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
13 0 obj
<<
/length 7564
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.038 tc
0.007 tw
[(r)19(esulting in continued pr)18(ofessional link)19(ages and e)19(x)18(changes among the man)19(y par-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.043 tc
0.012 tw
[(ticipating countries; the pr)19(oject has r)18(einf)19(or)19(ced the r)18(egional and nation)-3(a)-3(l)-3( )-3(l)-3(e)-3(a)-3(d)-3(e)-3(r)16(s)-3(h)-3(i)-3(p)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.026 tc
-0.002 tw
[(of our partner)19(s in envir)18(onment)19(al education. in the case of the a)56(uslinks pr)18(oject,)]tj
t*
-0.016 tc
-0.012 tw
[(the continuing netw)19(ork of f)18(ormer pr)19(oject participants has been partly r)19(espon-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.03 tc
0.002 tw
[(sible f)19(or the adv)18(ancement of se)19(v)18(er)19(al people t)19(o positions of gr)18(eater r)19(esponsibility)]tj
t*
-0.038 tc
0.011 tw
[(within the south african educational sy)19(stem. in this latter case)56(, the \322tr)18(ack r)19(ecor)19(d)1<d3>]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.041 tc
0.013 tw
[(of pr)19(oductiv)18(e w)19(ork has also serv)19(ed f)18(ormer pr)19(oject participants w)19(ell as the)18(y sought)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(positions of changed r)19(esponsibility within their pr)19(ofessional ar)18(ena.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 476.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(participants\325 preconceptions about the nature of research)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 457.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(p)44(a)-11(rt)-1(icip)1(at)18(ory r)19(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)18(ch b)18(y definition inv)19(o)-1(l)-1(v)18(e)-1(s)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1( )-1(c)-1(o)-1(l)-1(l)-1(a)-1(b)-1(o)-1(r)17(ation of r)19(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)18(ch)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.007 tw
[(partner)19(s in as man)18(y of the phases of r)19(esear)19(ch as possible)56(. ho)18(w)19(e)19(v)19(er)111(, differ)19(ent)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.001 tw
[(participants come fr)19(om differ)18(ent backgr)19(ounds\321f)19(or e)19(x)19(ample participants in the)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
-0.001 tw
[(community-based pr)19(ojects come fr)18(om a community de)19(v)19(elopment backgr)18(ound)]tj
t*
[(r)19(ather than fr)18(om a f)19(ormal educational r)19(esear)19(ch backgr)18(ound. in our e)19(xperience)56(,)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
-0.007 tw
[(it can ne)19(v)19(er be assumed that participants come t)18(o the pr)19(oject with a common)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
-0.005 tw
[(\322def)19(ault\323 construction of what counts as r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education.)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
-0.006 tw
[(some participants appr)19(oach a pr)19(oject with the e)18(xpect)19(ation that the r)19(esear)18(ch is)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.002 tw
[(of an \322)56(account)18(ability e)19(x)19(er)18(cise\323 kind, in which univ)19(er)19(sity-based r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s seek)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.01 tw
[(t)19(o measur)19(e the achie)18(v)19(ements of other participants against a set of independ-)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
-0.003 tw
[(ently-e)19(xisting and e)18(xternally-deriv)19(ed set of criteria. man)19(y assume that the v)19(ery)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.121 tw
[(w)19(or)18(d \322r)19(esear)18(ch\323 ent)19(ails the emplo)19(yment of quantit)18(ativ)19(e applied-science)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(esear)18(ch designs)37(. it has been import)19(ant t)19(o r)18(ecogniz)19(e these prior assumptions)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
-0.004 tw
[(about the natur)19(e of r)18(esear)19(ch and t)19(o engage them dir)18(ectly v)19(ery early on in pr)19(oj)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
0.006 tw
(ect discussions)tj
6.24578 0 td
-0.0112 tc
(,)tj
0.54 0 td
-0.011 tc
(and f)tj
2.15464 0 td
(or the e)tj
3.23846 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.47009 0 td
-0.011 tc
[(olving methodology-in-action t)19(o be the subject)]tj
-12.64897 -1.20001 td
0.002 tw
[(of open and continuing negotiation. this is one of the r)19(easons wh)18(y it usually)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.28503 0 td
-0.011 tc
0 tw
(ak)tj
0.97778 0 td
(es time t)tj
3.64023 0 td
-0.0112 tc
(o)tj
0.79251 0 td
-0.011 tc
(build a r)tj
3.45514 0 td
(esear)tj
2.22129 0 td
(ch cultur)tj
3.64024 0 td
-0.0112 tc
(e)tj
0.75555 0 td
-0.011 tc
(within an)tj
3.95426 0 td
-0.0112 tc
(y)tj
0.77452 0 td
-0.011 tc
(ne)tj
1.03284 0 td
-0.0113 tc
(w)tj
1.01438 0 td
-0.011 tc
[(pr)19(oject community)110(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 237.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(what is \322rigor\323 in participatory research in environmental education?)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 218.7616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(in the 7)37(0s and 80s)36(, r)19(esear)19(ch in envir)18(onment)19(al education, in north america)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.0001 tc
(at)tj
1.08621 0 td
0 tc
-0.006 tw
(least, w)tj
3.27096 0 td
(as domi)tj
3.43762 0 td
-0.006 tc
(nated b)tj
3.2144 0 td
-0.0057 tc
(y)tj
0.77914 0 td
(a)tj
0.76014 0 td
-0.006 tc
(\322ruling discour)tj
6.24053 0 td
[(se\323 of applied science r)19(esear)18(ch,)]tj
-18.789 -1.20001 td
0.002 tc
0.131 tw
[(wher)19(e objectivist, beha)18(viourist, and quantit)19(ativ)19(e appr)18(oaches w)19(er)19(e r)18(epr)19(e-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.014 tw
[(sented and uncritically r)19(epr)18(oduced within the field, not least b)19(y the edit)19(ori)-1(a)-6(l)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(polic)19(y of the )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 91.6343 170.7616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
-0.004 tw
[(journal of envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 238.9762 170.7616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(whose edit)19(orial polic)18(y seem-)]tj
-20.19762 -1.2 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(ingly constructed \322r)19(esear)18(ch\323 in terms which f)19(a)19(v)19(our)18(ed almost e)19(x)19(clusiv)18(ely f)19(orms)]tj
t*
0.022 tc
0.166 tw
[(of r)19(esear)18(ch which conf)19(ormed t)19(o accepted criteria of applied science)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(appr)tj
1.90548 0.00001 td
(oaches)tj
2.85847 0 td
-0.0145 tc
(.)tj
0.52752 0 td
-0.014 tc
(the assumption in this conte)tj
12.09889 0 td
(xt that r)tj
3.31608 0.00001 td
[(esear)19(c)1(h)1( )1(w)19(as almost obliged)]tj
-20.70644 -1.20002 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.29614 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.81475 0 td
0 tc
(be positivist in natur)tj
8.84956 0.00001 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.77762 0 td
(w)tj
0.7402 0.00001 td
0 tc
(as r)tj
1.55469 0.00001 td
(elativ)tj
2.2959 0.00001 td
(ely unchallenged until 1990.)tj
-13.5289 -1.2 td
-0.043 tc
0.006 tw
[(a)14(t the 1990 confer)19(ence of the north american association f)19(or envir)18(onment)19(al)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.028 tc
-0.008 tw
(education (naaee), a symposium or)tj
14.84492 0.00001 td
0 tw
(ganiz)tj
2.13498 0.00001 td
-0.008 tw
(ed b)tj
1.74961 0.00001 td
-0.0286 tc
(y)tj
0.73212 0 td
(p)tj
0.4897 0.00001 td
-0.028 tc
[(aul hart, rick mr)19(az)18(ek, and ian)]tj
-19.9513 -1.2 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.5889 0 td
-0.022 tc
0 tw
(obott)tj
2.1296 0 td
-0.003 tw
(om titled \322contesting p)tj
9.49576 0.00001 td
0 tw
(ar)tj
0.80661 0.00001 td
-0.003 tw
(adigms of envir)tj
6.45469 0.00001 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.23648 0.00001 td
-0.003 tw
(al education r)tj
5.90417 0.00001 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.1657 0.00001 td
(ch\323)tj
-30.7818 -1.2 td
-0.023 tc
-0.013 tw
[(w)19(as conducted, the pr)19(oceedings of which w)18(er)19(e subseq)-22(u)-22(e)-22(n)-22(t)-22(l)-22(y)-22( )-22(p)-22(u)-22(b)-22(l)-22(i)-22(s)-22(h)-22(e)-22(d)-22( )-22(u)-22(n)-22(d)-22(e)-22(r)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(120)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/length 6979
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
(a)tj
0.75799 0 td
-0.008 tw
[(differ)19(ent title \(mr)18(az)19(ek, 1993\). one of the out)19(comes of this colloquium w)19(as)]tj
-0.75799 -1.2 td
[(the r)19(ealiz)18(ation that envir)19(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch\321and the r)19(eporting of)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
-0.004 tw
[(such r)19(esear)18(ch\321needed t)19(o be r)19(egar)18(ded as pr)19(oblematic \(as \322)56(contested\323\) and)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(in need of deliber)19(ation and critique)55(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(p)56(artly in r)18(esponse t)19(o this r)19(ealiz)18(ation w)19(as the or)19(ganiz)18(ation of another sym-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.029 tw
[(posium at the 1997 naaee confer)19(ence titled \322ee r)18(esear)19(ch: guidelines f)19(or)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(ex)19(cellence)55(,\323 whose st)19(ated aim w)19(as: \322ee r)18(esear)19(ch has been criticiz)19(ed f)18(or lack)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(of rigor and educational merit of r)19(eported findings or r)18(esults)37(. this w)19(orkshop)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(will intr)19(oduce r)18(esear)19(ch methods and designs and pr)19(o)19(vide guidelines intend-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(ed t)19(o)1( )1(i)1(m)1(p)1(r)19(o)20(v)19(e the st)18(atus of ee r)19(esear)19(ch and r)18(eporting of findings)37(.\323 the)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.006 tw
[(intention in the symposium w)19(as thus the instrument)18(alist one of impr)19(o)19(ving)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(the rigor of envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch b)18(y actually )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 312.9962 455.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
[(p)1(r)19(o)20(viding)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 353.1502 455.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
(guidelines)tj
-28.01502 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.089 tw
[(f)19(or impr)19(o)18(ving the st)19(atus of r)19(esear)18(ch. this w)19(as duly done: the confer)19(ence)]tj
t*
0.043 tw
[(or)19(ganiz)18(er)19(s \(the north american commission on envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch\321na)56(ceer\) t)18(abled a number of documents and st)19(atements r)19(elating)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.057 tw
[(t)19(o r)18(esear)19(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education \(see smith-sebast)18(o, 2000\), but all)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(these t)19(abled documents w)18(er)19(e per)19(ceiv)18(ed b)19(y w)19(orkshop participants as being)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(dr)19(a)19(wn fr)18(om quantit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch tr)19(aditions)37(. r)18(ather than accepting these \322pr)19(o-)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(vided\323 guidelines)37(, the w)18(orkshop participants decided t)19(o de)19(v)18(elop their o)19(wn sets)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(f)18(or qualit)19(ativ)19(e appr)19(oaches)36(. the r)19(esulting dr)19(aft set of guidelines w)19(as published)]tj
t*
0 tc
[(in 2000 \(smith-sebast)19(o, 2000\).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.011 tc
0.128 tw
(the issue of the journal in which these guidelines w)tj
24.03231 0 td
0 tw
(er)tj
0.87376 0 td
0.0112 tc
(e)tj
0.92802 0 td
0.011 tc
(published,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 323.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)-265(6)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 223.1412 323.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[((1), includes articles appr)19(aising this dr)19(aft)]tj
-15.01412 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.107 tw
[(set of guidelines)37(. it is clear fr)18(om these articles that this set of guidelines)]tj
(r)'
0.34889 0 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
(emains contested, and that the notion of rigor in envir)tj
23.27113 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.35675 0 td
-0.012 tw
(al education)tj
-26.97677 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch r)18(emains pr)19(oblematic)19(.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.016 tc
0.122 tw
[(against this backgr)19(ound, member)18(s of the univ)19(er)19(sity of quebec at)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
0 tw
(montr)tj
2.55405 0 td
(eal\325)tj
1.45173 0 td
-0.0077 tc
(s)tj
0.6823 0 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(\(uq)56(am\325)36(s\) centr)19(e f)19(or envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch engaged)]tj
-4.68808 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(in a seminar on the t)19(opic of rigor in envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch. the)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.008 tw
[(appr)19(oach w)18(as simply t)19(o r)19(eflect on ho)18(w \322rigor\323 w)19(as constructed in the v)19(ari)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
(ous r)tj
2.07388 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.22604 0 td
-0.004 tw
[(ch pr)19(ojects engaged in b)18(y centr)19(e participants\321that is t)19(o st)18(art with)]tj
-4.29992 -1.20001 td
0.003 tc
0.135 tw
[(the concr)19(ete r)18(esear)19(ch pr)19(actice gained in the 1)55(0 or so pr)19(ojects curr)19(ently)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(underw)19(a)18(y within the centr)19(e in pr)18(offering ideas about the t)19(opic of rigor in envi-)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.35107 0 td
0 tw
[(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch. some of the per)19(spectiv)19(es adv)18(anced w)19(er)19(e:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 167.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.011 tw
[(st)19(andar)18(d dictionary definitions r)19(efer t)19(o such qualities as se)18(v)19(erity)111(, strictness)37(,)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0.047 tw
[(har)19(shness)36(, fixity)111(, har)19(dness)36(. such st)19(andar)19(d definitions seem t)19(o r)18(eflect char-)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(acteristics of quantit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch r)19(ather than those of the no)18(w br)19(oad r)19(ange)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(of r)19(esear)18(ch appr)19(oaches;)]tj
-1.5158 -1.2632 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[<a5>-1027(integrity)111(, honesty)111(, and humility on the part of the r)18(esear)19(cher ar)19(e part of what)]tj
1.5158 -1.2632 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(it is t)19(o be rigor)18(ous;)]tj
-1.5158 -1.2632 td
-0.034 tc
0.009 tw
[<a5>-1050(abo)19(v)19(e the )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 128.1362 95.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0321 tc
(a)tj
0.70247 0 td
-0.032 tc
(priori)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 157.7383 95.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.034 tc
0.009 tw
[(quality of an)19(y particular r)18(esear)19(ch design, rigor calls )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 352.7045 95.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.032 tc
(a)tj
0.70251 0 td
(posteriori)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 83.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.018 tc
-0.007 tw
[(f)18(or methodological tr)19(anspar)19(enc)19(y \(r)18(elating what r)19(eally happened\) and ackno)19(wl-)]tj
0 -1.2632 td
-0.011 tc
0 tw
[(edgement of the inher)19(ent and e)18(xternally-imposed limits of the r)19(esear)19(ch;)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 119.5884 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental education: some issues)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.153 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(121)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<<
/length 6780
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 588.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[<a5>-1016(it is import)19(ant t)19(o negotiate the r)18(esear)19(ch agenda with pr)19(oject participants;)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.017 tc
0.056 tw
[<a5>-1033(ethics is essential part of rigor)111(. in participat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch, t)19(o be ethical in part)]tj
1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.018 tc
-0.012 tw
[(means t)19(o conduct r)18(esear)19(ch that is r)19(ele)19(v)18(ant t)19(o participants)37(, t)19(o mak)18(e sur)19(e r)19(esults)]tj
t*
-0.037 tc
0.006 tw
[(ar)19(e collectiv)18(ely discussed and interpr)19(eted with participants)37(, and t)18(o shar)19(e with par-)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.028 tw
[(ticipants the act of r)19(esear)19(ch communication and diffusion, so as the)18(y ar)19(e r)19(ec-)]tj
t*
-0.037 tc
0.006 tw
[(ogniz)19(ed as full act)18(or)19(s of the r)19(esear)18(ch pr)19(ocess and of the pr)19(oduction of kno)19(wledge; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[<a5>-1016(self-r)19(eflection of the pr)19(actice of r)18(esear)19(ch is a component of rigor;)]tj
t*
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[<a5>-1012(pr)19(ocesses of iter)19(ativ)18(e synthesis of r)19(esear)19(ch accounts add t)18(o the rigor of)]tj
1.51579 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch;)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
[<a5>-1016(pr)19(ocesses of collabor)19(ativ)18(e self-e)19(v)19(aluation contribute t)18(o rigor;)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[<a5>-1038(a questioning of the dominant discour)19(se is an element of a rigor)19(ous appr)18(oach;)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.017 tw
[<a5>-1016(internal coher)19(ence among the philosophical assumptions \(epistemological,)]tj
1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(ont)19(ological, ideological . . .\) underpinning the r)19(esear)18(ch is another element of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(rigor in r)19(esear)18(ch; and)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[<a5>-1023(it is possible that the concept of \322rigor\323 is f)19(at)19(ally fla)19(w)18(ed thr)19(ough its hist)19(orical)]tj
1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(construction within an applied science conceptual fr)19(ame)19(w)18(ork and that in f)19(act)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.009 tw
[(w)19(e should be using a differ)19(ent term alt)18(ogether t)19(o qualify desir)19(ed char)18(acter-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(istics of participat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 360.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(it is clear that continued car)19(eful r)18(eflection on the meaning of rigor)111(, or an alter-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(nativ)19(e notion f)18(or appr)19(aising the quality of r)19(esear)19(ch, is r)18(equir)19(ed in the field of)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0 tw
(qualit)tj
2.40247 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.56413 0 td
0.0022 tc
(e)tj
0.91903 0 td
0.002 tc
(appr)tj
1.9721 0 td
0.137 tw
[(oaches t)19(o envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch, particularly)]tj
-6.85773 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(participat)19(ory envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 296.9036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(the colonialist dilemma: avoiding the \322package or perish\323 mentality)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 277.7036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(the \322)56(colonialist dilemma\323 r)18(eferr)19(ed t)19(o her)18(e arises when centr)19(al agencies)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(seek t)19(o become inv)18(olv)19(ed in curriculum de)19(v)18(elopment. the dilemma f)19(aced b)19(y)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(high pr)19(ofile international agencies is ho)18(w t)19(o achie)18(v)19(e their aims of pr)18(oducing)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
(materials designed f)tj
8.30888 0 td
(or international dissemination without lea)tj
17.23907 0 td
(ving themselv)tj
5.74791 0 td
-0.022 tc
0 tw
(es)tj
-31.29586 -1.20001 td
0 tc
-0.004 tw
(open t)tj
2.73709 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.81115 0 td
0 tc
(criticisms concerning the colonialist impact of these materials)tj
26.67394 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55209 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(put)tj
-30.77427 -1.20001 td
0.007 tw
(another w)tj
4.37602 0 td
(a)tj
0.4812 0 td
(y)tj
0.40796 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.5624 0 td
0 tc
(the dilemma is ho)tj
7.81621 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(w)tj
1.0432 0 td
(t)tj
0.2962 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.82141 0 td
0 tc
(widely disseminate useful accounts of)tj
-15.8046 -1.20001 td
-0.005 tc
0 tw
(pr)tj
0.89781 0 td
-0.009 tw
(actice in envir)tj
5.98434 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.34234 0 td
-0.009 tw
(al education without being seen in colonialist terms)tj
-10.22449 -1.20001 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
(as privileging cert)tj
7.29987 0 td
(ain cultur)tj
3.88159 0 td
[(al subject matter)19(s \(and the social conte)19(xts the)18(y ar)19(e)]tj
-11.18146 -1.20001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(embedded in\) o)tj
6.72812 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.47628 0 td
-0.005 tc
(er other)tj
3.35817 0 td
-0.0051 tc
(s)tj
0.68493 0 td
-0.005 tc
(\(dillon, 1999; r)tj
6.70057 0 td
0 tw
(obott)tj
2.21613 0 td
-0.009 tw
(om & k)tj
3.26699 0 td
0 tw
(yburz-gr)tj
3.66377 0 td
(aber)tj
1.79526 0 td
-0.0051 tc
(,)tj
0.53691 0 td
-0.005 tc
(2000\). )tj
-27.62713 -1.20002 td
-0.014 tc
0.013 tw
(one solution adopted b)tj
9.86248 0 td
(y)tj
0.78165 0 td
[(some author)19(s in these cir)18(cumst)19(ances is t)19(o base)]tj
-12.44413 -1.2 td
-0.003 tw
(the accounts of envir)tj
8.75301 0 td
[(onment)19(al education pr)19(actice on the out)18(comes of partici-)]tj
-8.75301 -1.20001 td
-0.015 tc
-0.012 tw
[(pat)19(o)1(r)1(y)1( )1(r)19(esear)19(ch. some of the pr)19(ojects in this category spend lar)19(ge amounts of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.33718 -0.00001 td
-0.014 tc
0.052 tw
[(esour)19(ces on supporting high quality participat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch in selected com-)]tj
-0.33718 -1.19999 td
-0.024 tc
-0.004 tw
[(munities t)19(o pr)18(oduce case studies of pr)19(actice)56(. the)19(y claim that the embedding of)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
-0.008 tw
[(these centr)19(ally pr)18(oduced materials within a discour)19(se of participat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0 tw
(confer)tj
2.6287 0 td
-0.0186 tc
(s)tj
0.6575 0 td
(a)tj
0.7315 0 td
-0.019 tc
-0.009 tw
[(degr)19(ee of \322)55(cultur)19(al sensitivity\323 t)19(o the materials)37(, and, further)110(, that this)]tj
-4.0177 -1.2 td
-0.035 tc
0.007 tw
[(quality justifies the mor)19(e gener)19(al subsequent distribution of the accounts of pr)19(ac)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
-0.013 tw
[(tice)56(. but the pr)19(oblem is that \322)55(cultur)19(al sensitivity\323 is not a comm)-8(o)-8(d)-8(i)-8(t)-8(y)-8( )-8(t)-8(h)-8(a)-8(t)-8( )-8(c)-8(a)-8(n)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(122)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/length 6299
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
0.002 tw
[(e)18(v)19(er actually imbue materials that ar)18(e still destined f)19(or univ)18(er)19(sal dissemina-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.009 tw
[(tion; materials can better be said t)19(o be cultur)18(ally sensitiv)19(e when the)19(y ar)19(e cul)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.008 tc
0.125 tw
[(tur)19(ally embedded thr)18(ough being conceptualiz)19(ed, de)19(v)18(eloped, and imple-)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
0 tw
(mented )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 110.3475 551.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
(within)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 140.8464 551.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
0.135 tw
[(particular cultur)19(es)36(. a)37(ttempts t)19(o disseminate the materials)]tj
-6.78464 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.004 tw
[(mor)19(e gener)18(ally)111(, be)19(y)18(ond the conte)19(xt of their de)19(v)18(elopment, compr)19(omises the)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(necessary conte)19(xtuality of envir)18(onment)19(al education curriculum.)]tj
1.8 -1.20001 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(p)55(articipat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch is essentially about r)19(esear)19(ch int)19(o issues of inter)18(est)]tj
-1.8 -1.19999 td
0 tc
-0.013 tw
[(and concern t)19(o participants within a particular pr)18(ofessional setting or com-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(munity)111(. it aims t)18(o impr)19(o)19(v)18(e the le)19(v)19(el of sophistication of the debate about those)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(issues)37(. the meaning and significance of the out)18(c)1(omes of the r)18(esear)19(ch ar)19(e lik)18(e)1(-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(ly t)19(o be highly conte)18(xtual, and of r)19(ele)19(v)18(ance and inter)19(est mainly if not only t)19(o)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(the community within which the)19(y ar)18(e gener)19(ated. p)56(articipat)18(ory r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.002 tw
[(does not seek t)19(o underwrite the gener)18(aliz)19(ability of r)19(esear)18(ch out)19(comes)37(, and)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(in f)19(act its underlying subjectivist epistemology mak)18(es claims t)19(o gener)19(aliz)18(ability)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(unsust)19(ainable)55(. in participat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch, ther)19(ef)19(or)18(e)56(, while ther)19(e is cert)18(ainly a)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.014 tw
[(phase of kno)19(wledge pr)18(oduction and identification of ne)19(w kno)18(wledge)56(, ther)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(is no subsequent phase of dissemination of \322univ)19(er)19(sally applicab)-1(le\323 out)19(comes)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(f)19(or adoption else)19(wher)18(e)56(. this is not t)19(o sa)18(y that it is inappr)19(opriate f)19(or the kno)19(wl)-1(-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(edge gener)19(ated thr)18(ough participat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch t)19(o be published widely; it is)]tj
t*
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(just t)19(o sa)18(y that the common pr)19(actice of wide \322)56(adoption-f)18(ocused\323 dissemination)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(of \322r)19(esear)18(ch-based\323 educational pr)19(ogr)19(ams is not appr)18(opriate if the r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
-0.0001 tc
(on)'
1.38857 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(which such pr)tj
6.03648 0 td
(ogr)tj
1.38794 0 td
(ams ar)tj
2.9436 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77777 0 td
0 tc
(based is participat)tj
7.85114 0 td
[(ory r)19(esear)18(ch. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 310.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(the bigger picture: technocratic rationality and participatory research)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 291.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education seeks)37(, in part, t)19(o be educativ)18(e about envir)19(on-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(ment)19(al issues)36(, including our o)19(wn r)19(elationship with these issues)36(. r)19(esear)19(ch int)18(o)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.037 tw
[(this f)19(orm of envir)18(onment)19(al education needs t)19(o ackno)18(wledge that method-)]tj
t*
0.136 tw
[(ological difficulties can arise as a function of the comple)19(x natur)18(e of the)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(r)19(esear)18(ch conte)19(xts themselv)19(es)36(. it is clear fr)19(om the pr)19(ojects r)19(eported abo)18(v)19(e)55(, and)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(fr)19(om other pr)18(ojects \(r)19(obott)19(om, 2003\), that the conte)18(xts of both school-)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
(based and community-based envir)tj
14.21799 0 td
[(onment)19(al education pr)18(ogr)19(ams shar)19(e at least)]tj
-14.21799 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(the f)19(ollo)18(wing char)19(acteristics:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 185.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[<a5>-1016(the)19(y ar)19(e comple)18(x in their structur)19(e;)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
[(this comple)19(xity t)18(ak)19(es differ)19(ent f)18(orms in differ)19(ent conte)19(xts;)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
[<a5>-1016(the)19(y inv)19(olv)18(e a wide r)19(ange of st)19(ak)18(eholder)19(s;)]tj
t*
[<a5>-1016(these st)19(ak)18(eholder)19(s e)19(xpr)18(ess a wide r)19(ange of v)19(alues and inter)19(ests;)]tj
<a5>'
1.51579 0.00001 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
(their de)tj
3.43614 0.00001 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.46614 0.00001 td
-0.015 tc
[(elopment r)19(equir)18(es negotiation and r)19(econciliation, and these ar)19(e usu-)]tj
-3.90227 -1.26318 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(ally difficult pr)19(ocesses; and)]tj
-1.5158 -1.2632 td
<a5>tj
1.5158 0 td
-0.017 tc
(envir)tj
2.1715 0 td
0.003 tw
[(onment)19(al education pr)18(ogr)19(ams ar)19(e shaped and constr)19(ained b)18(y social, cul-)]tj
-2.1715 -1.2632 td
0 tc
0 tw
(tur)tj
1.2029 0 td
(al, political, hist)tj
6.75903 0.00001 td
(orical, and envir)tj
7.0166 0.00001 td
(onment)tj
3.36987 0.00001 td
(al elements)tj
4.92652 0.00001 td
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 79.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.015 tc
-0.01 tw
[(as a consequence)56(, a competent f)19(orm of r)18(esear)19(ch itself needs t)19(o be capable of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
-0.004 tw
[(engaging these elements)37(. as w)19(e ha)18(v)19(e ar)19(gued else)18(wher)19(e \(r)19(obott)18(om, 2003\), the)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 119.5884 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental education: some issues)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1572 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(123)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/length 6593
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tc
0.131 tw
[(char)19(acteristics of an adequate f)18(orm of envir)19(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.033 tc
0.008 tw
[(w)19(ould include conte)19(xtual sensitivity)110(, r)19(esponsiv)19(eness)36(, an inter)19(est in the subjectiv)19(e)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.014 tc
-0.011 tw
[(interpr)19(etiv)18(e categories of participants)37(, and a capacity t)19(o identify and appr)18(aise)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
-0.004 tw
[(the social, cultur)19(al, political, hist)18(orical, and envir)19(onment)19(al elements that shape)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
0 tw
[(and constr)19(ain per)18(spectiv)19(es on envir)19(onment and envir)19(onment)18(al education.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.045 tc
0.009 tw
[(ho)19(w)18(e)19(v)19(er)111(, w)18(or)19(ds ar)18(e cheap and pr)19(actice is mor)19(e difficult. one of the difficulties)]tj
-1.8 -1.20001 td
-0.033 tc
-0.004 tw
[(in attempting t)19(o manifest an appr)18(oach t)19(o envir)19(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch that)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.02 tc
-0.01 tw
[(d)6(e)6(m)6(o)6(n)6(s)6(t)6(r)25(ates these char)18(acteristics is the effect of the o)19(v)19(er)19(all educational ethos)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.029 tc
-0.001 tw
[(within which envir)19(onment)18(al education t)19(ak)19(es place)55(. f)56(or p)56(eter p)56(osch, the \322f)18(ather\323)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.019 tc
-0.012 tw
[(of the long-running eur)19(opean \322envir)18(onment and school initiativ)19(es (ensi) pr)19(oj-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
0.128 tw
[(e)-5(c)-5(t)-5( )-5(\()-5(p)51(o)-5(s)-5(c)-5(h)-5(,)-5( )-5(1)-5(9)-5(8)-5(8)-5(\))-5(,)-5( )-5(t)-5(h)-5(e)-5( )-5(p)-5(r)14(e)13(v)13(a)-5(l)-5(e)-5(n)-5(t)-5( )-5(c)-5(ultur)19(es of teaching and learning ar)19(e still)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
-0.011 tw
[(attuned t)19(o a r)18(elativ)19(ely st)19(atic society in which the necessary kno)19(wledge)55(, compe-)]tj
t*
0.008 tw
[(tences)37(, and v)19(alues ar)18(e pr)19(edefined and st)19(or)18(ed in curricula, tests)37(, and accr)19(edited)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(te)19(xtbooks)36(. a)56(ccor)19(ding t)18(o p)56(osch, the main char)19(acteristics of these cultur)19(es ar)18(e: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 407.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(a)tj
0.77774 0 td
0 tc
[(pr)19(edominance of sy)18(stematic kno)19(wledge; )]tj
-2.29353 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(specializ)19(ation; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26315 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(a)tj
0.77776 0 td
0 tc
[(tr)19(ansmission mode of teaching; and )]tj
-2.29355 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(a)tj
0.77774 0 td
0 tc
[(pr)19(e)18(v)19(alence of t)19(op-do)19(wn communication. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 347.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.009 tw
[(this discour)19(ages self-contr)18(ol and cooper)19(ation among 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛
)37(, and among)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.013 tc
0 tw
(teacher)tj
3.27941 0 td
0 tc
(s)tj
0.40243 0 td
0.0134 tc
(,)tj
0.70822 0 td
0.013 tc
0.125 tw
(and netw)tj
4.27001 0 td
(orking within and acr)tj
9.91682 0 td
[(oss school boundaries \(p)56(osch,)]tj
-18.57688 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.139 tw
[(1997\). in our e)19(xperience)56(, such t)18(op-do)19(wn and centr)19(e-periphery or)18(ganiz)19(a-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(tional arr)19(angements pr)18(esuppose and r)19(einf)19(or)18(ce hier)19(ar)19(chical po)19(w)19(er structur)18(es)]tj
t*
(and r)tj
2.22257 0 td
(elationships that mitigate against the po)tj
17.00694 0 td
0 tc
(w)tj
0.73441 0 td
-0.006 tc
[(er-sharing aspir)19(ations of par-)]tj
-19.96392 -1.20001 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(ticipat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch. in short, ther)19(e is a pr)18(e)19(v)19(ailing technocr)19(atic r)18(ationality which)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(constitutes a hostile milieu f)19(or participat)18(ory r)19(esear)19(ch.)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.008 tw
(this perv)tj
3.97014 0 td
0 tw
(asiv)tj
1.66441 0 td
-0.0004 tc
(e)tj
0.76914 0 td
0 tc
-0.008 tw
[(technocr)19(atic r)18(ationality poses a major challenge f)19(or par-)]tj
-8.20369 -1.20001 td
0.005 tc
-0.011 tw
[(ticipat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education in that it sets up a number)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
0.003 tw
[(of philosophical incongruencies that r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s in envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.012 tw
(must ackno)tj
4.82383 0 td
(wledge and r)tj
5.36905 0 td
[(esolv)19(e if the r)18(esear)19(ch is t)19(o succeed in its participa)-1(t)24(o)5(r)5(y)]tj
-10.19288 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(aspir)19(ations)36(.)1( )1(w)94(e will use p)56(osch\325)36(s char)19(acteristics of pr)19(e)19(v)19(alent cultur)19(es of teach)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(ing and learning as a fr)19(ame)18(w)19(ork t)19(o elabor)19(ate this point. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 179.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
9.5 0 2.01929 9.5 51.4 179.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0031 tc
(a)tj
0.84237 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.009 tw
(predominance of systematic knowledge/emphasis on disciplinary knowledge.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 51.4 167.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
(priority is giv)tj
6.0431 0 td
[(en t)19(o w)18(ell-est)19(ablished f)19(acts allo)18(wing schools t)19(o maint)19(ain a)]tj
-6.0431 -1.26316 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(close r)19(elationship with the r)18(esults of academic kno)19(wledge pr)19(oduction. l)18(o)19(w pri-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.003 tw
[(ority is giv)19(en t)18(o open and contr)19(o)19(v)19(er)18(sial ar)19(eas of kno)19(wledge and t)18(o per)19(sonal)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(e)19(xperience and inv)19(olv)18(ement.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 55 107.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.029 tc
-0.001 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education, thr)19(ough its engagement of envir)19(onment)19(a)1(l)1( )1(i)1(s)1(s)1(u)1(e)1(s)37(,)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
0.134 tw
[(thriv)19(es on the educativ)18(e e)19(xplor)19(ation of \322)55(contr)19(o)19(v)19(er)19(sial ar)18(eas of kno)19(wledge\323)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.02 tw
[(such as contested pr)19(oposals f)18(or envir)19(onment)19(al change)55(. p)56(articipat)19(ory envir)18(on-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tw
[(ment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch b)19(y definition inv)18(olv)19(es st)19(ak)18(eholder)19(s in envir)19(onmen-)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(124)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/length 8148
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.035 tc
0.004 tw
[(t)19(al education in the pr)18(ocesses of r)19(esear)19(ch\321identification of issues of inter)19(est and)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
-0.007 tw
[(concern, collabor)19(ativ)18(e gathering and analy)19(sis of dat)19(a, r)18(esponding t)19(o conte)19(xtu)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.036 tc
0.005 tw
[(al e)19(xigenc)18(y)111(, and r)19(eporting of out)18(comes)37(. owing t)19(o its pr)18(axiological natur)19(e\321wher)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
[(kno)19(wledge gener)18(ation is mediated b)19(y critical r)19(eflection on action and cir)18(cum-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.128 tw
[(st)19(ance\321per)18(sonal e)19(xperience and inv)19(olv)19(ement ar)18(e centr)19(al t)19(o participat)19(ory)]tj
t*
-0.034 tc
0.003 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch. p)55(articipat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch questions and critiques \322)56(a pr)19(e-dominance of sy)18(s-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.043 tc
0.012 tw
[(tematic (disciplinary) kno)19(wledge\323 and \322priority . . . giv)19(e)-1(n)-1( )-1(t)17(o w)19(e)-1(l)-1(l)-1(-)-1(e)-1(s)-1(t)18(ablished f)18(acts)37<2ed3>]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 492.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
9.5 0 2.01929 9.5 87.4 492.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
(specialization)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 138.1161 492.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0157 tc
(.)tj
0.52344 0 td
-0.016 tc
-0.001 tw
[(kno)19(wledge is compartment)18(aliz)19(ed in subject matter fields which)]tj
-5.86198 -1.26316 td
-0.003 tc
-0.005 tw
[(mor)19(e or less corr)18(espond t)19(o the academic disciplines)37(. comple)19(x, r)18(eal-life situ-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(ations tend t)19(o be disr)18(egar)19(ded because the)19(y cr)19(oss disciplinary boundaries)37(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 91 445.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.008 tc
-0.014 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education actually deals in \322)56(comple)19(x, r)18(eal-life situations\323)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.032 tw
[(which ar)19(e nearly alw)18(a)19(y)19(s \322)55(adisciplinary\323 in natur)19(e)56(. envir)18(onment)19(al education)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
0.133 tw
[(seeks t)19(o inv)18(olv)19(e 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛
 in envir)19(onment)18(al pr)19(oblem-solving which r)19(ar)18(ely)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.137 tw
[(benefits fr)19(om a disciplinary per)18(spectiv)19(e)56(. envir)19(onment)18(al issues ar)19(e one of)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
-0.008 tw
[(the main subject matter)19(s of envir)18(onment)19(al education. y)80(et the specializ)18(ed dis-)]tj
t*
(ciplinary structur)tj
7.07431 0 td
(e)tj
0.74224 0 td
(of school curricula is not w)tj
11.1633 0 td
(ell suited t)tj
4.24441 0 td
(o)tj
0.77914 0 td
(this w)tj
2.48249 0 td
(ork. r)tj
2.50148 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.20771 0 td
(ch)tj
-31.19508 -1.20002 td
-0.011 tc
-0.011 tw
(in envir)tj
3.19533 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.30351 0 td
-0.011 tw
(al education must challenge these institutional structur)tj
22.9258 0 td
(es; the)tj
-29.42464 -1.20001 td
-0.023 tc
0.001 tw
[(alternativ)19(e is t)18(o conduct r)19(esear)19(ch in a w)19(a)18(y that t)19(ak)18(es these structur)19(es f)19(or gr)18(ant-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
-0.006 tw
(ed, and t)tj
3.66443 0 td
-0.0155 tc
(o)tj
0.77764 0 td
-0.016 tc
(do this r)tj
3.40394 0 td
-0.015 tc
0 tw
(einf)tj
1.56739 0 td
-0.016 tc
(or)tj
0.85718 0 td
-0.015 tc
-0.006 tw
(ces and r)tj
3.77429 0 td
(eifies the structur)tj
7.19326 0 td
(es themselv)tj
4.93586 0 td
[(es and the v)19(al-)]tj
-26.17399 -1.20002 td
-0.008 tc
-0.002 tw
(ues inf)tj
2.81315 0 td
(orming them. ir)tj
6.74841 0 td
0 tw
(onically)tj
3.16018 0 td
-0.0079 tc
(,)tj
0.53847 0 td
-0.008 tc
-0.002 tw
[(in attempting t)19(o e)18(xplor)19(e issues posed b)19(y this)]tj
-13.26021 -1.20001 td
0.066 tw
[(dissonance)56(, participat)18(ory r)19(esear)19(ch encounter)18(s and must deal with the con-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.029 tc
0 tw
(serv)tj
1.66041 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.43848 0 td
-0.0292 tc
(e)tj
0.72703 0 td
-0.029 tc
(vie)tj
1.15267 0 td
-0.0292 tc
(w)tj
0.98599 0 td
-0.029 tc
0.007 tw
(that these structur)tj
7.31291 0 td
(es ar)tj
1.91657 0 td
-0.0292 tc
(e)tj
0.72701 0 td
-0.029 tc
(\322part of schools and schooling\323 and that)tj
-15.92107 -1.20002 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.34329 0 td
-0.008 tc
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.23797 0 td
[(ch should not support the critiquing of these structur)19(es of schooling.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 278.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
9.5 0 2.01929 9.5 87.4 278.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0175 tc
(a)tj
0.82799 0 td
-0.018 tc
0.005 tw
(transmission mode of teaching)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 212.2771 278.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
(.)tj
0.52597 0 td
0.002 tw
[(this mode f)19(acilit)18(ates the r)19(etention of the sy)19(s-)]tj
-13.67092 -1.26316 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(tematic char)19(acter of kno)18(wledge and its r)19(econstruction b)19(y the student. it)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(tends t)tj
2.94458 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(o)tj
0.81467 0 td
0 tc
(discour)tj
3.1282 0 td
[(age the gener)19(ation and r)18(eflectiv)19(e handling of kno)19(wledge)56(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 91 231.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tw
[(p)56(articipat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch assumes)37(, encour)18(ages)37(, and is mediated b)19(y r)18(eflec-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.022 tc
0.131 tw
[(tiv)19(e pr)18(actice\321\322the gener)19(ation and r)19(eflectiv)18(e handling of kno)19(wledge)56<2ed3>]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(p)56(articipat)18(ory r)19(esear)19(ch challenges the vie)18(w that kno)19(wledge gener)19(ation is the)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.006 tw
(domain of centr)tj
6.91206 0 td
(ally located authorit)tj
8.52461 0 td
0 tw
(ativ)tj
1.55493 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77146 0 td
(e)tj
0.4812 0 td
0 tc
(xperts)tj
2.66651 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.54943 0 td
0 tc
-0.006 tw
(and supports the gener)tj
9.96194 0 td
(a)tj
0.5 0 td
(-)tj
-31.92214 -1.20002 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
(tion of ne)tj
3.92996 0 td
-0.0239 tc
(w)tj
0.9989 0 td
<d2>tj
0.36441 0 td
-0.024 tc
(community-based\323 kno)tj
9.66503 0 td
(wledge thr)tj
4.32838 0 td
(ough a pr)tj
3.89871 0 td
(ocess of critical r)tj
6.83623 0 td
0 tw
(eflec-)tj
-30.02162 -1.20002 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
(tion on pr)tj
4.17633 0 td
0 tw
(actitioner)tj
4.00483 0 td
-0.007 tw
[(s\325 theories)37(, pr)18(actices)37(, and the pr)19(ofessional conte)19(xts with)-1(-)]tj
-8.18116 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.104 tw
(in which these ar)tj
7.71945 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.88224 0 td
0 tc
[(made intelligible)56(. t)79(r)19(ansmissiv)19(e modes of learning ar)19(e)]tj
-8.60169 -1.2 td
0 tw
(anathema t)tj
4.90771 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.81477 0 td
0 tc
(participat)tj
4.07317 0.00001 td
[(ory r)19(esear)18(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 125.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
<a5>tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
9.5 0 2.01929 9.5 87.4 125.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0278 tc
(a)tj
0.81771 0 td
-0.028 tc
0.015 tw
(prevalence of top-down communication)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 239.7368 125.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0254 tc
(.)tj
0.51657 0 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(this discour)19(ages self-contr)18(ol and coop-)]tj
-16.552 -1.2632 td
0 tc
0.067 tw
[(er)19(ation among 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛
)36(, and among teacher)19(s)37(, and netw)19(orking within and)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(acr)19(oss school boundaries )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 91 78.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(p)tj
0.5236 0 td
0.005 tc
0.133 tw
[(articipat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch usually begins with the est)19(ablishment of net)-1(-)]tj
-2.3236 -1.2 td
0 tc
(w)tj
0.7495 0 td
0.009 tc
0.129 tw
(orks of pr)tj
4.52008 0.00001 td
0 tw
(ofessionals)tj
4.80804 0.00001 td
0.0095 tc
(,)tj
0.70428 0 td
0.009 tc
0.129 tw
(often acr)tj
4.04777 0.00001 td
(oss schools)tj
5.04896 0.00001 td
0.0095 tc
(,)tj
0.7043 0 td
0.009 tc
[(educational agencies)37(, and)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 119.5884 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental education: some issues)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1572 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(125)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
19 0 obj
<<
/length 6193
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(r)19(egional bor)19(der)18(s)37(. p)56(articipat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch seeks t)19(o build pr)18(ofessional capacity\321)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(t)19(o cr)18(eate the conditions f)19(or pr)19(ofessional self-de)18(v)19(elopment. p)56(articipat)18(ory)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(c)1(h)1( )1(c)1(r)1(i)1(t)1(i)1(q)1(u)1(e)1(s)1( )1(r)20(ather than r)18(einf)19(o)1(r)19(ces the po)19(w)19(e)1(r)1( )1(r)20(elationships immanent)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(in t)19(op-do)18(wn and centr)19(e-periphery structur)19(es)36(.)]tj
0 -2.27451 td
-0.006 tc
0.024 tw
[(t)88(w)18(o other elements of technocr)19(atic r)18(ationality that ar)19(e at odds with partici-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.007 tc
-0.012 tw
[(pat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch ar)19(e its assumption of the centr)18(ality of the scientific tenets of)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0 tw
[(objectivity)111(, r)18(ationality and truth, and the division of labour built int)19(o such hier-)]tj
t*
0.012 tc
0.121 tw
[(ar)19(chical pr)18(ocesses as the common \322r)19(esear)19(ch, de)19(v)18(elopment, diffusion,)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.009 tw
[(a)56(doption\323 \(rdd)56(a\) model of pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)19(elopment and curriculum de)18(v)19(el-)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
0.136 tw
[(opment in envir)19(onment)18(al education. r)19(ather than adopting an objectivist)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.026 tw
[(epistemology and r)19(ealist ont)18(ology)111(, participat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch ackno)19(wledges the)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.007 tw
[(socially constructed natur)19(e of kno)18(wledge about envir)19(onment)19(al issues)37(. r)18(ather)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.004 tw
[(than r)19(einf)18(or)19(cing a division in the r)18(ole of r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s and teacher)19(s)37(, participa-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(t)18(ory r)19(esear)19(ch seeks t)18(o pr)19(omote the concept of \322pr)19(actitioner-as-r)18(esear)19(cher)111<2ed3>]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(it is our vie)19(w)110(, based on e)19(xperience in pr)19(ojects such as those outlined ear)-1(-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0 tw
(lier)tj
1.23463 0 td
-0.0062 tc
(,)tj
0.53585 0 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
(that t)tj
2.21556 0 td
-0.0062 tc
(o)tj
0.79483 0 td
-0.006 tc
(be successful, participat)tj
10.12865 0 td
[(ory r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education)]tj
-14.90952 -1.20001 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(must be self-conscious about addr)19(essing \(and r)19(edr)18(essing\) each of these ele-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(ments of an hist)19(orical technocr)18(atic r)19(ationality in the field. w)93(e suggest that it)]tj
t*
[(is a common pitf)19(all t)18(o attempt participat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al edu-)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0.131 tw
[(c)-5(a)-5(t)-5(i)-5(o)-5(n)-5( )-5(w)-5(h)-5(e)-5(r)14(e)-5( )-5(t)-5(h)-5(e)-5( )-5(b)-5(r)13(oader instrument)19(alist fr)19(ame)18(w)19(ork is left subst)19(antially)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.007 tw
[(int)19(act. f)55(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, t)18(o appar)19(ently r)19(ecogniz)19(e and v)18(alue localiz)19(ed, community-)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0.096 tw
[(based, participat)19(ory envir)18(onment)19(al education \(whether this be curriculum)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.006 tw
[(de)19(v)19(elopment, pr)19(ofessional de)18(v)19(elopment, or r)19(esear)19(ch itself\) while at the same)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.134 tw
[(time attempting t)19(o de)18(v)19(elop single-f)19(ocus)37(, highly visible)56(, e)18(xternally-funded)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
-0.001 tw
[(curriculum pack)19(ages f)18(or univ)19(er)19(sal implement)19(ation is t)18(o f)19(ail t)19(o see the \322big pic-)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(t)6(u)6(r)25(e)6<d3>6( )6(o)6(f)6( )6(t)6(h)6(e)6( )6(p)6(e)6(r)6(v)24(a)6(s)6(i)6(v)25(e)6( )6(r)25(o)6(l)6(e)-258(of technocr)18(atic educational pr)19(ocesses and structur)19(e)1(s)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(and t)19(o court \322)55(colonialist critique\323 of the kind pr)19(offer)19(ed b)19(y dillon (1999).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 170.7444 231.6165 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(conclusions)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 208.8165 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
(in this article w)tj
6.34497 0 td
-0.0186 tc
(e)tj
0.7454 0 td
-0.019 tc
0 tw
(ha)tj
1.00002 0 td
0.005 tw
[(v)18(e r)19(eflected on methodological issues arising in tw)19(o of our)]tj
-8.09039 -1.20001 td
0 tc
-0.002 tw
[(o)19(wn r)19(ecent r)18(esear)19(ch pr)19(ojects as a f)18(orm of pr)19(actice)56(, as a w)18(a)19(y of engaging in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.0207 tc
(a)tj
0.74325 0 td
-0.021 tc
0 tw
(pr)tj
0.86591 0 td
0.007 tw
(axis of pr)tj
3.8434 0 td
(oject r)tj
2.54716 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.17392 0 td
0.007 tw
(ch. the pr)tj
4.17861 0 td
[(ojects that w)19(e ha)18(v)19(e chosen f)18(or this purpose)]tj
-14.35225 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
(ar)tj
0.85107 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77326 0 td
0 tc
(themselv)tj
3.90769 0 td
-0.005 tw
[(es concerned with teacher education in envir)19(onment)18(al educa-)]tj
-5.53202 -1.20001 td
0.028 tw
(tion: the)tj
3.62049 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(y)tj
0.82498 0 td
0 tc
[(include participat)19(ory \322r)18(eflectiv)19(e pr)19(actice\323 pr)18(ocesses in e)19(xploring)]tj
-4.44547 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(issues r)19(elating t)18(o f)19(ormal education in schools and inf)18(ormal education in com-)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(munities; and the)19(y ar)18(e r)19(ooted in specific conte)19(xts of de)18(v)19(eloping countries)37(, thus)]tj
t*
0.007 tc
0.131 tw
[(engaging post-colonialist educational and r)19(esear)19(ch issues)36(. one of these)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(pr)tj
0.907 0 td
0.059 tw
[(ojects w)19(as conducted in post-apartheid south africa, the other in south)]tj
-0.907 -1.2 td
0.01 tw
[(america. in both cases)37(, the author)18(s w)19(er)19(e among r)18(esear)19(ch teams invited t)19(o)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(participate in these pr)19(ojects b)18(y pr)19(oject or)19(ganiz)18(er)19(s)37(.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(126)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/length 5931
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 91 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
0.012 tw
[(w)92(e then pr)19(esented a number of issues arising in the conduct of partici-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.029 tc
0.01 tw
[(pat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch. these issues included questioning whose r)19(esear)19(ch agenda gets)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.007 tc
-0.013 tw
[(t)18(o be e)19(xplor)19(ed, the import)18(ance of pr)19(oject partner)19(ships)37(, participants\325 pr)18(econ-)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0 tw
[(ceptions about the natur)19(e of r)18(esear)19(ch, what "rigor" is in participat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.008 tw
[(in envir)19(onment)18(al education, the colonialist dilemma and a)19(v)19(oiding the "pack-)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
-0.001 tw
[(age or perish" ment)19(ality)110(, and the bigger pictur)19(e of technocr)19(atic r)19(ationality and)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.021 tc
0.001 tw
[(participat)19(ory r)18(esear)19(ch. each of these r)19(aises mor)18(e questions than ar)19(e answ)19(er)18(ed)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.027 tc
0.007 tw
[(her)19(e; w)18(e hope that the)19(y f)19(orm the basis f)18(or further discussion. ho)19(w)18(e)19(v)19(er)110(, in addi-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.019 tc
-0.001 tw
[(tion t)19(o addr)18(essing these mor)19(e or less specific issues)37(, w)18(e belie)19(v)19(e it is import)18(ant)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.011 tw
[(t)18(o consider the br)19(oader conte)19(xt within which participat)18(ory r)19(esear)18(ch is locat-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.009 tw
[(ed. it is our vie)19(w)110(, based on e)19(xperience in pr)19(ojects such as those outlined ear-)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.012 tw
[(lier)111(, that t)18(o be successful, participat)19(ory r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
[(must be self-conscious about addr)19(essing \(and r)18(edr)19(essing\) the hist)19(orical tech)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.009 tw
[(nocr)19(atic r)18(ationality in the field. w)93(e ha)19(v)18(e suggested that it is a common pitf)19(all)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0.131 tw
[(t)19(o attempt participat)18(ory r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education wher)18(e the)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
0 tw
[(br)19(oader instrument)18(alist fr)19(ame)19(w)18(ork is left subst)19(antially int)18(act. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 220.2285 374.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(notes)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
7 0 0 7 73 353.8716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 351.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.012 tw
[(aspects of this pr)19(oject and its implications f)18(or pr)19(ofessional de)19(v)18(elopment in)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0.022 tc
0 tw
(envir)tj
2.295 0 td
0.147 tw
[(onment)19(al education ha)18(v)19(e been described pr)19(e)18(viously in l)19(otz and)]tj
-2.295 -1.26316 td
0.01 tc
0.129 tw
[(r)19(obott)19(om (1998), l)19(egr)18(ange et al. (1999), r)19(obott)19(om and k)37(yburz-gr)18(aber)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[((2000) and r)19(obott)18(om (2003).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
7 0 0 7 73 305.8716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 303.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(http://www)tj
4.74073 0 td
[(.unites)37(.uqam.ca/ere-uq)56(am/ed)55(amaz)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 182.9719 269.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(notes on contributors)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 247.1616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
0.128 tw
[(i)-17(an r)37(obott)18(om)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 138.3031 247.1616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
0.12 tw
[(is associate pr)19(ofessor in the f)55(aculty of education at deakin)]tj
-6.53031 -1.2 td
-0.022 tc
-0.009 tw
[(univ)19(er)18(sity)111(. he has r)19(esear)18(ch and teaching inter)19(ests in envir)19(onment)19(al education,)]tj
t*
-0.043 tc
0.012 tw
(science education, pr)tj
8.29048 0 td
(ofessional de)tj
5.0846 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.43839 0 td
-0.043 tc
(elopment, and community-based participat)tj
17.04667 0 td
0 tw
(ory)tj
-30.86014 -1.20001 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.32647 0 td
-0.025 tc
-0.006 tw
[(esear)19(ch. he is particularly inter)18(ested in r)19(efle)19(xiv)18(e f)19(orms of r)19(esear)18(ch that seek t)19(o)]tj
-0.32647 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0 tw
(engage the ne)tj
5.83887 0 td
(xus betw)tj
3.75477 0 td
(een r)tj
2.1195 0 td
(esear)tj
2.19348 0 td
(ch theory and pr)tj
6.91872 0 td
(oject r)tj
2.56784 0 td
(esear)tj
2.19347 0 td
(ch pr)tj
2.12023 0 td
(actice)tj
2.34355 0 td
0 tc
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 175.1616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(l)tj
0.50695 0 td
-0.011 tc
0.137 tw
(ucie sauv\216)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
10 0 0 10 130.4267 175.1616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
0.129 tw
(is pr)tj
1.96041 0 td
[(ofessor at the f)56(acult\216 des sciences de l\325\216ducation of the)]tj
-7.70308 -1.2 td
-0.034 tc
0.009 tw
[(univ)19(er)18(sit\216 du qu\216bec \210 montr\216al \(uq)56(am\) and chairholder of the r)19(esear)19(ch chair)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
0.133 tw
[(of canada in envir)19(onment)18(al education. she is member of the institute of)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
0.132 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al sciences)37(, dir)19(ect)19(or of the uq)55(am post gr)19(aduate pr)19(ogr)19(am in)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
-0.007 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education, and co-dir)19(ect)19(or of the international r)19(esear)18(ch journal)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
[(\203ducation r)19(elativ)18(e \210 l'envir)19(onnement. her national and international cooper-)]tj
t*
-0.037 tc
0.011 tw
[(ation r)19(esear)18(ch pr)19(ojects f)19(ocus on pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)18(elopment in envir)19(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)18(al edu-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
0 tw
[(cation, on community education and envir)19(onment)18(al health edu)1(cation.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 119.5884 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(reflecting on participatory research in environmental education: some issues)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 401.1572 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(127)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/length 13710
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 171.7622 587.4685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(references)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37 565.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(dillon, j. (1999). [r)19(e)19(vie)18(w of] l)19(earning f)19(or a sust)18(ainable envir)19(onment. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 306.8585 565.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.005 tc
[(envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
-29.63041 -1.29412 td
0 tc
[(education r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 124.0687 554.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 128.7919 554.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(5)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 133.2017 554.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((2), 223-227.)tj
-11.31785 -1.29412 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(hart, p)148(., r)18(obott)19(om, i., & t)148(a)18(ylor)111(, m. (1994). dilemmas in participat)19(ory enquiry: a case study)]tj
2.11765 -1.29412 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
(of method-in-action. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 131.6879 532.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.012 tw
[(assessment and ev)19(aluation in higher education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 299.2411 532.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0016 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 303.8355 532.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
(19)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 312.6351 532.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[((3), 20)56(1-2)55(14.)]tj
-32.42766 -1.29412 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(her)19(on, j. (1998). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 100.2748 521.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(co-oper)19(ativ)18(e inquiry: r)19(esear)19(ch int)18(o the human condition)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 298.5161 521.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
0 tc
[(l)19(ondon: sage)55(.)]tj
-31.32227 -1.29412 td
0.052 tw
[(l)19(ammerink, m. p)148(. & w)92(olffer)19(s)37(, i. (1998). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 185.9972 510.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.048 tw
[(appr)19(oches participativ)18(es pour un d\216v)19(eloppement)]tj
-15.41144 -1.29412 td
0 tw
[(dur)19(able)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 81.2678 499.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55564 0 td
0 tc
[(p)56(aris/douala: institut panafricain pour le d\216v)18(eloppement.)]tj
-5.76361 -1.29412 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(l)74(e boterf, g. \(198)56(1\). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 111.8371 488.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.011 tw
[(l)167(\325enqu\220te participation en question : analy)18(se d\325une e)19(xp\216rience)37(, descrip-)]tj
-6.68672 -1.29412 td
[(tion d\325une m\216thode et r\216fle)19(xions critiques)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 199.1451 477.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0025 tc
(.)tj
0.53941 0 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(p)57(aris: ligue fr)18(ancaise de l\325enseignement et)]tj
-17.49766 -1.29412 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(de l\325education permanente)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.29412 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(l)18(egr)19(ange)56(, l., mak)19(ou, t)129(., neluvhalani, e., r)19(eddy)111(, c., & r)18(obott)19(om, i. (1999). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 300.636 455.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
0.004 tw
[(pr)19(ofessional self-)]tj
-28.89835 -1.29412 td
-0.01 tc
-0.003 tw
[(de)19(v)18(elopment in envir)19(onment)19(al education: the case of the \322educating f)18(or socio-ecological)]tj
0 -1.29411 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(change pr)19(oject.\323)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 115.5625 433.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(unpublished manuscript, gr)19(ahamst)18(o)19(wn, south africa.)]tj
-9.24265 -1.29412 td
-0.014 tc
[(l)19(otz, h. & r)19(obott)18(om, i. (1998). envir)19(onment as te)19(xt: initial insights int)18(o some implications)]tj
2.11765 -1.29412 td
0 tc
0.009 tw
[(f)19(or pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)19(elopment in envir)19(onment)18(al education. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 271.0601 411.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.008 tw
(southern african journal)tj
-25.41883 -1.29412 td
0 tw
[(of envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 153.0239 400.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 157.7471 400.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(18)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 166.5666 400.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.5557 0 td
0 tc
(19-28.)tj
-15.79883 -1.29412 td
(mr)tj
1.16601 0 td
(az)tj
0.94409 0 td
(ek, r. (ed.). (1993). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 128.7635 389.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alternativ)tj
4.10889 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.70241 0 td
0 tc
(par)tj
1.38776 0 td
(adigms in envir)tj
6.40275 0 td
(onment)tj
3.10962 0 td
(al education r)tj
5.66179 0.00001 td
(esear)tj
2.18238 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 337.0151 389.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55541 0 td
(t)tj
0.47616 0 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
(o)tj
0.51807 0 td
(y)tj
0.40795 0 td
(,)tj
-35.48692 -1.29413 td
[(ohio: north american association f)19(or envir)18(onment)19(al education.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.29412 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(or)19(ellana, i. (2002). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 107.55 367.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(l)18(a communaut\216 d\325appr)19(entissage en \216ducation r)19(elativ)18(e \210 l\325envir)19(onnement)]tj
-6.18235 -1.29412 td
-0.0015 tc
(:)tj
0.50345 0 td
-0.001 tc
-0.012 tw
[(signification, dynamique)37(,)1( )1(e)1(n)1(j)1(e)1(u)1(x)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 172.6182 356.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0015 tc
(.)tj
0.54047 0 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(unpublished doct)19(or)18(al thesis)37(, f)56(aculty of education,)]tj
-14.3779 -1.29412 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(univ)19(er)18(sit\216 du qu\216bec \210 montr\216al., montr)19(eal.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.29412 td
0.007 tw
[(p)56(osch, p)148(. (1988). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 100.1354 334.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.006 tw
[(the pr)19(oject \322envir)18(onment and school initiativ)19(es)36<2ed3>]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 276.0362 334.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.007 tw
[(p)56(aper pr)19(esented at the)]tj
-26.00426 -1.29412 td
0 tw
(envir)tj
2.25781 0 td
[(onment and school initiativ)19(es international confer)18(ence)56(, linz.)]tj
-4.37546 -1.29412 td
(p)tj
0.5332 0 td
0.015 tc
0.124 tw
(osch, p)tj
3.19285 0 td
(.)tj
0.70985 0 td
[((1997). social change and envir)19(onment)18(al education. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 281.4958 312.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(a)tj
0.5881 0 td
0.014 tc
(ustr)tj
1.68613 0 td
0.115 tw
(alian journal of)tj
-28.92079 -1.29413 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 143.8972 301.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 148.6204 301.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(13)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 157.4399 301.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55565 0 td
0 tc
(1-6.)tj
-14.72505 -1.29412 td
(r)tj
0.61108 0 td
(obott)tj
2.24073 0 td
-0.01 tw
(om, i. (1987). t)tj
6.64204 0 td
(w)tj
0.73999 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.80472 0 td
0 tc
[(par)19(adigms of pr)18(ofessional de)19(v)19(elopment in envir)19(onment)18(al edu-)]tj
-8.92091 -1.29413 td
0 tw
(cation. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 82.2266 279.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(the envir)19(onment)18(alist)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 157.5935 279.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 162.3166 279.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(7)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 166.7264 279.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((4), 29)56(1-298.)]tj
-15.26193 -1.29412 td
(r)tj
0.58675 0 td
-0.024 tc
(obott)tj
2.11908 0 td
0.01 tw
(om, i. )tj
2.68359 0 td
-0.052 tc
0 tw
((1993). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 108.0091 268.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(p)tj
0.48848 0 td
-0.049 tc
(olicy)tj
1.58933 0 td
-0.0489 tc
(,)tj
0.43002 0 td
-0.049 tc
(pr)tj
0.79169 0 td
(actice)tj
2.05828 0.00001 td
-0.0489 tc
(,)tj
0.43002 0 td
-0.049 tc
(pr)tj
0.79169 0 td
0.01 tw
(ofessional de)tj
4.74394 0 td
[(v)19(elopment and participat)18(ory r)19(esear)18(ch: sup)1(porting)]tj
-17.55984 -1.29414 td
-0.026 tc
-0.005 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al initiativ)19(es in a)56(ustr)18(alian schools)37(. an a)56(ustr)18(alian r)19(eport t)19(o the envir)18(onment and)]tj
0 -1.29412 td
0 tw
[(school initiativ)19(es (ensi) pr)18(oject \(r)19(eport\))]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 186.737 246.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0279 tc
(.)tj
0.50021 0 td
-0.028 tc
[(geelong, vict)19(oria: deakin univ)18(er)19(sity)111(.)]tj
-18.11633 -1.29412 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.61108 0 td
(obott)tj
2.24073 0 td
0.123 tw
(om, i. (2000). envir)tj
8.83238 0.00001 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.36987 0 td
0.123 tw
(al education and the issue of coher)tj
15.79562 0 td
0 tw
(ence)tj
1.98095 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 321.8332 235.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.115 tw
(themes in)tj
-31.39214 -1.29412 td
0 tw
(education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 90.0957 224.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 94.8188 224.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 99.2286 224.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((3), 227-24)56(1.)]tj
-7.32101 -1.29412 td
-0.011 tc
0.016 tw
[(r)8(o)-11(bott)19(om, i. \(in pr)18(ess\). communities)37(, envir)19(onment)19(al issues and envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
2.11765 -1.29412 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.33996 0 td
-0.011 tc
0 tw
[(esear)19(ch. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 89.7758 202.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
(education r)tj
4.88471 0 td
[(elativ)19(e a l)166(\325envir)19(onnement : r)19(egar)18(ds; r)19(echer)19(ches; r)18(efle)19(xion)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 333.6673 202.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0114 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 338.2016 202.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(4)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 342.5232 202.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.94391 -1.29412 td
(r)tj
0.61108 0 td
(obott)tj
2.24073 0 td
-0.004 tw
[(om, i. & hart, p)148(. (1993). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 151.3959 191.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r)tj
0.61108 0 td
(esear)tj
2.18238 0 td
-0.004 tw
[(ch in envir)19(onment)18(al education: engaging the debate)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6388 191.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.48692 -1.29412 td
[(geelong, vict)19(oria: deakin univ)18(er)19(sity pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.29412 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(r)19(obott)19(om, i. & k)37(yburz-gr)18(aber)111(, r. (2000). r)19(ecent international de)18(v)19(elopments in pr)19(ofessional)]tj
2.11765 -1.29412 td
-0.011 tc
0 tw
(de)tj
1.01625 0 td
-0.003 tw
[(v)18(elopment in envir)19(onment)19(al education: r)18(eflections and issues)37(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 290.5549 158.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
-0.003 tw
(canadian journal of)tj
-27.71234 -1.29412 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 143.8972 147.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 148.6204 147.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(5)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 153.0301 147.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55568 0 td
0 tc
(1-19.)tj
-14.20628 -1.29412 td
0.014 tw
[(sauv\216, l. \(200)56(1\). r)18(echer)19(che et f)19(ormation en \216ducation r)19(elativ)18(e \210 l\325envir)19(onnement : une)]tj
2.11765 -1.29412 td
0 tw
(dynamique r\216fle)tj
7.07398 0.00001 td
[(xiv)19(e)56(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 134.48 125.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(\203ducation permanente)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 213.6175 125.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 218.3407 125.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(148)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 231.5701 125.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55557 0 td
(3)tj
0.50009 0.00001 td
0 tc
(1-44.)tj
-23.9463 -1.2941 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(sauv\216, l. & or)19(ellana, i. (2002). a f)18(orma\215ao continuada de pr)19(ofesor)19(es em educa\215\213o)]tj
2.1176 -1.2941 td
0 tc
0.019 tw
[(ambient)19(al. in j. do sant)18(os & m. sat)19(o \(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 217.6135 103.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(a)tj
0.90627 0 td
0 tc
0.018 tw
[(contribu\215\213o de educa\215\213o ambient)19(al \210)]tj
-20.0373 -1.2941 td
0 tw
[(esper)19(an\215a de p)36(andor)19(a)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 135.3723 92.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((pp. 272-288). s\213o carlos: rima.)tj
-11.5732 -1.2941 td
-0.058 tc
(smith-sebast)tj
4.921 0 td
0.005 tw
(o, n. (2000). p)tj
5.37292 0.00001 td
(otential guidelines f)tj
7.24392 0.00001 td
[(or conducting and r)19(eporting envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
-15.4202 -1.2941 td
-0.039 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch: qualit)18(ativ)19(e methods of inquiry)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 192.5154 70.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.036 tc
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(e)1(s)1(e)1(a)1(r)19(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 305.5087 70.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0392 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 309.5704 70.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 313.6715 70.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.039 tc
((1), 9-26.)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(ian robottom & lucie sauv\216)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(128)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
22 0 obj
<<
/nums[0<</st 111/s/d>>]
>>
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 38/ampersand 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon 63/question 65/a/b/c/d/e 71/g 73/i/j 76/l/m/n 80/p/q/r/s/t/u 87/w 90/z 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p 114/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 136/agrave 142/eacute 210/quotedblleft/quotedblright 213/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 7144
/length1 7144
>>
stream




aanhpi+eurostileregular

7�����
�?��
�?��ea���


d3fgmdujoh
p1bsqzti&wnev4*.c
%l6"-�2�$+5xy	
k#(;8 /iw[f
�

u
i
�)g�fi�.������3�%m�	n	b	�
u
}
�\�c{

�ugc��on��2o��7�o���b0q�x%n��->b��{���.��.����.��.������e���;�3���.���9b��$���ɫ���������#m�o�o�#��&�����.�����xf��e�;�(uhagg`;z�	�q�������izaiwwib���?��kk�{��+�d��jo�u��t���d�6�jjtsip��r�b���kk��k�d�+����dz������#m������ۭ���Ԟ���{l��l�h$�^�� ����������/�🬈����di�o�u+-�o�"�&��&��� ���u��� u� ���u�$ong}!�:��ii�z��3�6������Σ��
�~s��r�zar� �n�s��r!��/�2�igssgo��q�^���kj��k�@�����a��� !|hoo����p�z� �z�����i�1�=�m�f���p����v�\�/^^1�0^����������u�1� �1� �-�p� �p� �*�� ���n���y��|o��o�t9g��� ��r�[��[.���>!z)a������p����p����[�$��0��(&geuuep��s�m���ee��i�"�@�����t.xlgkkfc{!$h��mm�|�����8�__��u�#�4����ǿ������ r�>�]�-�$�8y hwwgbr��c��kj�{��2�0����ӣ���t^����c�vmq��a�b���nm��m�d�d�����Ȧ��b�ap�w��v���d�d�lnw��6�c�"�>�>|!mccm>w��>��mm�}��>�>������ؠ���vc��������nj�4������é��0�6o�s��s"��.w�����.��2Ɗ���y�h�h�8��uc`lk`)|�,�
������`���@��zk��k�d�
���i�'��<��"*u_uu_p;��v�*���7�������$� ��o�s��s���3�'(weyyer@��������u���q�x@�(o�y)j��kk�{��՛�����ї���~q��:�� ���t���0��z)��z�r�s��͋�i3��d��0^1t����� �p���.� ���6��a�2�����Ѧ��h�up�v��u*��"�5"]/[����
� �����[�!�6�(z)i\[ift"�a��gf�y��(�3����Ԥ���s[��&�!�p��>u�hr q!�f�g�a�h�'�>�)���p��w��p-f�sn@�}�{�x��������ͦ��������"�����)�����y�,�����2!ygvvgqd ��a�gg�� y�i�x'ex]guug?��-l��kk�{�����%�w�%�f�ee��x�1�,����ij����@4��a��#���-�\���˙�����͔��Ѓ{��{�ai� ��'�u��� ����߳���ڡ��'�c�$p��� ����i�����6(^2h����� ��l���
���
��g���i��i�e�g�b�7�p�6��x�6s9s:�q�r�v�7�=���$���p�]���p�0���� ���c���s� �m��_�� ���	�ڳ���֠���|m��m�r7�� ��z���u�4�
u o��h)��6�.#u u����$� �p���u����i�$��b�� +heuuep��g�w���dc��h�'�4������� u� p���[�/��=y�iyyh@r�!e��ii�{��4�%�뭻��ϣ���s[�����p���	v;b__b@v�7r��on�}���� ��s���t�3������� �p� ����l�l�.�l�.���l�.�l�.���a�m���`�^�qwhgwj#�/�t���|{�,��4���{�o�o�t8�v<cmmb�
}�d�.+��fe�y����-�n��+�'�yy��s�y�v�'���ͼ��
�<�/n�q�q����h��j��
�g�f�y΋����ʺ�����6����|�m�m�f���-�3l�m��}�u���.u�.��mu���p�"�}�t}iod�o�n�q�#�������.���������}�����k�l�f���.�e���ˍ���������b�b9���.u���!����
���2�_�*��'����Ѩ��i�rp�v��u+�� �f#\/k����� ��� ����[�$�2�*z'j[[jgs%�>��ii�{��a� �豺��գ���r[�����l�l��h�tnnr�?���������z�.�d���l�������z����h�9f��e���w����3����p�/�ji��i��1���vs�&\ji["k�7�q���{�u��� �c��*�c�q�w���-�k�d���k��� �g���-�u9_kk_�{�f�9$��aa�v���p�.�p]�'�'�ww��"q�e�r�&��������b�p�.�p�����5��u�l�����7����g������)����������������eso���@i�q�nȋ�Λ�����ϖ���~s��r�l&x�+����o�s��s"��-�1 s]rr]o4�1�;�fx�}���-wkjk[k[{6����l��
�v�u�/q�������-���
�^�;�����y�Ñ̋��Њ��,ln��)p�[�n�j���cc�w����ϣ���˦����k���u�����#�r��.�����izaiwwib���?��kk�{��+�d��jo�u��t���d�6�jjtsip��r�b���kk��k�d�+����dz������#m������ۭ���Ԟ���{l��l�h$�^���:���a���ic����a�h����є�(�v��j�pk��j�5������4eahgaj�e�����i�??��9e�����=����<�����?ge]�h�i�k���gf�y�9������9�������l�r�ry��y��r����5�[�	��d"�-������`���@��zk��k�d�
���i�'��<��"*u_uu_p;��v�*���7�������$� ��o�s��s���3�'(weyyer@��������u���q�x@�(o�y)j��kk�{��՛�����ї���~q��8�����i�����ac)������tc^on^�}�i�s���kj�{�t��:�������p��{l��k�e��a�-����.l�o��o�	��b���;os>i[ct}n}n��)�����ê�t�9�9�%c�y�����3�˹ʹ��	��n��-�:��|u�>�{5kgfkay��
a��mm�|�����+�]�um��0�yy��s�8�5�����ũ��5�w�.������������.l�n��m���l�x�t^nm^m,�$��?�c�c�m�x�)xklmam`|:����7�"�[�[�$t�r��^���ʿɿ��
��;��|�m�m�m�+���ũ���4�3�s�m%�ydimli<|��n���ba�w����Э�����0�8�t�����o�k%!etgsg[ta����u�/�n�o�o�}��
��Ӳ�����2�5�}p��������#�⭪����b��y������©�
��8��>k�l�k����l��d��ofufui�
��7�d�+����϶�����8��yh��h�?�	�y8hkhk&q�<y�fs�hs_s^o-��$���k������ctip�k�����c�i6��.a�����-����ͤ�r����q�zw��w�-������+jiu��"�y��8����z�8izyi�s�s�t���ii�{�8������8�������t�s�rz������
���{m��m�i'�x?ekke0|�"�l���dc�x����*:�0�&�[[��!s�l�[����Ϳ���3�z�i�i�g�$���ȧ�����܋��� j�k�k����\��x��ro[n[m%��0�u�&���Ю�����)�5�}q��p�b�#vkbtsb���lw�������u��.�/�����.u�r�(����#���#�q�:�.��m�g��p���a�:w8v8�x�x�c�9����`���c�9w8x8�w�w�a�:����'���p�h�����6�ܞ���:�:��6����d���p�*�e�
�p�l���m���<���\�����;�������;�������v�;�5��u�o�����9���ix���)������������)����Ť��e��0�.am8m7|���b�b����78��a�0���*q��x9����z��)�����������)xz[xqr+����/�赩��ߛ���b�b{��m��m.��/e����r[����u�1� �1� �-��9�yvyqxy�������(���������2���� �����!����Ũ��%�gb��$�������,�(q�w��w�
��;�����1����s��}p��p�p/!xffmlf8|��)�j���!�6�}o��o�a�)xjgmmg>|�	�������������f�_�o�2w)dfed%y�8�l���yy�s��@��w��i��=���������f�t�}q��q�f�i�+��+i�h��g�)��|�|�.ii??he��^��
��]�����/�ff��/i�����2����Ū�-��ˉ�������u�d�=��:�����ru�<���i�����.���`��`�,�����,����������u��Ԉ���������
�����������2u�h�����d�)�xe��e�4��>x#geef&x�8�2)��ee�x���%w� �-�\[��t�^�_�����˫��f�?j�	i��i���h�n�e@v���2����+�������
h�e��e���w�v�mqmlql��h��p�����y���mm��m�f�b�����ì�
�h�9l�m��m���k�`�b:q��������
��@��s��s�[c��z�s�*���>�*�j�5��w;dlkc(|�4�9%��cc�w��4��̹�����*�8�zk����u����`�-�k�)��x�wsxu���gb�whwh�x�y�d����k�x���jd�xixh�x΁�����c����i�2�7���z���i���ɜ���m�i�v�������k�~�bu�5�2��l�l�.�l�.�4��ڸ��ߩ������d�%o�t��s"��0�n�
qyqqxo �6�^�%�����֫���ڛ���|n��n�d��a;7k8k3iriqgqgk0�m�+���������:�aa��w�^�a�����ì��c��!����li�
h��g���d�_�nrlkrl��j�4� �ts��p�b�p������a�-x.eiie"{�@�+,��cc�w�����%�o�x�����g�-�,�udaoo`�~�d�5��gg�y����ݰ�����)�=�yg����#u�l��h�snnr�>���������[�.��vu��%�w�x�k�j���j���������.���������?�?��-���5��u�.������lj������ŏ��y~��0^m��[�.���lj���Ū�ʋ��v|��0^m��[�.��
u�l��h�snnr�>���������[�.���l��h�pknm�>���������[�.����l�l�.�l�.�d��������w��u������t��e����
endstream
endobj
25 0 obj
<<
/descent -512
/fontname/aanhpi+eurostileregular
/flags 32
/fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867]
/italicangle 0
/ascent 1775
/fontfile3 24 0 r
/xheight 0
/stemv 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/stemh 0
/capheight 1775
>>
endobj
26 0 obj
<<
/widths[250 0 0 0 0 0 700 0 277 277 0 0 198 208 195 646 613 614 613 613 613 613 613 613 614 614 195 0 0 0 0 520 0 608 617 597 653 498 0 619 0 204 502 0 485 858 696 0 590 655 623 560 515 655 0 999 0 0 567 0 0 0 0 0 0 510 511 485 510 502 265 510 514 188 186 430 188 826 516 506 510 0 398 474 326 507 402 670 404 389 403 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 510 0 0 0 0 0 502 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 319 319 0 198]
/name/f0
/fontdescriptor 25 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 23 0 r
/basefont/aanhpi+eurostileregular
/lastchar 213
/firstchar 32
>>
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[65/a 82/r 97/a/b/c 109/m 114/r/s/t/u 142/eacute]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
28 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 1943
/length1 1943
>>
stream




fqfemd+usherwood-bolditalic

@��
����^������
��
��
/
+
f�v

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bold italicitc usherwood



"ctusbd3�vn
�
 
�
�q�0�5�ӆ��r���������cq���t�y�o��������� �y��������pa�[��k���������$��f������x�$�������������y�x�x\\�\$�k�����{yy\h�z��[gvn�oy������������$������r�k-y�������w
�+�����������erle{)��kǨ�k}�t�ua��c�g�ft��a��f��;�<�\�@?tj[c��o�����z쬜di�f�:(bm���oy���
�����"��������o�d�:���en�4��"�a��)�bbl[�p�d���������g�wcskrg�x�w�����ȋ��%�av�狱�������p�j����~��y���ǘw��������xuggjk}�����������Ǩ����|�ȅtx�e?��&e^:_y2hxc�s���k�i�|o�p���Ƿ��o�v�
�
���)��y�������n~������𑜒����}�hicenp>4���������}�fccdtpfq�s��������mu\m���j���������$�y���
���b����]�_���ɶ�t�y|ssz�u}�����e��e���gt�]$�=�!�v�3f�?�ܽӾ����y+oy�,>n������u𚚇���oy���
���s���4pxz<jtl�����۫�vjw�x�y�w�ɖ������o�f�6��3�7��i����ñ�������m�f�p��
����d���������o����������$��a�n����������a΋���1�1�������������$��p�u�x�i���l����Ώ����?��rk��k҉ji�lyy��y�y�y�y�҄k�����a|�x�};��|kzk@�����������ּnk0>j�
c�=y����������\'��(�c����π�!���(���(ekbs=lg�ǒ�������p��
�t�>�a��6�7��o���������{sb�\ayƜ���ry��*w��h���z�����t�xzuys�r}���������>�������y�w{t��x i�n��������v<�
�q1u|�������ب𕯐������wqmrob:r�r��������wwz�v�}�n'�l�j�mi�g����Ȼ���y�r�vp�i�������^�v�v�����>���p�z�x�ʘ��b���zop�d�ly�}���������$������Ƌ��tt~�v�}�g��n�r�sv�i��������w�yqmp�|�������z��"�������g�ikpn8h���������a�b;9�sc���������~�f`rng_ks�s��������yk<m�e�f���������$y����f��`��������
�����
endstream
endobj
29 0 obj
<<
/descent -254
/fontname/fqfemd+usherwood-bolditalic
/flags 262242
/fontbbox[-202 -308 1068 850]
/italicangle -12
/ascent 684
/fontfile3 28 0 r
/xheight 694
/stemv 112
/type/fontdescriptor
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
>>
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/widths[722 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 685 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 556 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 852 0 0 0 0 463 463 389 593 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 481]
/name/f1
/fontdescriptor 29 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 27 0 r
/basefont/fqfemd+usherwood-bolditalic
/lastchar 142
/firstchar 65
>>
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 44/comma/hyphen/period 58/colon/semicolon 63/question 65/a/b/c/d 78/n 80/p 82/r 84/t 87/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 136/agrave 142/eacute/egrave 153/ocircumflex 165/bullet 199/guillemotleft/guillemotright 210/quotedblleft/quotedblright 213/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
32 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 6787
/length1 6787
>>
stream




rrsawv+usherwood-mediumitalic

@��
����w���w��
��
��
3
/
��f

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood medium italicitc usherwood


38f
sgmduponiehjbtvxqk
zy5wiwc t1$%"l#3/�r���[jx5
�


�$|�5~��*�>�-�	�
6
�
��>[�
l
�
�a�-s���d�u�z#o�]�\��������
�����a�����'��a���������$�����
��z�x�l�st��$�s�����za��i�
�]�n��t�u�tpj�x$�s�����hj�&e�!e�"�c��t�u�tpj�x$�s�����h��)��u��n���������$���by��%�
������
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*���t�v��a����3���<�#�������|{�������֐������y�uajbmo7.���������y�fz{��}�3k�{��������mt;z�hq)���������$��������w�k�s��c���u�8�ǔ����w�Ԁsn�pb����-���yx~�~�~��̛�������������pq��q�!q�,e|r�lj�m��c�ni�35�wx�������t�jt�z~y�wf���?��p�t��y�����w
���|�����rvy�wz����������ɣ䒮wtls}=��s���gr�r�s:��j�j�jg�d�������ty��%�
������
�
o�^qo\m�se�����-몦wev�v�w�~���������_�e��#�4�b"�p�͵�ѻ��y����w������wsonery������������������Ѐvy�qz������jc<uk*a�s�n���m�l�kv�{�������y��0�
������ty�$�
�#�/�<���$�	�%�-��?�$�h���-�تla�<�-'>q��-y�kv�/����-�|�t�?�:�������xlp�q�q�n��j�c�ij�d������Ĺ~�z�zzw�v~�������t���������i�y8n:>h���������{�jz{��}3k�{��������mt8x�nr2���������$�ky�kv�/����d��$�|�z�e�h������toy�e�of�����������$��b����݋��xlp�q�q�n��j�c�ij�d������Ĺ~�z�zzw�v~�������z���������i�y@f<nw���������r�p<)�en���������{�jz{��}3k�{��������kw;m�y}y���������$�y�kv�/����w���{�z���3������nkt�t�t�n��j�j�jg�d������������rvy�wz�������z���������h�x9:'xd����<�ɚȜ�wtls}=��s���gr�r�sw��y5u5v7���������$�y��%����w
���s��������rvy�w{�����ɷ�kwtls}=��s���gz�}�z}np�n�n��3��a�1 �n��ｧ���x�v�vb�]����������#��,ﴳne_7���_k���*����z�� �
�����#���i�t�����kl�l$�j��p�-,�r�ڴɵ���o�t�n�(�vd�������o�xduesfn��\��q���'�������
������l�
������%bv�{�_p���y��dw����{�a���������rvy�{~�������ȫ��������z�mwt��z3k�{��������vxw�z�w�d�.�m�l�ld�a������$��������w�soknar�s��*y��%�
���[��|�y�{~{|w�t�����h��v���zlm�k$�,�(�q�74�p�ݸݻ�������k�i������������m�������ra�2~kq�\hd�d�y����ty��0�
�������������r�_�0�%�cr�7�� �d��"�`h^e�u�[���������r�wjwlul�g�g���	��͋���!�d{������ċ���r�b���-y�m������y��)Ҁ�t�������rvy�wz������[���{�wyw||s�s��������~y.'���ko����œ���ěƳ�z�kv{��z3k�{��������w}�io�'�hb�f����ɽ���v�s�sg�a�������
�����f��3��j��d�����o�s��������zx,��0`x���������x�}�{�z�{xy�x$�s�����e*��
bl��������1s�zrvz{wku�w����������\�$b�a�b���������$�����Ǝp�p�p�n�p�o���������$���y�`����p}w��s��}v�v�p��$����v��q��֝֜י���}~�}uw����������k�v���8��v�&�x�a-f�`p���������{�kz{��}3k�{��������tsx�t�zr���q��euq�_�����w���_n�f�@�
ey�������gw���'�b���j�����Σ�|�lvu��z3k�{��������uzr�m�sn��i�(h=k�vy�������m�ygwiuhq��i��8��(��(��������w�soknar�s��Ѡv�h�
�����f������ˆ�׵lot��zhb�z?a�y�
����������u�mkolmx�y������werozi�������
c��v��f����o�s��������xq6��.`?�����-ux{~z<l�v������ђ��6'.�ds����o�r�t�t�u�ww%���������b���]����~�o}w��s�y��qv�2�i��������a�q�h�iŋ�����ü}�x}wts�dy��}t�˧��ź���{z���o���y�v�qgoyi`k�}�}�b�psyzv�my�v��������mu��+cenxhry�st��yw{�c�v�x�����ŭ�y�
���y�����{�tossku�w�?���ŵ�w�խ������������$��t�b����������u�%��}�?��������qЄyb�2��agv��}�~�����qЁ]|uvy��ߏ���&�ux9�w@��*�v�/�
�*��l����o�s��������xw5�&�<`y������1s�zrvz{wku�w����������\�$b�a�b���������$���^�p����o}w��s�y���������y�����{�tossku�w�p��$�����{�tossku�w��t�v�<�l��-��-��h�zl1rcn�p������~�w�������������g�zl1rcn�p������~�w������������t�v�<�l��-��-���<������u�mkolmx�y������werozi��gv������u�mkolmx�y������werozi�y��%����w
�!����������hj�=�;�
fc�����tls}=��s���gr�r�s{0c��zt�z�e��c���g��4��_�;�=�q;f[����������y����i����&���_�.�������j��1�v�dw{��|؇|}�z������u}^wbsb��������f]��$8f0�q�n�n�h�2�����{�snurns�w��*�v�+v��w
�����������9�(':9'(�:�?��������n��w����������������k�4���y��r�y�����������$��e�q�����������1��i�	��.�8��{r��qԉqp�vww�x�w�w�w�Ԅs�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@���v�<�l
��-�
�<������u�mkolmx�y������werozi?y��Ȫl����,�����gygs'�
�
\���k��q�+��ja�������o؃����ts��s��ts�s�n�3�u�r�&�*�!�2��ò���k��ϵn��w���������������d��q�� �ehh�������d�o������������������b�+�5�~�//��1qq��r��qr�qww��x��ww�wt�s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@����������
������3�q�`�������������!����~hd�c��s���������$��`�x�~�\��������������b�c�bef�e$�s�����yvriyr�s����6y��fx������������$��������`�y�kv�7����w������2��wr8�5am}ϗ����g�p�������p������ĸ}�y~y|u�@��4� �������o�p<<4nq�����ɚȜ�wtls}=��s���gw�m�s|nm��d�+���������$?��k��ȵ�q�n�x��v�l�jy������������������f����b�v��������>�%um��l�l�l�p���~�}��}|��~j�s�����wq�r�q@��v+s�u�s�������
�%@j�
qb���������c�������؁94aa+=w��������n��w�
��4�g��
���������������w8��?�@o�{�����������$��x�_����������4Ƌϋ�w�@ā�q����������$��t�q�z�g������⽑��� �	1�,~n��n҉nm�{wx��xʌyx�x҄s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@����x��ܣ�����n�s�c���������'�p�������g��c��es�s�sut�u$�s�����ww�w�w;����{�}r�r�rrr�q$�s�����x�bl��k�����������$�by��%��aw���&�g<��(�o����҅�x�y�y{x�$���!��
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*��*�}v���7��%�}�����)��؝כٚ��r{��������������qod|w�}y��fk��g�"�,�+�h��u�ܻզ���e�3s�v�:f`���/��/���sgr>���wo���*y��%���ww����0f��$�����q��}�{|��{$}w�t�
��|�y�{~{|w�t�����h��v���zlm�k$�,�(�q�74�p�ݸݻ�������k�i������������m�������ra�2~kq�\hd�d�y����y�����������������u�mkolmx�y������werozip�m�������{�tossku�w��by��%���ww����0���$�����q��}�{|��{$}w�x�
��
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*��y��0��������p��(�2�����a�i�;�����ty�$�
�#�/�<���$�	�%�-��?�$�h���-�تla�<�-'>q���oy��%�s����Жy�������y�$�������s�l[t`9�~:��v�����\�)�Ѕ�h�h�gzz�y$h~r]qck�}�Ω��������c`d`h]��(k�8���v�v��w��[i�[����]�1��2g�/�!�g�����]�1��2g�/�!�g���v�v��w��[i�[����/�!��)�g��1���2��/�!��)�g��1y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
33 0 obj
<<
/descent -254
/fontname/rrsawv+usherwood-mediumitalic
/flags 98
/fontbbox[-195 -282 995 857]
/italicangle -12
/ascent 684
/fontfile3 32 0 r
/xheight 694
/stemv 75
/type/fontdescriptor
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
>>
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 333 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 259 259 0 0 0 389 0 667 574 574 648 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 648 0 574 0 630 0 574 0 0 944 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 519 426 519 444 333 500 537 278 278 519 259 833 556 519 519 500 426 426 352 556 500 759 537 519 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 444 444 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 389 389 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 426 426 0 259]
/name/f2
/fontdescriptor 33 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 31 0 r
/basefont/rrsawv+usherwood-mediumitalic
/lastchar 213
/firstchar 32
>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 34/quotedbl 38/ampersand/quotesingle/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 65/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w 89/y/z/bracketleft 93/bracketright 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 131/eacute 136/agrave 139/atilde 141/ccedilla/eacute 146/iacute 165/bullet 209/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright 213/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 11064
/length1 11064
>>
stream




yjklem+usherwood-book

?��
���&���x��
��
��
!

��+

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bookitc usherwood


ut"u
wbsjpvtnfxiedqogm	3c
,z[(4�0
8klhiw*5y�&$%1-67r./;2�#'�):�h+<>��w
*�


}'�h�i&�c�n�^�	f	�	�

�8m��
h
�
��m���a������
g��l"l�g�&��*���f�� _!!�"!"z"�#u$
$�%%]&=&`&�&�&�'�(���*�v�]v��w
������h�����:�'':9''�;�w������ɛ
����������������$�f�r����������u��+�v�w�ukn�k�{���������$�\���\��9�[x�x�wrs�r${����oysoz^e�jg�dfq�j���������z��y�� ��w������tsuylq���������������Ѕtx�`z�����q�v~bm{{����
����������*����
��:�l��r����������$��q��r�y�y�yvw�v${��~uz!��qn��Æ����������p�p�ooo�o${�����g�*y���v�a�m����|���q���~�{p�~���8������k��mv��{�{���������x��d}c{f����������sodo{p�q�k�s�\y[a�d�j�p�拵����]�n���������`�w������a�at2�ob��ɸ��������*�~Džw�����@�~c�{���������$�p�����<���®�vp������������}}�}j�^qsy�Ə���{�tnu~]�{���������*��w����e����j�}_{���������$�`������i�ċ�{�tnu~x�{���� ��������w�uuxytt�x��y��<�
�������y����4�d�
�'�;���)�'��.��������0�
�s/)8d��!�y��&��w�������iy�������u�����#Ћ���{�w}u{x�{����.�v@(3s���"��b��-{�ms{�]�{����o�f-�>���ؠ��i�j�l�ty��v�lv���w��fw���^����������v��ӻ��\�j���e�g�a��������nv�����������{����������{��|v�r#rr@f�i�|�z�z̀�arzhl�&rϬ�s�s�^�g�_�����*��������������i�~_{���������$�`������|�������z,�o:���u���������$�o�y���|�������r7�r1���r���������$�p�x���~�a�.7=>ur��g�3:ecpl�����{�tnu~x�{����1�*y���v���"��������d�nta?3 r��������ó���Ɋ��ܕ���������\���)1�8�?�b���洝����r�������'d��c]�ce:��q�
��b�����9�n���e����������$����	��
���#�����������$��������%�ь�|�{�|to�y${����dmr�1ox^��p�ow�c�#~�t�y{z�${��e�a=�hb��*�������������s�o�qnh�t${���{�@-���:��!��w��������j�}`{���������$�_������~������:k�n,���n���������$�d�����t�{��9@gup�d�ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����1-y��7��!��w�������)�{�w3*7p���.�����`?��uy�w��(�d�)�a���̯���@���j��������[��������ɋ�{�tnu~x�{����:�oy��7�t��������4�jugq9$�p�������sj���~�����y؄��������~��~{�u�-'�,�5�6���ݰ�-�}v���s��"����������(�s���v�)��i�6�y1'�~��p�����kl{��Ŏ�r�����1�b��p��"���"�g��+_q]t��������{�tnu~x�{�����?���*�����������j�}`{���������$�_������~������:k�n,���n���������$�d�����t�{��*w=xh���{�tnu~x�{����1�㆛�2��w�y���ؿ����������$�@�������—�����؅|o�fqÂ���̌���ȝdo��������}�����u��d$vda6�n�u�zgv�q�w���"��z��-������w�����t�s`{���������$�_�����d�ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����1��v�f�
�����j���������wtw��3p���v�w
�����z�;��n�g�����ea���v���$�bw���α�z��w����������x�ov{���������$�r�����s��ȁ�x��5�~�|�����������$������,͚�r�'�������%��tu��uΈuu�t{z��{֌{{�{�{��zm���1�m�������i:fx]�-y��7��!��w������ґ�������n��$���-�1/�#�izh\y��q�����{�tnu~x�{��������n�m~y���#����e��(9>(=e���w�ov�,������Ŵ��r�hsszq`r�y�������[ctsx-������w
����k����������$�v������Î���{j_f7{熋�.��*�uv�-�v�����
������dy�
��>��z�b-���/-���<�
껺����t�a��kf�cڽ����i�
#nq24n��-y�����6�y��w�"���[�u�m�s��5kz���́�����y�zuyxty��ݷ����^<ol6p�u�������u.�
)3�xi��d|s�w�sڋ�:����8�+Ծ�����-y�t���v��Ƭ���\����������������������������y�gsyo0vj��k\�kk�vo���y���������������
͋�"��'�>�o�t�x��x�}���y������y�fki>���������[5��=-=r[yyd�����-y��ܰ
�������y�.��9�0�u3���'@�+�n�m���'�+���>����
��,�(�@v�)0o��s�w�ov�/���n������Ŵ��r�hsszqhr�y�������[ctsx0��������w�uuwwuu�w��y�c����@�|��w�w���4�q��h�(�i�k֥��̋鋝����}�}�|vv�w${����anqs�|a���c/� ��(��q�����{�|�}�|��z�j��ut�w��w�y�}���xw�g�v�`lt e����
�%��⯨q��b�y�x���������$�������ů��(�c� skhi � �@֋������
�����Ɇ���������$�f�z���h�ӑ�������&�>��c�y�����������$�q�t�|�u�x�e�1�Ƿ�櫦�w�z�xrp�u${����sqbmj\�`�'�sϘ����p�o�pmm�m${���{f�6?��^������t��2�
��9�}��&�����µw�y�wyw�y${����fnjd�r$����Ƅ����������q�p�qno�n${���x�2�
��z����b+w`jv^�o|��ww��j�e�j������ю�)��o�v��f���f��w��2�������j��ȅ������������x�edh��*]��!�4�����rs�b�e��(p���������f{��b�f~e��������lt�s��p}wy������������������f����������x�p�tur�x${����97maj"�&;��=�3���-���xb���y�}���|����xu�j$�u#�&�j�r���/��Ү��������y���v���w��w������y�������u��+�����x��+��gɸ����hj����������ʆ�����cy��=��?d �m����uiqo$��$p޻�s��v�@�a�*y���v���"��0w������-����'���	��������-��� ���d�nta?3 r��������ó���Ɋ��Ҁ����������\���)1�8�?�b���洝�����r�������'d��c]�ce:��q�y��ҵ
���x��y�f��%�n�s� ��c�e��-�b�p�2��/�����=�������b�k�!��
���\���v�w
�.���%´�����v��e�m�]�!�g�n;+z[�y�
���y�����w�uuwwuu�w�����>��������d��������������$�ʯ�����t���+��p��0���������$�Υٶ�d��b�����y�y�yss�s${����xbjaut����d�9��p�y�y�yyz�z${����dnriq8�"�����]�����������l�l�lmm�l${���u��	�-�}v�3��w����e���>k}rl`~��}x��h�f�g�����"�‹�{�tnu~x�{����#��������w�uuxytt�x�����l��.��w���;����j�}`{���������$�_������л��������2f��w�q�q�t���������$�y�|�l�v�d�v�g���ȳ����{�z�zww�w${����vod\oaj`���ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����8�*����u�����s�����k�_���n�t������m�e�������}���������]�t���ɡǚ���gx��o��{���~w{xu~y��y�@�yw�y--n�.�b�{�t_��el���)�ӈĊ�u�p�a7fa�� 4>�ǭ����{�mv��l~�}�{|l�n������f�"�@�h��ۻ����_22[r=ng���b�v�p�x��������gtqbje�n������u�u�������������q�gtqbje�n������u�u������������b�v�p�x�������p��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsx��qz��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsx�y��������y�����w�uuwwuu�w�`�2�����w�uuwwuu�w�������
��Ȇ���������$�n�q���6ܥ����o�o�onl�m${����:�69r�m�-���ѱ�w�w�^��^w��w����������$�d�}��������ea��������w�|�}�j���~����������w�k�~x������������=��`�����l���-��j��l蟆���������$�}�v���������w�l�r�{y~�o�{���������$�[�`�h�u����袠����s�{ln��${����yizygdlj�v�h�}��������{�u�qoc�y${���b�o�3���"c^��]z�͠v�f�
�����k�������o��wt{v�f�p?�v����v˱�r������
��z�y�ˆ����������}������������v[rz[%5*����r����v�������������%t\}�u�3�r��<�ur���΋���}}rp�p���~��~s�~�~����{���d^�6k�xy�dy���w���w���"w����dl\j"�$��z�m����
��m�^�����|���w����~�y]��d�1���s�c���5��쭡��v�p�x
����p��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsx���~v���ȱ�w�����%�3dž��������������������v��a���`qp��p��pq�p{z��{��{{�{g{��zl�4o�ty�����������@�"�d�h'$�)�$���?��������w����	������i���������]5�
:n�k������������$�t�����k���#��;�0��wp��pֈpp�w}|��{�|�|�|��{����9�59r�m���v�rw
���y��i�ru�*�����ћ�
����x��������}���}��������s�3wp2��sߥ����o�m�onn�m${����7��3s�o\�-y��ܰ��c����e����y�����+�m��ؾ����b���<5>1�g�o�ur6b��-�b�
�0�c�ۨ���p�i*l`i�6d��؞��������]f5gltx;�f���y��ߛ
�������������r�r�rqq�q${��gt��;c0�$�j�����Ι����o�m�nnk�q${Ã�ab��k��.�q��6��_d�����
��j������[�򒮭p�p�p|{�|${����vgy^e)�
��� �x���������l�l�lmn�m${��i�e���/��j�g���������$�բש�-�}v���r��7��w��������������ő�n�����aǔ�����rh��{b�sb�4��	$�?��)��Ʈʵ��3��{ix�w�s������i�&�$u,$-_���9����
����
���ކ���������$�i�e���������,���d��
������ؿ�(��������k�z�z�zjp�`�{���������$�p�����$t�������ä����u�v�vqr�r$�y���^��v�w�vrr�r${���/3�������������v���v�u�v��5��ˌ���l��h�f�f��r�r�r�q���ߋ�2����&�Ɍ�y�y�yst�t${ր�w�(�������t�t�uvv�v${�z�������'�l�s���������$-�v��h�����w�w��n2�������������r����������*������w�cuso��e���o��_��k�2�si�j�|]y���&x���f�itq��ı���;���s�h�ey��l��}�}��ҵ���x���einbprf���g����sd�n��	�7������ɏ��������f��%�n�s� ��c�e��-�b�p�2��/�����=�������b�k�!��
���\�*y���v�a�m��0w���˥�-����f��[�-	�{�t�{�h����Ҁ�q���~�{p�~���8������k��mv��{ {��������Ҁx��d}c{f����������sodo{p�q�k�s�\y[a�d�j�p�拵����]�n���������`�w������a�at2�ob��ɸ���r��n��Ա�t�w������|ˉ����c����������r]7if,de�����w)� �a*���r���������������������<���
���b�����֡����cuo��r���rt�~}|��|���|}�|j�{����7�39r�m��������~�����������Ɇ���������$�f�v���f����w�������������%t[}�u�!�~��<�ur���ϊ���||so�q���~��~�~�~���{���d^�6k�xy�����iw�dw����t�-c�'���$��������-�/� �†���������$�`������m��#�d���oou�[{����.�\j�}_-y�����w
��������z�n����0�6�����
�7��4rwhz�������h����:������l "jm8"]��-�v��Ðw���j���zy�������ޱ�#������������ȉ�0��fz����~^vpw^��ӱ�����#��3�l}�7-���:�`��v������������������$��a�}��������������|�li{~s��������z�{zx�}$�#�0��%93�l����������0hr�\���m�uw�ton��o�������-y�����9Öw�vЫ�����y�������{�$�,����2��7_p|u���ݜˑ�������*�Ƥ�uyps�(po��p�o�p�o��&`�$h7�~�������k$"mb�
�eͷ{u��d�y�v���������
�	�����i�����f9r�m�{���������$�n�q���6ܥ����o�m�onn�m${����:�>���>ܥ����o�o�onl�m${����:�69r�m�{���������$�n�q��d����
��(���)��}����������$�\�����n���������ϋ�v�v�vyx�y${����lohm>2sk,�q�_ʋ�������l�l�khh�g${�|������=�po�q\��b�v�.�z�������.���b��w�q�pwxf��k�b���b��w�q�pwxf?�v����v˱�r������=w���
���-���	�4��'���
 ���������-����xpˆ����������}������������v[rz[%5*����r����v�������������%t\}�u�3�r��<�ur���΋���}}rp�p���~��~rp~�~���p{���d^�6k�xy���v�.�z
����.���b��w�q�pwxf���}v���
���s��ޥ����o�o�onl�m${����8��*_m]v}���t��^�b�k����=���3��g�
�	��	�3�s���g���s���3��g�
�1��l�3���sn��g�n�o�z�ԩ��|v�[�}w���/�Ɲ��4�jugq9$�p�������sj���~�����y瀄��������~ۀ�~{�u�-'�,��9�w�p�qwn�~��������unv�uy����vw�|���������m�g�����뀓�������������ݞ��*y���v�a�m����˔��f��
�����������������������������q�~�pxz��z�yy�r������r�uyv�����q���~�{p�~���8������k��mv��{�{���������x��d}c{f����������sodo{p�q�k�s�\y[a�d�j�p�拵����]�n���������`�w������a�at2�ob��ɸ���y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/descent -254
/fontname/yjklem+usherwood-book
/flags 34
/fontbbox[-101 -307 964 856]
/italicangle 0
/ascent 684
/fontfile3 36 0 r
/xheight 694
/stemv 59
/type/fontdescriptor
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
>>
endobj
38 0 obj
<<
/widths[278 0 444 0 0 0 722 278 296 296 0 0 278 278 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 0 0 0 0 0 630 593 611 704 574 537 630 704 296 296 648 500 815 685 741 574 741 630 519 556 667 611 944 0 611 556 333 0 333 0 0 0 500 556 463 556 500 315 500 556 259 241 519 241 889 574 537 556 556 370 426 315 537 500 759 537 519 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 574 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 500 0 463 500 0 0 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 963 444 444 0 278]
/name/f3
/fontdescriptor 37 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 35 0 r
/basefont/yjklem+usherwood-book
/lastchar 213
/firstchar 32
>>
endobj
39 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 147
/length1 147
>>
stream




armthe+eurostileregular

7�����
�?��
�?��dag��




!��{���.��.����.��.����
endstream
endobj
41 0 obj
<<
/descent -512
/fontname/armthe+eurostileregular
/flags 34
/fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867]
/italicangle 0
/ascent 1775
/fontfile3 40 0 r
/xheight 0
/stemv 0
/type/fontdescriptor
/stemh 0
/capheight 1775
>>
endobj
42 0 obj
<<
/widths[250]
/name/f4
/fontdescriptor 41 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 39 0 r
/basefont/armthe+eurostileregular
/lastchar 32
/firstchar 32
>>
endobj
43 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period 49/one 51/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 65/a 67/c 69/e 72/h/i/j 76/l 78/n 80/p 82/r/s/t 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j 108/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 131/eacute 136/agrave 139/atilde 141/ccedilla/eacute 144/ecircumflex 210/quotedblleft/quotedblright 213/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
44 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 8097
/length1 8097
>>
stream




xidpay+usherwood-bookitalic

@��
����o���`��
��
��
.
*
���

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporationitc usherwood book italicitc usherwood


<qfs
tdpouyvbmjwnhzc+g&e3ix")$r�-�
15i4kw�*	/
���>
��
p
s
�5�#��^�=��+�	,	�
*
��8�
4
�w!�2����w����8��7��#�j�a�[���}v���j��:�������f��Ɲ��̖�������k����������:�s�m΋���'�o�k�m9\dky�����������h{koyv`f����������tmbz<d�e�u��~uu�|��=���������x1!o�c�\_���by��:�
�������nwm:?bi�՗����Ę�����v�9�4��-�c �l����3����uj(�\pv�Ó��8����v�.�o����9�ؿ���=������۰ҳ���o��y�������������|�yxpb=g�����������h{koyv�`f����������xmdu;y>��ty��b��˖��$������������p�y�@� �rj�d�� �a�� �tb\a��lb�Ğ����w�yj~wrmh��d��������d��º��Ǩkh|�����ty��:�
��������is[=hmg���<��Ү�vdu�v�w���ģ����[�s���0�h��u���ҽ�*y��b�
������ly����0�=�(���1�# �0���d���.�ъ�p7�3*�61m���y��v�8�t����=Ő�z����������������u`m�a�h�k��l�x�qw�x����������z��|���o��������z��%�������b�w9<-ud�����������h{koyvj`f����������sios"u7��y��(��w������xsrxkox�����������Ҍ������І�y�x[������meaokln�x�i�…s�l�xw�y�������y��{v�a�t������b���sws}o�_|��!n�������}z���u���z�u�hd�%xi�t��ysrzzx�x`�~������Ĉ=���l^<xo}��~~��a�{�{��˺����"��p�������x�a���a��Ȍ��9���j�����|x~{�l�����������Nj����y�m���s}{���{zz�`�od�i���\y���������薬�������k{|��~h\�~��������xxj�i�k�n��o�k�vd�d����Ǭ���{�p�pd�c�������+y�a��gv�����l�\�w�}{xxs������b��}�����}��{��|z�|�a��b�%3�p����ū���}�{�{`�x�������
����_����~�toi���zt���y��֛�w
���q���z��|���o����������������eoyqr��{���f�����8�$�g�umw�x�������y������Ŕ�p������z��|���o��������ؤ�žЋ��k��}z��}9o�~���������ur�g�m�i��_�n�ew�x������$����������wswroz�{��o�v�8�a��$��o���u���?�s����m�~���fr�z��������k}1��<pm���������Ň�i{sx}zs^�~����������i�[�u�&y��v�8�t����l��.ŏ�]����������������xsvs*wbi����-���������¸��uxn�j�m�n�
�d�p�kw�x����������z��|���o��������]�򔫔����q�id�tqs@�������f�xmg=cp�����������f{koyvm`f����������zbcr�v7�=����n��*�~w�����6��)����y������������|�|x�w�d��e�0,�u��ߨ���o�!t�p�3�em�������|�u\xujp��[��-�������=���q������qm�dz[d�v8e�x�f����=������a��wfv����v�����������w�u�|���hu��z���������h:�*�b^x�������w��gzy|�}ku�}������ț��ee�h{ig7i3s�z�����v������ɼ����*y��:����w
� ��l��������x]go�n��{���{p��{�����l�yҋ�v��c��p�f4n*tw��s�������.��k@�b�p�dd��������ϛ
�������Ϧ�����f�g�flj�l$�{�����_}�~�~���{@r�6�^v�������u�`�qyc�x�lы���	���p��������w�x�x��a���l�@�������{�Ԃvw�sxԛ�����}t}�}�}��̠��������ou��n}c�tefz}8�nd�rp�2�'a�d;nn�p{�������|�ad������w�o��"��0�d�-����i��|vͭ��������(��<����������Š����������u_v_q)\���_�r����������z��~j�������şȜ�un�z[$ ����+�z_����Ǒ�{~x��w�sno��q9�q�s�u����{�����a}�~�~.�8z?w�s��*y�a��2��`w�����|�z����}y{�f���ӟݚ���0�Қϡ�{cnl}l��{����dpxh�t�vh�n�
�7��t���v����}�}�}g�l����������-��%���tbr8���gq��w���ĭ���x����脆���������$��d�z����������i��je��;ă9����������$��f�l�}�q���8$��Ր����?��oo��p؉op�ouu��u�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s�������������dc@zn�7?�y��v�=����w��Ŏ�z���k����ы��rvz�y�z�b�b�p�y�tw�x����������z��|���o��������z��*�������d�u=c1fg����m������eo_qr��{���f��|��l�&p�l�i��y�����w
������h��h���p���
�c������
4�.cdywj�����������r������w6�e..cx��
Ӡv�8�a�~w���$��\��p���o������������r�p�b�%�s�m�ǰ��w�v��~�r�~����=p��{��������sv.��)qd����������|�u���{�sz��${���{p7"�=-���������Ň�i{sx}zs^�~����������i�\�t�y��޵�d�g��w������z[y�lts��t�t�t�t�f3\�
s4�p�������m@+@*�ii��^|o�n�tۋ�:��
�
�c��
dc~}fԷ�Ԣ�䆱����
����w������ʛ~��������n�f����̨���������p�o�oqd�f��{���������$��z������z�!�������������k�k�jnn�m$�{�����pvrl{t�v��@"hc�uy�~����������$��������g����ŭ���
��f�����������$��u�h����������j��\�jx>x�r��{���������$��{�_����������6����ӓ��h�i�hii�i$�{�����d��x�}e�>����>�Х�����f�g�flk�l$�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s��������w
����������ç��$��i�r����������3������wdl`l&��{Ԫ�cy�}�{e��q�	r�x���v�����
������y�����i���c���%'���h񸴛����7�
c>�"g��$����п[$�>=:6a��-y��ڱ
���6����<_os#�
"j���q��t�.��	�jh�������|����yjq�a$�g�1�n���)�#�&���v���
������������Ő���q{z��r q�dzu�=�}v���e��:�����<��ɝ��ɖ���x����ӓ���;�қ���{��fhvu�d��<��q��n�ַЦ���a�o�w)g�\w=����@����\wi���bu���y���������y�����x�ynvsnu�|�p��,�����x�ynvsnu�|��by��:��5����f�j(��(�����&ڄ�v�v�u~}�~$vosgql�������nwm:?bi�՗����Ę�����v�9�4��-�c �l����3����uj(�\pv�Ó��8�������՛���p��������}—�~���Û���ueacm�1f{���������6�Τ�����f�g�flg�l$�{�����_}�~���(�6x<s�y���v�j�>
����j�����z�qqtvnz�������zeitr{�by��:��������c��(�m����[�q�r�t�@jkdkgq�c�����nwm:?bi�՗����Ę�����v�9�4��-�c �l����3����uj(�\pv�Ó��8����
���)�����z�qqtvnz�������zeitr{?��������x���������������
�`:��
o�2�]�����������$��t�h����������k�	�$���,�k��to��k؉jf�_{{��{�{�����_u�b�m>�z?l�]�-���խ�w� ��4���������������$��u�h����������z��ex�����������}�s�}�������������}؁]bty���������zy?x�r����v�j�>������ �n�2zjr�w������~�z�������������+�n�2zjr�w������~�z������������y��[w�'��
��v̀���q�h������g�t� ���)r����i�����87ig�'x�ϡ����w�wfxnrlz��6�;�+����r��n���λ����it~�~����������+�p���h���žϹ�k��}z��}9o�~���������ur�h�mb��h`�c�pv�������y�~r}mpjr��q������(����������wswroz�{��y�
���y�����x�ynvsnu�|����v�j�>�������j�����z�qqtvnz�������zeitr{��+{�����z�qqtvnz�������zeitr{�y����ˡ��z�x���y�����<�\���ȕ����j� �
=684�t�j�]�\��/�e���8�����i�i:?ki7:t����������;]i3-b\�g�i���+y�a��gv���5�����ib��
�����q�s�w�}�~�~uv�u$�{�b�u�w�}{xxs������b��}�����}��{��|z�|�a��b�%3�p����ū���}�{�{`�x�������
����_����~�toi���zt��������
��������������$��u�h����������6�Х�����f�g�flk�l$�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s��y����b��w���$�䆬o��t��k��!��@�op������
ʦԎ��fj�f�8n����w~f}gif���̧���=-fh<p�r�����ڳ]l�!��8\��w��v��{��w��n�� y��������@������̪���Ȏ�c�h�c��/^u����������z�yzy^oz��ӿ���%�8#�h��e�r��v�w
���n�g�f���a��g����du���g����j�-�yw����
����@�u�f���������<���h��d��m������a�ƛŚ�x�v�xvv�u$�{�����v|�}�}5��;�;>�:<�=x�x�xuv�v$�{�����\m�m�me��u�byh���������$��v�w
�l�]�'�����g���j#�t��i�y�t���a��g�%�����������)�����z�qqtvnz�������zeitr{p�2�l�����x�ynvsnu�|�����;�a�����|��m����������$��o�p���ؘ�����İ������������{ciuy��h��&������z�z�z{y�{$1��$�'�-��{�o�������֋҃���`t�m�i���mqh��h|u��z�����+�'����-����i��|vͭ��������5����j�����'������&ڄ�v�v�u~}�~$vosgql���y<0���������Š����������u_v_q)\0��_�r����������z��~j�������şȜ�un�z[$ ����+�z_����Ǒ�{~x��w�sno��q90q�s�u��0�{�����a}�~�~.�8z?w�s��t�x�Ω���:�
��������is[=hmg���<��Ү�vdu�v�w���ģ����[�s���0�h$�uՇ|txtwv�w��������ysu}rst��ytt�r�~�������l�e������Қ�ƶ��+y�a��gv����������t��
�r�����������������°���b~|w�y}{��}�|}�~`fjgn�m��u�w�}{xxs������b��}�����}��{��|z�|�a��b�%3�p����ū���}�{�{`�x�������
����_����~�toi���zt��y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
45 0 obj
<<
/descent -254
/fontname/xidpay+usherwood-bookitalic
/flags 98
/fontbbox[-187 -307 972 849]
/italicangle -12
/ascent 684
/fontfile3 44 0 r
/xheight 694
/stemv 58
/type/fontdescriptor
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
>>
endobj
46 0 obj
<<
/widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 278 278 0 0 259 315 259 0 0 519 0 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 259 259 0 0 0 0 0 630 0 556 0 556 0 0 667 296 296 0 519 0 630 0 574 0 630 519 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 499 500 426 500 444 315 481 519 278 259 0 259 796 537 500 519 481 389 426 315 519 463 722 519 481 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 0 499 0 0 499 0 426 444 0 444 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 407 407 0 259]
/name/f11
/fontdescriptor 45 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 43 0 r
/basefont/xidpay+usherwood-bookitalic
/lastchar 213
/firstchar 32
>>
endobj
47 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 73/i 76/l 82/r/s 97/a/b/c 101/e 105/i 109/m/n/o 116/t/u/v 142/eacute]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
48 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 2317
/length1 2317
>>
stream




jutnml+usherwood-bold

@��
����/������
��
��
"

e��

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bolditc usherwood


*bo
3pcun-vdjf4w�
o�
\
_
q��a�"��}����ㆫ�̫
���j�lܐ�’�c�c�ffc�c$k„�h:��:�ht�k���������$�t�����y�e����^����>����������d����e�x�&vx��yl�xz�z�����\k��x{buz�z�����ħp^tg�8vey,w�:�z��ģ�t��q�������[�*orucal�����ʣd�����z����z�������������$�v�����f�����Ę]r��m�v�~���������$�c�|���\�f�,5gfso�m�klioo�k���t3�	@�av����������[�f��w���[�
泆���������$�f�����3��-���v����������$�m�h�{�m���$����ͦ��3��ll��n։np�t|{��{�{�z�z��k„�h:��:�ht���b��������ҁ-17�f]-y���
�������y����/�/"���"-�/�/�-��������ܵ@��a@::a��?y�|v�$����w���|���p�t��ʒ�meogre�k���u5��~��}ze�|��������r��*��
�4�=��@b_kd������Ҵp+�
[33>x����y�����w������
ttlsk]s�����Ś�����Јv{�p7�czewc4rk���9�q��Ү��������z����r��r�������������$�v�����f�����Ę]r��m�v�~���������$�c�|���n��õ�Ę]r��m�v�~���������$�c�|���\�i�3<bkvm�yd�f5ofso�m�klioo�k���t3�	@�av���v��p������8������������������Ɩ—�l�8vvr[���.ܐ�’�c�c�ffc�c$k„�h:��x:�ht�ry��׫�w
���y��ny�������k������̒�melgoe�k���u5dbfk>kx����͒�melgoe�k���t3�(�m�
��Ԧ��e�c�u�=y���a�t����{���a�u|dnc0t���
���بhi���������l̄��������{��{v�p�,��$�(�+������������w������������������$�v�����	�͒�melgoe�k���t3�	@�av���������n�ggnngg�n��y��o���
���w��g�tu\sb�l����Ȍ��Ɗ������������d��,�,��!�&�+���殡���q�����ӝfu�*y�_����_����i�\�}�����������������$����y��9��)ɽ����df���������j�����������x��yr�c�8;��u��ދ�1exd9�j��{d��n�o�i�*�������v�v�t�-�-��k����������$���¯䠧��u�s�uno�o$k��|vy�l�n7�{�1��������������f�g�fde�d$k���k�k�y��o�����sw����ii���6���
�%�z�����&��g�tu\sb�l����Ȍ��Ɗ������������d��,�,��!�&�+���殡���q�����ӝfuy����f��`��������
�����
endstream
endobj
49 0 obj
<<
/descent -254
/fontname/jutnml+usherwood-bold
/flags 262178
/fontbbox[-155 -300 1092 866]
/italicangle 0
/ascent 684
/fontfile3 48 0 r
/xheight 694
/stemv 108
/type/fontdescriptor
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
>>
endobj
50 0 obj
<<
/widths[296 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 315 0 0 537 0 0 0 0 0 667 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 574 481 0 519 0 0 0 296 0 0 0 907 611 556 0 0 0 0 352 593 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519]
/name/f12
/fontdescriptor 49 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 47 0 r
/basefont/jutnml+usherwood-bold
/lastchar 142
/firstchar 32
>>
endobj
51 0 obj
<<
/kids[52 0 r 53 0 r 54 0 r 55 0 r 56 0 r 57 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 58 0 r
>>
endobj
52 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 51 0 r
/contents 4 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f1 30 0 r/f0 26 0 r/f2 34 0 r/f4 42 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
53 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 51 0 r
/contents 5 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f3 38 0 r/f0 26 0 r/f11 46 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
54 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 51 0 r
/contents 6 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f3 38 0 r/f0 26 0 r/f11 46 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
55 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 51 0 r
/contents 7 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r/f11 46 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
56 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 51 0 r
/contents 8 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
57 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 51 0 r
/contents 9 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f3 38 0 r/f0 26 0 r/f11 46 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
59 0 obj
<<
/kids[60 0 r 61 0 r 62 0 r 63 0 r 64 0 r 65 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 58 0 r
>>
endobj
60 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 59 0 r
/contents 10 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
61 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 59 0 r
/contents 11 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
62 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 59 0 r
/contents 12 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
63 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 59 0 r
/contents 13 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r/f11 46 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
64 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 59 0 r
/contents 14 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r/f11 46 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
65 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 59 0 r
/contents 15 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
66 0 obj
<<
/kids[67 0 r 68 0 r 69 0 r 70 0 r 71 0 r 72 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 58 0 r
>>
endobj
67 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 66 0 r
/contents 16 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r/f11 46 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
68 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 66 0 r
/contents 17 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
69 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 66 0 r
/contents 18 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
70 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 66 0 r
/contents 19 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
71 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 66 0 r
/contents 20 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 26 0 r/f3 38 0 r/f12 50 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
72 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 66 0 r
/contents 21 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r/gs0 1 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f3 38 0 r/f0 26 0 r/f11 46 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
58 0 obj
<<
/type/pages
/kids[51 0 r 59 0 r 66 0 r]
/count 18
>>
endobj
73 0 obj
<<
/pagelabels 22 0 r
/type/catalog
/pages 58 0 r
>>
endobj
74 0 obj
<<
/xpressprivate(%%documentprocesscolors: black\n%%endcomments)
/producer(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5)
/creationdate(20070408161620)
/creator(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5)
>>
endobj
xref
0 75
0000000000 65535 f 
0000000015 00000 n 
0000000059 00000 n 
0000000105 00000 n 
0000000152 00000 n 
0000005339 00000 n 
0000011255 00000 n 
0000018660 00000 n 
0000024944 00000 n 
0000031803 00000 n 
0000038832 00000 n 
0000045275 00000 n 
0000052469 00000 n 
0000059568 00000 n 
0000067185 00000 n 
0000074217 00000 n 
0000081050 00000 n 
0000087402 00000 n 
0000094048 00000 n 
0000102249 00000 n 
0000108495 00000 n 
0000114479 00000 n 
0000128243 00000 n 
0000128289 00000 n 
0000128698 00000 n 
0000135925 00000 n 
0000136147 00000 n 
0000136817 00000 n 
0000136947 00000 n 
0000138973 00000 n 
0000139207 00000 n 
0000139557 00000 n 
0000139928 00000 n 
0000146798 00000 n 
0000147028 00000 n 
0000147670 00000 n 
0000148181 00000 n 
0000159330 00000 n 
0000159550 00000 n 
0000160252 00000 n 
0000160343 00000 n 
0000160571 00000 n 
0000160793 00000 n 
0000160964 00000 n 
0000161383 00000 n 
0000169563 00000 n 
0000169791 00000 n 
0000170450 00000 n 
0000170610 00000 n 
0000173010 00000 n 
0000173236 00000 n 
0000173659 00000 n 
0000173766 00000 n 
0000173990 00000 n 
0000174195 00000 n 
0000174400 00000 n 
0000174605 00000 n 
0000174799 00000 n 
0000177613 00000 n 
0000175004 00000 n 
0000175111 00000 n 
0000175306 00000 n 
0000175501 00000 n 
0000175696 00000 n 
0000175902 00000 n 
0000176108 00000 n 
0000176303 00000 n 
0000176410 00000 n 
0000176616 00000 n 
0000176811 00000 n 
0000177006 00000 n 
0000177201 00000 n 
0000177407 00000 n 
0000177685 00000 n 
0000177754 00000 n 
trailer
<<
/size 75
/root 73 0 r
/info 74 0 r
/id[<6ea21508d47a21b171293fd949661fa0><6ea21508d47a21b171293fd949661fa0>]
>>
startxref
177929
%%eof