%pdf-1.3
%����
1 0 obj
<<
/type/extgstate
/opm 1
>>
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/type/extgstate
/op true
>>
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/type/extgstate
/op false
>>
endobj
4 0 obj
<<
/length 4868
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
13.5 0 0 13.5 73 585.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
9 0 0 9 73 564.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid, university of bath, united kingdom )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f1 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 528.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(a)19(bstr)19(act)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f2 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 516.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(the field o)19(f envir)18(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch has been mo)19(ving aw)18(ay fr)19(om)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
[(scientistic and positivistic discour)19(ses f)36(or some time no)19(w )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f3 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 316.5666 504.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(\(envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
-24.1228 -1.26316 td
[(education r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f2 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 169.7248 492.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.51766 0 td
0 tc
[(2000; hart & nolan, 1999\). ho)19(w)19(e)19(v)18(er)111(, it has been noted)]tj
-9.18343 -1.26316 td
[(that the met)19(a-discour)18(se about this r)19(esear)18(ch continues t)19(o dr)19(aw on their)]tj
t*
[(fr)18(amings)37(, r)19(egister)18(s)37(, and le)19(xicons \(hart, 2000; mar)18(cink)19(o)19(w)19(ski, 2000; smith-)]tj
t*
[(sebast)19(o, 2000\). p)36(oststructur)19(alist and critical appr)18(oaches t)19(o discour)19(se analy-)]tj
t*
[(sis highlight the constr)19(aints and possibilities in such discour)18(se)37(, including)]tj
t*
[(ho)18(w w)19(e mak)19(e sense o)18(f claims about the quality o)19(f r)18(esear)19(ch. with this in)]tj
t*
[(mind, the paper e)19(xplor)18(es the met)19(a-discour)18(se about envir)19(onment)19(al education)]tj
t*
[(r)19(esear)19(ch, using \322the science and art\323 o)18(f imaging and r)19(emote sensing o)19(f the)]tj
t*
[(envir)19(onment t)18(o illustr)19(ate the f)37(orms and functions o)18(f techno-scientific lan-)]tj
t*
(guage in this field. in so doing, the paper discusses a series o)tj
25.6565 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(f)tj
0.59159 0 td
0 tc
(observ)tj
2.81417 0 td
(ations)tj
-29.06225 -1.26316 td
(about interpr)tj
5.68505 0 td
(et)tj
0.77686 0 td
(ation and quality in envir)tj
10.79565 0 td
[(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch dis-)]tj
-17.25757 -1.26317 td
[(cour)19(se)36(, and constr)19(aints and possibilities in r)18(elation t)19(o the met)19(a-discour)18(se)37(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f1 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 336.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r\216sum\216)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f2 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 324.8022 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(l)19(e champ de la r)19(echer)18(che en ere s\325\216loigne des discour)19(s scientistes et posi-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
(tivistes depuis quelque temps d\216j\210 (eer 2000; hart et nolan 1999).)tj
t*
(cependant, il a \216t\216 not\216 que le m\216t)tj
14.4917 0 td
[(adiscour)19(s au sujet de cette r)18(echer)19(che con-)]tj
-14.4917 -1.26316 td
[(tinue de puiser dans leur)19(s encadr)18(ements)37(, leur)18(s r)19(egistr)19(es et leur)18(s le)19(xiques)]tj
0 -1.26315 td
(\(smith-sebast)tj
5.86889 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(o)tj
0.77762 0 td
0 tc
(2000; mar)tj
4.31467 0 td
(cink)tj
1.75953 0 td
(o)tj
0.5 0 td
(w)tj
0.73999 0 td
[(ski 2000; hart 2000\). l)19(es appr)18(oches post-)]tj
-13.9607 -1.26317 td
(structur)tj
3.49976 0 td
[(alistes et les critiques de l\325analy)19(se du discour)18(s soulignent les con-)]tj
-3.49976 -1.26316 td
[(tr)18(aintes et les possibilit\216s d\325un tel discour)19(s)37(, de m\220me que notr)19(e)]tj
t*
(compr\216hension des affirmations sur la qualit\216 de la r)tj
22.45435 0 td
(echer)tj
2.25732 0 td
(che)tj
1.36962 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(.)tj
0.51746 0 td
(v)tj
0.55602 0 td
0 tc
(oil\210)tj
-27.15478 -1.26317 td
[(pour)19(quoi cet article e)18(xplor)19(e le m\216t)18(adiscour)19(s sur la r)19(echer)18(che en ere, en)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
(r)tj
0.40698 0 td
(ecour)tj
2.35132 0 td
(ant \210 la science et \210 l\325art de l\325imagerie et de la t\216l\216d\216tection de l\325envi)tj
28.72291 0 td
(-)tj
-31.4812 -1.26317 td
(r)tj
0.40698 0 td
(onne)tj
2.07446 0 td
-0.003 tc
(ment pour illustr)tj
7.21306 0 td
[(er les f)37(ormes et les f)36(onctions du langage techno-scien-)]tj
-9.6945 -1.26317 td
[(tifique dans ce champ. ce f)37(aisant, l\325article discute d\325une s\216rie d\325observ)18(ations)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
(au sujet de l\325interpr\216t)tj
9.08474 0 td
(ation et de la qualit\216 du discour)tj
13.2815 0 td
-0.0027 tc
(s)tj
0.67951 0 td
-0.003 tc
(sur l\325ere ainsi que)tj
-23.04575 -1.26316 td
[(des contr)19(aintes et des possibilit\216s par r)18(apport au m\216t)19(adiscour)18(s)37(. )]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.496 324 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 176.8514 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(canadian journal of environmental education, 8, spring 2003)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396.994 17.4601 22.992 23.0399 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 412.5767 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(9)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
<<
/length 6647
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.074 tw
[(r)19(emote sensing is the science and art of obt)19(aining inf)18(ormation about a phe-)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
0 tw
[(nomenon without being in cont)19(act with it. \(schneider)110(, 200)56(1\))]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 554.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(f)56(or the purposes of this paper)111(, i assume that a critical f)18(orm of envir)19(onmen-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(t)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch attends t)19(o the scientific)19(, ecological, political, and cul-)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.135 tw
[(tur)19(al pr)18(actices that shape our \(often unpr)19(oblematiz)19(ed\) under)18(st)19(anding of)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(society-econom)19(y-envir)18(onment r)19(elationships)37(. dr)19(a)18(wing on insights fr)19(om crit-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
[(ical discour)19(se analy)18(sis)37(, i contend that inv)18(estigating the pr)19(oduction, negotia-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.063 tw
[(tion, and consumption of kno)19(wledge claims b)18(y r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s is essential t)19(o)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(under)19(st)18(anding the comple)19(x r)18(elationships betw)19(een envir)19(onment)18(al (and) edu-)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.014 tw
[(cational \322)56(e)19(xperts\323 and their \322)55(audiences\323 of teacher)19(s)37(, 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛
)37(, schools)37(, and)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(communities)37(. this is because the discour)18(se of e)19(v)18(ery act)19(or mobiliz)19(es or)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(silences riv)19(al claims about adequate)55(, legitimate)56(, and truthful w)19(a)19(y)18(s of sensing,)]tj
t*
0 tc
[(interpr)19(eting, and managing kno)18(wledge in envir)19(onment)19(al education. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.017 tw
[(discour)19(se is the tr)18(ansactional basis f)19(or a r)19(ange of activities in envir)18(on-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(ment)19(al education, including dialogue)56(, ar)18(gument, and communication about)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(the quality of teaching, learning, and r)19(esear)18(ch. y)80(et, while discour)19(se is the sub-)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(s)1(t)20(ance and conduit of discussion, it is also much mor)18(e)56(.)1( )1(d)1(r)20(a)19(wing on the w)19(o)1(r)1(k)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(of bakhtin \(t)88(odor)18(o)20(v)111(, 1984\), escobar \(1995\), and f)56(air)18(clough and chouliar)19(aki)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[((1999), critical discour)19(se analy)18(sts ar)19(gue that discour)18(se should not be tr)19(eated)]tj
t*
[(as simply the e)19(xpr)18(ession of thought. r)19(ather)111(, it is a set of pr)18(actices)37(, with con-)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
0 tw
(ditions)tj
2.79888 0 td
-0.0129 tc
(,)tj
0.52907 0 td
-0.013 tc
(rules)tj
1.97277 0 td
-0.0129 tc
(,)tj
0.52908 0 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
(and hist)tj
3.34107 0 td
(orical pr)tj
3.43825 0 td
(ecedents that locate)tj
8.31728 0 td
-0.0129 tc
(,)tj
0.52906 0 td
-0.013 tc
0 tw
(constr)tj
2.58893 0 td
-0.001 tw
(ain, and enable our)tj
-24.04439 -1.20002 td
0 tc
0 tw
(discur)tj
2.59131 0 td
(siv)tj
1.16577 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.88262 0 td
0 tc
0.105 tw
[(utter)19(ances within inter-individual netw)18(orks and \322or)19(der)19(s of dis-)]tj
-4.6397 -1.20001 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(cour)19(se\323 \(f)55(oucault, 198)56(1\). f)56(or f)56(air)18(clough (1992), r)19(ecognition of f)56(oucault\325)37(s e)18(xpla-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.022 tc
0.16 tw
(nation of dominant, subaltern, and contesting or)tj
23.06045 0 td
0 tw
(der)tj
1.47367 0 td
(s)tj
0.90778 0 td
(t)tj
0.31845 0 td
0.0221 tc
(o)tj
1.0189 0 td
0.022 tc
(discour)tj
3.28383 0 td
0.16 tw
(se is)tj
-30.06308 -1.20001 td
-0.015 tc
0 tw
(fundament)tj
4.61063 0 td
0.001 tw
(al t)tj
1.25768 0 td
-0.0146 tc
(o)tj
0.78636 0 td
(a)tj
0.74936 0 td
-0.015 tc
[(r)19(e)-1(f)-1(l)-1(e)17(xiv)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch community in that it articulates what has)]tj
-7.40403 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
(become imper)tj
6.2771 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.55493 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.77777 0 td
(t)tj
0.29621 0 td
(o)tj
0.81473 0 td
0 tc
(poststructur)tj
5.1467 0 td
(alist analy)tj
4.33325 0 td
(sis: t)tj
1.96216 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.81476 0 td
0 tc
(interr)tj
2.36859 0 td
(ogate:)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 254.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(the socially structuring configur)19(ations of discur)18(siv)19(e pr)19(actices; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
(their associations with particular social spaces and the \322r)tj
23.68507 0 td
(egimes of truth\323 that)tj
-23.68507 -1.26316 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.27685 0 td
(cher)tj
1.86987 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(s)tj
0.70368 0 td
0 tc
(use t)tj
2.03655 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.81476 0 td
0 tc
[(situate their pr)19(ojects; and )]tj
-9.56858 -1.26317 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(the shifting boundaries and flo)19(w)19(s betw)18(een such sites of truth/po)19(w)19(er)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 194.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(f)tj
0.48096 0 td
0.099 tw
(or a community of envir)tj
10.92954 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.36987 0 td
0.099 tw
(al educat)tj
3.96932 0 td
[(or)19(s)37(, the challenge of escobar\325)36(s)]tj
-18.74969 -1.20001 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[((1995) comments ar)19(e potentially f)18(ar r)19(eaching: \322)56(changing the or)19(der of discour)18(se)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.011 tw
(is a political question that ent)tj
12.64879 0 td
[(ails the collectiv)19(e pr)18(actice of social act)19(or)19(s and)]tj
-12.64879 -1.2 td
0 tw
[(the r)19(estructuring of e)18(xisting political economies of truth\323 \(p. 2)56(16\).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(this paper st)19(arts with an illustr)18(ation of these ar)19(guments in terms of the)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.011 tc
0.128 tw
[(sense-making pr)19(ocess in envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch. i then use)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(r)19(emote sensing as a pictur)19(e t)18(o e)19(xtend the initial consider)19(ations int)18(o r)19(eflections)]tj
t*
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
[(on the r)19(oles of assumptions and pr)18(actices f)19(or envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
t*
0.004 tc
0.134 tw
[(r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s)36(, and conclude with a comment)19(ary on their implications f)19(or)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(ho)19(w sense is made of the quality of r)18(esear)19(ch in envir)19(onment)18(al education.)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8 0 0 8 37.612 34.204 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(10)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/length 8346
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 206.5564 587.4685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(background)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 564.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tw
[(my st)19(arting point in applying this f)18(orm of analy)19(sis t)19(o this ar)18(ea is t)19(o observ)19(e)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(that the ne)19(xus of ideas that shape envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch discour)19(s)1(e)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(can be vie)19(w)18(ed as being primarily dr)19(a)19(wn fr)18(om tw)19(o br)19(oad ar)18(eas: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 337.2887 540.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
[(envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
-26.42887 -1.2 td
0.004 tc
[(r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 112.5017 528.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.005 tc
(and )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 133.1141 528.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.004 tc
0.125 tw
[(educational r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 220.5741 528.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.0047 tc
(,)tj
0.6995 0 td
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(be)19(y)19(ond the self-same discour)19(se)55(. both)]tj
-15.45691 -1.20001 td
0.01 tc
0.128 tw
[(pr)19(o)18(vide distinct contributions t)19(o envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch: f)19(or)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0 tw
[(inst)19(ance)55(,)1( )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 115.5457 504.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
0.127 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 218.6835 504.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(t)19(o the content of envir)19(onment)18(al educa-)]tj
-14.56835 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.011 tw
(tion, and )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 114.6982 492.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.01 tw
[(educational r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 202.9906 492.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.011 tw
[(t)19(o the effectiv)19(eness of envir)18(onment)19(al educa-)]tj
-12.99906 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(tion initiativ)19(es \(hungerf)18(or)19(d, p)56(e)18(yt)19(on, & wilk)18(e)56(, 1980\). ho)18(w)19(e)18(v)18(er)111(, while debate)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(on the r)19(elativ)18(e influence of each ar)19(ea in envir)19(onment)19(al education continues)36(,)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(discussion of their effects on envir)19(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch itself has been)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(limited (hart, 2000), including ho)19(w their discur)18(siv)19(e pr)19(actices oper)18(ate with-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(in the r)19(esear)18(ch discour)19(se)56(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(wher)19(e discussion does t)18(ak)19(e place)56(, as in )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 256.312 420.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.006 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(e)1(s)1(e)1(a)1(r)20(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 408.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((2000), it tends t)19(o f)18(ocus on: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 386.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(clarifying positions on the r)tj
11.70164 0 td
[(ole of r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education \(e)56(.g.,)]tj
-11.70164 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(t)19(o legitimate or challenge particular initiativ)19(es or tr)18(aditions\); )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26315 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.019 tc
(appr)tj
1.88824 0 td
0.005 tw
(eciating the merits and limit)tj
11.66127 0 td
(ations of alternativ)tj
7.70883 0 td
-0.0188 tc
(e)tj
0.74525 0 td
-0.019 tc
0 tw
(appr)tj
1.88828 0 td
0.005 tw
[(oaches and r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
-23.89187 -1.26317 td
-0.023 tc
0 tw
(cr)tj
0.76853 0 td
0.009 tw
[(afts \(e)56(.g., t)18(o est)19(ablish the contents of the r)19(esear)19(cher\325)36(s \322methods t)19(oolkit\323\); and )]tj
-2.28432 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
0.004 tw
[(ensuring pr)19(ocedur)18(al r)19(egularity and corr)19(ectness \(e)56(.g., t)18(o enhance the quality)]tj
t*
0 tw
(of r)tj
1.48072 0 td
(esear)tj
2.27685 0 td
(ch\). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 304.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tw
[(this is)37(, hart (2000) notes)36(, r)19(ather than e)19(xpr)18(essing the implications of differ-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tw
(ent ont)tj
3.07343 0 td
(ologies and associated epistemologies on methodologies and meth)tj
28.84873 0 td
(-)tj
-31.92216 -1.20001 td
-0.0103 tc
(ods)tj
1.75205 0 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(within a particular sy)19(stem of inquiry)110(. that this latter discussion is critical)]tj
-1.75205 -1.2 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.27224 0 td
-0.0241 tc
(o)tj
0.77678 0 td
(r)tj
0.32729 0 td
-0.024 tc
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.15734 0 td
0.01 tw
(ch discour)tj
4.19579 0 td
(se is under)tj
4.44092 0 td
0 tw
(scor)tj
1.681 0 td
0.01 tw
[(ed b)19(y tw)18(o r)19(elated sets of claims)37(. fir)18(st, claims)]tj
-13.85136 -1.20002 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.29614 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.82326 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(\322syner)tj
2.81347 0 td
0.009 tw
[(gy\323 and \322holism\323 ha)19(v)18(e rhet)19(orical appeal and curr)19(enc)19(y in the liter)-1(-)]tj
-3.93287 -1.20001 td
-0.025 tc
0 tw
(atur)tj
1.60312 0 td
0.011 tw
(es of envir)tj
4.26486 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.22024 0 td
0.011 tw
(al education and envir)tj
9.11289 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.22024 0 td
0.011 tw
(al education r)tj
5.56089 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.15216 0 td
0.011 tw
(ch, and)tj
-29.1344 -1.20002 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.30541 0 td
0.0092 tc
(o)tj
0.96295 0 td
0.009 tc
0.13 tw
(their inter)tj
4.50769 0 td
(sections (gr\237n, 1996). second, r)tj
14.68464 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.32321 0 td
(ch-inf)tj
2.48117 0 td
0.13 tw
[(ormed and e)19(vi)-1(-)]tj
-25.26507 -1.20002 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
(dence-based content and appr)tj
12.86427 0 td
[(oaches r)19(eceiv)18(e support in envir)19(onment)19(al edu-)]tj
-12.86427 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.068 tw
(cation, primarily in r)tj
9.10923 0 td
(elation t)tj
3.56773 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.88301 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(envir)tj
2.18376 0 td
(onment)tj
3.36987 0 td
0.068 tw
(al content, but incr)tj
8.38901 0 td
(easingly t)tj
4.16052 0 td
(o)tj
-31.66313 -1.20002 td
0 tw
(educational matter)tj
8.12891 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(s)tj
0.70359 0 td
0 tc
(\(r)tj
0.907 0 td
(eid & nik)tj
4.03589 0 td
(el, 2003\). )tj
-11.97539 -1.20001 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
(with this in mind, i consider envir)tj
14.19951 0 td
[(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch discour)19(se)]tj
-15.99951 -1.2 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.27412 0 td
-0.0221 tc
(o)tj
0.77886 0 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(be a f)19(orm of claims-making about envir)18(onment)19(al education, in which some)]tj
-1.05298 -1.2 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(claims ar)19(e accor)18(ded legitimac)19(y and other)19(s ar)18(e \322r)19(ebuffed\323 \(see hannigan, 1995,)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(p. 4\). claims-making as an analytical f)19(ocus highlights the effects of conflicts)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(arising fr)19(om differ)18(ences in epistemology in )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 259.4375 136.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.01 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 358.4718 136.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
(and )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 377.3149 136.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
(edu-)tj
-30.43149 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.101 tw
[(cational r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 148.5439 124.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.108 tw
[(on the met)19(a-le)18(v)19(el discour)19(se of envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
-7.5544 -1.2 td
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch, thr)18(ough ar)19(guing f)19(or an e)18(x)19(amination of ho)19(w claims ar)19(e:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 90.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.5158 0 td
0 tc
(cr)tj
0.814 0 td
-0.001 tw
(eated, legitimated and contested, fr)tj
15.34863 0.00001 td
[(om a f)56(oucauldian per)18(spectiv)19(e; and/or )]tj
-17.6784 -1.2632 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.5158 0 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(constructed, fr)19(amed and elabor)18(ated, when vie)19(w)19(ed fr)18(om a social constructivist)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(per)19(spectiv)18(e)56(. )]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
395.987 17.496 23.492 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3534 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(11)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 242.332 33.8347 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/length 7391
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
(by)tj
1.35384 0 td
-0.003 tw
[(w)19(a)18(y of illustr)19(ation, at one le)18(v)19(el, difficulties can be identified r)19(egar)18(ding the)]tj
-1.35384 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.004 tw
[(contr)19(asting disciplinary structur)18(es of )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 196.7981 575.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 296.645 575.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(and )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 315.682 575.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(education-)tj
-27.8682 -1.20001 td
-0.004 tc
-0.009 tw
[(al r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 81.6185 563.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0043 tc
(,)tj
0.53774 0 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(and the distinctiv)19(e cultur)18(es that ha)19(v)19(e emer)19(ged in these differing)]tj
-4.99959 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.006 tw
[(fields of inquiry \(f)56(oster)110(, 1999\). thus)37(, w)19(e might note that in r)18(elation t)19(o )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 341.2241 551.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(edu-)tj
-30.42241 -1.2 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(cational r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 106.521 539.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
(,)tj
0.53494 0 td
-0.007 tw
[(such a discussion dr)19(a)18(w)19(s attention t)19(o a shift in the assump-)]tj
-7.48704 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.099 tw
[(tions)37(, fr)18(ame)19(w)19(orks)37(, and criteria of educational inquiry \(denzin & lincoln,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(2000\). those of qualit)19(ativ)19(e methods of inquiry ar)18(e no)19(w embr)19(aced within envi-)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(r)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch, when quantit)18(ativ)19(e)55(, empirical-analytic)19(, and pos-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(itivistic appr)19(oaches w)18(er)19(e once the or)19(der of the da)18(y \(mar)19(cink)19(o)19(w)19(ski, 2000\). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.014 tw
[(such shifts)37(, and the featur)18(es of envir)19(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch that)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.036 tw
[(no)19(w e)18(xist, ar)19(e fundament)19(ally dissimilar t)18(o those of )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 261.5181 467.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.034 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 455.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(\(including r)19(emote sensing\), within which r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s and educat)18(or)19(s ha)18(v)19(e often)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(r)19(elied on quantit)19(ativ)18(e methods \(descriptiv)19(e)56(, corr)19(elational, causal-compar)18(ativ)19(e)56(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.054 tw
[(e)19(xperiment)19(al, et)18(c)19(.\) t)19(o inf)18(orm the content of envir)19(onment)19(al education and)]tj
t*
0.066 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch \(e)55(.g., st)19(anisstr)19(eet & bo)18(y)19(es)37(, 2000\). incr)19(easingly)110(, the r)19(esear)19(ch pr)19(o-)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(gr)19(ammes of \322)55(envir)19(onment)19(alists\323 ar)19(e not necessarily the pr)18(ogr)19(ammes of)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.004 tw
[<d2>56(educationalists\323 nor ar)19(e the w)18(a)19(y)19(s in which \322sense is made\323 in either ar)19(ea. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tw
[(furthermor)19(e)56(, within envir)18(onment)19(al education and envir)19(onment)18(al edu-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.049 tw
[(cation r)19(esear)18(ch, ther)19(e ar)19(e claims t)18(o complement)19(arity)111(, synthesis and inter-)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(disciplinarity \(st)19(ables & scott, 2002\), y)18(et these claims ha)19(v)18(e been vie)19(w)19(ed as)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.011 tw
[(either ignoring the featur)19(es of unique)55(, hist)19(orically situated f)19(orms of insight,)]tj
t*
0.101 tw
(or an attempt t)tj
6.80441 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.91628 0 td
0 tc
(accommodate them at methodic r)tj
15.16528 0 td
(ather than met)tj
6.62921 0 td
0 tw
(apar)tj
1.90698 0 td
(a-)tj
-31.42216 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tw
[(digmatic le)19(v)19(els)36(, as if philosophical differ)19(ences can be put t)19(o one side \(hart,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tw
[(2000\). this r)19(aises a second set of issues r)18(egar)19(ding: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 287.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(differ)19(ences in ideological and ont)18(ological orient)19(ations; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(their inter)19(action in differing w)18(a)19(y)19(s of kno)19(wing; and )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26315 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
(claims t)tj
3.53472 0 td
0.0061 tc
(o)tj
0.95976 0 td
0.006 tc
[(w)19(arr)18(anted belief and action and the f)19(oundations attributed t)19(o)]tj
-4.49447 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
(them. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 227.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(f)tj
0.47569 0 td
-0.0054 tc
(or)tj
1.16013 0 td
(e)tj
0.47595 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(x)19(ample)56(, at its cor)19(e)56(, the discour)18(se on )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 213.4468 227.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.008 tw
(educational r)tj
5.33139 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.15779 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 300.3254 227.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(is people-cen)tj
5.58965 0 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92219 -1.2 td
-0.014 tw
[(tr)19(ed and goes with the gr)18(ain of anthr)19(opocentric orient)19(ations and ideologies)]tj
t*
0.07 tw
[(\(envir)19(onment)18(al or otherwise\). in contr)19(ast, the discour)19(se on )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 299.4125 203.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
-26.24125 -1.2 td
(r)tj
0.37012 0 td
[(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 74.8436 191.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.009 tw
(can conv)tj
3.87908 0 td
[(e)19(y much other than this)37(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, bio/ecocentric ide)-1(-)]tj
-7.66344 -1.2 td
-0.023 tc
[(ologies and orient)19(ations and the \322ne)18(w envir)19(onment)19(al p)55(ar)19(adigm\323 \(dunlap, v)93(an)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
0 tw
(lier)tj
1.56627 0 td
-0.003 tw
[(e)56(, mertig, & jones)37(, 2000\), which ma)18(y be quite opposed t)19(o o)18(v)19(ertly anthr)19(o-)]tj
-1.56627 -1.2 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(pocentric fr)19(ame)18(w)19(orks)37(, lar)19(gely o)19(wing t)18(o a differ)19(ent w)19(orldvie)18(w \(gough, scott,)]tj
-0.0002 tc
(&)'
0.99967 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(st)19(ables)36(, 2000\).)]tj
0.80033 -1.2 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(such initial observ)19(ations disrupt the confidence that might be placed in)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.008 tw
[(positivist and post-positivist accounts of the r)19(oots of envir)18(onment)19(al educa-)]tj
t*
-0.012 tw
[(tion. in pr)19(esenting datum after datum of what has come t)18(o constitute envi-)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(r)19(onment)19(al education thr)19(ough perhaps a mark)18(edly atheor)19(etical r)19(egister \(e)56(.g.,)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(p)56(almer)110(, 1998\), critics ha)19(v)18(e noted that such hist)19(ories tend t)18(o locate the r)19(oots)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.008 tw
[(of envir)19(onment)18(al education in the cognitiv)19(e and pr)19(ofessional inter)18(ests and)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(12)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/length 6751
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.033 tc
0.013 tw
[(l)-6(e)-6(g)-6(a)-6(cies of envir)19(onment)18(alists r)19(ather than educationalists per se \(goodson, 1996;)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.007 tw
[(a. gough, 1997; mar)19(sden, 1997\), and envir)18(onment)19(al r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s r)19(ather than)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.008 tc
0.001 tw
[(e)-2(d)-2(u)-2(c)-2(a)-2(tional r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s per se \(bent)19(on & short, 1999; stern & dietz, 1994\).)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.003 tw
[(furthermor)19(e)55(, as i ha)19(v)18(e ar)19(gued pr)19(e)18(viously)111(, envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(cher)19(s)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.011 tw
[(ha)19(v)19(e occasion t)18(o \322belie)19(v)19(e in: the e)19(xistence of \324social f)18(acts with a single objec-)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.01 tw
[(tiv)19(e r)18(eality\325; observ)19(able and objectiv)19(e social truth; the possibility of the a)18(v)18(oid-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.008 tc
0.073 tw
[(ance of bias thr)19(ough r)18(esear)19(cher det)19(achment fr)18(om the r)19(esear)19(ch setting; the)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.008 tw
[(efficac)19(y of adher)18(ence t)19(o)1( )1(p)1(r)20(edetermined, infle)18(xible r)19(esear)19(ch pr)18(ocedur)19(es\323 and)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.013 tw
[(further subscribe t)19(o \322the justificat)18(ory notion that the)19(y and \324natur)19(al and ph)18(y)20(s-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.005 tc
0.125 tw
[(ical\325 science pr)19(actitioner)18(s ar)19(e the joint cust)19(odians of these per)18(ceptions\323)]tj
t*
-0.03 tc
0.008 tw
[(\(gough & r)19(eid, 2000, p. 48\). these observ)18(ations f)19(or)19(egr)18(ound the effects of these)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.012 tw
[(belief)19(s on the epistemological, ont)19(ological and envir)18(onment)19(al fr)19(ame)19(w)18(orks of)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.013 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education. this includes)37(,)1( )1(f)20(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, the absence of critique)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.011 tw
[(of the adequac)19(y of the narr)18(at)19(ological gr)19(oundings of envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch discour)19(s)1(e)56(, within the discour)19(s)1(e)57(, and be)18(y)20(ond t)18(o other ar)19(eas)37(.)1( )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.008 tw
[(in short, while the contributions of both envir)19(onment)19(al kno)18(wledge and)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0 tw
[(educational kno)19(wledge t)19(o d)-1(i)1(s)-1(cour)19(se on envir)19(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)18(al education r)18(esear)19(ch ar)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.007 tw
[(ine)19(vit)18(ably partial, situated and pr)19(o)19(visional, this is not alw)19(a)18(y)19(s ackno)19(wledged)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.013 tw
[(in a liter)19(atur)18(e that has been dominated b)19(y the \322pr)19(ofessional-scientific\323 vie)18(w)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.006 tw
[(of r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education noted abo)19(v)18(e \(gough & r)19(eid, 2000\).)]tj
t*
[(hart (2000), f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, e)19(xpr)18(esses concern at \322superficial dialogues about)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.012 tw
(method and simplistic debates about essentially r)tj
21.10347 0 td
(elated schools of thought\323)tj
-21.10347 -1.2 td
-0.028 tc
0.011 tw
[((p. 38) in r)19(elation t)18(o educational r)19(esear)19(ch discour)18(se in envir)19(onment)19(al education)]tj
t*
-0.013 tc
-0.004 tw
[(r)18(esear)19(ch. might this also apply t)19(o the ont)18(ological and epistemological aspects)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(of envir)tj
3.29128 0 td
(onment)tj
3.35323 0 td
(al r)tj
1.35878 0 td
[(esear)19(ch discour)18(se in envir)19(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch?)]tj
-6.20329 -1.20001 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(this then is the backgr)19(ound t)18(o the crux of the ar)19(gument)19(ation that f)19(ollo)18(w)19(s)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(on ho)19(w w)18(e mak)19(e sense of the met)18(a-discour)19(se)56(. thr)18(ough this paper i dr)19(a)18(w on)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
(such ideas t)tj
4.79343 0 td
-0.0254 tc
(o)tj
0.77563 0 td
-0.025 tc
(suggest that w)tj
5.85393 0 td
-0.0253 tc
(e)tj
0.73868 0 td
-0.025 tc
[(heed hart\325)37(s (2000) plea t)19(o consider issues of pur)-1(-)]tj
-12.16167 -1.20001 td
0.013 tc
0.126 tw
[(pose)56(, v)18(alue)56(, and assumption that shape the act of inquiry)111(, r)19(ather than)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(assuming that discour)19(se on envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch is primarily a)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.004 tw
(matter of addr)tj
6.26632 0 td
(essing the r)tj
4.9692 0 td
[(esear)19(cher\325)36(s cr)19(aft, the means of inquiry)111(, technical)]tj
-11.23552 -1.20001 td
0.007 tc
0.131 tw
[(pr)19(oficienc)18(y)111(, or e)19(v)18(en pr)19(ocedur)18(al competence)56(, v)19(aluable though this is f)19(or)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al educat)19(or)19(s)37(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
-0.001 tw
(the wider issue identified her)tj
12.40892 0 td
[(ein is t)19(o addr)18(ess cognitiv)19(e)-1( )-1(a)-1(n)-1(d)-1( )-1(p)-1(r)18(ofessional)]tj
-14.20892 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.008 tw
[(inter)19(ests and their legacies and impacts on discour)18(se about envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
(education r)tj
4.65531 0 td
[(esear)19(ch. t)87(o illustr)19(ate this theme)56(, i use the e)19(x)19(ample of r)18(emote sens-)]tj
-4.65531 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(ing and imaging the envir)19(onment as a pictur)18(e t)19(o e)19(xplor)18(e ho)19(w sense might be)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(made of r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onment)19(al education, fir)19(stly)110(, as a means t)19(o furthering)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(such discussion, but also t)19(o signal a wider debate in envir)18(onment)19(al educa-)]tj
t*
0 tw
(tion)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 89.8457 122.2716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 96.5154 119.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(that invites r)19(eader)18(s t)19(o: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 95.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.5158 0 td
0 tc
-0.012 tw
[(appr)19(aise the language of non-inv)18(asiv)19(e techniques)37(, calibr)19(ation, and interpr)18(e-)]tj
0 -1.2632 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(t)18(ation; utility)111(,)-1( )-1(m)-1(o)-1(d)-1(e)-1(l)-1(l)-1(i)-1(n)-1(g)-1(,)-1( )-1(a)-1(n)-1(d)-1( )-1(a)-1(p)-1(p)-1(l)-1(i)-1(c)-1(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(o)-1(n)-1(;)-1( )-1(t)18(ools)36(, sy)19(stems)37(, and r)18(esour)19(ces; and)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(mastery)111(, authorit)18(ativ)19(eness)37(, and the e)19(xpert in r)18(esear)19(ch; )]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(13)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/length 6764
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 588.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(pr)19(oblematiz)18(e wh)19(y terms lik)19(e \322measur)18(ement,\323 \322pr)19(ediction,\323 and \322beha)19(v)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0.055 tw
[(iour\323 ar)19(e no longer able t)18(o dominate the field of envir)19(onment)19(al education)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch; and )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(disrupt notions of liv)19(ed e)18(xperience; spatial, tempor)19(al, and social constr)19(aints;)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(and inter)19(disciplinarity in this field. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 516.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
[(the ne)19(xt part of the paper pr)18(esents the r)19(emote sensing e)19(x)19(ample)56(, after)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.006 tw
[(which i attempt t)19(o br)18(oaden the \322polyphonic\323 aspects of the ar)19(gument)19(ation)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(b)19(y intr)19(oducing some \322)55(contr)19(apunt)19(al\323 themes)36(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 464.9036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(the case of remote sensing)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 447.2036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.114 tw
[(phot)19(ogr)18(ammetry and r)19(emote sensing is the art, science)56(, and technology of)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.014 tw
[(obt)19(aining r)18(eliable inf)19(ormation fr)19(om non-cont)18(act imaging and other sensor sy)19(s-)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(tems about the earth and its envir)19(onment, and other ph)18(y)19(sical objects and)]tj
t*
0.022 tc
0.266 tw
[(pr)19(ocesses thr)18(ough r)19(ecor)19(ding, measuring, analy)18(sing and r)19(epr)19(esent)19(ation.)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(\(international society f)19(or phot)18(ogr)19(ammetry and r)19(emote sensing, 200)56(1\))]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 381.2036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.005 tw
[(as suggested abo)19(v)18(e)56(, envir)19(onment)18(al r)19(esear)19(ch techniques r)19(ely on a technolo-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.0256 tc
(gy)tj
1.22899 0 td
-0.026 tc
0.009 tw
[(and an interpr)19(et)18(ativ)19(e principle)56(. sensing methods ma)19(y be somatic)18(, corpor)19(eal)]tj
-1.22899 -1.2 td
-0.025 tc
0.008 tw
[(\(i.e)56(., based on the body\321manual, visual, et)18(c)19(.\) or some e)19(xtension of these \(e)56(.g.,)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.008 tw
[(r)18(emote sensing techniques)37(, including the electr)19(o-optical, micr)18(o)19(w)18(a)19(v)18(e/acousti-)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.005 tw
[(cal, et)19(c)18(.\) so as t)19(o br)19(oaden our sensory modes)37(, r)18(anges)37(, and capacities f)19(or dat)18(a)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.007 tw
[(detection, identification, and analy)19(sis)36(. in the case of r)19(emote sensing, meth-)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.01 tw
[(ods necessit)19(ate non-cont)18(act \(non-inv)19(asiv)19(e\) observ)19(ation and thus r)18(emo)19(v)19(e the)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.013 tw
[(\322human e)19(xperiencer\323 as a dir)19(ect \322sensor)110(.\323 a)37(t the same time)56(, the)19(y highlight)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.01 tw
[(the r)19(ole of interpr)18(et)19(ation in both e)19(xplicating and accounting f)18(or the qualities)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0.012 tw
[<d272>19(e)18(v)19(ealed\323 in the dat)18(a \(typically in quantit)19(ativ)19(e f)19(orm\), fr)18(equently r)19(elying on)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.006 tw
(computer technologies in the fir)tj
13.10648 0 td
(st place)tj
3.04578 0 td
(,)tj
0.51626 0 td
(but also the e)tj
5.49539 0 td
[(xperience)56(, inter)19(ests)36(, and)]tj
-22.16391 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.011 tw
[(e)19(xpertise of the r)18(esear)19(cher t)19(o garner meaning fr)19(om the dat)18(a r)19(epr)19(esent)18(ation. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.59023 0 td
-0.021 tc
0 tw
(efr)tj
1.10347 0 td
0.007 tw
(aming this e)tj
5.07768 0 td
0 tc
(x)tj
0.49722 0 td
-0.021 tc
(ample in the light of the earlier discussion, r)tj
18.11088 0 td
(emote sens)tj
4.74255 0 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92203 -1.20002 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
(ing inv)tj
2.90563 0 td
0 tw
(olv)tj
1.25652 0 td
-0.013 tw
[(es the use of instruments or sensor)19(s t)18(o \322)56(captur)19(e\323 the spectr)18(al and)]tj
-4.16215 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.004 tw
(spatial r)tj
3.42912 0 td
(elations of objects and materials observ)tj
17.14756 0 td
(able at a dist)tj
5.49342 0 td
0 tw
(ance\321typical)tj
5.85205 0 td
(-)tj
-31.92215 -1.20001 td
0.063 tw
(ly fr)tj
1.76677 0 td
(om abo)tj
3.34074 0 td
(v)tj
0.4812 0 td
(e)tj
0.44409 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.61894 0 td
0 tc
(an aerial phot)tj
6.20017 0 td
0 tw
(ogr)tj
1.38793 0 td
0.063 tw
[(aph is a common e)19(x)19(ample of a r)18(emotely)]tj
-14.23984 -1.20002 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
(sensed pr)tj
4.02424 0 td
(oduct \(b)tj
3.39231 0 td
-0.0161 tc
(y)tj
0.76685 0 td
-0.016 tc
[(camer)19(a and st)18(or)19(age medium\). its r)18(ele)19(v)19(ance f)19(or discussion)]tj
-8.1834 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.124 tw
(of ont)tj
2.66055 0 td
0 tw
(ology)tj
2.22265 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.6797 0 td
0 tc
(epistemology)tj
5.66688 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.67973 0 td
0 tc
0.124 tw
(and methodology in envir)tj
11.53766 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.36987 0 td
0.124 tw
(al education)tj
-26.81704 -1.20001 td
(r)tj
0.34967 0 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)18(ch discour)18(se is made clear when w)19(e consider ho)19(w time)55(, space)56(,)-1( )-1(p)-1(l)-1(a)-1(c)-1(e)55(,)]tj
-0.34967 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.045 tw
[(and sign/symbol structur)19(e the r)18(eality being sensed, and the sense-making)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(pr)19(ocess/pr)18(oduct \(p)56(a)18(yne)56(, 1999\). t)88(o continue)56(, r)18(emote sensing typically inv)19(o)-1(l)-1(v)18(es)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(pr)tj
0.90194 -0.00001 td
-0.011 tw
[(ecise measur)19(ement of biological, chemical and ph)18(y)19(sical char)19(acteristics of)]tj
-0.9019 -1.2 td
0.0049 tc
(a)tj
0.9217 0 td
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(terr)19(ain \(location, height-depth, temper)19(atur)18(e)56(, moistur)19(e content, chlor)19(o-)]tj
-0.9217 -1.2 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(ph)19(yll content, surf)18(ace r)19(oughness)37(, et)18(c)20(. f)18(or dat)19(a on v)19(eget)18(ation, soils)37(, miner)19(als)37(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.01 tw
[(w)19(ater)111(, ice)56(, and the atmospher)18(e)56(, and so on\) as a means t)19(o interpr)19(eting envi)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(r)18(onment)19(al qualities)37(, and f)19(or purposes of monit)18(oring, pr)19(ediction, and contr)19(ol.)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.032 tw
[(the close r)19(elationship betw)18(een technology)111(, teleology)111(, and interpr)19(et)18(ation is)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(14)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/length 6193
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(emphasiz)19(ed in the possibilities a)18(v)19(ailable t)18(o the analytical pr)19(ocess)37(, which, in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.108 tw
[(turn, ar)19(e r)18(elated t)19(o notions of per)19(spectiv)18(e)56(, purpose)56(, and vie)19(wpoint. thus)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(r)19(emote sensing of the envir)18(onment is often justified in terms of assa)19(ying the)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(earth\325)37(s r)18(esour)19(ces t)19(o inf)18(orm and implement r)19(esour)19(ce management str)19(ategies)36(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.008 tw
[(t)88(echnologies of r)18(emote sensing ar)19(e div)19(er)19(se in a v)18(ariety of w)19(a)18(y)19(s)37(, whether)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.018 tc
-0.002 tw
[(it be in terms of: sophistication and penetr)19(ativ)18(e gaz)19(e)56(, the art and science \(and)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.023 tc
0.004 tw
[(hist)19(ory\) of phot)18(ogr)19(aph)19(y \(visible electr)18(omagnetic r)19(ange t)19(o multispectr)18(al r)19(anges\),)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.006 tc
-0.014 tw
[(and e)19(v)18(en the aerial platf)19(orms \(bir)19(ds > balloons > kites > air)19(cr)18(afts > satel-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.019 tc
-0.001 tw
[(lites\) of the technology)111(. with the adv)18(ent of sub-orbit)19(al and orbit)19(al satellite sen-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.013 tc
-0.007 tw
[(sor sy)19(stems)36(, a simplified but gener)19(al model of r)19(emote sensing might inv)18(olv)19(e: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 455.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(acquiring dat)19(a fr)18(om electr)19(omagnetic r)19(adiation in the visible)55(, near-infr)19(ar)19(ed, mid-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0.032 tw
[(dle-infr)19(ar)18(ed, thermal infr)19(ar)19(ed, and micr)18(o)19(w)19(a)19(v)19(e portions of the spectrum on)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(absorption, r)19(eflection or emission; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(calibr)19(ating/pr)18(ocessing the signal; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(analyzing the dat)19(a using a v)18(ariety of image pr)19(ocessing algorithms)37(, such as pho-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(t)19(ogr)19(ammetry techniques; and )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26315 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(pr)19(esenting or displa)18(ying the r)19(esults as images or spatial inf)18(ormation sy)19(stems)37(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 359.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0092 tc
(the)tj
1.84839 0 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(outputs)37(, lik)18(e f)19(alse colour imaging, r)19(atio codes and brightness codes)36(, and)]tj
-1.84839 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.131 tw
[(la)19(y)19(er)18(ed and composite images)37(, r)19(emind us of the r)18(ole of the interpr)19(etiv)19(e)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0 tw
(pr)tj
0.86248 0 td
0.008 tw
(ocess as the v)tj
5.67623 0 td
(ehicle f)tj
2.9229 0 td
(or r)tj
1.455 0 td
[(endering the dat)19(a intelligible t)18(o the mind. w)93(e might)]tj
-10.91661 -1.20001 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(also consider the conceptual le)19(xicons and )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 246.2545 323.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.022 tc
(telos)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 267.2268 323.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(attribut)19(able t)18(o notions lik)19(e scal-)]tj
-19.42268 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.004 tw
[(ing, r)19(eal w)18(orld modelling, global imaging, combining and scoping, and the)]tj
t*
0.015 tw
(issue of r)tj
3.93517 0 td
(esolution uncert)tj
6.95734 0 td
0 tw
(ainties)tj
2.79541 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.57042 0 td
0 tc
0.015 tw
[(expr)19(essed her)18(e ar)19(e desir)19(es typically asso-)]tj
-14.25834 -1.20001 td
-0.014 tw
[(ciated with the pur)19(suit of pr)18(ediction, finality and contr)19(ol, and that the tech-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.013 tc
0.126 tw
[(niques can be e)19(xtended. in the case of the latter)110(, r)19(emote sensing and)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(phot)tj
1.94706 0 td
(ogr)tj
1.38962 0 td
0.138 tw
[(ammetry techniques ar)19(e incr)18(easingly applied t)19(o other fields)37(, lik)18(e)]tj
-3.33668 -1.20001 td
-0.028 tc
0.008 tw
[(m)-6(e)-6(d)-6(i)-6(c)-6(i)-6(n)-6(e)50(,)-6( )-6(h)-6(e)-6(alth, engineering, r)18(obotics)37(, ar)19(chitectur)18(e)56(, ar)19(chaeology)110(, et)19(c)18(. f)19(or close-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
0.136 tw
[(r)19(ange e)19(x)19(aminations and interr)19(ogations of bodies and sensory capacities)36(.)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.133 tw
(the techniques r)tj
7.46963 0 td
(emain in the domain of the technical-scientific and the)tj
-7.46963 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.015 tw
[(associated discur)19(siv)18(e pr)19(actices of the \322sciences\323 r)18(ather than the \322)56(arts)37(.\323 one)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.008 tw
[(effect, it appear)19(s)37(, is t)18(o r)19(eassur)19(e us that w)18(e ma)19(y feel sur)19(e and confident of the)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
0.135 tw
(claims made thr)tj
7.24785 0 td
[(ough r)19(emote sensing and imaging as a w)18(a)19(y of kno)18(wing)]tj
-7.24785 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0 tw
[(envir)19(onments)36(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 152.5617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(applied fields and meta-theoretical activities)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 133.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.029 tw
[(t)88(w)19(o observ)19(ations ar)18(e offer)19(ed about this e)19(x)19(ample in light of the earlier dis)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tw
[(cussion, bef)19(or)18(e considering the r)19(ole of interpr)19(et)18(ation further)111(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 97.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.006 tw
(to return to an earlier point, in general, both \322education\323 and \322environment\323 are)tj
0.2551 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.012 tw
[(r)-6(e)-6(g)-7(arded as applied fields. that is, they tend to derive their cognitive structures,)]tj
0.2551 -1.2 td
0.073 tw
(purposes and methodologies from elsewhere \(typically, we might assume, the)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(15)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/length 6864
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
-0.001 tw
[(human and the natural sciences, respectively\). as such, two effects are appar)-3(e)-6(n)-6(t)-6(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 575.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(fir)19(st, speculation about teleology\321e)18(xplaining what is happening in terms of)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(what is t)19(o be achie)18(v)19(ed\321will often locate the \322)56(ends\323 of \322)56(education\323 and)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[<d2>56(envir)19(onment\323 be)19(y)19(ond their subst)18(antiv)19(e domain, as in deliber)19(ations on)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(purposes)37(, intentions)36(, or goals)37(. thus)37(, pur)18(suit of educational ends ma)19(y be jus-)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(tified b)19(y r)18(efer)19(ence t)19(o securing a socio-economic imper)18(ativ)19(e)55(, lik)19(e \322tr)19(aining or)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(equipping the w)19(orkf)18(or)19(ce)56(,\323 while envir)18(onment)19(al ends)37(, as in r)18(emote sensing,)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(ma)19(y r)18(efer t)19(o ensuring efficient r)19(esour)18(ce use)56(, t)19(o continue the earlier e)18(x)19(ample)56(.)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.042 tw
[(in the specific case of envir)19(onment)18(al education, both ma)19(y be r)19(egar)18(ded as)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(inadequate and an attempt ma)19(y be made t)19(o mo)18(v)19(e be)19(y)19(ond both; o)19(v)19(er)18(ar)19(ching)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(imper)19(ativ)18(es f)19(or envir)19(onment)18(al education ar)19(e typically e)19(xpr)19(essed in terms of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.009 tw
[(slogans lik)19(e \322sa)18(ving the planet\323 or \322securing a sust)19(ainable futur)19(e)56(.\323 thus)36(, in)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(pr)19(o)19(viding a link with r)18(esear)19(ch, smith-sebast)19(o (2000) writes: \322it w)19(ould be f)18(ar)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(mor)19(e pr)18(oductiv)19(e t)19(o e)18(xplor)19(e ho)19(w the complement)18(ary methods of inquiry can)]tj
-0.0168 tc
(be)'
1.28635 0 td
-0.017 tc
0 tw
[(emplo)19(y)18(ed )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 93.7602 419.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
[(collabor)19(ativ)18(ely)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 154.3695 419.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
(and )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 172.8051 419.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
[(cooper)19(ativ)18(ely)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 228.1899 419.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(t)19(o mor)18(e completely e)19(xplor)19(e the)]tj
-19.11899 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.011 tw
[(issues f)19(acing ee as w)18(ell as society\325)37(s challenge t)19(o de)18(v)19(elop in an ecologically)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(sust)19(ainable manner\323 (p. 13). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(in f)56(oucault\325)36(s w)19(ork (1973), the pr)19(oblems associated with \322)55(applied\323 fields)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(ar)19(e e)18(xplained as those of the human sciences in gener)19(al. that is)37(, their diffi-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(culties ar)19(e attributed t)18(o, \322their danger)19(ous f)19(amiliarity with philosoph)18(y)111(, their ill-)]tj
t*
0.022 tc
0.133 tw
[(defined r)19(eliance upon other domains of kno)18(wledge)56(, their perpetually)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
(secondary and deriv)tj
8.42602 0 td
(ed char)tj
3.06915 0 td
0 tw
(acter)tj
1.9364 0 td
-0.0202 tc
(,)tj
0.5218 0 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
(and also their claim t)tj
8.67465 0 td
-0.0202 tc
(o)tj
0.78075 0 td
-0.02 tc
[(univ)19(er)18(sality)111(,\323 (p. 348))]tj
-23.40878 -1.20001 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(with the further observ)19(ation that all of the human sciences: \322interlock and can)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(alw)19(a)18(y)18(s be used t)19(o interpr)19(et one another; their fr)18(ontier)19(s become blurr)18(ed, inter-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.003 tw
(mediary and composite disciplines multiply endlessly)tj
23.05374 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55908 0 td
0 tc
(and in the end their)tj
-23.61282 -1.20001 td
0 tw
[(pr)19(oper object ma)18(y e)19(v)19(en disappear alt)18(ogether\323 (p. 358).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(second, in terms of the met)19(a-discour)18(se on r)19(esear)19(ch, debates about)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
(questions of ont)tj
6.61844 0 td
0 tw
(ology)tj
2.11654 0 td
-0.0213 tc
(,)tj
0.52069 0 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(epistemology and methodology\321r)19(egar)19(ding educational)]tj
-9.25567 -1.20001 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(or envir)19(onment)18(al dimensions\321tend t)19(o r)19(epeat the distinctions made betw)18(e)-1(e)-1(n)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.052 tw
[(the tw)19(o ar)18(eas)37(, and ar)19(e often at one r)19(emo)18(v)19(e fr)19(om (or out of step with) the)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
(debates of each \322par)tj
8.48611 0 td
(ent discipline)tj
5.3984 0 td
[(.\323 the upshot is)37(, the met)19(a-discour)18(se on envi-)]tj
-13.88451 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.12 tw
[(r)19(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch tends t)19(o be chr)18(onologically and epistemo-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.003 tw
[(logically dela)19(y)19(ed fr)18(om those of the \322st)19(ate of the art\323 \(or what w)19(e might call)]tj
t*
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
(the \322st)tj
2.6549 0 td
[(ate of the ark\323\), when w)19(e consider inputs fr)18(om envir)19(onment)19(al and envi)-1(-)]tj
-2.6549 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(r)19(onment)18(al educational conte)19(xts \(connell, 1997; eisner)111(, 1997; p)56(almer)111(, 1998\).)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.011 tw
(while the dist)tj
5.98492 0 td
[(ance this cr)19(eates has str)18(ategic benefits f)19(or w)19(ould-be pr)18(ot)19(ago-)]tj
-5.98492 -1.2 td
0.073 tw
[(nists and casualties in a \322par)19(adigm w)18(ar)111(,\323 observ)19(er)18(s of this \322)56(conflict\323 ma)19(y)]tj
t*
0.132 tw
[(r)19(egar)19(d envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch discour)18(se as little mor)19(e than a)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(\322deriv)19(ed discour)18(se)56(,\323 and thus)37(, in other senses)37(, perhaps e)18(v)19(en r)18(emote)56(, isolat-)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(ed, or anachr)19(onistic)18(, as befits an ante-bellum field \(see er)19(aut, 1985; mr)19(az)18(ek,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(1993; rickinson & colleagues)37(, 2000\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 83.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tc
-0.009 tw
[(my second point is, as with the \322science\323 and \322art\323 in the remote sensing exam)3(-)]tj
0.2551 -1.2 td
0 tc
[(ple, emphasis on the \322progeny\323 of the conjoining of education and envir)-6(o)-6(n)-6(m)-6(e)-6(n)-6(t)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(16)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
12 0 obj
<<
/length 7935
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 588.135 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.006 tc
-0.011 tw
[(in this discourse\321which i take here to be represented by the activities of envi)-3(-)]tj
0.25507 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.049 tw
[(ronmental educators\321may draw the focus of analysis in meta-theoretical dis)2(-)]tj
0.25507 -1.20001 td
0.12 tw
(cussion away from debates and issues about parentage \(and ontological or)tj
0.25507 -1.20001 td
0.01 tw
(epistemological compatibility\) towards a focus on environmental education, its)tj
0.25507 -1.2 td
0.012 tw
(necessity, and the interconnectedness it represents between educational and)tj
0.25507 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
0.009 tw
(environmental discourse.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 174.4711 528.135 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(t)88(o illustr)19(ate)56(, debates about unesco\325)37(s \322priority of pri-)]tj
-10.14711 -1.2 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(orities)37(,\323 whether it be r)18(eorienting teacher education t)19(o include envir)19(on-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(ment)19(al education or \322r)18(eorienting teacher educat)1(ion t)18(o addr)19(ess sust)19(ainability\323)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.085 tw
[(as mor)19(e r)18(ecently e)19(xpr)19(essed \(hopkins & mck)36(eo)19(wn, 200)56(1\), must no)18(w also)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.013 tw
[(attend t)19(o claims within unesco t)18(o e)19(xtending its conceptual \322f)19(amily\323, such)]tj
t*
0.029 tw
[(that: \322l)19(earning fr)18(om the successful e)19(xperiences of other education r)19(ef)19(orm)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.01 tw
[(m)1(o)20(v)19(ements)37(, and interpr)18(eting their lessons t)19(o education f)19(o)1(r)1( )1(s)1(u)1(s)1(t)20(a)1(i)1(n)1(a)1(b)1(i)1(l)1(i)1(t)1(y)111(,)1( )1(m)1(u)1(s)1(t)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(become the ne)19(w priority of priorities f)18(or education\323 (fien, 2000, p. 275).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.0264 tc
(in)tj
1.0812 0 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(r)19(elation t)18(o the ar)19(gument being de)19(v)19(eloped her)18(e)56(, this suggests that a clear)]tj
-2.8812 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(sense of the social construction of envir)19(onment)18(al education and the or)19(der-)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(ing of discour)19(ses \(f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, w)18(e might ask, )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 268.9417 408.135 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.011 tw
[(wh)19(y is this the )-1(pr)1(i)-1(o)1(rity e)18(x)19(actly)110(,)]tj
-19.59417 -1.2 td
0.005 tc
0.124 tw
[(and ho)19(w did it come t)18(o be so?)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 204.9989 396.135 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.0055 tc
(\))tj
0.71833 0 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(is absent as the discour)19(se shifts t)18(o)20(w)19(ar)19(d)1(s)]tj
-13.91822 -1.2 td
-0.016 tc
0 tw
(incorpor)tj
3.51935 0 td
0.002 tw
(ating a kind of \322ont)tj
8.05978 0 td
(ological gr)tj
4.23374 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
0.46534 0 td
-0.016 tc
[(vity\323 that its \322par)19(ents\323 nor some com-)]tj
-16.27821 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(ment)19(at)19(or)18(s in the field w)19(ould necessarily wish t)19(o see it e)18(xhibit \(gough, 199)56(1;)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
(n. gough, 1999\). )tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.004 tc
(furthermor)tj
4.99834 0 td
0 tc
(e)tj
0.4478 0 td
0.0035 tc
(,)tj
0.6983 0 td
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
(with r)tj
2.67483 0 td
0 tw
(egar)tj
1.86593 0 td
0.0036 tc
(d)tj
0.97632 0 td
0.004 tc
0.135 tw
[(t)19(o the or)18(dering of discour)19(s)1(e)1(s)38(, both within)]tj
-13.46152 -1.20001 td
-0.018 tc
0.005 tw
[(and be)19(y)19(ond the envir)19(onment)19(al education community)110(, the centr)19(a)1(l)1( )1(i)1(s)1(s)1(u)1(e)1( )1(i)1(n)1( )1(t)1(h)1(i)1(s)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(illustr)19(ation is the claim that it is t)18(o be \322the priority of priorities f)19(or education.\323)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.001 tw
(that is)tj
2.85347 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55687 0 td
0 tc
(of cour)tj
3.01848 0 td
0 tw
(se)tj
0.86987 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55696 0 td
0 tc
0.001 tw
[(if the claim is not intended as a rhet)19(orical plo)18(y or meant)]tj
-7.85565 -1.20001 td
0.052 tw
[(figur)19(ativ)18(ely)111(. if it is t)19(o be t)18(ak)19(en seriously)111(, it is cert)18(ain t)19(o r)19(aise the e)18(y)19(ebr)19(o)19(w)19(s)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.026 tc
0 tw
(\(met)tj
1.87564 0 td
0.012 tw
(aphorically and liter)tj
8.06425 0 td
(ally?\) of other act)tj
6.96259 0 td
-0.027 tc
0 tw
(or)tj
0.83528 0 td
-0.0264 tc
(s)tj
0.66355 0 td
(in)tj
1.04411 0 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
(the wider education ar)tj
9.19686 0 td
(ena who)tj
-28.64228 -1.20002 td
0 tc
0.091 tw
(suppose their education has priority st)tj
17.00858 0 td
0 tw
(atus)tj
1.74073 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.64675 0 td
0 tc
0.091 tw
[(if not mor)19(e)56(, or who question)]tj
-19.39606 -1.20001 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(whether the pur)19(suit of this end (telos) is actually desir)18(able or possible)56(. \(a case)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.121 tw
(in point will be r)tj
7.57573 0 td
(esponses t)tj
4.63923 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.93591 0 td
0 tc
(the un-sponsor)tj
6.80569 0 td
(ed decade of education f)tj
11.33671 0 td
0 tw
(or)tj
-31.29327 -1.20001 td
0.007 tc
(sust)tj
1.80595 0 td
0.132 tw
(ainable de)tj
4.79526 0 td
[(v)19(elopment, 2005-20)56(15, an ou)-1(t)19(come of the johannesbur)19(g)]tj
-6.60121 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(summit on sust)19(ainable de)18(v)19(elopment.\) in man)19(y countries)37(, f)18(or e)19(x)19(ample)56(, this)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.008 tc
0 tw
(ma)tj
1.354 0 td
-0.0082 tc
(y)tj
0.77482 0 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
(be seen as in competition with go)tj
14.28952 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.47314 0 td
-0.008 tc
(ernment policies pr)tj
8.25954 0 td
(omoting liter)tj
5.44337 0 td
0 tw
[(ac)19(y)111(,)]tj
-30.59438 -1.20001 td
0 tc
(numer)tj
2.85083 0 td
0.013 tw
[(ac)19(y or k)18(e)19(y skills)37(, or internationally)110(, in the ngo-led sect)19(or)111(, adv)18(ocates)]tj
-2.85083 -1.2 td
0.008 tw
[(of other adjectiv)19(al educations)36(, lik)19(e \322)56(education f)19(or peace)55(,\323 or \322)56(education f)19(or)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
0 tw
(citiz)tj
1.68615 0 td
-0.003 tw
(enship.\323 f)tj
4.2409 0 td
(or unesco)tj
4.78893 0 td
-0.0108 tc
(,)tj
0.53119 0 td
-0.011 tc
(tensions e)tj
4.25912 0 td
[(xist with supporter)19(s of \322basic education)]tj
-15.50629 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
(pr)tj
0.90698 0 td
0.056 tw
[(o)19(vision\323 who r)19(egar)18(d this as separ)19(ate fr)19(om \322)55(education f)19(or sust)19(ainability\323)]tj
-0.90698 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(though it could be ar)19(gued that in each of these e)19(x)18(amples the competing pri-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.119 tw
[(orities)37(, and or)18(der)19(s of discour)19(se)55(, ar)19(e intimately connected \(r)19(eid, scott, &)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0 tw
(gough, 2002\).)tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.014 tw
(also in r)tj
3.60048 0.00001 td
(elation t)tj
3.51325 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.82854 0 td
0 tc
(earlier comments)tj
7.58639 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.56949 0 td
0 tc
(it is noted that r)tj
6.94306 0.00001 td
(outes t)tj
2.90217 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.82849 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(securing)tj
-28.5719 -1.2 td
-0.009 tw
[(the goal e)19(xpr)18(essed in this \322priority of priorities\323 ar)19(e v)19(aried. earlier w)18(ork b)19(y)]tj
t*
0.04 tw
(fien and colleagues \(e)tj
9.6384 0.00001 td
(.g., 1993\) suggests a pr)tj
10.16191 0.00001 td
[(efer)19(ence f)18(or mer)19(ging the co-)]tj
-19.8003 -1.2 td
(e)tj
0.4812 0 td
0 tw
(xtensiv)tj
3.0916 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.778 0 td
0 tc
(dimensions of envir)tj
8.59065 0.00001 td
(onment)tj
3.36988 0.00001 td
(al education and envir)tj
9.62917 0.00001 td
(onment)tj
3.36987 0.00001 td
(al edu-)tj
-29.3103 -1.2 td
0.02 tc
0.119 tw
[(cation r)19(esear)18(ch, such that the particular truths of the f)19(ormer become)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(17)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
13 0 obj
<<
/length 7080
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(insepar)19(able fr)18(om the truth-seeking pr)19(actices of the latter)111(, thr)18(ough, f)19(or e)19(x)19(am-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(ple)56(, the use of \(participat)19(ory\) action r)18(esear)19(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 226.8077 578.2717 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 233.2602 575.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(despite its appar)19(ent str)18(engths)]tj
-19.62602 -1.20001 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(or dr)19(a)18(wbacks)37(, it is not the method that is at question her)18(e)56(. r)18(ather)111(, as outlined)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.081 tw
[(in the opening section t)19(o this paper)110(, such a r)19(oute is import)19(ant f)18(or under-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(st)19(anding the w)18(a)19(y in which)-1( k)19(e)18(y issues f)19(or r)19(esear)18(ch discour)19(se ar)19(e then fr)18(amed.)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.012 tw
[(f)56(or inst)19(ance)56(, in carrying out such r)18(esear)19(ch, does this imply consensus and)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(implement)19(ation r)18(egar)19(ding \322the priority of priorities)37(,\323 r)19(ather than an inspec-)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(tion of what is concealed and r)19(e)-1(n)-1(d)-1(e)-1(r)18(e)-1(d)-1( )-1(n)-1(a)-1(t)-1(u)-1(r)17(al or neutr)19(a)-1(l)-1( )-1(a)-1(b)-1(o)-1(u)-1(t)-1( )-1(e)-1(n)-1(v)-1(i)-1(r)18(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)17(a)-1(l)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(education r)19(esear)18(ch and envir)19(onment)19(al and educational discour)19(s)1(e)1(s)1(:)1( )1(n)1(a)1(m)1(e)1(l)1(y)112(,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(its natur)19(e(s), purpose(s), st)18(atus and pr)19(actices \(st)19(ables & scott, 2002\)? )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(the \322priorities\323 tr)19(ope ma)18(y)1( )1(w)20(ell lead t)19(o silence about the art and politics)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.039 tw
[(of kno)19(wledge construction f)18(or education and about envir)19(onments in envi-)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(r)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch, such that the cor)18(e claims of envir)19(onment)18(al edu-)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(cation come t)19(o r)18(epr)19(esent a liter)19(al, encompassing, and st)19(able truth about the)]tj
t*
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(w)19(orld, our)19(selv)18(es)37(, other)19(s \(species)36(, beings)37(, envir)19(onments)36(, et)19(c)19(.\), and the ties that)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.044 tw
[(bind each t)19(ogether \(p)56(a)18(yne)56(, 1997\). as english \(2000\) observ)19(es)36(, in such cir-)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(cumst)19(ances the \322truth\323 attributed t)18(o the pr)19(ocesses and pr)19(oducts of r)19(esear)18(ch-)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(ing\321principles and/or pr)19(actices\321can be pr)18(esented as singular)111(, unequiv)19(ocal,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.007 tw
[(and tr)19(anscendent, wher)18(e what is meant b)19(y tr)19(anscendence implies that the)]tj
t*
-0.012 tw
[(design of the r)19(esear)18(ch or the subst)19(antiv)19(e out)18(comes ar)19(e be)19(y)19(ond r)19(epr)18(oach. it)]tj
t*
0.008 tw
[(isn\325t that 世界杯2022赛程表淘汰赛
 or teacher)19(s or r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s cannot f)18(orm alternativ)19(e opin-)]tj
t*
-0.013 tw
(ions about educational r)tj
10.36567 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.27686 0 td
-0.013 tw
(ch or envir)tj
4.63832 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.36987 0 td
-0.013 tw
[(al r)19(esear)18(ch in envir)19(onmen-)]tj
-20.65072 -1.20001 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(t)18(al education. r)19(ather)111(, it is that within this particular fr)19(ame)18(w)19(ork f)19(or truth claims)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(and claims-making, ther)19(e is either little opportunity or fe)19(w means t)18(o do so. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.007 tc
0 tw
(thus)tj
2.00855 0 td
-0.0074 tc
(,)tj
0.53452 0 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
(if t)tj
1.11202 0 td
0 tw
(ak)tj
0.98547 0 td
-0.007 tw
[(en liter)19(ally)110(, critical discour)19(se analy)19(sis alerts us t)19(o the f)18(act that)]tj
-6.44056 -1.20001 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(accepting the kind of contention that fien mak)19(es abo)18(v)19(e risks er)19(asing the mul-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.005 tw
[(tiplicity of truths of other f)19(orms of envir)18(onment)19(al education kno)19(wledge)56(, its)]tj
t*
0 tw
(pr)tj
0.90698 0 td
0.037 tw
(oduction and contest)tj
9.14803 0 td
[(ation, within a unif)19(orm education f)18(or sust)19(ainability)]tj
-10.05501 -1.20001 td
0 tw
((jickling, 1997). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 224.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(w(h)ither environmental research?)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 205.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(if this is a possibility with the truths of other f)19(orms of education, that is)37(, the)18(y)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
(become incorpor)tj
7.08175 0 td
(ated (or not) int)tj
6.44288 0 td
-0.0196 tc
(o)tj
0.78136 0 td
-0.02 tc
(this particular \322r)tj
6.67626 0 td
(egime of truth\323 about envi)tj
10.93997 0 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92222 -1.20001 td
(r)tj
0.34766 0 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
(onments and sust)tj
7.60904 0 td
[(ainability)111(, w)18(e might also consider the f)19(a)-1(t)-1(e)-1( )-1(o)-1(f)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1( )-1<d2>-1(o)-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1(r)110<2cd3>]tj
-7.9567 -1.20001 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
(that of envir)tj
5.11401 0 td
[(onment)19(al r)18(esear)19(ch within envir)19(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch dis-)]tj
-5.11401 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(cour)19(se)55(. thus)37(, in terms of its significance f)19(or r)18(esear)19(ch as a whole)56(, which tends)]tj
0 tc
(t)'
0.29614 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.8216 0 td
0 tc
0.007 tw
[(be e)19(v)18(aluated against the criteria of making a subst)19(antiv)19(e contribution t)19(o)]tj
-1.11774 -1.20001 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(empirical kno)19(wledge and/or adv)18(anc)1(ing theory)110(, further discour)19(se analy)19(sis might)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(pur)19(sue whether envir)18(onment)19(al r)19(esear)18(ch is r)19(egar)19(ded as \322good\323 in educational)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(terms)tj
2.4627 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.5558 0 td
0 tc
(or educational r)tj
6.79456 0.00001 td
(esear)tj
2.27685 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(ch)tj
1.29665 0 td
0 tc
(as \322good\323 in envir)tj
7.7932 0.00001 td
[(onment)19(al terms?)]tj
-19.3797 -1.2 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(this r)19(efr)18(aming r)19(elocates both envir)19(onment and education t)19(o)19(w)18(ar)19(d the cen-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.005 tw
[(tr)19(e of analy)18(sis and dr)19(a)19(w)19(s attention again t)19(o issues concerning the or)18(dering)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
(of discour)tj
4.0339 0 td
-0.024 tc
0 tw
(ses)tj
1.2447 0 td
-0.0235 tc
(.)tj
0.5184 0 td
-0.023 tc
(or)tj
0.9533 0 td
-0.0235 tc
(,)tj
0.5185 0 td
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(as noel gough (1999) puts it, if the)19(y ar)19(en\325t at odds with each)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(18)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/length 5847
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(other)111(, r)18(ather than e)19(x)19(amine)55(, \322what education can do f)19(or envir)19(onment)19(al qual)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.011 tw
[(ity)111(,\323 w)18(e might interr)19(ogate)56(, \322what envir)18(onment)19(al qualities can do f)19(or educa-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(tion,\323 and the gener)19(ativ)18(e possibilities that envir)19(onments and envir)19(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)18(a)-1(l)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(subject matter)19(s)37(, \322offer t)19(o education conceiv)18(ed as educar)19(e\321as a \324bringing f)19(orth\325)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.006 tw
[(of human life\323 \(p. 4)56(16\). such an appr)18(oac)1(h)-1( helps pr)19(oblematiz)19(e simplistic or)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(dualistic r)19(eadings of the r)18(elativ)19(ely open notions of )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 282.6022 527.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(envir)19(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)17(al r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 379.0314 527.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.017 tc
(and)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 515.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
-0.002 tw
[(educational r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 158.7731 515.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(in this paper)111(, and the associated risks of t)18(aut)19(ology in the)]tj
-8.57731 -1.19999 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(earlier observ)19(ations)36(. f)56(or e)19(x)18(ample)56(, is quantit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch t)18(o be solely equat-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(ed with \322science\323 and \322scientific method,\323 positivist appr)18(oaches with empir-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
-0.002 tw
[(ical-analytic tr)19(aditions)36(, and envir)19(onment)19(al r)19(esear)18(ch e)19(x)19(clusiv)19(ely with an)18(y of)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(these categories (connell, 1997), particularly t)19(o the e)18(x)19(clusion of fictiv)19(e w)18(ork)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.081 tw
[(and r)19(eport)18(age on envir)19(onments as other w)19(a)19(y)19(s of kno)18(wing? on the latter)111(,)]tj
t*
0.015 tw
[(stephen gough highlights the w)19(ork of writer)18(s lik)19(e barry l)19(opez f)18(or envir)19(on-)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(ment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s)37(. f)55(or l)19(opez \(e)56(.g., 1998\), as in the earlier e)19(x)18(am-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.123 tw
[(ple of r)19(emote sensing methods)36(, with the body and its \322technologies\323 as)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[<d272>19(esear)18(ch instruments)37(,\323 the senses and observ)19(ational and interpr)19(etiv)18(e skills)]tj
t*
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(pr)19(o)18(vide the \322dat)19(a\323 and the gr)19(ounds f)18(or his claim that \322truth is so much mor)19(e)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.003 tw
[(than f)19(act,\323 and that the interpr)18(eter does w)19(ell t)19(o be open t)18(o being disturbed)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(b)19(y the \322dist)19(ance betw)18(een what i sa)19(w and what i w)19(anted t)18(o r)19(ecor)19(d\323 \(stephen)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(gough, per)19(sonal communication, 200)55(1\). )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
0.098 tw
[(the ne)19(xt section continues this shift of emphasis t)18(o consider further)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
(notions of interpr)tj
7.84626 0 td
0 tw
(et)tj
0.79805 0 td
0.138 tw
(ation, and their implications f)tj
13.35721 0 td
(or ho)tj
2.40126 0 td
0.0008 tc
(w)tj
1.17661 0 td
0.001 tc
[(sense is made)56(,)]tj
-25.57939 -1.20001 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(and quality judged, in envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch, the subject of the)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(final part of the paper)111(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 73 284.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(the role of interpretation)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 265.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
(the account giv)tj
6.53037 0 td
(en in the opening sections\321in constructing and r)tj
20.4823 0 td
0 tw
(eassembling)tj
-27.01267 -1.20001 td
0 tc
(envir)tj
2.18617 0 td
(onment)tj
3.37268 0 td
0.138 tw
(al education t)tj
6.11644 0 td
0.0003 tc
(o)tj
0.95411 0 td
0 tc
[(illustr)19(ate specific points\321w)18(as pr)19(edicated on)]tj
-12.6294 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tw
[(an under)19(st)18(anding that the import)19(ance giv)19(en t)18(o interpr)19(et)19(ation b)19(y pr)18(actition-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.012 tc
0 tw
(er)tj
0.82802 0 td
0 tc
(s)tj
0.37739 0 td
-0.0116 tc
(,)tj
0.53035 0 td
-0.012 tc
(academics)tj
4.41445 0 td
-0.0118 tc
(,)tj
0.53012 0 td
(r)tj
0.33967 0 td
-0.012 tc
(esear)tj
2.21921 0 td
(cher)tj
1.82376 0 td
0 tc
(s)tj
0.37739 0 td
-0.0117 tc
(,)tj
0.53027 0 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(polic)19(y-mak)18(er)19(s)37(, publisher)18(s)37(, et)18(c)19(. is fundament)19(al t)18(o)]tj
-11.97063 -1.20002 td
-0.021 tc
0 tw
(per)tj
1.34545 0 td
0.007 tw
(sonal, philosophical and pr)tj
11.07739 0 td
(actice-based e)tj
5.79344 0 td
[(v)18(aluations of what counts as envi-)]tj
-18.21628 -1.20001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(r)19(onment)19(al education and envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch. \(while what is)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.044 tw
(meant b)tj
3.63678 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(y)tj
0.84075 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(interpr)tj
2.92444 0 td
(et)tj
0.79615 0 td
0.044 tw
(ation is be)tj
4.54992 0 td
(y)tj
0.5 0 td
(ond the scope of this paper)tj
11.9063 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.59969 0 td
(a)tj
0.82169 0 td
0 tc
[(r)19(ange of per-)]tj
-26.57572 -1.20002 td
0 tw
(spectiv)tj
2.99951 0 td
(es is illustr)tj
4.5354 0 td
[(ated in figur)19(e 1.\) )]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3659 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(19)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<<
/length 6104
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 241.4987 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.022 tw
[(the ar)19(gument no)18(w consider)19(s ho)19(w sense is made of the met)18(a-discour)19(se)56(, in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
(terms of r)tj
4.01373 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.14152 0 td
(cher)tj
1.7616 0 td
0.013 tw
(s\325 commitments)tj
6.63374 0 td
-0.0272 tc
(,)tj
0.51474 0 td
-0.027 tc
0 tw
(habits)tj
2.41202 0 td
-0.0272 tc
(,)tj
0.51475 0 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(and dispositions t)19(o)19(w)19(ar)18(ds particular)]tj
-17.9921 -1.20002 td
0 tc
0.002 tw
(notions of interpr)tj
7.557 0 td
[(et)19(ation, as the)18(y r)19(elate t)19(o claims t)18(o truth in envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
-7.557 -1.2 td
0.033 tw
[(claims-making (hannigan, 1995), and t)19(o distinctiv)18(e methods and logics of)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0 tw
(inquiry)tj
2.78099 0 td
-0.0261 tc
(.)tj
0.51576 0 td
(f)tj
0.45521 0 td
-0.026 tc
(or)tj
1.11893 0 td
(illustr)tj
2.18821 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.45141 0 td
(e)tj
0.73797 0 td
(purposes)tj
3.66316 0 td
(,)tj
0.51593 0 td
0.012 tw
[(thr)19(ee positions on the r)18(espectiv)19(e r)19(oles of qual-)]tj
-13.42757 -1.20001 td
[(it)19(ativ)18(e and quantit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch in envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch ar)18(e intr)19(o-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.022 tc
0.33 tw
(duced t)tj
3.67153 0 td
0.0221 tc
(o)tj
1.18959 0 td
0.022 tc
[(demonstr)19(ate some of the comple)18(xities in under)19(st)18(anding)]tj
-4.86112 -1.2 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(interpr)19(et)18(ation differ)19(ently and their links t)19(o differing or)19(der)18(s of discour)19(se)56(.)]tj
t*
0.01 tc
0.129 tw
[(the positions emphasiz)19(e the pr)18(ocesses of selecting and interpr)19(eting in)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch, and the descriptiv)18(e and e)19(xplanat)19(ory aspects of envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(education r)tj
4.86914 -0.00001 td
(esear)tj
2.27686 -0.00001 td
(ch. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 97.4987 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.5158 0 td
0.0027 tc
(a)tj
1.0495 0 td
0.003 tc
0.136 tw
[(fir)19(st position is that qualit)18(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)19(ch can be useful in a pr)18(e-design)]tj
-1.0495 -1.2632 td
-0.006 tc
0 tw
(st)tj
0.7114 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(age of quantit)tj
5.853 0 td
[(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch, t)19(o help clarify the r)19(esear)18(ch question and \322lan-)]tj
-6.5644 -1.2631 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(guage and gr)19(ammar\323 of the r)18(esear)19(ch design, including aiding conceptualiz)19(ation)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(20)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 59.7999 570.2739 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0206 tc
(.)tj
0.52133 0 td
(.)tj
0.52133 0 td
(.)tj
0.52133 0 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(interpr)19(et)18(ation is an act of imagination and logic)19(. it ent)19(ails per)18(ceiving impor-)]tj
-1.56398 -1.23529 td
0 tc
0.03 tw
[(t)19(ance)56(, or)18(der)111(, and f)19(orm in what one is learning that r)18(elates t)19(o the ar)19(gument,)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(st)19(ory)110(, narr)19(ativ)19(e that is continually under)18(going cr)19(eation. )]tj
0 -2.47059 td
-0.007 tw
[(interpr)19(et)18(ation has t)19(o do with the confluence of questions)37(, images)37(, and ideas)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.005 tw
[(that ar)19(e the st)18(arting point of m)19(y inquiry)111(, or the conceptualizing of m)19(y study)110(. )]tj
0 -2.47059 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(interpr)19(et)18(ation has t)19(o do with wher)19(e i choose t)18(o lo)1(ok t)18(o see that something is)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(going on with r)19(egar)18(d t)19(o m)19(y conceptualiz)18(ation, or the situating of m)19(y study)111(. )]tj
0 -2.47059 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(i)-1(n)-1(t)-1(e)-1(r)-1(p)-1(r)18(e)-1(t)17(ation has t)19(o do with the judgment of what t)19(o)-1( )-1(c)-1(o)-1(l)-1(l)-1(e)-1(c)-1(t)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(a)-1(t)-1( )-1(p)-1(r)17(o)19(vides doc-)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(ument)19(ation f)18(or what i think is going on, or the inst)19(antiating of m)19(y study and)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(the further f)19(ocusing of its field of inquiry)110(. )]tj
0 -2.47058 td
0.1 tw
[(interpr)19(et)18(ation has t)19(o do with what t)19(o select f)18(or writing that est)19(ablishes or)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(affirms what i ha)19(v)18(e identified that has gone on, or the composing of the ele-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(ments of m)19(y r)18(esear)19(ch st)19(ory)110(. )]tj
0 -2.47059 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(finally)111(, interpr)18(et)19(ation has t)19(o do with a per)19(spectiv)18(al accounting f)19(or what i ha)19(v)19(e)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(learned, or the shaping of the meanings and under)19(st)19(andings of what has gone)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(on fr)19(om some point of vie)18(w)111(, an issue of the crisis of r)19(epr)18(esent)19(ation f)19(or some)]tj
t*
0 tc
-0.014 tw
[(observ)19(er)18(s . . . . it is inconceiv)19(able t)19(o me that i can conduct an)19(y aspect of m)18(y)]tj
t*
0.085 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch e)18(x)19(cept fr)19(om some point of vie)19(w)111(, which is t)18(o sa)19(y that other inter-)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(pr)19(et)18(ations)37(, other meanings and under)19(st)18(andings)37(, ar)18(e imaginable)56(. indeed, the)19(y)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.137 tw
[(m)-1(a)18(y offer stur)18(dy competition t)19(o m)18(y o)19(wn. f)56(or e)18(v)19(ery)18(one\325)37(s w)18(ork, ho)19(w)18(e)19(v)18(er)110(,)]tj
t*
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(ther)19(e is a court, not of last r)18(esort, but of public discour)19(se)56(. it comes int)19(o session)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(when our w)19(ork is published.)]tj
et
0.667 w 
0 0 0 1 k
37.133 276.335 322.533 318.532 re
s
38.466 277.668 319.867 315.866 re
s
0 0 0 0 k
36.667 249.337 323.333 24 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 54.0975 265.4985 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(figur)19(e 1. p)55(er)19(spectiv)19(es on interpr)18(et)19(ation \(fr)19(om p)56(eshkin, 2000, p. 9\).)]tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/length 7661
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 588.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(and gener)19(ating h)18(ypotheses f)19(or later r)19(esear)19(ch (connell, 1997). qualit)18(ativ)19(e meth-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(ods ma)19(y also be used t)18(o interpr)19(et, qualify)111(, or illuminate the findings of)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(quantit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch and t)18(o test h)19(ypotheses)37(. such a position can be f)18(ound in)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.034 tw
[(pr)19(agmatic justifications f)18(or choosing either integr)19(ated or separ)19(ate r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
t*
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(designs in r)19(esear)18(ch, f)19(or e)19(x)18(ample)56(, when the matter is fr)19(amed as tw)18(o questions)]tj
t*
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(\(w)93(alk)18(er)111(, 1997\): )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 151.2559 528.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.011 tw
[(what do w)19(e w)18(ant t)19(o kno)19(w? which appr)18(oach is lik)19(ely t)18(o answ)19(er)]tj
-6.72167 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(the question most effectiv)19(ely and efficiently?)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 504.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(an alternativ)19(e t)18(o the fir)19(st ar)19(gues that the sy)18(stematic methods appr)19(opriate t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(the r)19(esear)18(ch objectiv)19(e)56(, whether qualit)19(ativ)19(e or quantit)19(ativ)18(e)56(, ar)19(e fundament)19(al-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.139 tw
[(ly incommensur)19(able as the)18(y offer such differ)19(ent w)19(a)18(y)19(s of kno)19(wing about)]tj
t*
0.109 tw
[(the w)19(orld that the)18(y cannot be compar)19(ed. with this position the risk that)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(emer)19(ges is that r)18(esear)19(ch design is r)19(educed t)18(o simply a matter of per)19(sonal pr)19(ef-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(er)19(ence \(albeit with due r)18(efer)19(ence t)19(o conte)19(xt, question, r)19(esour)18(ces)37(, ar)19(gument,)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(et)19(c)19(.\). while e)19(x)19(clusivist appr)19(oaches t)18(o)1( )1(r)20(esear)19(ch can be r)19(ecogniz)18(ed her)19(e \(often)]tj
t*
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(e)19(xpr)19(essed in ar)18(guments f)19(or the superiority of a particular method\), this)]tj
t*
[(does not pr)19(eclude plur)18(alistic appr)19(oaches)37(. a virtue in sust)19(aining multiple)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(appr)19(oaches is t)18(o stimulate differ)19(ent ideas or appr)19(oaches t)19(o the r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.139 tw
[(objectiv)19(e \(cantr)18(ell, 1993\). this tends t)19(o r)19(equir)18(e decisions )1(about whether)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.005 tw
(some w)tj
3.25862 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
0.46183 0 td
(y)tj
0.48062 0 td
-0.0195 tc
(s)tj
0.67043 0 td
-0.02 tc
(of kno)tj
2.62963 0 td
-0.019 tc
[(wing ar)19(e mor)18(e v)19(alid than other)19(s)37(, and on what basis the)19(y)1( )1(a)1(r)20(e)]tj
-7.50114 -1.26317 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(complement)19(ary \(r)18(eid & gough, 2000\).)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0006 tc
(a)tj
0.89338 0 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(thir)19(d position is t)18(o ar)19(g)-1(u)-1(e)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(a)-1(t)-1( )-1(w)-1(h)-1(a)-1(t)-1(e)17(v)19(er method pr)18(oduces dat)19(a and r)19(esults)]tj
-0.89338 -1.26316 td
0.007 tc
0.131 tw
(most f)tj
2.91655 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
0.48863 0 td
(v)tj
0.48863 0 td
0.007 tc
[(our)19(able t)18(o a prior normativ)19(e claim should be possible)56(, allo)19(w)18(ed)]tj
-3.89381 -1.26317 td
0 tc
-0.001 tw
[(and/or sanctionable in r)19(esear)18(ch. this position r)19(ejects most tr)19(aditional ideas)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.002 tw
[(about the \322science\323 \(and it is ar)19(gued, the purported neutr)18(ality and objectiv-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(ity\) of educational r)tj
8.317 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.2637 0 td
-0.011 tw
(ch. claims t)tj
5.01966 0 td
-0.0028 tc
(o)tj
0.79819 0 td
-0.003 tc
[(scientific st)19(atus ma)18(y mask a desir)19(e t)19(o)]tj
-16.39856 -1.26317 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(contr)19(ol pr)18(actice in the inter)19(ests of particular)111(, appar)19(ently disinter)18(ested, social)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.002 tc
0 tw
(gr)tj
0.84733 0 td
(oups)tj
2.01105 0 td
(.)tj
0.53996 0 td
-0.012 tw
(such a position ma)tj
8.17013 0 td
(y)tj
0.781 0 td
(be associated with suggestions that some ends)tj
-12.34948 -1.26317 td
0 tc
0 tw
(ar)tj
0.85107 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.82378 0 td
0 tc
(mor)tj
1.77694 0 td
0.046 tw
[(ally superior t)19(o other)18(s)37(, as in st)19(andpoint r)19(esear)18(ch or envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
-3.4518 -1.26316 td
0 tw
[(activism \(see a. gough, 1999; r)19(obott)18(om & hart, 1993\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 228.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.005 tw
(so, fr)tj
2.28203 0 td
[(om a discour)19(se analy)18(sis per)19(spectiv)19(e)56(, w)18(e might ask a number of ques-)]tj
-2.28203 -1.2 td
0.021 tw
[(tions of each position r)19(egar)18(ding interpr)19(et)19(ation in envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
(r)'
0.35107 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.27686 0 td
0.054 tw
(ch. fir)tj
2.77499 0 td
0 tw
(stly)tj
1.38965 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.60954 0 td
0 tc
0.054 tw
(the st)tj
2.42434 0 td
[(atus of the r)19(esear)18(ch acts)37(, in terms of epistemology)111(,)]tj
-9.82645 -1.20002 td
0 tw
(methodology)tj
5.57519 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.54818 0 td
0 tc
-0.008 tw
[(and ont)19(ology \(e)56(.g., in r)18(elation t)19(o their assumptions about the)]tj
-6.12337 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(r)19(ealities of the r)19(esear)19(ching and the r)18(esear)19(ched\); and then, t)19(o)1( )1(r)19(eturn t)19(o an ear-)]tj
t*
0.019 tc
0.12 tw
(lier observ)tj
4.84729 0 td
[(ation, whether the)19(y allude t)18(o educational or envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
-4.84729 -1.2 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.36032 0.00001 td
0.009 tc
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.32308 0.00001 td
0.13 tw
(ch criteria in terms of judging the quality of the kno)tj
24.10943 0.00001 td
(wledge con)tj
5.12935 0.00001 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92218 -1.20002 td
0 tw
[(structed thr)19(ough envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch?)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.004 tc
0.138 tw
(the fir)tj
2.92191 0.00001 td
(st set of questions has been discussed b)tj
17.99444 0 td
-0.0046 tc
(y)tj
0.92555 0 td
(r)tj
0.60689 0.00001 td
-0.004 tc
0 tw
(obott)tj
2.21914 0.00001 td
0.138 tw
(om and hart)tj
-26.46793 -1.20002 td
-0.021 tc
0.001 tw
((1993), hart and nolan (1999), and hart (2000). these publications ar)tj
28.84161 0.00001 td
(gue that)tj
-28.8416 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
0.134 tw
[(differ)19(ent ont)18(ologies and associated epistemologies ha)19(v)19(e definite implica-)]tj
t*
-0.011 tc
-0.009 tw
(tions f)tj
2.6022 0 td
(or methodologies and methods that cannot be ignor)tj
21.96155 0.00001 td
(ed b)tj
1.82005 0.00001 td
-0.0107 tc
(y)tj
0.7666 0 td
(r)tj
0.34075 0.00001 td
-0.011 tc
0 tw
[(esear)19(cher)18(s)37(.)]tj
-27.4911 -1.2 td
0 tc
(t)tj
0.4395 0 td
-0.0286 tc
(o)tj
0.7668 0 td
-0.029 tc
(illustr)tj
2.1699 0 td
(ate)tj
1.1735 0 td
-0.0286 tc
(,)tj
0.5078 0 td
-0.029 tc
0.009 tw
(hart ar)tj
2.82703 0.00001 td
(gues that under)tj
6.31252 0.00001 td
0 tw
(st)tj
0.66493 0.00001 td
0.009 tw
(anding the div)tj
5.80415 0.00001 td
0 tw
(er)tj
0.79408 0.00001 td
0.009 tw
[(se comple)19(xities\321\322the r)18(eq-)]tj
-21.4602 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
-0.006 tw
[(uisite v)19(ariety\323\321of qualit)18(ativ)19(e inquiry not only challenges an)19(y method)-1(o)-6(l)-6(o)-6(g)-6(i)-6(c)-6(a)-6(l)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(21)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/length 6572
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.098 tw
[(unif)19(ormity within envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch discour)19(se)56(, but philo-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.012 tw
[(sophically)111(, it r)18(e)19(v)19(eals the epistemological and ont)19(ological limits of r)18(esear)19(ch,)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(qualit)19(ativ)18(e or quantit)19(ativ)19(e)56(, educational or envir)19(onment)18(al. hence hart ar)19(gues)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(that envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(cher)19(s:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 529.4617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.013 tc
0.123 tw
[(.)-417(. . need antif)19(oundationalist st)19(andar)18(ds which account f)19(or the distinctions)]tj
0 -1.2353 td
-0.019 tc
0.003 tw
[(betw)19(een method and methodology)111(, epistemology and ont)18(ology . . . whate)19(v)19(er our)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.005 tc
-0.011 tw
[(st)19(ance)55(, cert)19(ain issues r)19(elating t)19(o r)18(elationships \(at se)19(v)19(er)19(al ont)18(ological le)19(v)19(els\), per-)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0.011 tw
[(spectiv)19(e \(or point of vie)18(w\), inter)19(est(s) serv)19(ed, r)18(epr)19(esent)19(ation \(i.e)55(. authenticity\), legit-)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.012 tw
[(imation \(i.e)56(. authority\), te)19(xt \(i.e)55(. v)19(erisimilitude\), v)19(oice \(absent and pr)18(esent\), and)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.014 tw
[(mediating technology . . . must be addr)19(essed acr)19(oss the mor)18(e conv)19(entional cri-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(teria r)19(elated t)18(o pr)19(oblem, pr)19(ocess and communication in r)18(esear)19(ch. (p. 43))]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 442.4616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(these points ar)19(e intimately link)18(ed with the second issue r)19(egar)19(ding r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(criteria, which str)19(esses the import)18(ance of considering the r)19(esour)18(ces a)19(v)18(ailable)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.137 tw
[(f)18(or discussing the art and politics of kno)19(wledge construction. this t)19(opic)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(will be discussed in mor)19(e det)18(ail in the f)19(ollo)19(wing section t)19(o intr)18(oduce the theme)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.054 tw
[(of div)19(er)18(sity in notions of quality in envir)19(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch dis-)]tj
t*
-0.027 tc
0 tw
(cour)tj
1.77929 0 td
0.013 tw
[(se)56(, but also t)18(o note that this div)19(er)19(sity can be tr)18(aced t)19(o the multiplying r)19(oots)]tj
-1.77929 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.002 tw
[(of the discour)19(se as the legitimac)18(y and vie)19(w)19(s of the pr)19(ofessional-scientist in)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tw
[(constituting it become mor)19(e contested \(gough & r)18(eid, 2000\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
10 0 2.12557 10 37 331.0616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(the (im)possibility of criteria?)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 311.8616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(a)37(ttempts t)18(o de)19(v)18(elop criteria f)19(or judging the v)19(alue of r)18(esear)19(ch ar)19(e w)18(ell docu-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(mented and critiqued in envir)19(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch and include a f)19(ocus)]tj
t*
0.009 tc
0.13 tw
(on deliber)tj
4.5746 0 td
(ating on the r)tj
6.33382 0 td
(ange of objectiv)tj
7.24206 0 td
(es deemed pertinent t)tj
10.10403 0 td
0.0092 tc
(o)tj
0.96302 0 td
0.009 tc
0 tw
(quality)tj
-29.21754 -1.20001 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
(esear)tj
2.27686 0 td
(ch \(see )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 96.2407 275.8616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(envir)tj
2.20362 0 td
(onment)tj
3.10961 0 td
(al education r)tj
6.01514 0 td
(esear)tj
2.18237 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 240.7939 275.8616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55576 0 td
0 tc
(2000\). the)tj
4.66812 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(y)tj
0.79675 0 td
0 tc
(include:)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 251.8616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
(does the r)tj
4.27122 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.18618 0 td
0.004 tw
(ch meet technical and aesthetic r)tj
13.71914 0 td
0 tw
(equir)tj
2.11195 0 td
0.004 tw
(ements of w)tj
5.16008 0 td
0 tw
(ell-designed)tj
-27.44857 -1.26318 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
(esear)tj
2.27685 0 td
(ch? )tj
-4.14372 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
0.013 tw
[(is ther)19(e the e)18(xpect)19(ation that the r)19(esear)18(ch finds out mor)19(e about a particular)]tj
-0.0002 tc
(pr)'
0.90698 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(oblem? )tj
-2.42277 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
0.013 tw
(does it demonstr)tj
7.47026 0 td
[(ate that alternativ)19(e plausible e)18(xplanations ha)19(v)19(e been con-)]tj
-7.47026 -1.26316 td
0 tw
[(sider)19(ed? )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.014 tc
(or)tj
0.97226 0 td
(,)tj
0.52799 0 td
(perhaps)tj
3.32933 0 td
(,)tj
0.52798 0 td
(has the r)tj
3.63434 0 td
(esear)tj
2.20751 0 td
(ch stimulated debate and challenged complacenc)tj
20.66072 0 td
0 tc
(y)tj
-31.86013 -1.26318 td
(b)tj
0.5371 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(y)tj
0.78756 0 td
(f)tj
0.29621 0 td
0 tc
-0.009 tw
[(or)19(cing people t)18(o confr)19(ont issues and ar)19(guments that w)18(ould normally go)]tj
-1.62087 -1.26317 td
0 tw
[(unackno)19(wledged? )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 131.8616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.008 tc
(while a neat mapping of such \322)tj
13.35914 0.00001 td
(criteria\323 against the thr)tj
9.76956 0.00001 td
-0.009 tc
(ee positions obscur)tj
8.15373 0 td
(es)tj
-31.2824 -1.2 td
-0.022 tc
0.013 tw
[(the potential v)19(alue of each t)18(o the other)111(, in r)19(elation t)19(o discour)18(se about the qual-)]tj
t*
0.017 tc
0.128 tw
[(ity of r)19(esear)18(ch, these e)19(x)19(amples highlight a tension in the accounts of)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.3367 0 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.2049 0 td
-0.015 tc
(cher)tj
1.8123 0 td
-0.0146 tc
(s)tj
0.6808 0 td
(t)tj
0.2818 0 td
-0.0145 tc
(o)tj
0.792 0 td
-0.015 tc
0.006 tw
[(communicate both the subst)19(a)-1(n)-1(t)-1(i)-1(v)17(e findings of the inquiry)111(, and)]tj
-6.1086 -1.2 td
0.003 tc
-0.012 tw
[(their \(interlocut)19(ory\) deliber)18(a)1(t)-1(ions about the t)19(ak)19(en-f)19(or-gr)18(anted assumptions)]tj
t*
0.002 tc
-0.011 tw
[(of the r)19(esear)18(ch field \(in addition t)19(o those of the community of r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s)37(,)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(22)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/length 6706
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.008 tw
[(participants)37(, pr)18(actitioner)19(s)37(, polic)18(y-mak)19(er)18(s)37(, et)19(c)18(.\), matter)19(s illustr)18(ated at length)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.005 tc
0 tw
[(b)18(y seale (1999). )]tj
1.8 -1.20001 td
-0.0058 tc
(a)tj
0.89182 0 td
-0.006 tc
-0.005 tw
[(k)19(e)18(y e)18(x)19(ample of such tensions is the r)19(ole of \322)55(audience\323)148(. w)93(e might ask,)]tj
-2.69182 -1.20001 td
-0.008 tc
-0.012 tw
[(does the author assume that the audience is primarily one of envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.002 tc
[(r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s)37(, educational r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s)37(, envir)19(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s)37(,)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(et)19(c)18(., and what effect does this ha)19(v)19(e on r)18(eporting pr)19(actices and the out-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(comes of the r)19(esear)18(ch (hart, 1996)? then ther)19(e is the r)19(eader)111(, their r)18(eactions)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0 tc
0.127 tw
[(and r)19(e-interpr)18(et)19(ations of a te)19(xt: \322most writings about the w)18(a)19(y)19(s in which)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0.011 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch should be judged ar)18(e concerned almost e)19(x)19(clusiv)19(ely with the w)18(a)19(y)19(s)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(in which the r)19(esear)18(ch w)19(as done)56(, and not with )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 264.1486 479.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.018 tc
0.005 tw
[(the w)19(ay)18(s in which the st)19(andpoint)]tj
-19.11486 -1.2 td
0.0197 tc
(of)tj
1.24255 0 td
0.02 tc
0.11 tw
[(the r)19(eader will influence their judgement of that r)18(esear)19(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 340.3346 467.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.0211 tc
<d3>tj
0.88187 0 td
0.021 tc
0.118 tw
[(\(garr)19(att &)]tj
-27.61533 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(hodkinson, 1998, p. 524, m)19(y emphasis\).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(these points r)19(eanimate a pr)19(e)18(vious ar)19(gument \(r)18(eid & gough, 2000, p. 7)56(1\))]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(that the use char)19(acteristics of r)18(e)-1(s)-1(e)-1(a)-1(r)18(ch \(qualit)19(ativ)18(e or quantit)19(ativ)19(e)-1(\))-1( )-1(m)-1(e)-1(r)-1(i)-1(t)-1( )-1(a)-1(t)-1(t)-1(e)-1(n)-1(-)]tj
t*
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(tion, particularly when discour)19(se theory r)18(eminds us of the primac)19(y of the r)19(ead-)]tj
t*
-0.023 tc
0.009 tw
[(er\325)37(s interpr)18(et)19(ation of the r)19(eport, no)19(w that the author\325)36(s vie)19(wpoint can no longer)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(be r)19(egar)18(ded as occup)19(ying a privileged position f)19(or its interpr)19(et)18(ation. mor)19(eo)19(v)18(er)111(,)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(the e)19(v)19(aluativ)18(e criteria br)19(ought t)19(o bear on a te)18(xt ma)19(y w)18(ell be those of an audi-)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(ence who ar)19(e not necessarily the one that w)18(er)19(e hoped f)19(o)1(r)1( )1(b)19(y)1( )1(t)1(h)1(e)1( )1(r)20(esear)19(cher)111(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.043 tw
[(f)19(or e)19(x)18(ample)56(, those of the casual r)19(eader or \322gr)19(az)18(er\323 of r)19(eports)37(, or e)18(v)19(en the)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(\322magpie r)19(eader\323 in sear)18(ch of juic)19(y quotes and anecdotes)37(. )]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.025 tc
-0.003 tw
(what then of the r)tj
7.48892 0 td
0 tw
(ecor)tj
1.7524 0 td
(ds)tj
0.89561 0 td
-0.0247 tc
(,)tj
0.50335 0 td
-0.025 tc
(accounts)tj
3.5804 0 td
-0.0247 tc
(,)tj
0.50336 0 td
-0.025 tc
-0.003 tw
[(and pr)19(oducts of qualit)18(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch as)]tj
-16.52404 -1.20001 td
-0.009 tc
0.134 tw
(analytical tributes)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 149.25 326.2716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(3)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 157.1053 323.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
0.134 tw
[(t)19(o the often mundane and r)19(outine w)18(ork of analy)19(sis in)]tj
-8.41053 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
-0.013 tw
[(inv)19(estigation? in terms of this ar)18(gument, the)19(y r)19(emain the material f)18(or a wider)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
-0.007 tw
(debate on making sense of envir)tj
13.66362 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.2865 0 td
-0.007 tw
(al education r)tj
5.67979 0 td
[(esear)19(ch and wher)18(e our)]tj
-22.62991 -1.20001 td
-0.027 tc
-0.001 tw
[(attention lies r)19(egar)19(ding the social, tempor)18(al, hist)19(orical, and/or envir)19(onment)18(al as)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.032 tc
0.004 tw
[(dimensions t)19(o the epistemologies and ont)19(ologies of r)18(esear)19(ch. f)56(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, qual-)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(it)tj
0.52714 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.49935 0 td
(e)tj
0.74992 0 td
[(r)19(esear)18(ch pr)19(actices ar)19(e char)19(acteriz)18(ed b)19(y a r)19(ange of featur)18(es)37(, including: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 239.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(adopting the per)19(spectiv)18(es of the people being studied; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
(description of the setting of the study; )tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
[<a5>-1016(emphasis on conte)19(xt and on holism; )]tj
-0.0002 tc
<a5>'
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(emphasis on pr)19(ocess; and )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(fle)19(xibility of design and r)18(eluct)19(ance t)19(o impose a priori fr)19(ame)18(w)19(orks)37(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 167.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
(pr)tj
0.90654 0 td
-0.005 tw
[(actices e)19(xpected in qualit)18(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)19(ch that point t)18(o quality matter)19(s might)]tj
-0.90654 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
(then include: )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 131.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.0117 tc
(a)tj
0.75236 0 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(clear e)19(xposition of the conte)19(xt and the w)18(a)19(y(s) in which dat)18(a ha)19(v)19(e been pr)18(o-)]tj
-0.7524 -1.2632 td
0 tc
-0.001 tw
[(duced, collected and analyz)19(ed t)18(o suggest and justify findings)37(, e)19(xplanations)37(,)]tj
t*
0.012 tw
[(and interpr)19(et)18(ations; such that an account of cir)19(cumst)19(ances and pr)18(ocedur)19(es)]tj
t*
-0.012 tw
[(mak)19(es plain a r)18(efle)19(xiv)19(e account of the r)18(esear)19(cher\325)37(s o)18(wn prior per)19(sonal, the-)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(or)19(etical, and e)18(v)19(en political biases)36(, r)19(ecognizing the r)18(ole of v)19(alues and a priori)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(assumptions in shaping an)19(y r)18(esear)19(ch account;)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3742 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(23)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
19 0 obj
<<
/length 7789
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 588.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(demonstr)19(ation of engaging in a conscientious sear)18(ch f)19(or dat)19(a that ar)19(e incon)-1(-)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(sistent with the emer)19(ging analy)18(sis)37(, and their impact on the \322f)19(alsification\323 or)]tj
t*
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(r)19(efinement of analy)19(sis)36(, within or outwith the study \(e)56(.g., prior r)18(esear)19(ch\); and)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.011 tc
-0.008 tw
[(commitment t)19(o)1( )1(v)19(oicing multiple per)19(spectiv)19(e)1(s)37(, of the po)19(w)19(erful and po)19(w)19(erless)37(,)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
0.139 tw
[(the participants and the r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s)37(, and addr)19(essing the r)19(ele)18(v)19(ance of the)]tj
t*
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(o)5(u)5(t)24(comes t)18(o differ)19(ent gr)19(oups)36(, needs)37(, and time fr)19(ames \(e)56(.g., not just t)18(o the spon-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.011 tw
[(sor)19(s of the r)18(esear)19(ch, but also t)19(o the wider body of kno)18(wledge and inter)19(ests)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(and dir)19(ections within it, short term and long term\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 480.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.068 tw
[(some of these pr)19(actices)36(, associated with rigour)111(, clarity)111(, and sy)19(stematicity)110(,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.096 tw
[(might also be e)19(xpected of quantit)18(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch, albeit in differ)19(ent f)19(orms)]tj
t*
0.003 tc
0.135 tw
[(\(smith-sebast)19(o, 2000\). f)56(or the)-1( met)19(a-discour)19(se though, the)19(y can also be)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(r)19(ead as implying that discussions should not be narr)19(o)19(wly defined but br)18(oad-)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(ly based, est)19(ablishing \(r)18(ather than shr)19(ouding\) points of r)19(efer)19(ence and debate)]tj
t*
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(on theor)19(etical and pr)18(actical issues)37(, and e)19(v)19(en being imaginativ)18(e and cr)19(eativ)19(e)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.028 tw
[(in pur)19(suing their interpellations with the r)18(ealities of the r)19(esear)19(ch \(p)56(eshkin,)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.006 tw
[(2000\). it is perhaps of little surprise then that the \322r)18(e)-1(a)-1(d)-1(e)-1(r)-1( )-1(e)-1(f)-1(f)-1(e)-1(c)-1(t)-1(,)-1<d3>-1( )-1(t)18(ak)19(en with)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(the unique qualities and cr)19(afts of qualit)18(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch, has led t)19(o demands f)19(or)]tj
-0.0137 tc
(a)'
0.7503 0 td
-0.014 tc
(cultur)tj
2.36212 0 td
-0.0137 tc
(e)tj
0.75026 0 td
-0.014 tc
(of r)tj
1.42614 0 td
(eporting pr)tj
4.64537 0 td
(actices that inv)tj
6.26268 0 td
[(olv)19(e accounting f)18(or the pr)19(ocessual, sit-)]tj
-16.19687 -1.20001 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(uated, and dynamic natur)19(e of the envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch and its)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(subject matter)111(, such as:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 324.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(the e)19(xplication of the theor)19(etical assumptions of r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s)1( )1(i)1(n)1( )1(r)19(eports)37(, and)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(ho)19(w (lightly?) the)18(y ar)19(e held;)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0.003 tc
0.135 tw
(the difficulties of interpr)tj
10.92576 0 td
(eting one\325)tj
4.44801 0 td
0.0033 tc
(s)tj
0.84591 0 td
0.003 tc
[(o)19(wn and other\325)36(s meanings and per-)]tj
-16.21968 -1.26317 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(spectiv)19(es)36(, e)56(.g., about e)19(v)19(ents and inter)18(actions)37(, and the politics of r)18(elationships)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
(and r)tj
2.25879 0 td
(epr)tj
1.40698 0 td
(esent)tj
2.2959 0 td
(ation betw)tj
4.57324 0 td
(een r)tj
2.20287 0.00001 td
(esear)tj
2.27685 0 td
[(cher)19(s and participants;)]tj
-16.53043 -1.26318 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0.011 tc
0.128 tw
(the theor)tj
4.13712 0 td
[(etical r)19(esour)18(ces that inf)19(orm and justify a particular qualit)19(ativ)18(e)]tj
-4.13712 -1.26316 td
0 tc
-0.014 tw
[(method and interpr)19(etiv)18(e str)19(ategy)111(, such as those used in a)19(v)18(oiding anecdot)19(al-)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
(ism, liter)tj
3.62995 0 td
(alism, and the imposition of the r)tj
13.89 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.19293 0 td
(cher\325)tj
2.04571 0 td
-0.0169 tc
(s)tj
0.67303 0 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
(prior assumptions upon)tj
-22.43161 -1.26317 td
0 tc
0 tw
(his or her observ)tj
7.27613 0 td
(ations; and)tj
-8.79192 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.014 tc
[(engagement with the comple)19(xities and conte)18(xts in the situation t)19(o hand \(e)56(.g.,)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
(via pr)tj
2.40418 0 td
(olonged engagement, pr)tj
10.40696 0 td
0 tw
(ogr)tj
1.37262 0 td
(essiv)tj
2.06602 0 td
-0.0052 tc
(e)tj
0.75877 0 td
(f)tj
0.29111 0 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(ocusing, emer)19(gent r)18(esear)19(ch design,)]tj
-17.29965 -1.26317 td
0 tc
(h)tj
0.52293 0 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(ypothesis gener)19(ation\), and matter)19(s of gener)18(alizing fr)19(om the ideogr)19(aphic and)]tj
-0.52293 -1.26316 td
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(embedded t)19(o other settings)36(, pr)19(ocesses or cases)37(, whether the)18(y be theor)19(etically-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(or empirically-based. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 144.3035 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(the wider point t)19(o note her)18(e)56(, fir)18(st air)19(ed at the st)19(art of the paper)111(, is that such)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.028 tw
(criteria ar)tj
4.19222 0.00001 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.80595 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(deriv)tj
2.1658 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(ed)tj
1.36181 0 td
0 tc
(fr)tj
0.6661 0 td
0.028 tw
(om qualit)tj
4.12044 0.00001 td
[(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch discour)19(se)55(, r)19(ather than that of)]tj
-13.31232 -1.20002 td
<d2>tj
0.38664 0.00001 td
-0.001 tc
0 tw
(envir)tj
2.17735 0.00001 td
(onment)tj
3.36208 0.00001 td
-0.013 tw
(al r)tj
1.35208 0.00001 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.27036 0.00001 td
(ch.\323)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 149.838 122.6136 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(4)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 156.3597 120.3036 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
(lik)tj
1.25489 0.00001 td
0 tc
(e)tj
0.4799 0.00001 td
-0.002 tc
(wise)tj
1.88226 0.00001 td
-0.0014 tc
(,)tj
0.54053 0 td
-0.001 tc
(giv)tj
1.23604 0.00001 td
-0.013 tw
(en the div)tj
4.25821 0.00001 td
0 tw
(er)tj
0.84848 0.00001 td
-0.013 tw
(se natur)tj
3.45748 0.00001 td
-0.0014 tc
(e)tj
0.7626 0 td
-0.001 tc
(of qualit)tj
3.49407 0.00001 td
0 tw
[(ativ)19(e)]tj
-30.1504 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
0.034 tw
[(i)-3(n)-3(q)-3(u)-3(i)-3(r)-3(y)111(, w)18(e might also ask, can the st)19(andar)19(ds)36(, e)19(xpect)19(ations)36(, and criteria of)]tj
t*
-0.008 tc
0 tw
(quantit)tj
2.9826 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.5241 0 td
-0.0079 tc
(e)tj
0.7533 0 td
(r)tj
0.3435 0 td
-0.008 tc
(esear)tj
2.2383 0 td
-0.009 tw
[(ch in education be applied acr)19(oss the boar)18(d\321lik)19(e v)19(alidity)110(,)]tj
-7.8417 -1.2 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.3349 0 td
-0.016 tc
0 tw
(eliability)tj
3.3756 0 td
-0.0162 tc
(,)tj
0.523 0 td
-0.016 tc
-0.001 tw
(and gener)tj
4.1867 0.00001 td
0 tw
(aliz)tj
1.37924 0.00001 td
(ability\321t)tj
3.76186 0.00001 td
-0.0163 tc
(o)tj
0.78192 0 td
-0.016 tc
-0.001 tw
(inquiries that str)tj
6.78023 0.00001 td
(ess postpositivist concerns)tj
-21.1235 -1.2 td
-0.017 tc
0 tw
[(lik)19(e cr)18(edibility and r)19(ele)19(v)18(ance; constructivist concerns lik)18(e t)-3(r)-3(u)-3(s)-3(t)-3(w)16(o)-3(r)-3(t)-3(h)-3(i)-3(n)-3(e)-3(s)-3(s)-3( )-3(a)-3(n)-3(d)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(24)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/length 6486
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.011 tw
[(authenticity; critical theory concerns lik)19(e action, pr)18(axis)37(, and hist)19(orical situ-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.011 tw
[(atedness; and antif)19(oundationalist concerns that str)18(ess r)19(efle)19(xivity)110(, subjectiv-)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tw
[(ity)111(, and emotionality (hart, 2000)?)]tj
1.8 -1.20001 td
0.015 tc
0.118 tw
[(the heading f)19(or this section echoes that of concerns e)18(xpr)19(essed in)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 539.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(c)1(h)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 218.3461 539.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.006 tc
-0.009 tw
[((2000) about r)19(esear)18(ch being a highly con-)]tj
-14.53461 -1.2 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(t)6(e)6(s)6(t)6(e)6(d)-258(field, as typified b)19(y the disjunctur)18(es betw)19(een anti-r)19(ealist, r)19(elativist, and)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
-0.004 tw
[((subtle?) r)19(ealist positions on r)18(esear)19(ch, alongside the pr)19(oblematics of neces-)]tj
0 -1.19999 td
0.13 tw
[(sities and possibilities in de)19(v)18(eloping criteria f)19(or e)19(v)19(aluating the quality of)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch such that it inf)18(orms polic)19(y and pr)19(actice)55(. on the one hand, ther)19(e is)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(the challenge f)19(or r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s e)18(xpr)19(essed b)18(y seale (1999) that ther)19(e can be no)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(criteria f)19(or judging the quality of qualit)18(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)19(ch pr)18(oducts giv)19(en the natur)19(e)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.06 tw
[(of the t)19(ask. this vie)18(w articulates the case against an)19(y notion of a perfect,)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(impeachable f)19(orm of r)18(esear)19(ch, qualit)19(ativ)19(e or quantit)18(ativ)19(e)56(, educational or envi-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.001 tw
[(r)19(onment)19(al, as a study or as a r)18(eport of findings)37(. it is also a point alluded t)19(o)]tj
t*
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(b)19(y)1( )1(p)57(eshkin (2000) who r)19(esponds t)18(o the final entry in bo)19(x 1: \322r)19(ar)18(ely)111(, e)19(x)19(cept)]tj
t*
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
[(in highly contr)19(olled or consensually defined situations)37(, can r)18(esear)19(ch be a sim-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.026 tw
[(ple f)19(orm or r)18(ecor)19(d k)19(eeping and summary)110(. mor)19(e often, ho)19(w)19(e)18(v)19(er)111(, when it is)]tj
t*
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(unclear which interpr)19(et)18(ation is corr)19(ect, or whose)56(, the v)19(ery natur)18(e of the \322pr)19(ob-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(lem\323 is open t)19(o question\323 (p. 5).)]tj
1.8 -1.2 td
-0.011 tw
[(on the other hand, w)19(e might w)18(ant t)19(o consider ho)19(w ont)18(ological, episte-)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(mological, and methodological dimensions ar)19(e addr)19(essed, as in the e)18(x)19(ample)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
(of r)tj
1.43793 0 td
(emote sensing and imaging. f)tj
12.69285 0 td
(or e)tj
1.62299 0 td
0 tc
(x)tj
0.50844 0 td
-0.01 tc
[(ample)56(, britzman (1995) asks ho)18(w dis-)]tj
-16.26221 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(cussion of r)19(esear)18(ch is made intelligible b)19(y questions lik)19(e:)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 73 299.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
-0.009 tw
(what is it that structur)tj
9.64787 0 td
(es \(technologies)tj
6.86076 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.54685 0 td
0 tc
[(ont)19(ologies)36(, epistemologies)37(, et)19(c)19(.\) the)]tj
-17.05548 -1.26317 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(methodological imper)19(ativ)18(es f)19(or r)19(esear)18(ch, the r)19(esear)19(cher\325)37(s st)18(ances)37(, and their)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(v)19(oices?; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26315 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
0.092 tw
(which ar)tj
3.9983 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.86981 0 td
0 tc
[(the kinds of theor)19(etical tr)18(aditions thr)19(ough which dat)19(a ar)18(e con-)]tj
-4.86811 -1.26316 td
0 tw
[(structed, r)19(epr)18(esented/imaged, and narr)19(ated?; )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(what ar)19(e t)18(ak)19(en t)19(o be pr)18(oblems suited f)19(or r)19(esear)18(ch?; and)]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
(what ar)tj
3.38981 0 td
-0.0068 tc
(e)tj
0.75725 0 td
-0.007 tc
[(the pr)19(oblems of ho)18(w one might r)19(ead against the gr)19(ain of r)18(esear)19(ch?)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 203.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tw
[(in r)19(esponding t)18(o these challenges then, despite the superficial connections)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
(that might be made betw)tj
10.59382 0 td
[(een accounting pr)19(actices in qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch and)]tj
-10.59382 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.004 tw
[(other \322quality indicat)19(or)18(s\323 lik)19(e \322)56(ecological v)18(alidity)111(,\323 it appear)19(s that the crite-)]tj
t*
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
(ria of envir)tj
5.06142 0 td
[(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch ar)19(e essentially anthr)18(opocentric)]tj
-5.06142 -1.2 td
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(a)-1(n)-1(d)-1( )-1(l)-1(e)-1(a)18(v)18(e little r)19(oom f)18(o)-1(r)-1( )-1(a)-1(l)-1(t)-1(e)-1(r)-1(n)-1(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(v)18(e)55(, less anthr)19(opocentric fr)19(a)-1(m)-1(e)17(w)19(orks f)18(or judg-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(ing the quality of envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 299.0815 146.2716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(5)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 209.3494 110.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(conclusion)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 89.0616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
0.03 tw
[(p)56(oststructur)18(alist theories r)19(aise critical concerns about what it is that structur)18(es)]tj
0 -1.2353 td
-0.015 tc
-0.002 tw
[(m)-1(e)-1(a)-1(n)-1(i)-1(n)-1(g)-1(s)36(, pr)18(actices)37(, and bodies)37(, about wh)18(y cert)19(ain pr)19(a)-1(c)-1(t)-1(i)-1(c)-1(e)-1(s)-1( )-1(b)-1(e)-1(c)-1(o)-1(m)-1(e)-1( )-1(i)-1(n)-1(t)-1(e)-1(l)-1(l)-1(i)-1(g)-1(i)-1(b)-1(l)-1(e)54(,)]tj
0 tc
(v)'
0.4784 0 td
-0.003 tc
0.111 tw
(alorised, or deemed as tr)tj
11.15012 0.00001 td
(aditions while other pr)tj
10.02591 0.00001 td
(actices become discounted,)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3742 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(25)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/length 7505
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
0.003 tw
[(impossible)56(, or unimaginable)55(. f)56(or poststructur)19(alists)36(, r)19(epr)19(esent)18(ation is alw)19(a)18(y)19(s in cri-)]tj
0 -1.23529 td
-0.012 tc
-0.005 tw
[(sis)37(, kno)18(wledge is constitutiv)19(e of po)19(w)18(er)111(, and agenc)18(y is the constitutiv)19(e effect, and)]tj
t*
-0.003 tc
0 tw
[(not the originat)19(or)110(, of situated pr)19(actices and hist)18(ories)37(. \(britzman, 1995, p. 23)56(1\))]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 545.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.121 tw
[(this paper has dr)19(a)18(wn on critical discour)19(se ar)19(guments t)19(o suggest that all)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(r)19(esear)18(ch activities ha)19(v)18(e something t)19(o sa)19(y about methodology)110(, epistemology)111(,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(and ont)19(ology)110(, e)19(xplicitly or not. pr)19(e)18(viously i ar)19(gued \(r)19(eid & gough, 2000\) that)]tj
t*
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(deliber)19(ations on the pr)18(ocess and pr)19(oduct of judging the quality of qualit)19(ativ)19(e)]tj
t*
0.001 tc
0.138 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch in envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch r)19(equir)19(e the r)18(ecognition of)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(tw)19(o points within the liter)18(atur)19(e on guidelines: )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 37 461.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
[(the e)19(xistence of a wide v)18(ariety of types)37(, genr)19(es and f)19(orms of r)18(esear)19(ch; and )]tj
-1.51579 -1.26316 td
-0.0002 tc
<a5>tj
1.51579 0 td
0 tc
0.037 tw
[(the pr)19(oposition that the criteria f)18(or judging r)19(esear)19(ch quality cont)18(ain within)]tj
t*
-0.014 tc
0 tw
[(them, implicitly or e)19(xplicitly)110(, a defining vie)19(w of what r)19(esear)18(ch is)37(, and perhaps)]tj
t*
0 tc
[(mor)19(e contentiously)110(, what it should be)56(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 37 401.4874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
0.001 tw
[(h)1(e)1(r)20(e)56(,)1( )1(s)1(u)1(c)1(h)1( )1(a)1(r)20(guments ha)18(v)20(e been applied t)18(o)1( )1(e)1(n)1(v)1(i)1(r)20(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(c)1(h)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.006 tc
0.059 tw
[(discour)19(se t)18(o emphasiz)19(e the unequal r)18(oles and contributions of educational)]tj
0 tc
(r)'
0.32012 0 td
-0.031 tc
0.012 tw
[(esear)19(ch discour)18(se and envir)19(onment)19(al r)19(esear)18(ch discour)19(se t)19(o the met)18(a-discour)19(se)56(.)]tj
1.47988 -1.2 td
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(the str)19(eams of envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch discour)18(se about science)56(,)]tj
-1.8 -1.2 td
-0.021 tc
0 tw
(natur)tj
2.17002 0 td
(e/envir)tj
2.8121 0 td
0.007 tw
(onment, education, e)tj
8.80905 0 td
[(xperience)56(, and so on, along with other wide-)]tj
-13.79117 -1.20001 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(ly a)19(v)18(ailable narr)19(ativ)19(es about a)18(w)19(ar)19(eness)37(, sensitivity)110(, commitment, and action,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0 tc
0.029 tw
(help f)tj
2.45616 0 td
(orm the cultur)tj
6.22457 0 td
(al and conceptual t)tj
8.27399 0 td
(ools of the envir)tj
7.06867 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.36988 0 td
0.029 tw
(al educat)tj
3.9 0 td
0 tw
(or)tj
-31.29327 -1.20002 td
-0.024 tc
(\(p)tj
0.76653 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
0.45749 0 td
-0.024 tc
0.01 tw
[(yne)56(, 1999\). in this paper)110(, i ha)19(v)19(e attempted t)18(o encour)19(age further e)19(xplor)18(ation)]tj
-1.22402 -1.20001 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(of ho)19(w envir)18(onment)19(alists)37(,)1( )1(r)19(esear)19(cher)19(s and educat)19(o)1(r)19(s negotiate the meanings)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
(of these discour)tj
7.1329 0 td
0.001 tc
0 tw
(ses)tj
1.31958 0 td
0.0015 tc
(,)tj
0.69628 0 td
0.001 tc
0.137 tw
(including which discour)tj
10.55023 0 td
0.002 tc
(ses the)tj
3.13013 0 td
0.0015 tc
(y)tj
0.93725 0 td
0.001 tc
0 tw
(inv)tj
1.31878 0 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
(est authority in,)tj
-25.08515 -1.20001 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
(which the)tj
4.14741 0 td
-0.0077 tc
(y)tj
0.77525 0 td
-0.008 tc
[(find per)19(sonally convincing, and which discour)18(ses br)19(eak do)19(wn or)]tj
-4.92266 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
(seem useless)tj
5.61084 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(.)tj
-3.81084 -1.2 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
(human beings mak)tj
8.42725 0 td
-0.0006 tc
(e)tj
0.76338 0 td
-0.001 tc
(meaning in their liv)tj
8.39149 0 td
(es thr)tj
2.40893 0 td
(ough st)tj
3.11224 0 td
(orylines and nar)tj
7.01905 0 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92234 -1.20001 td
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
0.002 tw
[(ativ)19(es that ar)18(e accessible at a giv)19(en cultur)19(al and ecological time)56(. as l)18(ather)]tj
-0.35107 -1.2 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(and smithies (1997) ar)tj
9.75696 0 td
0 tw
(gue)tj
1.47256 0 td
-0.0029 tc
(,)tj
0.53907 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(no life fits entir)tj
6.48851 0 td
(ely int)tj
2.63582 0 td
-0.0029 tc
(o)tj
0.79809 0 td
-0.003 tc
0 tw
(an)tj
1.04949 0 td
(y)tj
0.77988 0 td
(st)tj
0.71639 0 td
(oryline)tj
2.92377 0 td
-0.0029 tc
(,)tj
0.5391 0 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(and e)tj
2.3637 0 td
0 tw
[(v)19(ery)-1(-)]tj
-30.06334 -1.20002 td
0 tc
0.039 tw
(body has t)tj
4.57911 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(o)tj
0.85356 0 td
(w)tj
0.74019 0 td
0 tc
(ork t)tj
2.03858 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(o)tj
0.85377 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(mak)tj
1.88891 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.81692 0 td
0 tc
0.039 tw
[(meaning acr)19(oss/within/be)18(y)19(ond/outside the nar-)]tj
-11.77104 -1.20001 td
0 tw
[(r)19(ativ)19(es and discour)18(ses a)19(v)19(ailable t)18(o them. hence the desir)19(ability of r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
(and r)tj
2.19491 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.21438 0 td
-0.001 tw
(ching. some st)tj
6.17383 0 td
(orylines help us tell our liv)tj
10.98172 0 td
(es in what w)tj
5.30753 0 td
-0.0126 tc
(e)tj
0.75135 0 td
-0.013 tc
(see as pos)tj
4.29814 0 td
0 tc
(-)tj
-31.92185 -1.20002 td
0 tw
(itiv)tj
1.31372 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(e)tj
0.77155 0 td
(w)tj
0.7402 0 td
0 tc
(a)tj
0.4812 0 td
-0.006 tw
[(y)19(s)37(, other)19(s \322tell us\323 less positiv)18(ely)111(, envir)19(onment)19(ally)110(, educationally or)]tj
-3.30667 -1.20001 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(otherwise)56(. within the discour)19(se on envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)18(ch, some)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.003 tw
(of the narr)tj
4.45187 0 td
-0.011 tc
[(a)-1(t)-1(i)-1(v)18(es will be chosen and used consciously)110(, other)19(s will simply \322tell)]tj
-4.45187 -1.2 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
(us\323 without our consciously kno)tj
14.54605 0 td
[(wing. their interpr)19(etiv)18(e function, f)19(or/of)]tj
-14.54605 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0.051 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(cher)19(s and other)18(s)37(, is not unif)19(ormly compli-)]tj
0 -1.2 td
0.089 tw
[(ment)19(ary)110(, particularly when vie)19(w)19(ed with the benefit of hindsight. as noel)]tj
t*
0.04 tw
[(gough \(1999, p. 4)56(12\) suggests in the conte)19(xt of significant life e)18(xperience)]tj
t*
-0.001 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch, our inquiries can speak of r)18(est)19(oring life t)19(o its original comple)18(xity)111(,)]tj
t*
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(or constitute pr)19(ocedur)18(es f)19(or r)19(educing multif)18(aceted life e)19(xperiences t)19(o a sim-)]tj
t*
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
[(plicity the)19(y ne)18(v)19(er had. this is also a challenge f)18(or met)19(a-analytical w)19(ork, wher)18(e)]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(26)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
22 0 obj
<<
/length 6523
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 587.9617 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(the pr)19(ocess and pr)18(oducts of our inquiries necessit)19(ate acts of r)19(emembr)18(ance)56(,)]tj
0 -1.2 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(critical r)19(eflection, and interpr)18(et)19(ation, which perhaps include that it is a fiction)]tj
0 -1.20001 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(that w)19(e sense r)18(emotely)111(, or imag(in)e with a vie)19(w fr)18(om no)19(wher)19(e)56(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 220.2285 530.3616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(notes)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 73 509.8716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 507.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(see n. gough (1997) on ho)19(w r)18(emote sensing techniques and images position)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
[(people as \322post-panoptic\323 observ)19(er)18(s)1( )1(r)20(ather than \322intimates of the earth,\323 and)]tj
t*
0.008 tc
0.131 tw
[(f)19(or an in-depth discussion of issues r)19(aised her)18(e)56(. further analy)19(sis of the)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.032 tw
[(implications and limit)19(ations of r)18(emote sensing can be f)19(ound in critical dis-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(cussions of geogr)19(aphic inf)18(ormation sy)19(stems \(curry)111(, 1998; pickles)36(, 1995\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 73 449.8716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 447.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(it is noted that, in some cir)19(cles)36(, action r)19(esear)19(ch is discur)18(siv)19(ely constructed t)19(o)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(r)19(epr)18(esent a panacea f)19(or r)19(esolving the pr)18(oblems of r)19(esear)19(ch, philosoph)18(y)111(, and)]tj
t*
-0.018 tc
0.004 tw
[(pr)19(actice in education \(www)110(.actionr)19(esear)19(ch.net\), which, one assumes)37(, includes)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.002 tw
[(\322subfields\323 lik)19(e envir)18(onment)19(al education \(cf. the critique of action r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
(b)'
0.53711 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(y)tj
0.79674 0 td
0 tc
0 tw
(gudmundsdottir)tj
6.94447 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55569 0 td
0 tc
[(199)56(1\).)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 73 389.8716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(3)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 387.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tw
[(n. gough (1999) suggests \322r)19(esults ar)18(e the testimonies t)19(o the e)19(xperiences of)]tj
0 -1.26315 td
-0.027 tc
0 tw
(the )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 102.153 375.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.026 tc
[(r)18(esear)19(cher)19(s)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 146.9998 375.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(as the)19(y)1( )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 177.0278 375.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.026 tc
[(pr)19(oduce)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 208.977 375.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.027 tc
0.013 tw
[(dat)19(a, that is)36(, the)19(y ar)19(e the joint accomplishments)]tj
-12.79758 -1.26316 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
[(of the subjects and the r)19(esear)18(cher)19(s\323 \(p. 4)56(13\). despite their differ)18(ences)37(, while)]tj
t*
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(some qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(eports ma)19(y v)18(aloriz)19(e the \322)56(e)18(x)19(otic\323 and highly char)19(ged issues)]tj
-0.0001 tc
(in)'
1.15267 0 td
0 tc
0.042 tw
(the inquiry)tj
4.6529 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.59782 0 td
0 tc
[(much of the pr)19(ocess of qualit)18(ativ)19(e dat)19(a analy)18(sis)37(, lik)19(e that of)]tj
-6.40339 -1.26316 td
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(quantit)19(ativ)18(e dat)19(a analy)19(sis)36(, pur)19(sues questions of significance and what will be)]tj
t*
-0.02 tc
0.006 tw
[(privileged in the r)19(esear)19(ch narr)18(ativ)19(e)56(, alongside decisions about what will be f)19(or-)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
(gotten, de)tj
4.3335 0 td
[(v)19(alued, or left (out) as mar)18(ginal.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 73 293.8716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(4)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 291.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.013 tc
0.126 tw
[(this is not t)19(o suggest that the ultimate f)18(ocus of r)19(esear)19(ch is other than)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0.007 tw
[(humans \(smith-sebast)19(o, 2000\), but t)18(o r)19(ecogniz)19(e that the pr)18(ofessional basis)]tj
-0.0001 tc
(of)'
1.16817 0 td
0 tc
0.038 tw
[(man)19(y envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(cher)18(s is located in the natur)19(al sci-)]tj
-1.16817 -1.26315 td
0.006 tc
0.132 tw
[(ences)37(, wher)18(e positivistic appeals t)19(o the natur)19(al sciences as a model f)19(or)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.026 tc
0.012 tw
[(social-scientific r)19(esear)18(ch ar)19(e common \(gough & r)19(eid, 2000\), wher)18(eas the f)19(ocus)]tj
t*
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(of the natur)19(al sciences)36(, typically the earth, oper)19(ates as the location of the \322)56(end\323)]tj
t*
0 tc
0 tw
[(f)19(or which man)19(y envir)18(onment)19(al educat)19(or)18(s e)19(xpect their w)18(ork t)19(o bear fruit.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
7 0 0 7 73 209.8716 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(5)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 87.4 207.5616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tw
[(p)56(ossibilities include multicultur)19(al postmodern ecological w)19(orldvie)19(w \(gough,)]tj
0 -1.26316 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(199)56(1\) and a multicultur)18(al ecology emplo)19(ying a act)19(or-netw)19(ork theory \(iv)18(akhiv)111(,)]tj
t*
0 tc
0.008 tw
[(2002\), both of which offer fr)19(ame)18(w)19(orks that ar)19(e less dependent on ont)19(olog-)]tj
t*
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
(ical distinctions betw)tj
8.87076 0 td
[(een classes of act)19(or)18(s or agents)37(, f)19(or e)18(x)19(ample)56(, as f)18(ound in)]tj
-8.87076 -1.26316 td
0 tc
0 tw
(biotic and abiotic actional netw)tj
13.53492 0 td
[(orks within envir)19(onment)18(al r)19(esear)19(ch.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 185.5769 125.9616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(notes on contributor)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f13 1 tf
10 0 0 10 73 103.1616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.01 tw
[(alan r)37(eid)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
10 0 0 10 119.2027 103.1616 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(w)19(orks at the centr)18(e f)19(or r)19(esear)18(ch in education and envir)19(onment,)]tj
-4.6203 -1.2 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(department of education, univ)19(er)18(sity of bath. )]tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3742 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(27)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/length 11584
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
11 0 0 11 171.7622 587.4685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(references)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37 564.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
-0.005 tw
[(bent)19(on, l.m. & short, j.r. (1999). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 159.4452 564.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
-0.004 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al discour)19(se and pr)19(actice)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 288.8124 564.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0095 tc
(.)tj
0.53247 0 td
-0.01 tc
-0.005 tw
[(o)-1(x)-1(f)18(or)18(d: blackw)19(e)-1(l)-1(l)-1(.)]tj
-30.15746 -1.41176 td
0.02 tc
0.119 tw
[(britzman, d. (1995). the question of belief: w)56(riting a poststructur)19(al ethnogr)19(aph)18(y)111(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 540.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(international journal of qualit)19(ativ)18(e studies in education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 252.432 540.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 257.1551 540.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(8)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 261.5649 540.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((3), 229-238.)tj
-26.4194 -1.41176 td
-0.022 tc
0.008 tw
[(cantr)19(ell, d.c. (1993). alternativ)18(e par)19(adigms in envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch: the inter-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0.015 tc
0.124 tw
[(pr)19(etiv)18(e per)19(spectiv)19(e)56(. in r. mr)18(az)19(ek (ed.), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 210.5514 516.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.014 tc
0.115 tw
[(alternativ)19(e p)36(ar)19(adigms in envir)18(onment)19(al)]tj
-18.30017 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(education r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 126.4303 504.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(\(pp. 8)56(1-1)55(06\). t)80(r)19(o)19(y)111(, oh: naaee.)]tj
-10.52121 -1.41176 td
-0.025 tc
0.011 tw
[(connell, s. (1997). empirical-analytical methodological r)19(esear)19(ch in envir)19(onment)18(al education:)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0.022 tc
0.158 tw
[(r)19(esponse t)18(o a negativ)19(e tr)19(end in methodological and ideological discussions)37(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 468.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 177.8702 468.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55571 0 td
0 tc
[(3(2), 1)161(17-132. )]tj
-17.12867 -1.41176 td
0.005 tc
0.134 tw
[(curry)111(, m. (1998). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 105.7623 456.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.005 tc
0.124 tw
[(digit)19(al places: living with geogr)18(aphic inf)19(ormation technologies)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 336.5994 456.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.0052 tc
(.)tj
0.69992 0 td
0.005 tc
[(ne)19(w)]tj
-33.82926 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(y)80(ork: r)19(outledge)55(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(denzin, n. & lincoln, y)130(. (2000). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 154.442 432.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.01 tw
[(handbook of qualit)19(ativ)18(e r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 271.1262 432.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
((2nd edition). thousand)tj
-25.42661 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(oaks)37(, c)36(a: sage)56(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.017 tc
-0.009 tw
[(d)-17(unlap, r.e., v)93(an lier)19(e)55(, k.d., mertig, a.g., & jones)37(, r.e. (2000). measuring endor)19(sement of)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.036 tc
0.005 tw
[(the ne)19(w ecological p)56(ar)18(adigm: a r)19(e)19(vised nep scale)55(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 227.7104 396.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.034 tc
0.005 tw
(journal of social issues)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 302.6521 396.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0362 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 306.8105 396.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.034 tc
(56)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 315.061 396.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.036 tc
0.005 tw
((3), 425-442.)tj
-32.71306 -1.41177 td
0 tc
0.032 tw
[(eisner)111(, e.w)129(. (1997). the pr)19(omise and perils of alternativ)19(e f)18(or)1(ms of dat)18(a r)19(epr)19(esent)18(ation.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 372.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(educational r)19(esear)18(cher)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 137.5865 372.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 142.3097 372.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(26)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 151.1293 372.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((6), 4-1)56(0. )]tj
-13.42698 -1.41176 td
0.138 tw
[(english, f)148(.w)129(. (2000). a critical appr)19(aisal of sar)19(a)-1( )-1(l)17(a)19(wr)18(e)-1(n)-1(c)-1(e)-1(-)-1(l)-1(i)-1(g)-1(h)-1(t)-1(f)18(oot\325)36(s portr)19(aitur)19(e as a)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(method of educational r)19(esear)18(ch. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 175.8822 348.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(educational r)19(esear)18(cher)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 258.4687 348.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 263.1919 348.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(29)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 272.0115 348.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((7), 2)56(1-26.)]tj
-27.64841 -1.41176 td
-0.005 tc
-0.009 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch. (2000). special issue: qualit)19(ativ)18(e methods of inquiry)111(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 324.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 177.8702 324.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 182.5934 324.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 187.0032 324.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((1), whole issue)56(.)]tj
-17.64744 -1.41176 td
-0.01 tc
(er)tj
0.90502 0 td
-0.004 tw
(aut, m. (1985). kno)tj
8.18733 0 td
[(wledge cr)19(eation and kno)18(wledge use in pr)19(ofessional conte)19(xts)36(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 333.9792 312.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
(studies)tj
-32.82108 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(in higher education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 125.0275 300.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 129.7506 300.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.056 tc
(10)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 138.095 300.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55557 0 td
0 tc
[(1)161(17-133.)]tj
-12.4491 -1.41176 td
0.006 tc
0.133 tw
[(escobar)111(, a. (1995). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 113.0549 288.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.006 tc
0.124 tw
[(encountering de)19(v)19(elopment: the making and unmaking of the thir)19(d)]tj
-6.82999 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(w)tj
0.86914 0 td
0 tw
(orld)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 76.3932 276.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55578 0 td
0 tc
(princet)tj
3.03553 0 td
[(on univ)19(er)18(sity pr)19(ess)37(.)]tj
-8.2258 -1.41177 td
[(f)56(air)19(clough, n. (1992). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 118.5282 264.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(discour)19(se and social change)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 217.6291 264.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
0 tc
[(l)19(ondon: p)55(olity pr)19(ess)37(.)]tj
-21.80614 -1.41176 td
0.002 tc
0.137 tw
[(f)56(air)18(clough, n. & chouliar)19(aki, l. (1999). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 189.9095 252.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.002 tc
0.127 tw
[(discour)19(ses in late modernity: r)18(ethinking cd)56(a)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.639 252.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.48695 -1.41176 td
[(edinbur)19(gh: edinbur)18(gh univ)19(er)19(sity pr)18(ess)37(.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(fien, j. (1993). ideology critique and envir)19(onment)18(al education. in j. fien (ed.), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 324.071 228.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.003 tc
(education)tj
-31.65542 -1.41176 td
-0.009 tc
-0.004 tw
[(f)19(or the envir)18(onment: critical curriculum theorising and envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 333.3391 216.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
(\(pp.14-)tj
-32.74578 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(49\). geelong: deakin univ)19(er)18(sity pr)19(ess)37(. )]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(fien, j. (2000). listening t)19(o the v)18(oice of y)19(outh: implications f)19(or educational r)18(ef)19(orm. in d.)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.028 tc
0.014 tw
[(y)80(enck)18(en, j. fien, & h. syk)19(es \(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 178.1853 180.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.026 tc
0.013 tw
[(envir)19(onment, education and society in the asia-p)36(acific)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 168.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(\(pp. 25)tj
3.01928 0 td
[(1-275\). l)19(ondon: r)18(outledge)56(.)]tj
-5.13693 -1.41176 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(f)56(oucault, m. (1973). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 111.7604 156.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tc
-0.009 tw
[(the origin of things: an ar)19(chaeology of the human sciences)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 317.0662 156.6685 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0041 tc
(.)tj
0.53783 0 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(ne)19(w y)79(ork:)]tj
-31.36916 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.61108 0.00001 td
0 tw
[(andom house)56(.)]tj
-2.72873 -1.41176 td
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
[(f)56(oucault, m. \(198)56(1\). the or)18(der of discour)19(se)56(. in r. y)79(oung (ed.), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 259.6739 132.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tc
-0.004 tw
[(untying the te)19(xt)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 317.1101 132.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.01 tc
-0.004 tw
((pp. 48-78).)tj
-30.83649 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(bost)19(on: r)18(outledge & k)37(egan p)56(aul.)]tj
-2.1176 -1.4118 td
(f)tj
0.481 0 td
(oster)tj
2.0366 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.569 0 td
0 tc
0.013 tw
(j. (1999). what price inter)tj
11.29222 0.00001 td
[(disciplinarity? cr)19(ossing the curriculum in envir)18(onmen-)]tj
-12.2612 -1.4118 td
0 tw
[(t)19(al higher education. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 132.5978 96.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(journal of geogr)19(aph)18(y in higher education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 279.0713 96.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 283.7944 96.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(23)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 292.614 96.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((3), 358-366.)tj
-30.0722 -1.4118 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
[(garr)19(att, d. & hodkinson, p)148(. (1998). can ther)18(e be criteria f)19(or selecting r)19(esear)18(ch criteria? a)]tj
2.1176 -1.4118 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
(hermeneutical analy)tj
8.56613 0.00001 td
(sis of an inescapable dilemma. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 240.2632 72.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
(qualit)tj
2.468 0.00001 td
(ativ)tj
1.49087 0.00001 td
-0.0113 tc
(e)tj
0.6786 0 td
-0.011 tc
(inquiry)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 304.3469 72.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0123 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 308.85 72.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(4)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 313.1646 72.6686 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
((4), 5)tj
2.12951 0.00001 td
0 tw
(15-539.)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(28)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/length 14898
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 73 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.01 tc
0.129 tw
[(goodson, i.f)148(. (1996). curriculum contests: envir)18(onment)19(al studies v)19(er)18(sus geogr)19(aph)19(y)111(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 213.8702 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 218.5934 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 223.0032 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((1), 7)56(1-88.)]tj
-17.64744 -1.41176 td
-0.0001 tc
(g)tj
0.62987 -0.00001 td
0 tc
0.028 tw
(ough, a. (1997). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 140.6184 564.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(e)tj
0.55586 -0.00001 td
0 tc
0.026 tw
[(ducation and the envir)19(onment: p)36(olicy)111(, tr)19(ends and the pr)18(oblems of mar-)]tj
-6.39332 -1.41176 td
0 tw
(ginalisation)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 132.5247 552.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.55579 0 td
0 tc
[(melbourne: a)56(ustr)18(alian council f)19(or educational r)19(esear)19(ch.)]tj
-7.55869 -1.41176 td
-0.006 tc
-0.008 tw
[(gough, a. (1999). the po)19(w)19(er and the pr)18(omise of feminist r)19(esear)19(ch in envir)18(onment)19(al edu-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(cation. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 118.2266 528.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(southern african journal of envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 306.2517 528.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 310.9748 528.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(19)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 319.7944 528.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.5557 0 td
0 tc
(28-39.)tj
-29.59034 -1.41176 td
-0.016 tc
0.002 tw
[(gough, n. \(199)56(1\). narr)18(ativ)19(e and natur)19(e: unsust)19(ainable fictions in envir)18(onment)19(al education.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(a)56(ustr)19(alian journal of envir)18(onment)19(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 255.2413 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 259.9645 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(7)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 264.3743 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55558 0 td
0 tc
[(3)56(1-42.)]tj
-23.0702 -1.41176 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(gough, n. (1997). w)93(eather)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
6.5 0 0 6.5 170.2822 495.1324 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0016 tc
(t)tj
0.5544 -0.00001 td
(m)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 181.4174 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(incorpor)19(ated: envir)18(onment)19(al education, postmodern iden-)]tj
-10.63734 -1.41176 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(tities)37(, and technocultur)18(al constructions of natur)19(e)56(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 271.7313 480.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
-0.012 tw
[(canadian journal of envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
-21.2625 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 126.0957 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 130.8188 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 135.2286 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55573 0 td
0 tc
(145-162.)tj
-7.87674 -1.41176 td
0.037 tw
[(gough, n. (1999). surpassing our o)19(wn hist)18(ories: a)56(ut)19(obiogr)18(aphical methods f)19(or envir)19(on-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(ment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 192.9855 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 315.8557 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 320.5789 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(5)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 324.9886 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((4), 40)56(7-4)55(18.)]tj
-29.64572 -1.41176 td
-0.004 tc
-0.01 tw
[(gough, s. & r)19(eid, a. (2000). envir)18(onment)19(al education r)19(esear)19(ch as pr)18(ofession, as science)56(,)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.0023 tc
(as)tj
1.18531 0 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
[(art and as cr)19(aft: implications f)18(or guidelines in qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)19(esear)18(ch. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 343.6102 420.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.002 tc
[(envir)19(onment)18(a)1(l)]tj
-29.71885 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(education r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 160.0687 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 164.7919 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 169.2017 408.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 47-57.)tj
-11.31785 -1.41177 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(gough, s., scott, w)130(., & st)18(ables)37(, a. (2000). be)19(y)18(ond o\325rior)19(dan: balancing anthr)18(opocentrism)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
(and ecocentrism. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 155.2482 384.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
-0.002 tw
[(international r)19(esear)18(ch in geogr)19(aphical and envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 392.637 384.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(9)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 95.4098 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 36-47.)tj
-2.63645 -1.41176 td
0.072 tw
[(gr\237n, m. (1996). an analy)19(sis of the discur)18(siv)19(e pr)19(oduction of envir)18(onment)19(al education:)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
(t)tj
0.46801 0 td
0 tw
(err)tj
1.22095 0 td
(orism, ar)tj
3.88696 0 td
[(chaism and tr)19(anscendent)18(alism. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 255.4966 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(curriculum studies)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 322.708 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 327.4311 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(4)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 331.8409 348.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((3), 329-347.)tj
-30.45187 -1.41176 td
-0.008 tc
-0.006 tw
[(gudmundsdottir)111(, s. \(199)56(1\). w)92(a)18(y)19(s of seeing ar)19(e w)18(a)18(y)19(s of kno)19(w)-1(i)-1(n)-1(g)-1(:)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1( )-1(p)-1(e)-1(d)-1(a)-1(g)-1(o)-1(g)-1(i)-1(c)-1(a)-1(l)-1( )-1(c)-1(o)-1(n)-1(t)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(kno)tj
1.57038 0 td
(wledge of an e)tj
6.10611 0 td
(xpert english teacher)tj
8.77139 0.00001 td
-0.0138 tc
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 235.2973 324.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
(journal of curriculum studies)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 336.2067 324.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0138 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 340.6971 324.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
(23)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 349.3027 324.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tc
((5), 409-42)tj
4.55607 0 td
(1.)tj
-37.06227 -1.41177 td
-0.021 tc
0.007 tw
(hannigan, j.a. (1995). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 152.935 312.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
(envir)tj
2.10451 0 td
(onment)tj
2.99069 0 td
0.007 tw
[(al sociology: a social constructivist per)19(spectiv)18(e)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 353.3169 312.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0215 tc
(.)tj
0.52042 0 td
(r)tj
0.58996 0 td
-0.021 tc
(outledge:)tj
-31.97119 -1.41177 td
0 tc
[(l)19(ondon.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.041 tc
0.01 tw
(hart, p)tj
2.59742 0 td
-0.0405 tc
(.)tj
0.48479 0 td
-0.041 tc
((1996). pr)tj
3.90193 0 td
-0.04 tc
(oblematizing enquiry in envir)tj
11.61439 0.00001 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.12751 0 td
-0.041 tc
0.01 tw
(al education: issues of method in a study)tj
-19.60839 -1.41178 td
-0.021 tc
-0.01 tw
(of teacher thinking and pr)tj
10.67854 0 td
0 tw
[(actice)56(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 205.763 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.02 tc
-0.009 tw
(canadian journal of envir)tj
10.18387 0 td
[(onment)19(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 359.4429 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0212 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 363.7292 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 367.9739 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.021 tc
(,)tj
0.50433 0 td
(56-88.)tj
-35.20714 -1.41176 td
-0.003 tc
-0.011 tw
(hart, p)tj
2.84048 0 td
-0.0028 tc
(.)tj
0.53919 0 td
-0.003 tc
((2000). r)tj
3.9469 0.00001 td
(equisite v)tj
4.07223 0 td
(ariety: the pr)tj
5.75495 0 td
(oblem with generic guidelines f)tj
13.40765 0 td
(or div)tj
2.45326 0 td
0 tw
(er)tj
0.84575 0.00001 td
-0.011 tw
(se genr)tj
3.09878 0 td
0 tw
(es)tj
-34.84155 -1.41179 td
0 tc
(of inquiry)tj
4.0918 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 130.5034 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(envir)tj
2.20361 0 td
(onment)tj
3.10962 0 td
(al education r)tj
6.01514 0 td
(esear)tj
2.18236 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 253.3737 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 258.0968 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 262.5066 252.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 37-46.)tj
-22.2949 -1.41176 td
0.06 tw
(hart, p)tj
2.93009 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(.)tj
0.61551 0 td
(&)tj
1.05951 0 td
0 tc
[(nolan, k. (1999). a critical analy)19(sis of r)18(esear)19(ch in envir)19(onment)18(al education.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(studies in science education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 191.2382 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 195.9613 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(34)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 204.7809 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55568 0 td
0 tc
(1-69.)tj
-16.05932 -1.41176 td
-0.017 tc
(hopkins)tj
3.41765 0 td
-0.0172 tc
(,)tj
0.52475 0 td
-0.017 tc
0.003 tw
(c. & mck)tj
3.92495 0 td
0 tw
(eo)tj
0.98393 0 td
0.003 tw
(wn, r. \(200)tj
4.80031 0 td
[(1\). r)19(eorienting teacher education t)18(o addr)19(ess sust)18(ainability)111(.)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91 204.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 179.8972 204.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 184.6204 204.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(66)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 193.4399 204.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55565 0 td
0 tc
(8-9.)tj
-14.72505 -1.41176 td
-0.008 tc
(hungerf)tj
3.42828 0 td
(or)tj
0.87296 0 td
-0.006 tw
(d, h., p)tj
3.09427 0 td
0 tc
(e)tj
0.47372 0 td
-0.008 tc
0 tw
(yt)tj
0.79995 0 td
-0.006 tw
(on, r., & wilk)tj
5.94919 0 td
0 tc
(e)tj
0.4366 0 td
-0.0076 tc
(,)tj
0.53436 0 td
-0.008 tc
(r. (1980). goals f)tj
7.31002 0 td
[(or curriculum de)19(v)18(elopment in envi-)]tj
-20.78171 -1.41179 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.36987 0 td
(al education. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 172.053 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(journal of envir)tj
6.53418 0 td
(onment)tj
3.10962 0 td
(al education)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 297.76 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 302.4832 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(1)tj
0.40795 0 td
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 310.3606 180.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((3), 42-47.)tj
-27.92478 -1.41176 td
-0.038 tc
0.002 tw
[(i)-22(v)18(akhiv)111(, a. (2002). t)88(o)19(w)19(ar)18(ds a multicultur)19(al ecology)111(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 244.6715 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.036 tc
0.002 tw
[(or)19(ganisation & envir)18(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 338.985 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0382 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 343.0789 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.036 tc
(15)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 351.2972 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.038 tc
0.002 tw
((4), 389-409.)tj
-32.74085 -1.41176 td
-0.002 tc
-0.012 tw
(jickling, b)tj
4.18641 0 td
-0.0023 tc
(.)tj
0.53974 0 td
-0.002 tc
[((1997). if envir)19(onment)18(al education is t)19(o mak)19(e sense f)18(or teacher)19(s)37(, w)19(e had bet-)]tj
-2.6085 -1.41177 td
-0.007 tc
-0.007 tw
(ter r)tj
1.77174 0.00001 td
[(ethink ho)19(w w)18(e define it! )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 195.5612 144.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.007 tc
-0.006 tw
(canadian journal of envir)tj
10.51378 0.00001 td
[(onment)19(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 354.0377 144.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0074 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 358.5831 144.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(2)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 362.9372 144.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0072 tc
(,)tj
0.53477 0 td
-0.007 tc
(86-1)tj
1.86153 0.00001 td
(03.)tj
-36.50657 -1.41177 td
-0.012 tc
-0.002 tw
[(l)19(ather)110(, p)148(. & smithies)37(, c. (1997). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 187.8504 132.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
-0.002 tw
[(t)80(r)19(oubling the angels: w)38(omen living with hiv/aids)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 360.5069 132.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
(.)tj
0.52999 0 td
(boulder:)tj
-32.23669 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(w)93(estvie)19(w/harpercollins)36(.)]tj
-2.1176 -1.4118 td
[(l)19(opez, b)37(. (1998). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 137.3892 108.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(a)19(bout this life: journe)19(y)18(s on the thr)19(eshold of memory)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 320.5314 108.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55565 0 td
0 tc
[(ne)19(w y)79(ork: knopf.)]tj
-29.677 -1.4118 td
0.037 tw
[(mar)19(cink)18(o)19(w)19(ski, t)130(. (2000). the naaee w)19(orkshop on de)18(v)19(eloping guidelines f)19(or qualit)18(ativ)19(e)]tj
2.1176 -1.4118 td
-0.003 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch in envir)18(onment)19(al education: an analy)19(sis of pr)18(emises)37(, pr)19(ocesses and pr)18(od-)]tj
t*
0 tw
[(ucts)37(. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 110.2039 72.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 233.0741 72.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 237.7972 72.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 242.207 72.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 27-35.)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 406.3701 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(29)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
25 0 obj
<<
/length 13014
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
36 63 324 532.8 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37 588.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.019 tc
0.005 tw
[(mar)19(sden, w)129(.e. (1997). envir)19(onment)19(al education: hist)19(orical r)18(oots)37(, compar)19(ativ)18(e per)19(spectiv)19(es)37(,)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0.019 tc
0.12 tw
[(and curr)19(ent issues in brit)18(ain and the united st)19(ates)37(.)1( )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 261.0134 576.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.017 tc
0.112 tw
(journal of curriculum and)tj
-24.23687 -1.41176 td
-0.0002 tc
(s)tj
0.51884 -0.00001 td
0 tc
0 tw
(upervision)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 96.3981 564.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 101.1212 564.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0004 tc
(1)tj
0.5186 -0.00001 td
(3)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 109.9408 564.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(\()tj
0.29586 -0.00001 td
0 tc
(1\), 6-29.)tj
-8.87713 -1.41176 td
0.009 tc
0.13 tw
[(international society f)19(or phot)18(ogr)19(ammetry and r)19(emote sensing. \(200)55(1\). a)74(v)19(ailable at)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(www)111(.ispr)18(s)37(.or)19(g, accessed january 200)56(1.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(p)56(almer)111(, j. (1998). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 100.4618 528.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
[(e)-1(n)-1(v)-1(i)-1(r)18(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)17(al education in the 2)56(1)-1(s)-1(t)-1( )-1(c)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)-1(u)-1(r)-1(y)-1(:)-1( )-1(t)-1(h)-1(e)-1(o)-1(r)-1(y)110(, pr)18(actice)37(, pr)19(o)-1(g)-1(r)17(ess and)]tj
-5.34845 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(pr)19(omise)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 83.3243 516.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
0 tc
[(l)19(ondon: r)18(outledge)56(.)]tj
-6.00558 -1.41176 td
0.098 tw
[(p)56(a)19(yne)56(, p)147(. (1997). embodiment and envir)19(onment)19(al education. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 269.3273 504.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.091 tw
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education)]tj
-25.21498 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 86.7733 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 91.4965 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(3)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 95.9062 492.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((2), 133-153.)tj
-6.93014 -1.41176 td
-0.009 tw
[(p)56(a)19(yne)56(, p)147(. (1999). p)56(ostmodern challenges and modern horiz)19(ons: education \322f)18(or being f)19(or)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tw
[(the envir)19(onment.\323 )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 124.876 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 247.7462 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 252.4694 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(5)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 256.8791 468.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 5-34.)tj
-25.86813 -1.41176 td
0.012 tc
0.126 tw
[(p)56(e)1(s)1(h)1(k)1(i)1(n)1(,)1( a)1(.)1( \()1(2)1(0)1(0)1(0)1(\))1(.)1( t)1(h)1(e)1( n)1(a)1(t)1(u)1(r)20(e )-1(of )-1(interpr)19(et)18(ation )-1(in )-1(qualit)19(ativ)19(e)1( r)19(esear)19(c)1(h)1(.)1( )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 316.5438 456.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.011 tc
(educational)tj
-30.76986 -1.41176 td
0 tc
[(r)19(esear)19(cher)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 93.8518 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 98.5749 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(29)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 107.3945 444.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((9), 5-9.)tj
-8.28171 -1.41176 td
-0.01 tw
[(pickles)37(, j. (1995). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 102.389 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.009 tw
[(gr)19(ound truth: the social implications of geogr)18(aphic inf)19(ormation sy)19(stems)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6386 432.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.4869 -1.41176 td
[(ne)19(w y)79(ork: guilf)19(or)18(d.)]tj
-2.11765 -1.41176 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(r)19(eid, a. & gough, s. (2000). guidelines f)19(or r)18(eporting and e)19(v)19(aluating qualit)19(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch:)]tj
2.11765 -1.41177 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(what ar)19(e the alternativ)18(es? )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 153.0509 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(envir)19(onment)18(al education r)19(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 275.9211 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 280.6443 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 285.0541 396.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[((1), 59-9)56(1.)]tj
-29.18284 -1.41176 td
0.049 tw
[(r)19(eid, a. & nik)19(el, j. (2003). r)18(eading a critical r)19(e)19(vie)18(w of e)19(vidence: notes and queries on)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
(r)tj
0.33625 0 td
-0.015 tc
0.001 tw
[(esear)19(ch pr)18(ogr)19(ammes in envir)19(onment)19(al education. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 237.5194 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.014 tc
(envir)tj
2.13442 0 td
0.001 tw
[(onment)19(al education r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6412 372.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 360.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(9)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 59.4098 360.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((2), 149-164.)tj
-2.63645 -1.41176 td
(r)tj
0.59985 0 td
-0.011 tc
-0.003 tw
(eid, a., scott, w)tj
6.65278 0 td
(., & gough, s. (2002). education and sust)tj
17.29893 0 td
[(ainable de)19(v)19(elopment in the uk:)]tj
-22.43391 -1.41178 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(an e)19(xplor)18(ation of pr)19(ogr)19(ess since rio. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 192.5419 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
[(geogr)19(aph)18(y)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 229.9784 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 234.7015 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(87)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 243.5211 336.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((3), 247-255.)tj
-24.2966 -1.41176 td
0.007 tc
0.132 tw
(rickinson, m. & colleagues)tj
12.15858 0 td
0.0072 tc
(.)tj
0.70201 0 td
0.007 tc
((2000). envir)tj
5.85567 0 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
3.41385 0.00001 td
0.132 tw
(al education r)tj
6.25373 0 td
0 tw
(esear)tj
2.31351 0 td
0.132 tw
(ch in the uk: a)tj
-28.5797 -1.41178 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.35107 0 td
0 tw
(esponse)tj
3.4624 0 td
-0.0003 tc
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 92.1377 312.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r)tj
0.61108 0 td
(esear)tj
2.18238 0 td
(ch intelligence)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 166.2159 312.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 170.9391 312.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(7)tj
0.46289 0 td
(1)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 179.2834 312.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.5557 0 td
0 tc
(36-37.)tj
-17.29493 -1.41176 td
-0.004 tw
[(r)19(obott)19(om, i. & hart, p)147(. (1993). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 151.3959 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.004 tw
[(r)19(esear)19(ch in envir)18(onment)19(al education: engaging the debate)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6388 300.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(.)tj
-35.48692 -1.41176 td
(geelong: deakin univ)tj
9.35156 0 td
(er)tj
0.85107 0 td
(sity pr)tj
2.72119 0.00001 td
(ess)tj
1.31471 0 td
(.)tj
-16.35618 -1.41178 td
(seale)tj
2.20386 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55571 0 td
0 tc
(c. (1999). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 99.0255 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(the quality of qualit)tj
8.27222 0 td
[(ativ)19(e r)18(esear)19(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 218.0898 276.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0002 tc
(.)tj
0.55566 0 td
(l)tj
0.48121 0 td
0 tc
[(ondon: sage)56(.)]tj
-22.34155 -1.41177 td
0.022 tc
(schneider)tj
4.3854 0 td
0.0221 tc
(,)tj
1.00537 0 td
0.022 tc
0.405 tw
(d. \(200)tj
3.72803 0.00001 td
0 tw
(1\). )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 130.6735 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(r)tj
0.63183 0 td
0.021 tc
0.377 tw
(emote sensing of the global envir)tj
16.17346 0.00001 td
0 tw
(onment)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 301.1681 264.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.0221 tc
(a)tj
1.22739 0 td
(a)tj
0.57825 0 td
0 tc
(v)tj
0.50344 0 td
0.022 tc
0.405 tw
(ailable at)tj
-31.27003 -1.41177 td
0 tc
0 tw
(www)tj
2.16553 0 td
(.geo.mtu.edu/r)tj
6.33276 0 td
(s)tj
0.38892 0 td
-0.0001 tc
(,)tj
0.55578 0 td
0 tc
(accessed january)tj
7.29554 0 td
-0.0002 tc
(,)tj
0.55569 0 td
0 tc
(200)tj
1.61178 0.00001 td
[(1. michigan t)88(echnological univ)18(er)19(sity)111(.)]tj
-21.02365 -1.41178 td
-0.019 tc
(smith-sebast)tj
5.38595 0 td
(o,)tj
1.04105 0 td
0.005 tw
[(n.j. (2000). p)56(otential guidelines f)18(or conducting and r)19(eporting envir)19(onment)19(al)]tj
-4.30935 -1.41177 td
-0.014 tc
0 tw
(education r)tj
4.71945 0 td
(esear)tj
2.20895 0.00001 td
(ch: qualit)tj
3.82701 0 td
(ativ)tj
1.50061 0 td
-0.0137 tc
(e)tj
0.75028 0 td
-0.014 tc
(methods of inquiry)tj
7.90297 0 td
-0.0139 tc
(.)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 237.2184 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.013 tc
(envir)tj
2.14025 0 td
(onment)tj
3.03357 0.00001 td
(al education r)tj
5.83716 0 td
(esear)tj
2.11901 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 356.6368 228.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 55 216.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(6)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 59.4098 216.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 9-2)tj
3.03711 0 td
(1.)tj
-5.67355 -1.41177 td
0.056 tw
[(st)19(ables)36(, a. & scott, w)130(. (2002). the quest f)19(or holism in education f)18(or sust)19(ainable de)19(v)19(el)-1(-)]tj
2.11765 -1.41176 td
0 tw
(opment. )tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 88.3733 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(envir)tj
2.20361 0 td
(onment)tj
3.10962 0 td
(al education r)tj
6.01513 0 td
(esear)tj
2.18238 0 td
(ch)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 211.2435 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 215.9667 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(8)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 220.3765 192.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((1), 53-60.)tj
-21.57371 -1.41176 td
(st)tj
0.81494 0 td
(anisstr)tj
2.85034 0 td
0.08 tw
(eet, m. & bo)tj
5.592 0 td
[(y)19(es)37(, e. (2000). benefits of quantit)18(ativ)19(e empirical studies f)19(or envi-)]tj
-7.13964 -1.41178 td
0.005 tc
0.133 tw
[(r)18(o)-1(n)-1(m)-1(e)-1(n)-1(t)18(al education. in b)37(. hor)18(st & j. ma)19(y)18(er \(eds)37(.\), )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 255.8955 168.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.005 tc
0.124 tw
[(st)19(ate of the art of empirical)]tj
-23.63477 -1.41176 td
0 tc
(r)tj
0.3844 0 td
0.014 tc
0.115 tw
[(esear)19(ch on envir)18(onment)19(al education)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 195.6562 156.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.015 tc
0.124 tw
(\(pp. 39-5)tj
4.11436 0 td
[(1\). kiel german)19(y: institut fur die)]tj
-20.66215 -1.41177 td
0 tc
(p)tj
0.51807 0.00001 td
0 tw
(adagogik der naturwissenschaften. )tj
-2.63572 -1.41177 td
-0.013 tc
-0.001 tw
[(stern, p)148(.c. & dietz, t)129(. (1994). the v)19(alues basis f)19(or envir)18(onment)19(al concern. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 302.7352 132.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.012 tc
-0.001 tw
(journal of social)tj
-29.14532 -1.41176 td
0 tc
0 tw
(issues)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 76.555 120.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 81.2782 120.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(50)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 90.0978 120.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((3), 65-84.)tj
-6.2468 -1.4118 td
0.021 tc
0.117 tw
[(t)87(odor)19(o)18(v)111(, t)129(. (1984). )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 113.913 108.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.02 tc
0.109 tw
(mikhail bakhtin: the dialogical principle)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 270.7227 108.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
0.021 tc
0.117 tw
[(\(t)80(r)18(ans)37(. wlad godzich\).)]tj
-25.3791 -1.4118 td
0 tc
0 tw
[(minneapolis: univ)19(er)18(sity of minnesot)19(a pr)19(ess)36(.)]tj
-2.1176 -1.4118 td
-0.001 tc
-0.013 tw
[(w)93(alk)19(er)110(, k. (1997). challenging critical theory in envir)19(onment)19(al education. )]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 307.4978 84.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.001 tc
[(envir)19(onment)18(al)]tj
-29.7056 -1.4118 td
0 tc
[(education r)19(esear)18(ch)]tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 124.0687 72.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
-0.0003 tc
(,)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f12 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 128.7919 72.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(3)tj
et
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f11 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 133.2017 72.9874 tm
0 0 0 1 k
((2), 155-162.)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
36.333 17.496 323.667 23.0401 re
f
q
/gs2 gs
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 37.612 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(alan reid)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
14.112 17.496 22.5 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 15.112 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(30)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
26 0 obj
<<
/length 315
>>
stream
/gs0 gs
1 g
0 648 0 0 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
0 0 0 0 k
72 63 324 532.8 re
f
72 17.4601 324 23.0399 re
f
q
/gs1 gs
q
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 241.668 33.8348 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(sensing environmental education research)tj
et
0 0 0 0 k
396 17.496 24.7 23.0401 re
f
bt
/f0 1 tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 404.2243 33.8708 tm
0 0 0 1 k
(<#>)tj
et
q

endstream
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/nums[0<</s/d/st 9>>]
>>
endobj
28 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 35/numbersign 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine 60/less 62/greater/question 65/a/b/c 69/e/f 73/i/j/k 77/m/n 82/r/s/t/u 87/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p 114/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 209/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
29 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 6138
/length1 6138
>>
stream




tpsjlj+eurostileregular

7�����
�?��
�?��ea���


=4fotjh
&wspnubmevd3i"
6zg#,$+ql5'.ciwx	
yk�*8 /?
�
s
�xv/2u��l����;��n��h�		�	�
\
��3�
t�<x��-��ct���-l:ma����l���{���.��.����.��.���a�m���`�^�qwhgwj#�/�t���|{�,��4���{�o�o�t8�v<cmmb�
}�d�.+��fe�y����-�n��+�'�yy��s�y�v�'���ͼ��
�<�/n�q�q����h��j��
�g�f�y΋����ʺ�����6����|�m�m�f���-�3l�m������izaiwwib���?��kk�{��+�d��jo�u��t���d�6�jjtsip��r�b���kk��k�d�+����dz������#m������ۭ���Ԟ���{l��l�h$�^���*�� ���n���y��|o��o�t9g��� ��r�[��[.���>!z)a������p�����y�,�����2!ygvvgqd ��a�gg�� y�i�x'ex]guug?��-l��kk�{�����%�w�%�f�ee��x�1�,����ij����@4��a��#���-�\���˙�����͔��Ѓ{��{�ai� ����u�1� �1� �-�p� �p� ����p����[�$��0��(&geuuep��s�m���ee��i�"�@�����t.xlgkkfc{!$h��mm�|�����8�__��u�#�4����ǿ������ r�>�]�-�$�8y hwwgbr��c��kj�{��2�0����ӣ���t^����l���
���
��g���i��i�e�g�b�7�p�6��x�6s9s:�q�r�v�7�=���$���p�]���p�0�:�� ���t���0��z)��z�r�s��͋�i3��d��0^1t����� �p��c�vmq��a�b���nm��m�d�d�����Ȧ��b�ap�w��v���d�d�lnw��6�c�"�>�>|!mccm>w��>��mm�}��>�>������ؠ���vc����� ���c���s� �m��_�� ���	�ڳ���֠���|m��m�r7�� ��z���u�4�
u o��h)��6�.#u u����$� �p����p�z� �z�����i�1�=�m�f���p����v�\�/^^1�0^�����������`���@��zk��k�d�
���i�'��<��"*u_uu_p;��v�*���7�������$� ��o�s��s���3�'(weyyer@��������u���q�x@�(o�y)j��kk�{��՛�����ї���~q����u��� u� ���u����i�$��b�� +heuuep��g�w���dc��h�'�4������� u� p���[�/��=y�iyyh@r�!e��ii�{��4�%�뭻��ϣ���s[�����p���	v;b__b@v�7r��on�}���� ��s���t�3������� �p� ���u�$ong}!�:��ii�z��3�6������Σ��
�~s��r�zar� �n�s��r!��/�2�igssgo��q�^���kj��k�@�����a��� !|hoo������e���;�3���.���9b��$���ɫ���������#m�o�o�#��&�����.�����xf��e�;�(uhagg`;z�	�q���'�u��� ����߳���ڡ��'�c�$p��� ����i�����6(^2h����� �����5��u�l�����7����g������)��������������l�l��h�tnnr�?���������z�.�g���-�u9_kk_�{�f�9$��aa�v���p�.�p]�'�'�ww��"q�e�r�&��������b�p�.�p�&�!�p��>u�hr q!�f�g�a�h�'�>�)���p��w��p-f�sn@�}�{�x��������ͦ��������"�����) ����������/�🬈����di�o�u+-�o�"�&��&��� �����!����Ũ��%�gb��$�������,�(q�w��w�
��;�����1����s��}p��p�p/!xffmlf8|��)�j���!�6�}o��o�a�)xjgmmg>|�	���������u���.�����g�p�w��&�[��������.������tc^on^�}�i�s���kj�{�t��:�������p��{l��k�e��a�-����.l�o��o�	��b���;os>i[ct}n}n��)�����ê�t�9�9�%c�y�����3�˹ʹ��	��n��-�:��|u�>�{5kgfkay��
a��mm�|�����+�]�um��0�yy��s�8�5�����ũ��5�w�.������������.l�n��m���l�x�t^nm^m,�$��?�c�c�m�x�)xklmam`|:����7�"�[�[�$t�r��^���ʿɿ��
��;��|�m�m�m�+���ũ���4�3�s�m%�ydimli<|��n���ba�w����Э�����0�8�t�����o�k%!etgsg[ta����u�/�n�o�o�}��
��Ӳ�����2�5�}p����.� ���6��a�2�����Ѧ��h�up�v��u*��"�5"]/[����
� �����[�!�6�(z)i\[ift"�a��gf�y��(�3����Ԥ���s[��������#�⭪����b��y������©�
��8��>k�l�k����l��d��ofufui�
��7�d�+����϶�����8��yh��h�?�	�y8hkhk&q�<y�fs�hs_s^o-��$���k������ctip�k�����c�i6��.a�����-����ͤ�r����q�zw��w�-������+jiu��"�y��8����z�8izyi�s�s�t���ii�{�8������8�������t�s�rz������
���{m��m�i'�x?ekke0|�"�l���dc�x����*:�0�&�[[��!s�l�[����Ϳ���3�z�i�i�g�$���ȧ�����܋��� j�k�k����\��x��ro[n[m%��0�u�&���Ю�����)�5�}q��p�b�#vkbtsb���lw����������:�aa��w�^�a�����ì��c��!����li�
h��g���d�_�nrlkrl��j�4� �ts��p�b�p������a�-x.eiie"{�@�+,��cc�w�����%�o�x�����g�-�,�udaoo`�~�d�5��gg�y����ݰ�����)�=�yg�����u��.�/�����.u�r�{�u��� �c��*�c�q�w���-�k�d���k��� �(����#���#�q�:�.��m���ru�<���i�����.���`��`�,�����,����������[�������.��-��-�q�?��mu���p�"�}�t}iod�o�n�q�#�������.���������}�����k�l�f���.�e���ˍ���������b�b9���.u���u�d�=��:���!����
���2�_�*��'����Ѩ��i�rp�v��u+�� �f#\/k����� ��� ����[�$�2�*z'j[[jgs%�>��ii�{��a� �豺��գ���r[�������lj������ŏ��y~��0^m��[�.���lj���Ū�ʋ��v|��0^m��[�.��
u�l��h�snnr�>���������[�.���l��h�pknm�>���������[�.����l�l�.�l�.�g��p���a�:w8v8�x�x�c�9����`���c�9w8x8�w�w�a�:����'���p�h�����6�ܞ���:�:��6����d���p�*9���ix���)������������)����Ť��e��0�.am8m7|���b�b����78��a�0���*q��x���2u�h�����d�)�xe��e�4��>x#geef&x�8�2)��ee�x���%w� �-�\[��t�^�_�����˫��f�?j�	i��i���h�n�e@v���2����+9����z��)�����������)xz[xqr+����/�赩��ߛ���b�b{��m��m.��/e����r[��e�
�p�l���m���<���\�����;�������;�������v�;���u�1� �1� �-��9�yvyqxy�������(���������2���� �������
h�e��e���w�v�mqmlql��h��p�����y���mm��m�f�b�����ì�
�h�9l�m��m���k�`�b:q��������
��@��s��s�[c��z�s�*���>�*�j�5��w;dlkc(|�4�9%��cc�w��4��̹�����*�8�zk����d�������}�u���.u�.���u����`�-�k�)��x�wsxu���gb�whwh�x�y�d����k�x���jd�xixh�x΁�����c����i�2�7���z���i���ɜ���m�i�v�������k�~�bu�5�2��l�l�.�l�.�4��ڸ��ߩ������d�%o�t��s"��0�n�
qyqqxo �6�^�%�����֫���ڛ���|n��n�d��a;7k8k3iriqgqgk0�m�+����vu��%�w�x�k�j���j���������.���������?�?��-���5��u�.�������1��u���u��� ��1����������~���~��@�
g�@����@�h�@��{/��z����|/��f�e���e��f�e�
��e�������
�������z���������1��u���u��� ��0���
endstream
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/ascent 1775
/fontname/tpsjlj+eurostileregular
/xheight 0
/stemv 0
/fontbbox[-185 -250 1123 867]
/italicangle 0
/fontfile3 29 0 r
/stemh 0
/capheight 1775
/type/fontdescriptor
/descent -512
/flags 32
>>
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/widths[250 0 0 613 0 0 0 0 277 277 0 0 198 208 195 0 613 614 613 613 613 613 613 613 614 614 0 0 433 0 433 520 0 608 617 597 0 498 489 0 0 204 502 603 0 858 696 0 0 0 623 560 515 655 0 999 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 510 511 485 510 502 265 510 514 188 186 430 188 826 516 506 510 0 398 474 326 507 402 670 404 389 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 692 319 319]
/name/f0
/fontdescriptor 30 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 28 0 r
/basefont/tpsjlj+eurostileregular
/firstchar 32
/lastchar 211
>>
endobj
32 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[65/a 82/r 97/a/b/c 109/m 114/r/s/t/u 142/eacute]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
33 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 1943
/length1 1943
>>
stream




vcpbji+usherwood-bolditalic

@��
����^������
��
��
/
+
f�v

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bold italicitc usherwood



"ctusbd3�vn
�
 
�
�q�0�5�ӆ��r���������cq���t�y�o��������� �y��������pa�[��k���������$��f������x�$�������������y�x�x\\�\$�k�����{yy\h�z��[gvn�oy������������$������r�k-y�������w
�+�����������erle{)��kǨ�k}�t�ua��c�g�ft��a��f��;�<�\�@?tj[c��o�����z쬜di�f�:(bm���oy���
�����"��������o�d�:���en�4��"�a��)�bbl[�p�d���������g�wcskrg�x�w�����ȋ��%�av�狱�������p�j����~��y���ǘw��������xuggjk}�����������Ǩ����|�ȅtx�e?��&e^:_y2hxc�s���k�i�|o�p���Ƿ��o�v�
�
���)��y�������n~������𑜒����}�hicenp>4���������}�fccdtpfq�s��������mu\m���j���������$�y���
���b����]�_���ɶ�t�y|ssz�u}�����e��e���gt�]$�=�!�v�3f�?�ܽӾ����y+oy�,>n������u𚚇���oy���
���s���4pxz<jtl�����۫�vjw�x�y�w�ɖ������o�f�6��3�7��i����ñ�������m�f�p��
����d���������o����������$��a�n����������a΋���1�1�������������$��p�u�x�i���l����Ώ����?��rk��k҉ji�lyy��y�y�y�y�҄k�����a|�x�};��|kzk@�����������ּnk0>j�
c�=y����������\'��(�c����π�!���(���(ekbs=lg�ǒ�������p��
�t�>�a��6�7��o���������{sb�\ayƜ���ry��*w��h���z�����t�xzuys�r}���������>�������y�w{t��x i�n��������v<�
�q1u|�������ب𕯐������wqmrob:r�r��������wwz�v�}�n'�l�j�mi�g����Ȼ���y�r�vp�i�������^�v�v�����>���p�z�x�ʘ��b���zop�d�ly�}���������$������Ƌ��tt~�v�}�g��n�r�sv�i��������w�yqmp�|�������z��"�������g�ikpn8h���������a�b;9�sc���������~�f`rng_ks�s��������yk<m�e�f���������$y����f��`��������
�����
endstream
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/ascent 684
/fontname/vcpbji+usherwood-bolditalic
/xheight 694
/stemv 112
/fontbbox[-202 -308 1068 850]
/italicangle -12
/fontfile3 33 0 r
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
/type/fontdescriptor
/descent -254
/flags 262242
>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<<
/widths[722 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 685 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 556 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 852 0 0 0 0 463 463 389 593 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 481]
/name/f1
/fontdescriptor 34 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 32 0 r
/basefont/vcpbji+usherwood-bolditalic
/firstchar 65
/lastchar 142
>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 38/ampersand 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period 48/zero/one/two 57/nine 59/semicolon 67/c 69/e 72/h/i 76/l/m/n 80/p 82/r/s/t 86/v/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y 136/agrave 142/eacute 144/ecircumflex 210/quotedblleft/quotedblright 213/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 7456
/length1 7456
>>
stream




isqkja+usherwood-mediumitalic

@��
����w���w��
��
��
3
/
��

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood medium italicitc usherwood


75if
gjmepowsnubvdtchxzq
)/
y	.l41r8iw*-&3�k�$�79
�
)
�
�"����q�z7��
�	�
i
�s�>��
�`�5������d�\���i����[���i��?���ŵ�w�խ������������$��t�b����������u�%��}�?��������qЄyb�2��agv��}�~�����qЁ]|uvy��ߏ���&�ux9�w@��y�kv�/����w���{�z���3������nkt�t�t�n��j�j�jg�d������������rvy�wz�������z���������h�x9:'xd����<�ɚȜ�wtls}=��s���gr�r�sw��y5u5v7���������$�by��%�
������
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*����������w�k�s��c���u�8�ǔ����w�Ԁsn�pb����-���yx~�~�~��̛�������������pq��q�!q�,e|r�lj�m��c�ni�35�wx�������t�jt�z~y�wf���?��p�t��y��dw����{�a���������rvy�{~�������ȫ��������z�mwt��z3k�{��������vxw�z�w�d�.�m�l�ld�a������$��������w�soknar�s��y�����w
���|�����rvy�wz����������ɣ䒮wtls}=��s���gr�r�s:��j�j�jg�d�������y��%����w
���s��������rvy�w{�����ɷ�kwtls}=��s���gz�}�z}np�n�n��3��a�1 �n��ｧ���x�v�vb�]����������#��,ﴳne_7���_k���y��0�
������ty�$�
�#�/�<���$�	�%�-��?�$�h���-�تla�<�-'>q��-y�kv�/����-�|�t�?�:�������xlp�q�q�n��j�c�ij�d������Ĺ~�z�zzw�v~�������t���������i�y8n:>h���������{�jz{��}3k�{��������mt8x�nr2���������$�*�v�/�
�*��l����o�s��������xw5�&�<`y������1s�zrvz{wku�w����������\�$b�a�b���������$���^�p����o}w��s�t�v��a����3���<�#�������|{�������֐������y�uajbmo7.���������y�fz{��}�3k�{��������mt;z�hq)���������$�ky�kv�/����d��$�|�z�e�h������toy�e�of�����������$��b����݋��xlp�q�q�n��j�c�ij�d������Ĺ~�z�zzw�v~�������z���������i�y@f<nw���������r�p<)�en���������{�jz{��}3k�{��������kw;m�y}y���������$��y����w������wsonery������������������Ѐvy�qz������jc<uk*a�s�n���m�l�kv�{�������*y��%�
���[��|�y�{~{|w�t�����h��v���zlm�k$�,�(�q�74�p�ݸݻ�������k�i������������m�������ra�2~kq�\hd�d�y���-y�m������y��)Ҁ�t�������rvy�wz������[���{�wyw||s�s��������~y.'���ko����œ���ěƳ�z�kv{��z3k�{��������w}�io�'�hb�f����ɽ���v�s�sg�a�������ty��%�
������
�
o�^qo\m�se�����-몦wev�v�w�~���������_�e��#�4�b"�p�͵�ѻ�ty��0�
�������������r�_�0�%�cr�7�� �d��"�`h^e�u�[���������r�wjwlul�g�g���	��͋���!�d{������ċ���r�b����y��%����w
�!����������hj�=�;�
fc�����tls}=��s���gr�r�s{0c��zt�z�e��c���g��4��_�;�=�q;f[���������*����z�� �
�����#���i�t�����kl�l$�j��p�-,�r�ڴɵ���o�t�n�(�vd�������o�xduesfn��\��q���'�������
������l�
������%bv�{�_p���
�����f��3��j��d�����o�s��������zx,��0`x���������x�}�{�z�{xy�x$�s�����e*��
bl��������1s�zrvz{wku�w����������\�$b�a�b���������$�����Ǝp�p�p�n�p�o���������$���y�`����p}w��s�������
c��v��f����o�s��������xq6��.`?�����-ux{~z<l�v������ђ��6'.�ds����o�r�t�t�u�ww%���������b���]����~�o}w��s��}v�v�p��$����v��q��֝֜י���}~�}uw����������k�v���8��v�&�x�a-f�`p���������{�kz{��}3k�{��������tsx�t�zr���q��euq�_�����w���_n�f�@�
ey���y�
����������u�mkolmx�y������werozi�y�m����m��w�.�t�y����������������ϡ�Ӻs�fb_ws�uu��ut�vu�t~|������k��d���)�l�+xx��y��xx�x������������s{vycnz��������Ƚ_j�i�$��mu�y��ҵ
������qy�t����*�q���t+���*��,�-�t�����Ѧd<�b���ep���y�����������������u�mkolmx�y������werozip�m�������{�tossku�w����������
w�w����������$��t�b����������e��e�e|a�n=��s���������$��w�a������������ݓ�֕��a�a�agg�g$�s�����]v�w�wl�!����!�Ք�ٔ��e�e�ecd�c$�s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@��y�^����9�|��w�w���w�q��؆���������$��f���;�������~�s�ywv�x$�s�����uqgo�w��.o�i�����t�����z�|�}�y��}�`�5}}��~�~~��|�zw�u�u�y)e�m�3��:���ڤ���	���Φ�(���dy{fh+�4�8ȋ����x��ܣ�����n�s�c���������'�p�������g��c��es�s�sut�u$�s�����ww�w�w;����{�}r�r�rrr�q$�s�����x�bl��k�����������$�������w
����������‰�$��k�k������*��rogmu"��s����ju[�ri�z:d�f���v���|����������y�/����8���6���#1��-�-���������������;�ct�"j���������u1.s*,dw����v�w
�=�?�:�����5���@1�\��`�f�k�����x�6dg�y�
���y�����{�tossku�w��Ѡv�h�
�����f������ˆ�׵lot��zhb�z?a�y��qv�2�i��������a�q�h�iŋ�����ü}�x}wts�dy��}t�˧��ź���{z���o���y�v�qgoyi`k�}�}�b�psyzv�my�v��������mu��+cenxhry�st��yw{�c�v�x�����ŭ��v�w
���r�q�z�����x�6����zn���5����@�9�y�9���v���t���=�i�o���������f�p��$�����1��� ��0�8����@�&�w ~�d|�s���������$��e�v�����������蔎ʛ��p�p�pno�o$����i��r�r�rll�l$�s�����\d��'g����������$�y�kv�7����w������2��wr8�5am}ϗ����g�p�������p������ĸ}�y~y|u�@��4� �������o�p<<4nq�����ɚȜ�wtls}=��s���gw�m�s|nm��d�+���������$�y��jw�0�
���^��z�t������p�y������z����r�����/�:ko#�f�;��⋢����q�teseph�^�/�l����	ً�
��[��j�� ��ϯ΋ڋ�e�r�}�}�~?��������n��w����������������k�4���y��r�y�����������$��e�q�����������1��i�	��.�8��{r��qԉqp�vww�x�w�w�w�Ԅs�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@��*�}v���7��%�}�����)��؝כٚ��r{��������������qod|w�}y��fk��g�"�,�+�h��u�ܻզ���e�3s�v�:f`���/��/���sgr>���wo���������
�����a�����'��a���������$�����
��z�x�l�st��$�s�����za��i�
�]�n��t�u�tpj�x$�s�����hj�&e�!e�"�c��t�u�tpj�x$�s�����h��)��u��n���������$�è§��t�v�<�l��-��-��h�zl1rcn�p������~�w�������������g�zl1rcn�p������~�w������������t�v�<�l��-��-���<������u�mkolmx�y������werozi��gv������u�mkolmx�y������werozi�����ܣ
w�	w����������$��t�b������������Ք�ٔ��e�e�ecd�c$�s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@���v���ţw��pw�������������y��ţţ�ivift�rr�����������Ք�ٔ��e�e�ecd�c$�s�����aw�t�x=���x9�w@�?�v���ov͵�|�x��w�w�-��x�x��������⃋q���Ɯƞ�iece�2ok���������;�ېu��ɛɝ�ntn�u/&��|���jk��q������sx�yx��;�kww��xr��ww�w���s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@�w��������n��w�
��4�g��
���������������w8��?�@o�{�����������$��x�_����������4Ƌϋ�w�@ā�q����������$��t�q�z�g������⽑��� �	1�,~n��n҉nm�{wx��xʌyx�x҄s�����aw�t�x=��x9�w@���v�<�l
��-�
�<������u�mkolmx�y������werozi�by��%��aw���&�g<��(�o����҅�x�y�y{x�$���!��
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*������gw���'�b���j�����Σ�|�lvu��z3k�{��������uzr�m�sn��i�(h=k�vy�������m�ygwiuhq��i��8��(��(��������w�soknar�s��*y��%���ww����0f��$�����q��}�{|��{$}w�t�
��|�y�{~{|w�t�����h��v���zlm�k$�,�(�q�74�p�ݸݻ�������k�i������������m�������ra�2~kq�\hd�d�y���?y��Ȫl����,�����gygs'�
�
\���k��q�+��ja�������o؃����ts��s��ts�s�n�3�u�r�&�*�!�2��ò�by��%��������3��(�2�����a�i�;�����
�"flwf?���
����`���u�o�5��/�:�
�p���侴#����vn0�v\_|����*�w�v����9�c�������������_�0�z��0�腷m�̆ߋƮ�����b�b�bee�e$�s�����cة�r����c���������$��#������}�{}�m�px{�~$y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
38 0 obj
<<
/ascent 684
/fontname/isqkja+usherwood-mediumitalic
/xheight 694
/stemv 75
/fontbbox[-195 -282 995 857]
/italicangle -12
/fontfile3 37 0 r
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
/type/fontdescriptor
/descent -254
/flags 98
>>
endobj
39 0 obj
<<
/widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 741 0 278 278 0 0 259 333 259 0 519 519 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 0 259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 574 0 574 0 0 667 296 0 0 537 815 648 0 574 0 630 519 574 0 630 944 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 519 426 519 444 333 500 537 278 278 519 259 833 556 519 519 500 426 426 352 556 500 759 537 519 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 444 0 444 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 426 426 0 259]
/name/f2
/fontdescriptor 38 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 36 0 r
/basefont/isqkja+usherwood-mediumitalic
/firstchar 32
/lastchar 213
>>
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 40/parenleft 69/e 82/r 97/a 99/c/d/e 104/h/i 108/l/m/n/o 114/r/s/t/u/v]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
41 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 2457
/length1 2457
>>
stream




hgibew+usherwood-medium

?��
���9������
��
��
%
!
l�	|

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood mediumitc usherwood


	&owjspnfubmevd
3ti
5�

�m���d�)�or����v�w
�����a�2��s���Ӷ��ea�&%�����)%�b-�v�w���qvٵ�n��w���w���p�Ǣ<p��������mǪ����p������������i�<pjs�f�/jj�����e���px�������������%ii~�~�/�n���pk���8�������z<pyu~�?�gzy��y9p�yz�yzpr����4�&4^�u�r���������z�������������$�z�����x�����ۑi6�5b�z�o���������$�p�����u�o�?<bjxu�����r�fcz�kr���y3�@a��s�*�����
��z�u��p����������$�
�����u�v�vtu�t$r����gpr�r&��$��������������g�h�hll�m$r�{�|��0������w����4����a��sr���������$�z�����������rfcz�kr���y3��������u�qpuuqp�u�������{���������������$�z�����
Ϊ�װ�l~���x�������mgt_c�����r�fcz�kr���y3�%*��n~-y��*�
�������y�!���&�&/��!�!0$�&�&�$�!�'�������/��]/%%^�������������r��r�������������$�z�����y�����ߋ>d�fa�{�}���������$�`�|���������՘z/�m[���x���������$�t����
�f�]�5>[zaw�ys�8hxzaw�����r�fcz�kr���y3�%*��n~�*y���v��������?�htgm6�2��f���؜�o���0�e��3��%��$���鱢����n�������(h��y����w������wwrrot��������������c��ej�rxnh:pr���o�h�Ҷã��*y��{v�f�
���b������~\�����m��[�azw����$s~a|a{b�~�����įwr�����s>�x�����i��]�������c�tf3ev@wb���͙������פ�w
�������������$�z�����q�����rfcz�kr���y3�a��s-y��!����w
������!�n�vh�k�/��)��/��
�ѱ���a�o�e��������w�����k�����rfcz�kr����k���j($:z������۪y??y�����w
���}��_y�������u�����q���rfcz�kr���j2�[?/.����‹ȏ�rfcz�ir���y3�"�f��е��_�c�p�=y��!�
���8�itio36n������ۥbq���������q�����jl�j$�5���)�)���没��������v��w�����ܳ������4�&4^�u�r���������$�m�����q��z��k�����������$�o�q�y�zɂ�,���������*��pp��p܉op�phg��h��)y�������p604t'd�ty��*�
���p��y�������{�$�����e��k�������oi���������o�����lm�l$,=\-�b��Ӌ�x\hx��ʻyf��y�y�yr���)����w
���z��n�������ۑi6�5b�z�o���������$�p�����u�o�?<bjxu�v�����rfcz�kr���y3�a��sr���������$�z����y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
42 0 obj
<<
/ascent 684
/fontname/hgibew+usherwood-medium
/xheight 694
/stemv 80
/fontbbox[-82 -282 1027 872]
/italicangle 0
/fontfile3 41 0 r
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
/type/fontdescriptor
/descent -254
/flags 34
>>
endobj
43 0 obj
<<
/widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 278 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 648 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 481 556 500 0 0 593 278 0 0 278 889 593 556 0 0 389 426 315 574 500]
/name/f3
/fontdescriptor 42 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 40 0 r
/basefont/hgibew+usherwood-medium
/firstchar 32
/lastchar 118
>>
endobj
44 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space/exclam 38/ampersand 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 62/greater/question 65/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w 89/y 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 159/udieresis 165/bullet 209/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
45 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 10086
/length1 10086
>>
stream




wuyqjh+usherwood-book

?��
���&���x��
��
��
!

��'i

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bookitc usherwood


o3fnpu
tojhidbesgcvqx	4

'*mw[z%lyiw5r:#&$tk.)18(�/-7+"a �06,2q
�
8
�=��6�������	
	�	�
|
�
�o�5���
�
�&��1���s�s���v
�l��e��m)�g&�~:�^� 8 �!!z!�"9"c"�"�#h#�$�$��w���α�z��w����������x�ov{���������$�r�����s��ȁ�x��5�~�|�����������$������,͚�r�'�������%��tu��uΈuu�t{z��{֌{{�{�{��zm���1�m�������i:fx]��*y���v���"��������d�nta?3 r��������ó���Ɋ��ܕ���������\���)1�8�?�b���洝����r�������'d��c]�ce:��q�����*��������������i�~_{���������$�`������|�������z,�o:���u���������$�o�y���|�������r7�r1���r���������$�p�x���~�a�.7=>ur��g�3:ecpl�����{�tnu~x�{����1�y��<�
�������y����4�d�
�'�;���)�'��.��������0�
�s/)8d��!��y�� ��w������tsuylq���������������Ѕtx�`z�����q�v~bm{{����
����������ty��v�lv���w��fw���^����������v��ӻ��\�j���e�g�a��������nv�����������{����������{��|v�r#rr@f�i�|�z�z̀�arzhl�&rϬ�s�s�^�g�_?���*�����������j�}`{���������$�_������~������:k�n,���n���������$�d�����t�{��*w=xh���{�tnu~x�{����1����*��w����e����j�}_{���������$�`������i�ċ�{�tnu~x�{���� ��������w�uuxytt�x��*����u�����s�����k�_���n�t������m�e�������}���������]�t���ɡǚ���gx��o��{���~w{xu~y��y�@�yw�y--n�.�b�{�t_��el���)�ӈĊ�u�p�a7fa�� 4>�ǭ����{�mv��l~�}�{|l�n������f�"�@�h��ۻ����_22[r=ng��-���:��!��w��������j�}`{���������$�_������~������:k�n,���n���������$�d�����t�{��9@gup�d�ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����1�oy��7�t��������4�jugq9$�p�������sj���~�����y؄��������~��~{�u�-'�,�5�6���ݰ��*y���v�a�m����|���q���~�{p�~���8������k��mv��{�{���������x��d}c{f����������sodo{p�q�k�s�\y[a�d�j�p�拵����]�n���������`�w������a�at2�ob��ɸ���-y��7��!��w�������)�{�w3*7p���.�����`?��uy�w��(�d�)�a���̯���@���j��������[��������ɋ�{�tnu~x�{����:�����*�~Džw�����@�~c�{���������$�p�����<���®�vp������������}}�}j�^qsy�Ə���{�tnu~]�{������㆛�2��w�y���ؿ����������$�@�������—�����؅|o�fqÂ���̌���ȝdo��������}�����u��d$vda6�n�u�zgv�q�w���"��z�-y��7��!��w������ґ�������n��$���-�1/�#�izh\y��q�����{�tnu~x�{��������n�m~y���#����e��(9>(=e���y��&��w�������iy�������u�����#Ћ���{�w}u{x�{����.�v@(3s���"��b��-{�ms{�]�{����o�f-�>���ؠ��i�j�l-�}v���s��"����������(�s���v�)��i�6�y1'�~��p�����kl{��Ŏ�r�����1�b��p��"���"�g��+_q]t��������{�tnu~x�{�������v�f�
�����j���������wtw��3p�
��b�����9�n���e����������$����	��
���#�����������$��������%�ь�|�{�|to�y${����dmr�1ox^��p�ow�c�#~�t�y{z�${��e�a=�hb��*�������������s�o�qnh�t${���{�@�y�
���y�����w�uuwwuu�w����v�w
�����z�;��n�g�����ea���v���$�b�y���v���w��w������y�������u��+�����x��+��gɸ����hj����������ʆ�����cy��=��?d �m����uiqo$��$p޻�s��v�@�a�w�ov�,������Ŵ��r�hsszq`r�y�������[ctsx-y�t���v��Ƭ���\����������������������������y�gsyo0vj��k\�kk�vo���y���������������
͋�"��'�>�o�t�x��x�}���y������y�fki>���������[5��=-=r[yyd�����-y��ܰ
�������y�.��9�0�u3���'@�+�n�m���'�+���>����
��,�(�@v�)0o��s-������w
����k����������$�v������Î���{j_f7{熋�.��*�uv����v�w
�.���%´�����v��e�m�]�!�g�n;+z[�������~�����������Ɇ���������$�f�v���f����w�������������%t[}�u�!�~��<�ur���ϊ���||so�q���~��~�~�~���{���d^�6k�xy�������
��Ȇ���������$�n�q���6ܥ����o�o�onl�m${����:�69r�m��-������w�����t�s`{���������$�_�����d�ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����1�*����
��:�l��r����������$��q��r�y�y�yvw�v${��~uz!��qn��Æ����������p�p�ooo�o${�����g�o�v��f���f��w��2�������j��ȅ������������x�edh��*]��!�4�����rs�b�e��(p���������f{��b�f~e��������lt�s��p}�����t��2�
��9�}��&�����µw�y�wyw�y${����fnjd�r$����Ƅ����������q�p�qno�n${���x�2�
��z����b+w`jv^�o|��ww��j�e�j������ю�)����~v���ȱ�w�����%�3dž��������������������v��a���`qp��p��pq�p{z��{��{{�{g{��zl�4o�ty�����������@�"�d�h'$�)�$�������l��.��w���;����j�}`{���������$�_������л��������2f��w�q�q�t���������$�y�|�l�v�d�v�g���ȳ����{�z�zww�w${����vod\oaj`���ʏ���{�tnu~x�{����8����l���-��j��l蟆���������$�}�v���������w�l�r�{y~�o�{���������$�[�`�h�u����袠����s�{ln��${����yizygdlj�v�h�}��������{�u�qoc�y${���b�o�3���"c^��]z�b�v�p�x��������gtqbje�n������u�u�������������q�gtqbje�n������u�u������������b�v�p�x�������p��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsx��qz��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsx-���ѱ�w�w�^��^w��w����������$�d�}��������ea��������w�|�}�j���~����������w�k�~x������������=��`�-�}v���r��7��w��������������ő�n�����aǔ�����rh��{b�sb�4��	$�?��)��Ʈʵ��3��{ix�w�s������i�&�$u,$-_��d����
��(���)��}����������$�\�����n���������ϋ�v�v�vyx�y${����lohm>2sk,�q�_ʋ�������l�l�khh�g${�|������=�po�q\�r��n��Ա�t�w������|ˉ����c����������r]7if,de�����w)� �a*���r���������������������<���
���b�����֡����cuo��r���rt�~}|��|���|}�|j�{����7�39r�m�-�v�����
������dy�
��>��z�b-���/-���<�
껺����t�a��kf�cڽ����i�
#nq24n��-y��ܰ��c����e����y�����+�m��ؾ����b���<5>1�g�o�ur6b��-�b�
�0�c�ۨ���p�i*l`i�6d��؞��������]f5gltx;�f��-���:�`��v������������������$��a�}��������������|�li{~s��������z�{zx�}$�#�0��%93�l����������0hr�\���m�uw�ton��o�������?�v����v˱�r������
��z�y�ˆ����������}������������v[rz[%5*����r����v�������������%t\}�u�3�r��<�ur���΋���}}rp�p���~��~s�~�~����{���d^�6k�xy�-y�����9Öw�vЫ�����y�������{�$�,����2��7_p|u���ݜˑ�������*�Ƥ�uyps�(po��p�o�p�o��&`�$h7�~�������k$"mb�
�eͷ{u��d�y�vdy���w���w���"w����dl\j"�$��z�m����
��m�^�����|���w����~�y]��d�1���s�c���5��쭡��v�p�x
����p��Ŵ��r�hsszqr�y�������[ctsx�y��������y�����w�uuwwuu�w�`�2�����w�uuwwuu�w��*�v�]v��w
������h�����:�'':9''�;��w�ov�/���n������Ŵ��r�hsszqhr�y�������[ctsx0��������w�uuwwuu�w��-�}v�3��w����e���>k}rl`~��}x��h�f�g�����"�‹�{�tnu~x�{����#��������w�uuxytt�x���v�rw
���y��i�ru-y�����w
��������z�n����0�6�����
�7��4rwhz�������h����:������l "jm8"]���9����
����
���ކ���������$�i�e���������,���d��
������ؿ�(��������k�z�z�zjp�`�{���������$�p�����$t�������ä����u�v�vqr�r$�y���^��v�w�vrr�r${���/3�������������
�	�����i�����f9r�m�{���������$�n�q���6ܥ����o�m�onn�m${����:�>���>ܥ����o�o�onl�m${����:�69r�m�{���������$�n�q��?��������w����	������i���������]5�
:n�k������������$�t�����k���#��;�0��wp��pֈpp�w}|��{�|�|�|��{����9�59r�m��y�c����@�|��w�w���4�q��h�(�i�k֥��̋鋝����}�}�|vv�w${����anqs�|a���c/� ��(��q�����{�|�}�|��z�j��ut�w��w�y�}���xw�g�v�`lt e����
�%��⯨q��b�y�x���������$�������ů��(�c� skhi � �@֋�����>��������d��������������$�ʯ�����t���+��p��0���������$�Υٶ�d��b�����y�y�yss�s${����xbjaut����d�9��p�y�y�yyz�z${����dnriq8�"�����]�����������l�l�lmm�l${���u��	wy������������������f����������x�p�tur�x${����97maj"�&;��=�3���-���xb���y�}���|����xu�j$�u#�&�j�r���/��Ү��������y��&��w���ƚ��ߒ����������y�ttwxtt�x��1�����x�ttxxtt�x�������iy�������u�����#Ћ���{�w}u{x�{����.�v@(3s���"��b��-{�ms{�]�{����o�f-�>���ؠ��i�j�l���������v���v�u�v��5��ˌ���l��h�f�f��r�r�r�q���ߋ�2����&�Ɍ�y�y�yst�t${ր�w�(�������t�t�uvv�v${�z�������'�l�s���������$-y�����6�y��w�"���[�u�m�s��5kz���́�����y�zuyxty��ݷ����^<ol6p�u�������u.�
)3�xi��d|s�w�sڋ�:����8�+Ծ������*�����ћ�
����x��������}���}��������s�3wp2��sߥ����o�m�onn�m${����7��3s�o\�d�����
��j������[�򒮭p�p�p|{�|${����vgy^e)�
��� �x���������l�l�lmn�m${��i�e���/��j�g���������$�բש����}v���
���s��ޥ����o�o�onl�m${����8��*_m]v}���t��^�b�k����=w������ɛ
����������������$�f�r����������u��+�v�w�ukn�k�{���������$�\���\��9�[x�x�wrs�r${����oysoz^e�jg�dfq�j���������z-�v��Ðw���j���zy�������ޱ�#������������ȉ�0��fz����~^vpw^��ӱ�����#��3�l}�7��v�p�x
���j�gtqbje�n������u�u�������������y����k���s�������!h����������«������p�?wz��|ԇ|}�}{�����z��c�bx^������Ō¹fp_u_oi^vrg�g�x�����x�x�'�����y�ssyxst�x��͠v�f�
�����k�������o��wt{v�f�p�͠v
���z���z�k��z�l>��:��9�y��ҵ
���x��y�f��%�n�s� ��c�e��-�b�p�2��/�����=�������b�k�!��
���\�y��ߛ
�������������r�r�rqq�q${��gt��;c0�$�j�����Ι����o�m�nnk�q${Ã�ab��k��.�q��6��_�����
�����Ɇ���������$�f�z���h�ӑ�������&�>��c�y�����������$�q�t�|�u�x�e�1�Ƿ�櫦�w�z�xrp�u${����sqbmj\�`�'�sϘ����p�o�pmm�m${���{f�6?��^���l��}�}��ҵ���x���einbprf���g����sd�n��	�7������ɏ��������f��%�n�s� ��c�e��-�b�p�2��/�����=�������b�k�!��
���\�y��v��w��2�
��� y�����w�utxxst�x�pw�,��	������ۋ����p�q�qpq�q${�{�l�;�i���[y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
46 0 obj
<<
/ascent 684
/fontname/wuyqjh+usherwood-book
/xheight 694
/stemv 59
/fontbbox[-101 -307 964 856]
/italicangle 0
/fontfile3 45 0 r
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
/type/fontdescriptor
/descent -254
/flags 34
>>
endobj
47 0 obj
<<
/widths[278 278 0 0 0 0 722 0 296 296 0 0 278 278 278 278 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 0 0 963 407 0 630 593 611 704 574 537 630 704 296 296 648 500 815 685 741 574 741 630 519 556 667 611 944 0 611 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 556 463 556 500 315 500 556 259 241 519 241 889 574 537 556 556 370 426 315 537 500 759 537 519 463 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 537 0 0 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 963 444 444 278 278]
/name/f11
/fontdescriptor 46 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 44 0 r
/basefont/wuyqjh+usherwood-book
/firstchar 32
/lastchar 213
>>
endobj
48 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 38/ampersand 44/comma/hyphen 47/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon 63/question 65/a/b/c/d/e 71/g/h/i/j 76/l/m 79/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
49 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 8579
/length1 8579
>>
stream




hwiinu+usherwood-bookitalic

@��
����o���`��
��
��
.
*
��!f

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporationitc usherwood book italicitc usherwood


=fowjspnubmtdiev
&3czqxy
 8lrgkh*+24"1%-)5$6(07.#?
^


r
�g���y�g�7���p		3	�
4
��*u�
�e�`���a�?�n���.�h�f�]�a�f��w+���9��by��:�
�������nwm:?bi�՗����Ę�����v�9�4��-�c �l����3����uj(�\pv�Ó��8��y��v�8�t����=Ő�z����������������u`m�a�h�k��l�x�qw�x����������z��|���o��������z��%�������b�w9<-ud�����������h{koyvj`f����������sios"u7�o�v�8�a��$��o���u���?�s����m�~���fr�z��������k}1��<pm���������Ň�i{sx}zs^�~����������i�[�u�y������Ŕ�p������z��|���o��������ؤ�žЋ��k��}z��}9o�~���������ur�g�m�i��_�n�ew�x������$����������wswroz�{����v�.�o����9�ؿ���=������۰ҳ���o��y�������������|�yxpb=g�����������h{koyv�`f����������xmdu;y>�*y��b�
������ly����0�=�(���1�# �0���d���.�ъ�p7�3*�61m���&y��v�8�t����l��.ŏ�]����������������xsvs*wbi����-���������¸��uxn�j�m�n�
�d�p�kw�x����������z��|���o��������]�򔫔����q�id�tqs@�������f�xmg=cp�����������f{koyvm`f����������zbcr�v7��y��(��w������xsrxkox�����������Ҍ������І�y�x[������meaokln�x�i�…s�l�xw�y�������+y�a��gv�����l�\�w�}{xxs������b��}�����}��{��|z�|�a��b�%3�p����ū���}�{�{`�x�������
����_����~�toi���zt���y��֛�w
���q���z��|���o����������������eoyqr��{���f�����8�$�g�umw�x�������ty��b��˖��$������������p�y�@� �rj�d�� �a�� �tb\a��lb�Ğ����w�yj~wrmh��d��������d��º��Ǩkh|�����ty��:�
��������is[=hmg���<��Ү�vdu�v�w���ģ����[�s���0�h��u���ҽ�y��v�=����w��Ŏ�z���k����ы��rvz�y�z�b�b�p�y�tw�x����������z��|���o��������z��*�������d�u=c1fg����m������eo_qr��{���f��|��l�&p�l�i��*y�a��2��`w�����|�z����}y{�f���ӟݚ���0�Қϡ�{cnl}l��{����dpxh�t�vh�n�
�7��t���v����}�}�}g�l����������-��%���tbr8���gq���x�a���a��Ȍ��9���j�����|x~{�l�����������Nj����y�m���s}{���{zz�`�od�i���\y���������薬�������k{|��~h\�~��������xxj�i�k�n��o�k�vd�d����Ǭ���{�p�pd�c�������-����i��|vͭ��������(��<����������Š����������u_v_q)\���_�r����������z��~j�������şȜ�un�z[$ ����+�z_����Ǒ�{~x��w�sno��q9�q�s�u����{�����a}�~�~.�8z?w�s�w���ĭ���x����脆���������$��d�z����������i��je��;ă9����������$��f�l�}�q���8$��Ր����?��oo��p؉op�ouu��u�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s�������������dc@zn�7?��v���
���������������q{z��r q�dzu�*y��:����w
� ��l��������x]go�n��{���{p��{�����l�yҋ�v��c��p�f4n*tw��s�������.��k@�b�p�dd���=������a��wfv����v�����������w�u�|���hu��z���������h:�*�b^x�������w��gzy|�}ku�}������ț��ee�h{ig7i3s�z�����v������ɼ�����}v���j��:�������f��Ɲ��̖�������k����������:�s�m΋���'�o�k�m9\dky�����������h{koyv`f����������tmbz<d�e�u��~uu�|��=���������x1!o�c�\_��Ӡv�8�a�~w���$��\��p���o������������r�p�b�%�s�m�ǰ��w�v��~�r�~����=p��{��������sv.��)qd����������|�u���{�sz��${���{p7"�=-���������Ň�i{sx}zs^�~����������i�\�t�y��{v�a�t������b���sws}o�_|��!n�������}z���u���z�u�hd�%xi�t��ysrzzx�x`�~������Ĉ=���l^<xo}��~~��a�{�{��˺����"��p���������
���)�����z�qqtvnz�������zeitr{��y���w���w���1���]�%}�|����l��@�d�bnw��|̆|��~������������{�{^|gs`��������lsbpohhhfh~sw�u�t�l�c�+�����x�ynvsnu�|��������
�����������_c��7�!�{�n��w�w�wvw�v$�{���l�y5�kjj��o�@��x�x�xvv�u$�{����$��m�%� �)���������$���#�������,��+��-���������$���������w�ˋ싞��q�{�r�yz}�|$�=y��v�b����w��|���������ydjbe�bbr�u�n�n����q����������r<���r�q�g�����������xx|{u�v|���m�q�p�v��������n�q<�nff]����e������eo_qr��{���f��{���=�}v���e��:�����<��ɝ��ɖ���x����ӓ���;�қ���{��fhvu�d��<��q��n�ַЦ���a�o�w)g�\w=����@����\wi���bu����������w�x�x��a���l�@�������{�Ԃvw�sxԛ�����}t}�}�}��̠��������ou��n}c�tefz}8�nd�rp�2�'a�d;nn�p{�������|�ad������w�o��"��0�d����������+�p���h���žϹ�k��}z��}9o�~���������ur�h�mb��h`�c�pv�������y�~r}mpjr��q������(����������wswroz�{��=����n��*�~w�����6��)����y������������|�|x�w�d��e�0,�u��ߨ���o�!t�p�3�em�������|�u\xujp��[��-�������=���q������qm�dz[d�v8e�x�f���������
��������������$��u�h����������6�Х�����f�g�flk�l$�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s�������ϛ
�������Ϧ�����f�g�flj�l$�{�����_}�~�~���{@r�6�^v�������u�`�qyc�x�lы���	���p��d��t��ڱ���d��Èo�b��������������u�ji]_g(���%���a�d�=�o�b�i�<�@�a�&�d�x�#���!�l��� ��s�g��p�3�h��l�,�
8��(�y��[w�'��
��v̀���q�h������g�t� ���)r����i�����87ig�'x�ϡ����w�wfxnrlz��6�;�+����r��n���λ����it~�~��y����ˡ��z�x���y�����<�\���ȕ����j� �
=684�t�j�]�\��/�e���8�����i�i:?ki7:t����������;]i3-b\�g�i��w������ʛ~��������n�f����̨���������p�o�oqd�f��{���������$��z������z�!�������������k�k�jnn�m$�{�����pvrl{t�v��@"hc�uy�~����������$��������g?��������x���������������
�`:��
o�2�]�����������$��t�h����������k�	�$���,�k��to��k؉jf�_{{��{�{�����_u�b�m>�z?l�]����q��ݭx����h�������������������������37��=jm��lx�ml�jtv��u�{�����a}�~�~.�8z?w�s�������������=��q�{��bo��������y���������y�����x�ynvsnu�|�p��,�����x�ynvsnu�|�������՛���p��������}—�~���Û���ueacm�1f{���������6�Τ�����f�g�flg�l$�{�����_}�~���(�6x<s�y�����ŭ���
��f�����������$��u�h����������j��\�jx>x�r��{���������$��{�_����������6����ӓ��h�i�hii�i$�{�����d��x�}e�>����>�Х�����f�g�flk�l$�{�����_}�~�~.�6z?w�s��y��޵�d�g��w������z[y�lts��t�t�t�t�f3\�
s4�p�������m@+@*�ii��^|o�n�tۋ�:��
�
�c��
dc~}fԷ�Ԣ�䆱����
�����y�����w
������h��h���p���
�c������
4�.cdywj�����������r������w6�e..cx��
��v��w����t��w�.�*�y����������j������y���x�phfi:�vu��t*�us�q������]�1�;�
��7�r�.qu��yr�x|�{�����f������yww~lgm��������Ϲ]c���������v�����
������y�����i���c���%'���h񸴛����7�
c>�"g��$����п[$�>=:6a���������w
����������ç��$��i�r����������3������wdl`l&��{Ԫ�cy�}�{e��q�	r�x��y���
������vy�a����j�o�%�h&���r!�(�
$�i�����&̪;j�;<���;t��-���խ�w� ��4���������������$��u�h����������z��ex�����������}�s�}�������������}؁]bty���������zy?x�r�-y��ڱ
���6����<_os#�
"j���q��t�.��	�jh�������|����yjq�a$�g�1�n���)�#�&��î�y���
�����~�生є��k�h�kon�o$�{�����cx�a�lq��s(k1�)�@i�ݡ���������͘��c�b�dmn�m$�{�����_x�r�ur���n�l�m!�w���$��h�dy��������������hߘ�����r��������������������r|�hz|z"�{�����z~���u�qbb��&i���[��e�3��kf�������y����w�m�q�=��#�u��l�s����4��‹�
�y����b��w���$�䆬o��t��k��!��@�op������
ʦԎ��fj�f�8n����w~f}gif���̧���=-fh<p�r�����ڳ]l�!��8\��w����;�a�����|��m����������$��o�p���ؘ�����İ������������{ciuy��h��&������z�z�z{y�{$1��$�'�-��{�o�������֋҃���`t�m�i���mqh��h|u��z�����+�'������v��{��w��n�� y��������@������̪���Ȏ�c�h�c��/^u����������z�yzy^oz��ӿ���%�8#�h��e�r�y��ڱ
���d���y�d�=�o�b�i�<�@�a�&�d�x�#���!�l��� ��s�g��p�3�h��l�,�
8��(�
y�f����g��w�����g�s�^�@j��j�ݝߒ�z�y�zyy�x$�{�����tgclzv0�n�,�j��eu���|�~�}���}�o��}|��|k}�|�|��{�_�y�f�k�4��
�2���ҷ�s�e�m�i���������$����f���Ӣ��!�h�6lldj0�&�?ԋ�r�v���
�1�����|������`/����k*�j��������Ә�ŗ��d�d�dlk�l$�{�|����������
�����������$���������{v�r�z|z��$��v�rw
u�
uy����rq�9��~��������2�q�k��������	�*�p��9��k��:�����i�k�����=�iw0c�h��{���������$��f�x����������1�ߞ����s�t�svv�v$��h��g��7o�bp�ap�cw�v�vsr�r$�{�����aw�o�t?��u>s?s>���������$?��q��ӭ�|�x��[�v�r~�����������������������?�s���Ǔ߫��5��
on��ol�no�o~~��~�{�����]}�~�~.�4{jvvr��`�����q��-id�@`k��������
�|������Ͽij�
.s,>y����f��`��������
����
endstream
endobj
50 0 obj
<<
/ascent 684
/fontname/hwiinu+usherwood-bookitalic
/xheight 694
/stemv 58
/fontbbox[-187 -307 972 849]
/italicangle -12
/fontfile3 49 0 r
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
/type/fontdescriptor
/descent -254
/flags 98
>>
endobj
51 0 obj
<<
/widths[259 0 0 0 0 0 759 0 0 0 0 0 259 315 0 259 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 259 0 0 0 0 407 0 630 574 556 667 556 0 611 667 296 296 0 519 815 0 685 574 685 630 519 556 648 593 907 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 499 500 426 500 444 315 481 519 278 259 481 259 796 537 500 519 481 389 426 315 519 463 722 519 481]
/name/f12
/fontdescriptor 50 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 48 0 r
/basefont/hwiinu+usherwood-bookitalic
/firstchar 32
/lastchar 121
>>
endobj
52 0 obj
<<
/type/encoding
/differences[32/space 65/a 82/r 97/a 100/d/e 105/i 108/l 110/n]
/baseencoding/macromanencoding
>>
endobj
53 0 obj
<<
/subtype/type1c
/length 1360
/length1 1360
>>
stream




opyzhi+usherwood-bold

@��
����/������
��
��
"

5�/

���copyright (c) 1990 adobe systems incorporated.  all rights reserved.itc usherwood is a registered trademark of international typeface corporation.itc usherwood bolditc usherwood


"mbo
3fje

��
l
�
���g�������n����
��a���u�`�`�t����������e���z�x�xsq�g�k���������$�t���u��f��i�i�ihh�h$k����t{�z�r�$�slu�h���������$��������:�����̫�w
���b�q�˒�meogre�k���t3��@�av�k���������$�v�����y�e����^����>����������d����e�x�&vx��yl�xz�z�����\k��x{buz�z�����ħp^tg�8vey,w�:�z��ģ�t��q�������[�*orucal�����ʣd�����z����z�������������$�v�����f�����Ę]r��m�v�~���������$�c�|���\�f�,5gfso�m�klioo�k���t3�	@�av����������[�f��w���[�
泆���������$�f�����3��-���v����������$�m�h�{�m���$����ͦ��3��ll��n։np�t|{��{�{�z�z��k„�h:��:�ht���b��������ҁ-17�f]�y��o���
���w��g�tu\sb�l����Ȍ��Ɗ������������d��,�,��!�&�+���殡���q�����ӝfu��������w������������������$�v�����	�͒�melgoe�k���t3�	@�av���������n�ggnngg�n�?y�������w
������by�������k��������ʒ�meogre�k���u5b�pm�q�)��(��+�	��ܸ��y�y�qb��/nb2@_������˼cky����f��`��������
�����
endstream
endobj
54 0 obj
<<
/ascent 684
/fontname/opyzhi+usherwood-bold
/xheight 694
/stemv 108
/fontbbox[-155 -300 1092 866]
/italicangle 0
/fontfile3 53 0 r
/stemh 0
/capheight 622
/type/fontdescriptor
/descent -254
/flags 262178
>>
endobj
55 0 obj
<<
/widths[296 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 519 0 0 574 519 0 0 0 296 0 0 296 0 611]
/name/f13
/fontdescriptor 54 0 r
/type/font
/subtype/type1
/encoding 52 0 r
/basefont/opyzhi+usherwood-bold
/firstchar 32
/lastchar 110
>>
endobj
56 0 obj
<<
/kids[57 0 r 58 0 r 59 0 r 60 0 r 61 0 r 62 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 63 0 r
>>
endobj
57 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 56 0 r
/contents 4 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f3 43 0 r/f1 35 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f2 39 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
58 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 56 0 r
/contents 5 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
59 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 56 0 r
/contents 6 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
60 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 56 0 r
/contents 7 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
61 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 56 0 r
/contents 8 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
62 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 56 0 r
/contents 9 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
64 0 obj
<<
/kids[65 0 r 66 0 r 67 0 r 68 0 r 69 0 r 70 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 63 0 r
>>
endobj
65 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 64 0 r
/contents 10 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
66 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 64 0 r
/contents 11 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
67 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 64 0 r
/contents 12 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
68 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 64 0 r
/contents 13 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
69 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 64 0 r
/contents 14 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
70 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 64 0 r
/contents 15 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
71 0 obj
<<
/kids[72 0 r 73 0 r 74 0 r 75 0 r 76 0 r 77 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 6
/parent 63 0 r
>>
endobj
72 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 71 0 r
/contents 16 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
73 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 71 0 r
/contents 17 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
74 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 71 0 r
/contents 18 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
75 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 71 0 r
/contents 19 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
76 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 71 0 r
/contents 20 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
77 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 71 0 r
/contents 21 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
78 0 obj
<<
/kids[79 0 r 80 0 r 81 0 r 82 0 r 83 0 r]
/type/pages
/count 5
/parent 63 0 r
>>
endobj
79 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 78 0 r
/contents 22 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r/f13 55 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
80 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 78 0 r
/contents 23 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
81 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 78 0 r
/contents 24 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
82 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 78 0 r
/contents 25 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs2 3 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f12 51 0 r/f0 31 0 r/f11 47 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
83 0 obj
<<
/mediabox[0 0 432 648]
/type/page
/parent 78 0 r
/contents 26 0 r
/resources<</extgstate<</gs0 1 0 r/gs1 2 0 r>>/procset[/pdf/text]/font<</f0 31 0 r>>>>
>>
endobj
63 0 obj
<<
/type/pages
/kids[56 0 r 64 0 r 71 0 r 78 0 r]
/count 23
>>
endobj
84 0 obj
<<
/pagelabels 27 0 r
/type/catalog
/pages 63 0 r
>>
endobj
85 0 obj
<<
/xpressprivate(%%documentprocesscolors: black\n%%endcomments)
/producer(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5)
/creationdate(20070408154814)
/creator(quarkxpress(tm) 6.5)
>>
endobj
xref
0 86
0000000000 65535 f 
0000000015 00000 n 
0000000059 00000 n 
0000000105 00000 n 
0000000152 00000 n 
0000005072 00000 n 
0000011771 00000 n 
0000020169 00000 n 
0000027612 00000 n 
0000034415 00000 n 
0000041231 00000 n 
0000047477 00000 n 
0000054394 00000 n 
0000062382 00000 n 
0000069515 00000 n 
0000075415 00000 n 
0000081572 00000 n 
0000089286 00000 n 
0000095911 00000 n 
0000102670 00000 n 
0000110512 00000 n 
0000117051 00000 n 
0000124609 00000 n 
0000131185 00000 n 
0000142823 00000 n 
0000157775 00000 n 
0000170843 00000 n 
0000171210 00000 n 
0000171254 00000 n 
0000171628 00000 n 
0000177849 00000 n 
0000178071 00000 n 
0000178723 00000 n 
0000178853 00000 n 
0000180879 00000 n 
0000181113 00000 n 
0000181463 00000 n 
0000181835 00000 n 
0000189374 00000 n 
0000189604 00000 n 
0000190254 00000 n 
0000190416 00000 n 
0000192956 00000 n 
0000193178 00000 n 
0000193558 00000 n 
0000194001 00000 n 
0000204172 00000 n 
0000204392 00000 n 
0000205083 00000 n 
0000205385 00000 n 
0000214047 00000 n 
0000214275 00000 n 
0000214752 00000 n 
0000214884 00000 n 
0000216327 00000 n 
0000216553 00000 n 
0000216896 00000 n 
0000217003 00000 n 
0000217217 00000 n 
0000217412 00000 n 
0000217618 00000 n 
0000217824 00000 n 
0000218019 00000 n 
0000221982 00000 n 
0000218214 00000 n 
0000218321 00000 n 
0000218528 00000 n 
0000218735 00000 n 
0000218942 00000 n 
0000219138 00000 n 
0000219345 00000 n 
0000219541 00000 n 
0000219648 00000 n 
0000219855 00000 n 
0000220062 00000 n 
0000220269 00000 n 
0000220465 00000 n 
0000220672 00000 n 
0000220868 00000 n 
0000220968 00000 n 
0000221186 00000 n 
0000221393 00000 n 
0000221600 00000 n 
0000221807 00000 n 
0000222061 00000 n 
0000222130 00000 n 
trailer
<<
/size 86
/root 84 0 r
/info 85 0 r
/id[<a3999d20aaf93966f6e523218c9add76><a3999d20aaf93966f6e523218c9add76>]
>>
startxref
222305
%%eof